Exposure to air particulate matter has been linked with hypertension and blood pressure levels. The metabolic risks of air pollution could vary according to the specific characteristics of each area, and has not been sufficiently evaluated in Spain. We analyzed 1103 individuals, participants in a Spanish nationwide population based cohort study (email@example.com), who were free of hypertension at baseline (2008–2010) and completed a follow-up exam of the cohort (2016–2017). Cohort participants were assigned air pollution concentrations for particulate matter < 10 μm (PM10) and < 2.5 μm (PM2.5) during follow-up (2008–2016) obtained through modeling combined with measurements taken at air quality stations (CHIMERE chemistry-transport model). Mean and SD concentrations of PM10 and PM2.5 were 20.17 ± 3.91 μg/m3 and 10.83 ± 2.08 μg/m3 respectively. During follow-up 282 cases of incident hypertension were recorded. In the fully adjusted model, compared with the lowest quartile of PM10, the multivariate weighted ORs (95% CIs) for developing hypertension with increasing PM10 exposures were 0.82 (0.59–1.14), 1.28 (0.93–1.78) and 1.45 (1.05–2.01) in quartile 2, 3 and 4 respectively (p for a trend of 0.003). The corresponding weighted ORs according to PM2.5 exposures were 0.80 (0.57–1.13), 1.11 (0.80–1.53) and 1.48 (1.09–2.00) (p for trend 0.004). For each 5-μg/m3 increment in PM10 and PM2.5 concentrations, the odds for incident hypertension increased 1.22 (1.06–1.41) p = 0.007 and 1.39 (1.07–1.81) p = 0.02 respectively. In conclusion, our study contributes to assessing the impact of particulate pollution on the incidence of hypertension in Spain, reinforcing the need for improving air quality as much as possible in order to decrease the risk of cardiometabolic disease in the population.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has identified air pollution as the largest single environmental health risk worldwide with outdoor air pollution accounting for more than 4.2 million deaths every year1. Particulate matter (PM) is a widespread air pollutant, consisting of a complex mixture of particles of different sizes and chemistry which are suspended in the air emitted from a range of sources. Particles with an aerodynamic diameter of less than 10 µm (PM10) include those inhalable particles that are sufficiently small to penetrate the respiratory tract. The fine fraction of PM10 includes particles with an aerodynamic diameter of less than 2.5 µm (PM2.5) which have a high probability of deposition in the smaller airways and alveoli. Chronic exposure to PM contributes to the risk of cardiovascular and respiratory diseases1,2. Particulate air pollution can impact the cardiovascular system through a number of mechanisms including endothelial dysfunction, systemic and pulmonary oxidative stress and inflammation, autonomic nervous system dysfunction and epigenetic changes3,4,5,6. Hypertension, as one of the most important risk factors for cardiovascular disease7, could also be a main mediator. Accordingly, a number of experimental and epidemiological studies have described the relationship of both short-term and long-term exposure to ambient air pollutants with hypertension and blood pressure (BP) levels8. However, relatively fewer studies have investigated the association between long-term exposure to PM and the incidence of hypertension prospectively9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16. It is noteworthy that air pollution effects could vary according to the specific air pollution mix of each area, climatic features, the genetic background, as well as the underlying lifestyle and health characteristics of the studied population17. In this regard, previous evidence in the Spanish population has been scarce, and limited to local studies12,18. The firstname.lastname@example.org study provides us with the opportunity to study this phenomenon, from a nationwide population-based study perspective.
The study population was composed of 1103 subjects, without hypertension at baseline, followed up for a mean of 7.4 years (5.8–8.8 years). The baseline characteristics of the study sample are presented in Table 1. Mean age ranged from 18 to 83 years, the percentage of women was 63.4%. Most of the population was Caucasian. The education level, proportion of smokers, drinking behavior, adherence to Mediterranean diet, physical activity and BMI are within the expected range according to the background population. Mean annual ambient temperature ranged between 9.9 and 18.8 °C, whereas mean ambient humidity was between 57 and 79%. A comparison of included and excluded individuals based on these covariates is included in Supplementary Table S1. Residential estimates of outdoor air pollution concentrations during follow-up across the study sample were relatively low, with mean and SD concentrations of PM10 and PM2.5 of 20.17 ± 3.91 μg/m3 and 10.83 ± 2.08 μg/m3 respectively (Table 2), again concordant with the background estimates for the Spanish population.
