Analysis of organic residues in pottery vessels has been successful in detecting a range of animal and plant products as indicators of food preparation and consumption in the past. However, the identification of plant remains, especially grain crops in pottery, has proved elusive. Extending the spectrum is highly desirable, not only to strengthen our understanding of the dispersal of crops from centres of domestication but also to determine modes of food processing, artefact function and the culinary significance of the crop. Here, we propose a new approach to identify millet in pottery vessels, a crop that spread throughout much of Eurasia during prehistory following its domestication, most likely in northern China. We report the successful identification of miliacin (olean-18-en-3β-ol methyl ether), a pentacyclic triterpene methyl ether that is enriched in grains of common/broomcorn millet (Panicum miliaceum), in Bronze Age pottery vessels from the Korean Peninsula and northern Europe. The presence of millet is supported by enriched carbon stable isotope values of bulk charred organic matter sampled from pottery vessel surfaces and extracted n-alkanoic acids, consistent with a C4 plant origin. These data represent the first identification of millet in archaeological ceramic vessels, providing a means to track the introduction, spread and consumption of this important crop.
Millet, a small-grained cereal with glumes of hard silica-rich tissue and a short growing season, was an important prehistoric crop that became established across Eurasia. However, the origins and dispersal of domesticated millet and the motivations for its incorporation into cropping regimes are far from clear. The most important species of millet cultivated in Eurasia are common or broomcorn millet (Panicum miliaceum) and foxtail millet (Setaria italica). By 6000 BC, based on charred grain assemblages, millets appear to have been cultivated across several northern Chinese cultures stretching some 1500 km along the Yellow River from the Xinglongwa Culture of the northeast in Manchuria, the Cishan Culture (Hebei Province), the Peiligang Cultures in northern Henan, the Houli Culture in northwest Shandong and in southeast Gangsu with the Dadiwan Culture1,2,3,4,5. Earlier dates for domestication at Cishan, based on starch grain and phytolith morphology6,7, have been questioned3,4. Where human remains are available, stable carbon isotope analysis of bone collagen has proved important in establishing the contribution of millet, a C4 plant, to diet in the period after domestication. The current isotope data show a mixed picture with millet appearing to range in the diet from a minor food component to a major food resource8.
From the presumed centre of origin in northern China, both millets are subsequently found over large areas of Eurasia, although the earliest finds are mostly of broomcorn millet4. Evidence from charred millet grain and stable isotope analysis of bone collagen from human and faunal remains has shown that broomcorn millet was established at Begash in Kazakhstan by the late third millennium BC9,10, in Eastern and Central Europe by ca. 1,500 cal BC11,12,13,14 and in northern Central Europe not before 1,200 cal BC15,16,17,18,19. Direct 14C dating of millet grains in Europe, considered to be found in much earlier contexts, has shown that they date to the second millennium BC or later20. In Europe, millet cultivation developed much later than the earliest agriculture at the onset of the Neolithic prompting debates that seek to answer the question ‘Why move starch into areas where starch was already available?’12,21,22.
The dispersal of millet may have been facilitated by mobile hunters, foragers and pastoralists occupying temporary or seasonal settlements since there are clear practical and logistical benefits due to its short growing season and ability to grow in marginal soils with low rainfall. In agrarian societies, millet may have been integrated into flexible crop regimes enabling an extended growing season and a consequent increase in food security8,19,21. In contrast Boivin and co-workers22 emphasize the social factors involved in the adoption of millet cultivation, noting that the perceived value of millet as an exotic crop may have been important in early exchange systems, well before the crop became established as a staple food. However, missing from this debate is any knowledge of how millet was prepared and consumed. This is essential to understand its perceived value and evolving role as a foodstuff.
Evidence from material culture has rarely been deployed in discussions involving the presence and role of specific crops, such as millets, in early societies. Impressions on pottery vessels, thought to be of millet grains, have occasionally been reported23. Molecular and isotopic analysis of organic residues associated with pottery containers has developed as a powerful tool for the direct identification of vessel use and insight into diverse cultural practices24. A range of plant products, including oils, resins and waxes has been recognised. Detecting residues of grain or seed crops in pottery vessels has proved more challenging. One exception is the presence of the C4 crop maize in vessels from North America utilising a combined lipid biomarker and compound-specific carbon isotope approach25,26. Other approaches have been explored in order to document the occurrence of millets in the archaeological record. The most promising is molecular analysis of soils and sediments demonstrating associations with millet cultivation in pit fills or sediment cores7,27,28,29; although this approach provides little evidence as to how the crop was processed or consumed.
