Human-pluripotent-stem-cell-derived kidney cells (hPSC-KCs) have important potential for disease modelling and regeneration. Whether the hPSC-KCs can reconstitute tissue-specific phenotypes is currently unknown. Here we show that hPSC-KCs self-organize into kidney organoids that functionally recapitulate tissue-specific epithelial physiology, including disease phenotypes after genome editing. In three-dimensional cultures, epiblast-stage hPSCs form spheroids surrounding hollow, amniotic-like cavities. GSK3β inhibition differentiates spheroids into segmented, nephron-like kidney organoids containing cell populations with characteristics of proximal tubules, podocytes and endothelium. Tubules accumulate dextran and methotrexate transport cargoes, and express kidney injury molecule-1 after nephrotoxic chemical injury. CRISPR/Cas9 knockout of podocalyxin causes junctional organization defects in podocyte-like cells. Knockout of the polycystic kidney disease genes PKD1 or PKD2 induces cyst formation from kidney tubules. All of these functional phenotypes are distinct from effects in epiblast spheroids, indicating that they are tissue specific. Our findings establish a reproducible, versatile three-dimensional framework for human epithelial disease modelling and regenerative medicine applications.
Both undifferentiated stem cells and terminally differentiated somatic cells form epithelia. These can function to establish axes for differentiation in the embryo, or to perform barrier and transport roles in adult organs such as the kidney. Three-dimensional (3D) cell culture in vitro is a powerful tool for investigating epithelial morphogenesis, physiology and disease, being readily accessible to microscopic inspection, chemical treatment and experimental manipulation. Studies of epithelial cell lines such as Madin–Darby canine kidney (MDCK) cells have, for instance, revealed polarity and apoptosis pathways contributing mechanistically to lumen formation1. Conventional epithelial cell lines, however, are lineage-restricted and lack genetic diversity. As a result, the 3D structures that arise are relatively simple, and it has been challenging to perform controlled comparisons of different epithelia of the same genetic background, or the same epithelia with different genetic backgrounds. Despite these limitations, interest in the cellular microenvironment and 3D culture systems has been increasing steadily, particularly for stem cell applications2. There is a significant need for genetically diverse cell culture platforms that accurately reconstitute tissue-specific epithelial function, particularly in humans where species–specific toxicology and disease pathophysiology is of significant biomedical relevance.
Human pluripotent stem cells (hPSCs) are capable of extensive self-renewal and can differentiate into diverse somatic cell types and tissues. hPSCs are also genetically diverse, including thousands of human embryonic stem cell (hESC) and induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) lines with patient-specific or gene-targeted mutations3,4,5,6. hPSCs have therefore emerged as a powerful and reproducible source of diverse human tissues for disease modelling and regeneration. hPSCs resemble the implantation-stage human epiblast, a tissue that forms the axes for the developing embryo and cannot be studied in living human embryos owing to ethical considerations2,7,8,9,10. Like the epiblast, hPSCs are epithelial cells, but their polarity, barrier and lumenogenesis characteristics remain very poorly understood. Mouse ESCs (mESCs) were recently shown to form polarized rosettes with small cavities when surrounded by Matrigel extracellular matrix, suggesting the possibility of modelling early amniotic cavity formation in the epiblast11. However, because these experiments were performed with mESCs, which more closely resemble the more primitive inner cell mass (ICM) than the epiblast, it remains unclear whether the observed rosettes truly represent epiblast and whether hPSCs could form similar structures8,12,13,14,15,16. Better understanding of human epiblast-stage biology may lead to improvements in the directed differentiation of hPSCs into specific cell types and organoids.
The kidney is an epithelial organ of major interest to the field of regenerative medicine17,18,19,20,21. Kidney epithelial subsets are highly specialized and their dysfunction can result in a variety of clinical disorders. For instance, polycystic kidney disease (PKD) features cystic expansion of tubular epithelial cells, whereas glomerulopathies involve injury to the podocyte epithelium through which blood is filtered into the tubules22,23,24,25,26,27,28. As proof-of-principle for using hPSCs to model kidney disease, we have identified a ciliary phenotype in undifferentiated iPSCs and descendant epithelial cells from PKD patients17. Intriguingly, hPSCs have been directed to differentiate in vitro into hPSC-derived kidney cells (hPSC-KCs) expressing markers typical of kidney progenitor cells, proximal tubules and podocytes18,19,20,21. However, these markers may not be exclusive to the kidney, and no study to date has demonstrated an ability to form renal-like structures in vitro and recapitulate a disease-relevant phenotype in hPSC-KCs. Ideally, such phenotypes would be expected to be present in kidney tissues but be absent in other epithelial cells not similarly affected by the disease. Reconstitution of kidney-specific microphysiology and injury/disease states in hPSC-KCs is therefore important to more conclusively identify these epithelia and to advance their translational application.
Here we establish adherent, 3D growth conditions for reconstitution of two distinct epithelial structures, epiblast spheroids and kidney organoids, which arise sequentially in a single continuous culture of hPSCs. Using small molecule treatments and genome-edited hPSCs, we demonstrate that these structures are capable of reconstituting tissue-specific epithelial transport, toxicity responses and disease phenotypes. Our results reveal both common and tissue-specific features in hPSCs and descendant hPSC-KCs, and establish an innovative human organoid model for kidney injury and disease. Our findings are broadly relevant for functional studies of human microphysiology, pathophysiology and regenerative medicine.
hPSCs form cavitated spheroids in 3D culture
To evaluate the tissue-specific functions of undifferentiated hPSCs and descendant hPSC-KCs, we developed an adherent, 3D culture system for hPSCs that first produced epiblast spheroids and subsequently kidney tubules (Fig. 1a). Dissociated, undifferentiated hPSCs sandwiched between two layers of dilute Matrigel (0.2 mg ml−1) formed compact, ball-like colonies; by 48 h, these formed internal cavities (Fig. 1b). Mature spheroids consisted of a simple columnar epithelium surrounding a hollow lumen (Fig. 1b,c). Spheroid cells exhibited polarized localization of podocalyxin (PODXL) to the luminal surface, zonula occludens 1 (ZO-1) to apical cell–cell junctions, and β-catenin (βCAT) to primarily basolateral membranes (Fig. 1c). Similar apicobasal polarization patterns were observed in monolayer hPSCs (Supplementary Fig. 1a).
