Abstract
The author has been asked to review the hospital records and X-rays of 12 patients from various regions of the United States who have sustained fracture dislocations of the cervical spine.
In no instance was the initial care considered to be appropriate.
No patient was significantly improved by treatment although only 17 per cent had apparent complete transverse cord syndromes on admission. Sixty-seven per cent of the patients became worse. In the latter group there were three patients who were admitted with either no neurological deficit or only minimal pyramidal signs. All of these three patients became tetraplegic as a consequence of their not being immobilised or placed in traction during periods of many hours to several days after admission.
There is little evidence that the treating physicians understood the need for immediate immobilisation, proper examination, steroid therapy, adequate safe radiological examination, expedited traction, postural adjustments, or follow-up examination. Aftercare was poor, leading to excessive complication. Two patients were transferred in deteriorating condition to other hospitals without safeguards and with adverse result.
The availability and the performance of neurological surgeons during the first critical hours after injury was generally suboptimal. Although all of the patients were admitted within an hour of injury only three were seen by a neurosurgeon within 2 hours of admission. Three patients were seen between 36 hours and 8 days. The remaining six patients were examined between 4 and 36 hours and at an average of 12 hours. Skeletal traction was instituted on an average of 11 hours after admission excluding one case of delay for 9 days. Only two patients had adequate reduction within 28 hours. Steroids were given to eight patients at an average of 6½ hours following admission but usually in inadequate dosage.
Five laminectomies and six anterior fusions were eventually performed. Two patients had both operations. One patient subsequently expired. No patient had a surgically remedial lesion or showed postoperative favourable change in cord function. Five operated patients developed spine deformity, persistent dislocation, spinal canal stenosis or instability.
This care was generally attested to meet proper standards and to represent the treatment ordinarily rendered when academic and qualified neurosurgeons gave testimony regarding it. Neither the funding of care and research, nor the adopted codes governing treatment in accredited hospitals, nor accepted teaching would appear to have influenced the substandard of care provided these patients. Other statistics confirm this to be a prevailing circumstance.
Similar content being viewed by others
Article PDF
References
Albin, M S (1974). Personal communication, July 1.
American Association of Neurological Surgeons (1975). Proposed standards for testimony. Newsletter A.A.N.S., November.
Bailey, I C (1975). Fracture dislocation of the cervical spine with gross displacement. J. Neurosurg. 42, 209–211.
Black, P (1973). Injuries of the vertebral column and spinal cord: mechanisms and management in the acute phase. In The Management of Trauma, ed. W. F. Ballinger, R. B. Rutherford and G. D. Zuidema. W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, pp. 193–218.
Bucy, P C (1973). Editorial: Emergency treatment of spinal cord injury. Surgical Neurology, 1, 216.
Bucy, P C (1973). Editorial: What's wrong with Americans? Surgical Neurology, 1, 354.
Campbell, J B, de Crescito, V, Tomasula, J J, et al., (1973). Experimental treatment of spinal cord contusion in the cat. Surgical Neurology, 1, 102–106.
Cloward, R (1969). Surgical treatment of dislocations and compression fractures of the cervical spine by the anterior approach. Proc. 17th V.A. Spinal Cord Injury Conference, New York, pp. 26–35.
Cloward, R (1973). Skull traction for cervical spine injury: should it be abandoned? Letter to the editor, J. Amer. Med. Assoc. 226, 1008.
Comarr, A E (1959). Laminectomy in patients with injuries of the spinal cord. Journal of the International College of Surgeons, 31, 437–442.
Committee on trauma of the American College of Surgeons (1965). Early Care of Acute Soft Tissue Injuries. W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia and London.
Committee On Trauma Of The American College Of Surgeons (1968). The Management of Fractures and Soft Tissue Injuries. W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia and London.
Committee On Trauma Of American College Of Surgeons (1972). Early Care of the Injured Patient. W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, London, Toronto.
Ducker, T B & Hamit, H F (1969). Experimental treatments of acute spinal cord injury. J. Neurosurg. 30, 693–697.
Ducker, T B & Perot, P L (1972-74). National Spinal Cord Injury Registry: Initial report and newsletters II-V. Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston.
Freed, M M, Bakst, H J & Barrie, D L (1966). Life expectancy, survival rates, and causes of death in civilian patients with spinal cord trauma. Arch. of Physical Med. and Rehab. 47, 457–463.
Gillingham, J (1976). Early management of spinal cord trauma. Neurosurgical Forum J. Neurosurg. 44, 766–767.
Guttmann, L (1963). Initial treatment of traumatic paraplegia and tetraplegia. In Proc. Symp. Spinal Injuries, ed. P. Harris. Roy. Coll. Surg., Edinburgh.
Guttmann, L (1973). Spinal Cord Injuries: Comprehensive Management and Research. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford.
Joint Commission on Accreditation (1970). Emergency services. Accreditation manual for hospitals: standard IV. (December), 4.
Kraus, D R & Stauffer, E S (1975). Spinal cord injury as a complication of elective anterior cervical fusion. Clin. Orth. and Rel. Res. 112, 130–141.
Michaelis, L S (1969). Neurological terminology, prognosis and classification of para-and tetraplegia. Proc. 17th V.A. Spinal Cord Injury Conference, New York, pp. 215–217.
Morgan, T H, Wharton, G W & Austin, G N (1971). The results of laminectomy in patients with incomplete spinal cord injuries. Paraplegia, 9, 14–23.
Nyquist, R H & Bors, E (1967). Mortality and survival in traumatic myelopathy during nineteen years, from 1946 to 1965. Paraplegia, 5, 22–48.
Scarff, T (1960). Injuries of the vertebral column and spinal cord. In Injuries of the Brain and Spinal Cord and their Coverings, ed. S. Brock. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, p. 565.
Sussman, B J (1976). Early management of spinal cord trauma. Neurosurgical Forum J. Neurosurg. 44, 766.
Suwanela, C, Alexander, E & Davis, C H (1962). Prognosis in spinal cord injury with special reference to patients with motor paralysis and sensory preservation. J. Neurosurg. 19, 220–227.
White, R J & Yashon, D C (1973). General care of cervical spine injuries. In Neurological Surgery, ed. J. R. Youmans. W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, pp. 1049–1066.
Yashon, D, Tyson, G & Vise, W M (1975). Rapid closed reduction of cervical fracture dislocations. Surgical Neurology, 4, 513–514.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sussman, B. Fracture dislocation of the cervical spine: a critique of current management in the United States. Spinal Cord 16, 15–38 (1978). https://doi.org/10.1038/sc.1978.5
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sc.1978.5
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Abstracts
Spinal Cord (1985)