Reduced near-infrared reflectance observed in September 1973 in Skylab images of the western flank of Mt. Etna has been interpreted as an eruption precursor of the January 1974 eruption. Until now, it has been unclear when this signal started, whether it was sustained and which process(es) could have caused it. By analyzing tree-ring width time-series, we show that the reduced near-infrared precursory signal cannot be linked to a reduction in annual tree growth in the area. However, comparing the tree-ring width time-series with both remote sensing observations and volcano-seismic activity enables us to discuss the starting date of the pre-eruptive period of the 1974 eruption.
Early detection of precursors to volcanic eruptions is important in reducing risks for populations and damage to infrastructures1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8. Once a volcanic eruption has started, thanks to modern techniques, we are now able to describe both seismic activity1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 and surface deformation9,10,11,12 to constrain the origin of magma through gas changes13,14,15 and to understand how magma intrusions propagate16,17. Still, we know too little about how the magma moves under the surface during pre-eruptive periods (months to days before the magma reaches the surface). For instance, it is sometimes unclear if magma input from depths is steady18, or, for how long magma could be stored at shallow depths (and eventually degassed) without being detected by seismic and geodetic networks. If not recorded because of their unconventional or too tenuous appearance, precursors of volcanic activity are lost forever.
Following the studies dedicated to vegetation monitoring from space, we propose to use trees to monitor volcanic activity. Trees are likely not reacting directly to volcanic activity but as it has been proposed they may respond to associated environmental changes19,20,21,22 such as water table variation, gas emissions, atmospheric water vapor or sudden temperature changes. As tree growth largely depends on environmental conditions (i.e., on the local availability of water and nutrients, and temperature during the vegetation season) tree rings have been widely used in the environmental sciences as proxies to assess both local and regional past climate variations23,24,25 or photosynthesis rates26. As trees form one growth ring each year, tree-ring chronologies may be used as annually resolved, long-term records of past eruptive events. Recently, it has been shown that pre-eruptive volcanic activity occurring during the vegetation period can influence the photosynthesis of trees, as shown by Normalized Difference in Vegetation Index (NDVI) derived from satellite imagery months before the beginning of the 2002–2003 eruption of Mt. Etna and the 2002 eruption of Mt. Niyragongo20. These observations were not the first satellite observables of this kind. Before the time of modern remote sensing sensors, a reduced near-infrared (NIR) signal was detected in September 1973 in the area of Monte de Fiore (Fig. 1) prior to the 1974 Mt. Etna eruption27. In this case, the start and duration of the NIR signal could not be determined nor was the cause of the signal identified as the eruptive activity started months later. In order to test whether trees were impacted by volcanic activity and with the aim of better understanding the dynamics of the early stages of the 1974 eruptive event, we built ring-width time-series of trees located near Monte de Fiore.
The 1974 eruption is key in the recent eruptive history of Mt. Etna when investigating how the magma feeding systems works. The eruption of January–March 1974 represents a petrological transition between two eruptive periods during which different types of magma were emitted: a phenocryst-charged basalt type, which was observed coming from the central vent until 1974, and a more glassy basalt type, free of plagioclase that has been observed in many occasions since 197428,29 and at least until the 2001–2003 flank eruption30. According to Rittman’s classification31, the 1974 eruption was either eccentric32, eccentric with deep origin30,33 or lateral30,34. Because of the lack of phenocrystals in the emitted basalts33, it has been proposed that the magma quickly ascended33 from a source located 11 km below ground30, corresponding to the depth at which the Mt. Etna magma chamber has been constrained12,35,36.
The 1974 eruption (30 January 1974–March 1974) was preceded (~10 days) and accompanied by one of the greatest seismic crisis ever observed on Mt. Etna34,37 with up to 150 events per day detected at the Mt. Vetore station (20 events per day at the Catania station; Fig. 2 and Material and Methods section). For reference, during the 1971 crisis, the daily seismic rate did not exceed 10 events per day at the Catania station38. The occurrence of seismic crisis before an eruptive period is not surprising. It is well known that seismic activity precedes volcanic activity39,40,41,42,43, also on Mt. Etna3,37,40,44,45,46,47 and afterwards is often associated with magma intrusions. Before the onset of the January 1974 eruption, Mt. Etna was already seismically active. In the summer-autumn 1973, a seismic event triggered the deployment of a seismic network on Mt. Etna48. Unfortunately, due to technical issues, the locations of the October events, could not be determined with certainty. The temporal coincidence of the October 1973 seismic crisis with both renewed activity at the Voragine and the NIR signal, raises the question of the presence of an early intrusion into the western flank in the vicinity of Monte de Fiore.