We further tested hPSC spheroids for pluripotency and self-renewal, which are the key functional characteristics of undifferentiated hPSCs. In nine serial passages, dissociated cavity-lining spheroid cells generated new cavitated spheroids after sandwiching, or alternatively flat colonies when the final passage was into monolayer conditions (Fig. 1d). Even after extensive serial passages to/from 3D culture, cavity-lining cells implanted into immunodeficient mice efficiently produced teratoma tissues derived from all three embryonic germ layers (Fig. 1e). Two-dimensional (2D) and 3D cultures exhibited similar growth rates, and pluripotency markers continued to be expressed in identical patterns in serially sandwiched cells, including octamer-binding transcription factor 4 (OCT4), sex-determining region Y box-2 (SOX2), NANOG and TRA-1-60 (Fig. 1f,g). 2D colonies and 3D spheroids in pluripotency-sustaining (mTeSR1) media also had nearly identical global gene expression profiles (Supplementary Fig. 1b). Thus, spheroids represented undifferentiated, self-renewing, pluripotent stem cells rather than a differentiated subtype.
During the development of humans and many other mammals, the ICM of the early embryo differentiates into the epiblast, from which all somatic cells are derived. We hypothesized that hPSC spheroids model the epiblast epithelial mass, which forms a columnar epithelium surrounding an early amniotic cavity in human and primate implantation-stage embryos15,16. Conversely, hPSCs resembling the more primitive ICM were predicted not to cavitate8,12,13. Indeed, ‘naive’ hLR5 iPSCs, which form compact, ICM-like colonies similar to mouse (m)ESCs8, did not form lumens in 3D cultures even after 5 days of growth, whereas ‘primed’ hLR5-derived (LD-)iPSCs, which resemble epiblast-stage hPSCs, formed cavities efficiently in sandwich cultures (Supplementary Fig. 2a,b). Both naive and primed hPSCs continued to express nuclear OCT4 and SOX2 in both 2D and 3D cultures (Supplementary Fig. 2c). Similarly, naive mESCs, which resemble the ICM, did not form cavities under a variety of 3D culture conditions, whereas epiblast-stage mEpiSCs formed rosettes surrounding small lumens (Supplementary Fig. 2d–f). These experiments identified the epiblast stage as a critical window for hPSC spheroid lumenogenesis, whereas naive (ICM-stage) hPSCs could not form lumens.
CHIR99021 differentiates spheroids into tubular organoids
To differentiate epiblast spheroids into descendant epithelia, we applied a directed differentiation regimen originally designed for cardiomyocyte generation from 2D cultures, involving the sequential inhibition of glycogen synthase kinase-3β (GSK3β) and wingless-related integration site (WNT) signalling29. Remarkably, rather than forming cardiomyocytes, spheroid cells underwent epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition to form a confluent monolayer that by day 10 aggregated into folds and initiated mesenchymal-to-epithelial transition into convoluted, translucent, tubular organoids (Fig. 2a, Supplementary Fig. 3a,b and Supplementary Movie 1). Optimization of this new protocol revealed that spheroid formation, treatment with the GSK3β inhibitor Chiron Technologies 99021 (CHIR99021) and subsequent incubation in B27-supplemented media were sufficient to induce tubular differentiation, whereas insulin and WNT inhibition steps were dispensable (Supplementary Fig. 3c,d; the optimized protocol is shown in Fig. 1a).
We examined these tubular organoids for the expression of kidney markers. Lotus tetragonolobus lectin (LTL), a marker of kidney proximal tubules, reacted strongly with tubular structures and appeared enriched in tubular lumens (Fig. 2b,c). By comparison, epiblast spheroids examined side-by-side with tubules had negligible affinity for LTL (Supplementary Fig. 3e). As LTL reacts strongly with kidney tubules and also with certain other epithelia, we performed a more thorough characterization of these organoids with markers of kidney and other organs. Tubules expressed the nephron progenitor/renal vesicle markers Lin11-Isl1-Mec3 (LIM) homeobox 1 (LHX1) and paired box gene 2 (PAX2; Fig. 2b). Sine oculis homeobox homologue 2 (SIX2) was expressed in mesenchyme adjacent to the tubules but not in the tubules themselves, consistent with the developmental restriction of this marker to the metanephric mesenchyme (Fig. 2b). The endocytosis receptors low density lipoprotein-related protein 2 (megalin) and cubilin were co-expressed apically and co-localized with LTL in tubule segments (Fig. 2c). Apical microvilli and tight junctions were observed in tubules by electron microscopy (Fig. 2d). We furthermore observed anatomical progression of tubules from segments expressing E-cadherin, a distal tubule marker30, to LTL+ segments (proximal tubule), to capsule-like structures containing PODXL+ podocyte-like cells (Fig. 2e). These PODXL+ cells aggregated at the termini of tubules, at the periphery of the organoids (Fig. 2f). They exhibited a spherical and tightly clustered morphology, lacked LTL reactivity, and co-expressed additional markers of kidney podocytes31,32,33, including Wilms tumour protein (WT1) and synaptopodin (Fig. 2f,g). Endothelial cords expressing CD31 and von Willebrand factor also arose within organoids, contacting both tubular and podocyte-like cell populations (Fig. 2g). These results suggested that tubular organoids contained self-organizing hPSC-KC subpopulations capable of nephron-like segmentation and vascular structures.
