Abstract
Stretchable polymer semiconductors (PSCs) have seen great advancements alongside the development of soft electronics. But it remains a challenge to simultaneously achieve high charge carrier mobility and stretchability. Herein, we report the finding that stretchable PSC thin films (<100-nm-thick) with high stretchability tend to exhibit multi-modal energy dissipation mechanisms and have a large relative stretchability (rS) defined by the ratio of the entropic energy dissipation to the enthalpic energy dissipation under strain. They effectively recovered the original molecular ordering, as well as electrical performance, after strain was released. The highest rS value with a model polymer (P4) exhibited an average charge carrier mobility of 0.2 cm2Vā1sā1 under 100% biaxial strain, while PSCs with low rS values showed irreversible morphology changes and rapid degradation of electrical performance under strain. These results suggest rS can be used as a parameter to compare the reliability and reversibility of stretchable PSC thin films.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Polymer semiconductors (PSCs) have been developed for use in next-generation soft electronics (e.g., flexible, bendable, or stretchable devices)1,2. Both chemical design strategies and fabrication methods have been explored to enhance their electrical and mechanical performance. PSC thin films can now realize comparable and even superior electronic performance to that of amorphous silicon3. However, to truly harness the advantages of flexibility and stretchability of polymers, it is necessary to develop PSC thin films with good stretchability that maintain electrical performance under repeated cycles of strain. Such semiconducting thin films are essential in order to create mechanically robust electronics4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13.
Chemical and physical approaches, such as tuning rigidity of the polymer backbone14,15,16,17,18,19, inter-chain crosslinking20,21, incorporating energy dissipating dynamic crosslinking22, adding molecular additives23,24,25, polymer blending26,27,28,29, nanoconfinement30,31, side-chain modification18,20,32, block-copolymerization with flexible polymers33,34, and tailoring polymer molecular weights35,36,37 are reported as approaches for producing good mechanical properties under external strains. However, few of these approaches have achieved both high stretchability and good electrical properties under strain. In general, PSC thin films, typically less than 100ānm in thickness for field-effect transistors (FETs), possess various levels of conformational freedom from polymer backbones and side chains, which can result in complex processing-dependent morphologies with both crystalline and amorphous domains coexisting1,5. Both the ability to transport charges and to dissipate mechanical stress in semicrystalline polymer thin films depend on molecular conformation, packing structure, grain size, degree of crystallinity and connectivity between grains5. Under an external strain, the larger crystalline domains may fracture and reduce electrical performance, or the thin film may yield under strain and fail to relax back to its original dimensions. None of the above issues are desirable for practical robust soft electronics1,2,3,4,5.
A number of properties, such as elastic modulus, tensile strength, resilience, and fatigue life, are standard parameters used to characterize polymer bulk materials and thin films. However, there is a need for parameters to directly compare polymer semiconductor thin films used specifically for thin film transistor applications, which have thicknesses less than 100ānm and typically are supported by elastic substrates. Some of the above-mentioned parameters may be challenging to measure for ultrathin films. As a result, crack onset strain is among the most commonly used, due to the simplicity in measurement, to compare stretchability of polymer semiconductor thin films5,14. However, it is highly dependent on molecular and microstructural changes which impact changes in mechanical and electrical behavior of polymer semiconductors under repeated strain cycles. The morphology of PSC thin films is well-known to be dependent on processing conditions, film thickness, and molecular weight, in addition to the polymer chemical structure. However, crack onset strain does not always correlate well with observed degradation of polymer semiconductor thin film electrical performance behavior under strain.
Since molecular conformation and microcrystalline morphology changes are important mechanisms for energy dissipation under strain, we propose a new parameter, relative stretchability (rS) to compare the relative strain tolerance of various PSC thin films for transistor applications. rS is defined as the change of polymer chain alignment (i.e., dichroic ratio (DR)) over the change of relative degree of crystallinity (rDoC) as a function of strain, rSā=āĪDR/ĪrDoC. The degree of chain alignment under strain directly correlates with energy dissipated entropically through polymer conformation change and crystallite re-orientation assuming similar viscoelastic properties; while the change of rDoC (ĪrDoC) represents the amount of energy dissipated enthalpically through amorphization of crystallites assuming similar latent heat of fusion (taking into account that there may be crystal formation due to strain-induced crystallization). Therefore, rS presents the ratio of the entropic energy dissipation over the enthalpic energy dissipation. Note that strain-induced crystallization is a more common phenomenon for semicrystalline polymers25,38,39. Strain-induced changes in crystallinity in polymer semiconductors only became of interest recently and has not been extensively investigated. However, we have observed such a phenomenon in several polymer semiconductors we investigated previously and in our current systems5,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25. The observed overall change of rDoC on PSC thin films may be from a competition between strain-induced crystallization and strain-induced amorphization depending on the specific thin film crystalline domain fraction, size, and distribution as well as polymer backbone rigidity and level of local aggregation in the amorphous domains. Due to the high rigidity of conjugated structures, a higher stress is asserted on the crystalline regions during strain when compared to the more flexible non-conjugated polymers. In this report, diketopyrrolopyrrole (DPP)-based PSCs, P2TBDPP2TBFT4, with molecular weights from approximately 20ā100ākgāmolā1 (denoted P1āP4; Fig. 1a)40 are used as model compounds while data from reported polymers are used for additional comparisons. Our results show that rS provides a good comparison of the likelihood of various PSC thin films to maintain stable thin film transistor electrical performance under repeated strain cycles regardless of their chemical structures. This finding also suggests that similar underlying molecular mechanisms contribute to stretchability of PSC thin films used for FETs. A higher rS value was found to correlate to a stronger ability for thin film deformability and retention of electrical functionality under strain, which arises from the ease of molecular conformational and chain alignment, while resisting fracturing in the crystalline domain fracturing. Indeed, P4, a high molecular weight PSC, exhibited the above molecular behavior and a high rS. Correspondingly, P4 maintained a high FET mobility of 0.2ācm2V-1s-1 under 100% biaxial strain (i.e., 400% area expansion) without noticeable degradation compared to pristine films. Surprisingly, we observed that despite its rigid conjugated polymer backbone, P4 displayed reversible chain alignment along arbitrary strain directions, which is rare for PSCs and more common for classical rubbery elastic polymers41. This work provides important fundamental insights for development of mechanically robust stretchable polymer thin film electronics.
