In this work, a non-intrusive, spatially resolved, spectro-tomographic optical diagnostic of the electronic density and temperature on the linear plasma column Mistral is presented. Coupling of spectroscopy and tomography technique gives access to the local plasma light emission at different wavelengths (visible and near IR) in an argon plasma. Taking advantage of the symmetry of the Mistral experiment, the diagnostic results are validated and the plasma is found to correspond to a corona equilibrium state. With the use of another spectrometer and a Langmuir probe, we propose a non-intrusive method to determine the electronic density and temperature of each pixel of the tomographic images of the plasma. The obtained results are in good agreement with the Langmuir probe ones.
Multiple applications in different areas such as surface treatment or etching processes, plasma engines or controlled fusion, makes plasmas’ diagnosis a topic of high relevance1,2,3,4. The measurements of fundamental parameters such as the electronic temperature and density are essential to understand the physics of complex plasmas. Both parameters have been classically measured with different kinds of probes5,6,7, but they can significantly disturb the plasma.
For that reason, other methods have been proposed, as for example emission spectroscopy8,9. This technique allows the non-intrusive determination of a wide range of plasma parameters such as electron, ion, neutral and metastable temperatures and densities along a single line of sight (LoS). The problem of these classical methods is the lack of spatial resolution, due to the fact that the signal measured corresponds to the sum, over the LoS length, of the local emissivity distribution of the plasma.
Tomography diagnostics are widely used, e.g. computed tomography scan in medicine, because it is a non-intrusive technique that can provide good spatial resolution. The tomographic technique has been applied to plasma diagnostics since the last two decades, often with the aim of accurately reconstructing the structure of the plasma10,11.
Spectro-tomography combines the advantage of these two approaches to simultaneously offer spatial and spectral resolution. This method provides 2D maps of light intensities at different wavelengths12, giving access to the plasma electronic density and temperature.
The experimental set-up and the tomographic method are presented in section 2 and 3, respectively. The experimental results are detailed in section 4 with 3 sub-sections:
Experimental confirmation of the corona equilibrium in Mistral,
Validation of the spectro-tomographic results,
2D measurement of ne and Te in Mistral.
The linear magnetized plasma device Mistral13 (Fig. 1) is used for the fundamental study of transport in cold plasmas (Te ∼ 3 eV and Ti ∼ 300 K). The plasma is a thermionic discharge in argon, created by 30 to 40 eV primary electrons emitted by 32 tungsten filaments, with a typical pressure of P ≈ 10−2 Pa in the source chamber and an electronic density ne ≈ 1015 m−3. The Mistral’s vacuum chamber is a 1.2 m long and 0.4 m wide cylinder with a typical magnetic field of 0.016 T.
The plasma is limited by a grid on each end of the column and an outer cylinder at r = 10 cm. The two grids and the cylinder can be independently polarized between −60 and 60 V. The magnetic field and different polarized surfaces (underlined on Fig. 1) in both the source and linear plasma chamber allow for a stable and reproducible control of the plasma state during several hours.
The spectro-tomography diagnostic (see Fig. 2) consists of two main parts: a tomographic device for the acquisition of 49 crossed LoS and an emission spectrometer. Two large windows, on the side and on the top of the linear chamber allow for an easy optical access of the plasma (shown as the tomography plane in Fig. 1). 49 optical fibres (core diameter 200 µm) are positioned outside of the vacuum chamber, in front of these windows14. Each fibre facing the plasma is placed at the focal plane of a micro-lens (3.4 mm in diameter and 9.85 mm focal length), collimating the lines of sight. The micro-lenses are mounted on individual mechanical holders. The fibres are divided in two fans, as shown in Fig. 2. The fan distribution is known to lessen the effect of noise by providing a wide range of viewing angles15. This optomechanical system has been carefully aligned. Indeed, because of the size of the collimation system and the distance to the plasma, a small misalignment can lead to a sizeable displacement of the line of sight. To well-adjust the collimation and position of the fibres, a laser has been retro-injected in the bundle and projected at 1 m length, a distance similar to the lens plasma distance.