Using this protocol, H9 hESCs and three different iPSC lines produced organoids incorporating cells and structures with characteristics of proximal tubules, endothelial cells and podocytes, in kidney-like segmental arrangements (Fig. 2g). hESCs showed the highest efficiency of differentiation, yielding ∼90 organoids per 1.9 cm2, with LTL+ cells representing ∼25% of the total culture (Fig. 2h and Supplementary Fig. 4a). Approximately 80% of LTL+ organoids included endothelial (CD31+) and podocyte-like (PODXL+) cell populations (Fig. 2h). Markers of neuroectoderm (TUJ1) or intestine (CDX2) were absent within organoids; however, separate clusters of TUJ1+ cells were observed in the cultures at a ratio of approximately 1:2 to kidney organoids, and projected axon-like processes towards the tubules (Supplementary Fig. 4b–d). RNA and protein analysis during the time course of differentiation revealed sequential induction of markers characteristic of mesendoderm, nephron progenitors and finally proximal tubules and podocyte-like cells (Supplementary Fig. 4e). To assess their potential to engraft in vivo, tubular organoid cultures were dissociated and implanted into kidneys of neonatal immunodeficient mice. After 3 weeks, we identified human nuclear antigen-positive (HNA+) epithelial structures within the mouse kidney cortex, with LTL intensities comparable to neighbouring mouse tubules (Fig. 2i). We concluded that tubular organoids most likely represented the kidney lineage.
Organoids recapitulate tissue-specific injury and transport
Tissue-specific functions or disease phenotypes have not been demonstrated in hPSC-KCs. We therefore investigated the potential of kidney organoids to upregulate a clinical biomarker of proximal tubule injury, kidney injury molecule-1 (KIM-1), also known as T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin domain 1 and hepatitis A virus cellular receptor 1 (refs 34, 35). When treated with the nephrotoxic drugs cis-diamminedichloroplatinum(II) (cisplatin) or gentamicin, KIM-1 immunofluorescence was detected at the luminal surface of tubules in ∼80% of organoids, and was confirmed using two different antibodies (Fig. 3a–c). In contrast, while epiblast spheroids exhibited dose-dependent sensitivity to both cisplatin and gentamicin (disintegration), they did not upregulate KIM-1 after treatment, indicating that this response was specific to kidney organoids (Fig. 3d). Notably, LTL+ tubules remained stable in extended cultures for at least 120 days, and cultures could also be miniaturized to a 96-well format (Fig. 3e,f). Kidney organoids might therefore provide a long-term, high-throughput model system to evaluate human nephrotoxicity.
To test whether epiblast spheroids and kidney tubules exhibit tissue-specific barrier functions, we developed a real-time assay to visualize molecular diffusion kinetics into and out of lumens, using fluorescent compounds of different sizes. In epiblast spheroids, lucifer yellow (521 Da) added to the culture media for 2–4 h gradually accumulated within cavities, whereas rhodamine-conjugated dextran (RD, 10,000 Da) was excluded from lumens and instead accumulated in apical intercellular regions and formed a bright halo around the lumen (Fig. 4a). Reciprocally, RD microinjected into the cavity remained detectable for hours (Fig. 4b). Another small molecule, fluorescein methotrexate (979 Da), did not accumulate in hPSC lumens (Fig. 4c). When fluorescent compounds were incubated with spheroids for several hours and subsequently washed out, the compounds initially retained their distributions, but faded in intensity over time, indicating that they remained dynamic and were not fixed in location (Fig. 4d). We performed parallel experiments assessing transport of fluorescent macromolecules in differentiated tubular organoids. In contrast to epiblast spheroids, RD localized to tubular lumens in ∼80% of organoids after 2–4 h of incubation, and remained associated during a 24-h washout chase, without corresponding enrichment of lucifer yellow (Fig. 4e,f). Co-incubation with latrunculin B, an inhibitor of actin polymerization and endocytosis, significantly reduced RD accumulation (Fig. 4g). Methotrexate also accumulated in kidney tubules, similar to RD, but appeared more dynamic than RD after washout (Fig. 4h). Tubular organoids thus exhibited transport characteristics typical of proximal tubules36,37 and distinct from those of epiblast spheroids.
Podocalyxin promotes epiblast cavitation
Podocalyxin is an apical sialomucin expressed highly in both epiblast and kidney podocytes1,11,26,27,38,39. To investigate the functional role of podocalyxin in these cell types, podocalyxin knockout (PODXL−/−) hPSCs were generated using the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/Cas9 genome editing system (Supplementary Fig. 5a). Immunoblots for podocalyxin revealed two major bands at ∼220 and 80 kDa that were completely absent in PODXL−/− hPSCs (Fig. 5a). TRA-1-60 and TRA-1-81, two pluripotency markers associated with podocalyxin, were ∼40% reduced in knockout cells (Supplementary Fig. 5b). PODXL−/− hPSCs exhibited teratoma formation, growth rates and 3D colony size indistinguishable from otherwise isogenic, unmodified hPSCs, indicating that they remained pluripotent and self-renewing (Supplementary Fig. 5c–e). Strikingly, compared with unmodified controls of otherwise identical genetic background, PODXL−/− hPSCs in 3D sandwich cultures exhibited a drastic (∼85%) decrease in their ability to produce hollow lumens, appearing instead as solid spheroids by phase contrast microscopy (Fig. 5b,c). Furthermore, podocalyxin expression was much higher in epiblast-stage hPSCs and mEpiSCs, which formed podocalyxin-lined cavities, than in ICM-stage cells, which did not form cavities (Fig. 5d,e). These results revealed that podocalyxin was dispensable for the maintenance of pluripotency but required for epiblast spheroid lumenogenesis.
