Future increases in the intensity of hurricanes and El Niño periods predicted by climate change models have focused attention on their role in stimulating harmful algal blooms (HABs). A series of hurricanes that recently impacted Florida (USA) provided a unique opportunity to explore the relationships between hurricanes, El Niño and HABs in two Florida estuaries subject to repeated intense ecosystem disruptive HABs, the Indian River Lagoon and the St. Lucie Estuary. The roles that hurricanes and El Niño play in contributing to HAB events are examined in the context of key structural and functional features of each estuary and their watersheds, including morphology, water residence time and hydrology, such as the influence of Lake Okeechobee discharges into the St. Lucie Estuary. The most direct impact was the increase in rainfall associated with hurricanes and El Niño, resulting in enhanced nutrient loads which drive HABs in the Indian River Lagoon and Lake Okeechobee. Major HABs in Lake Okeechobee also present an indirect threat of freshwater HAB blooms in the St. Lucie Estuary via mandated discharges from the lake into the estuary during high rainfall periods. Conversely, during the absence of HABs in Lake Okeechobee, short water residence times produced by discharges into the St. Lucie Estuary can result in lower bloom intensities.
There is a consensus about the role that human activity plays in nutrient enrichment of aquatic environments as drivers of harmful algal blooms (HABs)1,2. There are also growing concerns that anticipated future changes in climatic conditions will increase threats for HABs2,3. Among these climatic threats are increases in the intensity and duration of hurricanes and El Niño periods4,5,6. High rainfall and winds associated with storms and elevated rain during El Niño periods in certain regions of the world can impact a range of processes relevant to phytoplankton dynamics and HAB development, including nutrient loads, physical disruption of ecosystems and ecosystem flushing rates7,8,9,10. These impacts can be exacerbated by human influences on nutrient loads and hydrology11,12.
A series of hurricanes that recently impacted the peninsula of Florida, and the long record of El Niño/La Niña cycles, provide an opportunity to explore the potential impacts on HABs. The effects of storm and El Niño-driven changes to the hydrology and nutrient status of coastal estuaries can be difficult to define without a basic understanding of the structure and function of both the core estuary and its watershed. For example, storm enhanced watershed runoff can increase external nutrient loads that fuel algal blooms, or contain high HAB biomass from freshwater ecosystems in the watershed, or conversely, in some ecosystems elevated flushing rates can limit the intensity of autochthonous HABs by reducing water residence times. In addition to bringing high rainfall to impacted areas which enhance nutrient loads, the winds associated with storms can cause physical damage (e.g. erosion) or disruption (e.g. sediment re-suspension) of aquatic ecosystems, contributing to internal nutrient loading and re-distribution of nutrient sources and sinks13,14.
We address these issues and examine the relationships between hurricanes (and more generally tropical cyclones), El Niño periods and HABs in two sub-tropical ecosystems, the St. Lucie Estuary and the Indian River Lagoon (Fig. 1). In subtropical ecosystems, relatively modest seasonal variability in temperature and irradiance can reduce the predictability of seasonal trends in phytoplankton biomass and composition15. Consequently, other variables can take on greater importance in driving phytoplankton dynamics, often on longer and less predictable time intervals16. Two such factors are multi-year cyclical patterns (e.g. El Niño/La Niña cycles) and stochastic variability in rainfall intensity and wind associated with storm events. Both the St. Lucie Estuary and Indian River Lagoon have experienced significant hurricane activity, but each illustrates a different set of drivers and consequences associated with storm events as it relates to HABs. In the St. Lucie Estuary, hurricanes can indirectly impact HABs by increasing the potential for introduction of high algae biomass from freshwater systems in the watershed (Fig. 2a). In the Indian River Lagoon, both hurricanes and El Niño periods have a direct positive effect on HABs of internal origin (i.e. autochthonous), predominantly through the enhancement of nutrient loads. These relationships are explored within the context of key structural and functional features of each estuary and its watershed, including water residence times, composition of dominant algal species during HABs within and entering the estuary from watersheds and temporal patterns of hydrologic management activities, such as regulated discharges from Lake Okeechobee into the St. Lucie Estuary via the St. Lucie Canal17,18.
In the St. Lucie Estuary, the study focused on two sampling sites in the inner regions of the St. Lucie Estuary, Site SL1 in the North Fork region and Site SL2 in the South Fork region (Fig. 1). The St. Lucie Estuary has an area of 29 km2 and is shallow throughout (i.e. mean depth 2–2.5 m)19,20. In addition to two natural inflows, Ten-mile Creek and Old South Fork, three man-made canals (C-23, C-24 and C-44) were added to the system in the first half of the 20th Century to control hydrology in the region, including the regulation of water releases from Lake Okeechobee into the St. Lucie Canal (C-44) for flood control (Fig. 1). The canals provide an average of 75% of the freshwater discharge into the estuary, and all the inflows are managed by means of water control structures, such as locks, dams and water pumping stations21. The shallow depth and relatively small size of the St. Lucie Estuary result in rapid and spatially extensive responses to changes in discharge22. Water residence times in the South Fork/North Fork region of the estuary range from 1–16.5 days, based on CH3D hydrodynamic/salinity models19. Salinity isoclines can move substantial distances up and down the estuary on time scales of days to weeks, and vertical stratification is generally short-lived. The estuary is microtidal (amplitude <0.5 m)22.
Lake Okeechobee, located in south-central Florida (27°00′ N, 80°50′ W), is the largest lake in the southeast United States (1,730 km2 surface area). It is shallow (2.7 m mean depth), eutrophic and frequently subject to intense cyanobacteria blooms17. It has been impacted repeatedly by hurricanes, sometimes several in the same year. The lake has distinct zones that differ in their ecological structure and function, including a large comparatively deep (i.e. 4–5 m) central zone characterized by flocculent muddy sediments, a shallower (<3 m) perimeter zone characterized by firmer sediments, and a shallow northern perimeter zone subject to the largest external inflows from the water shed23,24. In terms of HAB events, blooms often begin in the shallow perimeter regions of the lake because of higher light availability and proximity to external nutrient inputs, but can spread throughout the lake24. In order to capture potential variability in conditions, data for two sites were included in these analyses, i.e. Sites LO1 and LO2 in the nearshore region of the lake, near the outflow to the St. Lucie Canal, which flows into the St. Lucie Estuary (Fig. 1).
