Global ocean acidification is expected to chronically lower the pH to 7.3 (>2200 µatm seawater pCO2) by the year 2300. Acute hypercapnia already occurs along the South African west and south coasts due to upwelling- and low-oxygen events, with increasing frequency. In the present project we investigated the impact of hypercapnia on the endemic demersal shark species Haploblepharus edwardsii. Specifically, we experimentally analysed acid-base regulation during acute and chronic hypercapnia, the effects of chronic hypercapnia on growth rates and on denticle structure- and composition. While H. edwardsii are physiologically well adapted to acute and chronic hypercapnia, we observed, for the first time, denticle corrosion as a result of chronic exposure. We conclude that denticle corrosion could increase denticle turnover and compromise hydrodynamics and skin protection.
The continuous absorption of anthropogenic CO2 from the atmosphere feeds the ongoing process of ocean acidification, affecting both the average CO2 levels and the magnitude of CO2 fluctuations1,2. The ongoing changes in the ocean’s carbonate chemistry caused by anthropogenic CO2 emissions are thought to have profound effects on the biology, distribution, morphology, behaviour and physiology of marine organisms3,4,5. The increased dissolution of CO2 in seawater results in a net increase in the concentration of H3O+ ions and a decrease in CO32− ions leading to a lowered pH - a process known as ocean acidification6. By the year 2300, a global pH of about 7.3 is expected7 as a result of an increased oceanic pCO2 of above 2200 µatm, with potentially severe effects on marine organisms and ecosystems. Elucidating these effects is paramount to predict and mitigate against their impact.
The South African west and south coasts are influenced by the environmental dynamics in the Benguela Large Marine Ecosystem (BCLME), characterised by coastal upwelling and, in some areas, periods of low-oxygen due to algal decay and bacterial respiration. The BCLME is one of the world’s largest Eastern Boundary (upwelling) systems8. Frequent upwelling events in austral summer cause periodic episodes of hypercapnia (pH levels 7.4–7.6) which can even reach pH 6.6 for several days during low oxygen events in autumn10. Upwelling takes place in 3–10 day cycles in spring and summer9, moving cold (~10 °C), hypercapnic water (pH 7.4–7.6) closer to the surface11,12. Low oxygen events normally occur after the upwelling season caused by the collapse of phytoplankton blooms13. As a result of climate change, upwelling events in eastern boundary current systems, and in turn hypercapnic episodes, are predicted to become longer, more frequent and severe in the near future14,15,16,17, with much variability observed in the BCLME18.
Cartilaginous fishes play an essential role in the global marine ecosystems19 and some species represent an important fishing resource20, yet the consequences of ocean acidification for this phyletic group remain poorly understood21. Their slow rate of evolution, low phenotypic plasticity and low adaption potential due to long generation times and low fecundity put sharks at a higher risk from the effects of climate change22. The South African chondrichthyofauna includes representatives from all 10 orders of cartilaginous fishes, 44 of 60 families (73%), 100 out of 189 genera (53%), and over 181 of the 1171 world species (15%), with a high degree of endemism23. The puffadder shyshark (Haploblepharus edwardsii, Scyliorhinidae) is a small (600 mm max. total length), benthic catshark species endemic to South African shallow temperate waters. Puffadder shy sharks are generalist feeders residing in kelp beds and sand-inundated reefs, preying on crustaceans, polychaetes and small teleosts in relatively shallow water. In its habitat, H. edwardsii is exposed to highly variable pH and temperature conditions.
There have been a number of studies investigating the effects of hypercapnia on invertebrates24 and teleosts25,26, but very few on chondrichthyans27. Physiological effects such as haemolymph- or blood acidosis are known for invertebrates and fishes3,26,28. Effects on growth rates have been found to be highly variable among different groups and life history stages29. Recent findings suggest that embryo survival and development time are unlikely to be affected, but effects on body condition, growth, aerobic potential and behaviour have been suggested for demersal shark species27. Effects on formation and alteration of skeletal, otolith or integument structures have been elucidated in various studies30. The potential impact of hypercapnia on mineralisation in elasmobranchs has been less studied so far: Chronic hypercapnia has an impact on the skeleton of juvenile (i.e. developing) skates31 and a minor effect on mineralisation of vertebrae of juvenile sharks32. When the impact of hypercapnia on chondrichthyan denticles was investigated, no effects were found in juvenile catshark21 (4–6 months at 1100 µatm) and skate embryos31 (1 month at 990 µatm). Generalisation of existing results is difficult due to the diversity of experimental conditions and species’ responses, but species in highly variable environments might already reside close to their biological limits24 and rapid change of baseline conditions, such as predicted for the BCLME, might result in suboptimal and even lethal conditions.
