Reconstructing the dynamic response of the Antarctic ice sheets to warming during the Last Glacial Termination (LGT; 18,000–11,650 yrs ago) allows us to disentangle ice-climate feedbacks that are key to improving future projections. Whilst the sequence of events during this period is reasonably well-known, relatively poor chronological control has precluded precise alignment of ice, atmospheric and marine records, making it difficult to assess relationships between Antarctic ice-sheet (AIS) dynamics, climate change and sea level. Here we present results from a highly-resolved ‘horizontal ice core’ from the Weddell Sea Embayment, which records millennial-scale AIS dynamics across this extensive region. Counterintuitively, we find AIS mass-loss across the full duration of the Antarctic Cold Reversal (ACR; 14,600–12,700 yrs ago), with stabilisation during the subsequent millennia of atmospheric warming. Earth-system and ice-sheet modelling suggests these contrasting trends were likely Antarctic-wide, sustained by feedbacks amplified by the delivery of Circumpolar Deep Water onto the continental shelf. Given the anti-phase relationship between inter-hemispheric climate trends across the LGT our findings demonstrate that Southern Ocean-AIS feedbacks were controlled by global atmospheric teleconnections. With increasing stratification of the Southern Ocean and intensification of mid-latitude westerly winds today, such teleconnections could amplify AIS mass loss and accelerate global sea-level rise.
Understanding centennial to millennial-scale variability of the Earth’s ice sheets is key to gaining insights into ice sheet-climate feedbacks1,2, and quantifying their contribution to past and future environmental change3,4. This is important, as despite mounting evidence of significant changes in AIS dynamics5, Southern Ocean6, and atmospheric circulation7, current projections of global mean sea level (GMSL) imply only moderate increases by the end of the twenty-first century3. These projections, however, do not fully include ice-sheet-ocean dynamic feedbacks which are believed to have triggered rapid continental ice-sheet retreat and driven periods of abrupt sea-level rise during the geological past2,8. The LGT offers a potential process analogue for future climate trends, characterised by multi-millennial global warming, poleward migrating and strengthening westerly winds9, and increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide levels10, similar in magnitude to future projections4.
During the LGT, long-term warming was interrupted by the ~2,000-year duration cold event across the mid to high latitude Southern Hemisphere, known as the Antarctic Cold Reversal11,12, which was associated with a ~35 m GMSL rise. Within the ACR, Meltwater Pulse 1A (MWP-1A) forms a prominent abrupt rise in sea level of ~16 m (14,700–14,300 years or 14.7–14.3 ka) that has been a major focus of previous studies, and which was coincident with a period of enhanced iceberg flux in the Southern Ocean2. However, the actual contribution of the AIS during this period remains unclear13,14 due to the paucity of geological records capable of resolving ice-sheet volume changes in such a dynamic contemporary ice sheet setting15, and the difficulties in precisely aligning the chronologies of marine and terrestrial sequences2,11. While the contribution of AIS to GMSL rise during MWP-1A range from ‘high-end’ scenarios (>10 m contributing over half of the total GMSL rise), to ‘low-end’ (scenarios with little to no contribution), the AIS input (if any) during the ACR and the subsequent period of sustained Southern Hemisphere warming remains debated14,16,17. Crucially, the role of the AIS in global climate-ocean dynamics during the LGT remain uncertain11,18. An improved understanding of the links between AIS stability and ice-ocean-climate feedbacks throughout the LGT (i.e. not just MWP-1A), and its relationship to Northern Hemisphere changes, is therefore critical for improving projections of sea-level rise3,4 and understanding ice-sheet-climate feedbacks2,17 in detail.
Here we take a novel approach that investigates a new 800 m long ‘horizontal ice core’ that captures a unique record of ice-sheet dynamics and climate across the Weddell Sea Embayment (WSE)19, a region which today drains more than one-fifth of the ice-mass of continental Antarctica, including sectors of the East and West Antarctic ice sheets and the Antarctic Peninsula (Fig. 1A).