Results
Multi-modal energy dissipation mechanisms and relative stretchability
Achieving high thin film deformability without compromising electrical performance has been a long-standing challenge for PSCs. Previous work focused mainly on the effects of uniaxial strains1,2,3,4,5. A systematic correlation between morphological, mechanical, and electrical behaviors based on molecular organization needs to be developed, especially for stretchable PSCs that in application are likely to endure multi-directional deformation (Fig. 1a). Here, we uncover the type of PSC thin film morphology that enables stable performance under biaxial strain cycles (Fig. 1c). P2TBDPP2TBFT4-based PSCs with number-averaged molecular weights of 22 (P1), 50 (P2), 73 (P3), and 97 (P4) kg molā1 are studied (Fig. 1a). Above a critical molecular weight, these polymers showed a clear increase in the slope of solution viscosity as a function of molecular weight, suggesting the presence of topological entanglements, chain aggregation, or change in solubility (Supplementary Fig. S1), while the polymer thin films became more disordered37,42,43. The glass transition temperatures (Tg) of the conjugated backbone were only visible for bulk P3 and P4 films (>1āĀµm in thickness, Supplementary Fig. S2). This implies that P3 and P4 thin films are likely more disordered. Note that the Tg of sub-100-nm thin films (i.e., thin films for stretchable transistor devices), which usually requires specialized methods to measure, are known to differ from the bulk film properties44. Furthermore, the molecular packing orientations of the crystalline domains in P1āP4 films were characterized using grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction (GIXD) (Supplementary Fig. S3). P1 exhibited a strong edge-on packing preference, while P2āP4 had both edge-on and face-on packing orientations with the fraction of face-on crystallites significantly increasing with molecular weight. Furthermore, the charge transport behavior was affected by the different crystallite orientations (Table 1; Supplementary Fig. S4)43,45.
In addition to packing orientation, the rDoC is an important parameter that impacts the electronic and mechanical characteristics of stretchable PSC films. As is well established for other reported PSCs35,36,37, the rDoC usually drops progressively with increasing molecular weight (Supplementary Fig. S5), and the semicrystalline films became more disordered for higher molecular weight polymers. Comparing P1āP4, the rDoC value decreased by over 93%. Such a large change in crystallinity has been directly linked with thin film deformability. It was seen that the lower molecular weight P1 and P2 films were brittle and could easily form macro-cracks at less than 30% strain, while thin films (~50ānm) based on high molecular weight P4 can be stretched to over 100% strain without cracks (Supplementary Fig. S6 and 7). Consistent with the above observations, a P4 bulk film (approximately 1.5 to 2āĀµm) can be stretched to over 35% strain, while other PSC bulk films typically break below 20%46 (Supplementary Fig. S8). Moreover, the elastic moduli of P1āP4 films were measured in a range from 20 to 350āMPa (Supplementary Fig. S9), while lower moduli were observed for higher molecular weight films, again consistent with their much lower rDoC.
Although the above results show that molecular ordering and morphology of PSCs can directly impact thin film properties, none of these properties on their own can be used to determine whether a given PSC will exhibit stable and reversible electronic performance under strain1,3,4,42. Moreover, it is challenging to compare the promise of various reported intrinsically stretchable PSC thin films, typically less than 100ānm thick, for thin film transistors, owing to variations in characterization and sample preparation methods used. Therefore, a quantitative metric is needed to allow comparison of PSCās ability to maintain high electrical performance under strain, while taking into account their molecular and morphological characteristics.