Incidence of hypertension according to PM10 and PM2.5 concentrations
During follow-up, 282 cases of incident hypertension were recorded (25.6% of the study sample). Table 3 shows the incidence rates, and crude and multivariate weighted ORs and 95% CIs for developing hypertension according to PM10 and PM2.5 concentration quartiles. As can be observed, both higher PM10 and PM2.5 concentrations were significantly associated with increased ORs of incident hypertension with a significant dose response. Multivariate weighted analysis of the data even strengthened the association. In the fully adjusted model, the highest PM10 exposure quartile (PM10 22.80–30.18 μg/m3) was associated with a significant OR for developing hypertension of 1.45 (95% CIs 1.05–2.01), compared with the reference category. Accordingly, the highest PM2.5 exposure quartile (11.80–16.49 μg/m3) was associated with a significant OR for incident hypertension of 1.48 (95% CIs 1.09–2.00). For each 5-μg/m3 increment in PM10 and PM2.5 concentrations the odds for incident hypertension were 1.22 (1.06–1.41) p = 0.007 and 1.39 (1.07–1.81) p = 0.02 respectively.
Subgroup analysis showed that the association was consistent across strata of sex, age, MedScore adherence, physical activity, smoking status, alcohol intake and BMI without any significant effect modification by these factors (Fig. 1).
In this nationwide cohort of Spanish non-hypertensive adults we found a positive association between PM concentrations (both PM10 and PM2.5) and the incidence of hypertension after a mean follow-up of 7.4 years. The association remained after multivariate weighted analysis of the data, showing a significant dose response, and was consistent across various subgroups.
To the best of our knowledge, this report provides the first data about the impact of air pollutants on hypertension in Spain from a National study perspective, whereas previous evidence had been limited to local studies from Northeast Spain18, also included in multicenter studies12.
Our data are consistent with a large body of evidence suggesting that air pollution may contribute to hypertension pathogenesis8, also supporting that the particulate component of air pollution is the most important threat for the cardiovascular system3,4,5,6. In this regard, although previous associations between exposure to gaseous pollutants and hypertension have shown some discrepancies, the majority of the studies reporting on long-term exposure to PM and incident hypertension have reported positive associations which are consistent with our findings9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16.
Interestingly, these associations have now been observed in studies from countries with relatively low concentrations of PM from North America (mean PM2.5 of 10.7 μg/m310, 13.9 μg/m311 and 13.2 μg/m313 and Europe, (mean PM2.5 between 6.6 and 15 μg/m312 and 10.8 μg/m3 in in the present study), and also at highly polluted regions in Asia (mean PM2.5 26.5 μg/m314, 77.7 μg/m315 and 92.1 μg/m316. This strongly suggests that the relation between PM exposures and hypertension development is likely a general phenomenon across different populations and over the pollution range. In fact, the increased incidence of hypertension we describe in our study occurs within PM10 and PM2.5 concentration ranges which are well below the existing European Ambient Air Quality Directive target values (PM10 < 40 µg/m3 and PM2.5 < 25 µg/m3)19. In contrast, our results are in line and reinforce the validity of the maximum annual concentrations for health protection suggested by the WHO (PM10 < 20 µg/m3and PM2.5 < 10 µg/m3)20.
The mechanism by which PM could contribute to the development of hypertension includes inflammation and oxidative stress and the triggering of autonomic nervous system imbalance affecting vascular tone and reactivity3. Epigenetic changes that occur during exposure may also play a role in the interaction between air pollution and Hypertension21,22,23.
Interestingly, controlled studies in humans have confirmed observational results showing that acute inhalation of concentrated particulate matter can trigger a rapid and sustained increase in blood pressure24.
Our study has several limitations:
Firstly, our sample size is relatively small, which can affect the precision of the estimates. Due to the experimental design, the time from event until outcome was not available for analysis. We therefore used logistic regression models to calculate adjusted odds ratios, which are known to overestimate relative risks28.
