As a means for investigating human mobility during late the Neolithic to the Copper Age in central and southern Italy, this study presents a novel dataset of enamel oxygen and carbon isotope values (δ18Oca and δ13Cca) from the carbonate fraction of biogenic apatite for one hundred and twenty-six individual teeth coming from two Neolithic and eight Copper Age communities. The measured δ18Oca values suggest a significant role of local sources in the water inputs to the body water, whereas δ13Cca values indicate food resources, principally based on C3 plants. Both δ13Cca and δ18Oca ranges vary substantially when samples are broken down into local populations. Statistically defined thresholds, accounting for intra-site variability, allow the identification of only a few outliers in the eight Copper Age communities, suggesting that sedentary lifestyle rather than extensive mobility characterized the investigated populations. This seems to be also typical of the two studied Neolithic communities. Overall, this research shows that the investigated periods in peninsular Italy differed in mobility pattern from the following Bronze Age communities from more northern areas.
The complex interweaving of cultures associated with human mobility has traditionally represented a jigsaw puzzle for our understanding of the biological, cultural, and social evolution of past populations1. Unfortunately, population dynamics and mobility cannot easily be inferred from the archaeological record alone2 since the simple act of people moving from one place to another does not necessarily leave behind archaeological traces3. Even though mobility could have been a critical element of foragers’ strategies for resource exploitation4,5, it could also underlie other fundamental factors, such as social complexity and population dynamics.
The transition between the Neolithic and the Copper Age (dating around 4th millennium BCE in Italy) marked a tipping point for many aspects of peoples' lifestyles. This transition was accompanied by changes in settlement structures, subsistence strategies, cultural assemblages, and mortuary practices6,7,8.
Farming technologies were refined, and metallic ores such as copper started to be mined and used to produce artefacts in the Copper Age. The introduction of metal processing in the Copper Age led to a significant increase in the commercial trade9 and was complemented by the onset of a complex trade network associated with the movement of people9,10,11,12,13.
Archaeological evidence of goods movements can be integrated with the information retained in the human skeletons. Carbon and nitrogen isotope analysis of bone collagen for dietary reconstruction can provide information on subsistence strategies in human populations, though only rarely shifts in dietary habits have been used to support hypothesis concerning human mobility14,15,16. This is mainly associated with issues of collagen turnover and renewal in living organisms. Conversely, tooth enamel forms during the first years of life, becomes biologically inert, and does not undergo chemical modifications as individual ages17, recording the isotopic composition of dietary inputs during the early stages of life18. Such isotope fingerprint is inherited from the local environment. For this, isotope measurements in tooth enamel are useful for the identification of local and foreign individuals in an area. These investigations, in combination with other archaeological evidences19, prove valuable in addressing questions on human mobility.
Despite the plentiful archaeological surveys, the analysis of settlements and burial grounds in central and southern Italy has not yet provided a coherent picture of mobility dynamics for the Neolithic and Copper Age people. Archaeologists have often interpreted the transitions in typological structures of artefacts and the differences in funerary practices as reflecting a population shift due to mobility. This has been demonstrated in northern Italy but remains questionable in the central and southern Italian peninsula20 and reference therein. Isotope studies on human skeletons therefore represent valuable adjuncts to the few studies of mobility in Italy from the Neolithic to the Bronze Age21,22,23,24,25.
This paper aims at providing a new set of human tooth oxygen and carbon isotope measurements from Neolithic (Mora Cavorso, MC, and Galliano Palagiano, PA) and Copper Age (Buca di Spaccasasso, SS, Fontenoce di Recanati, FR, Celano Pratovecchio, CE, Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi, OC, Casetta Mistici, CM, Torre della Chiesaccia, TC, Pantano Borghese, PB, Grotta Nisco, GN) settlements/funerary areas (Table 1, Supplementary Figure S1)26. The archaeological record for those communities has suggested some mobility dynamics. Pottery typological heterogeneity and a variety of funerary practices, which could be consistent with imported items or deposition cultures developed with increased people mobility, characterized most of the archaeological contexts (Supplementary Information). However, the degree of mobility in each community cannot be assessed through the sole archaeological data, which could reflect only cultural diffusion. Indeed, the isotopic signatures provide a reliable disclosure of individuals’ mobility patterns, representing a valuable contribution to the comprehensive characterization of the Italian Neolithic and Copper Age communities.
Overall, the sites cover about 2000 years and the studied samples provide a glimpse of human mobility in peninsular Italy for the addressed periods.
Our collection includes all the available skeletal material for these periods in the considered geographical areas, as granted by the Institutions involved in the project. Indeed, this investigation might be slightly biased due to specific population features but, despite some potential cultural peculiarities, our research aims to provide enamel oxygen and carbon isotopic signatures for these prehistoric Italian communities and therefore generate a novel cross-sectional overview of population dynamics and the extent of individual mobilities at the time. Future studies will likely implement our preliminary research once new sample collections are available.
Several isotopic markers are used in palaeo-mobility research27,28. The most applied are oxygen and strontium isotopes from tooth enamel28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35, while the isotopes of other elements are seldom applied for this topic32,35,36,37,38. Mobility research via oxygen isotopes relies on site-specific isotopic signatures to gauge where people might have lived during the period of skeletal mineralization. Oxygen isotopes can be extracted from enamel, dentine, or bone samples. Human tooth enamel forms during childhood and adolescence38,39 and remains unaltered through adulthood. Tooth dentine grows incrementally during tooth formation with negligible remodeling later in life40, even though secondary and tertiary dentine keeps forming after tooth completion, making this tissue not completely isotopically inert. Bone tissue is instead continuously remodeled in life.
Individuals develop typical isotopic signatures based on the composition of foodstuff and water they consume. If dietary supplies are local, body signatures should reflect the isotopic fingerprinting of the regions where people live41,42. The isotopic features of the environment are in turn related to typical parameters such as temperature and precipitation, which influence in different ways both the carbon and the oxygen isotopes expressed in vegetation and drinking waters43. Oxygen enters the body water through drinking, eating, and breathing, and it is partially removed with respiration and discarded liquids and vapor44,45,46. Despite a metabolic fractionation between body water and tissues, oxygen isotopes in biological tissues are related to the water inputs to the diet and can thus be used to investigate human compatibility to a certain area47. Carbon isotopes reflect the local vegetation and can discern plants following C3 versus C4 metabolic cycles, as well as the consumption of marine resources48, as this information is transferred to the tissues of organisms feeding on those resources.
Thus, isotopes in skeletal remains are suitable proxies to investigate mobility and can assist in disentangling larger bioarchaeological questions at the community level42. This approach is however not devoid of complications: for example, a local signature can overlap with regions characterized by comparable environment43,49 or the same can be altered by food and drink manipulation.
Oxygen isotope values can be extracted from two components of biological apatite: carbonate (CO3) and phosphate (PO4); their isotopic signatures will hereafter be indicated as δ18Oca and δ18Op, respectively49,50,51,52,53,54. The relationship between δ18Op and δ18Oca with drinking water in humans is well established44,53,55,56,57. While measurements of δ18Oca is a robust and cost-effective method, which is often preferred over δ18Op measurements since it comes with the carbon isotope information (δ13Cca), the carbonate fraction of bioapatite is also more prone to postmortem alteration than the phosphate fraction53,58, for which extreme care has to be taken in its interpretation. Once converted to drinking water (δ18Odw), measured skeletal δ18Oca values can be compared with local mapped ground- or meteoric-water isotope values59,60, making it possible to evaluate if an individual signature is consistent with that expected for local people. However, the isotopic features of rainwaters in an area depend on local climate conditions, that could change through time, and rainwater is often not the sole source of drinking water for humans. Thus, the conversion of oxygen isotopes from skeletal items to environmental waters, is not straightforward57,61.