Podocalyxin is proposed to regulate lumenogenesis through tight junction organization39,40. In PODXL−/− hESCs, however, the junctional components ZO-1, occludin and filamentous actin appeared properly localized, and transepithelial electrical resistance (TEER) was indistinguishable from wild-type controls (Fig. 5f–h). Although lumens were only very rarely observed by phase contrast microscopy in living cells, immunofluorescence in fixed cultures revealed small, compressed lumens in PODXL−/− hESC spheroids, lined with apically polarized ZO-1 (Supplementary Fig. 6a). Lucifer yellow added to the media accumulated within these small lumens, while RD was excluded from lumens and accumulated in intercellular foci, similar to wild-type cells (Supplementary Fig. 6b). These experiments demonstrated that podocalyxin is not required to establish polarized, functional tight junctions in hPSCs. To investigate whether podocalyxin might contribute directly to luminal expansion via intermolecular charge repulsion, hPSCs were treated with a low concentration (8 μg ml−1) of protamine sulfate, a positively charged polycation that neutralizes the negatively charged, sialylated extracellular domain of podocalyxin41. Protamine sulfate strongly inhibited 3D cavity formation, causing mislocalization of podocalyxin to dispersed patches (Supplementary Fig. 6c,d). Collectively, these results revealed that podocalyxin can promote epiblast lumenogenesis independently of its association with tight junctions, likely through a direct, charge-mediated mechanism.
Podocalyxin regulates junctions in podocyte-like cells
We next investigated podocalyxin function in human kidney cell types. In tissue sections from adult human kidneys, podocalyxin was highly expressed in the glomeruli, but was not detected in the tubules (Fig. 6a). Similarly, in hPSC-derived kidney organoids, only podocyte-like cells expressed high levels of podocalyxin (Fig. 6b). We determined the localization pattern of podocalyxin and junctional markers in these cells by confocal microscopy. Both podocalyxin and another podocyte marker, Crumbs3, brightly coated the plasma membrane on the exterior of podocyte-like aggregates, whereas ZO-1, SYNPO and βCAT co-localized in a reciprocal pattern, forming internal zipper-like tracks between adjacent cell layers (Fig. 6c,d). The combined expression of PODXL, Crumbs3, ZO-1, SYNPO, βCAT and WT1 (see Fig. 2f) is not known to occur in any population other than kidney podocytes, nor would such cells be expected to appear alongside LTL+ tubular cells in other organs26,27,42,43,44. These results furthermore reveal that hPSC-KC podocyte-like cells form polarized domains segregating junctional components such as Crumbs3 from ZO-1, consistent with biochemical and microscopic analyses of podocytes in vivo31,32,33.
To investigate podocalyxin function in human podocyte-like cells, we produced kidney organoids from PODXL−/− hPSCs. In contrast to wild-type organoids, in PODXL−/− organoids, the appearance of linear ZO-1+SYNPO+ tracks was strongly reduced, and junctional markers adopted a more diffuse expression pattern (Fig. 6e). The disappearance of these tracks in PODXL−/− organoids correlated with a decrease in gap width between adjacent podocyte-like cells, compared with isogenic controls (Fig. 6f). The absence of podocalyxin did not affect the efficiency of hPSC-KC differentiation into tubules (ZO-1+LTL+) or podocytes (ZO-1+SYNPO+; Supplementary Fig. 7a). Tubules, which expressed little to no detectable podocalyxin, exhibited no defects in their morphologies, diameters and LTL or ZO-1 expression patterns in PODXL−/− organoids (Supplementary Fig. 7a,c). We concluded that podocalyxin is dispensable for kidney organoid differentiation, but is specifically required in podocyte-like cells for proper junctional organization.
Genome-modified kidney organoids form PKD-specific cysts
Lastly, we investigated the potential of kidney organoids to functionally model PKD, which is characterized by the expansion of kidney tubules to form cysts. Biallelic, loss-of-function mutations in PKD1 or PKD2 are proposed to contribute strongly to PKD cystogenesis22,23,28. We therefore applied the CRISPR/Cas9 genome editing system to introduce biallelic, truncating mutations in PKD1 or PKD2 in hPSCs (PKD hPSCs). Chromatogram analyses and immunoblotting confirmed frame-shift mutations at the target site and demonstrated the absence of the corresponding full-length proteins (Fig. 7a,b and Supplementary Fig. 8a,b). PKD hPSCs differentiated into teratomas similar to isogenic controls, and formed epiblast spheroids with similarly sized lumens (Fig. 7c and Supplementary Fig. 8c,d). These experiments revealed that PKD1 and PKD2 were dispensable for the maintenance of pluripotency, and did not detectably affect epiblast spheroid cavitation or morphogenesis.
To test whether these lines might produce phenotypes relevant to PKD in the kidney lineage, we cultured renal organoids derived from PKD hPSCs for several weeks side-by-side with isogenic, unmodified controls. Remarkably, in the PKD hPSC cultures, we observed formation of large, translucent, cyst-like structures alongside tubular organoids (Fig. 7d). These structures remained tethered to the underlying matrix, but moved freely in response to vibration, in contrast to neighbouring tubular organoids that remained fixed in position near the surface of the dish (Supplementary Movie 2). These cysts were detected at a low rate, at ∼6% of that of kidney organoids (Fig. 7e). Importantly, isogenic control hPSCs plated and differentiated side-by-side did not form cysts under these conditions (Fig. 7e). No differences were observed in the overall efficiency of organoid differentiation between PKD hPSCs and controls (Supplementary Fig. 8e). PKD cysts first became noticeable about 35 days after the initial plating and continued to expand for the duration of the culture. Cysts exhibited a strong affinity for LTL comparable to neighbouring tubules (Fig. 7f) and were observed to arise from tubular structures in time-lapse movies (Supplementary Movie 3). Confocal microscopy indicated that cyst-lining epithelia surrounded hollow interior compartments devoid of cells (Fig. 7g). These findings suggested that PKD mutations resulted in aberrant cystogenesis from tubular organoids, in contrast to epiblast spheroids.