We report results from an exposed ancient blue ice area (BIA) outcropping alongside Patriot Hills in Horseshoe Valley (Fig. 1A), a locally sourced compound glacier that is buttressed by, but ultimately coalesces with the Institute Ice Stream close to the contemporary grounding line of the AIS20, making the site highly sensitive to elevation changes across the broader WSE region21. Geochemically identified volcanic (tephra) horizons along with multiple trace gas species (CO2, CH4 and N2O) provide key age tie points across the profile (Fig. 2; Methods and Supplementary Information), and demonstrate that the profile spans from ~2.5 to 50 ka, with two unconformities (discontinuities D1 and D2; Fig. 1B) that mark the build up to, and deglaciation from, the Last Glacial Maximum (see Methods)20. The conformable BIA layers or ‘isochrons’ between these two unconformities span ~11 to ~23 ka, capturing a unique highly-resolved record of ice-sheet dynamics across the LGT in an area of exceptionally slow-moving ice20 (Fig. 1B).
The water stable isotope deuterium (δD) from the Patriot Hills BIA identifies a two-stepped change in values during the LGT, with a ~39‰ increase recorded across the ACR between ~14.7–12.7 ka, followed by a millennial-duration isotopic plateau (~12.7–11.7 ka) (Fig. 3G). Using a regionally applied δD–temperature relationship of 6.4 ± 1.3‰ per °C22, the Patriot Hills record implies an increase in annual temperature of ~6 °C across the ACR with little to no subsequent change up to ~11.7 ka; comparable trends are also recorded in the δ18O profile (SI Figure S6). The deuterium excess values demonstrate there is no significant regime shift across the profile during the LGT, suggesting no change in precipitation source, or the sign of the isotope-temperature relationship (Fig. 2). These apparent temperature changes are in marked contrast to regional climate records across continental Antarctica23 and the Antarctic Peninsula22 that show a clear plateau/reversal in the warming trend during the ACR (Fig. 3). Given the isolated nature of Horseshoe Valley both during contemporary times and at the LGT19,20, and the buttressing effect of the AIS on ice flow from the valley (Fig. 1), we interpret the isotopic trend captured in the Patriot Hills BIA as the result of ice-sheet elevation changes due to mass loss across the broader WSE21 (see Methods). Thus, increasing δD (and δ18O; Supplementary Information) water isotope values across the ACR and the apparent local warming can only reflect regional ice-sheet draw down. The isotopic profile that followed (~12.7–11.7 ka) appears to reflect a stabilisation of ice-sheet elevation for approximately a millennium.
The marked change in δD captured in the record across the ACR implies an ice-sheet surface elevation decrease of ~615 m across Horseshoe Valley (at a rate of ~0.4 m/a), assuming an atmospheric lapse rate of 10 °C/km24. This rate of change across the WSE is similar to that inferred from terrestrial cosmogenic isotope studies of mid-Holocene glacier thinning in the WSE25, and lower than recorded in the Amundsen Sea sector of the West Antarctic in recent decades5. Importantly, the projected elevation changes represent absolute minima. If the effects of regional ACR cooling and potential glacial isostatic rebound are included this value would exceed ~800 m. The period of mass loss we identify in the WSE parallels a period of enhanced iceberg-rafted debris flux as recorded in marine sediments from the Scotia Sea (Fig. 3D)2, strongly indicating enhanced AIS iceberg discharge was sustained across the ACR (that included but was not limited to MWP-1A). Importantly, during the subsequent period, modelled ice-sheet outputs (see Methods) suggest a marked reduction in AIS drawdown between 12.7 and 11.7 ka (Fig. 3E and Supplementary Information), consistent within the uncertainties of the Patriot Hills BIA chronology (Supplementary Information) of invariant stable isotope values following the ACR (Fig. 3G).
