Reconstructing the original biogeochemistry of organic fossils requires quantifying the extent of the chemical transformations that they underwent during burial-induced maturation processes. Here, we performed laboratory experiments on chemically different organic materials in order to simulate the thermal maturation processes that occur during diagenesis. Starting organic materials were microorganisms and organic aerosols. Scanning transmission X-ray microscopy (STXM) was used to collect X-ray absorption near edge spectroscopy (XANES) data of the organic residues. Results indicate that even after having been submitted to 250 °C and 250 bars for 100 days, the molecular signatures of microorganisms and aerosols remain different in terms of nitrogen-to-carbon atomic ratio and carbon and nitrogen speciation. These observations suggest that burial-induced thermal degradation processes may not completely obliterate the chemical and molecular signatures of organic molecules. In other words, the present study suggests that organic molecular heterogeneities can withstand diagenesis and be recognized in the fossil record.
The fossil record contains crucial information about the evolution of Life on Earth1, 2. Molecular investigations regarding ancient Life are yet limited by the poor quality of the ‘biogeochemical’ signals preserved in the fossil record: in addition to biodegradation, burial-induced alteration processes (i.e. thermal maturation) inevitably modify the original biochemical signatures of fossilized organic molecules1, 3. With increasing temperature, weaker organic bonds are thermally broken and significant deoxygenation and dehydrogenation reactions occur1, 4. Thermal degradation eventually promotes increasing structural reorganization and may ultimately lead to the formation of pure graphite5, 6.
It has long been recognized that biomacromolecules exhibit conspicuous differences in decay in natural environments7, 8. For instance, cell-wall biopolymers that protect some algae, cysts, spores and pollen grains are intrinsically more resistant than polysaccharides, proteins and nucleic acids9,10,11. In some contexts, taxon-specific chemosystematic data can even be preserved in the fossil record12, 13. Still, the general perception in paleobiology remains that thermal maturation processes lead to a converging composition of organic materials from different origins, thereby limiting the use of chemical composition for discriminating between possibly different fossilized taxa14.
Taking advantage of advanced spectroscopic tools (including synchrotron-based techniques), a number of studies have demonstrated that organic molecules may undergo only partial degradation during diagenesis in natural settings15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24. In parallel, laboratory experiments have helped evaluating the influence of key factors such as the pressure-temperature conditions, the redox conditions, the presence or absence of a fluid or of certain mineral phases on the degradation of organics22, 25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35. Altogether, these studies highlighted that burial-induced thermal degradation of organic molecules can be more abstruse than generally believed.
Here, we report results of thermal maturation experiments performed on two strains of unicellular microorganisms (the prokaryotic cyanobacteria Gloeobacter violaceus and the eukaryotic microalgae Euglena gracilis) and on two nitrogen-rich organic aerosols (PAMPRE and Nebulotron – see Methods) for different durations (1 to 100 days). The morphological and chemical changes of experimental organic residues have been characterized using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) spectroscopy, a synchrotron-based technique offering a precise estimation of the nitrogen-to-carbon (N/C) atomic ratio of organics36, 37 as well as key information about chemical structures, i.e. carbon and nitrogen speciation, with a submicrometric spatial resolution24, 38.
Evolution of morphologies
SEM has been used to document morphological changes of the organic materials. Fresh G. violaceus exhibit spherical cells of about 1 μm in diameter, while fresh E. gracilis cells are approximately 30 μm in length and 10 μm in width (Fig. 1). Nebulotron are rod shaped particles of tens to hundreds of microns in length and approximately 2 µm in width. PAMPRE are spherical particles of about 0.5 µm in diameter. During diagenesis experiments, G. violaceus, E. gracilis and PAMPRE have evolved towards more or less oily residues with no particular morphologies while the initial morphology of Nebulotron has been partially preserved, even after 100 days (Fig. 1). Note the sponge-like texture of PAMPRE residues, likely resulting from gaseous compounds generation during the experiments.
Evolution of N/C values
Following Alleon et al.37, N/C values of the starting materials and experimental residues have been estimated from their X-ray absorption spectra (Fig. 2). N/C values of 0.24 and 0.17 (±0.01) have been determined for G. violaceus and E. gracilis, respectively. Nebulotron and PAMPRE aerosols exhibit higher nitrogen contents, with N/C values of 0.71 ± 0.01 and 0.46 ± 0.02, respectively, in good agreement with bulk measurements39. While the N/C values of G. violaceus and Nebulotron have significantly decreased during the experiments following a log-linear relationship with experimental duration, E. gracilis and PAMPRE residues exhibit N/C values quite similar to those of the starting materials, even after 100 days at 250 °C and 250 bars (Fig. 2).
