Introduction

Axially chiral structural motifs are commonly present in bioactive compounds, and they are also widely used as chiral ligands or catalysts in asymmetric catalysis1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8. Therefore, atroposelective synthesis of axially chiral molecules has become one of the most-investigated research areas in recent years9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16. As part of our ongoing research efforts, we recently became interested in atroposelectively constructing an axially chiral axis between a five-membered heterocycle and an aryl ring17, since these molecules are valuable, yet their asymmetric synthesis is inherently challenging and has not been well studied18,19. In this context, N-arylpyrrole skeletons are often found in natural products, chiral ligands, and catalysts20,21,22,23,24,25 (Fig. 1a), therefore, catalytic asymmetric synthetic methods to access this type of molecules would be of great significance and highly appealing. There are only a handful of reports describing catalytic asymmetric synthesis of N-arylpyrroles up to date. Utilizing catalytic asymmetric Paal−Knorr reaction, Tan and co-workers achieved highly atroposelective synthesis of arylpyrroles26. Through remote control, the same group constructed axially chiral N-arylpyrroles via a desymmetrization or kinetic resolution strategy27. Through a chiral-at-metal rhodium Lewis acid-catalyzed atroposelective electrophilic aromatic substitution, Houk, Meggers, and co-workers achieved atroposelective synthesis of axially chiral N-arylpyrroles28. Very recently, Szpilman et al. reported a copper- and chiral nitroxide-catalyzed kinetic resolution of axially chiral N-arylpyrroles29. Given the importance of N-arylpyrrole compounds, and the scarcity of methods for their atroposelective synthesis, we decided to devise an efficient asymmetric synthetic approach to access these molecules.

Fig. 1: Background and our working hypothesis.
figure 1

a Representative examples containing axially chiral N-arylpyrrole skeleton. b Atroposelective functionalization of activated arylalkynes. c Atroposelective cyclization of ynamides. d Our working hypothesis. Cyp cyclopentyl, Ms methanesulfonyl, CPA chiral phosphoric acid, dr diastereomeric ratio, ee enantiomeric excess.

In devising a catalytic atroposelective synthetic method to prepare N-arylpyrroles, we opted to make use of unactivated alkyne substrates, as alkynes are a family of pivotal and sustainable feedstocks for pharmaceutical and agrochemical industries30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39. When the asymmetric construction of axially chiral molecules is concerned, there are numerous examples that alkynyl substrates were synthetically manipulated for the creation of atropoisomers40. In 2004, Shibata and co-workers reported the first asymmetric synthesis of axially chiral compounds via an iridium-catalyzed [2 + 2 + 2] cycloaddition41. Subsequently, the construction of axial chirality from alkynes via transition metal catalysis has been extensively investigated42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53. On the other hand, the examples on organocatalytic atroposelective functionalization of alkynes are much less. In general, the alkynyl moieties in the substrates are subjected to two types of transformations; through a catalytic addition reaction to form axially chiral styrenes54,55,56,57,58,59 (Fig. 1b), or undergoing an annulation reaction to yield biaryl atropisomers60,61,62,63,64,65,66,67 (Fig. 1c). Apparently, the employment of alkynes as one of reaction partners for the construction of axial chirality would be more desirable, as simple and unactivated alkyne substrates are readily available, while the alkynyl substrates are not, and their preparation often requires extra synthetic steps. In our projected reaction of utilizing alkyne substrates for the creation of axial chirality, we envisioned that light-induced Paternò-Büchi [2 + 2] reaction68,69,70,71 between an alkyne and a quinone would generate the crucial spiro-oxetene intermediate (Int-A). Under phosphoric acid catalysis and in the presence of pyrrole substrates, the ring-opening of oxetane to form p-quinone methide (p-QM) intermediate72,73,74,75,76,77 and the subsequent nucleophilic addition with N-arylpyrroles are anticipated to deliver axially chiral N-arylpyrrole products (Fig. 1d). Herein, we report an asymmetric preparation of axially chiral N-arylpyrroles, via an atroposelective oxo-diarylation of unactivated alkynes enabled by light-induced phosphoric acid catalysis.