Alternative interpretative methods are based on geostatistical elaboration of skeletal δ18O values to assess the expected biological compositions for a specific area34,35,62. In this paper, we employed both approaches.
Some further complexities in isotopic mobility studies are associated to: different individual dietary habits (cooking, infusing, poaching); potential consumption of modified or imported water sources (e.g., wine, beers, etc.); drinking waters coming from further away (rivers) or that may have undergone extensive evaporations (lakes), and metabolic effects47,50,63,64,65.
Additionally, mineralized tissues such as tooth enamel might record an 18O enrichment due to breastfeeding until weaning starts, with later forming tissues scoring values closer to adult ranges64,65,66,67,68. However, this enrichment is not systematically observed, and may be blurred in many archaeological records because the collections could be composed of individuals whose breastfeeding was completed at different ages, or that may have grown up in slightly different climatic conditions. Therefore, the possibility of an increase in δ18Oca in juvenile teeth must be considered.
To summarize, although the isotopic approach to mobility is challenging, it can provide valuable insights into past human movements and interactions.
Oxygen isotope values (δ18Oca reported vs. V-SMOW69) and carbon isotope values (δ13Cca vs. V-PDB) were measured in the carbonate fraction of tooth enamel apatite of 126 individuals pertaining to 10 funerary contexts in central and southern Italy (Table S3).
Most of the samples cluster in a range from 24‰ to 28‰ in δ18O and from about − 15 to − 11‰ in δ13Cca (Fig. 1). Some samples from Mora Cavorso (MC) and Fontenoce di Recanati (FR) show a shift towards more 13C-enriched values.
Oxygen isotopes show a difference between the individuals from Fontenoce di Recanati (FR) and Celano Pratovecchio (CE), with typically lower δ18O values, and those from the other burial sites here investigated.
The Neolithic sites of Mora Cavorso (MC) and Galliano-Palagiano (PA) show intermediate δ18O values, with the former showing similar results to the nearest Copper Age sites (Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi, OC, Casetta Mistici, CM, Torre della Chiesaccia, TC, Pantano Borghese, PB); Galliano-Palagiano (PA) has values lower than the nearest Copper Age site in Apulia (Grotta Nisco, GN) (Fig. 2).
Since breastfeeding could affect the δ18O values in our investigated teeth, systematic 18O enrichment66 in deciduous teeth and M1s was checked. Results were compared to enamel values from permanent teeth, which should be unhampered or minimally affected by the breastfeeding effect. All the values obtained from deciduous teeth fall within the range of adults or possibly weaned people in every site, and no systematic offset is detected (expected on the range of 0.5–2‰64), even though the limited sample size could partially mask this phenomenon (Fig. 3).
Measured oxygen isotope values were converted to environmental waters57 to assess general consistency between the bioapatite record of each group with local water sources, and to compare the ranges with those of (current) precipitations in the geographic areas of recovery. The results of these conversions are reported for each site in Table S1.
The individuals from Buca di Spaccasasso (SS, n = 50), located near the Tyrrhenian coast (southern Tuscany), show the highest δ18O values recorded in this study. These values have a mean of 26.8 ± 0.6 ‰, and converted to environmental water values they give an interval of − 6.0 ± 0.9 ‰ (Table S1), consistent with modern waters for the area, ranging between − 5 and − 6‰59,60.
Human teeth from Grotta Nisco (GN, n = 7) show similarly high δ18O values (26.9 ± 0.5 ‰), which converted to environmental waters give values of − 6.0 ± 0.9‰, (Table S1) consistent with modern local precipitations (− 6 to − 7‰72,73).
The Copper Age sites of Fontenoce di Recanati (FR) and Celano (CE) overlap, with mean δ18O of 24.4 ± 1.2‰ (n = 18) and 24.5 ± 0.3‰ (n = 3), respectively. The converted values from Celano are consistent with those of modern precipitations in the area (− 9.7 ± 0.4‰) but those of Fontenoce seem to be lower compared to the range of modern precipitations (− 9.9 ± 1.9‰)59,60.
Samples from Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi (OC), Casetta Mistici(CM), Torre della Chiesaccia (TC), and Pantano Borghese (PB), all coming from Rome area, overlap and have similar δ18O medians (Pantano Borghese, PB-Torre della Chiesaccia, TC, n = 2; T-test − 0.73; p = 0.25; Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi (OC), Casetta Mistici (CM) and the Pantano Borghese-Torre della Chiesaccia group, n = 16;7;7 Kruskal–Wallis H = 1.85; p = 0.40). The proximity of these sites (Fig. 4), their contemporaneity, and similarity in isotopic results make them suitable for grouping together for statistical analysis. The median of “Rome Copper Age group” for δ18O is 26.2 ‰ ± 0.7 (n = 30), and the, converted to environmental waters57, gives values averaging − 7.1‰ ± 1.1, consistent with the − 6 to − 7‰ range for modern waters in the area59,60,74,75,76. Mora Cavorso samples have a converted mean value for environmental water slightly lower than the Roman sites (− 7.5 ± 0.9 ‰).
The samples of the Neolithic site of Galliano-Palagiano (PA) have an average value of 25.4 ± 0.7‰ (n = 9). The calculated environmental water (− 8.3 ± 1.1 ‰) is significantly lower than the expected value for the site59,60.
Carbon delta values are mostly restricted to a range of − 14 to − 11‰ in all sites (Fig. 5); some samples from Mora Cavorso (MC), however, diverge substantially, showing values as high as − 4‰.
The samples investigated in this study cover a timeframe of several centuries and possibly various environmental conditions. Provided that the calculated environmental water (Table S1) values are comparable with modern rainwaters, there is a correspondence between water and skeletal values in most cases, even though it must be considered that indeed some climate fluctuations have characterised the Middle Holocene70,71, and these likely had effects on the rainwater oxygen isotope ratios. With this in mind, we could observe that converted values from the samples of Buca di Spaccasasso (SS), Grotta Nisco (GN) and all the sites scattered in the Roman area are consistent with modern precipitations; the lower values recorded at Celano Pratovecchio (CE) might instead be associated to the location of this site on the Apennines mountain chain, with peaks higher than 2000 mt a.s.l.. These areas are typically characterised by low mean annual temperatures and consequent low δ18O values in precipitations59,60,72,73. The samples from Fontenoce di Recanati (FR) are also characterised by relative low oxygen isotope values, though this site is located at a much lower altitude than Celano (CE). It is however sited at the foothills of the range and it is reasonable to assume that the water sources for this site could have been springs or riverine waters fed by precipitations falling at higher elevations, similar to those available at Celano (CE).
It can also be assumed that, given the relative low values typical of the samples from the site of Galliano-Palagiano (PA), despite its location, the primary source of drinking water originated at higher elevations in the Apennines77. Clearly, the drinking water at this site compositionally differed from the one supplying the Copper Age community buried in the other Apulian site of Grotta Nisco (GN), for which the calculated δ18Odw is − 5.9 ± 0.8‰. A possible explanation for the observed difference, besides the use of different water resources, could be that they experienced different climatic conditions70,78.