The epithelial characteristics of hPSCs and derived kidney cells are poorly understood. Reconstitution of epithelial physiology and morphogenesis in these cell types is important for advancing their potential as human laboratory models and regenerative therapeutics. The described culture system and assays establish a framework for generating and functionally profiling undifferentiated hPSCs and descendant hPSC-KCs in three dimensions. hPSCs are a well-characterized, homogenous and genetically diverse cell type that includes patient-specific, immunocompatible iPSCs45,46. Well-functioning hPSC-derived epithelia may therefore have applicability for regenerative medicine.
We demonstrate, for the first time, that undifferentiated, epiblast-stage hPSCs form cavitated spheroids in 3D culture, similar to rosettes recently derived from mESCs, but with expanded lumens11. By directly comparing 2D and 3D cultures, our studies reveal that spheroid formation at the epiblast stage can significantly affect subsequent cell fate decisions, producing tubular organoids instead of cardiomyocytes. These organoids recapitulate key characteristics of kidney development and physiology in vitro, which have been challenging to model using primary adult or embryonic kidney cells1,47,48,49. In contrast to previous protocols for kidney directed differentiation from hPSCs18,19,20,21, our simple, two-step procedure of spheroid formation followed by GSK3β inhibition in growth-factor reduced Matrigel does not require exogenous supplementation with fibroblast growth factor 2, activin or bone morphogenetic protein. The tubular structures are surrounded by dilute extracellular matrix in an adherent, microplate format that is experimentally accessible, scalable and potentially high throughput18,19,20,21. These structures exhibit a lineage complexity that differs from conventional kidney cell lines and organoids1,47. All the major components of the developing proximal nephron—tubular cells, endothelial cells, nephron progenitors and podocyte-like cells—are represented within each individual organoid, in kidney-like architectures (Fig. 8b). The proximal tubules transport fluorescent cargoes in a characteristic manner, which is distinct from the pluripotent spheroid epithelia from which they derive36,37. When injured, tubules express a clinical biomarker, KIM-1, a response that is highly characteristic of the proximal tubule in vivo but lost in de-differentiated primary cultures34,35. This may provide a quantifiable human standard with which to predict proximal tubule nephrotoxicity, a frequent cause of failure in drug development.
As our studies of PODXL−/− hPSCs illustrate, this advanced differentiation system can be combined with CRISPR/Cas9 genome editing to determine the function of specific genes in different human cell types, on an isogenic genetic background. Our results suggest a molecular model whereby the combination of apicobasal polarization, tight junction organization and podocalyxin expression distinguishes epiblast-stage hPSCs from ICM-stage progenitors and promotes formation of the early amniotic cavity (Fig. 8a). Although podocalyxin upregulation and tight junction organization occur simultaneously, tight junctions can organize and function independently of podocalyxin in hPSCs. In contrast, in podocyte-like cells, podocalyxin plays a dominant role in the organization of junctions and the spacing of adjacent cells (Fig. 8b), consistent with reports of tight junction phenotypes during rodent glomerulogenesis and in MDCK cells26,27,38,39. Thus, although podocalyxin plays an anti-adhesive role in both epiblast and podocyte, its effect on cell polarity and tight junctions is limited to podocytes. Further investigations are required to determine the precise molecular mechanisms underlying these cell type-specific differences, which suggest the presence of co-regulatory factors present in one cell type but not the other. As alterations in podocalyxin expression and the podocyte cytoskeleton are a well-described characteristic of human glomerular disease states24,25,26,27, such studies may produce new insights into pathophysiology and treatment.
PKD is among the most common monogenic diseases and of major interest to both clinicians and cell biologists. Existing cellular systems have reported quantitative differences in the formation of simple spheroids or ‘cysts’ attributed to defects in PKD gene expression50,51,52. However, even wild-type cells frequently form cysts in these systems. A reproducible system for PKD-specific cyst formation from tubules is therefore an important goal for the field, particularly in humans where species–specific pathophysiology and therapy is of clinical interest17. We find that loss-of-function PKD mutations result in cyst formation from hPSC-derived tubular cells, which is not observed in isogenic controls17,22,23. This finding suggests that PKD-specific cystogenesis from tubules is a cell-intrinsic phenomenon that can be modelled in a minimal system in vitro. As cystogenesis was observed for both PKD1 and PKD2 mutants, and was specific to the kidney organoids but not epiblast spheroids, the phenotype is both gene specific and lineage specific in this system. Further studies are required to determine the cellular basis of cystogenesis in this system and whether iPSCs from PKD patients, which have heterozygous mutations and variable genetic backgrounds, also produce cysts17. As cysts are a relatively rare phenomenon, improvements in iPSC differentiation efficiencies may be required to perform such experiments.
The described hPSC system does have limitations. For instance, we have not yet observed formation of a vascularized glomerulus from hPSC podocyte-like cells and neighbouring endothelia. The tubules also do not contain a full brush border. Although SIX2+ mesenchyme was observed adjacent to tubular cells, we did not observe evidence of ureteric bud markers in these tubules. Rather, the tubules have characteristics of proximal tubules derived from the SIX2+ mesenchyme, which was induced to differentiate through a non-developmental pathway. Neurons were abundant in these cultures and might possibly represent a source of inductive signals for kidney tubular differentiation in the absence of ureteric bud, similar to embryonic spinal cord53. A further limitation of this hPSC-based system is the lack of widely available fluorescent reporter lines with which to perform lineage tracing experiments. One possible solution to this problem would be to adapt this protocol for mouse EpiSCs, which are similar to hPSCs in phenotype. For instance, EpiSCs from the Six2-eGFPCre reporter mouse might be used to determine with greater certainty whether all tubular cells in our system derive from the SIX2+ mesenchyme, using developing kidneys from this mouse as positive controls54. Overall, our findings suggest that while kidney differentiation is indeed occurring from hPSCs, this process in vitro does not fully recapitulate developmental kidney nephrogenesis. Dedicated studies involving fluid flow and the tissue microenvironment in vivo are required to further develop this system into fully functional nephrons, for more advanced disease modelling and therapeutic application.