Evolution of chemical structures
Chemical structures of starting materials
Fresh G. violaceus exhibit a C-XANES spectrum typical of bacteria (Fig. 3a), with a main peak at 288.2 eV, assigned to the 1 s → π* electronic transitions in amide groups ((R1, R2)N–C=O), a peak at 289.4 eV corresponding to 1 s → 3p/σ* transitions in hydroxyl groups (C-OH), a peak at 285.1 eV, attributed to 1 s → π* transitions in aromatic or olefinic groups (C=C), and a large shoulder centered at about 287.4 eV, attributed to both 1 s → π* transitions (287.0–287.3 eV) in carbonyl (C=O) and phenolic (Ar-OH) groups and 1 s → 3p/σ* transitions (287.5–288.0 eV) in aliphatic (-CxHy) groups19, 29, 40. The C-XANES spectrum of fresh E. gracilis appears quite similar with a more intense peak at 289.4 eV (Fig. 3a), indicating a higher content of carbohydrates, likely stored inside the cells as starch granules and paramylon41. Fresh Nebulotron particles also display a C-XANES spectrum dominated by three absorption features at 285.1, 288.2 and 289.4 eV which respective intensities indicate a higher concentration of amide ((R1, R2)N–C=O) and hydroxyl groups (C-OH) and a lower concentration of aromatic or olefinic carbons (C=C) compared to G. violaceus and E. gracilis. The shoulder centered around 286.7 eV can be attributed to 1 s → π* electronic transitions in imine (C=N), nitrile (C≡N), carbonyl (C=O) and/or phenolic (Ar-OH) groups42,43,44. The C-XANES spectrum of fresh PAMPRE exhibits a different pattern with a broad peak centered around 288.2 eV, attributed to the contribution of 1 s → π* electronic transitions in amide groups ((R1, R2)N–C=O) and to that of 1 s → 3p/σ* transitions in various aliphatic groups mostly connected to nitrogen, and two shoulders, an intense one centered at about 286.7 eV and attributed to 1 s → π* electronic transitions in nitrile (C≡N) and a more gentle one centered at about 285.1 eV and attributed to 1 s → π* transitions in aromatic or olefinic groups (C=C)42,43,44.
Due to overlapping energies of several resonances, absorption peaks at the N K-edge cannot be univocally assigned to given functional groups42, 45, 46. Still, the N local coordination can be partly inferred based on the energy of absorption features42, 45, 46: imine, nitrile and pyridinic N will generate absorption features below 400 eV, while absorption features above 400 eV will indicate the presence of amide, nitro and pyrrolic N. Fresh G. violaceus and E. gracilis exhibit very similar N-XANES spectra with a main peak at 401.4 eV, likely related to amide groups that form the peptide bonds in proteins (the main N storage in microorganisms) and a wide absorption feature of low intensity in the range 398.8–399.9 eV, attributed to 1 s → π* transitions in either imine, nitrile or pyridine groups (Fig. 3b). The N-XANES spectrum of fresh Nebulotron particles is quite different: the absorption peak attributed to the contribution of 1 s → π* transitions in amide groups occurs at 400.8 eV instead of 401.4 eV, and a wide absorption peak, attributed to 1 s → π* transitions in either imine, nitrile or pyridine groups¸ can be observed at about 399.5 eV (Fig. 3b). The N-XANES spectrum of fresh PAMPRE does not display any absorption features above 400 eV, but a quite intense peak at 399,9 eV, attributed to the contribution of 1 s → π* transitions in nitrile groups, and a shoulder at about 398.8 eV, attributed to 1 s → π* transitions in imine groups39.