Upon stretching, mechanical energy can be dissipated by one or more of the following mechanisms: (i) elastic or plastic deformation of the amorphous domains;47 (ii) molecular alignment or re-orientation of crystallites;48,49,50 (iii) amorphization of crystalline domains51 and (iv) ultimately bond breakage and crack formation. Having multiple possible modes of energy dissipation can potentially produce more stable electrical performance under repeated strain cycles. The change in rDoC and DR are two parameters that can be used to characterize changes in the film due to energy dissipation mechanisms (i)-(iii) during strain. Specifically, the change of rDoC represents whether there is amorphization of ordered domains under strain, while the DR reflects the ability of polymer chains (in both crystalline and amorphous domains) to be deformed and aligned along the strain direction (Fig. 1b)52. The details of DR and rDoC measurements will be described later. Interestingly, we found that the ratio between the change of polymer chain alignment measured by DR over the change of rDoC under strain correlated well with both the crack onset strain and reversibility of mechanical and electrical properties of the film (Fig. 1d). Therefore, we define this ratio as the relative stretchability (rS) to capture the contributions from both entropic energy dissipation and enthalpic energy dissipation on the ability of the polymer to tolerate strain. The rS is calculated as the slope of a linear fit of ĪDR as a function of ĪrDoC under 0, 50, and 100% strain. In the DPP-based polymer family, PDPPTVT and PDPPTVT-alkyl16 thin film are brittle with high modulus, showing a small rS of 0.38 and 0.45, respectively. P2TDPP2TFT415 and PDPPTVT-PDCA16 are both ductile and can be stretched up to uniaxial strain of 50% and 100% without cracks, giving rS of 2.04 and 2.65, respectively. In addition, other stretchable PSCs, such as indacenodithiopheneābenzothiadiazole (IDTBT)17 and isoindigo-bithiophene (PII2T-C8)18 have rS values of 2.17 and 1.83, respectively. Their rS values are consistent with the strain-dependent thin film properties across polymer structures. For the PSCs in this study, the rS values were calculated to be 1.19, 2.78, 4.16, and 11.5 for P1, P2, P3, and P4, respectively. In general, we found polymers with a higher rS tend to have improved electronic stability and mechanical durability under strain since more mechanical energy can be dissipated under strain through non-deleterious processes, such as chain alignment or crystal alignment (Fig. 1e). Note that values of crack onset strain may be affected by the sample preparation conditions, measuring conditions, and the calibration methods used. Moreover, rS values, in the range from 0.3~3, were calculated for other reported stretchable PSCs based on published data. These rS values correlated well with the trend of electrical properties under strain as reported in the literature (Fig. 1f, g)15,16,17,18. Therefore, rS provides a reasonable comparison of various designs of stretchable PSCs based on their morphological response to strain. Future work will be carried out to collect additional datasets to identify potential limitations and refinement of rS as a parameter for comparing the potential of polymeric materials for flexible and stretchable electronics. The polymer P4 utilized in this study, exhibited an rS as high as 11.5, which is approximately 4 times higher than previously reported stretchable PSCs, implying a much higher mechanical resilience. In addition, the rS values of not only neat PSCs, but other high-performance stretchable semiconducting polymer systems, such as terpolymers19 and polymer/additive blends25, have been analyzed (Fig. 1h). The terpolymer, DPP-8TVT, has an rS values of 7.1, which is higher than most of the reported neat PSCs because of multi-scale molecular ordering by randomizing the conjugated polymer backbone. Additionally, the normalized mobility under strain of DPP-8TVT FETs with a rS value between 5 and 10 followed the general trend of other neat PSCs with similar rS values (Supplementary Fig. S10), suggesting the performance of P4 is not an unexpected outlier. Interestingly, the stretchable polymer with a plasticizing additive (DPP/DOP-r) exhibited a negative rS value because of its strain-induced crystallization (increase of rDoC) under strain. With an absolute rS value larger than 3, these PSC thin films are all ductile and can be deformed uniaxially up to 100% strain without cracking, which is consistent with our observations of the neat PSCs described above. Surprisingly, P4 still showed the highest rS value, a result of the presence of multi-modal mechanical energy dissipation mechanisms under strain. Indeed, P4 thin films can maintain their electrical performance while being expanded 400% in area under a biaxial strain (Fig. 1b), which has never been achieved for any other neat PSC.
Characterizations of molecular ordering under an external strain
As noted above, molecular conformation and crystallinity play important roles in stretchability of PSCs. A 4-fold increase of rS value was seen for the same polymer chemical structure by simply changing the molecular weight. Grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction (GIXD) was utilized to characterize the evolution of overall molecular ordering (including rDoC, coherence length, and packing orientation) of the PSC films under strain. rDoC values under different strain levels were determined by integrating the intensity of the lamella diffraction peak, taken from 2D diffraction patterns collected with the PSC film rotated with respect to in-plane azimuthal angle Ļ from 0Ā° to 90Ā°, as illustrated in Fig. 2a53. The effect of applied strain on thin film crystallinity is depicted in Fig. 2b. The rDoC value for each polymer was normalized based on its DoC at 0% strain. In general, rDoC decreased as the polymer films were deformed, indicating amorphization of crystallites by tensile strain51. As mentioned earlier, strain-induced crystallization is a common phenomenon for many polymers25,38,39. Here, our polymer may also have strain-induced crystallization, but the observed overall change of rDoC is a combination of both strain-induced crystallization and strain-induced amorphization with the later process more dominant. The cause for the more dominant strain-induced amorphization in these conjugated polymers may be attributed to the high rigidity of their structures, which may assert a higher stress on the crystalline regions under strain compared to more flexible non-conjugated polymers. The rDoC dropped by ~40% under 50 (P1 film) and 100% (P2 film) strain, respectively, and crystallinity did not recover once strain was released. In addition, a drop in the lamella coherence length was observed in thin films of low molecular weight polymers (i.e., P2) under strain (Fig. 2c). The decrease of the coherence length (approximately 20% at 100% strain) was particularly apparent in the direction perpendicular to the strain, suggesting that ordered domains can also break due to compression orthogonally to the stretching direction. In comparison, films based on high molecular weight polymer (P4) showed nearly constant mean coherence length and a much smaller decrease (~10% under 100% strain) in rDoC under strain. Moreover, the rDoC recovered to ~95% of the initial value after strain was removed, which suggests that the crystalline domains can almost recovery reversibly. This reversibility is unexpected for PSCs due to their high rigidity. This behavior was observed for thermoplastic elastomers, such as poly(styrene-ethylene-butylene-styrene) (SEBS), where it has been found that the glassy polystyrene domains exhibit an affine deformation under strain and recover when strain is released41,54. In addition, the relative degree of aggregation (rDoA), extracted from the ratio of (0ā0) and (0ā1) peaks in UV-vis spectra, as a function of applied strain were evaluated (Supplementary Fig. S11) to take into account the behaviors of both longer and shorter range ordered polymer aggregates under deformation since rDoC only depicts long-range order. In contrast to the significant rDoC drop, only small rDoA changes were observed for low molecular weight polymers (i.e., P1 and P2) under strain. This may be due to the polymer films cracking at low strains and the subsequent energy dissipation occurring mainly through crack propagation. Conversely, the high molecular weight P3 and P4 showed less decay in rDoC but more decrease in rDoA because of the continuous film deformation. Additionally, higher values of DR under strain were observed for higher molecular weight P3 and P4. This is expected as there is a decreased fraction of crystalline domains with molecular weight and higher free volumes of polymer chains in the amorphous regions, both of which provide sufficient flexibility for the polymer chains to undergo conformational extension and alignment under an external strain (Supplementary Fig. S12). This appears reversible for P2āP4, suggesting there is sufficient entropic gain even for these rigid polymers to return to disordered states. Additionally, little degradation in electrical performance for P3 and P4 films under uniaxial strain was observed (Supplementary Figs. S13 and 14). Finally, PSCs with higher rS values exhibited more stable electrical performance under strain (Fig. 1f, g).