Secondly, our food frequency questionnaire did not include data on salt consumption of the participants so that we could not adjust our analyses accordingly.
Thirdly, nationwide Spanish noise maps are also not available at present, so we could not adjust our analyses by ambient noise. Nevertheless, although long‐term noise exposure has been linked to incident hypertension in some studies12,29, the results have been inconsistent30. Moreover the associations between PM and hypertension in both cross sectional31,32,33, and longitudinal studies9,12 have not changed substantially after adjustment for noise.
Finally, as in other studies, we used ambient outdoor measurements modeled at the residential addresses of the participants as a proxy for exposure to air pollution, whereas no information on time–activity patterns or on the PM concentrations indoors was available. This is however a common limitation to most studies assessing the health effects of air pollution and, in fact, air quality guidelines focus primarily on ambient (outdoor) air pollution for their recommendations20.
As strengths of the study we included a population-based design with BP measurements of each participant at both baseline and follow-up examinations so we could identify both diagnosed and undiagnosed cases of hypertension.
We have also included extensive individual-level data including clinical, demographic and lifestyle variables which allowed us to perform a robust multivariate adjustment of the data.
Finally, our nationwide perspective, first in the Spanish population, allows us to extrapolate our results more widely than local or regional studies increasing the public health implications of the findings.
In conclusion, our study contributes to assessing the impact of particulate pollution on the incidence of hypertension in Spain. Our results reinforce the need for improving air quality as much as possible to decrease the risk of hypertension in our population, since even moderate levels such as those in this study raise the risk significantly.
Study design, setting and population
The email@example.com epidemiological trial is a population based cohort study. The initial cross-sectional study was undertaken between 2008 and 2010 using a random cluster sampling to form a representative random sample of the Spanish population34. The study sample consisted of 5072 subjects older than 18 years, randomly selected from the National Health System registries distributed into 110 clusters (primary health care centers).
The cohort was re-evaluated in 2016–17 (follow-up time was 7.4 ± 0.5 years).
For the present study, residents in the Canary Islands (no data on emissions available) and subjects who had hypertension or missing data on blood pressure at baseline were excluded from all the incidence calculations. Therefore, the at-risk sample included 2697 people who were residents in the Iberian Peninsula or the Balearic islands and without hypertension at baseline. Of this at-risk sample, 97 individuals had no contact information, 62 individuals had died and 200 had moved from their original location before the follow-up started. 65 other individuals were excluded (because of pregnancy or recent delivery, severe disease, institutionalized, hospitalization, or surgery during the previous month). Of the remaining 2273 individuals, 1103 subjects completed the follow-up, with complete clinical information and BP measurements available for analyses (Fig. 2). The research was carried out in accordance with the Code of Ethics of the World Medical Association (Declaration of Helsinki). Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants. The study was approved by the Ethics and Clinical Investigation Committee of the Hospital Regional Universitario de Málaga (Malaga, Spain) in addition to other regional ethics and clinical investigation committees all over Spain.
Variables and procedures
In both phases of the study, the participants were invited to attend an examination visit at their health center with a nurse specially trained for this project. Information was collected using an interviewer administered structured questionnaire, followed by a physical examination and blood sampling.
Information on age, gender, educational level, ethnicity, smoking status, alcohol intake and other socio-demographic variables was obtained by questionnaire. Food consumption was determined by a food frequency questionnaire and adherence to the Mediterranean diet was estimated by an adaptation of a 14 item Mediterranean diet score (MedScore)35 Supplementary Table S2. The level of daily physical activity was estimated by the short form of the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ)36. Weight and height were measured by standardized methods. The BMI was calculated. Blood pressure was measured using a blood pressure monitor (Hem-703C, Omron, Barcelona, Spain) after several minutes in a sitting position; the mean of 3 measurements taken at least 2 min apart was used for analysis. In both phases of the study, hypertension was considered if there was a previously self-reported physician-diagnosed hypertension and/or if the mean systolic blood pressure was ≥ 140 mmHg and/or the mean diastolic blood pressure was ≥ 90 mmHg7.
The mean annual temperature (°C) and relative humidity (%) from each site was obtained from the Spanish National Meteorological Agency website37.
