Abstract
This paper presents a digital elevation model (DEM) of the dunes found in the Lençóis Maranhenses National Park, an environmental protection area located in the Maranhão state (Brazil). The DEM supports the modeling studies of sand-dune evolution using multi-temporal satellite images and ground truth data, obtained through the post-processed kinematic Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) positioning. The study area is located at the border of three major neotropical ecosystems: the Amazonia, Caatinga, and Brazilian savanna. It is located in the northeastern state of Maranhão and encompasses the largest dune fields in the country. Wide shrubby areas (restingas, in Portuguese), lakes, mangroves, and a multitude off reshwater lagoons compose the park’s natural environments. The objective of the present study is to create an DEM that can evidence the complex dynamics of dune formation in the study area with use of GNSS. Geodetic techniques and precision mapping were employed to monitor the short-term coastal dynamics. The use of GNSS receivers is justified by the difficulty of mapping the dune’s features using conventional methods such as theodolite, level, and total station systems, due to their high cost, time restriction sand low data precision. Surface surveys were carried out annually between December 2015 and January 2017 to create a DEM. The study results reveal that the area has a negative volumetric balance of erosion and a preferential direction of sediment transport by wind, which may justify the pattern of advancement and retraction observed in the dunes of the studied area.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Coastal zone corresponds to the transition between the continental and marine domains, being subject to continuous morphodynamic changes that originate from the continental, marine and/or anthropogenic processes1. These processes are critical for the formation of different coast types, and include sea level oscillations, erosion, and depositional dynamics, associated with the action of waves, tides, marine currents and winds2,3,4. Being a highly unstable environment, the transition zone presents great temporal and spatial variability.
The Brazilian coast has a complex set of climatic, oceanographic and geomorphological elements that influence the active processes in certain areas, and subdivide the coast into distinct zones, such as the Amazonian Littoral, Northeastern Littoral, Eastern Littoral, and Southeastern Littoral5,6. The presence of dunes in the Northeastern Littoral zone is remarkable. Dunes are characterized as deposits formed by the action of wind on sand with or without vegetation7. Coastal dunes are notable for their role in protecting sea-level rise and are deemed important for conservation due to their vulnerability to natural and anthropogenic disturbances8.
Digital elevation models (DEM’s) are crucial in coastal dynamics studies providing a 3-D topographic model of the terrain9,10,11. The DEM’s can be used in: (1) the coastal evolution studies by feeding the predictive models and identifyingthe risk areas12, (2) the sustainable land use studies, and (3) the areas of intense coastal dynamics under the influence of anthropic activity. The DEMs can also be utilized in the analyses of sea-level rise and large-scale climate phenomena (e.g., El Niño and La Niña)13,14.
Previous information exists on the continental dune front advance in the Lençóis Maranhenses region15,16, however, no dune migration studies have utilized the GNSS methods in the surface of the dunes. This research is devoted to the generation of a DEM for the Lençóis Maranhenses National Park dunes using high-precision geodesy, dune-formation modeling studies, and field truth based on the GNSS data collection. The objective of the present study is to create a DEM that can evidence the complex dynamics of dune formation (processes of advancement and retraction) in the study area with use of GNSS.
Study Area
The study area is situated within the Lençóis Maranhenses National Park(NPLM), Maranhão, northeastern Brazil (central coordinates: 02°31′02′′S, 43°01′54′′W, WGS84). More precisely, a dune sector in the Village of Caburé (Barreirinhas municipality), near the Preguiças River mouth was studied (Fig. 1). This area is represented by transition from the Pre-Amazonian blackwoods to wide dune fields and mangroves. The NPLM park area constitutes approximately 155,000 hectares, and is composed of sand dunes, freshwater lagoons, restingas, lakes, mangroves and a 70 km beach strip. The dune field in the area has been interpreted to form as the result of: (1) retrogradation of sediments by construction of barriers in the Tertiary, (2) extension of the continental shelf, (3) successive marine transgressions since the Pleistocene, and (4) fluvial sediment input from the region’s main rivers17.The NPLM contains the Brazil’s largest dune field18 and was converted into a park in 1981. The NPLM represents chains of sinuous dunes interspersed with shallow, freshwater, temporary lagoons, making it the only “desert” with water on the Earth19.