Although the strain-dependent rDoC values showed a good correlation between mechanical and electrical properties of semiconducting polymer films, it does not fully take into account all energy dissipation mechanisms. For example, the change of crystalline domain orientation under strain is another mechanism. This aspect was investigated for P1āP4 using 2D GIXD patterns (Fig. 2d, Supplementary Figs. S15ā18). The crystalline domains in P1 film may be changed as cracks readily formed. At the same time, there may be a new polymorph formed by applied strain (Supplementary Fig. S19). The higher molecular weight P2āP4 exhibited strain-dependent crystalline domain reorientation. Specifically, P2 initially had 34% and 66% edge-on and face-on packing (Fig. 2d), respectively. When a tensile strain was applied, the fraction of edge-on crystallites increased to nearly 50%, at 50% strain, indicating that the crystallites can be rotated or tilted, which is another possible mechanism for strain energy dissipation48,55. Such a reorientation is expected to give some degree of alignment, which is accounted for by DR values. However, the edge-on packing fraction of P2 decreased back to 40% under 100% strain, which could be due to micro-scale crack formation and released stress, as observed by microscopic images (Supplementary Figs. S6 and 7). Similarly, a monotonic increase in edge-on packing with strain was observed for polymers with higher molecular weight, especially with P3 film. Without microcracking (Supplementary Fig. S6b), the face-on and edge-on ratio continued to change and contribute to energy dissipation up to 100% strain. Note that P4 films exhibited lower levels of changes of the packing orientation, probably due to its low DoC (Supplementary Fig. S5).
Based on the above observations, the molecular picture of the PSC films under strain can be summarized as shown in Fig. 2e. The lower molecular weight polymer films initially possessed larger mean crystallite sizes and greater rDoCs. The crystallites rotate under a low external strain in addition to chain extension and alignment in the amorphous regions. Some aligned chains may undergo strain-induced crystallization, even though this is minimal in P1āP4 systems. At a high strain level, crystallites may be amorphized and eventually cracks form. In contrast, thin films of higher molecular weight polymers tend to have smaller crystalline domain sizes and lower rDoC. A larger fraction of molecules is in the disordered amorphous phase and have more freedom to reorient, change conformation and align under applied strains, leaving the small fraction of small crystallites mostly intact. Moreover, the stress distribution in stretched thin films with crystalline domains can be visualized by a finite element simulation (Supplementary Fig. S20). It can be seen that stress tends to be more concentrated in the larger crystalline domains, while large strain concentrations are observed in the lower molecular weight polymer films. Such a morphology is more likely to experience damage (i.e., micro-cracks), as observed in Supplementary Fig. S6. On the other hand, high molecular weight films possess smaller crystallites with low density. Thus, stress is distributed more uniformly and is less localized on the crystalline domains. The above molecular picture shows the way to useful design rules for intrinsically stretchable PSCs. For example, a terpolymer of multiple conjugated building blocks, which conforms to these design criteria, has been reported to exhibit exceptional electronic performance under tensile strain19. Again, both molecular alignment and crystallite re-orientation are characterized by DR, while the crystallite fraction and amorphization are characterized by rDoC. Therefore, rS (i.e., ĪDR/ĪrDoC; entropic energy dissipation/enthalpic energy dissipation) takes into account the above-described major factors contributing to thin film stretchability (recall Fig. 1d; P4 thin film with rS value of 11.5 is the one with the highest crack-onset strain).
Stretching thin films under multi-directional strain
P4 is a promising candidate for stretchable electronics, which require the active semiconducting layer be subjected to non-uniform stress (stretching in any combinations of directions). So far, most reported works have only cover investigations of PSC films under a uniaxial strain. Here, simultaneous biaxial stretching of the polymer films is studied as it is closer to realistic conditions (details of the biaxial stretching process are illustrated in Supplementary Fig. S21). Figure 3a shows the AFM surface topography of P2 and P4 films under biaxial 100% strain. Remarkably, even under 100% strain, which corresponds to a 400% expansion by area, the P4 film remained smooth and no cracks could be observed. In comparison, P2 films were completely damaged by the biaxial stretching and micro-scale cracks were readily observable (Supplementary Fig. S22). In addition, the rDoC and coherence lengths of such films under biaxial strain were extracted from 2D GIXD patterns (Supplementary Fig. S23). Similar to the results of uniaxially stretched films, lower molecular weight P2 films showed substantial decrease in rDoC and coherence length under biaxial strain, indicating the crystalline domains in the film were mostly amorphized or cracked. The molecular ordering in high molecular weight P4 thin films, however, appears to be maintained even under a high level of strain. The rDoC decreased by less than 25% and the mean crystal size stayed almost the same as its initial (i.e., non-stretched) state under 100% biaxial strain.
