Skip to main content

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.

Russian scientist defends Lake Vostok life claims

New bacterial species not just contamination.

Scientists working in Antarctica think that they have found a new species of bacterium flourishing in Lake Vostok. Credit: ALEXEY EKAIKIN/REUTERS

The Russian scientist who is leading an effort to analyse samples from a lake buried under almost 4 kilometres of Antarctic ice has hit back against criticism that an unknown species of bacterium discovered by the team was in fact contamination.

At an international scientific meeting in Moscow on 6 March, Sergey Bulat of the Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute in Gatchina said that water from Lake Vostok contained a bacterium whose DNA was less than 86% similar to DNA from known bacterial species. But other researchers argue that announcement was premature because the bacterium might just have been a contaminant from the drilling fluid.

“They really need to stop playing around with frozen lake water bathed in kerosene and get a clean bulk water sample,” says John Priscu, a glaciologist at Montana State University in Bozeman who in January led a US expedition to Antarctica’s Lake Whillans, a comparatively small, shallow body of water beneath 800 metres of Antarctic ice.

But Bulat stands by the claim, and says that the team took steps to rule out potential contamination.

“We are very sure that what we have found is an unclassified native microbe,” Bulat says. “It seems to belong to a division of uncultured environmental bacteria that haven’t been determined yet.”

The Russian team broke through into the pristine lake in February 2012. At roughly the size of Lake Ontario, Vostok is by far the largest of the 300 or so subglacial lakes beneath Antarctica’s ice sheet. A preliminary analysis, reported last October, suggested that the upper layers of the lake were lifeless. But tests carried out since have revealed that this is not the case, says Bulat. Genetic analysis has revealed three variants of the bacterium that cannot be assigned to bacterial lineages described in global databases, he says.

A Russian team completed drilling 4,000 metres into Lake Vostok in February last year.

The scientists have not yet established the mysterious microbe’s physiology and biochemistry, and they do not know how it might extract energy from its pitch-dark and nutrient-poor environment. More sophisticated tests, including whole-genome sequencing, will be required to answer these and other questions, says Bulat.

However, he says, the high level of contamination — the current samples contain as much drill fluid as lake water — and the meagre numbers of bacteria, just 167 cells per millilitre, mean that these analyses cannot yet be done. He hopes that samples from a 54-metre-long ‘fresh-frozen’ ice core drilled during the 2012–13 season and expected to arrive in St Petersburg in May will reveal more about the genetics of microbial life in Lake Vostok, he says.

Other researchers say that they would be surprised if Lake Vostok is totally devoid of life. The US team has already reported the presence of microbes in water and sediment samples retrieved from Lake Whillans. Those samples are currently being analysed in US labs. But many point out that about 90% of the bacteria on Earth remain uncultured and unsequenced, so finding bacterial DNA that doesn’t fully match that of well-classified taxa is not very surprising.

“It happens quite a lot,” says Brent Christner, a microbiologist at Louisiana State University in Baton Rouge and one of the researchers analysing the Lake Whillans samples.

The Russian team may have found differences of a few hundred base pairs to species in the databases, but this is “neither remarkable nor diagnostic” agrees David Pearce, a microbiologist with the British Antarctic Survey in Cambridge. Nonetheless, he says, the Russian findings — if they hold up — are “an encouraging and positive first step“.

Authors

Related links

Related links

Related links in Nature Research

Lake-drilling team discovers life under the ice 2013-Feb-11

Antarctic researchers find life in subglacial lake 2013-Feb-07

Life abounds in Antarctic lake sealed under ice 2012-Nov-26

Hunt for life under Antarctic ice heats up 2012-Nov-21

Vostok’s microbes elusive in first measurements of surface water 2012-Oct-18

Related external links

Lake Whillans drilling project

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Schiermeier, Q. Russian scientist defends Lake Vostok life claims. Nature (2013). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature.2013.12578

Download citation

  • Published:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature.2013.12578

Search

Quick links

Nature Briefing

Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. Sign up for Nature Briefing