On the other side of the bundle, the 49 fibres face the entrance slit of the Princeton Instruments Isoplane 160 imaging spectrometer that provides high resolution across the entire focal plane. The spectrometer has three diffraction gratings (150, 600 and 1200 lines/mm) and an adjustable entrance slit with an 11 mm effective height. The measurements shown in this work have been done with the 600 lines/mm diffraction grating and the entrance slit width fixed at 50 μm. A PROEM-HS, Princeton Instruments EMCCD camera (1024 × 1024 pixels, pixel size 13.6 × 13.6 µm) is positioned at the image focal plane of the Isoplane spectrometer. For this work, 49 Regions of Interest (ROI) (each of 1024 pixels length, and 13 pixels height) evenly spaced image the 49 LoS. Measurements were taken at different central wavelengths (from 400 nm to 900 nm, 50 nm steps), to cover the whole visible spectrum and the near infrared. For a better signal to noise ratio, each spectrum is averaged over 20 acquisitions. The spectral response of the diagnostic is obtained with a calibrated black-body applied to the Isoplane spectra. The black-body is an integrating sphere (Lambertian source) that allows transforming the arbitrary units (counts) from the spectrometer to plasma emissivity (μW cm−2 sr−1 nm−1). This calibration remove any ulterior dependence from the instruments.
The spectro-tomography results are validated by comparing them with the spectra measured with a low spectral resolution spectrometer (JAZ-Ocean Optics). This spectrometer has three diffraction gratings centred on three complementary parts of the visible spectrum and near infrared, providing a whole measurement range from 400 to 980 nm. The JAZ line of sight is composed of a 600 µm trifurcated optical fibre placed at the focal point of a f’ = 200 mm lens. The resulting diameter of the line of sight, one meter from the lens, is 8 mm. The JAZ line of sight is placed at the end of the plasma column, parallel to the magnetic field lines of the Mistral solenoid (see “JAZ spectro LoS” on Fig. 1). The JAZ spectrometer was calibrated following the same black-body protocol as the Isoplane spectrometer. In addition, a Langmuir probe radially moving from the plasma centre to its edge allows an independent measurement of ne and Te16. As can be seen in Fig. 3, the logarithmic plot of a typical probe characteristic in Mistral is approximately linear between 10 V and 18 V. Then, the electron temperature can be deduced from the inverse of the slope of the characteristic in that bias region. The whole probe characteristic procedure for ne and Te measurement is detailed in ref. 16.
The tomographic diagnostic has been explained in detail and validated in previous works14,17, so only the most important features will be referenced here. The numerical tomographic inversion is based on a finite-element scheme. With i = 1,…,L intersecting LoS, the tomographic technique gives access to the local plasma emissivity divided into pixels, through the tomographic relation18:
The measured signal fi on the ith line of sight is linked to the local emissivity gj of the plasma in the jth pixel, through the transfer matrix Tij. Inverting the transfer matrix gives access to the plasma emissivity. The discretisation problem leads to an ill-conditioned transfer matrix. Consequently, a careful procedure is needed for the inversion process. Instead of directly solving the system, we search for the local emissivity gj through the minimisation of ϕ = 1/2(Tij gj−fi)² + αR with α a positive weighting parameter and R a regularizing functional. Several methods are available to obtain the best regularisation19. In our case, a second order regularisation gave the best results. No further hypothesis is made on the plasma shape or position. This tomographic inversion software has been successfully tested on ghost images20, with similar features than Mistral plasma.
The following procedure has been applied to the 49 raw spectra: first, the instrumental function obtained from the black-body calibration is applied to the spectra. Then, the wavelength integrated intensities of the most intense emission lines in each ROI are calculated. Finally, the tomographic reconstruction is applied to each emission line.
In this section, we first focus on the equilibrium model corresponding to the plasmas in Mistral. Secondly, the spectro-tomography results are experimentally validated. Finally, an example of 2D measurements of ne and Te in Mistral is presented.
