Root traits such as root angle and hair length influence resource acquisition particularly for immobile nutrients like phosphorus (P). Here, we attempted to modify root angle in rice by disrupting the OsAUX1 auxin influx transporter gene in an effort to improve rice P acquisition efficiency. We show by X-ray microCT imaging that root angle is altered in the osaux1 mutant, causing preferential foraging in the top soil where P normally accumulates, yet surprisingly, P acquisition efficiency does not improve. Through closer investigation, we reveal that OsAUX1 also promotes root hair elongation in response to P limitation. Reporter studies reveal that auxin response increases in the root hair zone in low P environments. We demonstrate that OsAUX1 functions to mobilize auxin from the root apex to the differentiation zone where this signal promotes hair elongation when roots encounter low external P. We conclude that auxin and OsAUX1 play key roles in promoting root foraging for P in rice.
Food security represents a pressing global issue. Crop production has to double by 2050 to keep pace with predictions of global population increasing to 9 billion. This target is even more challenging given the impact of climate change on water availability and the drive to reduce fertilizer inputs to make agriculture environmentally sustainable. In both cases, developing crops with improved water and nutrient uptake efficiency by manipulating root architecture, which critically influences nutrient and water uptake efficiency would provide part of the solution. For example, root angle impacts phosphate acquisition efficiency (PAE) as this nutrient preferentially accumulates in the top soil1,2.
Very few genes that regulate root architecture traits such as root angle have been identified in crop plants to date3. In contrast, major progress has been made characterizing genes and molecular mechanisms controlling root angle in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana4. AUX1 was one of the first genes identified in Arabidopsis to control root angle5,6 and later shown to encode an auxin influx carrier7,8. AUX1 regulates root angle by transporting auxin from gravity-sensing columella cells at the root tip via the lateral root cap to elongating epidermal cells that undergo differential growth to trigger root bending9,10. Such detailed functional information in model organisms opens possibilities to perform translational studies to manipulate equivalent root traits in crops controlled by orthologous genes.
In this study, we describe how a translational approach was initially adopted to improve PAE in rice by genetically manipulating the orthologous AUX1 sequence. Reverse genetic studies in rice combined with non-invasive X-ray (microCT) imaging in soil confirmed that root angle was significantly altered in osaux1 compared to wild-type plants. Nevertheless, physiological experiments performed on osaux1 (versus wild-type) failed to demonstrate improvement in PAE, suggesting that OsAUX1 controls other traits important to P acquisition. Further studies revealed OsAUX1 was also required for rice root hair elongation, an important adaptive response designed to forage for immobile nutrients such as P in the soil11. Auxin quantification and reporter lines revealed that under low P conditions, auxin levels are elevated in the root hair zone. We conclude that in response to low external P supply, OsAUX1 is required to transport elevated auxin from the root apex to the differentiation zone to promote root hair elongation and hence facilitate rice P acquisition. In parallel papers, we demonstrate that this auxin-dependent root hair response to low external P is highly conserved in the dicotyledonous model Arabidopsis thaliana12 and which relies on AUX1 to promote hair elongation via intracellular auxin and calcium signaling13.
Rice root angle is altered by disrupting the OsAUX1 gene
The AUX1 gene family in rice is encoded by five closely related OsAUX1/LAX genes (Supplementary Figure 1a). Bioinformatic analysis revealed that the two rice sequences (Os01g63770 and Os05g37470) were closely related to AUX1. In order to identify which rice sequence(s) represents an orthologous gene, we tested the ability of each of their cDNA sequences to complement the Arabidopsis aux1 agravitropic phenotype. This genetic assay revealed that only one of the OsAUX1 sequences (Os01g63770) was able to successfully rescue the aux1 mutant’s root agravitropic defect (Supplementary Figure 1b, c). Our observations are consistent with previous complementation experiments using Arabidopsis AUX/LAX sequences, which revealed that gene family members had undergone a process of sub-functionalization14.
To test the in planta function of OsAUX1 in rice directly, we characterized two independent T-DNA insertion lines (3A-51110 and 3A-01770) disrupting the Os01g63770 genomic sequence in the Dongjin background (see “Methods”). The T-DNA insertion lines were termed osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3 (in agreement with Zhao et al.15). Southern hybridization confirmed that single T-DNA insertion events had disrupted the OsAUX1 gene in osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3, respectively. PCR amplification of genomic fragments adjacent to each T-DNA followed by sequencing confirmed that T-DNA insertions in osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3 had disrupted the gene coding sequence in exon 3 and exon 6, respectively (Fig. 1a). Reverse transcription quantitative-PCR (RT-qPCR) analysis also revealed that both T-DNA alleles exhibited significantly reduced OsAUX1 transcript abundance (>80%; Supplementary Figure 2). Hence, osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3 appear to represent null alleles.