Unlike other deserts, the NPLM receives relatively large amounts of water as precipitation (up to 2000 mm/year)20. The main form of precipitation is rain (>90%), falling between January and July. The rain is absorbed quickly by sand, and causes the rise of water table, thus forming the temporary lagoons (~1 m deep) between the dunes. High humidity, lack of wind, and elevated water table prevent the dunes from moving during the rainy season. The dunes gradually dry out and start moving in the second semester, when the prevailing winds blow from the east at 70 km/h.
The area studied in this work was a dune sector in Caburé village, near the mouth of the Preguiças River, Barreirinhas municipality, (Fig. 1). It is located in the Lençóis Maranhenses region, between 2°42′21′′ and 2°35′09′′ west longitude and between 42°470′15′′ and 42°39′56′′ south latitude. This region represents a transition between the Pre-Amazonia, Brazilian backwoods, and wide dune fields interspersed with mangroves, which are restricted to the river mouth and sand bays.
Data acquisition and methodology
The location for data collection was chosen based on the satellite imagesof different scales. Two sensor image datasets (LANDSAT 5-TM (1986) and LANDSAT 8-OLI (2014)), both freely available from the US Geological Survey (website: https://www.usgs.gov/), were employed. The dune fieldsurvey was performed on different dates aiming to select the most appropriate location for the geodetic survey. Area accessibility and proximity to the region with evident shoreline changes were also taken into account.The images were georeferenced and RGB color-coded using the software ENVI 5®. The target area (near the villageof Caburé and the Preguiças River mouth) was identified usingthe software ArcGIS®, based on the most profound changes in the coastline architecture.
The geodetic survey was performed by satellite (GNSS) positioning and altimetry. DEM generation was based on the methodology proposed by another study10,21, that was later tested and validated by a number of other researchers22,23,24. The applied methodology consists of three phases: data acquisition, data processing, and DEM creation.
The data acquisition stage was subdivided into: (1) positioning of the geodetic mark, and (2) planialtimetric survey of the dunes.The geodetic mark is a key survey point on the Earth’s surfacethat is necessary to carry out the planialtimetric survey by obtaining short vectors in the processing. The implementation of the geodetic mark (No. RGLMA-01, Fig. 2) followed the methodology outlined in another search10, and was based on the cadastral and geodetic marks specifications of the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE)25.
Coordinate navigation was carried out by the Geodetic L1,L2 Topcon GPS device (model Hiper+). The geodetic coordinates, ellipsoidal elevation and standard deviations were obtained using the Topcon Tools software to obtain the, according to the post-processing report, with IBGE’s RBMC stations, using São Luís and Teresina (Fig. 1). The static positioning method is the traditional GNSS measurement technique, consisting of data collection for a long session, between 1 and 8 hours. This method is ideal for long bases, with distances greater than 20 km, and it is used for implantation, control, densification of geodetic networks and several other precision works26. The geodetic planialtimetric survey of the dune surfaces was accomplished by the post-processed kinematic positioning (PPK) of the GNSS. The mobile receiver Trimble R3 with a horizontal accuracy of 10 mm + 1 ppm, vertical accuracy of 20 mm + 1 ppm and a 1 sec recording rate was set in a motorized quadricycle permitting faster data acquisition. The geodetic mark RGLMA-01 was used as a reference station, from which short bases to the GNSS positioning were employed, thus obtaining the geodetic coordinates with high precision.