Here, we propose a new approach for studying millet utilisation in the past, through its identification in direct association with archaeological pottery vessels using a combination of bulk isotope analysis, compound-specific carbon isotope analysis and identification of the pentacyclic triterpene methyl ether (PTME), miliacin. Miliacin is the principal (c. 99%) PTME in broomcorn millet (P. miliaceum) but is absent in many other commonly cultivated species or present in similar abundance to other PTMEs28. It is abundant in other Panicum species but occurs with high abundances of amyrin methyl ethers. Miliacin is absent in Setaria italica (foxtail millet) and is not ubiquitous in Pennisetum. The strength of this approach is that only a small number of the C4-grasses of the Panicoideae subfamily synthesize miliacin as their sole PTME28. The presence of high abundances of miliacin in sediment profiles indicating the locations of past millet cultivation has already been demonstrated27. In this study of Alpine lake sediments, P. miliaceum was deemed to be the only possible source of miliacin, given the context and since it was the only PTME detected. High abundances of miliacin have also been reported in Early Iron Age palaesols (eastern Ukraine) from pits comprising broomcorn millet crop processing waste29. In contrast, a study of pit fills from Neolithic Cishan, China identified miliacin in authentic samples of both P. miliaceum and S. italica and suggested differences between the two species based on the presence of other PTMEs in lower abundance7. The finding of miliacin in S. italica is not supported by investigations of authentic samples28.
Unlike previous studies we focus on the identification of millet in pottery using molecular and isotopic characterisation. Ceramic vessels are abundant on archaeological sites during the period of millet domestication and dispersal. Prehistoric Eurasian pottery has been studied by archaeologists for centuries and often benefits from well-established chronologies. This approach also provides a means of contextualizing millet within the spheres of culinary practice and artefact use, allowing further and more detailed insight into the cultural significance of the crop.
Ceramics from two prehistoric sites, one in East Asia and one in Europe, were selected for analysis in order to demonstrate the approach (Fig. 1). These sites were chosen as charred millet grains were identified amongst the botanical remains at both sites.
Bruszczewo, a settlement in Poland some 60 km south of Poznań (52°00′47″N, 16°35′07″E), has been subject to comprehensive investigations30,31,32,33. Situated on a spur and close to a lake, two main settlement periods each with several sub-phases can be distinguished: An Early Bronze Age phase (EBA, 2100–1650 cal BC) with fortification, houses and clear settlement activities, and after an apparent gap of several hundred years, occupation dated to the Late Bronze Age/Early Iron Age (LBA/EIA, 1100–800 cal BC). The excavations uncovered several EBA layers and houses preserved in a wet area below the spur at the shore of the lake that date to ca. 1800–1650 BC cal33. Constructed originally on dry ground at the lakeshore during the EBA, the water level rose in the Middle Bronze Age and preserved parts of the site under wet conditions34. Archaeobotanical analyses revealed a diachronic differentiation in the occurrence of broomcorn millet. Only single charred grains were recovered from the EBA contexts, but they are numerous in the LBA thus indicating its relevance as food crop in this phase. Furthermore, there are impressions of millet grain in some sherds, particularly on the interior surface of the lower portion of the vessel, perhaps to facilitate the drying process prior to firing. Sixty-one visible charred deposits or ‘foodcrusts’ adhering to pottery vessel surfaces were sampled. The samples include those from clearly defined and dated EBA and LBA/EIA contexts as well as a mixed transgression layer from the lake. This layer includes significant EBA material and very few younger finds; hence this group is identified as ‘mostly EBA’.
The Majeon-ri site (36°09′89″N, 127°08′37″E) is a settlement with a cemetery and paddy field system with wooden structures belonging to the Late Bronze Age and dated to 800–500 cal BC, located in the western region of the Korean peninsula35. Fifteen pottery sherds excavated from the irrigation ditch and puddle features at this site were selected for analysis. Unlike the pottery sherds from Bruszczewo, no charred surface deposits were observed.
Mobilisation and absorption of miliacin in pottery
To test whether miliacin is mobilised from millet during processing and absorbed into the ceramic matrix, an experiment was undertaken involving the prolonged cooking of four species of millet; broomcorn millet (Panicum miliaceum), finger millet (Eleusine coracana), barnyard millet (Echinochloa esculenta) and foxtail millet (Setaria italica) in replica ceramic vessels. The results performed on solvent extracts of powdered sherds from these vessels show that a low quantity of miliacin (290 ng g−1 ceramic) is transferred to the pottery vessel wall during cooking of P. miliaceum. No miliacin was detected in the three other millet varieties, confirming previous analysis made directly on the plants28. This study reports yields of 297–476 μg miliacin g−1 P. miliaceum grain following solvent extraction and column chromatography to isolate the neutral fraction28. Much lower levels of miliacin were found in the leaves, roots and stems of P. miliaceum and the compound was found to be absent in the hulls. It is therefore likely that only a small proportion of miliacin is released and transferred to the ceramic matrix during cooking of millet grain.