Overall, the implication suggested by the results is that most of the populations investigated relied on local, unmodified water sources for their needs.
The attempt to identify non local people was pursued via an individual δ18O signature evaluation in comparison with that of the local population, assuming that the majority of the investigated skeletons represents resident people. The deciduous teeth values fall among adults δ18O values (Fig. 3), showing that despite stable oxygen isotope analysis from bulk sampling could be used empirically to reconstruct weaning ages, successful identification of this practice depend on multiple factors63,79,80,81,82,83 and does not systematically result in a detectable rise of the isotopic signature.
To estimate the presence of possible outliers in each site, we followed the discussion in Lightfoot and O’Connell62.
The whole range of δ18O values from tooth bioapatite at Buca di Spaccasasso (SS) is 3.4‰. If the MAD threshold is applied (MADQ3) (see62 and reference therein) (n = 50, Shapiro–Wilk test W = 0.95; p = 0.02), one sample can be spotted as an outlier (SPS_23p at 24.7‰) by all the four statistical evaluations and should be considered a newcomer.
SPS_25p (25.4‰), SPS_44p (28.1‰) and SPS11p (25.5‰) are outside the range obtained using 2‰ offset from the mean, but only SPS_25p is highlighted as a “not local” by 1,5IQR range.
The lowermost skeletal values are too depleted in 18O compared to the rest of the people from the same site: they result in converted values for the d18Odw of about -9.3‰ and, even considering the mathematical error associated with the conversion of 1–2‰57,61, they seem to be more pertinent to individuals from the highlands of the Apennine, the Alps, but also other regions further away in north-western Europe. These individuals seem more typical, for example, to the highlands of the Apennines or the Alps, but also to other regions further away in north-west Europe. The identification of their exact origin is impossible with the current available data.
The δ13Cca for the individuals identified as outliers does not differ substantially compared to the rest of the people from Buca di Spaccasasso (SS).
Grave goods with noteworthy typological features from the ossuary enclosure seem to indicate a deep similarity with some southern Tuscany and Conelle contexts in the Marche region. This evidence could suggest a mobility pattern involving both southern areas of Tuscany and upper Latium and the trans-Apennines areas such as the Marche region. A remarkable presence of items typologically inspired to the southern-Italian Laterza cultural complex, mainly set in Apulia, is also remarkable84. This link seems to be also suggested by dietary habits analyses85,86 that highlighted a common exploitation typology between people at Buca di Spaccasasso (SS) and the community buried in the Apulian site of Grotta Nisco (GN).
The δ18O range for Fontenoce di Recanati (FR) is 4.7‰, from 21.6 to 26.3‰ (Table 2). The application of the 3MADnorm threshold reduces the locality-range to 4.2‰ (from 22.3 to 26.5‰) (n = 18, Shapiro–Wilk test W = 0.95 p = 0.47). The range excluded FRN 6.1, set beyond the lower end of the range, while a second individual (FRN 19.1) sits at the boundary. These two individuals lie outside the locality range also for 1.5IQR and the 2‰ offset from the mean. The identified outliers were buried in multiple graves containing at least two individuals, even though the non local features are derived from only one member of each skeletal couple. FN6.1 was a baby buried in association with a specific funerary ceremony involving the deliberate slaughter of a dog. This kind of ritual process seems to be quite widespread in the Italian peninsula since the Neolithic87,88 and was also found in the Abruzzi Neolithic site of Grotta Continenza.
FN19.1 was a man buried with an infant, with no evidence to be considered a newcomer.
Given the similarities in the environmental settings and the same δ18O patterns, all the samples from the Copper Age sites around Rome were grouped to enhance the statistical power.
The range of values is 3.8‰ (Table 2). The 1.5IQR reduces this range to 1.6‰ for considering local individuals (from 25.4 to 27‰). The application of Tukey’s 1.5IQR method allows us to detect 6 individuals (CF2.2, CF7.3, CF17, CF24, CF27, T1NEC) as atypical in the context of the site, and four of these (CF2.2, CF7.3, CF27, T1NEC) showed δ18O values outside of the MADQ3 range too57 (n = 30, Shapiro–Wilk test W = 0.87, p = 0.00). Three of those individuals pertain to Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi (OC CF2.2, CF7.3, CF27), and one from Casetta Mistici (CM T1NEC). Finally, by employing the 2σ deviation from the mean value, only one extreme individual from Osteria del CuratoVia Cinquefrondi (OC CF2.2) can be identified as an outlier, and the same is also obtained by setting the threshold at 2‰ from the mean. None of the identified outliers for δ18O have unusual δ13Cca values.
CF7.3 was a child secondarily buried in a “grotticella” tomb, which is typically related to the Rinaldone-style multiple burials in the Rome area, containing both synchronic and diachronic remains. CF7.2 was a teenager buried in the same tomb but whose oxygen isotope signature supports a local origin, thus the same multiple burial could have hosted people of various origins, synchronically buried or not.
CF2.2 (4032 ± 45 BP, cal. 2σ 2700–2460 B.C.) and CF27 (4030 ± 65 BP, cal. 2σ 2900–2300 B.C.)89 were young adults referred to the Ortucchio culture complex recovered in different areas of the Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi site (OC). This cultural frame could be related to a sort of modification of the pre-existing Laterza culture framework in Latium, due to the spread of Bell Beaker culture from northern regions towards central Italy89. This cultural modification seems to have been accomplished through contact among people carrying out substantial changes in ceramic production. CF24 and CF17 (3919 ± 45 BP, cal. 2σ 2500–2280 B.C.) could also be categorized as Ortucchio-related tombs, but their goods seem to distinguish their status. Indeed, CF24 owned a generic vase and a single used arrowhead close to the body, while CF17 was buried with a pottery bowl that was ritually broken and put close to the pelvis. The rest of the people buried with broken pots show these items placed by the side of the head, suggesting a unique feature for this woman, possibly of non-indigenous origin. However, the relatively high δ18O value could also be related to metabolic alterations as diffuse periostitis on her long bones and heavy alveolar resorption in the jaws are present90.
The non-local origin of sample T1 in Casetta Mistici (CM)91 was previously hypothesized due to the southern spread of the Rinaldone culture complex, a cultural prospect mainly based in Tuscany, Umbria, and Marche. The topographical scattering of that tomb is also remarkable because the T1 child was recovered in the burial ground located outside the settlement itself. Despite the early age at death, this individual does not show a clear indication for breastfeeding as he/she is characterized by an isotopic value depleted in 18O compared to the local range of people. This evidence seems to be remarkable for considering this child coming from elsewhere with his/her mother possibly not be represented in the analysed samples.
The sample size for each of the Neolithic sites is rather small and accordingly, the statistical elaborations are less powerful. However, their analysis is still of considerable interest due to the different chronologies with the previous sites and some peculiarities. The data at Galliano-Palagiano (PA) shows a range of 2.1‰ (Table 2) and, after setting the thresholds for the proposed indicators, we identify one putative newcomer (PAL10; detected by the MAD method). The mean oxygen isotopes signature for this site is quite different from what would be expected based on its location and this result could be consistent with the funerary usage of the site by people coming from the neighboring areas (Supplementary material). A similar scenario of low range mobility was also deduced by strontium isotope analysis in other Neolithic sites from northern Apulia21.