Chemical structures of experimental residues
The four organic materials have undergone a significant molecular evolution during the experiments: the relative intensities of C- and N-XANES peaks vary as a function of experimental duration (Fig. 3). Qualitatively, G. violaceus and E. gracilis have evolved in a similar manner. Their relative concentrations of amide and hydroxyl groups have decreased (as evidenced by the intensity decrease of the absorption peaks at 288.2/401.4 eV and 289.4 eV) while the relative concentrations of aromatic/olefinic groups and imine/nitrile/carbonyl/phenolic groups have increased (as evidenced by the intensity increase of the absorption features at 285.1/398.8–399.9 eV and 287.4/398.8 eV). Yet, while the molecular degradation of G. violaceus seems almost complete after 1 day, E. gracilis has evolved more progressively. With increasing experimental duration, both strains show a progressive shift of the aromatic/olefinic carbons absorption (from 285.1 to 285.3 eV). A similar progressive evolution is observed for Nebulotron (Fig. 3), except that Nebulotron residues have become enriched in imine/nitrile/carbonyl/phenolic groups (higher intensities of absorption in the ranges 285.8–287.4 eV and 398.8–399.9 eV). This is also the case for PAMPRE residues, despite a more chaotic chemical evolution (Fig. 3): carboxylic groups have formed within the first day (intense absorption peak at 288.4 eV), hydroxyl groups have appeared between 1 and 10 days (intense absorption peak at 289.5 eV) and aliphatic groups have become predominant between 10 and 100 days (absorption features in the 287.4–288.0 eV energy range).
SEM observations and XANES data show that the four organic materials do not degrade similarly when submitted to 250 °C and 250 bars, and remain distinct, even after 100 days, in terms of both morphology and molecular composition. Quite illustrative are the evolutions of the N/C values (Fig. 2). The present study evidences the different molecular transformations that chemically different organic materials may undergo when experimentally submitted to pressure and temperature conditions typical of burial-induced thermal diagenesis, thereby pointing out that organic molecular heterogeneities can withstand diagenesis. Of note, no simple correlation can be drawn between the evolutions of N/C, AI and UI values and the initial N/C values of the four organic materials, nor their initial morphologies or chemical structures, nor their biological or abiogenic nature. These observations illustrate both the diversity and the complexity of the degradation pathways that organic materials are likely to follow.
The N/C values of G. violaceus and Nebulotron have decreased with increasing experimental duration following apparent log-linear kinetic behaviors while those of E. gracilis and PAMPRE have remained nearly constant. Although Nebulotron initially exhibit N/C values 50% higher than those of PAMPRE, this is the opposite after 100 days. Similar trends can be evidenced for G. violaceus and E. gracilis despite the quite comparable initial chemical compositions of these microorganisms. Their chemical evolutions (Fig. 3) are typical of microorganisms having undergone thermal maturation25, 29, 35, i.e. a loss of heteroatomic functional groups concomitant to an increase of the relative abundance of aromatic structures. Yet, their nitrogen speciation has evolved slightly differently even though these microorganisms could not initially be distinguished based on their N-XANES spectra (Fig. 3).
To discuss the chemical evolution of the starting organic materials in a more quantitative manner, deconvolution of C-XANES spectra has been performed, thereby allowing the extraction of two parameters: the aromaticity index (AI) and the unsaturation index (UI). The AI values of the four organic materials drastically increase during the first days and then reach a plateau value (in less than 10 days) that is higher for G. violaceus and E. gracilis than for Nebulotron and PAMPRE (Fig. 4a). The UI values of the four organic materials reveal a different evolution trend (Fig. 4b). With increasing experimental duration, the UI values of both G. violaceus and E. gracilis drastically increase during the very first days and then reach a plateau value that remains lower than 1. In contrast, the UI values of PAMPRE and Nebulotron drastically decrease during the very first days and then reach a plateau value that remains higher than 1. These two opposite trends indicate that, while the thermal maturity increases for all samples as indicated by the AI values, the concentration of C=N, C≡N, C=O and Ar-OH groups remains higher than that of aromatic groups in residues of Nebulotron and PAMPRE (UI > 1) but lower than that of aromatic groups in residues of E. gracilis and G. violaceus (UI < 1).
The evolutions of AI and UI values of the four organic materials with experimental duration are well modelled by a first-order kinetic law according to:
with t the experimental duration, P the plateau value and τ the characteristic time for the evolutions of either AI or UI values. The parameter α accounts for the increasing (α = 1) or decreasing (α = −1) evolution of AI and UI values with experimental duration. For both AI and UI values, while the calculated τ values are significantly lower than 1 for the four organic materials, the obtained P values differ from one organic material to another. For instance, the P values of G. violaceus (PAI = 0.148 ± 0.005; PUI = 0.810 ± 0.010) and E. gracilis (PAI = 0.152 ± 0.001; PUI = 0.720 ± 0.001) significantly differ from the ones of Nebulotron (PAI = 0.118 ± 0.004; PUI = 1.471 ± 0.001) and PAMPRE (PAI = 0.099 ± 0.007; PUI = 1.724 ± 0.001).
