New research shows that most patients undergoing imaging tests after primary treatment of thyroid cancer have an increased likelihood of being treated for recurrence, but no improvement in disease-specific survival. In a population-based, retrospective cohort study, 28,220 patients in the SEER-Medicare database diagnosed with differentiated thyroid cancer between 1998 and 2013 were followed-up for a median of 69 months. During the period 1998–2013, incident cancer, imaging and treatment for recurrence all increased significantly (rate ratio (RR) 1.05, 1.13 and 1.01, respectively); mortality was not significantly changed (RR 0.98). Neck ultrasonography increased the likelihood of additional surgery (OR 2.30) and 131I treatment (OR 1.45); radioiodine scanning increased the likelihood of additional surgery (OR 3.39), 131I treatment (OR 17.83) and radiotherapy (OR 1.89); and PET increased the likelihood of additional surgery (OR 2.31), 131I treatment (OR 2.13) and radiotherapy (OR 4.98). Disease-specific survival was unaffected by use of neck ultrasonography and PET; however, radioiodine scanning was associated with improved disease-specific survival (HR 0.7).