The corona model is a simple description of the distribution of the excited atomic/ionic levels populations. The population of an excited state results from the balance of electron impact excitation from the ground state and decays by spontaneous emission21. The plasma can be described by the corona model if the distribution of the excited states populations can be fitted with the following expression with x ≤ 322:
where Ni and gi are the population density of the excited levels and the degeneracy of the excited level, respectively. The effective principal quantum number pi of the excited states is given by22:
with EH the Rydberg constant (13.6 eV), E∞ the ionization energy of the considered species and Ei the energy of the excited level i. The normalized distribution of the excited population of Ar I has been measured in Mistral with the JAZ spectrometer. As can be seen in Fig. 4, Ni/gi is in good agreement with a pi−3 fit. Following the classical expression of the optical depth of a Doppler broadened emission line21, the Mistral plasma is optically thin.
The 2D map of ne and Te can be deduced from the argon emission lines intensities obtained by spectro-tomography if the relation between them is known. Taking advantage of the (ne, Te) homogeneity along the JAZ spectrometer line of sight, we have acquired a series of JAZ spectra and measured ne and Te with a Langmuir probe radially positioned into the JAZ LoS.
The measurements were performed in an argon plasma, with the following configuration: PAr = 0.054 Pa, B = 16 mT, grounded collector, floating separating grid and non-polarised outer cylinder.
The electronic density has been progressively changed without a strong variation of the electronic temperature. This is possible by increasing/decreasing the voltage current applied to the 32 filaments of Mistral, giving rise to an increase/decrease of the ionising primary electron flux incoming in the plasma column from the source, and then to a corresponding electronic density variation. Figure 5 shows the intensity of several Ar I wavelengths (693, 696, 750, 751 and 842 nm) when the voltage of the filaments are modified from 16.6 to 11.4 V, leading to an electronic densities decrease from 1.34·1011 to 6.58·108 cm−3 with a fixed pressure of 0.1 Pa. At the same time, Te decreases from 2.7 to 1.7 eV. These lines where selected for different reasons: the ones at 750 and 751 nm correspond to excited levels populated directly from the ground level. The Ar I emission lines at 693, 696 and 842 nm are sufficiently intense to be detected even when the electronic density is low. All the lines plotted in Fig. 5 show a linear trend. This is coherent with the corona model, namely the intensity of a neutral line is directly proportional to the electronic density.
Although the plasma emission is dominated by neutral argon lines16, the spectrum recorded by the JAZ spectrometer has also several lines corresponding to ionized argon (Ar II). In the frame of the coronal model, their intensities are directly proportional to ne2.
Figure 6 shows, the ne dependence of the intensities of two Ar II emission lines. As can be seen, linear fits of the experimental data are in good agreement for ne > 1010 cm−3.
In conclusion, we have experimentally checked the following relations for the intensities IArI and IArII of neutral and ionized emission lines, respectively:
It is important to note that the relation (5) is experimentally found to be valid only for ne >1010 cm−3. However, as we will see in part 4.3.2, the electron density range in the Mistral plasma column is always larger than this value. This is an important step to measure (ne, Te) by spectro-tomography. The electronic temperature dependence of the emission lines intensities, f1(Te) and f2(Te) (shown in Fig. 7) depend mainly on the excitation rate by electronic collisions from the fundamental level,. Two populations of electrons can populate the excited levels: the secondary electrons and the few percent of primary electrons (npe/nse ≈ 0.03)16. The primary electrons are in the minority, but can play an important role because of their relatively high energy.
Validation of the spectro-tomography technique
As the plasma parameters are homogeneous along the magnetic field lines, it is possible to validate the results of the spectro-tomography diagnostic: the normalized radial distributions of the argon emission lines intensities extracted from the 2D images must correspond to the results obtained with the JAZ spectrometer. Figure 8 shows the Ar I (751 nm) emission line radial distributions in an argon plasma with the same experimental configuration as the previous section. As can be seen, the two sets of data show similar radial profiles for the normalised intensities. The error bar in the JAZ intensities has been considered a 10% of the maximum value, to compensate possible mistakes in the integration of the JAZ LoS. In the case of the spectro-tomography, the error has been considered to be 10%, corresponding to the noise level tested for the reconstruction. The horizontal error bars represent the size of a pixel.