Here we investigate effects of future ocean acidification levels on H. edwardsii. The hypercapnic level (pH 7.3, expected by year 2300 according to IPCC scenario) was chosen to be below the range of what occurs regularly during upwelling and taking into account that pH levels are usually well below the global average pH of 8.1 in the BCLME. Puffadder shysharks are already adapted to a highly variable environment and are restricted in their distribution to the Southern tip of Africa without a possibility of a range shift to mitigate against negative effects of climate change. The species is well suited for our experiments because they are relatively small, easy to rear and can easily be obtained in relevant numbers for experimentation. In the present study we specifically investigated the acid-base regulation during the exposure of puffadder shysharks to (1) acute (32 h) and (2) chronic (9 weeks) hypercapnia in laboratory experiments. Furthermore we examined the effects of chronic hypercapnia on (3) growth rates and (4) on denticle structure by means of Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) scans and elemental composition analysis. We hypothesised that puffadder shy sharks, due to their environmental adaptation, are able to physiologically acclimatize to acute and possibly chronic hypercapnia. We further hypothesize that physiological compensation during chronic hypercapnia will come at an energetic cost that decreases somatic growth. Finally, we postulate that the low pH will have a detrimental effect on the denticle structure of the shy shark, similar to human dental corrosion after exposure to carbonated drinks.
Materials and Methods
All research presented here was conducted under permission of the Research Ethics Committee: Animal Care and Use of Stellenbosch University (SU-ACUM14-00006) and is in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations. Specimens (80) of the Puffadder shyshark H. edwardsii were caught in the harbour basin of the False Bay Yacht Club in Simons Town, South Africa (34.07°S, 18.33°E) in austral spring. Sharks were caught by SCUBA divers by hand after setting out bait (sardines) in perforated 5 l plastic bottles. Caught sharks were collected in nets until they were transferred into an 800 l tank on a car trailer. Water in the tank was continuously provided with oxygen (technical) from a cylinder. After capture, sharks were transported within an hour to holding tanks at the Research Aquarium of the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries (DAFF) in Cape Town.
In Cape Town, they were weighed and maintained in round flow-through holding tanks (4500 l) for four months prior to experimentation (pH ranged from 7.9 to 8.1; TA from 8.4 to 16.8 °C). They were fed rations of 5% of average body mass with pieces of squid once a week. Sharks were not fed in the week of experimentation.
For acute exposure, 66 larger sharks (179 ± 52 g, 67% male) were acclimatized for 48 h prior to experimentation in smaller round tanks (∅ = 1.2 m, h = 1 m, 1130 l). Tanks were well mixed by propellers and aerated by compressed air. At the start of the trial, individuals were distributed between two replicate control- (normocapnic) or hypercapnic tanks (141 l rectangular glass tanks) with corresponding pH levels of ~7.3 and ~8.0, respectively. Weight of animals did not differ significantly between replicate groups (ANOVA, p = 0.993). For blood sampling, individuals were removed from tanks at the respective time points of incubation, i.e. after 1.5, 3, 6 and 24 hours, alternating between replicate tanks. Each time point represents samples from both replicates of the same treatment (3 per replicate for hypercapnic treatment, 2 or 3 for normocapnic treatment. For the starting value (time 0), blood was collected from sharks from the same batch. These sharks were not incubated thereafter. To test recovery, some sharks were transferred after 24 h of exposure into tanks with normocapnic conditions and sampled after a further 8 h (i.e. a total of 32 h from the start of the trial). After sampling, sharks were transferred back into the acclimation tank and not used further. Blood was sampled (see below) only once from each shark. Analyses were carried out in the statistical software environment R (Ver. 3.0.1.), including the nlme package (Ver. 3.0.1.)33. Differences between parameters were tested for each interval against the base value (0 h) for the normocapnic (control) group and the hypercapnic (treatment) by means of ANOVA. Response variables were modelled as a function of the interaction between sampling time and treatment with linear-mixed effects models. Tank was initially included as a random effect, but found to increase the AIC value when tested against a fixed-effects model and consequently dropped. Filtered seawater for the system was provided by the main water storage tank of the research aquarium. It supplied each replicate via a header (mixing) tank. In two of the header tanks, pH was adjusted by its own CO2 supply for hypercapnic treatment. This was accomplished by using a pH controller (7074/2, TUNZE, Germany) containing a solenoid valve (7074.111) and a pH electrode (7070.110) attached to a 9 kg CO2 bottle (technical). A level of pH of 7.3 was selected as this level is predicted by the year 23007. The experiment was carried out in a room with stable ambient air temperature (ranging from 16–18 °C) so that additional control of seawater temperature was unnecessary. During the acute experiment, seawater conditions were tested five times in each replicate tank (summarised in Table 1) and did not differ significantly between replicates of each treatment (pH, T; ANOVA).