In the Indian River Lagoon, the study focused on two sampling sites located in two separate sub-basins of the northern Indian River Lagoon subject to frequent HABs: Site IRL1 in the northern Indian River Lagoon near Titusville, and Site IRL2 in the central Banana River Lagoon (Fig. 1). Both sub-basins are microtidal and have long water residence times, with estimated mean water half-lives (i.e. 50% exchange) of 107 days in the northern Indian River Lagoon and 156 days in the central Banana River Lagoon25,26. Mean water depths are approximately 2 m in both regions. The sub-basins associated with Sites IRL1 and IRL2 are both characterized by small watersheds (i.e. 35,446 ha and 5628 ha, respectively), relative to the size of the receiving basins (i.e. 16,465 ha and 10,202 ha, respectively), but their watersheds differ in terms of percent distribution of land-uses27,28. The sub-basin of Site IRL1 had 65% undeveloped, 24% agricultural and 11% urban/residential land-use areas in 200928. The sub-basin of Site IRL2 had significantly higher urban/residential area at 65%, low agricultural (4%) and 33% undeveloped land-use areas in 200928.
Sampling and field collections
Sites SL1 and SL2 in the St. Lucie Estuary were sampled on a weekly basis from May 2005 through April 2008. Sites IRL1 and IRL2 in the northern Indian River Lagoon were sampled monthly from September 1997 to August 2005, and twice monthly from September 2005 through April 2018. Temperature and salinity were measured at the surface and near the bottom at each site with a Hydrolab Quanta environmental multi probe. Water samples for phytoplankton analysis were collected with a vertical integrating sampling tube that captured water from the surface to within 0.1 m of the bottom, to avoid sample bias resulting from vertical stratification of phytoplankton. Duplicate aliquots were preserved on site, one with Lugol’s solution and one with buffered glutaraldehyde.
Nutrient and chlorophyll a data
Monthly total Kjeldahl nitrogen and total phosphorus data for Indian River Lagoon (1997–2018) were obtained from the St. Johns River Water Management District (Palatka, Florida). Nitrate, soluble reactive phosphorus, total suspended solids and chlorophyll a data for the two sites in Lake Okeechobee (2004–2007) were obtained from the South Florida Water Management District (West Palm Beach, Florida).
Climate, discharge and remotely-sensed cyanobacteria observations
Rainfall data for the Stuart and Titusville (Florida) meteorological stations were obtained from the NOAA Climatological Data for Florida web site (www.ncdc.noaa.gov/IPS). Flow data capturing discharge from Lake Okeechobee into the St. Lucie Canal (Site 02276877) were obtained from the U.S. Geological Survey. Satellite imagery captured by MERIS and Sentinel-3 OLCI were analyzed using the Cyanobacteria Index (CI)29 for cyanobacteria abundance and distribution in Lake Okeechobee. The CI was calculated from MERIS imagery for dates in 2005, and Sentinel-3 imagery in 2018.
General phytoplankton composition was determined using the Utermöhl method30. Samples preserved in Lugol’s were settled in 19-mm diameter cylindrical chambers. Phytoplankton cells were identified and counted at 400× and 100× with a Leica phase contrast inverted microscope. At 400×, a minimum of 100 cells of a single taxon and 30 grids were counted. If 100 cells of a single taxon were not counted by 30 grids, up to a maximum of 100 grids were counted until 100 cells of a single taxon were reached. At 100×, a total bottom count was completed for taxa >30 µm in size.
Fluorescence microscopy was used to enumerate picoplanktonic cyanobacteria (e.g. Synechococcus.spp., spherical picocyanobacteria spp.) at 1000× magnification31. Subsamples of seawater were filtered onto 0.2 µm Nuclepore filters and mounted between a microscope slide and cover slip with immersion oil. If not analyzed immediately, samples preserved with buffered glutaraldehyde were refrigerated and counted within 72 h.
Cell biovolumes were estimated by assigning combinations of geometric shapes to fit the characteristics of individual taxa32,33. Specific phytoplankton dimensions were measured for at least 30 randomly selected cells. Species which vary substantially in size, such as many diatom species, were placed into size categories. Phytoplankton biomass as carbon values (i.e. µg carbon ml−1) were estimated by using conversion factors for different taxonomic groups applied to biovolume estimates: i.e. 0.065× biovolume of diatoms, 0.22× biovolume of cyanobacteria or nanoplanktonic eukaryotes, and 0.16× biovolume of dinoflagellates or other taxa34,35,36,37,38.
Statistical and modeling methods
Basic statistical procedures (i.e. determination of mean values, standard deviations, and Spearman’s comparison of means) were carried out using SAS v9.2 (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina, USA).
Water residence times are expressed as E60 values (i.e. time in days for 60% water exchange), otherwise referred to as the e-folding time. Water residence time data for the inner St. Lucie Estuary used in this paper were provided by D. Sun of the South Florida Water Management District (W. Palm Beach, Florida). The St. Lucie Estuary is strongly influenced by tidal water exchange rates as well as freshwater flushing rates, therefore both factors are incorporated into the model formulations of water residence time19,20. Water residence time estimates for the study period were based on linear regression relationships developed between historical E60 values derived from a hydrodynamic model for 1997–199919,20 and rainfall integrated over a period of two weeks prior to the date (i.e. X) of the E60 model estimate. Regression for North Fork was E60 = −0.2534X + 17.028, R2 = 0.77. Regression for South Fork was E60 = −0.0257X + 2.9239, R2 = 0.21. A number of factors contribute to the lower R2 of the relationship for South Fork, including the morphology of the estuary and the implications for tidal mixing, very shallow mean depth, small volume compared to North Fork and direct impacts of the flow-regulated discharges from the St. Lucie Canal to South Fork.