Results

Optimization of the reaction conditions

We initiated our investigation by running a three-component reaction involving alkyne 1a, benzoquinone 2a and N-arylpyrrole 3a in the presence of different chiral phosphoric acid (CPA) catalysts under 440 nm Kessil LEDs irradiation (Table 1). With the employment of CPAs 5a5e, the reaction proceeded smoothly, however, the enantioselectivities were poor (entries 1−5). When CPA 5f with a bulky triphenylsily group was used, the reaction virtually did not take place (entry 6). We were delighted to discover that the utilization of CPAs 5g & 5h led to dramatic improvement on the enantioselectivity of the reaction (entries 7 and 8). A solvent screening was then followed. Among different solvents examined, only dichloromethane and n-butyronitrile were comparable to acetonitrile (entries 9−12). We next lowered the reaction temperature to further enhance stereoselectivities of the reaction. When the reaction was performed in acetonitrile at −42 °C, 89% ee and 19:1 dr were obtained (entry 13). Since the melting point of acetonitrile is at −45 °C, we then used a mixture of acetonitrile and n-butyronitrile (melting point −112 °C) to run the reaction at lower temperatures. After some experimentations, we established the optimal reaction conditions; when the reaction was performed in a mixed solvent system (acetonitrile/n-butyronitrile = 5:1) at −50 °C, the desired product was obtained in 85% yield, with 20:1 dr and 92% ee (entry 15).

Table 1 Optimization of the reaction conditionsa

Substrate scope

The generality of the reaction was subsequently investigated (Fig. 2). The suitability of different alkynes was evaluated first (Fig. 2a). Alkynes bearing alkyl chains with the length ranging from one (methyl) to five (n-pentyl) were well tolerated, and regiospecific products with excellent diastereo- and enantioselectivities were obtained in good yields (4a4e). The alkyl moiety in the alkyne substrates possessing a benzyl or a phenylethyl group were also found to be suitable (4f4g). Interestingly, a free hydroxyl group in the alkyne was also found applicable (4h). Moreover, naphthyl alkynes also turned out to be good substrates (4i−4j). Both terminal and diaryl alkynes turned out to be suitable substrates (4k & 4l). However, no product was formed with the employment of dialkyl alkynes, likely due to the low activity of p-QM intermediate (4m). The benzoquinone substrates could also be varied (Fig. 2b), and consistent good results were attainable (4n−4q). Nonetheless, when 1,2-benzoquinone or 2,3-dichloro-5,6-dicyano-p-benzoquinone (DDQ) was used, no desired products were observed (4r & 4s).

Fig. 2: Reaction scope.
figure 2

Reaction conditions: 1a (0.2 mmol), 2a (0.1 mmol), 3a (0.1 mmol) and CPA 5 (5 mol%) in CH3CN/n-BuCN (v/v 5:1, 4.0 mL) under irradiation using 440 nm Kessil LEDs at −50 °C for 48 h under argon; isolated yields reported. a The scope of the alkyne substrates. b The scope of the benzoquinone substrates. c The scope of the N-arylpyrrole substrates. ee enantiomeric excess, ND not detected, n-BuCN n-Butyronitrile.

The generality of the reaction with regard to the N-arylpyrrole substrates was next studied (Fig. 2c). Various N-arylpyrroles with a mono-substituted phenyl ring possessing electronically and sterically diverse functional groups were evaluated, and consistent high yields, excellent diastereoselectivities, and very good enantioselectivities were attainable (4t, 4v4y). The reaction also worked for an N-naphthylpyrrole substrate (4u). Subsequently, the suitability of N-arylpyrroles bearing a disubstituted phenyl ring was examined. Regardless of the substitution patterns, i.e. ortho-, meta-, or para-, and electronic nature of the substituents, e.g. halogens, methyl/methoxyl, nitro, cyano or ester, the desired products were obtained in high yields, with excellent enantioselectivities and diastereoselectivities (4z4ak). It is noteworthy that when the N-arylpyrrole containing 2,6-disubstituted phenyl moiety was employed, the challenging axially chiral product bearing four substituents along the C−N axial bond, including a quaternary stereogenic center, was prepared in good yield, with good enantioselectivity and excellent diastereoselectivity (4al). Finally, N-naphthylpyrrole and N-arylpyrroles bearing a trisubstituted phenyl ring were suitable for the reaction, and the yields and stereoselectivities were well-maintained (4am and 4an). We also examined 2-aryl indole as a potential nucleophile, and the desired product was not detected (4ao). The absolute configurations of the products were assigned on the basis of the X-ray crystallographic analysis of 4w (see the Supplementary Information and Supplementary Tables S1S6).