Subsequently, the remaining 13 smaller sharks were taken from the holding tank (see above) for chronic exposure. They were weighed (w) total length (L) measured and tagged (barbed dart tags (D-tag; 89 mm, Ø 1.4 mm; Hallprint Pty Ltd, South Australia) left of the first dorsal fin (121.4 ± 34.2 g, 85% male, see Results for more details). Thereafter they were transferred into normocapnic- or hypercapnic replicate tanks as described above, except that rectangular 1000 l plastic tanks were used here. All tanks were well mixed and aerated. ANOVA revealed no difference in w and L between the four replicate groups (p = 0.993; 0.914). In the two weeks prior to chronic exposure, seawater temperature in the holding tanks was in the range of 15.7–16.3 °C. Sharks of both treatments were acclimatized for a week to around 18 °C after which the pH for hypercapnic treatment was lowered in two steps in five days from approximately 8.1 to 7.3, using a pH control system as described above. The experimental pH of 7.3 was selected as this level is predicted to be reached by the year 23007. It will possibly be reached earlier in the BCLME as it is close to values already attained over short periods during severe upwelling periods and after decay of algal blooms10. Seawater temperature was allowed to fluctuate with the incoming seawater. Similar seawater temperatures were recorded in all replicate tanks throughout experimentation. Seawater parameters were measured daily with the exception of AT which was measured thrice a week (summarised in Table 1) and did not differ significantly between replicates of the same treatment (pH, T; ANOVA). Sharks remained under experimental conditions for 63 days (~9 weeks). To record growth and to adjust the food rations, sharks were re-weighed and measured after 4, 6 and 9 weeks. Paired t-tests were carried out to test for significant changes in length and mass within treatments. Differences at the end of incubation (blood parameters, elemental composition and physical damage of denticles) were modelled with linear-mixed effects models that included treatment as fixed and Tank as random effect. Equally to the acute experiment, Tank was found to increase the AIC value when tested against a fixed-effects model and consequently dropped (R Ver. 3.0.1.)33.
Seawater pCO2, [CO32−] and [HCO3−] were calculated using measured pH, salinity, ambient temperature (TA) and total alkalinity (AT)34 as constants in CO2SYS software35. Oxygen concentration was determined using a Multi 350i meter set (WTW, Germany). Water quality was monitored by measuring NH3 concentration (Ammonia test kit, Sera, Germany) and never exceeded 0.09 mg l−1.
At the given intervals during the acute experiment and at termination of the chronic experiment, sharks were removed from their tanks, heads (eyes) were covered by a seawater-soaked cloth to reduce stress and prevent curling of the tail and animals placed upside down on a seawater-soaked cloth. In addition, head and tail were held tight by hand to avoid movement. Approximately 1 ml blood was immediately withdrawn from the caudal vein by syringe with a hypodermic needle (Neomedic 1 ml, 26 G) into a 2 ml syringe treated with heparin before the animals were carefully returned to the tank. All animals from the chronic experiment were subsequently sacrificed using ethylene glycol monophenyl ether (C8H10C2, 0.8 ml l−1). Skin samples were then taken dorso-laterally next to the first dorsal fin and frozen at −20 °C for electron-microscopic- and elemental analysis.
Analysis of denticles
Micrographs of shark skin areas and denticles were obtained by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) using a Leo 1430VP (Zeiss, Germany) of gold-platinum-sputtered samples whereas elemental composition of the outer denticle surface was analysed using energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) with an ESEM Quanta 400 FEG instrument (Thermo Scientific, USA) after sputtering with gold and palladium (80:20)36,37. On the resulting SEM micrographs, ratios of damaged and intact denticles were quantified by counting.
Blood acid-base balance
The blood pH was measured within 20 s after sampling using an Orion 3 star pH meter equipped with an Orion 8220 BNWP micro pH electrode (Thermo Scientific, USA). Calibration was performed with NBS precision buffers (Applichem, Germany) at the same temperature as that of ambient seawater of the experimental tanks. A blood subsample (50 µl) was immediately injected into a de-gassing (magnetic stirrer) chamber containing 200 µl of 100 mM H2SO4 and liberated total CO2 (cCO2) determined as described previously38. From measured pH and cCO2 values, pCO2, and [HCO3−] were calculated using derivatives of the Henderson Hasselbalch equation (I and II). The required solubility coefficient αCO2 and dissociation constant pK’1 of carbonic acid were obtained from Boutilier et al.39 for catsharks (Scyliorhinus canicula and S. stellaris).
Ca2+ and Mg2+ concentrations were determined spectrophotometrically by commercial kits (Diaglobal, Germany) in undiluted small subsamples.
Subsamples of 500 μl blood were immediately transferred into an EDTA pre-treated K2E reaction vessel (BD Microtainer, USA) for measurement of haematocrit. The vessels were closed and the samples shaken to ensure mixing of EDTA. Thereafter, 80 iu/ml sodium-heparinised micro haematocrit capillaries (Marienfeld, Germany) were completely filled, sealed with plasticine and subsequently spun at room temperature for 5 min in a Haematospin 1300 centrifuge (Lasec, SA). Haematocrit was subsequently quantified using a Micro Haematocrit reader (Hawksley, UK).