Results and discussion
St. Lucie Estuary-Lake Okeechobee connection
The results of a three-year study of the St. Lucie Estuary provide insights into two different ways storms affect HABs, i.e. internal blooms (i.e. autochthonous) of marine species and externally introduced blooms (i.e. allochthonous) of freshwater species39. The largest biomass peaks of marine species were observed in late summer/early fall (August-October) of 2006 (Fig. 2b, Supplemental Fig. S1), when salinities and water residence times were comparatively high (Fig. 2c) due to below average rainfall levels (Fig. 3), providing the conditions favorable for accumulation of marine phytoplankton biomass. Millie et al.40 made a similar observation during a one-year study coinciding with a drought period in 2000, when diatom blooms were observed in the inner estuary. Conversely, periods of high rainfall, such as late summer/early fall of 2007, coincided with shorter water residence times, low salinities (Fig. 2c) and lower phytoplankton biomass (Fig. 2b), despite the fact that average nutrient levels during the 2006 period (i.e. TP, 0.20 mg L−1; TN, 0.90 mg L−1) were lower than during the same period in 2007 (i.e. TP, 0.25 mg L−1; TN, 1.20 mg L−1). These observations indicate that periods of high rainfall and discharge from the watershed can restrict marine phytoplankton biomass due to diminished water residence times39, highlighting the potential importance of water residence time in modifying the potential intensity of HABs involving marine species. The impact of water residence time can be compounded by elevated colored dissolved organic matter and tripton (i.e. non-algal particulate matter) in watershed discharge, which can reduce light availability in the water column for phytoplankton. This is reflected by lower mean CDOM and turbidity values in the August-October period of 2006 (i.e. 59 Pt-Co and 7.8 Ntu), than the same period in 2007 (i.e. 127 Pt-Co and 18.5 Ntu). However, the magnitude of potential light limitation for phytoplankton production may be partially mitigated by the shallow mean depths in the St. Lucie Estuary (i.e. mean depths of 2–2.5 m).
In contrast to the relationships described for blooms of marine species, high rainfall periods can be associated with freshwater HAB events in the St. Lucie Estuary, when discharges from Lake Okeechobee into the St. Lucie Estuary via the St. Lucie Canal occur during major HAB events in the lake. The latter scenario was observed in 2005 (Fig. 4a, Supplemental Fig. S2), during a period (2004–2005) when central Florida was impacted by five hurricanes, i.e. Charley, Francis, and Jeanne in 2004, and Dennis and Wilma in 200539,41,42 (Fig. 4b, Fig. 5). The storms affected Lake Okeechobee in several important ways relevant to the dynamics of HABs17,18. Exceptionally high rainfall resulted in large inflows of nutrient-rich water to the lake from its watershed, as evidenced by large increases in dissolved inorganic nitrogen and soluble reactive phosphorus in the lake (Fig. 4b). The increases in dissolved inorganic nitrogen may have been particularly important since the lake is more prone to nitrogen-limiting conditions for phytoplankton production than phosphorus limitation43,44. High winds associated with several of the hurricanes in 2004 caused intense re-suspension of muddy flocculent lake bottom sediments, resulting in high total suspended solids concentrations (Fig. 4c) and low light availability for primary production (i.e. Secchi depths less than 30 cm), as well as a potential for introduction of additional nutrients associated with bottom sediments39,45,46. The response of the phytoplankton community to the enhanced inorganic nutrient concentrations was not realized until the summer of 2005 (Fig. 4c), when total suspended solids concentrations declined significantly, providing the additional light necessary to support high phytoplankton production and biomass17,44,47. A major lake-wide bloom was observed on the lake in July-August 2005, as evidenced by satellite imagery (Fig. 4a), coinciding with a rapid decline in DIN (Fig. 4b), which reflects the high demand for inorganic nitrogen during blooms (Fig. 4b).
During the major 2005 HAB event in Lake Okeechobee, water levels in the lake were high due to excessive rainfall from the multiple hurricane events. Unlike most natural lake ecosystems, Lake Okeechobee is entirely contained within a man-made dike (i.e. Hoover Dike), built in the early 1900’s to prevent flooding in south Florida48. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is tasked with maintaining specific water levels in the lake to avoid breaching of the dike49. However, as an ecosystem with restricted outflows, Lake Okeechobee is characterized by long water residence times, i.e. 3.5 years50, which enhance the potential for intense HABs, particularly during periods of high external nutrient loads. In the summer of 2005, water levels reached a critical threshold, mandating large releases of water into the St. Lucie Canal, which discharges into the South Fork region of the St. Lucie Estuary (Fig. 1). Discharge rates went up significantly following the hurricane events (Fig. 5)51. The high releases in July and August 2005 coincided with a major cyanobacteria bloom in the lake (Fig. 4a), resulting in large influxes of cyanobacteria biomass into the estuary, as evidenced by the cyanobacteria peak in the St. Lucie Estuary (Fig. 2a,b). The biomass was dominated by the toxic freshwater species Microcystis aeruginosa, with peak average chlorophyll a concentrations observed in the water column of 166 µg L−1, and peak surface scum layer values up to 2,863 µg L−1 39. The cyanobacteria bloom was also associated with concentrations of the hepatotoxin microcystin in excess of 1,000 µg L−1 in surface water grab samples39, which greatly exceed the World Health Organization guidelines for drinking water and recreational exposure, i.e. 1 µg L−1 and 10 µg L−1 microcystin, respectively52,53. During the discharge period, salinities in the inner half of the estuary were near freshwater levels (Fig. 2c), providing an environment conducive to the survival and continued growth of the toxic algae. The relationship between freshwater discharges from Lake Okeechobee and Microcystis aeruginosa blooms in the St. Lucie Estuary highlights how hurricanes can indirectly increase freshwater bloom potential in estuaries with strong connections to human-impacted eutrophic freshwater systems.