The data processing phase consisted of: (1) determination of the geodetic coordinates, and (2) determination of the orthometric altitudes. The geodetic coordinates (i.e., latitude, longitude and geometric altitude) and the standard errors of captured points in the field were secured bythe GNSS data processing and adjustments. Data processing was carried out by the software Topcon Tools 7.5.1 with a fixed-type solution (fixed ambiguities), confidence level of 68%, and the standard permissible error in the vectors of 10 cm. The orthometric heights were calculated from the geometric altitudes of the revolution ellipsoid26. The geoidal model was obtained using the geoid undulation (N), where the orthometric altitude (H) was calculated by subtraction of the geoidal undulation (N) from the geodetic altitude (h), according to the equation (I): H = h − N. The interpolation by the triangulated irregular network (TIN) method was determined to be the most adequate technique for the representation of the sandy beach surfaces27. Thus, the DEM was generated using the TIN technique with the Delaunay triangulation in the software ArcGIS 9.3. Accordingly, the isolines were drawn from the original data layout with no extrapolation, and the estimates were limited to the area resulting from the sum of the areas of the triangles21,28,29.
Results and Discussion
In Fig. 3, we can observe the changes which occurred in images acquired at an interval of 28 years: an increase of mangrove areas, dune and sand migration in a NE-SW direction (Fig. 3B), and a decrease in beaches of the region covered between Vila do Caburé and the study area.
Figure 3(A,B) presents satellite images from 1986 and 2014, with emphasis for the study area. Figure 3A presents an image of the Landsat 5TM series for the year 1986 with the color composition RGB_321, highlighting mangroves in red, beach and dune fields in white. Figure 3B shows an image of the Landsat 8 OLI satellite for 2014, showing a colored composition RGB_NDVI_PC1_B7 (NDVI, Main component 1 and Band 7), highlighting mangroves in orange, and beach and sand dunes in light cyan. The two images are processed in differently to reveal the main objects of interest: mangroves, sea, rivers, sand, among others.
Figure 4 shows the cloud of points obtained in the geodetic survey conducted in the dunes in December 2015 and January 2017. Respectively, a total of 1,010 and 1,700 sampling points with irregular distribution were collected, diffused according to the different morphological features found at the time of the survey. The precision obtained in GNSS data processing had an average of 1.0 cm in North, 2.4 cm in East and 2.5 cm in height for the UTM (Universal Transverse Mercator) coordinates.
Figure 3 shows points obtained at the base, top, and regions between dunes to accurately portray the morphology of the study region. The point cloud shows dune migration in the NE-SW direction illustrated in Fig. 4B. In 2015, it was not possible to access this region using a 4-wheeler.
Figure 5 shows the DEM of 2015 and Fig. 6 presents the DEM of 2017. Both DEMs were obtained from the study area and by the geodetic method. The projection system used the UTM plan (Fuse 23 S) and the level curves generated had vertical intervals of 0.20 m, which was compatible with DEM accuracy. To improve the visualization of the models in the adopted scales, a color table with variations of 0.50 m was applied from blue (lower region) to red (highest region). The DEM has an altimetric precision of 2.5 cm and 0.50-cm resolution.
It was observed in the DEM of 2015 that the altitudes have an amplitude of 10.1471 m, ranging from 11.4575 m in the higher regions to 1.6104 m in the lower regions. In the 2017 DEM elevations, an amplitude of 10.1011 m was observed, varying from 11.4272 m in the highest regions to 1.3261 m in the lowest regions. In both models, the lowest regions was found between the dunes.
We observed that no relevant differences between low and high altitudes, or with range. However, visually, the DEM reveals dune migration we observed that there is no relevant difference in low and high altitudes (NE-SW). The direction of the migration is an important factor in the modeling process. The dunes are modeler by the wind, that’s the main actor to do it, like show30,31.
The relief of the area is typical of a dune region, with most altitudes concentrated between 1.0 m and 3.0 m (i.e., amplitudes of 2.0 m), accounting for 76.9% of the altitudes values between 1.0 m and 3.0 m, being 2.3% less than 1.0 m and 22.2% greater than 3.0 m). In the analyzed section, a pattern was observed in relief distribution, varying mainly according to location south of Caburé beach. The peaks present the highest altitudes, while the interdunal regions have the lowest altitudes. The model allowed the identification of morphological features typical of dunes in beach areas, such as the flat, horizontal and sloping profiles of the emerged beach face, small dunes in formation, depressions and elevations, as well as morphological features indicative of erosion32.