Blood acid-base balance during acute hypercapnia
The acute exposure experiment revealed differences between responses to normocapnic and hypercapnic conditions, respectively.
In the normocapnic control group, there were no significant changes in pH (Table 2). Extracellular total CO2 (cCO2) levels remained in a narrow range of between 5 and 6 mmol l−1 throughout the course of the experiment. Accordingly, calculated values of [HCO3− + CO32−] and pCO2 showed very little change. This is also evident from the Henderson-Hasselbalch diagram (Fig. 1).
Despite the increase in seawater pCO2 and subsequently blood pCO2 (Table 2), the extracellular pH in sharks in the hypercapnic treatment increased by 0.1 units in the first 3 h after sudden exposure to hypercapnia (Table 2). From this point, it followed a similar course as observed in normocapnic sharks (see above). To the 24 h mark, this comprises an over-compensation of pH by approximately 0.15 pH units or reduction in [H+] by 5.1 mM (29%) compared with initial levels. pH increased by another 0.05 units during the subsequent 8 h of recovery in normocapnic seawater. All treatment: time interactions were significant from 1.5 h incubation onwards.
Extracellular cCO2 levels rose by 114% from an initial 6.3 mmol l−1 during 24 h of hypercapnic exposure (Table 2). These increases were significant from 1.5 h incubation onwards. Subsequent recovery in normocapnic seawater caused a sharp decline by 58% (not sig. different to 0 h) to below the initial level. Values for [HCO3− + CO32−] followed a similar trend (Table 2). The partial pressure of CO2 increased from its initial level peaking at the 24 h time interval (sig. different from 1.5 h incubation) after which it decreased sharply to below the initial value during recovery (not sig.). Data was used to construct a Henderson-Hasselbalch diagram, depicting the extracellular pH, calculated [HCO3− + CO32−] and pCO2 values (Fig. 1). No acidosis occurred initially after exposure to hypercapnia which would have been indicated by a shift to the left. Compensation by an increase in [HCO3− + CO32−] started immediately, buffering the blood and leading to an alkalosis when compared to the initial pH measured. This is indicated by a shift to the right. This alkalosis is carried over to the 32 h (recovery) value although pCO2 and [HCO3− + CO32−] dropped sharply during this period. In contrast, there is very little change in sharks exposed to normocapnic conditions (Fig. 1). Between treatments, haemolymph pHs only differed up to the 1.5 h time interval, after which both followed a similar path, including 8 h of recovery (Table 2). Total CO2, calculated pCO2 and [HCO3− + CO32−], however, were substantially higher in hypercapnic sharks with the exception of the recovery values. Concentrations of Ca2+ and Mg2+ were stable in both treatments and did not differ between treatments throughout the experiment (Table 2).
Acid-base balance and other blood parameters during chronic hypercapnia
The pH levels measured in the blood of hypercapnic- and normocapnic incubated sharks were identical (not sig.), whereas cCO2 had approximately doubled (sig.) to 8.3 mM under hypercapnia compared with normocapnia (Table 3). Accordingly, calculated pCO2 and [HCO3− + CO32−] were 2.2 Torr compared to 1.1 Torr (not sig.) and bicarbonate 8.1 mM compared to 4.2 mM under normocapnia (sig.), respectively. Water pCO2 levels rose from 0.3 to 1.4 Torr during hypercapnic incubation but venous blood was significantly higher at 2.2 Torr. The Henderson-Hasselbalch diagram provided an illustration of the interaction of extracellular pH, calculated haemolymph bicarbonate and pCO2: At similar pHs in sharks from both treatments, elevation of pCO2 and [HCO3− + CO32−] caused a vertical shift in hypercapnic sharks, indicating bicarbonate buffering that results in slight alkalosis (Fig. 2). [Ca2+] and [Mg2+] were at the same level after both treatments (not sig.; Table 3). Haematocrit levels were similar after chronic treatment and not sig. different (Table 3).
Analysis of denticles following chronic hypercapnia
SEM analysis of skin areas covered with denticles revealed contrasting results: Denticles from normocapnic sharks were mostly intact and had a shiny surface with sharp edges (Fig. 3). In contrast, many denticles from hypercapnic sharks were damaged and their surface appears corroded and edges less sharp (Fig. 3). Comparison of SEM images from individual denticles confirmed this. Surfaces look smoother on normocapnic denticles (Fig. 4). Quantitative analysis of denticles from SEM micrographs revealed that significantly less (n = 3, p < 0.05) denticles (9.2 ± 3.2%) were damaged (pieces broken off) on normocapnic sharks than on hypercapnic ones (25.0 ± 6.7%).