Intense toxic freshwater cyanobacteria blooms in the St. Lucie Estuary associated with federally-mandated flood control discharges from Lake Okeechobee have been a recurring phenomenon17,18,39,45,54. Hurricanes enhance the potential for blooms by elevating nutrient loads to the lake from the watersheds north and west of the lake, which in combination with long water residence times and mandated discharge from the lake, create a “perfect storm” of conditions for the potential introduction of intense HABs into the estuary. Most recently these conditions have led to re-occurrence of intense cyanobacteria blooms in the St. Lucie estuary in 2016 (Fig. 6) and 201818,45,54. As in 2005, both bloom events occurred during a three-year period of strong tropical storm activity in the Lake Okeechobee region, including hurricanes Joaquin and Erika in 2015, Colin, Julia and Mathew in 2016, and Emily and Irma in 2017. The HAB event in Lake Okeechobee in 2018 is shown in a satellite image of Lake Okeechobee taken during the peak of the freshwater HAB blooms in the St. Lucie Estuary (Fig. 4a).
Indian River Lagoon
For the Indian River Lagoon ecosystem, a long-term continuous 20-year time-series of phytoplankton composition and biomass dating back to 1997 provides an opportunity not only to examine hurricane effects, but also more general trends in climatic effects on HABs. The northern Indian River Lagoon has repeatedly experienced intense HABs since 1997 (i.e. >2 µg carbon mL−1, or roughly equivalent to >30–50 µg chlorophyll a L−1) (e.g. Fig. 7a), as illustrated by the time-series at Site IRL1 (Figs. 1 and 7b, Supplemental Fig. S3). One of the trends in the time series is the positive relationship between rainfall and peaks in phytoplankton biomass14,55. The trend is indicated by the positive linear relationship between bloom biomass peaks of the toxic dinoflagellate Pyrodinium bahamense and rainfall prior to the blooms (R2 = 0.45, Supplemental Fig. S4). P. bahamense is one of the dominant bloom-forming HAB species in the Indian River Lagoon (Fig. 7b, Supplemental Fig. S3), and a major HAB species in other Florida ecosystems and many tropical ecosystems around the world56,57. One of the important cyclical phenomena that affects rainfall in central Florida is El Niño/La Niña periods. El Niño periods are often characterized by higher rainfall than La Niña periods (Fig. 8), particularly during the dry season (i.e. Nov.-April)58,59. A comparison of the temporal records of P. bahamense biomass and El Niño/La Niña periods (expressed as Multivariate ENSO Index: MEI) further demonstrates the relationship between peak P. bahamense biomass and high rainfall El Niño periods (Fig. 7c). The relationship is functionally tied to the positive relationship between nutrient concentrations and rainfall14,56. External nutrients enter the northern Indian River Lagoon from a variety of sources, including surface water runoff, groundwater discharge, direct rainfall inputs, septic system leakage, and permitted and accidental releases from sewage treatment systems60,61,62,63,64,65. All of these processes can be enhanced by high rainfall, although the relative importance of the sources can vary by nutrient type. For example, atmospheric contribution to non-point source nitrogen loads are significantly greater (i.e. 32–53%) than for phosphorus loads (i.e. 4–13%) (Gao 2009).
Beyond the general effects of elevated rainfall and nutrient loads on HAB potential, hurricanes can exacerbate the effect in several other ways, as observed in Lake Taihu, China13. Intense winds can impact nutrient concentrations through sediment re-suspension and re-mineralization of nutrients from damaged aquatic vegetation (e.g. seagrasses) and damaged terrestrial biomass in the watershed which can potentially be transported into the estuary. Because of long water residence times in the northern Indian River Lagoon (i.e. E50 of 100–200 days, 50% half water turnover rates) storm impacts can extend for months. For example, the effects of storm events in July-October (i.e. peak period for tropical activity) can have both short-term and long-term impacts, including elevated nutrient concentrations which can extend into the following year. The phytoplankton biomass time-series for Site 1 in the northern Indian River Lagoon provide an example of the latter phenomena (Fig. 7b. Supplemental Fig. S3). The tropical storm seasons of 2005, 2015 and 2017 all had storms with high rainfall totals66. All three years were associated with significant increases in nutrient concentrations (Supplemental Fig. S5) and HABs blooms in the following years, i.e. 2006, 2016 and 2018 (Fig. 7b, Supplemental Fig. S3). In 2006, the bloom involved the toxic dinoflagellate P. bahamense14,56. In 2016 and 2018, the bloom events also involved the brown tide species Aureoumbra lagunensis, as well as other nanoplanktonic eukaryotic algae (Fig. 7a,b, Supplemental Fig. S3)66.
The dramatically higher bloom biomass peaks in 2016 and 2018 relative to 2006 are the result of a shift in the intensity of blooms that began in the northern Indian River Lagoon in 201114. The shift also involved significant changes in the structure of the ecosystem, such as widespread and major losses of seagrass communities, which may have intensified the response of the phytoplankton community to external and internal nutrient loads14,66. It is also possible that high winds associated with storms in 2015 and 2017 contributed to the persistence of the shift by disrupting the stability of surface sediment layers, and limiting seagrass recovery. The trend toward more frequent and intense blooms may be further accentuated if future storms and El Niño become more frequent and are associated with higher rainfall totals, as predicted by some climate models, which tie future increases in ocean water temperatures to increases in atmospheric water content4,5,6,67,68. In this context, the added dimension of temperature increases add up to a triple threat for bloom development, i.e. by enhancing nutrient loads, increasing algal growth rates and promoting dominance by cyanobacteria and other HAB species1,3,68,69,70,71.
