Hibernation and short daily torpor are states of energy conservation with reduced metabolism and body temperature. Both hibernation, also called multiday torpor, and daily torpor are common among mammals and occur in at least 11 orders. Within the primates, there is a peculiar situation, because to date torpor has been almost exclusively reported for Malagasy lemurs. The single exception is the African lesser bushbaby, which is capable of daily torpor, but uses it only under extremely adverse conditions. For true hibernation, the geographical restriction was absolute. No primate outside of Madagascar was previously known to hibernate. Since hibernation is commonly viewed as an ancient, plesiomorphic trait, theoretically this could mean that hibernation as an overwintering strategy was lost in all other primates in mainland Africa, Asia, and the Americas. However, we hypothesized that a good candidate species for the use of hibernation, outside of Madagascar should be the pygmy slow loris (Nycticebus pygmaeus), a small primate inhabiting tropical forests. Here, we show that pygmy slow lorises exposed to natural climatic conditions in northern Vietnam during winter indeed undergo torpor lasting up to 63 h, that is, hibernation. Thus, hibernation has been retained in at least one primate outside of Madagascar.
Over the past decades, it has become clear that heterothermia and hypometabolism in endotherms, i.e., torpor and hibernation, are not restricted to temperate or arctic conditions. Lemurs, rodents, bats, marsupials, and monotremes use torpor in subtropical or tropical habitats, which can be quite seasonal and energy demanding1,2,3,4,5. It seemed unlikely therefore, that the unusual situation among primates, in which true hibernation seemed to be restricted to Malagasy lemurs, should actually reflect the complete absence of primate hibernators in other parts of the world. We hypothesized that any non-Malagasy primate using torpor should be found in a habitat with clear seasonal changes in temperature and/or precipitation as well as seasonally changing food availability. Further, we predicted that such a primate would be relatively small, because hibernation in bears and other large carnivores is the rare exception, whereas the vast majority of hibernators have body masses <3.5 kg (median 70 g6). Finally, we expected that this putative primate hibernator would probably belong to the suborder Strepsirrhini, which also includes all Malagasy lemurs that exhibit torpor5 as well as the galagos, such as the African lesser bushbaby (Galago moholi), which uses daily torpor as an emergency response7.
All three of these criteria apply to pygmy slow lorises, which are small strepsirrhine primates inhabiting forests in Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos and China with mostly quite seasonal environments. In northern Vietnam, for example, the climate is profoundly seasonal with wet warm summers and cool dry winters during which ambient temperature (Ta) reaches 5 °C8. Given their relatively small body size (~400 g) and associated high rates of heat loss, low winter temperatures can be expected to create high energetic costs for thermoregulation in pygmy slow lorises. However, during winter this omnivorous species also faces a shortage of fresh vegetation and insects9. During this time of the year, normally nocturnally active pygmy slow lorises are known to remain entirely inactive for prolonged periods of time, which would be compatible with their use of torpor10. There are anecdotal reports of animals that appeared to be torpid, that is, stiff, unresponsive, and cool to the touch8,10, but this was not corroborated by any measurements of body temperature (Tb) or metabolism. Moreover, this species is known to exhibit an apparently endogenously controlled body mass gain of up to 50% towards winter, as is typically seen in fattening hibernators10. Thus, a variety of factors pointed to a possible occurrence of heterothermia in pygmy slow lorises, and its adaptive potential. To see if N. pygmaeus in fact displays any form of torpor we continuously measured core body temperatures using intraperitoneally implanted data loggers over fall, winter, and subsequent spring. The animals were kept in large outdoor enclosures, which allowed for both recapture and veterinary surveillance, but were exposed to natural climatic conditions in northern Vietnam.
All animals monitored over winter showed bouts of torpor, with the first bout occurring during a cold spell in late October and the last one in early April (Fig. 1). Torpor was most frequent in midwinter (mid December – mid February; Fig. 1). During this period the animals exhibited multiday torpor, i.e., hibernation, interspersed with several days of euthermia and/or short torpor episodes (Fig. 2). On euthermic days between torpor bouts, all animals fed on the food provided in the enclosures.
Mean overall torpor bout duration was 15.0 ± 1.8 h (n = 91). Bouts of multiday torpor lasted on average 43.0 ± 3.0 h (n = 20; range: 25.9–62.6 h). The mean minimum Tb reached during torpor was 22.6 ± 0.6 °C (n = 91; range: 11.0–29.9 °C). Minimum Tbs were similar in all animals, i.e., 12.0 °C, 11.0 °C, 11.0 °C and occurred at Tas of 6.5 °C, 6.0 °C, and 8.0 °C, respectively. Times of torpor entrances were not uniformly distributed (Rayleigh’s test P < 0.001) but predominantly occurred in the early morning (mean: 05:19 ± 0.21 h). Times of arousals also significantly clustered around a mean of 14:06 ± 0.19 h (Rayleigh’s test P < 0.001).