Phenotypic analysis of young seedlings (homozygous for the T-DNA inserts) germinated on vertical agar plates revealed a reduced root angle phenotype in both osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3 alleles compared to the positive gravitropic behavior of the wild-type control roots (Fig. 1b). The gravitropic defect became apparent in both primary and crown roots of osaux1 seedlings 4–8 days after germination (Fig. 1b). Mutant seedling primary and crown roots exhibited altered root angles compared to wild-type roots that grew closer to the vertical (Supplementary Figure 3). Similarly, seedling primary roots of both osaux1 alleles failed to reorient after a 90° gravity stimulus in contrast to wild-type roots (Supplementary Figure 4). Hence, the OsAUX1 gene appears to control primary and crown root gravitropic responses and angle in rice.
Phosphorus acquisition efficiency is not improved in osaux1
Root angle represents an important determinant for PAE. Many crops with roots whose angles deviate more from the vertical exhibit greater P foraging ability since this nutrient preferentially accumulates in the upper soil volume11. We initially investigated whether OsAUX1 controls root angle in rice plants grown in soil. The architecture of wild type versus osaux1 lines was compared using X-ray microCT and rhizotron-based root phenotyping approaches16. When using microCT, rice lines were grown in soil for a total of 4 weeks, non-invasively scanning samples every week. This non-destructive imaging approach helped reveal the temporal evolution of wild-type and mutant rice root architecture. Clear differences in root distribution within the soil volume were apparent at week 2 (Fig. 2) with osaux1 lines preferentially colonizing the upper soil space compared to wild type. Large rhizotrons (1.5 M depth by 0.5 M width) enabled imaging of 2D root architecture in older rice plants, and independently validated differences observed using microCT in root angle and colonization of the upper soil profile by osaux1 mutant roots (Supplementary Figure 5). Hence, rice plants lacking OsAUX1 exhibit a major change in the vertical distribution of roots.
Given the striking difference in osaux1-1 root angle compared to wild type when grown in soil (Fig. 2 and Supplementary Figure 5), we next tested whether the mutant also had improved PAE. We performed a series of experiments designed to assess whether the osaux1 mutant’s root angle phenotype conferred a selective advantage for P foraging. When plants were provided with limited, sufficient and high levels of this immobile nutrient in the soil, no significant difference was evident in P accumulation in shoot tissues of osaux1 compared to the wild-type control (Supplementary Figure 6). Rather surprisingly, split nutrient treatments (where sufficient or high P were provided in the top 50% soil volume) revealed that osaux1 accumulated less P in shoot tissue compared to the wild type (Supplementary Figure 6). We conclude, based on the latter observations, that OsAUX1 must also control other root traits of importance for soil P acquisition.
OsAUX1 promotes root hair growth in low phosphate conditions
Root hairs play an important role in accessing immobile nutrients like P from the soil. We therefore examined whether mutating OsAUX1 disrupted root hair development, in addition to root angle. We initially observed that both osaux1 mutant alleles retained the ability to form root hairs (Fig. 3a and Supplementary Figure 7). However, closer examination revealed that mutant root hairs were shorter than wild type (Fig. 3b and Supplementary Figure 7). The reduced root hair length in osaux1 phenocopies the previously reported root hair elongation defect in Arabidopsis aux1 mutant alleles17,18 and reveals that this growth response represents a highly conserved AUX1-dependent process.
External phosphate availability has been reported to control root hair length in several plant species11. We also observed that external P concentration had a major effect on wild-type rice root hair length (Fig. 3a, b and Supplementary Figure 7), which increased more than threefold to >500 μm under the most limiting nutrient conditions. In contrast, the osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3 alleles either exhibited a highly attenuated root hair response or this was completely abolished, respectively (Fig. 3b and Supplementary Figure 7). The marked reduction in root hair length of the osaux1 alleles (particularly under P limiting conditions) will negatively impact their ability to forage for P in soil. Root hairs account for up to 90% of P uptake19, and the benefits of increased root length in the top soil profile is more than canceled by the loss of surface area induced by shorter root hairs considering that 91% of the total root surface area is contributed by hairs20.