Direct versus indirect impacts
The two estuaries highlighted in this study illustrate how the impacts of hurricanes and El Niño periods on HABs not only depend on direct effects on nutrient loads that drive blooms, but also differences in the structure and function of individual ecosystems, such as water residence time, flushing rates, as well as indirect (i.e. allochthonous) introduction of blooms from the watershed. For ecosystems with long water residence times and shallow depths, like Lake Okeechobee and the northern Indian River Lagoon, enhanced watershed nutrient loads caused by hurricane and El Niño-related rainfall can directly enhance the potential for autochthonous HAB events. Physical disturbance of sediments by storm events can also enhance internal nutrient loads, as observed in Lake Taihu, China13. Similar observations have been made in Florida Bay, a restricted estuary on the southern tip of the Florida peninsula. Three hurricanes impacted Florida Bay in 2005 (i.e. Katrina, Rita and Wilma), resulting in transport of nutrient rich sediments into the eastern bay, increased nutrient load from the bay’s watersheds and destruction of mangrove habitat. The hurricane period was followed by intense marine picoplanktonic cyanobacteria blooms from 2005–2008, in part aided by the very long water residence times in the bay31,72,73.
By contrast, the St. Lucie Estuary presents a different picture, in part because of the shorter and more variable water residence times (i.e. 1–16.5 days)19,39, and the linkage to bloom-prone Lake Okeechobee. As a result, the greatest potential for autochthonous marine algal blooms occurs during periods of comparatively low rainfall, watershed discharge and nutrient levels, but longer water residence times which permit the accumulation of phytoplankton biomass. Conversely, periods of high rainfall, watershed discharge and nutrient inputs from the watershed can be associated with lower peak phytoplankton biomass levels due to short water residence times. Similar relationships have been observed in two other ecosystems in Florida, the Guana, Tolomato, Matanzas estuary41,74,75 and Lake George17,76. In both ecosystems the strong hurricane seasons of 2004 and 2005 yielded reduced peaks in phytoplankton biomass due to reduced water residence times, despite elevated concentrations of nutrients. The exception to this trend in the St. Lucie Estuary is high rainfall periods associated with high discharges from Lake Okeechobee during intense freshwater HAB events in the lake, leading to freshwater HABs of allochthonous origin in the estuary18,39. Similar relationships have been observed in other estuaries77, such as the Caloosahatchee estuary in Florida78 and San Francisco Bay79.
Potential impacts of hurricanes and El Niño periods on HABs are not limited to coastal estuaries and inland lakes, but can extend into nearshore and open ocean environments, particularly in shallow shelf regions. The potential is illustrated by the intense red tide event experienced along the southwest coast of Florida in the summer of 201877,80,81,82. The toxic dinoflagellate bloom, dominated by Karenia brevis, extended over a broad reach of the inner shelf near several major freshwater outflows from the watershed, including large inputs from the Caloosahatchee River. The red tide resulted in serious impacts to aquatic animal and human health, as described for earlier red tide events in the region, including mass mortalities of marine animals and human health impacts related to exposure to aerosolized neurotoxins produced by K. brevis (i.e. brevetoxin)81,83. As in the case of the St. Lucie estuary, the Caloosahatchee River was subject to large discharges from Lake Okeechobee in response to the strong hurricane season in 2017 and high rainfall in the spring of 2018. Recent research has shown that periods of high discharge result in significant elevation of nutrient levels in the estuary82. It may be hypothesized that such discharges contribute to the nutrient supplies that support red tide events, such as the event observed in 201882, highlighting the need for further research on land-sea interactions in relationship to coastal blooms.
Irrespective of the origin of HAB events, they can be disruptive to ecosystem structure and function in many ways, including production of toxins, promotion of hypoxic conditions, shading out of benthic primary producers (e.g. seagrasses) and alteration of food web dynamics84. Depending on the species involved, HABs can also pose threats to human and animal health, particularly as it relates to toxin exposure52,53,81,83,85. Beyond these direct harmful effects, there are indirect side effects to HAB phenomena, which can have important economic and life-style consequences86,87. Except for some inquisitive and committed phycologists, most people find the types of intense algal scums encountered in the St. Lucie Estuary (Figs. 2a and 5) and Indian River Lagoon (Fig. 7a) disturbing and undesirable, leading to impacts on tourism, recreational use and property values. In a sense, the visual imagery of these blooms sends a strong message on the sensitivity of aquatic ecosystems to changes in the environment related to human activities, including cultural eutrophication, hydrological alteration and climate change. These are multi-dimensional problems requiring multi-dimensional solutions based on a clear ecosystem-specific understanding of driving factors and consequences of HABs. The results of this study highlight the important roles that both stochastic (e.g. hurricanes and storms) and cyclical (e.g. El Niño/La Niña patterns) climatic processes can play in HAB dynamics. The anticipated future progressive changes in cultural eutrophication and global climatic conditions, if left unaddressed, will likely exacerbate existing weather-driven HAB instigations. The ecosystems included in this study are exemplary of many subtropical environments which are sensitive to climate changes due to their position in the transition between temperate and tropical environments, as well as high frequency of exposure to tropical storms. Many sub-tropical/tropical regions around the world are also subject to rapid population growth and development, heightening the challenges associated with cultural eutrophication.
The data used in this paper were obtained from the South Florida Water Management District for Lake Okeechobee. Nutrient data were obtained from St. Johns River Water Management District for the Indian River Lagoon (Palatka, Florida), as part of project data reporting requirements and should be accessible from the respective Districts.
Heisler, J. P. et al. Eutrophication and harmful algal blooms: a scientific consensus. Harmful Algae 8, 3–13 (2008).
O’Neil, J. M., Davis, T. W., Burford, M. A. & Gobler, C. J. The rise of harmful cyanobacteria blooms: The potential roles of eutrophication and climate change. Harmful Algae 14, 313–334 (2012).
Wetz, M. S. & Yoskowitz, D. W. An ‘extreme future for estuaries? Effects of extreme climatic events on estuarine water quality and ecology. Marine Poll. Bull. 69, 7–18 (2013).
Emanuel, K. Increasing destructiveness of tropical cyclones over the past 30 years. Nature 436, 686–688 (2005).
Webster, P. J., Holland, G. J., Curry, J. A. & Chang, H. R. Changes in tropical cyclone number, duration, and intensity in a warming environment. Science 309, 1844–1846 (2005).
Fasullo, J. T., Otto-Bliesner, B. L. & Stevenson, S. ENSO’s changing influence on temperature, precipitation and wildfire in a warming climate. Geophysical Res. Letters 45, 9216–9225 (2018).