In conclusion, we have developed a 3D culture system that reconstitutes functional, structured epithelia modelling the epiblast, kidney tubular cells and podocyte-like cells. These pluripotent and descendant epithelia share certain key structural features, but they can nevertheless recapitulate stage-specific transport characteristics and morphogenesis mechanisms. This provides an accurate and reproducible platform in which to model human microphysiology, injury and disease at distinct developmental stages. Genome-modified tubular organoids functionally recapitulate kidney disease phenotypes, strengthening the identification of these structures as kidney and establishing innovative cellular systems for studying human renal physiology and pathophysiology in vitro. The described methodologies are broadly applicable and adaptable to diverse tissues and genetically diverse backgrounds, and can be used immediately to experimentally investigate molecular pathways relevant to human epithelial diseases. In the longer term, this system may provide a useful setting in which to optimize and test the functionality of patient-derived epithelia in vitro, before regenerative graft administration.
Cell lines included H9/WA09 hESCs (WiCell), iPSCs from BJ foreskin fibroblasts (ATCC CRL-2522) and HDFα human dermal fibroblasts (Invitrogen C-013–5C) previously derived in our laboratory17, human-LIF-plus-5-reprogramming-factors (hLR5) iPSCs provided by Niels Geijsen (Hubrecht Institute)8, human fibroblast hfib2-iPS4 and hfib2–iPS5 iPSCs provided by George Daley (Boston Children’s Hospital), and mESC lines J1 (ATCC SCRC-1010), R1 (ATCC SCRC-1011), and v6.5 (Novus Biologicals NBP1-41162). Cells were maintained feeder-free on 3% Reduced Growth Factor GelTrex (Life Technologies) for at least one passage in the following media: hPSCs in Modified Tenneille’s Special Recipe 1 (mTeSR1, StemCell Technologies); mESCs in N2/B27 medium+2i (0.5X Neurobasal media, 0.5X Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle Medium/Nutrient Mixture F12 (DMEM/F12) media, 0.5X N2 supplement, 0.5X B27 supplement, 0.5X Glutamax, 0.0025% bovine serum albumin and 0.1 mM β-mercaptoethanol (all from Thermo Fisher Scientific), 1,000 U ml−1 mouse leukaemia inhibitory factor (LIF, Millipore), 3 μM CHIR99021 (Stemgent), and 100 nM Sigma PD173074)12; and hLR5 iPSCs in hESC media (DMEM/F12 with 20% knockout serum replacement, 1X non-essential amino acids, 1X Glutamax, 1X penicillin-streptomycin and 0.1 mM β-mercaptoethanol, all from Thermo Fisher Scientific) pre-incubated/conditioned for 48 h by 4.0 × 106 gamma-irradiated mouse embryonic fibroblasts (GlobalStem) per 50 ml and subsequently supplemented with 10 ng ml−1 human LIF (Sigma) and 2 ng ml−1 doxycycline (Sigma)8. Cells were dissociated with Accutase (StemCell Technologies) or TrypLE (Thermo Fisher Scientific). LD-iPSCs were derived from naive hLR5 iPSCs by withdrawing LIF and doxycycline and substituting with 10 ng ml−1 fibroblast growth factor 2 (PeproTech)8. For thin gel sandwich colonies, cells were plated at 60,000 (primed) or 30,000 (naive) cells/well of a 24-well plate or 4-well chamber slide pre-coated with GelTrex in media supplemented with 10 μM Rho-kinase inhibitor Y27632 (Stemgent). The following day the media was replaced with 500 μl 1.5% GelTrex in mTeSR1. Media was changed after 24 h. For thick gel cultures, 20,000 (epiblast stage) or 6,000 (naive) cells/well of a 96-well plate were resuspended in 75 μl of either buffered collagen I (containing 10 mM HEPES and 1X DMEM), reduced growth-factor Matrigel (BD Biosciences), or a 1:1 mixture of the two, incubated for 45 min at 37 degrees, and then overlaid with 100 μl of media plus Y27632. For serial passaging in thin gels, colonies with lumens in 3D cultures were dissociated 72 h after plating, replated at a density of 300,000 cells/well within a 6-well plate, and cultured for 72 h in either 2D or 3D conditions before dissociation, cell counting and replating. For suspension, 20,000 dissociated hPSCs were plated in mTeSR1 media in one well of a low-adherence 6-well plate. For all cells, media was changed daily.
Tubular Organoid Differentiation
In all, 60,000–120,000 H9 hPSCs were plated per 1.9 cm2 and sandwiched, sufficient to produce scattered, isolated spheroid colonies. Forty-eight hours after sandwiching, hPSC spheroids were treated with 12 μM CHIR (Stemgent) for 36 h, then changed to RB (Advanced RPMI+1X Glutamax+1X B27 Supplement, all from Thermo Fisher Scientific) and replaced every 3 days thereafter. Alternatively, spheroids were treated with 12 μM CHIR in RB minus insulin (RBNI) for 24 h, RBNI for 48 h, 5 μM inhibitor of WNT production-2 (IWP2, Tocris) for 48 h, RBNI for 48 h and RB every 3 days thereafter, as described for 2D cardiomyocyte differentiation29.