Mora Cavorso (MC) deserved a more in-depth approach as the carbon isotope values seem worth discussing. Generally, in this study, δ13Cca is consistent with a C3 plant-based diet. However, δ13Cca at Mora Cavorso (MC) ranges from − 11.1 to − 3.8‰. Apart from a few individuals (12, 11?, 13*, and possibly 11*, with − 11.1‰, − 11.3‰, − 10.8‰, and − 9.7‰, respectively), the rest of the people have unusually 13C enriched values (δ13Cca ranging from − 3.8‰ to − 7.0‰). These people with data at odd with the general trend might potentially represent individuals originated in other geographical areas, and therefore individuals that have relocated to this site after childhood.
At first glance, these unusual values could also be consistent with a contribution of C4 plants to the diet, even though the consumption of marine food cannot be ruled out92. This hypothesis is puzzling as C4 plants consumption in the Italian peninsula is assumed to have started in the Bronze Age14. Besides, the topographic location of Mora Cavorso (MC) seems incompatible with the exploitation of marine fish. The bioapatite results of Mora Cavorso (MC) are also incongruous with those from collagen of individuals from the same site, ranging from 19.7 to − 20.5‰, and thus suggesting a diet principally based on C393. This holds true even taking into account that collagen and bioapatite δ13C may record different components of the diet, with the former92 reflecting mainly the protein fraction, and the latter the entire diet (carbohydrates, lipids, and proteins)94. Although the presence of C4 plants in the area is unrealistic, also tooth enamel of two herbivores (one sheep and one deer) investigated at this site gave similar results (δ13Cca: − 5.4‰ and − 6.8‰, δ18Oca: 25.6‰ and 25.2‰, respectively), while faunal collagen δ13C data93 ranges from − 18.6 to − 23.6‰, thus suggesting a variable diet. Therefore, the peculiar δ13Cca in some of the individuals at Mora Cavorso (MC) could also be primarily interpreted with a diet based on the consumption of 13C-enriched prays.
One of the possible explanations, however, is still that the protocol of pre-treatments have changed the pristine isotopic composition of these samples95,96,97, even though, in this case, the biological signature should have been modified by several per mils to reach the observed values, which seems rather unrealistic.
Diagenetic changes from secondary carbonate of the karst cave should also be assumed as a confounding factor.
To check the occurrence of post-mortem carbonate contaminations of the Mora Cavorso (MC) samples, the bioapatite measurements were plotted against the carbonate values of two speleothems sampled from the same cave (Supplementary Table 4; Fig. 6), one formed during the MIS5 ca. 126 kya) and the other one formed during the Holocene, and representative of the tufa covering the archaeological sequence.
The teeth from Mora Cavorso (MC) lie between the carbonate composition of the two speleothems in the cave. They are also between the carbonate composition of most of the other teeth analysed, representative of human variability at the time, and the Holocene karst precipitations, on which the archaeological record is embedded. This evidence suggests that the chemistry of the teeth might have been modified by circulating fluids in the cave, with a critical impact on the carbon isotope composition. The δ18O in the teeth have instead a similar range to most of the investigated teeth, and any interaction with a fluid of similar composition would not be so evident.
None of the explanations above can fully justify the results from Mora Cavorso (MC) at this stage, therefore, no reliable hypothesis on the mobility pattern of this population can be completed.
Compared to the oxygen isotope results for the Bronze Age communities from northern Italy22,23,24,25, our study shows little evidence of extensive mobility in the central and southern Italy in earlier communities. This is consistent with the sulphur data of Bronze Age central Italian samples, where only a few individuals were considered as newcomers at Grotta dello Scoglietto23. The mobility patterns of Neolithic and Copper Ages people in these areas seem far from those related to social strategies of the northern Italian Bronze Age people who switched from a residential-based mobility during the Early Bronze Age to socially and politically motivated displacements with the progressive stabilization of the settlements22. Moreover, the data obtained in this study seems to support the idea that Neolithic and Copper Age people from central Italy were generally sedentary, and sporadic mobility was associated with a few individuals. Our results support the observations provided for Neolithic communities in Apulia, where a sedentary lifestyle was preferred despite the widespread of social and economic interactions and the presence of specific sites where people coming from elsewhere were buried21.
This study presents the first set of tooth bioapatite isotope data from Italian Copper Age and Neolithic sites. The δ18O from the carbonate fraction of bioapatite shows significant differences between people buried at different funerary areas of the Italian peninsula but indicating a good relationship between the measured values and the local water sources. Overall, the number of outliers identified is quite small, suggesting that mobility was rather sporadic in the Copper Age and perhaps linked to small groups, and this seems to be even more sporadic in the Neolithic communities.
Convincing outliers were identified at the Copper Age sites from Rome, Fontenoce di Recanati (FR) and Buca di Spaccasasso (SS). These results are consistent with the archaeological record, supporting contacts among people fostering the typological circulations in central and southern Italian Copper Age.
The lack of a comprehensive osteological characterization of each individual, mainly due to a combination of poor skeletal preservation and the nature of bone assemblage, prevents the demographic assessment of the putative identified newcomers in some sites. Although the relatively small number of individuals might limit the robustness of the observations, this study represents a valuable contribution for investigating the mobility patterns of Italian prehistoric communities, which is a crucial topic in Italian archaeology. An increase in sample size is mandatory to frame the wide archaeological and anthropological scenario properly; a supplementary genomic analysis would also help to identify the origins of the recognized newcomers.
One hundred and twenty-six teeth from people buried at ten central and southern Italian sites of Neolithic (Galliano Palagiano, PA, in Apulia, and Mora Cavorso, MC, in Latium) and Copper Age (Buca di Spaccasasso, SS, in Tuscany, Fontenoce di Recanati, FR, in Marche, Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi, OC, Casetta Mistici, CM, Torre della Chiesaccia, TC, and, Pantano Borghese, PB, in Latium, Celano Pratovecchio, CE, in Abruzzi and Grotta Nisco, GN, in Apulia) were collected and analyzed for this study (Table 1). Details of the funerary contexts are in Supplementary Information section. Permission for managing the materials and their use in this research were obtained by the formal commitment from each Superintendence, responsible for the anthropological remains.
The investigated teeth are primarily permanent M2, and comprise a range of other teeth, including some deciduous. The availability of skeletal items of choice is limited in the selected sites; therefore, to obtain some statistical representation of the investigated populations, it was decided to analyze all accessible teeth, regardless of the life-stage of the individuals they would represent. Accordingly, the analysis includes teeth formed at a very young age, potentially biased by the breastfeeding effect. However, it has been observed that, although there is a known trend in deciduous and early-forming teeth (such as incisors and M1) to be enriched in 18O with breastfeeding, such enrichment is not systematic66. Nevertheless, specific care was taken in interpreting these results and a comparison between deciduous and permanent teeth was carried out.
The description and archaeological background of each site are provided in the Supplementary material. Most of the sites suggest the presence of putative non-local migration due to the recovery of non-local items and various funerary practices. All the recovered skeletons at each site have been screened and the individual selection was driven by the presence of teeth and their good macroscopic preservation status. The basic demographic parameters of these specimens were marked according to classical anthropological methods98,99 and are provided in Supplementary Table S2. Only one tooth per individual was sampled. At Buca di Spaccasasso (SS), no anthropological evaluation could be performed due to the nature of the bone assemblage (see Supplementary material). Accordingly, only the right second molars from the mandibles were sampled for this site.