In this study, we (i) evaluate whether the ring-width time series of Monte de Fiore trees changed before and after the eruption, (ii) assess whether the NIR signal detected27 can be associated with tree-ring growth changes, and (iii) discuss our findings in the context of geophysical observations made between September 1973 and March 1974.
We sampled two groups of trees: MFs, south of the southernmost 1974 lava flow, and MFn, in the north close to the Monte de Fiore craters (1737 m a.s.l.). All trees were growing in the area where the NIR signal disturbance was observed27 (see the red contour line in Fig. 1). In total, we collected 52 cores from 26 trees (Pinus nigra J. F. Arnold) growing in the area close to the 1974 eruption at Monte de Fiore (MF). MFn trees are located very close to the 1974 eruptive craters and include 10 trees, whereas the 16 trees of MFs are farther away along the lava flow that originated from Monte de Fiore (Fig. 1). Since the trees were located close (<1 km) to the Monte de Fiore craters, their growth was probably disturbed by projectiles, lava-flow heat49 and fires during the 1974 eruption. We expected MFn trees to be more disturbed than the MFs trees as they were closer to the 1974 vents. In order to establish the growth of an undisturbed control group, we sampled the cores of 50 control trees of the same species, located on the north-eastern flank of Mt. Etna 13 km away close to Piano Provenzana (control group) at an elevation of approximately 1700 m a.s.l. The growth of these trees was probably not disturbed by volcanic activity during the 1970s and 1980s because there was little eruptive activity during this period along the North-East rift.
Most of the trees in MFn germinated in the 1950s and are younger than trees in MFs, which mostly germinated between 1910–1920 (Supplementary Fig. S1). The similar tree ages in each of the two groups suggest that the germination of the trees probably happened after disturbances such as wildfire or clear cutting.
Nine out of ten trees in MFn did not form any rings during two consecutive vegetation seasons (1974 and 1975; Fig. 3a), probably because of the heat radiating from the lava. Trees at other sites on Mt. Etna have also been found to lack tree rings close to lava flows49, and we explain these observations as only one hour of exposure to temperatures of 60 °C is able to decrease tree growth50. In contrast, trees in MFs located close to a lava flow but far away from the crater formed regular rings during 1974 and 1975 and seemingly were not affected by the heat emitted by the lava flow (Fig. 3b). Before comparing the tree-ring width of 1973 with the ring width of previous years, we need to correct for the age-related growth trend in trees. Only then will it be possible to discuss whether the observed reduction of photosynthesis was already sustained before September 1973.
Tree growth varies over the lifespan of a tree. Such ontogenetic variation strongly impacts the shape of the raw tree-ring width time-series, an effect also known as “age trend”51. For dendrochronological purposes, age trends are removed using standardizing methods depending on what growth information is needed52. In this study, we used a 30-year spline detrending where a “moving window” is used to standardize the raw data series51 together with a variance stabilization to obtain equally balanced chronologies which preserved the short-term variability52,53. In Fig. 4 the detrended ring-width data for trees in MFn (a), MFs (b), both parts of Monte de Fiore (c) and the control site (d) are shown. After detrending the low-frequency variability of the raw time series is eliminated but high-frequency variability, such as the reduced growth of MFn trees during 1974–1975, is preserved.
Tree-ring patterns are affected by changes in the forest stand structure that changes competition processes for resources such as water and light54,55. The tree-ring width patterns of the sampled trees might be affected by changes in the stand during the past decades, e.g., those induced by the death of trees. However, the ring-width patterns of our samples do not show any evidence of changes in competition, e.g., abrupt growth changes except for the growth release of MFn trees during the time after the 1974 eruption, most likely effects of reduced competition caused by burning of some trees After correction for the age trend, the erratic growth of MFn trees and the slow decrease in the growth of MFs trees after 1974 in the raw ring-width data are no longer visible (Fig. 4). Comparing the ring widths of 1973 and 1974–1975 with those of the preceding years 1968–1972 (Fig. 5) suggests that none of the trees showed disturbed growth during 1973, but the growth was strongly reduced or completely suppressed in MFn in 1974 and 1975. Thus, tree growth in this area was significantly impacted only after the eruption (t-test; p < 0.01).