Bulk carbon and nitrogen isotope analysis of Bruszczewo charred surface deposits
The presence of charred surface deposits at Bruszczewo permitted the application of elemental analysis isotope ratio mass spectrometry (EA-IRMS) to determine bulk carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotope ratios. Figure 2 shows a marked change in carbon isotope ratios between the EBA (and ‘mostly EBA’) and LBA/EIA phases with indications in the latter of a wider range of foods including a possible C4 plant input (see also Table 1 and Supplementary Table 1). The EBA samples form a clustered group considered to represent C3 plants and animals consuming C3 plants, relatively depleted in 13C. In contrast the LBA/EIA samples plot over a much wider range of carbon isotope values with 45% of the samples having δ13C values greater than −20.0‰, consistent with the input of 13C-enriched C4 plants such as millet. Any input from marine foods is highly unlikely as a result of the distance from the coast, absence of marine fish bone in the faunal assemblage, the low δ15N values and the high C/N ratios. The difference in carbon isotope ratios between the EBA and LBA/EIA samples is significant (heteroscedastic two-tailed t-test, p = <0.05). The δ15N values are not significantly different. The low δ15N values and high C:N values in the majority of samples suggest the presence of low trophic level foods expected from the charring of plant tissues in the pots36.
In general, the LBA/EIA foodcrusts from Bruszczewo have lower δ13C values when compared with direct measurements on charred millet grains suggesting that mixtures of C3 and C4 resources were processed in some of the vessels. For example, bulk isotope data (δ13C = −12.5‰; δ15N = 4.7‰, Fig. 2) was obtained on a deposit comprising carbonized millet grains adhering to a potsherd from Ryugasaki A (Shiga Prefecture, Japan) and radiocarbon dated to 800–555 cal BC37. Bulk carbon isotope analysis of charred broomcorn and foxtail millet grain from archaeological sites in northern China gave mean values of −11.1 ± 0.5‰ (n = 26) and −10.5 ± 0.6‰ (n = 27) respectively38. Direct 14C dates (ca. 1500 BC to 500 AD) determined on charred P. miliaceum grains from central and southeastern Europe yielded δ13C values from −9.6 to −11.2‰20. Data from cooking experiments in pottery vessels show relatively minor (ca. 1‰) shifts in bulk isotope values of foods during cooking, including millet grain39 and this is consistent with heating experiments undertaken directly on cereal grains40. These data are helpful when evaluating bulk isotope data of ‘foodcrusts’ transformed by heating and suggest that changes due to cooking are unlikely to impact on the differences in carbon isotope values between C3 and C4 plants. Assessing the proportion of C3 and C4 (maize) foods incorporated into charred deposits has been attempted but cooking experiments and modelling of the data highlights caution in interpreting bulk carbon isotope data in this way41,42.
Molecular characterisation by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS)
Two of the ‘foodcrusts’ from Bruszczewo, one EBA and one LBA/EIA, were selected for GC-MS and GC-c-IRMS (Table 2). They were chosen to represent widely separated carbon isotope values (−26.0‰ for the EBA sample and −11.8‰ for the LBA/EIA sample). The GC-MS data are summarised in Table 3. Despite markedly different bulk carbon isotope ratios, the lipid composition of the samples is very similar. Both residues are characterized by a narrow range of n-alkanoic acids (C14:0 - C18:0) with a high C16:0 over C18:0 abundance. The presence of C16 and C18 ω-(o-alkylphenyl)alkanoic acids was detected in both samples. The C18 analogues are clearly visible in the total ion current (TIC) chromatogram of the LBA/EIA sample whereas in the EBA sample they were only detected in the extracted ion chromatograms (m/z 105 and 290). These ω-(o-alkylphenyl)alkanoic acids are thermal alteration products of unsaturated n-alkanoic acids43. The distribution of the C18 acids is consistent with those of authentic heated plant oils and not consistent with the profile given by a terrestrial animal fat and aquatic oil44. No trace of C20 and C22 analogues, commonly associated with the thermal alteration of longer-chain n-alkenoic acids in aquatic oils41, was detected. In summary, the lipid extracts are consistent with a plant origin but further differentiation is not possible. Epicuticular waxes, phytosterols and aquatic biomarkers are absent. Miliacin was detected by GC-MS operating in SIM mode in the LBA/EIA sample, suggesting the presence of broomcorn millet, but absent in the EBA sample.
Lipids were detected in all of the samples from Majeon-ri (n = 15). Separate solvent and acid/methanol extracts are dominated by saturated n-alkanoic acids (Supplementary Table S2). A range of other compounds were detected in the residues including n-alkanols, ketones and sterols/stanols. The presence of levoglucosan in MJR03 supports the cooking of plant tissues since this molecule is formed from the pyrolysis of starch and cellulose45. In addition, C18 ω-(o-alkylphenyl)alkanoic acids were detected in two samples, MJR06 and 08. Miliacin was identified in seven of the 15 sherds from Majeon-ri. In five of these cases, the molecule was identified in both acidified methanol and solvent extracts obtained on samples taken from the same sherd. In the remaining two sherds, miliacin was only identified in the acidified methanol extract, presumably due to the higher recovery of lipid using this extraction methodology. Figure 3a shows the presence of miliacin in extracts from sample (MJR10). The mass spectrum (Fig. 3d) is indicative of a pentacyclic triterpene methyl ether (M+ m/z 440; base peak m/z 189). The retention time of this peak matched an authentic sample of miliacin (Fig. 3c) as well as the peak corresponding to miliacin released experimentally by boiling broomcorn millet (Fig. 3b).