The identification of the dental elements for sampling was carried out by following odontological criteria100. Whenever possible, the second molar was selected, though in some cases different dental elements were chosen. Regardless the fact that different teeth might result in a slight bias since they represent various periods in a person’s life, we chose to sample as many individuals as possible for this isotopic study. Bulk sampling in each tooth at a fixed distance from the root-enamel junction in a consistent manner was performed64,101. Indeed, the sampling for permanent teeth was performed by drilling the buccal areas superior to the enamel-root junction (ERJ)68, and reference herein even though we are conscious of extensive discussion of methodological approaches that could mitigate inter-teeth sampling. This strategy allows us to collect data related to the post-weaning period for incisors, canines and first and second molars (3.5–6 years). Few premolars and third molars were included in the sampling even though the isotopic information provided could be related to the subsequent ontogenetic period.
Furthermore, few deciduous teeth were sampled to preliminarily investigate the role of confounding factors such as breastfeeding in mobility-related oxygen isotopes analysis.
Teeth were mechanically abraded and cleaned to remove soil and exogenous materials. They were then soaked in 0.1 M acetic acid for 2 h at room temperature to remove external diagenetic precipitates such as secondary carbonate97,102, followed by a rinsing step with deionized water and overnight drying at 37 °C. An aliquot of 25 mg/tooth of enamel was drilled and treated according to Sponheimer103: 1.8 ml NaOCl (2.5%) was added to the sample for 1 h and subsequently removed by three washing steps in deionized water. The powder was then treated with 1.8 ml acetic acid 0.1 M for 1 h and rinsed again three times. The lyophilization procedure returned a purified enamel powder to be analyzed by mass spectrometry. Approximately 2 mg of enamel powder was measured in duplicate along with three internal standards (MC-200, CaCO3—Merck CCM, and Solnhofen limestone—SLNF, calibrated against international standards NBS18 and NBS19) to normalize the raw δ18Oca and δ13Cca values to the V-PDB scale. Repeated analyses of internal carbonate standards (n ≫ 30) yield 1std dev < 0.1‰ for both δ13Cca and δ18Oca. An aliquot of the enamel powder for each sample was weighed and placed into empty vials and analyzed by a Thermo Scientific™ Gas Bench II connected to a Thermo Delta Plus isotope ratio mass spectrometer. The data obtained were normalized by a linear calibration equation derived from a plot of accepted versus measured values for the three aforementioned internal standards.
This also allows an easier comparison with previously published data from tooth carbonate in Italy and with phosphate oxygen isotope measurements produced from bioapatite, from which it is expected an offset of about 7–9‰53,57,105,106. Given, however, that this conversion could be associated with small mathematical errors, statistical analysis was performed on both the raw and the calibrated results, with no difference between the outcomes.
The equation provided in Chenery et al.57, was applied to convert teeth values to environmental water values (δ18Odw): δ18Odw = 1.59 * δ18Oca(V-SMOW) − 48.634.
Values are reported by violin plots: this type of plot, similar to other types of box plots, make it possible to visualize the distribution of data in a population, with the box embedded inside indicating the lower and upper quartile (i.e. the interquartile range, IQR) and the middle line indicating the median for the distribution of the values. The lower and upper whiskers indicate the spread of values outside the interquartile range (i.e. the values that are below the 25% and above the 75% mark). Single dots outside the whiskers represent the outliers in the population107.
Descriptive statistics and comparison tests have been performed by R v.3.6.1108, which makes it possible to draw the boxplot describing the variability of the data in each site and to perform the Shapiro–Wilk test to check the goodness of fit to the normal distribution of the dataset. The significance threshold was set equal to p = 0.05.
To estimate the presence of possible outliers in each site, we followed a statistical approach as discussed in Lightfoot and O’Connell62. Thresholds were set as: (a) 2σ deviation from the mean, (b) 3 times (MAD) (Median Absolute Deviation) from the median, for normal distribution of the data (MADnorm) or non-normal distribution of the data (MADQ3), (c) 1.5 Interquartile Range (IQR), and (d) 2‰ offset from the mean (Table 3). The statistical approach for the identification of outliers was applied only for those groups with a sufficiently high number of individuals (i.e., n ≥ 9). This limit was set to perform the statistical analysis in as many sites as possible, since sample size for each funerary context varies and generally comprise small communities. The validity of these results might however be questionable, since Lightfoot and O’Connell62 indicated 25 as the suitable sample size for this approach, a number hard to obtain in most archaeological Italian contexts for these periods.
Samples of the speleothems from Grotta Cavorso for stable isotope ratios were obtained with an air-drill 1 mm drilling bit. Stable isotope compositions (oxygen and carbon) were measured using an Analytical Precision AP2003 IRMS at the University of Melbourne on CO2 gas released by reaction with 105% H3PO4 at 70 °C. Results were normalized using an internal working standard (NEW1, Carrara Marble), calibrated against the international standards NBS18 and NBS19. Results are reported on the VPDB scale with the δ-notation in per mill (‰). Mean analytical uncertainties are 0.10‰ and 0.05‰ for δ18O and δ13C, respectively. Maps were generated using Esri ArcMap 10.4.1 software109.
Gori, M., Revello Lami, M. & Pintucci, A. Human Mobility in Archaeology: Practices, Representations and Meanings (Archaeopress, Oxford, 2019).
Jochim, M. A. Archaeology as a long-term etnography. Am. Anthropol. 93, 308–321 (1991).
Close, A. E. Reconstructing movement in prehistory. J. Archaeol. Method Theory 7, 49–77 (2000).
Jones, E. L. Mobility, settlement, and resource patchiness in Upper Paleolithic Iberia. Quatern. Int. 318, 46–52 (2013).
Gallagher, E., Shennan, S. & Thomas, M. G. Food income and the evolution of forager mobility. Sci. Rep. 9, 1–10 (2019).
Kostov, R. I. Precious and decorative minerals from the Eneolithic necropolis in Northeastern Bulgaria and their significance in the history of gemology. In YBG (ed. Bulgarian Geological Society) 205–208 (Bulgarian Geological Society, Sofia, 2005).
Chapman, R. Emerging Complexity: The Later Prehistory of South-East Spain, Iberia, and the West Mediterranean (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1990).
García Sanjuán, L., Lucianez Trivino, M., Schuhmacher, T. X., Wheatley, D. & Banerjee, A. Ivory craftsmanship, trade and social significance in the southern Iberian Copper Age: the evidence from the PP4-Montelirio sector of Valencina de la Concepción (Seville, Spain). Eur. J. Archaeol. 16, 610–635 (2013).
Barfield, L.H. L’Europa nel 3500 a.C.: una congiuntura tra diffusione e crisi ambientale? in Il declino del mondo neolitico. Ricerche in Italia centro-settentrionale tra aspetti peninsulari, occidentali e nord-alpini (eds. Ferrari, A. & Visentini, P.) 11–18 (Atti Convegno, 2002).
Leonini, V. & Sarti, L. Sepolture e rituali funerari nell’Eneolitico in Italia in La cultura del morire nelle società preistoriche e protostoriche italiane (ed. Martini, F.) 129–160 (Origines, 2006).