Since P4 films have the unusual capability to resist damage from applied strain during biaxial stretching, a stable charge transport performance was obtained (Fig. 3b). P4 maintained nearly constant field-effect mobility of 0.15ācm2V-1s-1 with negligible hysteresis under biaxial strain of 0ā100% (Supplementary Fig. S24). Effects of biaxial strain on organic electronic materials have rarely been investigated28,56. This is the first report of a PSC achieving stable electrical behavior with a mobility greater than 0.1ācm2V-1s-1 under biaxial deformation. Previously, only (i) P3HT was stretched biaxially using a two-step method (stretched one direction to 100% and then stretched the orthogonal direction to 100%) with a resulting mobility lower than 0.01ācm2V-1s-1 under biaxial strain56, and (ii) a P3HT/polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) blend exhibited a dramatic decay in mobility (over 85%) under 50% biaxial strain28 (Supplementary Fig. S25), were reported. As expected, compared to P4, the mobility of P2 and P3-based films exhibited significant decay upon biaxial stretching. The corresponding stable (P4-based device) or unstable (P2-based device) current output as a function of strain is depicted in the FET transfer characteristics (Fig. 3b and Supplementary Fig. S26).
Furthermore, high operational cycling stability of the stretchable P4 film was observed. Almost unchanged electrical performance was observed after 500 stretch and release cycles of 100% biaxial strain, as shown in Supplementary Fig. S27. In addition, a 3āĆā3 array of electrodes with different in-plane orientations were used to study the anisotropy of charge transport in biaxially stretched films (Supplementary Fig. S28). The on-state currents of FETs along various charge transport directions with respect to the stretching direction were observed to be approximately the same, indicating isotropic charge transport in biaxially deformed films. Additionally, the effect of anisotropic biaxial stretching (i.e., 25āĆā50%, 50āĆā75%, and 50āĆā100%) was investigated. Unlike the symmetric biaxially stretched films, which did not experience force-induced polymer chain alignment due to the isotropic force applied, films under anisotropic biaxial strain exhibited DR values larger than 1 along the direction with a larger strain, indicating alignment along the larger strain direction (Supplementary Fig. S29). However, the degree of polymer alignment in this case was much smaller than that from uniaxial stretching because part of the tensile strain is canceled from the compression generated in the perpendicular direction due to the Poisson effect. For the P4 film stretched to 50āĆā100% strain for 50 stretch/release cycles, the DR stayed in a range of 0.95ā1.2 (Supplementary Fig. S30). As a result, we observed that the charge carrier mobility changed when an anisotropic biaxial strain was applied (Supplementary Table S1). Along the direction with a higher net strain, both the mobility and DR were slightly higher.
Comparing P4 FET devices exposed to a uniaxial, isotropic biaxial, or anisotropic biaxial strain, consistent mobilities between 0.1ā0.25ācm2V-1s-1 were achieved, suggesting that no matter which direction the force was applied to the PSC film, excellent maintenance of charge transport was observed (Fig. 3c).
The above observation is new and surprising for rigid conjugated semicrystalline polymer semiconductors. Such mechanical behavior is only observed previously for conventional rubber materials, in which the material can be anisotropically strained and return to its original shape41,57. Remarkably, P4 can achieve reversible behavior (correlated with its high rS value). As discussed above, reversible chain alignment, chain and crystallite re-orientation, and crystallite amorphization and reformation are important molecular mechanisms for energy dissipation. In this case, all the above mechanisms can be contributed by tuning the molecular weight of the conjugated polymers despite their rigid polymer backbones.
Discussion
Our work above suggests rS is a relevant parameter for comparing promise of PSCs for stretchable FETs. Both amorphous and crystalline domains may dissipate the accumulated stress in stretched thin films. A higher rS value is obtained when there is a greater energy dissipation during film deformation, resulting in reversible molecular ordering, as observed in various PSC systems (Supplementary Fig. S31). Similar to thermoplastic elastomers, such as SEBS, the crystallinity of the smaller, more rigid domains are more likely to be maintained during deformation as less stress is concentrated on smaller hard domains distributed in larger soft amorphous domains, as compared to larger hard domains distributed within smaller soft domains41,54. In general, the rS takes into account energy dissipated entropically through polymer conformation change and enthalpically through amorphization of crystallites, respectively, which can quantitatively describe the strain-dependent behaviors of semicrystalline stretchable PSCs. Finally, a fully stretchable FET device using high rS P4 as the active material was fabricated30 and a charge carrier mobility of approximately 0.2ācm2V-1s-1 was measured (Fig. 3d). Operational stability of such a fully stretchable device under multi-directional deformation is depicted in Fig. 3e. Negligible degradation was observed in source-drain current before and after stretching, suggesting the electrical performance can be maintained under irregular strain.
In summary, the ability for reversible molecular ordering under strain is found to be a key factor in realizing robust mechanical and electrical performance of intrinsically stretchable PSCs. We found that relative stretchability (rS) correlated well with a polymerās ability to align and maintain crystalline domains as an indication of the effectiveness of stress energy dissipation of the conjugated PSC films under strain. Indeed, PSCs possessing high rS showed reversible molecular ordering, which is similar to broadly studied semicrystalline non-conjugated rubbers whose glassy domains can be deformed reversibly with small domain sizes. Our findings provide a way to compare stretchable polymer semiconductor materials.
