Published online 25 May 2011 | Nature 473, 427-428 (2011) | doi:10.1038/473427a

News

Public health: Polio clings on in Pakistan

Fears grow that health-service reforms may let virus flourish, just as the global eradication effort reaches its endgame.

Children are still being disabled by polio in Pakistan despite years of effort to eradicate the disease.Children are still being disabled by polio in Pakistan despite years of effort to eradicate the disease.UNICEF/NYHQ2011-0198/ZAIDI

Asif Ali Zardari, the president of Pakistan, held a meeting last month to tackle yet another setback for his troubled nation. The focus was neither Al-Qaeda's resurgence nor poor diplomatic relations with the United States — it was polio, a crippling disease that has been wiped out in almost every other part of the world.

As an assessment of the global polio eradication campaign by its Independent Monitoring Board warns, "Pakistan risks being the country that prevents global polio eradication" (see http://go.nature.com/7tnvcg). After a spike in cases in Pakistan last year, a new emergency action plan to tackle the threat is off to a slow start with at least 36 confirmed cases this year. Meanwhile, constitutional reforms that will eliminate the country's central health ministry could slow efforts to turn the tide.

The push to make polio the second human pathogen after smallpox to be eradicated began in 1988. That year, an estimated 350,000 people developed poliomyelitis, an insidious infection that attacks the nervous system and can render patients paralysed within hours. The Global Polio Eradication Initiative, a public–private partnership led by the World Health Organization (WHO), hoped to finish the campaign by 2000. Yet many countries in Africa and central Asia did not begin eradication until the mid-1990s. Pakistan, meanwhile, successfully reduced its burden from 1,155 cases in 1997 to 28 in 2005.

By the mid-2000s, fewer than 2,000 people worldwide contracted polio each year, with the vast majority of cases occurring in Nigeria and India, where the campaign faced obstacles including vaccine boycotts. Public-awareness and vaccination campaigns have beaten back the disease since then: India has recorded just one case so far this year, and Nigeria eight.

"India and Nigeria decided to put on the retro-boosters and they dropped their cases from the thousands to below the levels of Pakistan," says Bruce Aylward, an assistant director-general at the WHO and head of the polio eradication campaign. "All of a sudden Pakistan is in the glare."

Pakistan is one of four countries in which polio is still endemic (see 'Stubborn holdouts'), but with 144 confirmed cases in 2010, it is the only country in which polio is making a comeback. The worsening situation in Pakistan could put gains elsewhere at risk. "As long as there's polio in any one country it's a threat to every country in the world," says David Heymann, chairman of the board of the UK Health Protection Agency and a former assistant director-general of the WHO involved in polio eradication.

Click for larger image

Climate, population density and other factors make the virus particularly infectious in Pakistan, Aylward says, requiring child vaccination rates of more than 95% to prevent its rapid spread. Yet immunization rates and surveillance are weak in Pakistan, according to the report released last month by the Independent Monitoring Board. Last year's floods displaced millions of people, spreading the virus and undercutting vaccination efforts. Poor security and religious opposition in the country's Federally Administered Tribal Areas may partly explain low vaccination rates there, but not the polio hotspot in the southern city of Karachi. Unaccountable local government officials and poor health infrastructure also plague many districts where polio has held on, according to the monitoring board report and WHO officials.

Donald Henderson of the Center for Biosecurity at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center in Baltimore, Maryland, who led the WHO's war on smallpox in the 1960s and 1970s, says that smallpox also lingered in Pakistan long after it was eradicated from India and Bangladesh, which had similar natural obstacles to eradication. "To be experiencing polio is kind of a paradox," he says. "There's something seriously wrong with their health services."

Pakistan's government has not ignored the problem. In January, the country rolled out an emergency action plan, with the goal of halting virus transmission by the end of 2011. The plan seeks greater accountability at all levels of government to boost immunization rates, and it calls for health officials to work with the military and local leaders in tribal areas to build support for vaccination. Frustrated with the lack of progress reported at the April meeting, President Zardari also ordered an investigation into recent polio outbreaks in Sindh and Balochistan, and formed a new oversight committee to keep him personally informed about eradication efforts.

Yet some fear that looming constitutional reforms could make it harder for Pakistan to exterminate polio. The country is set to devolve its Ministry of Health by the end of June, part of a long-delayed move to transfer more power to provincial governments. Bill Gates, whose Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation in Seattle, Washington, funds polio eradication programmes, has expressed concern about the changes directly to Zardari. Sania Nishtar, a health-policy expert who heads Heartfile, an independent health-policy think tank in Islamabad, worries that without a central health authority to coordinate international donors' efforts and vaccine procurement and distribution, Pakistan's polio campaign will suffer.

ADVERTISEMENT

Aylward, however, believes that the constitutional change is a "manageable risk". With eradication funding in Pakistan expected to reach US$137.5 million over the next two years, he wants to see clear signs of success. He hopes that the campaign will stop transmission of the virus by the end of 2012. In the meantime, after a couple of large vaccination campaigns, officials will assess whether the virus has vanished from some areas of Pakistan, and will look for a decline in the genetic diversity of the remaining virus — that would suggest that polio is on its last legs.

Simply blaming Pakistan for inaction is unhelpful, Aylward adds. "Everybody wants a whipping boy," he says. "Let's help them get this finished. This is our Alamo." 

See Comment page 446

Comments

If you find something abusive or inappropriate or which does not otherwise comply with our Terms or Community Guidelines, please select the relevant 'Report this comment' link.

Comments on this thread are vetted after posting.

  • #60523

    Doesn’t Bali have a very high number of cases of Antibiotic-resistant Polio strains? Granted, it’s smaller than Pakistan, but it would seem to me to be crucial, when speaking of Global eradication. The poverty there has played a large part in creating conditions suitable for these strains to “breed”.
    Jack at knol

  • #62215

    I think it's just because it's unusual and odd looking, not something you see every day.

Commenting is now closed.