Response to climate
The internal correlation coefficient (inter-correlation) for the Monte de Fiore series is 0.6 (Table 1), which suggests that all trees were growing synchronously. Furthermore, the patterns in tree growth in Monte de Fiore (MF) and Piano Provenzana (control; north-eastern rift zone; inter-correlation = 0.53) were similar. Over the last 100 years from 1915 to 2014, the correlation between MF and control age-detrended ring width was 0.5 (p < 0.001, Supplementary Fig. S2) despite the sites having different expositions and being approximately 13 km apart. This inter-group correlation suggests that tree growth in MF and at the control site during this period (Supplementary Fig. S2) was mostly influenced by common factors (i.e. weather, climate, nutrient availability, volcanic activity).
To quantify the impact of climate variations on tree growth, we used interpolated temperature and precipitation anomalies (1924–2004) from the CRU databank (Climatic Research Unit, University of East Anglia, Norwich, U.K.)56,57 and compared them to tree-growth patterns. Tree-growth at similar elevations on Mt. Etna was shown to be weakly influenced by climate variability58. We found that only variations in July precipitation significantly affected trees in MF (r < 0.23; p < 0.05). This effect, however, was weak. Climate had a stronger influence on the control chronology (Supplementary Fig. S3), with positive precipitation-ring width correlations during summer (0.22 < r < 0.35; p < 0.05), and temperature-ring width correlations in August (r = −0.4; p < 0.001) and March (r < 0.35; p < 0.01). The rather low correlations are supported by observations in Mediterranean area at similar elevations59. Temperature and precipitation thus do not seem to strongly affect tree growth at Monte de Fiore. No eruption precursory signals could be found in the tree-growth time-series (Fig. 5c and d). This suggests that the NIR signal observed from SKYLAB was either i) not sustained before September 1973 and therefore had no impact on tree growth, or ii) was sustained but occurred after the vegetation period.
Response to volcanic activity
Consequences of pre-eruptive volcanic activity on tree growth strongly vary with the nature of the processes in place. Volcanic activity has been associated with enhanced photosynthesis during pre-eruptive periods27. In other contexts, as in the Mammoth mountains in 1990s60 and possibly also in Pico del Nambroque, La Palma in 194961, pre-eruptive volcanic activity led to tree damage or even die-off. Similarly, the observed decrease in NIR reflectance on the western flank of Mt. Etna27 may have been caused by processes associated with the inception of the 1974 event. In September 1973 at the time of the SKYLAB observation62, the NDVI processing technique had not yet been developed63. Because only the NIR band was available, it is challenging to identify the nature of the process responsible for the detected signal. If the NDVI method had been used with both red and infrared bands, it would have been possible to distinguish between changes of vegetation canopy reflectance and ground temperature.
Growth analyses on trees growing at latitudes comparable to Mt. Etna have shown that tree growth stops after August even though photosynthesis may still be active64. Then, if precursory activity had changed the ecological settings around the trees during the growth period of 1973 (March–August 1973), associated signals would be visible in the ring-width time-series. The reduced NIR signal observed with SKYLAB in 1973 may have been caused by higher soil moisture65,66 due to degassing of large amounts of volatiles67,68 or a decrease in the photosynthetic activity in the area27,69,70. The 1973 ring widths do not differ statistically (t-test; p > 0.1) from those of the previous five years (1968–1972) as discussed earlier. If a change in volcanic activity affected tree growth in the area, it must have started at the end of, or after, August 1973. However, the end of the detected NIR signal cannot be constrained in time using tree-ring width analysis as trees are not reacting to environmental influences after the end of the growth season. Here seismic activity might help, as the seismic event of 1973 lasted until the end of October. This date might then be the end of the magma intrusion. At last, in the light of observations collected/comprised in this study, we suggest that the SKYLAB NIR anomalous signal may have been the result of an early dyke intrusion, initializing the 1974 eruptive event. Observed seismic34,37 and explosive (at central crater) activity during the months of September and October 197334 (see Material and Methods section) further support this hypothesis and may help dating the end of the intrusive episode.