Gomez, F. et al. ENSO-induced co-variability of salinity, plankton biomass and coastal currents in the northern Gulf of Mexico. Scientific Reports 9, 178 (2019).
Mallin, M. A. & Corbett, C. A. How hurricane attributes determine the extent of environmental effects: Multiple hurricanes and different coastal systems. Estuaries Coasts 29, 1046–1061 (2006).
Miller, W. D., Harding, L. W. & Adolf, J. E. Hurricane Isabel generated an unusual fall bloom in Chesapeake Bay. Geophys. Res. Lett. 33, LO6612 (2006).
Dybas, C. Two decades of hurricanes change coastal ecosystems: increase algae blooms, fish kills, dead zones. Nsf.gov/discoveries/disc_summ.jsp?cntc_id+245304. (2018).
Burkholder, J. M. et al. Comprehensive trend analysis of nutrients and related variables in a large eutrophic estuary: A decadal study of anthropogenic and climatic influences. Limnol. Oceanogr. 51, 463–487 (2006).
Paerl, H., Valdes, L. M., Peierls, B. L., Adolf, J. E. & Harding, L. W. Anthropogenic and climatic influences on the eutrophication of large estuarine systems. Limnol. Oceanogr. 51, 448–462 (2006).
Zhu, M. et al. The role of tropical cyclones in stimulating cyanobacteria (Microcystis spp.) blooms in hypertrophic Lake Taihu, China. Harmful Algae 39 (2014).
Phlips et al. From red tides to green and brown tides: Bloom dynamics in a restricted subtropical lagoon under shifting climatic conditions. Estuaries Coasts 38, 886–904 (2015).
Bienfang, P. K., Szyper, J. P., Okamoto, M. Y. & Noda, E. K. Temporal and spatial variability of phytoplankton in a subtropical ecosystem. Limnol. Oceanogr. 29, 527–539 (1984).
Cloern, J. E. & Jassby, A. D. Patterns and scales of phytoplankton variability in estuarine-coastal ecosystems. Estuaries Coasts 33, 230–241 (2010).
Havens, K. et al. Extreme weather events and climate variability provide a lens to how shallow lakes may respond to climate change. Water 8, 229, https://doi.org/10.3390/w8060229 (2016).
Rosen, B. et al. Understanding the effect of salinity tolerance on cyanobacteria associated with harmful algal blooms in Lake Okeechobee, Florida. Scientific Investigations Report 2018-5092. U.S. Dept. Of Interior, U.S. Geological Service, Reston Virginia, USA. https://doi.org/10.3133/sir20185092 (2018).
Sun, D. Development of CH3D hydrodynamic/salinity model for the St. Lucie Estuary: Appendix D in technical document to support a water reservation rule for the North Fork of the St. Lucie River. Technical Memorandum, South Florida Water Management District, West Palm Beach, Florida, USA (2009).
Sun, D. Estimate of residence time using a box model approach. Technical Memorandum, South Florida Water Management District, West Palm Beach, Florida, USA (2011).
Doering, P. H. Temporal variability of water quality in the St. Lucie Estuary, South Florida. Water Resources Bull. 32, 1293–1306 (1996).
Ji, Z., Hu, G., Shen, J. & Wan, Y. Three-dimensional modeling of hydrodynamic processes in the St. Lucie Estuary. Estuarine Coastal Shelf Sci. 73, 188–200 (2007).
Phlips, E. J. et al. Spatial and temporal variability of trophic state parameters in a shallow subtropical lake (Lake Okeechobee, Florida, USA). Arch. Fur Hydrobiologie 128, 437–458 (1993).
Phlips, E. J., Aldridge, F. J. & Hansen, P. Patterns of water chemistry, physical and biological parameters in a shallow subtropical lake (Lake Okeechobee, Florida). Arch. Hydrobiol. Special Issues, Advances in Limnology 45, 117–135 (1995).
Sheng, Y. P. & Davis, J. D. Indian River Lagoon pollution load reduction (IRLPLR) model development. Final Report to the St. Johns River Water Management District, Volume 1: A 3-D IRL hydrodynamic/salinity model (UF-CH3D). St. Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida (2003).
Steward, J. S., Virnstein, R. W., Morris, L. J. & Lowe, E. F. Setting seagrass depth, coverage, and light targets for the Indian River Lagoon System, Florida. Estuaries 28, 923–935 (2005).
Sigua, G. C. & Tweedale, W. A. Watershed scale assessment of nitrogen and phosphorus loadings in the Indian River Lagoon basin, Florida. J. Environmental Management 67, 363–372 (2003).
Gao, X. Nutrient and dissolved oxygen TMDLs for the Indian River Lagoon and Banana River lagoon. TMDL Report, Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Bureau of Watershed Management, Tallahassee, Florida, USA (2009).
Lunetta, R. S. et al. Evaluation of cyanobacteria cell count detection derived from MERIS imagery across the eastern USA. Remote Sens Environ. 157, 24–34, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2014.06.008 (2015).
Utermöhl, H. Zur Vervollkommnung der quantitativen phytoplankton-methodik. Mitt. Int. Ver. Theor. Angew. Limnol. 9, 1–38 (1958).
Phlips, E. J., Badylak, S. & Lynch, T. L. Blooms of the picoplanktonic cyanobacterium Synechococcus in Florida Bay. Limnol. Oceanogr. 44, 1166–1175 (1999).
Smayda, T. J. From phytoplankters to biomass. In: Sournia. A. (ed.), Phytoplankton Manual. UNESCO, Paris, pp. 273–279, (1978).
Sun, J. & Liu, D. Geometric models for calculating cell biovolume and surface area for phytoplankton. J. Plankton Res. 25, 1331–1346 (2003).
Strathmann, R. R. Estimating the organic carbon content of phytoplankton from cell volume or plasma volume. Limnol. Oceanogr. 12, 411–418 (1967).
