Accumulation of amyloid-β (Aβ) has been associated with cognitive decline in preclinical Alzheimer disease, but the rate of decline varies widely between individuals. A new study by Yen Ying Lim and colleagues demonstrates that cognitive decline is faster in patients with Aβ accumulation who carry APOE*ɛ4 and BDNFMet alleles than in those carrying APOE*ɛ4 and BDNFVal/Val. APOE*ɛ4 was the strongest modulator of decline: over 4.5 years, little change was observed in patients with other APOE alleles. The results could facilitate estimation of prognosis, and have important implications for future clinical trials.