Methods
Polymer characterization
The number-averaged molecular weight (Mn) and polydispersity index (PDI) of these polymers were measured by high temperature size exclusion chromatography (SEC) (Polymer Labs (Now Owned by Agilent) GPC 220 system with a refractive index detector) at 200āĀ°C using polystyrene as molecular weight standards and 1,2,4-trichlorobenzene as eluent. Dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) was performed on a TA Instrument Q800 with a static force of 0.01āN, an oscillation strain of 0.1% at 1.0āHz and a ramp rate of 2āĀ°C min-1. A PSC solution (10āmgāmL-1 in chlorobenzene) was drop-casted on top of the polyimide film and the films were then annealed at 100āĀ°C for 3āh to relax the polymer chains. Afterwards, the polyimide film coated with PSC was removed from the supporting OTS-modified Si substrate and installed between the DMA clamps for measurement. The polyimide films and sample preparation were followed by our published procedure58. The mechanical strain-stress tests were performed by using an Instron 5565 instrument with a stretching rate of 10%āsā1. A PSC solution (10āmgāmL-1 in chlorobenzene) was drop-casted on top of a Teflon plate in the ambient environment and annealed at 100āĀ°C for 1āh. The thickness of the drop-casted films is in a range of 2ā3āĀµm. Finally, the free-standing PSC bulk films were installed between the Instron clamps for measurement.
PSC thin film characterization
The elastic modulus of PSCs was determined using the buckling method59. The polymer films of approximately 50ānm were spin-coated on an OTS-modified Si substrate and annealed at 100āĀ°C for 20āmin, then the PSC thin films were transferred onto a pre-strained (i.e., 4%) PDMS substrates. Once the strain was released, wrinkles were clearly formed. The elastic moduli of the films were calculated from the wrinkle wavelength and film thickness. The surface morphology of PSC thin films was recorded by a Nanoscope 3D controller atomic force micrograph (AFM, Digital Instruments) operated under tapping mode at room temperature. Optical images of the PSC films were taken by an optical microscope (Leica DM4000M). Grazing-incidence X-ray diffraction (GIXD) experiments were performed at beamline 7-2 and 11-3 in Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Light source (SSRL) with a photon energy of 14 and 12.73ākeV, respectively. Note that the incident angle was fixed at 0.12Ā° to improve the diffraction intensity and reduce the substrate scattering. All GIXD images were collected in reflection mode with a 2D area detector, and the samples were placed under a Helium atmosphere. Data analysis was performed in Wixdiff, written by S. Mannsfeld. The relative degree of crystallinity (rDoC) values under different strain levels were determined by integrating the intensity of the lamella diffraction peak, taken from 2D diffraction patterns collected with the PSC film rotated with respect to angle Ļ from 0Ā° to 90Ā°. The integrated intensity was normalized by the scattering intensity to scattering volume and exposure time. Additionally, the scattering intensity was corrected for scattering geometry, as detailed in previous work by Toney and co-workers60 and a sin(omega) correction was applied for the data analyses. Agilent Cary 6000i UV/Vis/NIR spectroscopy was used to measure the UV-vis absorption spectra. A polarizer crystal was equipped to measure the absorption intensity with the polarization parallel (A//) and perpendicular (Aā„) to the stretching directions. The dichroic ratio (DR) was determined by A///Aā„ for analyzing polymer chain alignment under strain. The rS value is defined as the ratio of DR/rDoC at various strains, the DR values were averaged from at least 3 samples from 3 different batches and the rDoC values were averaged from at least 3 samples from 3 different batches for each polymer under a specific strain condition (i.e., 0, 50, or 100% strain). All the FET devices were probed using a Keithley 4200 semiconductor parameter analyzer (Keithley Instruments Inc.) in ambient at room temperature
Data availability
The authors declare that all data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article and its Supplementary Information files or from the corresponding author upon request.
References
Root, S. E., Savagatrup, S., Printz, A. D., Rodriquez, D. & Lipomi, D. J. Mechanical properties of organic semiconductors for stretchable, highly flexible, and mechanically robust electronics. Chem. Rev. 117, 6467ā6499 (2017).
Ma, R., Chou, S. Y., Xie, Y. & Pei, Q. Morphological/nanostructural control toward intrinsically stretchable organic electronics. Chem. Soc. Rev. 48, 1741ā1786 (2019).
Fratini, S., Nikolka, M., Salleo, A., Schweicher, G. & Sirringhaus, H. Charge transport in high-mobility conjugated polymers and molecular semiconductors. Nat. Rev. Mater. 19, 491ā502 (2020).
Printz, A. D. & Lipomi, D. J. Competition between deformability and charge transport in semiconducting polymers for flexible and stretchable electronics. Appl. Phys. Rev. 3, 021302 (2016).
Wang, G. J. N., Gasperini, A. & Bao, Z. Stretchable polymer semiconductors for plastic electronics. Adv. Electronic Mater. 4, 1700429 (2018).
Qian, Y. et al. Stretchable organic semiconductor devices. Adv. Mater. 28, 9243ā9265 (2016).
Thiyagarajan, K. & Jeong, U. Strategies for stretchable polymer semiconductor layers. MRS Bulletin 42, 98ā102 (2017).