Calculation of Te and ne by spectro-tomography
A classical approach for the realisation of an electron density/temperature diagnostic by emission spectroscopy is to compare some chosen emission lines intensities ratio to an atomic physics model. For example, the measurement of Te and ne in edge plasmas of tokamaks is usually done by the use of three He I emission lines ratios coupled to a collisional-radiative code23. This method has been applied in Mistral for helium plasmas and the high precision collisional-radiative code SOPHIA developed by F. B. Rosmej, taking into account particle diffusion and suprathermal electrons beam24. This work showed how complex is the atomic physics in Mistral plasmas. Then, considering that the atomic physics data of neutral/ionized argon is much less complete than helium ones, we chose not to develop an argon collisional-radiative model. Instead, a method based on spectroscopic calibration with Langmuir probe acquisition for (ne; Te) measurement coupled to spectroscopic acquisition of argon spectra was developed. This procedure must be operated only once.
In this section, we present how to measure a 2D map of ne and Te with a purely optical diagnostic for a corona equilibrium plasma, after a probe calibration phase. For the experimental conditions detailed in Section 2 with 49 lines of sight, we perform the tomographic inversion on 49 = 7 × 7 pixels (size 16 × 16 mm). As mentioned before, the real potential of this technique is the spectral resolution: the capability to perform simultaneously the tomographic reconstructions of emission lines at different wavelengths in the whole range of the visible spectrum. In Fig. 9, three tomographic reconstructions are shown, for three different wavelengths: 416, 549 and 751 nm. The pixels at the edge of the domain can present a higher noise level than the central ones, and some of them present a zero value.
Determination of Te
which is independent of ne. The ratio of two neutral Ar lines would be as well independent of ne. However, the upper states are populated in a similar way so that such ratio is poorly dependent of Te.
JAZ spectrometer and probe acquisitions were simultaneously performed along the radial profile of the plasma (with fixed plasma parameters), to measure the Te dependence of the ratio I ArII (434 nm)/(I ArI (751 nm))2. The result is shown in Fig. 10, with a linear fit of the data. These specific wavelengths have been chosen because of the good signal-to-noise ratio.
Figure 11 shows an example of measurement of this ratio by spectro-tomography for the 7 × 7 matrix of pixels. Some of the edge pixels of the ratio IArII (434 nm)/(IArI (751 nm))2 present Not-a-Number values because in the original tomographic reconstructions it is possible to find pixels with zero value. To avoid non-realistic values of ne and Te, a threshold has been imposed: all the pixels that not reach the 25% of the maximum value of IArII (434 nm) and the 15% of IArI (751 nm) have been discarded; and represented by grey pixels in Fig. 11.
The 2D electronic temperature map is presented in Fig. 12. The value of Te in each pixel has been calculated combining the values of the ratio IArII(434 nm)/(IArI(751 nm))2 of each pixel in Fig. 11 and solving the equation presented in Fig. 10. The electronic temperature in the plasma centre is nearly constant, with a value around 3 eV. Te decreases through the plasma limits, reaching low values around 1.5 eV.
Figure 13 shows the comparison of Te values deduced from the Langmuir probe characteristics and from the fit of Fig. 10 applied to a row of pixels of the tomographic inversion, matching the location of the horizontally movable Langmuir probe. The graph shows only three points corresponding to the path of the probe (central row of the tomographic reconstruction). The fourth pixel has been omitted because it provides a negative value of Te. Indeed, the plasma is too disturbed if the probe and its holder go further away than the plasma centre. The two data series are in very good agreement, with a maximum difference of about 7%.
Determination of ne
In this section we describe the method to measure the electronic density for each pixel of the tomographic reconstruction, with the use of the measured values of Te. In order to provide a method as robust as possible, we are considering again the ratio of two lines: I ArII (434 nm)/I ArI (751 nm). A lower precision is expected, as it is a more indirect method than for the measurement of Te. By considering the ratio I ArII (434 nm)/I ArI (751 nm), the f3(Te) function can be expressed as follows:
In the same way as in the precedent section, the electron temperature dependence of f3(Te) has been measured by coupling the JAZ spectrometer and the Langmuir probe diagnostic. Figure 14 shows the linear fit applied to f3(Te).
Following the same procedure, Fig. 15 shows the intensities ratio matrix of the emission lines Ar II (434 nm) and Ar I (751 nm). As in the previous case, some pixels give non-realistic values.