Compound-specific carbon isotope analysis of n-alkanoic acids by GC-combustion-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC-c-IRMS)
The most frequent compounds usually encountered in archaeological cooking vessels are n-alkanoic acids (fatty acids). However, C3 and C4 plants cannot be distinguished solely on their n-alkanoic acid distributions25. In view of this, the compound-specific carbon isotope compositions of the most abundant n-alkanoic acids in the lipid extracts were determined by GC-c-IRMS. Table 3 presents the data obtained on the two samples from Bruszczewo compared with the bulk carbon isotope data. As expected, the lipids are more depleted in 13C than the bulk samples, which may contain degraded proteins and carbohydrates relatively enriched in 13C. However, there is a marked difference in the offset between the bulk and compound-specific carbon isotope values (ΔBULK-CSIA) of the two samples. The magnitude of the offsets fall within the range determined from modern bulk and compound-specific carbon isotope data from C3 plants (i.e., 3–9‰) and C4 plants (i.e., 7–14‰) respectively46. These data, together with the lipid molecular information, suggest that the residues are dominated by a single foodstuff – a C3 and a C4 plant (millet) respectively.
Compound-specific carbon isotope analysis was also undertaken on seven lipid extracts from Majeon-ri where sufficient quantities of n-alkanoic acids were preserved (Supplementary Table 2). Miliacin had been identified by GC-MS in four of these samples. Three samples (MJR06, MJR09 and MJR10) contained n-alkanoic acids relatively enriched in 13C in keeping with the processing of C4 plants such as broomcorn and foxtail millet. However, miliacin was identified in only two of these, perhaps reflecting differential preservation or that another species of millet, such as foxtail millet, was predominantly processed in this vessel. Conversely, despite the presence of miliacin, two of the samples (MJR02, MJR08) have more mixed fatty acid δ13C values indicating a combination of C3 and C4 resources.
The presence of miliacin as the only PTME in the ceramic lipid extracts strongly suggests the presence of broomcorn millet processed in pottery vessels from the Korean and European Bronze Age. This represents the first molecular identification of this plant in archaeological pottery vessels opening up the potential for further research. At Bruszczewo, the high δ13C and low δ15N values of the visible surface deposits and the larger offset between the bulk and compound-specific carbon isotope values are consistent with C4 plant signals. The presence of charred deposits and thermally altered lipids also implies that millet was heated in the preparation of the foodstuff for consumption. The presence of millet in the LBA/EIA samples is supported by archaeobotanical evidence from the site. A few charred millet grains have been recovered from EBA layers, which could point to small-scale cultivation whereas abundant charred millet grains have been recovered in LBA/EIA contexts. However, caution is required given the possibility of movement of small grains through the soil column20. The archaeobotanical evidence suggests that millet became a widespread and important crop during the LBA/EIA of Eastern, South-eastern, Central and northern Central Europe14,15,16.
At Majeon-ri, the occurrence of miliacin in the majority of the sherds analysed (Supplementary Table 2) indicates that broomcorn millet was regularly processed in these vessels. It has been suggested that human diet in the Korean Bronze Age was largely based on C4 plants. For example, carbon isotopic analysis of human bone collagen from the contemporary Konam-ri site on the west coast of Korea produced values consistent with C4 plant consumption47. However, consumption of marine resources, also enriched in 13C, complicates this interpretation. Whilst the identification of millet in pottery does not allow dietary quantification, it does demonstrate that millet was directly consumed in Bronze Age Korea. Further insights into how millet was consumed are also provided by the analysis. For example, variability in δ13C values of alkanoic acids extracted from the vessels containing miliacin shows that millet was commonly mixed, or sequentially processed, with other food products. This may indicate it was not treated specially or, at least, afforded dedicated ceramic vessels for its preparation. The presence of thermally-altered plant derived compounds in the potsherds, such as C18 ω-(o-alkylphenyl)alkanoic acids and levoglucosan shows that millet was heated during its preparation. Millet is often used as gruels and porridge or ground into flour by contemporary societies11. Another potential role for millet is as a base for fermented beverages. For example, Boza is a slightly alcoholic (1.5%), sour drink made without any additional malt prepared by grinding the millet grains, mixing with water, cooking and fermentation48. Distinguishing a gruel or porridge from a cooked and fermented millet-based drink is not possible from the data presented here but further experimental work, consideration of vessel typologies and analysis of vessels from ethnographic contexts may help elucidate these practices in the past.
The identification of millet associated with pottery provides a new opportunity to examine the history of this important crop. Firstly, this approach has the advantage of identifying direct consumption of millet, a distinction that is not afforded by most archaeobotanical finds and particularly pertinent since millet is often considered to be an important fodder crop11. Secondly, the identification of millet in pottery provides unique information regarding its mode of preparation and consumption, which may be crucial for understanding the role and value of the crop when first introduced to a region21,22. Given that the wild ancestor of broomcorn millet has not yet been identified, pottery residue analysis could help to identify the first intensive use of this plant. Thirdly, the abundance of pottery already recovered from archaeological sites, and held in collections, provides an easily accessible resource for undertaking a wider survey of the introduction and spread of millet cultivation and the role it played in food processing and diet across Eurasia.
