Protein processing is increasingly being recognized to be extremely important in a wide variety of cell functions, not only in physiological conditions, but also in many pathological conditions, especially in several neurodegenerative disorders.1 However, such processing activities are usually very weak and very difficult to analyze. Here we show the ‘cleavage-dependent cell selection system’ in which a weak protein processing activity is converted into a strong transcriptional activity, thus allowing the expression of drug resistance proteins required for selection. This system will provide a novel cell selection system for isolating cells containing processing activities for any protein concerned, and will contribute to the identification of yet unknown processing enzymes involved in various cell functions.
A class of inherited human neurodegenerative disorders, including Huntington disease (HD), Machado-Joseph disease (MJD), and spinobulbar muscular atrophy (SBMA) has been found to be caused by expanded CAG repeats encoding polyglutamines,1,2,3 and is thus called ‘the polyglutamine diseases’.4,5 Although the gene responsible for each disease is ubiquitously expressed in most tissues as well as throughout the nervous system, each disorder has its own susceptible regions in the central nervous system.4,5,6 We previously isolated the MJD gene,2 the gene responsible for MJD, and demonstrated that expanded polyglutamines, if expressed as part of a fragment of the MJD protein, but not when expressed as part of the entire MJD protein, aggregate and trigger cell death in cultured cells, and induce neurodegeneration in vivo in transgenic mice.7 From these results, we have proposed the ‘processing model’, in which cleavage or processing of the diseased protein is a crucial step in the pathogenesis of the polyglutamine diseases;4,5,7 namely, the brain region-specific cleavage of the diseased proteins with expanded polyglutamines leads to the degeneration of specific brain regions in each disease. Several lines of evidence supporting this model have been demonstrated.8,9,10,11,12
In order to find further evidence to substantiate the ‘processing model’, we attempted to identify cultured cells possessing MJD protein processing activity. For this purpose, we expressed MJD79 in a variety of cell lines, and immunocytochemically examined the MJD79 protein expressed.2,7,13 Unfortunately, we were initially unable to find any evidence suggesting cleavage of the MJD protein in any of the cultured cells examined, which were all dividing cells. However, when neuronally differentiated post mitotic PC12 cells were examined several days after transfection of MJD79, we noticed that approximately one in a few hundred of the transfected PC12 cells made polyglutamine-mediated aggregates in the cells; these aggregates could be detected only with an antibody which recognizes an amino acid stretch just downstream of the polyglutamine portion in the MJD protein, but not with an antibody to a tag attached to the N-terminus of the MJD protein.13 With a similar frequency, aggregate formation was detected in living cells upon transfection of MJD79-GFP, but not GFP-MJD79, again only in differentiated PC12 cells several days after transfection (Figure 1A). These aggregates observed within the homogenous GFP signals were indistinguishable from those observed upon Q79-GFP transfection. These observations suggested that a very small population of PC12 cells is capable of cleaving the MJD protein, and due to the fact that this activity is very weak, the cleaved MJD product does not accumulate enough to form aggregates in dividing cells.
We have previously established a system for the enhancement of a weak transcriptional activity by greater than a 100-fold.14 Modifying this system, we designed the ‘cleavage-dependent cell selection system’, in which a very weak protein processing activity can theoretically be converted into a strong transcriptional activity. For example (Figure 1B), the full-length MJD protein with Gal4VP16 (an artificial strong transcriptional activator)14 fused to its C-terminus, is expressed together with a Gal4 reporter plasmid14 which drives the expression of a drug resistant marker protein, in this case for Zeocin resistance. More specifically, the system should work in the following way: when the MJD protein, MJD35 for example, is cleaved by its processing enzyme, the cleaved portion with Gal4VP16 will translocate to the nucleus and transactivate the reporter gene, thereby resulting in Zeocin resistance in dividing pre-differentiated PC12 cells. The Zeocin-resistant cells obtained from this system should contain PC12 subclones with enhanced processing activity of the MJD protein. By repeating this selection process, cells with a much higher processing activity for the MJD protein should be obtained. We used MJD35, which contains a normal length of polyglutamine repeats in the selection process, in order to avoid aggregate formation of the cleaved fragments which should result in cell death. In order to exclude the non-cleaved MJD35-Gal4VP16 protein from the nucleus, the transmembrane domain of the Fas receptor15 was fused to the N-terminus of the MJD35-Gal4VP16 protein. The TM-MJD35-Gal4VP16 protein was confirmed to be exclusively attached to the cell membrane by immunocytochemical analysis (data not shown).