Electronic density for each pixel is computed from the Eq. (8) by using the values of Te already found by spectro-tomography and the fit of f3(Te). The results are shown in Fig. 16. At the plasma centre, the mean electronic density is 6.9·1010 cm−3, in the same range than the mean electronic density measured with the Langmuir probe equal to 5.6·1010 cm−3. A slight decrease of ne can be observed for increasing radius, except for some noisy pixels at the periphery.
To summarize, the following procedure is applied for each pixels of the spectro-tomographic inversion:
The value of Te is deduced from the experimental ratio IArII(434 nm)/IArI(751 nm)2 and the linear fit presented in Fig. 10.
Then, the value of ne is obtained from the relation ne = (IArII(434 nm)/IArI(751 nm))/f3(Te) and the value of Te obtained previously.
Determination of ne: an alternative way
It is possible to calculate ne with an alternative method described in this part. As it has been shown in Eq. (4), the intensity of a neutral Ar line is directly proportional to ne and to a function of the temperature. Then, the relation can be expressed as follow:
So, the intensity of a neutral Ar line divided by f1(Te) measured as shown in the previous part allows a direct measurement of the electronic density. The resulting ne map is shown in Fig. 17.
Therefore, for this alternative method, the following procedure is applied for each pixels of the spectro-tomographic inversion:
The value of Te is deduced from the experimental ratio IArII(434 nm)/IArI(751 nm)2 and the linear fit presented in Fig. 10.
Then, f1(Te) is deduced from Fig. 7 and the value of ne is obtained from the ratio IArI/f1(Te).
The comparison of the measurement of ne by spectro-tomography and by the Langmuir probe installed on the Mistral experiment are shown on Fig. 18. The blue diamonds represent the values of ne measured with the Langmuir probe, meanwhile the red dots/green triangles show the values of ne obtained with the first/second (alternative) methods, respectively. The two spectro-tomography methods used for measuring the electronic density are in good agreement. The more direct alternative method allows a better reproduction of the ne spatial variations than the first one. However, the tomographic measurements are found to be lower than the probe values. One should note that the probe is strongly perturbative for the plasma. Then, it cannot be an absolute reference for the comparison.
In this work, a visible spectro-tomographic diagnostic installed on the Mistral experiment is presented. It is an update of a previous tomographic setup14,17. In the present case 49 optical fibres, divided in two fans, collect the plasma emission and send it to an imaging spectrometer, giving a simultaneous access to the brightness of emission lines in the whole visible and the near IR argon spectrum. Specifically developed software operates the tomographic reconstruction14,17, leading to 7 × 7 pixels plasma images, with 16 mm square pixels.
With the help of a second spectrometer facing the plasma column and a Langmuir probe, taking advantage of the plasma symmetry, the tomographic reconstruction is validated by the comparison of radial profiles of intensity of emission lines. Moreover, the corona equilibrium is experimentally checked for the plasmas conditions in Mistral.
The powerful ability of the spectro-tomographic diagnostic to acquire simultaneously 2D integrated intensity of several emission lines allows to access to a wide kind of physical parameters. In the case of Mistral, we show how it is possible to measure 2D maps of the electronic density and temperature for plasma in corona equilibrium. Taking into account the ratio of ionized and neutral argon lines, we obtain spatial distribution of the electronic density and temperature, in good agreement with Langmuir probe results. The precision of the results is mainly limited by the precision of the tomographic process and by the relatively low number of LoS.
The goal of this work is to show that spectro-tomography is a reliable diagnostic allowing the measurement of important plasma parameters by purely optical methods. In the future, two strategies are planned to improve the diagnostic: first, we have begun the realisation of a transmission imaging spectrometer with an entrance slit height larger than 20 mm. This would allow increasing significantly the number of optical fibres illuminating the entrance slit, and consequently the number of LoS. Second, we are evaluating the possibility of realizing optical tomography with mirrors surrounding the plasma, allowing several views of the plasma. This would increase considerably the numbers of crossing views of the plasma.
Lochte-Holtegreven, W. Plasma-Diagnostics. Ed. North-Holland, Amsterdam (1968).
Hieftje, G. M. Plasma diagnostic techniques for understanding and control. Spectrochim. Acta B. 47, 3–25 (1992).