Elemental composition of denticles from both treatments revealed some significant differences: Two of the elements that form fluoroapatite (Ca5(PO4)3F) and hydroxyapatite (Ca5(PO4)3OH) that are normally present in substantial quantities, Ca (−35%) and P (−26%), have a lower proportion in denticles from hypercapnic sharks (sig.), resulting in a lower Ca: P ratio (Table 4). In contrast, the proportions of C (+29%) and O (+15%,) are elevated although not significantly in the case of O.
Impact of chronic hypercapnia on body size
Sharks from the chronic normocapnic treatment increased in total length by 0.2 ± 0.6 cm (0.5%) from 31.6 ± 2.8 to 32.4 ± 3.0 cm and by mass by 7.7 ± 9.9 g (6.2%) from 123.8 ± 33.4 to 131.5 ± 37.1 g. Total length of hypercapnic sharks remained relatively stable (+0.1 ± 0.5 cm = 0.2%) from 31.4 ± 2.1 to 31.5 ± 2.1 cm and their mass changed by 0.8 ± 4.5 g (0.7%) from 118.5 ± 27.6 to 119.3 ± 29.0 g in nine weeks. The changes in length and mass were neither significantly different within nor between treatments.
The main findings of the present study are that (1) Haploblepharus edwardsii adjusts well physiologically (i.e. regulation of acid-base balance) to acute hypercapnia. (2) This regulation can be maintained during chronic hypercapnic exposure. (3) The prolonged regulation is likely to be energetically costly but in the present study no significant depression of somatic growth was observed. (4) Although the sharks can maintain their acid-base balance, prolonged exposure to hypercapnia has detrimental chemical effects that cannot be compensated, namely the dissolution of their denticles’ surface.
As a result of upwelling, the habitat of H. edwardsii is characterised by short periods of strong hypercapnia. Acute environmental hypercapnia results in increased extracellular pCO2 and decline of pH and, if uncompensated, would most likely impact gas exchange of haemoglobin and at the tissues. Compensation mechanisms exist in many marine animals in the form of an elevation of bicarbonate [HCO3−] levels to return pH levels to close to original values3. Also, the outward gradient for CO2 removal would become difficult to maintain due to an insufficiently high extracellular pCO2 level compared with the increased environmental pCO2. Such compensatory capacity is present in H. edwardsii.
We could demonstrate that H. edwardsii possesses the necessary compensation mechanisms to react to a sudden onset of hypercapnia: A rapid elevation of [HCO3−] by a net 7.1 mmol l−1 (+115%) after 24 h was observed, with a near doubling (+4.3 mmol l−1) already after 90 min of exposure, likely rapid enough to prevent a decline of arterial plasma pH. At the same time, the arterial plasma pCO2 was elevated by a net 1.2 Torr (+50%). This increased the outward CO2 gradient to 1.9 Torr, despite elevation of ambient pCO2 by 1.4 Torr. The 1.7 Torr of the latter was well within the range of resting plasma pCO2 and would have made gas exchange impossible. In the normocapnic group, the gradient was 1.2 Torr after the same incubation period. Such fast response is indicative of exposure and adaptation of the species to frequently elevated hypercapnia in its habitat40.
The Henderson-Hasselbalch diagram (Fig. 1) illustrates the interaction of arterial plasma pH, calculated plasma bicarbonate and pCO2: Whereas values are concentrated in a very restricted area throughout entire experimentation in the normocapnic group, the situation is very different in the hypercapnic group. Over-compensation of plasma pH (move to right, alkalosis) due to the elevation of bicarbonate levels (upward move) caused an increase in pH. In other species, a transitional acidosis (drop in plasma pH) that lasted several hours, has been observed before compensation through bicarbonate became effective41,42. In our study, a further increase (along a constant pCO2 isopleth) was caused by bicarbonate increase until 24 h of exposure. Such rapid responses indicate the presence of an efficient Cl−/HCO3− exchanger as was previously found in the gills of sharks43, possibly supplemented by a Na+/NH4+ exchanger42. In addition, an involvement of a Na+-K+-ATPase as in teleosts is possible44. After the sharks were returned to normocapnic conditions after 24 h, alkalosis (high pH) persisted regardless of a substantial and rapid decline in bicarbonate concentration. Adjustment of pH to initial levels takes probably longer to allow cellular processes to adjust. The rapid recovery indicates the reversibility of this mechanism. Esbaugh et al.26 have hypothesised that species that are adapted to low-level hypercapnia may no longer rely on traditional short-term acid-base regulation and use morphological changes (gill permeability, diffusion distances) instead or in addition. In H. edwardsii this may be a contributing factor but has not been studied here.