Jinno, H. et al. Stretchable and waterproof elastomer-coated organic photovoltaics for washable electronic textile applications. Nat. Energy 2, 780ā785 (2017).
Zhang, G. et al. Robust and stretchable polymer semiconducting networks: from film microstructure to macroscopic device performance. Chem. Mater. 31, 6530ā6539 (2019).
Yin, H., Zhu, Y., Youssef, K., Yu, Z. & Pei, Q. Structures and materials in stretchable electroluminescent devices. Adv. Mater. 33, 2106184 (2021).
Wang, B. et al. Foundry-compatible high-resolution patterning of vertically phase-separated semiconducting films for ultraflexible organic electronics. Nat. Commun. 12, 4937 (2021).
Zheng, Y. Q. et al. Monolithic optical microlithography of high-density elastic circuits. Science 373, 88ā94 (2021).
Matsuhisa, N. et al. High-frequency and intrinsically stretchable polymer diodes. Nature 600, 246ā252 (2021).
Roth, B. et al. Mechanical properties of a library of low-band-gap polymers. Chem. Mater. 28, 2363ā2373 (2016).
Lu, C. et al. Effects of molecular structure and packing order on the stretchability of semicrystalline conjugated poly (tetrathienoaceneādiketopyrrolopyrrole) polymers. Adv. Electronic Mater. 3, 1600311 (2017).
Oh, J. Y. et al. Intrinsically stretchable and healable semiconducting polymer for organic transistors. Nature 539, 411ā415 (2016).
Zheng, Y. et al. An intrinsically stretchable highāperformance polymer semiconductor with low crystallinity. Adv. Funct. Mater. 29, 1905340 (2019).
Wu, H.-C. et al. Isoindigo-based semiconducting polymers using carbosilane side chains for high performance stretchable field-effect transistors. Macromolecules 49, 8540ā8548 (2016).
Mun, J. et al. A design strategy for high mobility stretchable polymer semiconductors. Nat. Commun. 12, 3572 (2021).
Wang, G. J. N. et al. Inducing elasticity through oligoāsiloxane crosslinks for intrinsically stretchable semiconducting polymers. Adv. Funct. Mater. 26, 7254ā7262 (2016).
Wang, G. J. N. et al. Tuning the cross-linker crystallinity of a stretchable polymer semiconductor. Chem. Mater. 31, 6465ā6475 (2018).
Zheng, Y. et al. A molecular design approach towards elastic and multifunctional polymer electronics. Nat. Commun. 12, 5701 (2021).
Chen, S. et al. Highly flexible and efficient allāpolymer solar cells with highāviscosity processing polymer additive toward potential of stretchable devices. Angew. Chem. In. Ed. 57, 13277ā13282 (2018).
Mun, J. et al. Conjugated carbon cyclic nanorings as additives for intrinsically stretchable semiconducting polymers. Adv. Mater. 31, 1903912 (2019).
Xu, J. et al. Tuning conjugated polymer chain packing for stretchable semiconductors. Adv. Mater. 33, 2104747 (2022).
Scott, J. I. et al. Significantly increasing the ductility of high performance polymer semiconductors through polymer blending. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 8, 14037ā14045 (2016).
Shin, M. et al. Highly stretchable polymer transistors consisting entirely of stretchable device components. Adv. Mater. 26, 3706ā3711 (2014).
Kim, H. J., Thukral, A., Sharma, S. & Yu, C. Biaxially stretchable fully elastic transistors based on rubbery semiconductor nanocomposites. Adv. Mater. Tech. 3, 1800043 (2018).
Zhang, G. et al. Versatile interpenetrating polymer network approach to robust stretchable electronic devices. Chem. Mater. 29, 7645ā7652 (2017).
Xu, J. et al. Highly stretchable polymer semiconductor films through the nanoconfinement effect. Science 355, 59ā64 (2017).
Xu, J. et al. Multi-scale ordering in highly stretchable polymer semiconducting films. Nat. Mater. 18, 594ā601 (2019).
Wen, H.-F. et al. Soft poly (butyl acrylate) side chains toward intrinsically stretchable polymeric semiconductors for field-effect transistor applications. Macromolecules 50, 4982ā4992 (2017).
Sugiyama, F. et al. Stretchable and degradable semiconducting block copolymers. Macromolecules 51, 5944ā5949 (2018).
Wang, J.-T. et al. Stretchable conjugated rodācoil poly (3-hexylthiophene)-block-poly (butyl acrylate) thin films for field effect transistor applications. Macromolecules 50, 1442ā1452 (2017).
Choi, J. et al. Importance of critical molecular weight of semicrystalline n-type polymers for mechanically robust, efficient electroactive thin films. Chem. Mater. 31, 3163ā3173 (2019).
Pei, D. et al. Impact of molecular weight on the mechanical and electrical properties of a high-mobility diketopyrrolopyrrole-based conjugated polymer. Macromolecules 53, 4490ā4500 (2020).
Koch, F. P. V. et al. The impact of molecular weight on microstructure and charge transport in semicrystalline polymer semiconductorsāpoly (3-hexylthiophene), a model study. Prog. Polym. Sci. 38, 1978ā1989 (2013).
Chen, J.-Y. et al. Electrospinning-induced elastomeric properties of conjugated polymers for extremely stretchable nanofibers and rubbery optoelectronics. J. Mater. Chem. C 8, 873ā882 (2019).
Lin, L. et al. Towards tunable sensitivity of electrical property to strain for conductive polymer composites based on thermoplastic elastomer. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 5, 5815ā5824 (2013).