Production of experimental vessels
Experimental vessels (h. 30 cm, d. 28 cm, 7 mm thickness) were formed by coiling, and fired at a temperature of 1,000 °C using an electric kiln. These vessels were used to cook four varieties of millet; broomcorn millet (Panicum miliaceum), finger millet (Eleusine coracana), barnyard millet (Echinochloa esculenta) and foxtail millet (Setaria italica). The seeds were either purchased or collected in Japan. After filling the lower part of the pot with the seeds, water (ca. 900 ml), was added up to the inflection point below the rim. The pot was then placed on a fire made with broadleaf wood fuel until visible carbonised deposits had formed. The cooking continued for up to one hour. The temperature measured on the outer surface of the vessel often exceeded 300 °C. After the experiment the vessels were dried at room temperature. Then 1 g of ceramic was drilled from the ceramic interior at a depth between 2–5 mm.
Lipids were extracted and methylated simultaneously using acidified methanol49. Briefly, methanol was added to homogenized charred deposits (1 mL to 10–30 mg) and ceramic powders drilled (d. 2–5 mm) from the sherd surface (4 mL to 1 g). The mixture was ultrasonicated for 15 min, and then acidified with concentrated sulphuric acid (200 μL). The acidified suspension was heated in sealed tubes for 4 h at 70 °C and then allowed to cool. Lipids were then extracted with n-hexane (3 × 2 mL) and dried under a gentle stream of N2. 10 μg of internal standard (n-hexatriacontane) was added to each sample prior to analysis by GC-MS and GC-C-IRMS using standard conditions and protocols50,51. In addition, the sherds from Majeon-ri were subjected to conventional solvent extraction following established methods52 to compare the recovery of miliacin between acidified methanol and solvent extraction. Sherd powders (1 g) were extracted by ultrasonication into a mixture of DCM:MeOH (2/1 v/v, 3 × 2 mL) to obtain the extracts which were combined and dried under a gentle stream of N2, followed by silylation with N,O-bis(trimethylsilyl)trifluoroacetamide (BSTFA) with 1% trimethylchlorosilane (TMCS) at 70 °C for one hour, and dried again under N2. n-hexane was added to the derivatised samples prior to gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS).
Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS)
GC-MS was carried out on all samples using an Agilent 7890 A Series chromatograph attached to an Agilent 5975 C Inert XL mass-selective detector with a quadrupole mass analyser (Agilent technologies, Cheadle, Cheshire, UK). A splitless injector was used and maintained at 300 °C. The carrier gas used was helium, and inlet/column head-pressure was constant. The column (DB-5 ms) was coated with 5% phenyl-methylpolysiloxane column (30 m × 0.250 mm × 0.25 μm; J&W Scientific, Folsom, CA, USA). The oven temperature was set at 50 °C for 2 min, then raised by 10 °C min−1 until 325 °C was reached, where it was held for 15 min until the end of the run. The GC column was inserted directly into the ion source of the mass spectrometer. The ionisation energy of the mass spectrometer was 70 eV and spectra were obtained in scanning mode between m/z 50 and 800. The MS was also used in selected ion monitoring (SIM) mode with the oven temperature set at 50 °C for 1 min, then raised by 20 °C min−1 until 280 °C, then raised at 10 °C min−1 until reaching 325 °C, where it was held for 10 min until the end of the run. In SIM mode, a first group of ions (m/z 189, m/z 204, m/z 231, m/z 425, m/z 440) corresponding to miliacin fragmentation were monitored. After 16 min, a second group of ions (m/z 57, m/z 71, m/z 85, m/z 478, m/z 506) were monitored to record the internal standard.
Gas Chromatography-combustion-Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry (GC-c-IRMS)
In each extract, compound specific stable carbon isotope analyses (GC-c-IRMS) of methyl palmitate (C16:0) and methyl stearate (C18:0) were conducted according to previous methodologies53. An Isoprime 100 (Isoprime, Cheadle, UK) linked to a Hewlett Packard 7890B series gas chromatograph (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) with an Isoprime GC5 interface (Isoprime, Cheadle, UK) was used. All samples were diluted with hexane and subsequently 1 μL of each sample was injected into a DB-5MS ultra-inert fused-silica column. The temperature was set for 0.5 min at 50 °C, and raised by 10 °C min-1 until 300 °C was reached, and held for 10 min. The carrier gas was ultra-high purity grade helium with a flow rate of 3 mL min−1. The gases eluting from the chromatographic column were split into two streams. One of these was directed into an Agilent 5975C inert mass spectrometer detector (MSD), for sample identification and quantification, while the other was directed through the GC5 furnace held at 850 °C to oxidise all carbon species to CO2. A clear resolution and baseline separation of the analysed peaks was achieved. Eluted products were ionized in the mass spectrometer by electron impact. Ion intensities of m/z 44, 45, and 46 were monitored in order to automatically compute the 13C/12C ratio of each peak in the extracts. Computations were made with IonVantage and IonOS Softwares (Isoprime, Cheadle, UK) and were based on comparisons with a standard reference gas (CO2) of known isotopic composition that was repeatedly measured. The results from the analysis are reported in parts per mil (‰) relative to an international standard (V-PDB). Replicate measurements of each sample and a mixture of fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) with δ13C values traceable to international standards were used to determine instrument precision (±0.3‰) and accuracy (±0.5‰) standard deviation. Finally a standard mixture of C16:0 and C18:0 fatty acids of known isotopic composition processed in each batch under identical conditions was used to correct for the methylation of the carboxyl group that occurs during acid extraction.