It is important to note that acute physiological responses often differ distinctly from those to chronic exposure. In H. edwardsii, however, the response shown after acute exposure was maintained for a period of more than 60 days. In both treatments, plasma pH levels were very similar and there was no acidosis as could be expected if compensatory mechanisms cannot be maintained for prolonged periods. The increase in bicarbonate concentrations seen in the Henderson-Hasselbalch diagram makes it also apparent that, at least in part, increased bicarbonate levels are part of these mechanisms, ensuring that the outward pCO2 gradient (0.6 Torr) is maintained at a level found in normocapnia (0.8 Torr). However, long term compensation is likely to come at a cost: Lower metabolic rates, dissolution of hard structures such as shells and carapaces have been found3,45,46. Although metabolic depression47 is an adequate, reversible strategy to mitigate against short term hypercapnic exposure, the concomitant reduction in somatic growth and reproductive output might have negative effects during chronic exposure. This was previously shown in Port Jackson sharks48.
Structural- and compositional changes of denticles under chronic hypercapnic conditions were evident from structural scans and elemental composition of samples. Weakening and deformation of CaCO3 shell and skeleton elements has been observed in a host of different marine invertebrates30 and fishes49 and largely attributed to the negative effects of increased pCO2 on calcification or chemical dissolution. Shark denticles differ from invertebrate shells and skeletal structures as they are composed of calcium fluoro phosphate (fluorapatite) and calcium hydroxyl phosphate (hydroxyapatite)37. Although both materials are only weakly soluble50, the H+ concentration of 50 nM in our experiment seems to have been sufficient to dissolve a measurable portion of the apatites. This is evident from the lower concentration of Ca, P, and F in denticles exposed to those conditions (Table 4). The observed changes here are not the result of a physiological process, as the time it takes to form new denticles is in the order of 4 months51 and therefore exceeds the duration of the experiment. The observed effects are the result of chemical dissolution, but there is no information on such an effect on shark denticles under chronic hypercapnia. Green and Jutfelt21 found no visible change in Scyliorhinus canicula denticle morphology after short term (one month) hypercapnic exposure (pH 7.7). S. canicula and H. edwardsii are both common in areas with strong coastal upwelling and large fluctuations in seawater conditions, including temperature and pH, and are therefore likely adapted to acute changes in these. Our results however suggest that chronic exposure to severe hypercapnic (pH 7.3) conditions causes the dissolution of fluorapatite and in turn corrosion and weakening of the denticle surface. Shark denticles have been attributed a number of different functions, the protection against skin abrasions during hunting and mating and the improvement of hydrodynamics52. Our results suggest that chronic exposure to lower pH commensurate to future ocean acidification scenarios might impair the functionality of the denticles and in turn have negative effects for feeding and hydrodynamics. The latter might not be important in demersal sharks such as H. edwardsii that are buccal ventilators and do not need to swim in order to breathe. We speculate that, in large pelagic elasmobranchs which are facultative ram ventilators and must maintain forward motion to sufficiently ventilate their gill surface, impaired hydrodynamics by denticle corrosion may impact metabolic CO2 removal from the gills. However, further research is needed to examine this hypothesis. The intact denticle surface is responsible for as much as 12% increase in swimming speed52. Reduced hydrodynamics will not only make their swimming less effective, but will in addition make it more difficult to remove metabolic CO2. In a mackerel (teleost), higher swimming speed was shown to eliminate CO2 more efficiently from the blood39. In addition, corrosion of the teeth surface of all sharks will impair feeding.
H. edwardsii are already well adapted to hypercapnic conditions due to the frequent occurrence of these after coastal upwelling and subsequent low-oxygen events. Despite these adaptations, we observed negative consequences during chronic hypercapnia: denticle corrosion. Denticle corrosion and the resultant increase in denticle turnover can potentially compromise hydrodynamics and skin protection. As denticles and shark teeth are structurally and materially identical, chemical dissolution of teeth at a similar rate can be expected. We speculate that a combination of these multiple effects might negatively affect the populations of this and other endemic, coastal elasmobranch species for which range shift is impossible as they reside at the southern tip of the African continent. We suggest that these multiple stressors make chondrichthyans particularly susceptible to ocean acidification and additional studies are urgently needed to elucidate the extent of this effect on already vulnerable species.
Ohde, S. & van Woesik, R. Carbon dioxide flux and metabolic processes of a coral reef, Okinawa. Bull. Mar. Sci. 65, 559–576 (1999).
Shaw, E. C., McNeil, B. I., Tilbrook, B., Matear, R. & Bates, M. L. Anthropogenic changes to seawater buffer capacity combined with natural reef metabolism induce extreme future coral reef CO2 conditions. Global Change Biol. 19, 1632–1641 (2013).
Fabry, V. J., Seibel, B. A., Feely, R. A. & Orr, J. C. Impacts of ocean acidification on marine fauna and ecosystem processes. ICES J. Mar. Sci. 65, 414–432 (2008).
Harvey, B. P., Gwynn-Jones, D. & Moore, P. J. Meta-analysis reveals complex marine biological responses to the interactive effects of ocean acidification and warming. Ecol. Evol. 3, 1016–1030 (2013).