Lorises were more prone to enter torpor on cold days. The probability to undergo torpor significantly increased as mean Ta (computed over 24 h prior to noon of the day of torpor entry) decreased (binomial model; z = −11.1, P < 0.001). Further, mean daily Tb was positively associated with Ta both on days with torpor (daily minimum Tb < 30 °C) and on euthermic days (Fig. 3.). On days with torpor mean daily Tb, as an integrative measure of both depth and duration of torpor, significantly decreased with mean daily Ta (Tb = 13.1 + 0.11*Ta; R2 = 0.36; P < 0.001). During euthermic days, mean Tb obtained from all 5 animals investigated also was a linear function of mean Ta (Tb = 33.7 + 0.07*Ta; R2 = 0.44; P < 0.001). Interestingly, this was also the case for maximum daily Tb (Tb = 35.29 + 0.056*Ta; R2 = 0.36; P < 0.001; data not shown on graph).
We were able to obtain Tb records from a total of five animals, including three animals recorded during winter. Despite this limited number of individuals, our results leave no doubt that N. pygmaeus has the capability to hibernate, as all animals (of both sexes) monitored during winter did undergo bouts of multiday torpor (Fig. 2). Hibernation is defined by the occurrence of torpor bouts that last longer than 24 hours (e.g.11,12), which clearly is the case in pygmy slow lorises. This definition of hibernation is justified because, whilst several hibernators may also exhibit short torpor bouts lasting only several hours, the opposite is not the case: Many mammals may undergo daily torpor but are incapable to exhibit multiday torpor, which requires releasing metabolism and Tb from the strict control by the circadian pacemaker (review in6). Daily torpor seems to be a mere amplification of daily rhythms in metabolism and Tb, whereas hibernation requires switching to an alternative clock mechanism that allows staying torpid over multiple days6,13,14. Therefore, there is a growing consensus that daily torpor represents the more ancient trait, whereas prolonged hibernation is viewed as an advanced, secondary adaptation6,14,15,16. Apparently, this evolutionary step has occurred in N. pygmaeus and it would not be surprising if future studies reveal that hibernation occurs in further primates outside Madagascar, especially within the Lorisidae.
We have several reasons to think that spontaneous torpor and hibernation during episodes of low Ta, as observed here, are natural responses in N. pygmaeus, and were not caused by our keeping the animals in outdoor enclosures. The animals in our study were well acclimated to living in enclosures. Also, even though torpor may be induced by shortage of food, the experimental animals were continually offered and in fact consumed a broad spectrum of food items throughout our study. Thus there is no indication that lorises were food restricted or nutritionally stressed. Further, there is accumulating evidence that species that can be very reluctant to exhibit torpor in captivity regularly do so in the wild6. Therefore, if our housing conditions had any effect at all, we would expect that they might have lowered the use of torpor, compared with free-ranging animals. Finally, there have been anecdotal observations pointing to torpor in free-living pygmy slow lorises before8.
The highly variable pattern of multiday torpor of lorises, interspersed with several days of euthermia and short torpor bouts (Fig. 2), seems to be quite typical for tropical species that show torpor at relatively high Ta4,17. However, when provided with food during winter even north-temperate hibernators, such as the garden dormouse, can show very similar patterns and may remain active for several days between torpor episodes18. The fact that the use of torpor in pygmy slow lorises was apparently limited to cooler periods suggests that heterothermia was employed opportunistically and restricted to environmental conditions that would have required large energy expenditure for thermoregulation. Also, none of the five animals showed torpor outside the winter season and hibernation was restricted to the coldest months (Figs 1, 2). These findings support the view that, while torpor results in enormous energy savings, it also involves risks and trade-offs19,20,21,22. In pygmy slow lorises, a particularly important risk of torpor may be increased susceptibility to predation. Although pygmy slow lorises move slowly and are unable to leap even when euthermic9, they will be entirely unable to escape predators in the torpid state. However, this handicap may be at least partially compensated by the fact that the animals are relatively well camouflaged9 and are motionless and hardly emit any odour while torpid, which makes them difficult to detect for predators23.