The regional climate and sea-level fingerprint of the ACR across the mid- to high-latitude Southern Hemisphere is difficult to reconcile. Recent modelling studies have demonstrated that it is possible to reconstruct the spatial pattern without substantial fresh water forcing in the Southern Ocean11,14. However, our modelling, together with the results of previous studies2,13,18, suggests that a significant fresh water input into the Southern Ocean provides a potential trigger for the ACR signal, a hypothesis supported by our field data. Our inferred decoupling of ice-sheet elevation from air temperature across the LGT implies ocean forcing was a primary driver of Antarctic-wide ice-sheet dynamics through this period. Independent ice-sheet modelling experiments, driven by transient Earth System Model (LOVECLIM) outputs that include fresh water hosing in the Ross and Weddell seas17 (see Supplementary Information), predict similar changes in ice-sheet geometry and ice-flow dynamics (Figs 3 and 4 and Supplementary Information). The modelled increase in freshwater flux strongly suggests the drawdown of the AIS during the ACR was sustained by a positive feedback operating within the Southern Ocean. Crucially, we find a freshening of surface waters leads to a weakening of Southern Ocean overturning, resulting in reduced Antarctic Bottom Water (AABW) formation, enhanced stratification and sea-ice expansion17 (Fig. 4). The increased delivery of relatively warm Circumpolar Deep Water (CDW)26 onto the continental shelf close to the grounding line of the AIS thermally erodes marine-based ice, maintaining a positive ice-ocean feedback (Fig. 4)17. High resolution ice sheet modelling suggests that this mechanism predicts increases in ice mass loss across the AIS during the ACR in excess of 800 Gt/a, with an average of ~400 Gt/a, making a GMSL contribution of ~0.3 to 0.1 m per century17, importantly this rate almost doubles during the period defined by MWP-1A (Fig. 3E). Modelling of the following millennium implies a marked reduction in mass loss from all sectors of the AIS including the Weddell Sea (Fig. 3E), reflecting reduced Southern Ocean stratification and resumption of AABW formation post ACR, in agreement with our observations from the Patriot Hills BIA.
The coincidence between changes in AIS elevation from the Patriot Hills, enhanced iceberg flux2, atmospheric temperature trends22,23, and Southern Hemisphere mid-latitude westerly airflow9 through the LGT (Fig. 3B,C) implies a tight coupling between the ice-ocean-atmosphere system. Recent work using absolutely-dated tree ring chronologies has identified an abrupt increase in the inter-hemispheric radiocarbon gradient as a result of increased upwelling of 14CO2–depleted abyssal waters from 12.7 ka12, coincident with the maximum southerly extent of the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) and strengthening Southern Hemisphere Westerlies (SHW)9. Our results are consistent with these findings, suggesting that weaker SHW during the ACR enhanced Southern Ocean stratification and maintained a positive ice-sheet-ocean feedback that drove substantial drawdown of the AIS (Fig. 4). This positive feedback appears to have only been disrupted by the re-expansion of the tropical belt and Hadley circulation during subsequent Northern Hemisphere cooling, and anti-phase southern warming after 12.7 ka (Fig. 3), suggesting AIS dynamics are highly sensitive to global atmospheric circulation.
The Patriot Hills preserves a record of significant AIS ice-sheet drawdown, mass loss and meltwater discharge during the ACR and across the LGT, contrasting markedly with previous interpretations of the configuration in the Weddell Sea sector of the AIS, which predict limited ice sheet drawdown since the local Last Glacial Maximum (LGM)15. Previous terrestrial reconstructions, based upon cosmogenic isotope analysis, predict a maximum thinning of ~480 m since the LGM, that occurred predominately during the mid-Holocene, suggesting that the WSE only made a minor contribution to GMSL rise since the LGM25. These estimates contrast with model-based reconstructions from far-field sites16, recent ice-sheet modelling studies8, reconstructions of IRD in the Scotia Sea2, and, crucially, our estimate of ~600 m of ice sheet surface elevation change across the ACR and MWP-1A (Fig. 3). Whilst we cannot define an upper altitudinal limit of the pre-ACR ice sheet across the WSE, the results reported here are inconsistent with estimates based upon terrestrial cosmogenic reconstructions25.