Figure 7 shows the volumetric variation in the dunes of the study area for an annual monitoring interval between December 2015 and January 2017. Negative values in red represent altimetric loss (erosion) and positive values in blue represent altimetric gains (accretion). Thus, during the monitoring period, there was a decrease in sediment volume in the region with sediment displacement in the northeast to southwest direction.
Table 1 shows survey data, which is organized by a number of cloud points per year, minimum and maximum dune heights, and a total dune volume for each year.
Using the software Area and Volume tool, 3D Analyst, a total volume of 838.018,78 m³ ± 2.5 cm was obtained for 2015, and a total volume of 776,588.07 m³ ± 2,5 cm was obtained for 2017. In other words, there was erosion on the order of 61.43071 m³ ± 2.5 cm in 1 year and 3 months of monitoring (Table 1). Figure 7 shows that the main areas of erosion are located at the top and bottom of the dunes and that sediment accumulation occurs to the southwest. Figures 4 and 5 indicate a decrease in the maximum altitude of the region, going from 11.7575 m to 11.42725 m, (i.e., a decrease of 33.03 cm). This is mainly seen in the red regions. The decrease in minimum latitude was similar to that occurring at the maximum altitude, being 28.43 cm.
Conclusions
This research presents a multitemporal data analysis aimed for detection of the morphological changes in the dunes, located near by the village of Caburé, Lençóis Maranhenses region. The dunes have been deemed to experience the natural and anthropological changes (e.g., from the hotel construction businesses and tourist activities). This study uses a number of geodetic techniques and precision mapping to provide solutions for the short-term coastal dynamic’s problems. DEM supports the modeling studies of sand-dune evolution using multi-temporal satellite images and ground truth data, obtained through the post-processed kinematic Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) positioning. Several GNSS surface surveys were carried out annually between December 2015 and January 2017. The information has been collected and analyze dusing the digital elevation model (DEM). The study identified annual variations in the dune heights, recognized areas of sediment erosion and deposition, and allowed to understand the orientation of sediment particle transport and its balance. We have identified that the main dune change agent is the wind that carries the loose sand grains. The study results show that the area has a negative on-balance volume of −61.43071 m³, representing active erosion. More analyses are needed in the years to come in order to better understand the sediment dynamics and dune evolution in this transitional area of the Brazilian coast. Another perspective observed was the extreme relevance of the monitoring time extension of the morphological modifications of the region, indicating the necessity to repeat procedure in the following years. With more information, it will be possible to improve the understanding of the dynamics of sediment migration and dune evolution in the study area.
Change history
28 November 2019
An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.
References
de Oliveira, J. S. Análise sedimentar em zonas costeiras: subsídio ao diagnóstico ambiental da Lagoa do Peri - Ilha de Santa Catarina-SC, Brasil. Dissertação (mestrado) - Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Centro de Filosofia e Ciências Humanas. Programa de Pós-Graduação em Geografia.Santa Catarina –SC (2002).
Muehe, D. Estado morfodinâmico praial no instante da observação: uma alternativa de identificação. São Paulo Revista Brasileira de Oceanografia 46(2), 157–169 (1998).
Pereira, C. & Coelho, C. Mapas de Risco das Zonas Costeiras por Efeito da Ação Energética do Mar. Revista de Gestão Costeira Integrada - Journal of Integrated Coastal Zone Management. 13(1) (2013).
Tessler, M. G. & Goya, S. C. Processos Costeiros Condicionantes do Litoral Brasileiro. Revista do Departamento de Geografia 17(2005), 11–23 (2005).
Souza Filho, P. W. M. Maâmar El-Robrini. Geomorphology of the Bragança coastal zone, northeastern Pará state. RevistaBrasileira de Geociências, volume 30 (2000).
Summerfield, M. A. Global geomorphology: an introduction to the study of landforms. New York, Longman, 537p (1991).