Root auxin response is elevated by low phosphate and OsAUX1
The observed functional link between OsAUX1 and root hair elongation response to P deficiency suggests roots employ auxin as a signal during this important adaptive response. To directly test whether auxin levels are elevated in rice roots under P limiting conditions, we grew wild-type plants hydroponically under low external P supply, then surgically excised root tips and root hair zones and measured levels of the major form of auxin, indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) using GC-MS/MS (see “Methods”). Hormone quantification revealed IAA levels were indeed elevated in wild-type root tip and root hair zone under low external (compared to high) P conditions (Supplementary Figure 8).
To visualize if low external P conditions triggered an auxin response, rice reporter lines encoding the auxin responsive reporter DR5:VENUSX3 were created (see “Methods”). We monitored changes in rice root auxin response to external P levels employing two forms of laser scanning microscopy (see Methods). Multi-photon microscopy was used to image deep inside rice root tissues, revealing that the DR5:VENUSX3 reporter signal was elevated in root cap and epidermal cells when grown under low external P (versus high P) conditions (Fig. 4a, b). In parallel, confocal microscopy was employed to image root surface tissues under both external P conditions. A maximal surface projection image was taken to capture the entire cylindrical root surface (Fig. 4c–f). This revealed low DR5:VENUSX3 auxin response expression in root surface tissues grown in high external P (Fig. 4d), but under low external P conditions reporter activity was strongly upregulated in all root epidermal cells between the apex and hair zone (Fig. 4c).
Lateral root cap and epidermal tissues have been shown in Arabidopsis roots to represent the AUX1-mediated conduit for auxin to be transported “shootward” from the root apex to root hair zones9. Transgenic rice roots encoding an OsAUX1 promoter GUS reporter (OsAUX1:GUS) revealed that the rice orthologue was expressed in lateral root cap and epidermal tissues (Fig. 4g). To test whether the osaux1-1;3 mutation reduced auxin-dependent root hair elongation by disrupting “shootward” auxin transport, we monitored DR5:VENUSX3 reporter expression in the mutant background (Fig. 4e, f). This revealed DR5:VENUSX3 auxin response expression remained low in root surface tissues grown in either high or low external P. In the latter case, the DR5:VENUSX3 reporter was clearly elevated in osaux1-1;3 epidermal cells close to the root apex, but (unlike wild type) was not expressed in more distal cells within the elongation and differentiation zones (Fig. 4e, f). This behavior concurs with model simulations of auxin transport in root tissues, which reveal that influx carrier activity is necessary for this hormone signal to move efficiently from cell to cell9,10. We conclude auxin response is elevated in root epidermal cells due to this signal being upregulated at the root apex by low external P, then mobilized to the root hair zone in an OsAUX1-dependent manner.
Auxin and root hair growth are induced by local phosphate availability
Given that P is relatively immobile in soil, roots are likely to employ mechanisms to fine tune their hair length in response to this nutrient’s heterogeneous distribution. This would necessitate a local (rather than systemic) signaling solution by roots to monitor external P availability and then trigger adaptive responses like hair elongation. To investigate whether root hair length is regulated by either a local or systemic signaling system, rice plants were grown employing a split root experimental set-up, where roots from a single plant were grown in two separate hydroponic chambers to control external P availability. As reported above (Fig. 3), control split roots grown under just low or just high P exhibited long and short root hairs, respectively (Supplementary Figure 9). Interestingly, when roots from individual rice plants were grown simultaneously in high and low external P conditions, they exhibited short and long root hair lengths, respectively (Supplementary Figure 9). Hence, root hair elongation in rice appears to be controlled by local (rather than systemic) P availability. However, when we performed a split plate experiment in soil, where seminal roots from the same rice plant were exposed (at the same time) to replete P and low P conditions, the latter roots exhibited an attenuated hair elongation response compared to control roots (Supplementary Figure 10). This suggests that, while root hair length is strongly influenced by local P availability, a systemic signal(s) may also communicate the P status of shoot tissues.
We next examined whether auxin response plays a role in local and/or systemic signaling mechanisms to P availability using our split root hydroponic system. As reported above, DR5:VENUSX3 rice split roots grown under just low or just high external P conditions exhibited high and low reporter signals, respectively (Fig. 5a, b and Supplementary Figures 11 and 12). Similarly, when roots from individual rice DR5:VENUSX3 plants were grown simultaneously in high and low external P conditions, they also exhibited low and high auxin response reporter expression, respectively (Fig. 5a, b and Supplementary Figures 11 and 12). Hence, root auxin response appears to be inversely related to local P availability, where low levels of this key nutrient triggers an increase in root epidermal auxin response, which promotes root hair elongation to better forage for this immobile resource in soil.