We were indeed able to obtain several PC12 subclones after selection with 100 μg/ml Zeocin (Figure 1C, a). Among these subclones, only one subclone (B16) appeared to possess increased MJD processing activity. In the B16 cells, approximately 7.5% of the GFP-positive cells contained visible aggregates 12 days after MJD79-GFP transfection, and such aggregate-positive cells eventually died several days after. Using the B16 cells, we repeated the drug selection with a higher concentration of Zeocin, 400 μg/ml, and were able to isolate several subclones with a further enhanced activity to make visible aggregates than the B16 cells, and hence these subclones are thought to possess much higher MJD processing activity (Figure 1C, a). Among the subclones, C10 cells appeared to have the highest MJD processing activities. In both the B16 and C10 cells, polyglutamine-mediated aggregates increased in a time-dependent manner (Figure 1C, b), and approximately 24% of GFP-positive cells contained visible aggregates in the C10 cells 12 days after the transfection of MJD79-GFP. Compared with the parental cells, cell death was clearly observed in the B16 and C10 cells upon transfection with MJD79-GFP, C10 cells exhibiting stronger cell death than B16 cells (data not shown). The true percentage of aggregate-positive C10 cells is probably even higher, as at this time point; many GFP-positive dead cells were floating in the culture medium, which was more evident than in the B16 cells. Aggregate formation was not observed in the B16 and C10 cells upon transfection with MJD35-GFP, and there was no enhancement of cell death when compared with the transfection of GFP only (data not shown).
We were able to biochemically confirm the specific processing of the MJD protein in the B16 and C10 cells via Western blotting (Figure 1D). The transfected full-length MJD35-GFP and MJD79-GFP proteins were detected as 65 kDa and 73 kDa bands respectively, using an anti-GFP antibody. In addition to these bands, cell extracts from the B16 and C10 cells showed an additional band of approximately 40 kDa in the MJD35-GFP transfection and approximately 46 kDa in the MJD79-GFP transfection. The polyglutamine repeat length did not affect the efficiencies of cleavage of the MJD protein in these cells. To test the cleavage specificity of the B16 and C10 cells, we examined the ability of these cells to cleave huntingtin and the androgen receptor, gene products responsible for HD and SBMA, respectively. We could not detect any cleavage products of huntingtin (Figure 1D) or the androgen receptor (not shown) that were enhanced in the B16 and C10 cells. These results clearly indicated that the processing activity enhanced in both the B16 and C10 cells is specific for the MJD protein, showing that this ‘cleavage-dependent cell selection system’ can indeed be used for the selection of cells with enhanced cleavage activity for a particular protein.
A rough estimation of the cleavage site of the MJD protein from the sizes of the cleaved products suggests that the MJD protein is cleaved in these cells around the 250th amino acid residue, which is towards the C-terminus of the protein.2 Our preliminary data from NMR structural analysis of bacterially synthesized MJD protein indicated that the MJD protein possesses a higher ordered structure in its N-terminal portion and a relatively free structure around its C-terminus, where the polyglutamine stretch resides. Consistent with this, trypsinization specifically cleaved the MJD protein at a single site after the 206th Lysine2 (Y Kamei and A Kakizuka unpublished data), which is located near the predicted cleavage region observed in the B16 and C10 cells. Mutation of this trypsin cleavage site in the MJD protein still allowed the protein to be cleaved in B16 and C10 cells (data not shown), indicating that the MJD processing being observed is not mediated by trypsin or trypsin-like proteases. These selected cells, especially the C10 cells will be useful for further characterization of the MJD protein processing activity and for the identification of the yet unknown MJD processing enzyme. Application of this system to other proteins will definitely open a new field in protein processing research.
References
Huntington's Disease Collaborative Research Group Cell . 1993 72: 971
Kawaguchi Y et al. Nat. Genet 1994 8: 221
La Spada AR et al. Nature 1991 352: 77
Kakizuka A . Curr. Opin. Neurol 1997 10: 285
Kakizuka A . Trend. Genet 1998 14: 396
Ross CA . Neuron 1995 15: 493
Ikeda H et al. Nat. Genet 1996 13: 196
DiFiglia M et al. Science 1997 277: 1990
Li M et al. Ann. Neurol 1998 44: 249
Schmidt T et al. Brain Pathol 1998 8: 669
Lunkes A, Mandel JL . Hum. Molec. Genet 1998 7: 1355
Schilling G et al. Neuron 1999 24: 275
Yasuda S et al. Genes Cells 1999 4: 743
Segawa T et al. Cancer Res 1998 58: 2282
Takebayashi H et al. Cancer Res 1996 56: 4164
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Yamamoto, Y., Hasegawa, H., Tanaka, K. et al. Isolation of neuronal cells with high processing activity for the Machado-Joseph disease protein. Cell Death Differ 8, 871–873 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.cdd.4400901
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.cdd.4400901