Adamovich, I. et al. The 2017 Plasma Roadmap: Low temperature plasma science and technology. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 50, 323001 (2017).
Samukawa, S. et al. The 2012 plasma roadmap. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 45, 253001 (2012).
Cherrington, B. E. The use of electrostatic probes for plasma diagnostics-A review. Plasma Chem. Plasma Process. 2, 113–140 (1982).
Hopkins, M. B. & Graham, W. G. Langmuir probe technique for plasma parameter measurement in a medium density discharge. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 57, 2210–2217 (1986).
Hershkowitz, N. & Cho, M. H. Measurement of plasma potential using collecting and emitting probes. J. Vac. Sci. Technol.: Part A. 6, 2054–2059 (1988).
Tian-Ye, N. et al. A comparison among optical emission spectroscopic methods of determining electron temperature in low pressure argon plasmas. Chinese Phys. 16, 2757 (2007).
Van der Sijde, B. & Van der Mullen, J. A. M. Temperature determination in non-LTE plasmas. J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transf. 44, 39–46 (1990).
Filonin, O. V. Spectral-tomographic methods and means of studying propellant flows of ion and plasma low-thrust engines. Optics and Spectroscopy. 118, 181–190 (2015).
Neger, T. Optical tomography of plasmas by spectral interferometry. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 28, 47 (1995).
Barni, R., Caldirola, S., Fattorini, L. & Riccardi, C. Tomography of a simply magnetized toroidal plasma. Plasma Sci. Technol. 20, 025102 (2017).
Matsukuma, M. et al. Spatiotemporal structure of low frequency waves in a magnetized plasma device. Phys. Lett. A. 163, 163–167 (2003).
David, P. et al. A tomography diagnostic in the visible spectrum to investigate turbulence and coherent modes in the linear plasma column Mistral. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 88, 113507 (2017).
Decoste, R. X-ray tomography on plasmas with arbitrary cross sections and limited access. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 56, 806–808 (1985).
Escarguel, A. Optical diagnostics of a low frequency instability rotating around a magnetized plasma column. Eur. Phys. J. D. 56, 209–214 (2010).
David, P., Escarguel, A., Camenen, Y. & Baude, R. Characterisation of coherent rotating modes in a magnetised plasma column using a mono-sensor tomography diagnostic. Phys. Plasmas 23, 103511 (2016).
Granetz, R. S. & Smeulders, P. X-ray tomography on JET. Nucl. Fusion. 28, 457 (1988).
Anton, M. et al. X-ray tomography on the TCV tokamak. Plasma Phys. Control. Fusion. 38, 1849 (1996).
Baude, R. et al. Visible spectro-tomography: from low temperature laboratory plasmas to the WEST tokamak. 43rd EPS Conference on Plasma Physics (2016).
Griem, H. R. Principles of plasma spectroscopy. Academic Press, New York. (1966).
Gordillo-Vázquez, F. J. et al. Spectroscopic measurements of the electron temperature in low pressure radiofrequency Ar/H2/C2H2 and Ar/H2/CH4 plasmas used for the synthesis of nanocarbon structures. Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. 15, 42 (2005).
Schweer, B., Brix, M. & Lehnen, M. Measurement of edge parameters in TEXTOR-94 at the low and high field side with atomic beams. J. Nucl. Mater. 266, 673–678 (1999).
Lefevre, T., Escarguel, A., Stamm, R., Godbert-Mouret, L. & Rosmej, F. B. Investigation of particle diffusion and suprathermal electrons in a magnetized helium plasma column. Phys. Plasmas. 21, 023502 (2014).
This work has been carried out within the framework of the French Federation for Magnetic Fusion Research and of the Eurofusion consortium, and has received funding from the Euratom research and training programme 2014–2018 and 2019–2020 (work package WPEDU) under grant agreement No 633053. The views and opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of the European Commission.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Gonzalez-Fernandez, V., David, P., Baude, R. et al. Spatially resolved determination of the electronic density and temperature by a visible spectro-tomography diagnostic in a linear magnetized plasma. Sci Rep 10, 5389 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-62426-9
Scientific Reports (2021)