Our study has uncovered a novel role for OsAUX1 in facilitating root adaptation to low external P by promoting hair elongation, thereby helping increase the volume of soil being explored by the plant root. Plant physiologists have long known that low P availability triggers a root hair elongation response in many species11. Arabidopsis developmental biologists have also observed two decades ago that auxin and AUX1 promote root hair elongation17,18. Our current study in rice provides the experimental evidence that integrates these observations and stimulated subsequent efforts in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana12,13 to develop a mechanistic framework for this adaptive response pathway.
The conservation of the AUX1-regulated root hair adaptive response between model dicot and monocot species provides confidence that we have uncovered a highly conserved auxin regulatory mechanism controlling plant responses to external P availability. A central role for auxin has been further substantiated by the observation that Arabidopsis mutants either disrupting auxin response (e.g., arf19), synthesis (e.g., taa1), or degradation (e.g., dao1) also modify the P deficiency-induced root hair elongation response12. In addition, hormone quantification, pharmacological treatment, and reporter studies in rice and Arabidopsis have revealed that P-deficit elevates IAA levels and response (Supplementary Figure 8)12,13, triggering enhanced auxin responsive gene expression in key root tissues that include epidermal root hair cells. Targeting AUX1 to just lateral root cap and epidermal root tissues rescued the aux1 P deficiency root hair defect, demonstrating the functional importance of the shootward auxin transport pathway from the root apex via the lateral root cap to elongation and differentiation zones12. Auxin-inducible transcripts that exhibit elevated expression in the elongation and differentiation zones during P-deficit conditions include the transcriptional factor genes ARF19 and (its targets) RSL2 and RSL4. Given the recent demonstration that the abundance of RSL4 exhibits a linear relationship with root hair length21, RSL4 mRNA upregulation by auxin (in response to P deficit) would promote hair elongation. Collectively, our experimental results can be placed into a mechanistic framework initiated by auxin upregulation at the root apex in response to low external P availability and culminating in upregulation of RSL2 and RSL4 in the elongation/differentiation zones that enhances root hair length and P acquisition.
Exactly how low external P availability triggers the upregulation of auxin levels at the root apex has been unclear until now. Split root experiments in rice and Arabidopsis12 demonstrate that auxin upregulation triggered by low external P was a local (rather than systemic) response. The recent elegant demonstration that P uptake and sensing by a root occurs at the apex22 raises the intriguing possibility that root cap cells provide a nexus for integrating information about local external nutrient availability that generates physiological signals like auxin. Bhosale et al.12 have demonstrated that the auxin biosynthesis gene TAA1 and its protein is upregulated at the root apex in response to low external P levels. As a consequence, elevated auxin levels are transported to other root cells (e.g., epidermal cells) to trigger adaptive responses designed to enhance local root P acquisition (e.g., root hair elongation; Fig. 5). The seventeenth century plant anatomist Grew originally made the connection between plant nutrition and the root tip23. The present study establishes how auxin serves as an important signal for P status in the root, linking the root cap and root differentiation zones employing the auxin influx carrier OsAUX1, to promote root hair elongation in order to help capture more P.
Plant material and growth conditions
Arabidopsis thaliana seeds (Col-0) were surface sterilized and grown in a growth room under 16 h light (150–200 μmols m−2 s−1; 23 °C) and 8 h dark cycle (18 °C). Rice (Oryza sativa L. japonica) AUX1 T-DNA insertion lines osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3 (Dongjin background) and Dongjin wild-type seeds were provided by Pr G An, Kyung Hee University, Korea24. Rice plants were grown in 13 cm pots (volume 804 cc) filled with a 1:1 (w:w) ratio of John Innes No1 (John Inness, Norwich UK): Levington M3 (JFC Monro, Devon, UK) soil mix, at 28 °C in 12 h light and 12 h dark cycle and regularly irrigated with plant media25.