Mean annual PM2.5 and PM10 concentrations in Spain for the period 2008–2016 were calculated with the CHIMERE chemistry-transport model38 This model calculates the concentration of gaseous species and both inorganic and organic aerosols of primary and secondary origin, including primary particulate matter, mineral dust, sulphate, nitrate, ammonium, secondary organic species and water. This model has been broadly evaluated in Spain by comparison with measured air pollutants at a large set of monitoring sites39,40. The model was applied to a domain covering the Iberian Peninsula at a horizontal resolution of 0.1 × 0.1° (approximately 10 × 10 km2), except for 2015 and 2016, when a resolution of approximately 5 × 5 km2 was used. The modeled concentrations were corrected with observed values, by considering a methodology described by Martín et al.41 in which (1) a bias is calculated with respect to the observations in the Spanish air quality network of monitoring sites, (2) these biases are spatially interpolated using a krigging methodology to obtain a gridded bias, and (3) this gridded bias is applied to the modeled concentration grid. This methodology considers a different bias grid for rural and urban sites that are then combined and weighted by population density. This methodology is currently used to support the Spanish Ministry for Ecological Transition in the process of evaluation and information to the European Commission about the air quality in Spain42.
We combined the mean annual averages from each follow up year into an 8 year moving average. We assigned the 8 year exposure average at each participant address by interpolating the estimated concentrations to the centroid of their residential postal codes. Figure 3 shows the modeled concentrations of PM10 and PM2.5 during the study period in Spain, and the location of study clusters where the crossing between participant addresses and PM exposure estimates was performed.
The study population was categorized into four groups according to the quartiles of the mean 8 year exposures of PM10 and PM2.5 during follow-up (2008–2016). Incidence rates of hypertension during follow-up were estimated on each quartile calculating the incidence rates for each 1000 inhabitant-years (95% confidence interval [CI]). We constructed logistic regression models to calculate the odds ratios for developing hypertension according to the PM10 and PM2.5 categories using the first exposure quartile as a reference. The association of each 5 μg/m3 increment of PM concentrations with incident hypertension was also calculated. To decrease the likelihood of bias we used an inverse probability weighting (IPW) approach by means of the propensity scores method43, using as possible confounding variables age, gender, ethnicity (Caucasian/others), education level (no studies/basic/high school-college), MedScore, IPAQ (low/medium/high)36, alcohol intake (< 30/30–60/ > 60 servings per month), smoking (never-former/current), BMI, BP levels at baseline, ambient temperature and humidity. These variables are all accepted risk factors for hypertension.
In addition, we performed subgroup analyses to test potential effect modifications in the association between PM exposures and incident hypertension by sex (male/female), age (< 40/40–60 or ≥ 60 years), MedScore (< 8 or ≥ 8), IPAQ (low, medium or high), smoking status (never-former or current), alcohol intake (< 30 or ≥ 30 per month) and BMI (< 30 or ≥ 30 kg/m2). Each potential modifier was examined in a separate model by adding an interaction term. We evaluated the significance of effect modification with the likelihood ratio test. Reported p values were based on two-sided tests with statistical significance set at 0.05.
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
WHO | Ambient air pollution: Health impacts [Internet]. WHO. World Health Organization; 2020. Available from: http://www.who.int/airpollution/ambient/health-impacts/en/. Accessed 9 February 2021.
Landrigan, et al. The Lancet Commission on pollution and health. Lancet 391, 462–512 (2018).
Brook, et al. Particulate matter air pollution and cardiovascular disease: An update to the scientific statement from the American Heart Association. Circulation 121, 2331–2378 (2010).
Cosselman, K. E., Navas-Acien, A. & Kaufman, J. D. Environmental factors in cardiovascular disease. Nat. Rev. Cardiol. 11, 627–642 (2015).
Rajagopalan, S., Al-Kindi, S. G. & Brook, R. D. Air pollution and cardiovascular disease: JACC state-of-the-art review. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 17, 2054–2070 (2018).
Al-Kindi, S. G., Brook, R. D., Biswal, S. & Rajagopalan, S. Environmental determinants of cardiovascular disease: Lessons learned from air pollution. Nat. Rev. Cardiol. 10, 656–672 (2020).