We suggest these contrasts may reflect two factors: firstly, there is a question over the effectiveness of terrestrial cosmogenic isotope studies to truly reflect the former elevation of the LGM ice-sheet surface in areas of cold based non-erosive polythermalice sheet settings27,28. Secondly, it is possible under a scenario of dynamic deglaciation during the LGT that rapid regional bedrock isostatic variations may have effectively masked rapid ice-sheet elevation changes that have occurred during deglaciation and subsequently during the Holocene (Supplementary Information). Therefore, terrestrial cosmogenic isotope reconstructions from mountains and nunataks across the WSE are only likely to robustly reconstruct ice-sheet surface elevation changes during Holocene deglaciation25,29,30. This is an issue which requires future detailed analysis, with multiple lines of evidence pointing towards a dynamic history of ice-sheet change across the WSE during the Holocene29,30,31, with significant implications for defining the pre-Holocene history of this sector of the AIS. Innovative reconstructions, such as that provided by the Patriot Hills BIA, are urgently required to define in detail dynamic Antarctic ice-climate feedbacks and better constrain the ice sheets contribution to global sea level rise during periods of rapid climate transition such as the LGT.
Supported by marine geological evidence of enhanced iceberg calving2, and independent ice-sheet and Earth system modelling experiments17, the Patriot Hills BIA provides the first direct terrestrial evidence that the Antarctic ice sheet was highly responsive to global ice-ocean-atmosphere feedbacks during the LGT2,17. Modelling suggests this pattern could be Antarctic wide, sustained by ice-ocean feedbacks amplified by the delivery of CDW onto the Antarctic Continental Shelf. The counterintuitive finding of sustained ice-sheet mass loss across this sector of the AIS during a period of atmospheric cooling suggests that Southern Ocean AIS feedbacks were likely modulated by global atmospheric teleconnections during a period of asynchronous hemispheric climate change. Defining the details of these atmosphere-ocean-ice feedbacks is crucial to reducing uncertainty in sea level projections4,32, and understanding the implications of observed high-latitude Southern Hemisphere environmental changes today6,7, which may conspire to amplify future Antarctic ice mass loss.
Description of the Patriot Hills BIA
The characteristics of the Patriot Hills BIA are rare in Antarctic terms, with Horseshoe Valley being a slow flowing (<5 m/a) compound glacier system situated within an over-deepened catchment, that coalesces with the Institute Ice Stream at the periphery of the WSE (Fig. 1), making it highly sensitive to grounding line changes across the WSE33; this contrasts with the relatively insensitive inland ice domes, the sites of traditional ice cores23 (Supplementary Information; Figure S8). In the lee of the Patriot Hills – a small mountain chain at the end of Horseshoe Valley – strong local katabatic winds descend into the valley from the polar plateau, ablating the ice sheet surface, drawing up ancient ice from depth within Horseshoe Valley, and forming the extensive (>800 m) Patriot Hills BIA19,20.
High-resolution analysis of the Patriot Hills BIA using ground-penetrating radar (GPR) demonstrates a remarkably consistent pattern of layering along the 800 m transect out from Patriot Hills with two distinct unconformities at 247 m (D1) and 360 m (D2) along the profile (Fig. 1). These unconformities are interpreted as periods of BIA formation within Horseshoe Valley20, occurring in the lee of mountains in the upper part of Horseshoe Valley during normal ice flow in the build-up to the LGM and at some point during the LGT. This interpretation is further supported by high-resolution ice-sheet modelling and GPR analysis, which concludes that there was no major regional flow direction change into Horseshoe Valley during the buildup of the AIS at the LGM20. Together, these lines of evidence confirm that the ice that accumulated between the unconformities at 247 m (D1) and 360 m (D2) is formed within the valley, thus providing a faithful record of environmental change in the catchment of Horseshoe Valley in response to broader changes across the WSE19,20,21.
The chronology of the Patriot Hills BIA
Chronological control across the profile is provided by Antarctic-wide volcanic tephra horizons at 282 m (~17.8 ka), 279 m (18.2 ka) and 190 m (36.4 ka) (Supplementary Information), and a comprehensive suite of trace gas samples – carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4) and nitrous oxides (N2O) – taken from depth (>3 m) along the BIA transect (Supplementary Information). The trace gases were extracted and measured at CSIRO’s Ocean and Atmosphere ICELAB facility in Melbourne, calibrated to internationally-recognised standards, and aligned to published values reported from EPICA Dome C34,35 (Supplementary Information), providing a conservative range of possible age solutions, which together with the absolute constraints provided by the tephra horizons, allows the development of a robust chronological framework (Supplementary Information) that can be tied directly to the isotopic profile through high-resolution GPR survey19,20. The integrity of the extracted air was further checked using sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) as an indicator of contamination by modern air. The average concentration of 8 samples analysed for SF6 was about 5% of modern day atmospheric concentrations and less than 2% for two of the samples selected to develop the chronology. The available constraints indicate the complete 800-m long Patriot Hills BIA transect spans ~50 to ~2.3 ka. Here we focus on the central section of the record, captured between the unconformities at 247 and 360 m, which, with multiple age ties together with the presence of the volcanic horizons dated to 17.8 ka and 18.2 ka, provides a robust chronology across the Patriot Hills BIA sequence of uninterrupted isochrons (Fig. 1). Further details are available in the Supplementary Information.