Fluorescence and Electron Microscopy
To fix while preserving 3D architecture, an equal volume of 8% paraformaldehyde was added to the culture media (4% final concentration) for 15 min at room temperature. After fixing, samples were washed in PBS, blocked in 5% donkey serum (Millipore)/0.3% Triton-X-100/PBS, incubated overnight in 3% bovine serum albumin/PBS with primary antibodies, washed, incubated with Alexa-Fluor secondary antibodies (Invitrogen), washed and stained with DAPI or mounted in Vectashield H-1000. Primary antibodies included OCT4 (sc-5279; Santa Cruz; 1:100 dilution), NANOG (RCAB0004PF; Cosmobio; 1:300), brachyury (sc-17745; Santa Cruz; 1:100), TRA-1-60 (MAB4360; Millipore; 1:500), TRA-1-81 (MAB4381; Millipore; 1:500), acetylated α-tubulin (051M4770; Sigma; 1:2,000), ZO-1 (339100; Invitrogen; 1:100), CDX2 (-88; Biogenex; 1:100), AQP1 (AB2219; Millipore; 1:500), WT1 (sc-192; Santa Cruz; 1:100), LHX1 (Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank; 1:50), mPODXL (AF1556; R&D; 1:500), hPODXL (AF1658; R&D; 1:500), HNA (MAB1281; Millipore; 1:200), SYNPO (sc-21537; Santa Cruz; 1:100), CD31 (555444; BD; 1:500), occludin (71-1500; Fisher; 1:100) and Crumbs 3 (HPA013835; Sigma; 1:200). Stains included fluorescein-labeled LTL (FL-1321; Vector Labs; 1:500) and phalloidin–tetramethylrhodamine B isothiocyanate (P1951; Sigma; 1:1,000) for filamentous actin. Fluorescence images were captured using a Nikon epifluorescence 90-I (upright), Eclipse Ti (inverted), or confocal C1 microscopes. For electron microscopy, structures were scraped from the plate after 5 min of fixation, pelleted at 300g for 4 min, and the pellet was gently released by pipetting into 0.15 M sodium cacodylate trihydrate (Sigma) dissolved in water (pH 7.3) containing 4% formaldehyde and 2% glutaraldehyde (Electron Microscopy Sciences), post-fixed with osmium tetroxide solution (Sigma), dehydrated in serial ethanol dilutions (Sigma) and embedded in epoxy resin. Semi-thin sections were cut at 1 mm and stained with toluidine blue (Sigma) to identify tubular structures with apparent lumens by light microscopic examination. Ultrathin sections (75 nm) were cut, mounted on 200 mesh copper grids, counterstained with uranyl acetate and lead citrate stains (Electron Microscopy Sciences), and examined in a JEOL JEM-1010 transmission electron microscope.
Implantation in vivo
Kidney organoid cultures (400,000 cells) were dissociated with accutase, pelleted, resuspended in Advanced RPMI and injected into the kidneys of P0 NOD.CB17-Prkdcscid/J mice (Jackson Labs). The mice were sutured and killed 3 weeks later and the kidneys were sectioned. To form teratomas ∼2,000,000 undifferentiated hPSCs were dissociated, resuspended in 50 μl cold Matrigel (BD), and injected dorsally into 8-week-old NOD.CB17-Prkdcscid/J mice. Growths were collected 8–10 weeks later. Male and female animals were used. Experiments were performed in compliance with ethical regulations and ARRIVE guidelines and in accordance with protocols approved by the Harvard Medical Area Standing Committee on Animals.
To test permeability, media was supplemented with 20 mM HEPES plus Lucifer Yellow carbohydrazide potassium salt (Invitrogen, 38 μM) and Rhodamine-B isothiocyanate dextran (Sigma, 0.5 μM), and imaged by confocal microscopy. For microinjection, 5 μM rhodamine-conjugated dextran solution in mTeSR1 was diluted 1:1 with Phenol Red Solution (0.5%, Sigma) for visualization. A measure of 2 nl was microinjected via a pulled glass capillary microneedle on a Nanoject-2 micromanipulator, and monitored in real-time by wide-field epifluorescence. To block uptake, Latrunculin B (Sigma) was added simultaneously with RD. To measure TEER, 50,000 hPSCs were plated on 24-well transwell plates (Corning) pre-coated with dilute Matrigel. The media was gently exchanged for 10 days until cells were completely confluent. TEER was measured using an EVOM 2 device (World Precision Instruments).
Organoids in identically plated wells of a 24-well plate were treated with increasing concentrations of gentamicin (0.05–15 mM) and cisplatin (0.015–5 mM) for 36–48 h, fixed, and processed for immunofluorescence with KIM-1 antibodies AKG7 (Bonventre laboratory, undiluted hybridoma supernatant) or 1400 (Biogen, 1:100 dilution). Immunofluorescence for KIM-1 was observed at moderate, sub-toxic doses which did not induce gross tubular disintegration.
Sixteen hours after plating, hPSCs were transfected with Dharmacon Smartpool siRNAs directed against PODXL (Fisher M-010617-01-0005), OCT4 (M-19591-03-0005), PKD2 (M-006288-01-0005) or scrambled control (D-001206-13-20) in mTeSR1 without antibiotics. Ten hours later, the media was changed and the cells were either cultured in 2D or sandwiched for 3D culture.
Constructs encoding green fluorescent protein-tagged Cas9 (Addgene 44719) and a guide RNA (Addgene 64711) targeting the second exon of PODXL (5′-GCTACACCTTCACAAGCCCGGGG-3′), the first exon of PKD2 (5′-GCGTGGAGCCGCGATAACCCCGG-3′), or the thirty-sixth exon of PKD1 (5′-GTGGGTGCGAGCTTCCCCCCGGG-3′) were transiently transfected into H9 hESCs, and green fluorescent protein-expressing cells were isolated by flow cytometric sorting, clonally expanded and screened for clones with biallelic loss-of-function indels. Approximately 200,000 sorted hESCs were plated per well of a 6-well plate in hESC-conditioned mTeSR1 plus Y27632. The media was replaced the following morning without Y27632 and cells were clonally expanded and the PODXL gRNA region was amplified by PCR. Chromatogram sequences were analysed manually and mutations were confirmed by immunoblot and immunofluorescence.
hPSCs plated in 2D or 3D were prepared side-by-side using the RNEasy Mini Kit (Qiagen). Samples were subjected to quality control analysis on an Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer to check for high integrity samples. Qualifying samples were then prepped using the TruSeq stranded mRNA library kit (Illumina). Sequencing was performed on an Illumina NextSeq500 75 × 75 paired end high output run. Samples were aligned to hg19 reference sequence using the TopHat2 splice junction mapper for RNA-Seq reads (http://ccb.jhu.edu/software/tophat/index.shtml) and differential expression calculated using the Cuffdiff program (http://cole-trapnell-lab.github.io/cufflinks/cuffdiff/).