Chobanian, A. V. et al. Seventh report of the Joint National Committee on prevention, detection, evaluation, and treatment of high blood pressure. Hypertension 6, 1206–1252 (2003).
Yang, B. Y. et al. Global association between ambient air pollution and blood pressure: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Environ. Pollut. 235, 576–588 (2018).
Coogan, P. F. et al. Air pollution and incidence of hypertension and diabetes mellitus in black women living in Los Angeles. Circulation 125, 767–772 (2012).
Chen, H. et al. Spatial association between ambient fine particulate matter and incident hypertension. Circulation 129, 562–569 (2014).
Zhang, Z., Laden, F., Forman, J. P. & Hart, J. E. Long-term exposure to particulate matter and self-reported hypertension: A prospective analysis in the Nurses’ Health Study. Environ. Health Perspect. 124, 1414–1420 (2016).
Fuks, K. B. et al. Long-term exposure to ambient air pollution and traffic noise and incident hypertension in seven cohorts of the European study of cohorts for air pollution effects (ESCAPE). Eur. Heart J. 38, 983–990 (2017).
Honda, T. et al. Long-term exposure to residential ambient fine and coarse particulate matter and incident hypertension in post-menopausal women. Environ. Int. 105, 79–85 (2017).
Zhang, Z. et al. Long-term exposure to fine particulate matter, blood pressure, and incident hypertension in taiwanese adults. Environ. Health Perspect. 126, 017008 (2018).
Huang, K. et al. Long-term exposure to fine particulate matter and hypertension incidence in China. Hypertension 73, 1195–1201 (2019).
Prabhakaran, D. et al. Exposure to particulate matter is associated with elevated blood pressure and incident hypertension in urban India. Hypertension 76, 1289–1298 (2020).
Samoli, E. et al. Estimating the exposure-response relationships between particulate matter and mortality within the APHEA multicity project. Environ. Health Perspect. 113, 88–95 (2005).
Foraster, M. et al. Association of long-term exposure to traffic-related air pollution with blood pressure and hypertension in an adult population-based cohort in Spain (the REGICOR study). Environ. Health Perspect. 122(4), 404–411 (2014).
Directive 2008/50/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 May 2008 on ambient air quality and cleaner air for Europe. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2008/50/2015-09-18 (2008).
WHO | Air quality guidelines—global update 2005 [Internet]. WHO. World Health Organization. Available at http://www.who.int/airpollution/publications/aqg2005/en/ (2020).
Bellavia, A. et al. DNA hypomethylation, ambient particulate matter, and increased blood pressure: Findings from controlled human exposure experiments. J. Am Heart Assoc. 19, e000212 (2013).
Motta, V. et al. MicroRNAs are associated with blood-pressure effects of exposure to particulate matter: Results from a mediated moderation analysis. Environ. Res. 146, 274–281 (2016).
Holland, N. Future of environmental research in the age of epigenomics and exposomics. Rev. Environ Health. 32, 45–54 (2017).
Cosselman, K. E. et al. Blood pressure response to controlled diesel exhaust exposure in human subjects. Hypertension 59, 943–948 (2012).
Chen, R. et al. Cardiopulmonary benefits of reducing indoor particles of outdoor origin: A randomized, double-blind crossover trial of air purifiers. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 65, 2279–2287 (2015).
Shi, J. et al. Cardiovascular benefits of wearing particulate-filtering respirators: A randomized crossover trial. Environ. Health Perspect. 125, 175–180 (2017).
Morishita, M. et al. Effect of portable air filtration systems on personal exposure to fine particulate matter and blood pressure among residents in a low-income senior facility: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA Intern Med. 178, 1350–1357 (2018).
Schmidt, C. O. & Kohlmann, T. When to use the odds ratio or the relative risk?. Int. J. Public Health 53, 165–167 (2008).
Shin, S. et al. Association between road traffic noise and incidence of diabetes mellitus and hypertension in Toronto, Canada: A population-based cohort study. J. Am. Heart Assoc. 9, e013021 (2020).
van Kempen, E., Casas, M., Pershagen, G. & Foraster, M. WHO environmental noise guidelines for the European region: A systematic review on environmental noise and cardiovascular and metabolic effects: A summary. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 15, 379 (2018).