AUX1 complementation experiments
cDNA sequences for OsAUX/LAX genes were PCR amplified from rice root or leaf cDNA libraries, other than OsLAX1 which was obtained from the rice BAC clone AK111849. Each cDNA was initially cloned into pGEM-T Easy and then the binary vector pMOGORFLAUX114, which contains the 2 kb promoter region, start codon and the 3′UTR of the Arabidopsis AUX1 gene. Constructs were then transformed into the Arabidopsis mutant aux1-22 using the floral-dip method26. Primers used for cDNAs amplification are listed in Supplementary Table 1. Root growth and gravitropism analyses were performed on vertical agar plates and quantified as described earlier27.
Characterization of osaux1 root architecture
Two independent T-DNA insertion mutant lines of Osaux1 were identified using OryGeneDB software28. In line 3A-51110, the T-DNA was inserted within intron 5, while in line 3A-01770 the T-DNA was inserted in exon 6 (and termed osaux1-1;1 and osaux1-1;3, respectively). T-DNA insertions were confirmed using the site-finder approach29. Root growth and gravitropism analyses were performed on vertical agar plates and quantified as described earlier27. Root architecture analysis of soil grown plants was performed using either rhizotrons30 and X-ray microCT16. In the latter case, the germinated seeds were planted in plastic columns containing sandy loam (Newport) soil. For phosphate amendment crushed TSP (44% P2O5 in 50 mL of deionised water) was mixed thoroughly with the soil. The amended soil was sieved to <2 mm and then packed in polypropylene columns (5.5 cm diameter, 10 cm height, and 0.23 cm thick) to a 1.2 g cm−3 density. Columns were microCT scanned at weekly intervals for 4 weeks using a GE NanoTom CT model. Typical settings were 130 kV, 240 µA, 1080 projections, 73 min total scan time, sample-source distance of 22.7 cm, 27.3 µm voxel size with a 0.1 mm copper filter. The relatively long scan time (73 min) was used to obtain the best quality X-ray CT images for the sample size. Each sample received an approximate X-ray dose of 5.9 Gy over the four scans (1.5 Gy each scan) as estimated by the RadPro X-ray Device Dose-Rate Calculator (McGinnis 2002-2009). Root systems were segmented from the X-ray CT generated images using VGStudioMax and measured with VGStudioMax and RooTrak software31.
Root hair assays
Dehusked rice seeds were surface sterilized with 2% bleach and 0.1% Triton for 15 min followed by five washes with sterile water. Seeds were then germinated on moist Whatman paper for 3 days in dark. Uniformly germinated seedlings were then transferred on 1/4th strength MS plates (pH 5.6 with 1% agar) containing 1 µM, 31 µM, or 312 µM P. Low P media were complemented with equimolar concentration of KCl. Seedlings were grown vertically in 12-inch square plates in growth chamber maintained at 28 °C with 12 h of light and 12 h of darkness. After 9 days of growth seedlings were transferred to glass tubes filled with same media without agar (hydroponic system). Liquid media was changed every day and root hair growth was recorded on nodal roots of 15 days old seedlings using a Zeiss stereo zoom microscope (optical zoom ×2.5, digital zoom ×1.2). Experiments were repeated three times. RH length was measured as the average of 30–60 fully elongated root hairs from one seedling. Data from >10 seedlings were used to calculate the final RH length.
Split root experiments
Rice seeds (DR5:VENUS3X) were dehusked and were cut into halves to retain only embryo portions (onwards referred as seeds). Seeds were then surface sterilized with 50% bleach for 10 min followed by 10 washes with sterile water. After washing, seeds were dried on sterile Whatman paper for 10 min. Seeds were germinated for 3 days on vertical ½ MS (Murashige and Skoog) plates (supplemented with 0.5% phytagel) in a growth chamber maintained at 28 °C (250–300 µM photons/m2/s). Uniformly germinated seedlings were then transferred to hydroponic solutions of modified Yoshida medium24 containing 1 µM (low) P in phytotron growth chamber (16 h day (30 °C)/8 h night (30 °C) photoperiod, 250–300 µM photons/m2/s photon density and ̴̴ 70% relative humidity). After 7 days of growth in low P (1 µM), 10 low Pi-starved seedlings were split into two glass tubes filled with low (1 µM) and high (312 µM) P Yoshida medium. The liquid medium was changed every day and fluorescence images and Z-stacks were recorded on nodal roots of 13 days old seedlings using Leica SP5 confocal microcope. All recorded images and Z-stacks were processed in Fiji to generate maximal surface projection images and to measure raw integrated densities of fluorescence. The.lif file format was opened in Fiji and all z slices were summed and duplicated. The duplicated image was used for thresholding to visualize the maximum fluorescence pixels. After thresholding, each fluorescence pixel was selected using the ROI manager tool and a ROI number added to that image. Finally, raw integral densities were calculated using the measurement tool.