Elemental Analysis Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometry
About 1 mg of crushed and homogenised charred deposit was weighed into tin capsules in duplicate. These were directly analysed by elemental analysis - isotope ratio mass spectrometry (EA-IRMS) to determine their bulk stable carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen isotope (δ15N) composition, as previously reported46. Samples yielding less than 1% N were not used and instrument precision on repeated measurements was ±0.2‰ (s.e.m.). δ13C, δ15N = [(Rsample/Rstandard−1)] × 1,000, where R = 13C/12C and 15N/14N. All sample measurements are expressed in per mil relative to the δ13C standard (Vienna PeeDee Belemnite, V-PDB) and the δ15N standard (air N2) respectively.
How to cite this article: Heron, C. et al. First molecular and isotopic evidence of millet processing in prehistoric pottery vessels. Sci. Rep. 6, 38767; doi: 10.1038/srep38767 (2016).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Crawford, G. W. Agricultural origins in North China pushed back to the Pleistocene–Holocene boundary. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106, 7271–7272 (2009).
Bettinger, R. L., Barton, L. & Morgan, C. The origins of food production in North China: a different kind of agricultural revolution. Evol. Anthropol. 19, 9–21 (2010).
Zhao, Z. New archaeobotanical data for the study of the origins of agriculture in China. Current Anthropology 52(S4), S295–S306 (2011).
Miller, N. F., Spengler, R. N. & Frachetti, M. Millet cultivation across Eurasia: origins, spread, and the influence of seasonal climate. The Holocene, doi: 10.1177/0959683616641742 (2016).
Crawford, G. W., Chen, X., Luan, F. & Wang, J. People and plant interaction at the Houli Culture Yuezhuang site in Shandong Province, China. The Holocene. 26, 1594–1604 (2016).
Lu, H. et al. Earliest domestication of common millet (Panicum miliaceum) in East Asia extended to 10,000 years ago. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106, 7367–7372 (2009).
Yang, X. et al. Early millet use in northern China. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109, 3726–3730 (2012).
Liu, X., Jones, M. K., Zhao, Z., Liu, G. & O’Connell, T. C. The earliest evidence of millet as a staple crop: new light on neolithic foodways in North China. Am. J. of Phys. Anth. 149, 283–290 (2012).
Frachetti, M. D., Spengler, R. S., Fritz, G. J. & Mar’yashev, A. N. Earliest evidence of broomcorn millet and wheat in the Central Eurasian Steppe region. Antiquity. 84, 993–1010 (2010).
Boivin, N. & Fuller, D. Q. Shell middens, ships and seeds: Exploring coastal subsistence, maritime trade and the dispersal of domesticates in and around the ancient Arabian Peninsula. Journal of World Prehistory. 22, 113–180 (2009).
Valamoti, S. M. Millet, the late comer: on the tracks of Panicum miliaceum in prehistoric Greece. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences. 8, 51–63 (2016).
Lightfoot, E., Liu, X. & Jones, M. K. Why move starchy cereals? A review of the isotopic evidence for prehistoric millet consumption across Eurasia. World Archaeol. 45, 574–623 (2013).
Tafuri, M. A., Craig, O. E. & Canci, A. Stable isotope evidence for the consumption of millet and other plants in Bronze Age Italy. Am. J. of Phys. Anth. 139, 146–153 (2009).
Stika, H.-P. & Heiss, A. In The Oxford Handbook of the European Bronze Age (eds Fokkens, H. & Harding, A. ) 348–369 (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2013).
Effenberger, H. Pflanzennutzung und Ausbreitungswege von Innovationen im Pflanzenbau der Nordischen Bronzezeit und angrenzender Regionen. Studien zur nordeuropäischen Bronzezeit, Wachholtz Verlag, Neumünster (in press, 2016).
Kirleis, W. Vegetationsgeschichtliche und archäobotanische Untersuchungen zur Landwirtschaft und Umwelt im Bereich der prähistorischen Siedlungen bei Rullstorf, Ldkr. Lüneburg. Probleme der Küstenforschung im südlichen Nordseegebiet. 28, 65–132 (2003).
Kirleis, W. Ein goldgelber Schatz: Der älteste Rispenhirsevorrat Niedersachsens. Archäologie in Niedersachsen. 7, 42–44 (2004).
Kneisel, J., Kirleis, W., Dal Corso, M. & Taylor, N. In Collapse or Continuity? Environment and Development of Bronze Age Human Landscapes. Proceedings of the International Workshop “Socio-Environmental Dynamics over the Last 12,000 Years: The Creation of Landscapes II (eds Kneisel, J., Kirleis, W., Dal Corso, M., Taylor, N. & Tiedtke, V. ) 267–279 (Universitätsforschungen zur prähistorischen Archäologie 205, Verlag Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, Bonn, 2012).