Sørensen, M. et al. Long-term exposure to traffic-related air pollution associated with blood pressure and self-reported hypertension in a Danish cohort. Environ. Health Perspect. 120, 418–424 (2012).
Babisch, W. et al. Associations between traffic noise, particulate air pollution, hypertension, and isolated systolic hypertension in adults: the KORA study. Environ. Health Perspect. 122, 492–498 (2014).
Fuks, K. B. et al. Arterial blood pressure and long-term exposure to traffic-related air pollution: an analysis in the European Study of Cohorts for Air Pollution Effects (ESCAPE). Environ. Health Perspect. 122, 896–905 (2014).
Soriguer, F. et al. Prevalence of diabetes mellitus and impaired glucose regulation in Spain: the firstname.lastname@example.org Study. Diabetologia. 55, 88–93 (2012).
Schröder, H. et al. A short screener is valid for assessing Mediterranean diet adherence among older Spanish men and women. J. Nutr. 141, 1140–1145 (2011).
International Physical Activity Questionnaire [Internet]. Available from: https://sites.google.com/site/theipaq/ (2020).
Spanish National Meteorological Agency website. Available at: www.aemet.es.
Menut, L. et al. CHIMERE 2013: A model for regional atmospheric composition modelling. Geosci. Model Dev. 6, 981–1028 (2013).
Vivanco, M. G. et al. Multi-year assessment of photochemical air quality simulation over Spain. Environ. Model Softw. 24, 63–73 (2009).
Vivanco, M. G., Azula, O., Palomino, I. & Martín, F. Evaluating the impact of resolution on the predictions of an air quality model over Madrid area (Spain). In Geocomputation, sustainability and environmental planning [Internet] (eds Murgante, B. et al.) 145–62 (Springer, Berlin, 2011).
Martín, F., Palomino, I. & Vivanco, M. G. Combination of measured and modelling data in air quality assessment in Spain. Int. J. Environ. Pollut. 49, 36–44 (2012).
Vivanco, M. G., Theobald, M., Garrido, J. L. & Martin, F. División de Contaminación Atmosférica CIEMAT. Evaluación de la calidad del aire en España utilizando modelización combinada con mediciones. Pre evaluación año 2017 30 Junio 2018 Ref: 10/2018 Available at: https://www.miteco.gob.es/es/calidad-y-evaluacion-ambiental/temas/atmosfera-y-calidad-del-aire/preevaluacion2017-ciemat_final_tcm30-482150.pdf (2018).
Williamson, E. J. & Forbes, A. Introduction to propensity scores. Respirology 19, 625–635 (2014).
The email@example.com project is a collaborative study with various phases and subprojects in which a large number of researchers and technicians have collaborated, to whom we are indebted; we wish to thank Isabel Ramis (CIBERDEM) for her help in the organization of the study. Our profound appreciation goes to the primary care managers and personnel of the participating health centers, to all the fieldworkers, nurses, and technicians and to the study participants for their altruistic participation. Samples were managed by the Hospital Regional Universitario of Malaga-IBIMA Biobank and by the CIBERDEM Biorepository (IDIBAPS Biobank), integrated in the Spanish National Biobank Network.
CIBERDEM (Ministerio de Economía, Industria y Competitividad-ISCIII), Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad-ISCIII, Instituto de Salud Carlos III (PI17/02136, PI20/01322), European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) “A way to build Europe”. Ayudas a la investigación SED 2020. GRM belongs to the regional Nicolás Monardes research program of the Consejería de Salud (C-0060-2012 and RC-0006-2016; Junta de Andalucía, Spain). CMA is recipient of a “Rio Hortega” research contract (CM19/00186, Instituto de Salud Carlos III).
EM has been on advisory boards, has received consulting fees, speaker honoraria or research support from Astra Zeneca, Menarini Laboratories, Merck Sharp and Dohme, Novartis, Novo-Nordisk and Sanofi. The rest of authors declare no competing interests relevant to this article.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Doulatram-Gamgaram, V., Valdés, S., Maldonado-Araque, C. et al. Association between long term exposure to particulate matter and incident hypertension in Spain. Sci Rep 11, 19702 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-99154-7