Auxin and P measurements in rice plants
Root tip (~1.5 mm) and differentiation zone (next 2 mm region) from 15 days old rice seedling grown under low and high P were excised under a dissecting stereo microscope and frozen immediately in liquid nitrogen. Twelve–fifteen roots were used per sample with four biological replicates. Five-hundred picograms of 13C6-IAA internal standard was added to each sample before purification. Auxin quantification was performed using GC-MS/MS as described earlier32 with minor modifications. P levels in shoot tissues were measured using ICP-MS.
Generation of rice reporter lines
The DR5 rev ::VENUS fragment was composed of a generic synthetic promoter with nine repeats of the auxin response element (AuxRE) motif (TGTCTC) linked to minimal 35S CaMV promoter33,34, driving the expression of three copies of the YFP VENUS sequence with the nuclear localization signal N7 from maize35. The construct was inserted into the pMLBART36 vector to form the DR5rev::3xVENUS construct. The vector was transformed into rice japonica cultivar 9522 calli using Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain EHA10537. To create the OsAUX1 pro :GUS construct, 1.8 kbp of the OsAUX1 promoter sequence was PCR amplified and cloned into Gateway binary vector pGWB3, which contains the GUS gene (Supplementary Figure 2). This vector was then transformed into Agrobacterium. Rice transformation was carried out as described earlier38.
Two photon laser scanning microscopy (TLSM)
Plant seeds were sterilized in ethanol 70% for 1 min, and then in 40% sodium hypochlorite for 30 min under agitation. Seeds were transferred to ½ strength MS plates (supplemented with half strength vitamins; 0.8% agar; pH 5.8). Plates were kept at an angle of 15% from the vertical in a growth chamber maintained at 25 °C, 60% humidity, and under a 12 h photoperiod for 3 days. Root tips were counter stained with propidium iodide (PI; 10 µg/ml) for 10 min and were then briefly washed with distilled water thrice. Root tips were mounted in low melting agarose (0.5%) and were scanned typically using a two photon laser scanning microscope. The GFP and PI emissions were collected in separate channels with excitation at 836 nm (Chameleon Ultra II) and 1096 nm (Chameleon Compact OPO), respectively, with a gain set at 600 nm using 2 PMT NDD and 2 PMT BiG detectors. All images were processed using Zeiss ZEN software. For images stack, the auto brightness correction was applied. In some cases, roots were scanned using Leica SP5 confocal microcope with 1.5 μm step size for Z-stacks. Maximum projections were generated using Leica SP5 software,
RT-qPCR and reporter imaging
qRT-PCR was performed in three biological and four technical replicates per sample. Total RNA (2 µg) was used for cDNA synthesis using transcriptor first-strand cDNA synthesis kit (Roche)14. For GUS assays, samples were kept immersed in ice-cold 90% acetone with gentle shaking for 1 h followed by three washes with sodium phosphate buffer pH 7 for 1 h. Tissues were incubated in GUS staining solution for 3 h at 37 °C14 and images were taken on a Leica microscope using DIC optics.
The authors declare that all data supporting the findings of this study are available within the manuscript and its supplementary files or are available from the corresponding author on request.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This work was supported by the awards from the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council [grant numbers BB/G023972/1, BB/R013748/1, BB/L026848/1, BB/M018431/1, BB/PO16855/1, BB/M001806/1, BB/P010520/1]; the European Research Council FUTUREROOTS Advanced Investigator grant [grant number 294729]; Leverhulme Trust [grant number RPG-2016-409]; Royal Society [grant number WM130021, NA140281]; Newton International Fellowship (NF140287) and British Council Newton Bhabha (228144076). This work was also supported by funds from the University of Nottingham Future Food Beacon of Excellence Nottingham Research and PhD+ fellowship schemes; the Interuniversity Attraction Poles Program initiated by the Belgian Science Policy Office [P7/29]; the Swedish Governmental Agency for Innovation Systems (VINNOVA), and the Swedish Research Council (V.R.) to K.L. We also thank Roger Granbom (Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences) for technical assistance and Gabriel Castrillo for commenting on the manuscript text. Part of this work has been conducted at the Rice Functional Genomics REFUGE platform funded by Agropolis Fondation in Montpellier, France. We also thank DBT-CREST BT/HRD/03/01/2002.
About this article
Nature Communications (2018)