Hall-Spencer, J. M. & Harvey, B. P. Ocean acidification impacts on coastal ecosystem services due to habitate degradation. Emerg. Topics Life Sci. 3, 197–206 (2019).
Caldeira, K. & Wickett, M. E. Anthropogenic carbon and ocean pH. Nature 425, 365 (2003).
Stocker, T. F. et al. Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis. (Cambridge University Press, 2013).
Summerhayes, C. P. et al. Variability in the Benguela current upwelling system over the past 70,000 years. Prog. Oceanogr. 35, 207–251 (1995).
Hill A. E. et al. Eastern ocean boundaries coastal segment in The Global Coastal Ocean, Regional Studies and Syntheses. (eds. Robinson, A. R. & Brink, K. H.) 29–68 (Wiley 1998).
Pitcher, G. C. & Probyn, T. A. Red tides and anoxia: an example from the southern Benguela current system In Harmful Algae (eds. Pagou, P. & Hallegraeff, G.) 175–177 (International Society for the Study of Harmful Algae and Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO, 2010).
Pitcher, G. C., Figueiras, F. G., Hickey, B. M. & Moita, M. T. The physical oceanography of upwelling systems and the development of harmful algal blooms. Prog. Oceanogr. 85, 5–32 (2010).
Pitcher, G. C. et al. Dynamics of oxygen depletion in the nearshore of a coastal embayment of the southern Benguela upwelling system. J. Geophys. Res. Oceans 119, 2183–2200 (2014).
Probyn, T. A., Pitcher, G. C., Monteiro, P. M. S., Boyd, A. J. & Nelson, G. Physical processes contributing to harmful algal blooms in Saldanha Bay, South Africa. S. Afr. J. Mar. Sci. 22, 285–297 (2000).
Bakun, A. Global climate change and intensification of coastal ocean upwelling. Science 247, 198–201 (1990).
Diaz, R. J. & Rosenberg, R. Spreading dead zones and consequences for marine ecosystems. Science 321, 926–929 (2008).
Pitcher, G. C. & Probyn, T. A. Anoxia in southern Benguela during the autumn of 2009 and its linkage to a bloom of the dinoflagellate Ceratium balechii. Harmful Algae 11, 23–32 (2011).
Sydeman, W. J. et al. Climate change. Climate change and wind intensification in coastal upwelling ecosystems. Science 345, 77–80 (2014).
Jarre, A. et al. Synthesis: climate effects on biodiversity, abundance and distribution of marine organisms in the Benguela. Fish. Oceanogr. 24, 122–149 (2015).
Kitchell, J. F., Essington, T. E., Boggs, C. H., Schindler, D. E. & Walters, C. J. The role of sharks and longline fisheries in a pelagic ecosystem of the central Pacific. Ecosystems 5, 202–216 (2002).
Barker, M. J. & Schluessel, V. Managing global shark fisheries: suggestions for prioritizing management strategies. Aquatic Conservation:. Mar. Freshw. Ecosys. 15, 325–347 (2005).
Green, L. & Jutfelt, F. Elevated carbon dioxide alters the plasma composition and behaviour of a shark. Biol. Lett. 10, 20140538, https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2014.0538 (2014).
Rosa, R. et al. Neuro-oxidative damage and aerobic potential loss of sharks under elevated CO2 and warming. Mar. Biol. 163, 1–10 (2016).
Da Silva, C. et al. The current status and management of South Africa’s chondrichthyan fisheries. Afr. J. Mar. Sci. 37, 233–248 (2015).
Byrne, M. & Przeslawski, R. Multistressor Impacts of warming and acidification of the ocean on marine invertebrates’ life histories. Integr. Comp. Biol. 53, 582–596 (2013).
Bignami, S. et al. Ocean acidification alters the otoliths of a pantropical fish species with implications for sensory function. PNAS 110, 7366–7370 (2013).
Esbaugh, A. J., Heuer, R. & Grosell, M. Impacts of ocean acidification on respiratory gas exchange and acid–base balance in a marine teleost, Opsanus beta. J. Comp. Physiol. B 182, 921–934 (2012).
Rosa, R., Rummer, J. L. & Munday, P. L. Biological responses of sharks to ocean acidification. Biol. Lett. 13, 20160796, https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2016.0796 (2017).
Esbaugh, A. J. Physiological implications of ocean acidification for marine fish: emerging patterns and new insights. J. Comp. Physiol. B 188, 1–13 (2018).
Kroeker, K. J., Kordas, R. L., Crim, R. N. & Singh, G. G. Meta‐analysis reveals negative yet variable effects of ocean acidification on marine organisms. Ecol. Lett. 13, 1419–1434 (2010).
Orr, J. C. et al. Anthropogenic ocean acidification over the twenty-first century and its impact on calcifying organisms. Nature 437, 681–686 (2005).
Di Santo, V. Ocean acidification and warming affect skeletal mineralization in a marine fish. Proc. R. Soc. B 286, 20182187 (2019).