Kneisel, J., Dal Corso, M., Kirleis, W., Taylor, N. & Tiedtke, V. In The Third Food Revolution? Setting the Bronze Age Table: Common Trends in Economic and Subsistence Strategies in Bronze Age Europe. Proceedings of the International Workshop “Socio-Environmental Dynamics over the Last 12,000 Years: The Creation of Landscapes III (eds Kneisel, J., Kirleis, W., Dal Corso, M., Scholz, H., Taylor, N. & Tiedtke, V. ) 275–287 (Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, Bonn, 2015).
Motuzaite-Matuzeviciute, G., Staff, R. A., Hunt, H. V., Liu, X. & Jones, M. K. The early chronology of broomcorn millet (Panicum miliaceum) in Europe. Antiquity. 87, 1073–1085 (2013).
Jones, M., Hunt, H., Lightfoot, E., Lister, D., Liu, X. & Motuzaite-Matuzeviciute, G. Food globalization in prehistory. World Archaeology, 43, 665–675 (2011).
Boivin, N., Fuller, D. Q. & Crowther, A. Old World globalization and the Columbian exchange: comparison and contrast. World Archaeol. 44, 452–469 (2012).
Pashkevich, G. In Plants and Ancient Man: Studies in Palaeoethnobotany (eds van Zeist, W. & Casparie, W. A. ) 277–284 (A. A. Balkema, Boston, 1984).
Roffet-Salque, M., Dunne, J., Altoft, D., Casanova, E., Cramp, L., Smyth, J. et al. From the inside out: Upscaling organic residue analyses of archaeological ceramics. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. 10.1016/j.jasrep.2016.04.005 (2016).
Reber, E. A. & Evershed, R. P. How did Mississippians prepare maize? The application of compound-specific carbon isotope analysis to absorbed pottery residues from several Mississippi Valley sites. Archaeometry. 46, 19–33 (2004).
Reber, E. A. & Evershed, R. P. Identification of maize in absorbed organic residues: a cautionary tale. J. Archaeol. Sci. 31, 399–410 (2004).
Jacob, J. et al. Millet cultivation history in the French Alps as evidenced by a sedimentary molecule. J. of Archaeol. Sci. 35, 814–820 (2008).
Bossard, N. et al. Distribution of miliacin (olean-18-en-3β-ol methyl ether) and related compounds in broomcorn millet (Panicum miliaceum) and other reputed sources: Implications for the use of sedimentary miliacin as a tracer of millet. Org. Geochem. 63, 48–55 (2013).
Motuzaite-Matuzeviciute, G., Jacob, J., Telizhenko, S. & Jones, M. K. Miliacin in palaeosols from an Early Iron Age in Ukraine reveal in situ cultivation of broomcorn millet. Archaeologial and Anthropological Sciences. 1–8 (2013).
Czebreszuk, J. & Müller, J. Bruszczewo I. Ausgrabungen und Forschungen in einer prähistorischen Siedlungskammer Großpolens (VML, Poznań, 2004).
Müller, J., Czeberszuk, J. & Kneisel, J. Bruszczewo II. Ausgrabungen und Forschungen in einer prähistorischen Siedlungskammer Großpolens (Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, 2010).
Czebreszuk, J., Müller, J. & Kneisel, J. Bruszczewo III. The settlement and fortification in the mineral zone of the site (Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, Poznań, 2015).
Czebreszuk, J., Müller, J., Mateusz, J. & Kneisel, J. Bruszczewo IV. Natural resources and economic activities of the Bronze Age people (Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, Poznań, 2015).
Müller, J. & Kneisel, J. In Bruszczewo II. Ausgrabungen und Forschungen in einer prähistorischen Siedlungskammer Großpolens (eds Müller, J., Czebreszcuk, J. & Kneisel, J. ) 756–783 (Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, 2010).
Lee, H., Park, S.-H. & Lee, H.-J. The Majeon-ri Site -Loc. C. (Institute for Archaeological Resource, Korea University, 2004).
Heron, C. & Craig, O. E. Aquatic resources in foodcrusts: identification and implication. Radiocarbon. 57, 707–719 (2015).
Miyata, Y., Kojima, T., Matsutani, A., Onbe, S. & Nishimoto, T. Oldest common millet from western Japan: Carbonized material adhering to pottery from the Ryugasaki A site, Shiga prefecture. Bulletin National Museum Japanese History 137, 255–265 (2007).
An, C.-B. et al. Variability of the stable carbon isotope ratio in modern and archaeological millets: evidence from northern China. J. Archaeol. Sci. 53, 316–322 (2015).
Yoshida, K. et al. Dating and stable isotope analysis of charred residues on the Incipient Jomon pottery (Japan). Radiocarbon. 55, 1322–1333 (2013).
Fraser, R. A. et al. Assessing natural variation and the effects of charring, burial and pre-treatment on the stable carbon and nitrogen isotope values of archaeobotanical cereals and pulses. J. Archaeol. Sci. 40, 4754–4766 (2013).