Cazzella, A. & Guidi, A. Il concetto di Eneolitico in Italia in Atti della XLIII Riunione Scientifica dell’Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, 2008 25–32 (Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, 2011).
Cocchi Genick, D. Problematiche e prospettive della ricerca sull’età del rame in Italia in ricordo di Gianni Bailo Modesti in Atti della XLIII Riunione Scientifica dell’Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, 2008 13–24 (Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, 2011).
Recchia, G. & Baroni, I. Aspetti demografici nell'analisi delle comunità eneolitiche dell'Italia centro-meridionale in Atti della XLIII Riunione Scientifica dell'Istituto Italiano di Preistoria Istituto Italiano di Preistoria 49–56 (IIPP, 2011).
Tafuri, M. A., Craig, O. E. & Canci, A. Stable isotope evidence for the consumption of millet and other plants in Bronze Age Italy. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 139, 146–153 (2009).
Hakenbeck, S., McManus, E., Geisler, H., Grupe, G. & O’Connell, T. Diet and mobility in Early Medieval Bavaria: a study of carbon and nitrogen stable isotopes. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 143, 235–249 (2010).
Parker Pearson, M. et al. Bell Beaker people in Britain: migration, mobility and diet. Antiquity 90, 620–637 (2016).
Hillson, S. Teeth (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2005).
Passey, B. H. & Cerling, T. E. Tooth enamel mineralization in ungulates: implications for recovering a primary isotopic time-series. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 66, 3225–3234 (2002).
Armada, X. L., Murillo-Barroso, M. & Charlton, M. Metals, Minds and Mobility Integrating Scientific Data with Archaeological Theory (Oxbow, San Francisco, 2018).
Dolfini, A. From the Neolithic to the Bronze Age in Central Italy: settlement, burial, and social change at the dawn of metal production. J. Archaeol. Res. 28, 503–556 (2019).
Tafuri, M. A. et al. Life and death in Neolithic Southeastern Italy: the strontium isotopic evidence. Int. J. Osteoarchaeol. 26, 1045–1057 (2016).
Cavazzuti, C. et al. Flows of people in villages and large centres in Bronze Age Italy through strontium and oxygen isotopes. PLoS ONE 14, e0209693 (2019).
Varalli, A., Moggi-Cecchi, J., Moroni, A. & Goude, G. Dietary variability during Bronze Age in Central Italy: first results. Int. J. Osteoarchaeol. 26, 431–446 (2016).
Sparacello, V. S. et al. The re-discovery of Arma dell’Aquila (Finale Ligure, Italy): New insights on Neolithic funerary behavior from the sixth millennium BCE in the north-western Mediterranean. Quatern. Int. 512, 67–81 (2019).
Varalli, A. et al. Dietary continuity vs. discontinuity in Bronze Age Italy. The isotopic evidence from Arano di Cellore (Illasi, Verona, Italy). J. Archaeol. Sci. Rep. 7, 104–113 (2016).
De Angelis, F. et al. Eneolithic subsistence economy in Central Italy: first dietary reconstructions through stable isotopes. Archaeol. Anthropol. Sci. 11, 4171–4186 (2019).
Pflug, K.P., Schuster, K.D., Pichotka, J.P. & Forstel, H. Fractionation effects of oxygen isotopes in mammals. In Stable Isotopes: Proceedings of the Third International Conference (ed. Klein, E.R. & Klein, P.D.) 553–561 (Academic Press, New York, 1979).
Reiter, S. & Frei, K. M. Interpreting past human mobility patterns: a model. Eur. J. Archaeol. 22, 454–469 (2019).
Evans, J. A., Chenery, C. A. & Fitzpatrick, A. P. Bronze Age childhood migration of individuals near Stonehenge, revealed by strontium and oxygen isotope tooth enamel analysis. Archaeometry 48, 309–321 (2006).
Eckardt, H. et al. Oxygen and strontium isotope evidence for mobility in Roman Winchester. J. Archaeol. Sci. 36, 2816–2825 (2009).
Guede, I. et al. Isotope analyses to explore diet and mobility in a medieval Muslim population at Tauste (NE Spain). PLoS ONE 12, E0176572 (2017).
Killgrove, K. & Montgomery, J. All roads lead to Rome: exploring human migration to the eternal city through biochemistry of skeletons from two imperial-era cemeteries (1st–3rd C AD). PLoS ONE 11, E0147585 (2016).
Pellegrini, M., Pouncett, J., Jay, M., Pearson, M. P. & Richards, M. P. Tooth enamel oxygen “isoscapes” show a high degree of human mobility in prehistoric Britain. Sci. Rep. 6, 34986 (2016).
Laffoon, J. E. et al. Investigating human geographic origins using dual-isotope (87Sr/86Sr, Δ18O) assignment approaches. PLoS ONE 12, E0172562 (2017).
Montgomery, J. et al. Strategic and sporadic marine consumption at the onset of the Neolithic: increasing temporal resolution in the isotope evidence. Antiquity 87, 1060–1072 (2013).
Font, L., Jonker, G., van Aalderen, P. A., Schiltmans, E. F. & Davies, G. R. Provenancing of unidentified World War II casualties: application of strontium and oxygen isotope analysis in tooth enamel. Sci. Justice 55, 10–17 (2015).
Valentine, B. et al. Evidence for patterns of selective urban migration in the Greater Indus Valley (2600–1900 BC): a lead and strontium isotope mortuary analysis. PLoS ONE 10, E0123103 (2015).
Paladin, A. et al. Early medieval Italian Alps: reconstructing diet and mobility in the valleys. Archaeol. Anthropol. Sci. 12, 82–102 (2020).
Reid, D. J. & Dean, M. C. Variation in modern human enamel formation times. J. Hum. Evol. 50, 329–346 (2006).
Nanci, A. T. Cate’s Oral Histology-E-Book: Development, Structure, and Function (Elsevier Health Sciences, Amsterdam, 2017).
Katzenberg, M. Stable isotope analysis: a tool for studying past diet, demography, and life history. In Biological Anthropology of the Human Skeleton (eds Katzenberg, M. & Saunders, S.) 413–422 (Wiley-Liss, New York, 2008).
Perry, M. A. Bioarchaeology and Behavior: The People of the Ancient Near East (University Press of Florida, Gainesville, 2012).
Knudson, K. J. & Price, T. D. Utility of multiple chemical techniques in archaeological residential mobility studies: case studies from Tiwanaku- and Chiribaya-affiliated sites in the Andes. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 132, 25–39 (2007).
Longinelli, A. Oxygen isotopes in mammal bone phosphate: a new tool for paleohydrological and paleoclimatological research?. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 48, 385–390 (1984).
Luz, B., Kolodny, Y. & Horowitz, M. Fractionation of oxygen isotopes between mammalian bone phosphate and environmental drinking-water. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 48, 1689–1693 (1984).
Bryant, J. D. & Froelich, P. N. A model of oxygen isotope fractionation in body water of large mammals. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 59, 4523–4537 (1995).
Daux, V. et al. Oxygen isotope fractionation between human phosphate and water revisited. J. Hum. Evol. 55, 1138–1147 (2008).
Schoeninger, M. J. & DeNiro, M. J. Nitrogen and carbon isotopic composition of bone collagen from marine and terrestrial animals. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 48, 625–639 (1984).