Synthetic application

To showcase the practicability of our method, a scale-up experiment was performed, axially chiral 4a was prepared in 80% yield with 92% ee (Fig. 3a). We felt at the outset that the N-arylpyrroles being constructed herein may be used as a chiral ligand or a catalyst in asymmetric catalysis, we thus proceeded to synthesize a chiral phosphine (6a, 96% ee) from one of axially chiral products (4w) (Fig. 3b). Notably, 6a has a C−N axial chirality, as well as a central quaternary stereogenic center at the pyrrole 2-position. To our delight, 6a was found to be a good ligand in palladium-catalyzed allylic substitution reaction78,79, furnishing product 9a in excellent diastereo- and enantioselectivities. Furthermore, 6a also turned out to be an excellent chiral phosphine catalyst, promoting the [3 + 2] annulation80 between allenoate 10a and alkene 11a in a highly stereoselective manner (Fig. 3c).

Fig. 3: Scale-up experiment and the applications of chiral N-arylpyrroles.
figure 3

a Scale-up experiment. b Elaboration into a chiral phosphine. c Phosphine 6a as a chiral ligand or catalyst.

Discussion

Mechanistic studies

Preliminary mechanistic studies were performed (Fig. 4). The UV−vis spectra of alkyne 1a, benzoquinone 2a and N-arylpyrrole 3a were acquired, and only 2a showed strong absorption band at the visible light region with the maximum absorption peak at around 428 nm (Fig. 4a). The reaction between benzoquinone 2a and N-arylpyrrole 3a under CPA catalysis did not yield the corresponding product (4a’), indicating that there is no such background reaction (Fig. 4b). When two molar equivalences of alkyne 1a and benzoquinone 2a were irradiated using 440 nm Kessil LEDs, p-QM 13a was formed in 89% yield, the other regioisomer 13a’ and double addition product 13a” were not observed – these results are consistent with the regioselectivity observed in our reaction. The excellent regioselectivity observed in our reaction is likely attributed to two factors: the higher stability of the benzyl radical compared to the alkyl radical and the steric difference between an aryl group and an alkyl group (TS-1 vs. TS-2) (Fig. 4c). The UV−vis spectrum of 13a was acquired, revealing a strong absorption band at the visible light region with the maximum absorption peak at around 407 nm. When alkyne 1a and p-QM 13a were irradiated using 410 nm Kessil LEDs, the double addition product 13a” was not observed (Fig. 4d). If p-QM 13a was reacted with N-arylpyrrole 3a in the presence of CPA 5g, the same axially chiral product 4a was obtained in high yield with excellent dr and ee values (Fig. 4e), suggesting that p-QM may likely be the reaction intermediate during our one-pot, three-component catalytic process.

Fig. 4: Mechanistic studies.
figure 4

a UV–Vis spectra of the substrates and the catalyst. b The reaction of benzoquinone 2a with N-arylpyrrole 3a under CPA catalysis. c The reaction of alkyne 1a with benzoquinone 2a under visible light irradiation. d UV–Vis spectrum of 13a and the reaction of alkyne 1a with 13a under visible light irradiation. e CPA-catalyzed reaction of between 13a with N-arylpyrrole 3a.

In summary, we have developed a highly atroposelective synthesis of N-arylpyrroles through a one-pot, three-component oxo-diarylation reaction enabled by light-induced phosphoric acid catalysis. By directly employing unactivated alkynes as one of the substrates, a good range of arylpyrroles were prepared in good yields, with high distereo- and enantioselectivities. Notably, the products contain both C−N axial chirality and a nearby central quaternary stereogenic center, which were simultaneously created in a highly stereoselective manner. Moreover, facile structural elaboration of the N-arylpyrrole product led to the formation of a chiral ligand/an organic catalyst which have been shown to be very useful in asymmetric catalysis. By making use of readily available feedstocks i.e. unactivated alkynes and developing an efficient oxo-diarylation process, we are disclosing a new strategy for the construction of axially chiral N-arylpyrroles, which represent structural motifs that may be used as ligands/catalysts in asymmetric catalysis. We believe the method reported herein has a general implication for practical synthesis of novel axially chiral molecular architectures with potential applications in asymmetric catalysis and synthesis.

Methods

General procedure for asymmetric oxo-diarylation reaction

To a dried and argon-filled 10 mL screw-cap vial equipped with a magnetic stir bar were added alkyne 1 (0.2 mmol), benzoquinone 2a (0.1 mmol, 10.8 mg), N-arylpyrrole (0.1 mmol), CPA 5g (5 mmol%) and CH3CN/n-butyronitrile (v/v, 5:1, 4.0 mL). The mixture was then irradiated by 440 nm Kessil LEDs at −50 °C. The reaction mixture was concentrated under reduced pressure after 48 h and the residue was purified by column chromatography on silica gel to furnish the product.