δD isotopic measurements at 1 m resolution were performed across the Patriot Hills BIA transect at the Australian Antarctic Division (AAD). These results were confirmed and augmented by δD and δ18O isotopic measurements at 5 m resolution at James Cook University (JCU), and the University of New South Wales (UNSW) ICELAB. At the AAD an on-line chromium reduction method on a EuroVector EuroPyrOH-HT system interfaced in continuous flow mode to an Isoprime isotope ratio mass spectrometer. Analytical precision is <0.5‰ and δD values are expressed relative to the Vienna Standard Mean Ocean Water (VSMOW) scale. To confirm δD values, particularly the rapid transitions across the periods defined by the LGT, δD and δ18O were measured independently at JCU using Diffusion Sampling - Cavity Ring-down Spectrometry (DS-CRDS). This system continuously converts liquid water into water vapour for real-time stable isotope analysis by laser spectroscopy (Picarro L2120-i, Sunnyvale, CA, USA). Each analytical run consisted of 12 standards interspersed with 44 unknown samples. Data processing was performed using a customised Excel™ template and included correction for between-sample memory, instrumental drift and normalisation to the VSMOW scale. Further details are available in the Supplementary Information. Finally, to ensure reproducibility a sub set of samples were rerun at UNSW ICELAB for δD and δ18O using a Las Gatos Research Liquid Water Isotope Analyzer 24d (International Atomic Energy WICO Lab ID. 16117). Reported overall analytical precision on long term ice core standards are <0.32‰ for δD, and <0.13‰ for δ18O values are expressed relative to the (VSMOW Scale).
How to cite this article: Fogwill, C.J. et al. Antarctic ice sheet discharge driven by atmosphere-ocean feedbacks at the Last Glacial Termination. Sci. Rep. 7, 39979; doi: 10.1038/srep39979 (2017).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
C.J.F., C.S.M.T. and N.R.G. are supported by their respective Australian Research Council (ARC) and Royal Society of N.Z. fellowships. Fieldwork was undertaken under ARC Linkage Project (LP120200724), supported by Linkage Partner Antarctic Logistics and Expeditions. J.W. and K.W. undertook GPR survey of the Patriot Hills record under NERC grant NE/I027576/1 with logistical field support from the British Antarctic Survey. We thank Dr Chris Hayward for electron microprobe assistance, Dr Nelia Dunbar for providing the Siple Dome data and Kathryn Lacey and Gareth James for help with preparing the tephra samples, CSIRO GASLAB personnel for support of gas analysis, and Prof. Bill Sturges and Dr Sam Allin of the Centre for Ocean and Atmospheric Sciences, University of East Anglia for performing the SF6 analyses. CSIRO’s contribution was supported in part by the Australian Climate Change Science Program (ACCSP), an Australian Government Initiative. SMD acknowledges financial support from Coleg Cymraeg Cenedlaethol and the European Research Council (ERC grant agreement no. 25923), LM acknowledges funding from the ARC (DE150100107). We thank A/Prof. Andrew Mackintosh for detailed discussions over the implications of our data and acknowledge the efforts of two anonymous reviewers whose detailed reviews strengthened the manuscript. The data reported in this paper are archived on the NOAA Paleoclimatology website. The author(s) wish to acknowledge use of the Ferret program for analysis and graphics of the LOVECLIM outputs presented in this paper. Ferret is a product of NOAA’s Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory. (Information is available at http://ferret.pmel.noaa.gov/Ferret/).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/