Elliot, J. C., Holcomb, D. W. & Young, R. A. Infrared determination of the degree of substitution of hydroxyl by carbonate ions in human dental enamel. Calcif. Tissue Int. 37, 372–375 (1985).
Killgrove, K. Identifying immigrants to imperial Rome using strontium isotope analysis in Roman diasporas: archaeological approaches to mobility and diversity in the Roman Empire. J. Rom. Archaeol. Suppl. 78, 157–174 (2010).
Kolodny, Y. & Luz, B. Oxygen isotopes in phosphates of fossil fish devonian to recent in Stable Isotope Geochemistry: A Tribute To Samuel Epstein (eds. Taylor, H.P. et al.) 105–119 (Geochem. Soc., 1991).
Bryant, J. D., Koch, P. L., Froelich, P. N., Showers, W. J. & Genna, B. J. Oxygen isotope partitioning between phosphate and carbonate in mammalian apatite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 60, 5145–5148 (1996).
Iacumin, P., Bocherens, H., Mariotti, A. & Longinelli, A. Oxygen isotope analyses of coexisting carbonate and phosphate in biogenic apatite: a way to monitor diagenetic alteration of bone phosphate. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 142, 1–6 (1996).
Pellegrini, M., Lee-Thorp, J. A. & Donahue, R. E. Exploring the variation of the δ18Op and δ18Oc relationship in enamel increments. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol. 310, 71–83 (2011).
Luz, B. & Kolodny, Y. Oxygen isotope variations in phosphate of biogenic apatites. IV. Mammal teeth and bones. Earth Planet Sci. Lett. 75, 29–36 (1985).
Kohn, M. J. & Cerling, T. E. Stable isotope compositions of biological apatite. Rev. Mineral. Geochem. 48, 455–488 (2002).
Chenery, C. A., Pashley, V., Lamb, A. L., Sloane, H. J. & Evans, J. A. The oxygen isotope relationship between the phosphate and structural carbonate fractions of human bioapatite. Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 26, 309–319 (2012).
Zazzo, A., Lécuyer, C. & Mariotti, A. Experimentally-controlled carbon and oxygen isotope exchange between bioapatites and water under inorganic and microbially-mediated conditions. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 68, 1–12 (2004).
Longinelli, A. & Selmo, E. Isotopic composition of precipitation in Italy: a first overall map. J. Hydrol. 270, 75–88 (2003).
Giustini, F., Brilli, M. & Patera, A. Mapping oxygen stable isotopes of precipitation in Italy. J. Hydrol. Reg. Stud. 8, 162–181 (2016).
Pollard, A. M. et al. “These boots were made for walking”: the isotopic analysis of a roman inhumation from Gravesend, Kent, UK. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 146, 446–456 (2011).
Lightfoot, E. & O’Connell, T. C. On the use of biomineral oxygen isotope data to identify human migrants in the archaeological record: intra-sample variation, statistical methods and geographical considerations. PLoS ONE 11, E0153850 (2016).
Brettell, R., Montgomery, J. & Evans, J. Brewing & stewing: the effect of culturally mediated behaviour on the oxygen isotope composition of ingested fluids and the implications for human provenance studies. J. Anal. At. Spectrom. 27, 778–785 (2012).
Britton, K., Fuller, B. T., Tütken, T., Mays, S. & Richards, M. P. American oxygen isotope analysis of human bone phosphate evidences weaning age in archaeological populations. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 157, 226–241 (2015).
Kohn, M. J. Predicting animal δ18O: accounting for diet and physiological adaptation. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 60, 4811–4829 (1996).
Wright, L. E. & Schwarcz, H. P. Stable carbon and oxygen isotopes in human tooth enamel: identifying breastfeeding and weaning in prehistory. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 106, 1–18 (1998).
Evans, J. A., Chenery, C. & Montgomery, J. A summary of strontium and oxygen isotope variation in archaeological human tooth enamel excavated from Britain. J. Anal. At/ Spectrom. 27, 754–764 (2012).
Pederzani, S. & Britton, K. Oxygen isotopes in bioarchaeology: principles and applications, challenges and opportunities. Earth Sci. Rev. 188, 77–107 (2019).
Brand, W. A., Coplen, T. B., Vogl, J., Rosner, M. & Prohaska, T. Assessment of international reference materials for isotope-ratio analysis (IUPAC technical report). Pure Appl. Chem. 86, 425–467 (2014).
Giraudi, C., Magny, M., Zanchetta, G. & Drysdale, R. N. The Holocene climatic evolution of Mediterranean Italy: a review of the continental geological data. The Holocene 21, 105–115 (2011).
Kaniewski, D. et al. Climate change and social unrest: a 6000-year chronicle from the Eastern Mediterranean. Geophys. Res. Lett. 47, e2020GL087496 (2020).
Tazioli, A. et al. Estimating the isotopic altitude gradient for hydrogeological studies in mountainous areas: are the low-yield springs suitable? insights from the Northern Apennines of Italy. Water 11, 1764–1780 (2019).
Petitta, M., Fracchiolla, D., Aravena, R., Aravena, M. & Barbieri, M. Application of isotopic and geochemical tools for the evaluation of nitrogen cycling in an agricultural basin, the Fucino Plain, Central Italy. J. Hydrol. 372, 124–135 (2009).
Sappa, G., Ergul, S. & Ferranti, F. Vulnerability assessment of Mazzoccolo Spring Aquifer (Central Italy), combined with geo-chemical and isotope modeling. In Engineering Geology for Society and Territory-Volume 5 (eds Lollino, G. et al.) 1387–1392 (Springer, Berlin, 2015).
Giggenbach, W. F., Minissale, A. A. & Scandiffio, G. Isotopic and chemical assessment of geothermal potential of the Collialbani Area, Latium Region, Italy. Appl. Geochem. 3, 475–486 (1988).
Carucci, V., Petitta, M. & Aravena, R. Interaction between shallow and deep aquifers in the Tivoli Plain (Central Italy) enhanced by groundwater extraction: a multi-isotope approach and geochemical modelling. Appl. Geochem. 27, 266–280 (2012).
Parisi, S. et al. Groundwater recharge areas of a volcanic aquifer system inferred from hydraulic, hydrogeochemical and stable isotope data: mount vulture, Southern Italy. Hydrogeol. J. 19, 133–153 (2011).
Zanchetta, G. et al. Enhanced rainfall in the Western Mediterranean during deposition of sapropel S1: stalagmite evidence from Corchia cave (Central Italy). Quatern. Sci. Rev. 26, 279–286 (2007).
Tsutaya, T. & Yoneda, M. Reconstruction of breastfeeding and weaning practices using stable isotope and trace element analyses: a review. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 156, 2–21 (2015).
Fuller, B. T., Fuller, J. L., Harris, D. A. & Hedges, R. E. M. Detection of breastfeeding and weaning in modern human infants with carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 129, 279–293 (2006).
Beaumont, J., Gledhill, A., Lee-Thorp, J. & Montgomery, J. Childhood diet: a closer examination of the evidence from dental tissues using stable isotope analysis of incremental human dentine*. Archaeometry 55, 277–295 (2013).
Eerkens, J. W. & Bartelink, E. J. Sex-biased weaning and early childhood diet among middle holocene hunter–gatherers in Central California. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 152, 471–483 (2013).
Wood, J. W. et al. The osteological paradox: problems of inferring prehistoric health from skeletal samples [and comments and reply]. Curr. Anthropol. 33, 343–370 (1992).