Cordazzo, C. V. & Seeliger, U. Guia Ilustrado da Vegetação Costeira do Extremo Sul do Brasil, Rio Grande. Universidade Federal do Rio Grande - FURG, 275p (1988).
Carneiro, M. C. S. M. Monitoramento das dunas utilizando o sistema de mapeamento a laser (lidar) aerotransportável: um estudo do campo de dunas do município de Rio do Fogo, RN, Brasil, Tese de Doutorado (2011).
Eakins, B. W. & Grothe, P. R. Challenges in Building Coastal Digital Elevation Models. Journal of Coastal Research. 297, 942–953 (2014).
Santos, M. S. T. & Amaro, V. E. Rede Geodésica para o Levantamento Costeiro do Litoral Setentrional do Rio Grande do Norte. Boletim de Ciências Geodésicas 17(4), 571–585 (2011).
Woolard, J. W. & Colby, J. D. Spatial characterization, resolution, and volumetric change of coastal dunes using airborne LIDAR: Cape Hatteras, North Carolina. Geomorphology. Volume 48, Issues 1–3, 1 November 2002, Pages 269–287 (2002).
Alcoforado, A. V. C. Índice de vulnerabilidade costeira e risco à inundação em cenários de mudanças climáticas no estuário do Rio Piranhas-Açu com utilização de imagens de sensores orbitais e de LiDAR aeroportado. 2017. 121f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Geodinâmica e Geofísica) - Centro de Ciências Exatas e da Terra, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Natal (2017).
Esteves, L. S., Williams, J. J. & Dillenburg, S. R. Seasonal and interanual influences on the patterns of shoreline changes in Rio Grande do Sul, Southern Brazil. Journal of Coastal Research 22(5), 1076–1093 (2006).
Klemas, V. Remote Sensing Techniques for Studying Coastal Ecosystems: An Overview. Journal of Coastal Research 27(2), 2–17 (2011).
Goncalves, R. A., Santos, J. H. S. & Castro, J. W. A. O papel da Dinâmica costeira no controle dos campos de dunas eólicas do setor leste da planície costeira do Maranhão - BR - Lençóis Maranhenses. In: X Congresso Brasileiro da ABEQUA, 2005, Guarapari. Qual a chave para o futuro?, p. 1–6 (2005).
Santos, J. H. S., Silva, J. X., Santos, N. F. B. & dos Santos, M. C. F. V. Monitoramento do Campo de Dunas dos Lençóis Maranhenses - MA/Brasil. In: XII Encuentro de Geógrafos de América Latina, 2009, Montevideo. 12 Encuentro de Geógrafos de America Latina,. p. 1–15 (2009).
Castro, A. C. L. & Piorski N. M. Plano de Manejo do Parque Nacional dos Lençóis Maranhenses. ICMbio, http://www.icmbio.gov.br/portal/biodiversidade/unidades-de-conservacao/biomas-brasileiros/marinho/unidades-de-conservacao-marinho/2264-parna-dos-lencois-maranhenses, 2002 [Accessed on 06 October 2012].
Miranda, J. P., Costa, J. C. L. & Rocha, C. F. D. Reptilesfrom Lençóis Maranhenses National Park, Maranhão, northeasternBrazil. ZooKeys 246, 51–68, https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.246.2593 (2012).
Rego, M. & Albuquerque, P. Redescoberta de MeliponasubnitaDucke (Hymenoptera: Apidae) nas restingas do Parque Nacional dos lençóis Maranhenses, Barreirinhas, MA. Neotropical Entomology 35(3), 416–417, Scientific note (2006).
UEMA. Atlas do Maranhão/Gerência de planejamento e desenvolvimento econômico, Laboratório de Geoprocessamento (LABGEO/UEMA). São Luís: GEPLAN. 36 p (2000).
Santos, M. S. T., Amaro, V. E. & Souto, M. V. S. Metodologia geodésica para levantamento de Linha de Costa e Modelagem Digital de Elevação de praias arenosas em estudos de precisão de geomorfologia e dinâmica costeira. Revista Brasileira de Cartografia (Impresso) 63, 663–681 (2011).
