Abstract
Replying to: N. B. Simmons, K. L. Seymour, J. Habersetzer & G. F. Gunnell Nature 466, 10.1038/nature09219 (2010).
We appreciate the comments of Simmons et al.1 and welcome the new information they have provided about the oldest fossil bat, Onychonycteris finneyi, as well as their confirmation of contact between the stylohyal and tympanic bones in Myzopoda aurita, an extant laryngeal echolocator. Two skeletal features—relatively large cochleae and contact between the stylohyal and tympanic bones—identify extant bats with the capacity for laryngeal echolocation. Although the size of the cochlea can be measured in O. finneyi, the stylohyals may or may not have contacted the tympanics. Simmons et al.1 disagree with our interpretation2 of the possible contact between the stylohyal and the tympanic bone in O. finneyi, which indicated that this Eocene bat may have had the capacity for laryngeal echolocation, and have a different interpretation of our results.
Similar content being viewed by others
Main
We agree with Simmons et al.1 that the known specimens of O. finneyi do not provide clear morphological evidence about contact between the stylohyal and tympanic bones and, by extension, about the applicability of this character for identifying this bats’ capacity for laryngeal echolocation. As they note, the holotype of O. finneyi does provide data about the form of the stylohyal and the size of the cochlea, leading them to conclude that the bat did not echolocate.
Simmons et al. propose that the elongated stylohyal in bats is an ossified combination of stylohyal, tympanohyal and the ligament/cartilage between these two elements. The predictions arising from this hypothesis can be tested by studying patterns of development and ossification in living bats.
We join Simmons et al.1 in awaiting the discovery and description of further fossil bats that can help to resolve the question of the origin and timing of the evolution of flight and echolocation in bats.
References
Simmons, N. B., Seymour, K. L., Habersetzer, J. & Gunnell, G. F. Inferring echolocation in ancient bats. Nature 466, 10.1038/nature09219 (2010)
Veselka, N. et al. A bony connection signals laryngeal echolocation in bats. Nature 463, 939–942 (2010)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Veselka, N., McErlain, D., Holdsworth, D. et al. Veselka et al. reply. Nature 466, E9 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature09246
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature09246
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.