The benefits of torpor in terms of energy savings, on the other hand, are evident, even if metabolic rate was not measured in this study. Especially when Tb is lowered to values very close to Ta, as in pygmy slow lorises (Figs 2, 3), hibernation results in a reduction of energy expenditure to ~5% of the animals’ basal metabolic rate6. In pygmy slow lorises a drastic reduction of energy expenditure is apparently an adaptation to the seasonal change in food availability, in particular the low abundance of insects in winter. As indicated by the large seasonal change of body mass in this species10, which peaks in November/December (578 g ± 58 SD in males, 543 g ± 111 SD in females) and is lowest in March/April (367 g ± 26 SD in males, 360 g ± 25 SD in females)10, it seems that pygmy slow lorises largely rely on body energy stores during winter similar to other tropical hibernators24. However, as the animals in our study were offered food throughout the year, torpor and hibernation are most likely not directly triggered by changes in food availability. In other mammals, the seasonal occurrence of hibernation and daily torpor is controlled by an endogenous circannual clock or photoperiodic time measurement13,25,26, which may be also the case in N. pygmaeus.
One interesting aspect of hibernation in pygmy slow lorises, and other tropical hibernators4, is that they remain exposed to large daily fluctuations in Ta, whereas many ‘classical’ hibernators experience almost constant Ta in their underground burrows (e.g.,27). This factor, together with continued nocturnal foraging activity, has apparently led to a synchronization of torpor with the light-dark cycle. Pygmy slow lorises predominantly entered torpor during late night/early morning, when lowering the large Tb-Ta gradient is energetically most effective. Even more interestingly, return to euthermia (Tb > 30 °C) occurred typically in the early afternoon, that is, well prior to the onset of nocturnal activity9. We attribute this timing to the energetic advantage of synchronizing rewarming with the daily rise in Ta, which is quite obvious from the temperature traces in Fig. 2. It is well known that several other heterotherms make use of passive warming during rises in Ta and even use sun-basking to minimise the energetic costs of returning to euthermia28,29. During the cold season, pygmy slow lorises indeed move to sunny spots during their daytime resting phase, whereas during hot periods they only change sleeping sites when disturbed (U.S. unpublished observations).
In addition to the use of torpor and hibernation, pygmy slow lorises also reduced energy requirements by significantly lowering both mean and maximum daily Tb, even in the euthermic state, as Ta declined (Fig. 3). Within a smaller range of Tas this linear decrease of Tb in N. pygmaeus has been observed before30. The degree of down-regulation of Tb (~1.5 °C over a 20 °C Ta range) even during the daily active phase is unusual for primates31,32,33 but interestingly has also been observed in the closely related slow loris, Nyctycebus coucang34. Whether the pronounced seasonal change of pelage in lorises9 also plays a role for thermoregulation is currently unknown. However, it seems that pygmy slow lorises employ an entire arsenal of mechanisms to minimise energy expenditure during winter, ranging from reduced activity9, over lowered euthermic Tb, to torpor and hibernation. It would be interesting to see if these physiological responses are even more pronounced in entirely free-living animals that have to rely on natural food resources only.
In summary, this study shows that hibernation in primates is not restricted to species inhabiting Madagascar. Thus, there are no specific climatic conditions or evolutionary histories that have limited the occurrence of primate hibernation to this island. This finding opens the door for the search for hibernation in further primates living in seasonal habitats.
Material and Methods
Animals and study site
The study was carried out between August 2010 and May 2011 at the Endangered Primate Rescue Center (EPRC), Cúc Phương, Ninh Bình, Vietnam (20°14′N , 105°44′E) using 6 adult pygmy slow loris (4 non-pregnant females, 2 males; body mass 240–420 g). The animals had been confiscated by Vietnamese authorities from illegal wildlife traders, and were kept at EPRC in outdoor enclosures for at least 3 months prior to the experiments. All experiments were carried out in accordance with the guidelines on “Use if Animals in Research and Education” of the World Organization on Animal Health (OIE), of which Vietnam is a member. All experimental protocols were approved by the Vietnamese Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Decision 59/QD-BNN-KL (dated 09.09.2009). All experimental procedures were also reported to the Ethics Committee of the University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna, Austria. Animals were housed individually in outdoor enclosures (size 3 m*1.5 m*2 m) with open soil, natural vegetation of a tropical evergreen forest and a furnishing of bamboo and branches. Sleeping boxes were provided as shelters. The animals were fed the same mixture of boiled eggs, fruits and vegetables (bananas, pineapples, dragonfruit, papaya, apples, pears, oranges, grapes and carrots) throughout the year. In addition, stick insects, grasshoppers and crickets were fed daily (except for periods of rainy weather of up to three days) additionally between May and October, when these insects were abundant, but not during winter, when arthropods are virtually absent in this habitat8. In addition, the natural vegetation and natural soil in the enclosures allowed for a certain degree of independent capture of insects. The animals had permanent access to water. Air temperature at the site was measured at hourly intervals using a data logger (EL-USB2, Lascar Electronics, Salisbury, UK; accuracy ± 0.5 °C) placed inside one of the enclosures in the shade.