In September 1973, a reduced NIR reflectivity was detected on the western flank of Mt. Etna27 at a location where four months later the 1974 eruption occurred. Seismicity, renewed activity at the central vent37,48 and remote sensing historical datasets suggest that magma was intruded into the western flank of the volcano months before the January 1974 eruption (Fig. 6). The NIR signal may have been caused by the soil moisture due to gas condensation near the surface, which reduced the NIR reflectance. Such a positive change of the ecological settings would have had a positive influence on tree growth if it had been sustained during the growth season. However, the analyses of the ring widths of tree samples collected in the Monte de Fiore area indicate that, if volcanic activity was indeed causing the anomalous NIR signal, the pre-eruptive period of the 1974 event started by the end of August 1973 at the earliest. This would imply that the duration of the pre-eruptive activity was of the order of a couple of months, which is well compatible with lengths of other pre-eruptive periods observed at Mt. Etna: 6 days in July 2011 before the start of the south flank event5, only weeks in in autumn 198571, in 198944,46 and in 19983, while on some occasions lasting months before the onset of eruptions3,37,40,44,45,46. Our study has shown that tree-growth histories can help dating the occurrence of early magma intrusions, and that analyzing tree rings can provide valuable information on pre-eruptive volcanic processes. We therefore encourage the use of such tree-ring analyses when reconstructing the processes involved in past volcanic events.
Materials and Methods
Tree ring width analysis
Trees were sampled at 1.3 m height using a 0.5 cm diameter corer 40 cm in length. To account for variability in individual tree growth, two cores were taken from opposite sides of each tree (180° from each other). Each core was glued on a wooden support and prepared by sanding the surface with decreasing grain-size sandpaper so that the tree-ring width could be dated and measured accurately.
We used a Leica Wild M32TM binocular microscope (25–50x magnification) connected to a LINTAB measuring device, coupled with a computer running TSAPwin (Time Series Analysis Program) software (RinnTech, Heidelberg, Germany), to measure the ring widths of our samples with a resolution of 0.01 mm. To assess the quality of the single measurements of the two cores extracted from each tree and to assure that no rings were missing, we crossdated the ring-width patterns of each tree sample-pair visually (TSAPwin) and statistically (COFECHA)72,73. On average, all series cover a period longer than 70 years (see chronology statistics in Table 1).
During the autumn of 1973, the west flank of Mt Etna was the place of an intense seismic activity. The analysis of the daily seismicity rates at the Mt. Vetore seismic station suggest that seismicity in September-October 1973 was either larger than the seismic activity of late January 1974 or the events were located closer to the seismic instrument. We favor the second hypothesis as the Catania station was detecting less activity in October than in January. During this short seismic survey (10.11–15.11.1973), it was determined that 1) the strongest signals were detected in the western quadrants (stations GVD, VTD, and DNZ and 2) the weakest ones were recorded between East and North directions (stations MSL, CVD, MAR and BVC). The source of the October-November period correspond well to the location of the western flank. The spatial analysis made there could not be supported by other permanent stations already installed at the time along the flanks of the volcano. At the start of the 1974 eruptive period, the seismic sensors located at Serra La Nave (37°41′30″N, 14°45′22.9″E)74 were not functioning since the 5th December 197344.
How to cite this article: Seiler, R. et al. Tree-ring width reveals the preparation of the 1974 Mt. Etna eruption. Sci. Rep. 7, 44019; doi: 10.1038/srep44019 (2017).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We greatly appreciated Sebastiano Cullotta (University of Palermo) helping with sampling tree cores on Mt. Etna and the support of our colleagues from the dendroecology and dendroclimatology groups at the Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape (WSL). We also wish to thank Vincenzo Crimi (Corpo Forestale, Bronte) for his help with logistics support during our fieldwork on Mt. Etna. We thank Prof. James Kirchner (ETH) for helping to improve this manuscript. The authors would like to thank two anonymous reviewers, Patrick Allard and Jean-Claude Tanguy for their helpful comments and Jorge Dubuc for his help with translating materials in Spanish language. This work was financially supported by the Swiss National Foundation (Project Grant 205321_143479). Unless indicated differently, all figures are created using the R program (R Core Team, 2014).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/