Ferreira, A. T. S., Amaro, V. E. & Santos, M. S. T. Geodésia aplicada à integração de dados topográficos e batimétricos na caracterização de superfícies de praia. RBC. Revista Brasileira de Cartografia (Online), v. 1, p. 153–170 2014.7
Santos, A. L. S., Amaro, V. E. & Santos, M. S. T. Geodésia de precisão aplicada à análise da evolução morfodinâmica de curto prazo na Ilha Barreira do Corta Cachorro, litoral do Rio Grande do Norte, Nordeste do Brasil. Revista Brasileira de Geomorfologia 15, 425–442 (2014).
Santos, M. S. T., Amaro, V. E., Ferreira, A. T. S. & Santos, A. L. S. Altimetria GNSS de precisão aplicada ao monitoramento da dinâmica sedimentar costeira de curta duração em escala regional. Boletim de Ciências Geodésicas (Online) 19, 624–638 (2013).
IBGE (INSTITUTO BRASILEIRO DE GEOGRAFIA E ESTATÍSTICA), http://www.ibge.gov.br. [Accessedon 01 January 2012].
Monico, J. F. G. Posicionamento pelo GNSS: descrição, fundamentos e aplicações. São Paulo: EditoraUnesp, p.477 (2008).
Amaro, V. E., Lima, F. G. F. & Santos, M. S. T. An Evaluation of digital elevation models to short-term monitoring of a high energy barrier island, Northeast Brazil. World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, vol. 76 (2013).
Matos, A. C. O. C. Implementação de modelos digitais de terreno para aplicações na área de geodésia e geofísica na América do Sul. 2005. 335f. Tese (Doutorado em Engenharia de Transportes) – Departamento de Engenharia de Transportes, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Engenharia de Transportes, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo (2005).
Zanardi, R. P. Geração de Modelo Digital de Terreno a Partir de Par Estereoscópico do Sensor CCD do Satélite CBERS-2 e Controle de Qualidade das Informações Altimétricas. 2006. 94 f. Dissertação (Mestrado em Sensoriamento Remoto) - Programa de Pós-Graduação em Sensoriamento Remoto, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Rio Grande do Sul. (2006).
Zhang, J., Shao, Y. & Huang, N. Measurements of dust deposition velocity in a wind-tunnel experiment. Atmos. Chem. Phys. 14, 8869–8882 (2014).
Zhang, J., Teng, Z., Huang, N., Guo, L. & Shao, Y. Surface renewal as a significant mechanism for dust emission. Atmos. Chem. Phys. 16, 15517–15528 (2016).
Santos, A. L. S., Amaro, V. E. & Santos, M. S. T. Avaliação da metodologia de aquisição de dados para representação de feições morfológicas de praias arenosas através do Modelo Digital de Elevação. Mercator, Fortaleza 14(2), 137–155 (2015).
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa e Desenvolvimento do Estado do Maranhão - FAPEMA (Grant UNIVERSAL-00714/15), and the Universidade CEUMA - UNICEUMA for financial aid provided. This study was financed in part by the Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior - Brasil (CAPES) - Finance Code 001. Finally, we would also like to thank the Instituto Federal de Educação, Ciência e Tecnologia do Maranhão - IFMA for providing the financial incentive through the Special Program for Internationalization of Research, and the Laboratório de Geoprocessamento of the Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte - UFRN for the geodetic GPS loan.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
André Luis Silva dos Santos, Denilson da Silva Bezerra and Hélder Borges wrote the main body of the manuscript. André Luis Silva dos Santos prepared Figures 1 to 7. Celso Silva Junior and Raimundo Nonato Piedade Júnior supervised the work. Hélder Borges and Celso Silva Junior translated the manuscript to English.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing Interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
dos Santos, A.L.S., Borges, H., Silva Junior, C.H. . et al. Modelling Dunes from Lençóis Maranhenses National Park (Brazil): Largest dune field in South America. Sci Rep 9, 7434 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-43735-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-43735-0
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.