Hart, J. P., Lovis, W. A., Schulenberg, J. K. & Urquhart, G. R. Paleodietary implications from stable carbon isotope analysis of experimental cooking residues. J. Archaeol. Sci. 34, 804–813 (2007).
Hart, J. P., Urquhart, G. R., Feranec, R. S. & Lovis, W. A. Non-linear relationship between bulk delta C-13 and percent maize in carbonized cooking residues and the potential of false-negatives in detecting maize. J. Archaeol. Sci. 36, 2206–2212 (2009).
Hansel, F. A., Copley, M. S., Madureira, L. A. S. & Evershed, R. P. Thermally produced ω-(o-alkylphenyl)alkanoic acids provide evidence for the processing of marine products in archaeological pottery vessels. Tetrahedron Lett. 45, 2999–3002 (2004).
Evershed, R. P., Copley, M. S., Dickson, L. & Hansel, F. A. Experimental evidence for the processing of marine animal products and other commodities containing polyunsaturated fatty acids in pottery vessels. Archaeometry. 50, 101–113 (2008).
Simoneit, B. R. T., Schauer, J. J., Nolte, C. G., Oros, D. R., Elias, V. O., Fraser, M. P., Rogge, W. F. & Cass, G. R. Levoglucosan, a tracer for cellulose in biomass burning and atmospheric particles. Atmos. Environ. 33, 173–82 (1999).
Ballentine, D. C., Macko, S. A. & Turekian, V. C. Variability of stable carbon isotopic compositions in individual fatty acids from combustion of C4 and C3 plants: implications for biomass burning. Chem. Geol. 152, 151–161 (1998).
An, D.-I. Dietary reconstruction by stable isotopic analysis: the Konam-ri shell midden in Korea. Journal of the Korean Ancient Historical Society. 54, 5–20 (2006).
Sõukand, R. et al. An ethnobotanical perspective on traditional fermented plant foods and beverages in Eastern Europe. J. Ethnopharmacol. 170, 284–296 (2015).
Correa-Ascencio, M. & Evershed, R. P. High throughput screening of organic residues in archaeological potsherds using direct acidified methanol extraction. Anal. Methods. 6, 1330–1340 (2014).
Copley, M. S. et al. Direct chemical evidence for widespread dairying in prehistoric Britain. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100, 1524–1529 (2003).
Craig, O. E. et al. Molecular and isotopic demonstration of the processing of aquatic products in Northern European Prehistoric Pottery. Archaeometry. 49, 135–152 (2007).
Evershed, R. P., Heron, C. & Goad, L. J. Analysis of organic residues of archaeological origin by high temperature gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. Analyst. 115, 1339–1342 (1990).
Craig, O. E., Allen, R. B., Thompson, A., Stevens, R. E., Steele, V. J. & Heron, C. Distinguishing wild ruminant lipids by gas chromatography/combustion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry. Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 26, 2359–2364 (2012).
Jacob, J., Disnar, J.- R. & Bardoux, G. Carbon isotope evidence for sedimentary miliacin as a tracer of Panicum miliaceum (broomcorn millet) in the sediments of Lake le Bourget (French Alps). Org. Geochem. 39, 1077–1080 (2008).
A sample of authentic miliacin was kindly provided by Jérémy Jacob (CNRS, Institut des Sciences de la Terre d’Orléans). Carl Heron wishes to thank the Alexander von Humboldt Stiftung for a Research Award during 2014–15 and the Wellcome Trust for an Engaging Science award to the British Museum in 2016. Shinya Shoda acknowledges the award of a Marie Curie International Incoming Fellowship (II7-624467). Part of this research has been supported by an award from the Arts and Humanities Research Council (AH/L0069X/1). The authors from Kiel and Poznań wish to thank the Polish and German Research Foundation. Their contribution was supported by the DFG/NCN project “Unetice North” (MU 1259/30-1; NCN DEC-2014/15/G/HS3/04720) and the DFG Collaborative Research Centre SFB 1266 “Scales of Transformations: Human-Environmental interaction in prehistoric and archaic societies”.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Heron, C., Shoda, S., Breu Barcons, A. et al. First molecular and isotopic evidence of millet processing in prehistoric pottery vessels. Sci Rep 6, 38767 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep38767
Preliminary results on content analysis of Early Bronze Age vessels from the site of Castelluccio, Noto, Sicily
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports (2020)
Pollen and lipid analysis of coprolites from Yuhuicun and Houtieying, China: Implications for human habitats and diets
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports (2020)
Evidence of increasing functional differentiation in pottery use among Late Holocene maritime foragers in northern Japan
Archaeological Research in Asia (2020)
Digging deeper - A new data mining workflow for improved processing and interpretation of high resolution GC-Q-TOF MS data in archaeological research
Scientific Reports (2020)
Broad-spectrum foodways in southern coastal Korea in the Holocene: Isotopic and archaeobotanical signatures in Neolithic shell middens
The Journal of Island and Coastal Archaeology (2020)