RNA was prepared on days 2, 10, 14 and 21 after plating during the differentiation time course using the RNeasy Mini Kit (Qiagen). RNA from all time points was reverse transcribed side-by-side using the M-MLV Reverse Transcription System (Promega). Quantitative RT–PCR reactions were run in duplicate using cDNA (diluted 1:10), 300 nM primers16, and iQ SYBR Green Supermix (Bio-Rad) with the iQ5 Multi-Color Real-Time PCR Detection System (Bio-Rad), using β-actin as the housekeeping gene. Primer sequences are as follows: WT1 5′-GGGTACGAGAGCGATAACCA-3′, 5′-TCTCACCAGTGTGCTTCCTG-3′, SIX2 5′-CTGGAGAGCCACCAGTTCTC-3′, 5′-GCTGCGACTCTTTTCCTTGA-3′, LHX1 5′-ATCCTGGACCGCTTTCTCTT-3′, 5′-GTACCGAAACACCGGAAGAA-3′, OCT4 5′-CAGTGCCCGAAACCCACAC-3′, 5′-GGAGACCCAGCAGCCTCAAA-3′.
Quantification and Statistical Analysis
Quantification was performed to measure differences or similarities between separate cultures detectable by eye. Sample size was chosen based on the researchers’ qualitative assessment of the reproducibility and variability of each particular experiment (higher variability required greater sample size), and the nature of the data being quantified (whole experiment percentage versus metrics of individual structures). The experiments were not randomized. The investigators were not blinded to the conditions during the experiments or analysis. For all experiments, equal numbers of cells were plated. Experimental and control wells (for treatment), fields and samples (for imaging and quantification), and the order of cell lines in plate wells were chosen at random for each experiment. Processing was performed simultaneously and in parallel for all conditions within each experiment. For fluorescence intensity quantifications, images were taken in a single imaging session and at identical exposures and processed identically. The number of cavitated colonies (ellipsoid with lumen) versus flat colonies (non-ellipsoid or without a lumen) was scored manually in phase contrast images of living cells, in which lumens were discerned more easily than in fixed samples. To quantify intensities, line scans of equal length were drawn through randomly selected structures imaged with identical exposures to obtain raw fluorescence values in NIS Elements software (Nikon). The averaged line scan values were plotted with error bars. For CHIR-induced differentiation, ∼6,000 individual cells were identified in low-magnification immunofluorescence images using Cell Profiler 2.0 and fluorescence intensities were measured automatically. Statistical comparisons used a two-tailed t-test for two samples with unequal variance (heteroscedastic). Immunoblots were quantified using the ImageJ Gel Analyzer.
Accession codes: The RNA-seq data have been deposited in the NCBI BioSample database under accession codes SAMN04105275, SAMN04105276, SAMN04105277, SAMN04105278, SAMN04105279, SAMN04105280, SAMN04105281, SAMN04105282.
How to cite this article: Freedman, B. S. et al. Modelling kidney disease with CRISPR-mutant kidney organoids derived from human pluripotent epiblast spheroids. Nat. Commun. 6:8715 doi: 10.1038/ncomms9715 (2015).
We thank the Harvard PKD Center, Vishal Vaidya (Brigham and Women’s Hospital/Harvard School of Public Health), Niels Geijsen (Hubrecht Institute), George Daley (Boston Children’s Hospital), Jayaraj Rajagopal (Massachusetts General Hospital), Dennis Brown (Massachusetts General Hospital) and Oxana Ibraghimov-Beskrovnaya (Genzyme) for sharing cell lines, equipment and reagents; Suneet Agarwal (Boston Children’s Hospital), Jagesh Shah (Brigham and Women’s Hospital), Vicki Kelley (Brigham and Women’s Hospital), Friedhelm Hildebrandt (Boston Children’s Hospital), Wassim El-Jouni (Massachusetts General Hospital), Takaharu Ichimura (Brigham and Women’s Hospital), Jonathan Himmelfarb (University of Washington), Stuart Shankland (University of Washington), Ed Kelly (University of Washington), Chuck Murry (University of Washington), David Beier (Seattle Children’s Hospital) and other members of the Bonventre, Zhou and Lerou laboratories for helpful discussions. We thank the University of British Columbia Biomedical Research Centre Sequencing Core for RNA-Seq analysis. Studies were supported by the National Institutes of Health (DK092036, DK102826, DK864406, DK39773, DK072381, DK51050, DK099532, NCATS Loan Repayment Program), the Harvard Stem Cell Institute, Canadian Institutes for Health Research grant MOP-84545, Heart and Stroke Foundation of British Columbia, Yukon Grant in Aid, American Heart Association Fellow-to-Faculty Award, Grant-in-Aid for the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science for Research Abroad, and a National Kidney Foundation Young Investigator Grant.
Brightfield time lapse showing differentiation of spheroids into tubules. Scale bar, 100 µm.
Real-time time-lapse movie showing an epithelial cyst grown from PKD2 knockout hPSCs, subjected to vibration.
Time-lapse movie of cystogenesis from tubular cells. Days are labeled (d1 = day 19 of the culture).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/