Pistevos, J. C. A., Reis-Santos, P., Izzo, C. & Gillanders, B. M. Element composition of shark vertebrae shows promise as a natural tag. Mar. Freshw. Res. https://doi.org/10.1071/MF18423 (2019).
R Core Team. R: A language and environment for statistical computing, http://www.R-project.org (R Foundation for Statistical Computing 2013).
Sarazin, G., Michard, G. & Prevot, F. A rapid and accurate spectroscopic method for alkalinity measurements in sea water samples. Water Res. 33, 290–294 (1999).
Pierrot, D., Lewis, E. & Wallace, D. W. R. MS Excel program developed for CO2 system calculations, ORNL/CDIAC-105a. (Carbon Dioxide Inf. Anal. Center, Oak Ridge Natl. Lab. US Dep. Energy, 2006).
Enax, J., Prymak, O., Raabe, D. & Epple, M. Structure, composition, and mechanical properties of shark teeth. J. Struct. Biol. 178, 290–299 (2012).
Enax, J., Janus, A. M., Raabe, D., Epple, M. & Fabritius, H.-O. Ultrastructural organization and micromechanical properties of shark tooth enameloid. Acta Biomaterialia 10, 3959–3968 (2014).
Knapp, J. L., Bridges, C. R., Krohn, J., Hoffman, L. C. & Auerswald, L. Acid–base balance and changes in haemolymph properties of the South African rock lobsters, Jasus lalandii, a palinurid decapod, during chronic hypercapnia. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 461, 475–480 (2015).
Boutilier, R. G., Heming, T. A. & Iwama, G. K. Appendix: Physicochemical parameters for use in fish respiratory physiology in Fish Physiology 10 (eds. Hoar, W. S. & Randall, D. J.) 403–430 (Academic Press 1984).
Heinrich D. D. U. et al. A product of its environment: the epaulette shark (Hemiscyllium ocellatum) exhibits physiological tolerance to elevated environmental CO2. Conserv. Physiol. 2, https://doi.org/10.1093/conphys/cou047 (2014).
Heisler, N., Weitz, H. & Weitz, A. M. Hypercapnia and resultant bicarbonate transfer processes in an elasmobranch fish (Scyliorhinus stellaris). Bull. Eur. Physiopath. Respir. 12, 77–86 (1976).
Claiborne, J. B. & Evans, D. H. Acid-base balance and ion transfers in the spiny dogfish (Squalus acanthias) during hypercapnia: a role for ammonia excretion. J. Exp. Zool. 261, 9–17 (1992).
Heisler, N. Acid base regulation in fishes. (ed. Heisler, N.) 309–356 (Elsevier 1986).
Deigweiher, K., Koschnick, N., Pörtner, H.-O. & Lucassen, M. Acclimation of ion regulatory capacities in gills of marine fish under environmental hypercapnia. Am. J. Physiol. Regul. Integr. Comp. Physiol. 295, R1660–R1670 (2008).
Pane, E. F. & Barry, J. P. Extracellular acid–base regulation during short-term hypercapnia is effective in a shallow-water crab, but ineffective in a deep-sea crab. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 334, 1–9 (2007).
Spicer, J. I., Raffo, A. & Widdicombe, S. Influence of CO2-related seawater acidification on extracellular acid–base balance in the velvet swimming crab Necora puber. Mar. Biol. 151, 1117–1125 (2007).
Hand, S. C. Metabolic dormancy in aquatic invertebrates. Adv. Comp. Env. Physiol. 8, 1–50 (1991).
Pistevos, J. C., Nagelkerken, I., Rossi, T., Olmos, M. & Connell, S. D. Ocean acidification and global warming impair shark hunting behaviour and growth. Sci. Rep. 5, 16293 (2015).
Gagliano, M., Depczynski, M., Simpson, S. D. & Moore, J. A. Y. Dispersal without errors: symmetrical ears tune into the right frequency for survival. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci. 275, 527–534 (2008).
Zhu, Y. et al. A comparative study on the dissolution and solubility of hydroxylapatite and fluorapatite at 25 °C and 45 °C. Chem. Geol. 268, 89–96 (2009).
Reif, W.-R. Wound healing in sharks. Zoomorphol. 90, 101–111 (1978).
Lauder, G. V. & di Santo, V. Swimming mechanics and energetics of elasmobranch fishes. Fish Physiol. 34, 219–253 (2015).
We are grateful to Mr. N. van den Heever and his dive team for assistance with shark collection and to Mr. A. Busby and team from the Seapoint Research Aquarium for technical support.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Dziergwa, J., Singh, S., Bridges, C.R. et al. Acid-base adjustments and first evidence of denticle corrosion caused by ocean acidification conditions in a demersal shark species. Sci Rep 9, 18668 (2019) doi:10.1038/s41598-019-54795-7