Body temperature measurements
Core Tb was measured at 6 min intervals using intraperitoneally implanted, custom-constructed programmable data loggers based on digitally readable temperature sensors (MCP 9800, Microchip Technology, Chandler, AZ, USA; resolution: 0.0625 °C storage capacity: 104 832 values; weight 6.5 g). Loggers were individually calibrated in a water bath prior to implantation and checked for accuracy after explantation. The maximum deviation between measured and actual temperature after explantation was <0.2 °C. Prior to implantation, loggers were coated with a paraffin/beeswax mixture and subsequently EtO-gas-sterilized (Anprolene AN74i, Andersen Products Inc., Haw River, NC, USA). However, apparently due to faults in the coating several of the loggers failed after implantation (but retained the stored data). Thus, we obtained records for the full study period (September-May) for 2 out of 6 implanted loggers only (one male, one female), as well as data for September to mid January for one female. For two more females, we retrieved records from autumn (September-October) over 45 and 80 days, respectively. One logger failed after a few days only, and these data were entirely omitted. All together, Tb was measured during 769 days in 5 animals (255, 250, 139, 80, and 45 days per animal).
Surgical anaesthesia was induced by intramuscular injection of 5 or 10 mg kg−1 ketamine (Ketamidor 10%; Richter Pharma, Wels, Austria) and 50 μg kg−1 medetomidine (Dormitor; Orion Parma, Espoo, Finland) and maintained with 0.2–1.5% isoflurane (IsoFlo; Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Il, USA) in an oxygen stream. The animals were placed in dorsal recumbency, the operation field was prepared according to standard surgical procedures and covered with sterile surgical drapes. The abdominal cavity was opened through a ~1.5 cm incision in the central midline. The logger was inserted free-floating. Postimplantation, peritoneum, abdominal muscles were sutured using synthetic absorbable surgical suture material USP 3/0 (Surgicryl PGA; SMIAG, Hunningen, Belgium) using a single-button suture technique. The skin was sutured separately using synthetic absorbable surgical suture material USP 3/0 (Surgicryl PGA; SMI AG) with an intracutaneous suture technique. During the entire procedure, vital parameters [respiration rate, peripheral haemoglobin oxygen saturation as measured by pulse oximetry (SpO2), heartrate] were monitored. Postsurgical analgesia (5 mg kg−1 Meloxicam (Kwizda Pharma, Vienna, Austria) subcutaneously) was provided.
Torpor was defined as Tb decreasing below 30 °C for at least 1 h. This slightly conservative definition was used because Tb was highly variable even at night in the absence of clear torpor episodes (Figs 1,2), and in order to identify events that were most likely energetically relevant. In the three animals measured in winter we observed 91 torpor episodes. As there were no notable differences in torpor characteristics among animals, summary statistics were computed from pooled data. Data are given as means ± SEM. To see if times of torpor entrance and arousal were uniformly distributed we used Rayleigh’s test as provided by the R-package “circular”35. For the relationships between mean daily Tb as well as maximum daily Tb and Ta on euthermic days we fitted linear mixed effects models, using animal-ID as a random factor to adjust for repeated measurements (R-package nlme)36. To test if Ta had an effect on the probability of animals to enter torpor we computed a variable torpor (yes/no) for each day (n). We then computed mean Ta for the period 12:00 h on day n−1 to 12:00 h on day n, and tested the effect of this mean Ta on the probability of torpor entry on day n using a mixed effects binomial model (R package lme4)37, again entering animal ID as the random effect. There was no indication for overdispersion in this model (dispersion parameter 1.08).
How to cite this article: Ruf, T. et al. Hibernation in the pygmy slow loris (Nycticebus pygmaeus): multiday torpor in primates is not restricted to Madagascar. Sci. Rep. 5, 17392; doi: 10.1038/srep17392 (2015).
We are grateful to the director of the Cúc Phương National Park, Mr. Truong Quang Bich, the management board of the National Park, and the Ministry for Agriculture und Rural Development for their support of this project. We thank Gerhard Fluch for constructing and calibrating the temperature loggers. We also thank Renate Hengsberger for her help with the literature search and formatting of the manuscript.