Volante, N. & Sarti, L. Caves and shelters in the Uccellina Mountains (Alberese – Grosseto)—funerary practices and rituals during the Bronze and Copper Ages at Grotta dello Scoglietto and Buca di Spaccasasso. In Papers in Italian Archaeology VII, the archaeology of death (eds Herring, E. & O’Donoghue, E.) 399–409 (National University of Ireland, Dublin, 2018).
Martínez-Labarga, C. et al. Palaeodiet in Central and Southern Italy from Upper Palaeolithic to Eneolithic in Biological and Cultural Heritage of the Central-Southern Italian Population Through 30 Thousand Years. EPIC (Eredità della Popolazione dell'Italia Centro-Meridionale) (ed. Rickards, O. & Sarti, L.) 137–152 (Universitalia, 2016).
De Angelis, F. et al. Eneolithic subsistence economy in Central Italy: first dietary reconstructions through stable isotopes. Archaeol. Anthropol. Sci. 11, 4171–4186 (2019).
Cultraro, M. La tomba 6 di Fontenoce/area Guzzini di Recanati (Macerata) e il rituale del sacrificio del cane in atti della XXXVIII Riunione Scientifica dell’Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, 2003 481–493 (Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, 2005).
Silvestrini, M. & Pignocchi, G. The Eneolithic necropolis of Fontenoce/Guzzini area in Atti della XXXIII Riunione Scientifica dell'Istituto Italiano di Preistoria. 123–126. (Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria, 1997).
Carboni, G. & Anzidei, A. L’Eneolitico recente e finale nel Lazio centro-meridionale: una puntualizzazione sullo sviluppo e la durata di alcuni aspetti culturali sulla base delle più recenti datazioni radiometriche in Cronologia assoluta e relativa dell’età del Rame in Italia (ed. Cocchi Genick, D.) 91–118 (QuiEdit, 2013).
Lysenko, O. B. et al. Biogenic chemical elements isotope ratios in living organism as a new potential indicator of physiological state. J. Phys. Chem. Biophys. 6, 218–229 (2016).
Anzidei, A.P. et al. Il Gaudo a Sud del Tevere: Abitati e Necropoli dall’area Romana in Atti della XLIII Riunione Scientifica dell’Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria. 309–321 (Istituto Italiano Preistoria e Protostoria, 2011).
Loftus, E. & Sealy, J. Technical note: interpreting stable carbon isotopes in human tooth enamel: an examination of tissue spacings from South Africa. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 147, 499–507 (2012).
Scorrano, G. et al. Effect of Neolithic transition on an Italian Community: Mora Cavorso (Jenne, Rome). Archaeol. Anthropol. Sci. 11, 1443–1459 (2019).
Royer, A., Daux, V., Fourel, F. & Lécuyer, C. Carbon, nitrogen and oxygen isotope fractionation during food cooking: implications for the interpretation of the fossil human record. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 163, 759–771 (2017).
Pellegrini, M. & Snoeck, C. Comparing bioapatite carbonate pre-treatments for isotopic measurements: part 2—impact on carbon and oxygen isotope compositions. Chem. Geol. 420, 88–96 (2016).
Snoeck, C. & Pellegrini, M. Comparing bioapatite carbonate pre-treatments for isotopic measurements: part 1—impact on structure and chemical composition. Chem. Geol. 417, 394–440 (2015).
Koch, P. L., Tuross, N. & Fogel, M. L. The effects of sample treatment and diagenesis on the isotopic integrity of carbonate in biogenic hydroxylapatite. J. Archael. Sci. 24, 417–429 (1997).
Acsádi, G. & Nemeskéri, J. History of Human Life Span and Mortality (Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest, 1970).
Meindl, R. S., Lovejoy, C. O., Mensforth, R. P. & Walker, R. A. A revised method of age determination using the Os pubis, with a review and tests of accuracy of other current methods of pubis symphyseal aging. Am. J. Phys. Anthropol. 68, 29–45 (1985).
White, T. D., Black, M. T. & Folkens, P. A. Human Osteology (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2012).
Hoppe, K. A., Amundson, R., Vavra, M., McClaran, M. P. & Anderson, D. L. Isotopic analysis of tooth enamel carbonate from modern North American feral horses: implications for paleoenvironmental reconstructions. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol. 203, 299–311 (2004).
Garvie-Lok, S. J., Varney, T. L. & Katzenberg, M. A. Preparation of bone carbonate for stable isotope analysis: the effects of treatment time and acid concentration. J. Archaeol. Sci. 31, 763–776 (2004).
Sponheimer, M. Isotopic ecology of the Makapansgat limeworks Fauna. Dissertation, Rutgers University (1999).
Kim, S.-T., Coplen, T. B. & Horita, J. Normalization of stable isotope data for carbonate minerals: Implementation of IUPAC guidelines. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 158, 276–289 (2015).
Coplen, T. B., Kendall, C. & Hopple, J. Comparison of stable isotope reference samples. Nature 302, 236–238 (1983).
Bryant, J. D., Koch, P. L., Froelich, P. N., Showers, W. J. & Genna, B. J. Oxygen isotope partitioning between phosphate and carbonate in mammalian apatite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 60, 5145–5148 (1996).
Chambers, J. Graphical Methods for Data Analysis (Wadsworth, Belmont, 1983).
R Core Team. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. https://www.R-project.org/ (2017).
ESRI. Environmental Systems Research Institute (ESRI). ArcGIS Desktop, ArcMap 10.4.1 (2016). https://support.esri.com/en/products/desktop/arcgis-desktop/arcmap/10-4-1.
We are grateful to every Institution involved in this project for granting access to the skeletal remains that have been analyzed. This work was supported by the Italian Ministry of Education, Universities and Research (MIUR) through PRIN 2010–2011 action (EPIC Project: Biological and cultural heritage of the central-southern Italian population through 30 thousand years. Grant ID: 2010EL8TXP) allotted to OR. We are also immensely grateful to the late Anna Paola Anzidei for her comments about Roman sites on an earlier version of the manuscript: her soul is now at peace. Authors would acknowledge the authorities granting access to the skeletal remains. Soprintendenza Speciale Archeologia, Belle Arti e Paesaggio dell’Abruzzo permitted the selection and analysis of Celano Pratovecchio. Soprintendenza Archeologia Belle Arti e Paesaggio per le province di Siena, Grosseto e Arezzo permitted the sampling for Buca di Spaccasasso. Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici delle Marche provided the authorization for analysis of Fontenoce di Recanati. Soprintendenza Speciale Archeologia, Belle Arti e Paesaggio di Roma granted the access for Osteria del Curato-Via Cinquefrondi, Casetta Mistici, Torre della Chiesaccia. Pantano Borghese was analyzed thanks to the permission provided by former Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici del Lazio. Soprintendenza Archeologia Belle Arti e Paesaggio per la città metropolitana di Bari allowed to analyze Galliano Palagiano and Grotta Nisco. FDA and the co-authors appreciate the language editing provided by Frank Wendt. We are grateful to the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments and suggestions that greatly improved the quality of the paper.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
De Angelis, F., Pellegrini, M., Martínez-Labarga, C. et al. Exploring mobility in Italian Neolithic and Copper Age communities. Sci Rep 11, 2697 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-81656-z
Scientific Reports (2022)