Ahlgren, G. Comparison of methods for estimation of phytoplankton carbon. Archives Hydrobiologia 98, 489–508 (1983).
Sicko-Goad, L. M., Schelske, C. L. & Stoermer, E. F. Estimation of intracellular carbon and silica content of diatoms from natural assemblages using morphometric techniques. Limnol. Oceanogr. 29, 1170–1178 (1984).
Verity, P. et al. Relationships between cell volume and the carbon and nitrogen content of marine photosynthetic nanoplankton. Limnol. Oceanogr. 37, 1434–1446 (1992).
Work, K., Havens, K., Sharfstein, B. & East, T. How important is carbon to planktonic grazers in a turbid, subtropical lake? J. Plankton Res. 27, 357–372 (2005).
Phlips, E. J. et al. Climatic influences on autochthonous and allochthonous phytoplankton blooms in a subtropical estuary, St. Lucie Estuary, Florida, USA. Estuaries Coasts 35, 335–352 (2012).
Millie, D. F., Carrick, H. J., Doering, P. H. & Steidinger, K. A. Intra-annual variability of water quality and phytoplankton in the North Fork of the St. Lucie Estuary, Florida (USA): a quantitative assessment. Estuarine Coastal Shelf Sci. 61, 137–149 (2004).
Dix, N., Phlips, E. J. & Gleeson, R. Water quality changes in a tidal creek within the Guana Tolomato Matanzas National Estuarine Research Reserve, Florida, associated with the four tropical storms of 2004. J. Coastal Res., Spec. Issue 55, 70–81 (2008).
Havens, K. E. et al. Hurricane effects on the planktonic food web of a large subtropical lake. J. Plankton Res. 33, 1081–1094 (2011).
Aldridge, F., Phlips, E. J. & Schelske, C. L. The use of nutrient enrichment bioassays to test for spatial and temporal distribution of limiting factors affecting phytoplankton dynamics in Lake Okeechobee, Florida. Arch. Hydrobiol. Special Issues, Adv. Limnol. 45, 177–190 (1995).
Phlips, E. J. et al. The control of phytoplankton abundance and structure by nutrient and light availability in a shallow subtropical lake. J. Plankton Res. 19, 319–342 (1997).
Krimsky, L., Phlips, E. & Havens, K. A response to frequently asked questions about the 2018 algae blooms in Lake Okeechobee, the Caloosahatchee and St. Lucie estuaries. Florida Sea Grant Program Publication ED-2, http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu (2018).
Hansen, P., Phlips, E. J. & Aldridge, F. J. Algal growth response to sediment resuspension in a shallow subtropical lake, Lake Okeechobee: A laboratory simulation. N. Amer. Lake Res. Management 13, 154–159 (1997).
Havens, K. E., Phlips, E. J., Cichra, M. F. & Li, B. L. Light availability as a possible regulator of cyanobacteria species composition in a shallow subtropical lake. Freshwater Biol. 39, 547–556 (1998).
Leatherman, S. P., Zhang, K. & Xiao, C. Lake Okeechobee, Florida: The Next Hurricane Disaster? Water Resources Impact 9, 5–7 (2007).
Cadavid, L., C. et al. Lake Okeechobee Operations by Means of the Water Supply and Environment (WSE) Regulation Schedule. Oper. Reserv. Chang. Cond. Pp. 205–214 (2006).
James, R. T. & Pollman, C. D. Sediment and nutrient management solutions to improve the water quality of Lake Okeechobee. Lake Reservoir Management 27, 28–40 (2011).
United States Geological Survey. USGS 0227 St. Lucie BLW S-308, NR Port Mayaca (AUX) FL. www.waterdata.usgs.gov/nwis.
Chorus, I. & Bartram, J. Toxic cyanobacteria in water: A guide to their public health consequences, monitoring and Management. World Health Organization, London, UK. (1999)
Farrer, D., Counter, M., Hillwig, R. & Cude, C. Health-bsed cyanotoxin guideline values for cyanotoxin-based monitoring and efficient public health response to cyanobacterial blooms. Toxins 7, 457–477 (2015).
Oehrle, S., Rodriguez-Matos, M., Cartamil, M., Zavala, C. & Rein, K. S. Toxin composition of the Microcystis aeruginosa bloom in the St. Lucie Estuary, Florida. Toxicon 138, 169–172 (2017).
Phlips, E. J., Badylak, S., Christman, M. C. & Lasi, M. A. Climatic trends and temporal patterns of phytoplankton composition, abundance and succession in the Indian River Lagoon, Florida, USA. Estuaries Coasts 33, 498–512 (2010).
Phlips, E. J., Badylak, S., Bledsoe, E. L. & Cichra, M. Factors influencing the distribution and abundance of Pyrodinium bahamense in coastal ecosystems of Florida. Mar. Ecol. Progr. Ser. 322, 99–115 (2006).
Usup, G., Ahmad, A., Matsuoka, K., Lim, P. & Leaw, C. Biology, ecology and bloom dynamics of the toxic dinoflagellate Pyrodinium bahamense. Harmful Algae 14, 301–312 (2012).
Kahya, E. & Dracup, J. A. U.S. Streamflow patterns in relation to the El Niño/Southern Oscillation. Water Res. Res. 29, 2491–2503 (1993).
Abtew, W. & Trimble, P. El Niño-Southern Oscillation link to south Florida hydrology and water management applications. Water. Res. Manage. 24, 4255–4271 (2010).
Swarzenski, P. W., Martin, J. & Cable, J. Submarine ground-water discharge in upper Indian River Lagoon. In: Kuniansky, E. L. (ed.), U.S.G.S Karst Group Proceedings, pp. 194-197, Water Resources Investigations Report 01-4011 (2001).
Adkins, M. et al. Watershed model development for the Indian River Lagoon basin: Providing simulated runoff and pollution load to the Indian River Lagoon pollution load reduction model. St. Johns River Water Management District Technical Memorandum 50. St. Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida (2004).
Steward, J. S. & Green, W. C. Setting load limits for nutrients and suspended solids based upon seagrass depth-limit targets. Estuaries Coasts 30, 657–670 (2007).