Niu, W. et al. Synthesis and properties of soluble fused thiophene diketopyrrolopyrrole-based polymers with tunable molecular weight. Macromolecules 51, 9422ā9429 (2018).
Dechnarong, N. et al. Microdomain structure change and macroscopic mechanical response of styrenic triblock copolymer under cyclic uniaxial and biaxial stretching modes. Polym. J. 53, 703ā712 (2021).
Rodriquez, D. et al. Comparison of methods for determining the mechanical properties of semiconducting polymer films for stretchable electronics. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 9, 8855ā8862 (2017).
Noriega, R. et al. A general relationship between disorder, aggregation and charge transport in conjugated polymers. Nat. Mater. 12, 1038ā1044 (2013).
Chen, J. et al. Effect of molecular chain architecture on dynamics of polymer thin films measured by the Ac-chip calorimeter. Macromolecules 47, 3497ā3501 (2014).
Zhang, W., Milner, S. T. & Gomez, E. D. Nematic order imposes molecular weight effect on charge transport in conjugated polymers. ACS Central Sci. 4, 413ā421 (2018).
OāConnor, B. et al. Correlations between mechanical and electrical properties of polythiophenes. ACS Nano 4, 7538ā7544 (2010).
Printz, A. D., Zaretski, A. V., Savagatrup, S., Chiang, A. S. C. & Lipomi, D. J. Yield point of semiconducting polymer films on stretchable substrates determined by onset of buckling. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 7, 23257ā23264 (2015).
Flory, P. J. & Yoon, D. Y. Molecular morphology in semicrystalline polymers. Nature 272, 226ā229 (1978).
Men, Y., Rieger, J. & Strobl, G. Role of the entangled amorphous network in tensile deformation of semicrystalline polymers. Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 095502 (2003).
Jiang, Z. et al. Structural evolution of tensile-deformed high-density polyethylene during annealing: scanning synchrotron small-angle X-ray scattering study. Macromolecules 40, 7263ā7269 (2007).
Jabbari-Farouji, S. et al. Plastic deformation mechanisms of semicrystalline and amorphous polymers. ACS Macro Lett. 4, 147ā150 (2015).
OāConnor, B. T. et al. Morphological origin of charge transport anisotropy in aligned polythiophene thin films. Adv. Funct. Mater. 24, 3422ā3431 (2014).
Nikzad, S. et al. Effect of extensional flow on the evaporative assembly of a donorāacceptor semiconducting polymer. ACS Appl. Electronic Mater. 1, 2445ā2454 (2019).
Dechnarong, N. et al. In situ synchrotron radiation X-ray scattering investigation of a microphase-separated structure of thermoplastic elastomers under uniaxial and equi-biaxial deformation modes. Macromolecules 53, 8901ā8909 (2020).
Hiss, R. et al. Network stretching, slip processes, and fragmentation of crystallites during uniaxial drawing of polyethylene and related copolymers. A comparative study. Macromolecules 32, 4390ā4403 (1999).
Gargi, D. et al. Charge transport in highly face-on poly (3-hexylthiophene) films. J. Phys. Chem. C 117, 17421ā17428 (2013).
Heinrich, G., Straube, E., & Helmis, G. Rubber elasticity of polymer networks: Theories. In Polymer physics 33ā87 (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1988).
Schroeder, B. C. et al. Non-conjugated flexible linkers in semiconducting polymers: A pathway to improved processability without compromising device performance. Adv. Electronic. Mater. 2, 1600104 (2016).
Savagatrup, S. et al. Mechanical properties of conjugated polymers and polymer-fullerene composites as a function of molecular structure. Adv. Funct. Mater. 24, 1169ā1181 (2014).
Baker, J. L. et al. Quantification of thin film crystallographic orientation using X-ray diffraction with an area detector. Langmuir 26, 9146ā9151 (2010).
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research under award numbers FA9550-18-1-0143 (17RT0917) and FA9550-21-1-0413 (21RT0491). J.X. acknowledges the Center for Nanoscale Materials, supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, under Contract No. DE-AC02-06CH11357. N.M. acknowledges funding support from an overseas fellowship from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS). C.L. acknowledges support from the National Science Foundation through grant CMMI-1911836. This work was partially performed at the Stanford Nano Shared Facilities (SNSF), supported by the National Science Foundation under award ECCS-1542152. GIXD experiments were carried out at the Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Laboratory (SSRL), a national user facility operated by Stanford University on behalf of the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Basic Energy Sciences. The authors acknowledge Bart Johnson at SSRL for supporting GIXD experiment and Brandon Clark for helping thin film characterizations.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
H.-C.W and S.N. contributed equally to this work. H.-C.W., M.H., and Z.B. conceived and designed the experiments; H.-C.W., S.N., C.Z., N.M., J.X., and Y.-Q.Z. fabricated and characterized thin films and transistor devices; H.-C.W., S.N., and H.Y. did the GIXD characterizations; Y.L., W.N., J.R.M. and M.H. designed and synthesized the conjugated polymers; P.K.A., R.R., and C.L. carried out the simulation of stretched films; H.Y. and M.F.T. advised on the discussion of morphological results; H.-C.W. organized the data and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. All authors reviewed and commented on the manuscript. Z.B. directed the project.
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Peer review
Peer review information
Nature Communications thanks Dean DeLongchamp, and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. A peer review file is available.
Additional information
Publisherās note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the articleās Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the articleās Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Wu, HC., Nikzad, S., Zhu, C. et al. Highly stretchable polymer semiconductor thin films with multi-modal energy dissipation and high relative stretchability. Nat Commun 14, 8382 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-44099-w
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-44099-w
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.