Gao, X. Nutrient and dissolved oxygen TMDLs for the Indian River Lagoon and Banana River Lagoon. Report to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Tallahassee, Florida (2009).
Lapointe, B. E., Herren, L. W., Debortoli, D. D. & Vogel, M. A. Evidence of sewage-driven eutrophication and harmful algal blooms in Florida’s Indian River Lagoon. Harmful Algae 43, 82–102 (2015).
Barile, P. J. Widespread sewage pollution of the Indian River Lagoon system, Florida (USA) resolved by spatial analyses of macroalgal biogeochemistry. Marine Pollution Bulletin 128, 557–574 (2018).
Phlips, E. J. & Badylak, S. Phytoplankton abundance and composition in the Indian River Lagoon. Annual Report to the St. Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida, USA (2018).
Huang, P., Xie, S., Hu, K., Huang, G. & Huang, R. Patterns of the seasonal response of tropical rainfall to global temperature. Nature Geoscience 6, 357–361 (2013).
Wang, G. et al. The peak structure and future changes of the relationships between extreme precipitation and temperature. Nature Climate Change 7, 268–275 (2017).
Paerl, H. W. & Paul, V. J. Climate change: Links to global expansion of harmful cyanobacteria. Water Research 46, 1349–1363 (2012).
Acevedo-Trejos, E., Brandt, G., Steinacher, M. & Merico, A. A glimpse into the future composition of marine phytoplankton communities. Frontiers Mar. Sci. 1, 15 (2014).
Augusti, S., Lubián, L. M., Moreno-Ostos, E., Estrada, M. & Duarte, C. M. Projected changes in photosynthetic picoplankton in a warmer subtropical ocean. Frontiers Mar. Sci. 5, 506 (2019).
Glibert, P. M. et al. Florida Bay: water quality status and trends, historic and emerging algal bloom problems. Contrib. Mar. Sci. 38, 5–17 (2009).
Phlips, E. J., Lynch, T. C. & Badylak, S. Chlorophyll a, tripton, color and light availability in a shallow tropical inner shelf lagoon, Florida Bay. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 127, 223–234 (1995).
Phlips, E. J. et al. A comparison of water quality and hydrodynamic characteristics of the Guana Tolomato Matanzas National Estuarine Research Reserve and the Indian River Lagoon in Florida. J. Coastal Res. Spec. Issue 45, 93–109 (2004).
Hart, J. A. et al. Phytoplankton biomass and composition in a well-flushed sub-tropical estuary: The contrasting effects of hydrology, nutrient loads and allochthonous influences. Mar. Environmental Res. 112, 9–20 (2015).
Srifa, A., Phlips, E. J., Cichra, M. F. & Hendrickson, J. C. Phytoplankton dynamics in a sub-tropical lake dominated by cyanobacteria: Cyanobacteria ‘like it hot and sometimes dry. Aquatic Ecology 50, 163–174 (2016).
Preece, E. P., Hardy, F. J., Moore, B. C. & Bryan, M. A review of microcystin detections in estuarine and marine waters: Environmental implications and human health risk. Harmful Algae 61, 31–45 (2017).
Paerl, H. et al. Co-occurrence of dinoflagellate and cyanobacterial harmful algae blooms in southwest Florida waters: A case for dual nutrient (N and P) input controls. Mar. Ecol. Progr. Ser. 371, 143–153 (2008).
Peacock, M. B., Gibble, C. M., Senn, D. B., Cloern, J. E. & Kudela, R. M. Blurred lines: Multiple freshwater and marine algal toxins at the land-sea interface of San Francisco Bay, California. Harmful Algae 73, 138–147 (2018).
FWC. Red tide. myFWC.com/redtide (2018).
Fleming, L. et al. Review of Florida red tide and human health effects. Harmful Algae 10, 224–233 (2011).
Heil, C. A. et al. Nutrients and Karenia brevis (Davis) G. Hansen & Moestrup blooms in the eastern Gulf: Management recommendations. Harmful Algae Sp. Issue 38, 127–140 (2014).
Kirkpatrick, B. et al. Inland transport of aerosolized Florida red tide toxins. Harmful Algae 9, 186–189 (2010).
Granéli, E. & Turner, J. T. Ecology of harmful algae. Springer-Verlag, Berlin (2006).
Landsberg, J. H. The effects of harmful algal blooms on aquatic organisms. Rev. Fish. Sci. 10, 113–390 (2002).
Anderson, D., Hoagland, P., Kaoru, Y. & White, A. Estimated annual economic impacts from harmful algal blooms (HABs) in the United States. Sea Grant Technical Report WHOI-2000-11. Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (2002).
Hoagland, P. & Scatasta, S. Economic impacts of algal blooms. In: Ecology of Harmful Algae. E. Granéli and J. T. Turner (eds.). Springer-Verlag, Berlin (2006).
The research presented in this paper was in part funded by grants from the St. Johns River Water Management District (Palatka, Florida), South Florida Water Management District (West Palm Beach, Florida), USEPA Indian River Lagoon National Estuary Program and NSF CBET Award #1853041. The authors thank Dr. Margie Lasi, Dr. Charles Jacoby, Jan Miller and Lauren Hall for their collaborations in the Indian River Lagoon research. The authors acknowledge Dr. Detong Sun of the South Florida Water Management District (West Palm Beach, Florida) for providing data on water residence times in the St. Lucie Estuary. The authors thank Dr. Blake Schaeffer (U.S.E.P.A.) for his assistance in using the Cyanobacteria Index. The authors thank Kelly Young (Volusia County Environmental Management) for the use of her photo in Fig. 7a. Natalie Nelson is supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, Hatch Project 1016068. Edward Phlips and Susan Badylak are supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, Hatch Project 1017098.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Phlips, E.J., Badylak, S., Nelson, N.G. et al. Hurricanes, El Niño and harmful algal blooms in two sub-tropical Florida estuaries: Direct and indirect impacts. Sci Rep 10, 1910 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-58771-4