Here, the four organic materials have undergone degradation only during the very first days of experiments. Even the AI and UI values of PAMPRE reach a plateau within a day despite the more chaotic evolution of these aerosols during thermal maturation. The low τ values obtained from the simple modelling of the evolutions of the AI and UI values highlight that a metastable thermodynamic equilibrium, likely consisting of a mixture of gas, oil and a mature solid residue47, 48, has been achieved during the very first days of experimental diagenesis (99% of the plateau (5τ) is reached in 3.5 days for Nebulotron and within the first day for G. violaceus, E. gracilis and PAMPRE). Basic extrapolations of the obtained kinetic laws for much longer durations suggest that no additional degradation would occur during geological times. In other words, the present results suggest that initially chemically different organic materials can remain different after several million years of diagenesis.
Advanced chemical characterization using spatially resolved spectroscopy techniques have been tentatively used to discuss the biological affinities of organic-walled microfossils16, 24, 49,50,51,52,53. Still, most of the witnesses of the first steps of the history of Life are unicellular organic-walled microfossils of unknown and probably varied biological affinities which fall into the category of acritarchs2, 54, 55. As illustrated here, consistently with reports of partly preserved biogenic organic molecules in the fossil record15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24, thermal maturation does not necessarily result in a convergence in the composition of organic materials from different sources. Thus, the present results suggest that enigmatic fossil acritarchs of different biological affinities could be distinguished based on their molecular compositions provided that they underwent a similar diagenetic history.
As for all laboratory simulations, the present experiments do not exactly mimic what really occurs in natural settings during millions of years22, 25, 29, 31, 33,34,35. Biodegradation and early taphonomic processes that may occur within sediments have not been simulated here, even though they may also alter the chemical composition of organic materials before the beginning of thermal maturation14, 56. Organic maturation processes in natural settings may also be strongly affected by the circulation of fluids57,58,59,60 or by the presence of certain mineral phases28, 29, 35, 61,62,63,64, which respective influence still needs to be rigorously investigated. In any case, besides its potential applications for the generation of thermostable biocomposites following the extreme biomimetic concepts65, 66, the present study highlights the pertinence of performing laboratory experiments to strengthen the current mechanistic understanding of organic material degradation processes, and thence, to accurately reconstruct the original chemical composition of ancient organic microfossils.
Materials and Methods
Selected organic materials
Two strains of unicellular oxygenic photosynthetic microorganisms have been selected: the prokaryotic cyanobacteria Gloeobacter violaceus (PCC 7421) and the eukaryotic microalgae Euglena gracilis (n°1224-5d - Cambridge). Both strains have been cultured at ambient temperature at IMPMC (Paris, France), G. violaceus in a regular BG-11 culture medium as done by Couradeau et al.67, and E. gracilis in a culture medium composed of KH2PO4 (0.5 g·L−1), MgSO4, 7H2O (0.5 g·L−1), CaCl2, 2H2O (0.26 g·L−1), (NH4)2HPO4 (0.5 g·L−1), a complement of vitamins, zinc (as ZnSO4), iron (as FeCl3), and manganese (as MnSO4) as done by Miot et al.68, 69. Cells of both strains were rinsed 3 times in bi-distilled water and dried in an oven at 50 °C under vacuum for 3 days prior to the experiments.
Two synthetic organic areosols (called Nebulotron and PAMPRE hereafter) have been selected for the present experimental study. These solid organics have been synthesized at CRPG (Nancy, France) by plasma discharge in gaseous mixtures using two different experimental setups39. Nebulotron are nitrogen and oxygen-rich aerosols condensed from a gaseous mixture made of 80% N2 and 20% CO while PAMPRE are nitrogen and hydrogen-rich aerosols condensed from a gaseous mixture made of 95% N2 and 5% CH4.
Thermal maturation experiments
About 1 mg of precursors have been placed into individual gold capsules that have then been sealed under argon atmosphere using an electrical arc and placed in Parr© autoclaves in which temperature and pressure conditions typical of burial-induced diagenesis (250 ± 2.5 °C and 250 ± 2.5 bars) have been maintained for 1, 10 and 100 days, thereby allowing kinetic investigations. All experiments have been repeated three times. Experimental solid residues have been recovered from the capsules and stored at 4 °C before being prepared for microscopic and spectroscopic analyses.
Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM)
SEM observations have been performed on pieces of experimental residues deposited on aluminum stubs and coated with 15 nm of gold, using the SEM-FEG ultra 55 Zeiss (IMPMC - Paris, France) microscope operating at a 3 kV accelerating voltage and a working distance of 3 mm for secondary electrons analyses (SE2 detector).
X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure (XANES) spectroscopy
XANES data acquisition procedure
XANES data have been collected on the 10ID-1 beamline (SM beamline)70 at the Canadian Light Source (CLS). The CLS SM beamline uses a monochromated X-ray beam spanning the 130–2500 eV range. This beam is generated with an elliptically polarized undulator (EPU) inserted in the 2.9 GeV, 250–100 mA, CLS synchrotron storage ring. The microscope chamber is first pumped down to 100 mTorr after sample insertion and then back-filled with He gas. A 100 nm thick titanium filter is used to remove the contribution of second order light. Energy calibration is done using the well-resolved 3p Rydberg peak of gaseous CO2 at 294.96 eV for the C K-edge and using the 1 s → π* photoabsorption resonance of gaseous N2 at 400.8 eV for the N K-edge. Image stacks have been collected with energy increments of 0.1 eV over the 250–450 eV energy range with a dwell time of one millisecond or less per pixel to prevent irradiation damages as recommended by Wang et al.71. Data processing has been done using the aXis2000 software package72. The N/C atomic ratio has been determined following the procedure developed by Alleon et al.37. The C- and N-XANES spectra shown here were averaged among triplicate samples and correspond to homogeneous areas of several tens of squared micrometers.
C-XANES data deconvolution procedure
A deconvolution procedure in three steps has been applied to C-XANES spectra: (i) background subtraction, (ii) normalization to the total carbon content, and (iii) spectral fitting using Gaussian functions. Background subtraction classically consists in the subtraction of a linear regression over the 270–282 eV energy range. Then, following Barré et al.73, C-XANES spectra have been normalized to their area between 280 eV and 291.5 eV, thereby ensuring chemical consistency (a spectrum showing a more prominent absorption than others at a given energy must have a less intense absorption at the energy of the other functional groups). Gaussian functions with a constant full-width at half maximum (0.6 eV) have been used for signal deconvolution. Their positions have been fixed following Myneni42, Dhez et al.74 and Solomon et al.75: 284.4 eV, quinones; 285.0 & 285.4 eV, aromatics and/or olefinics; 285.8 eV, imines; 286.2, 286.6 & 287.1 eV, nitriles/carbonyls/phenols; 287.7 eV, aliphatics; 288.2 eV, amides; 288.6 eV, carboxylics; 289.1 eV, aldehydes; 289.4 eV, hydroxyls; 289.9 eV, aliphatics; 290.3 eV, carbonates. Following Bernard et al.31, 76, Le Guillou et al.77, 78 and Alleon et al.35, two semi-quantitative parameters have been extracted from the XANES spectra: (1) the ‘aromaticity index’ (AI) that corresponds to the contribution of aromatic/olefinic carbons (i.e. the sum of the areas of the three Gaussian functions used to deconvolve the absorption signal in the range 284.4–285.4 eV), and (2) the ‘unsaturation index’ (UI) that corresponds to the contribution of C≡N, C=N, C=O and Ar-OH (i.e. the sum of the areas of the three Gaussian functions used to deconvolve the absorption signal in the range 285.8–286.6 eV) normalized to the aromaticity index. The degree of uncertainty associated with these estimated values (±10%, 1 SD) is inherited from the normalization procedure.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We gratefully acknowledge support from the ERC (project PaleoNanoLife; grant #161764 - PI: F. Robert) and from the Emergence program of Sorbonne Universités (project MarsAtLab - PI: S. Bernard). Special thanks go to Mélinée Deretz for administrative simplification, Imene Esteve (IMPMC) for her expert support of the SEM and Jian Wang and Jay Dynes for their expert support of the STXM at the Canadian Light Source (CLS). The SEM facility of the IMPMC is supported by Region Ile de France grant SESAME Number I-07-593/R, INSU-CNRS, INP-CNRS and UPMC-Paris 6, and by the Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR) grant number ANR-07-BLAN-0124-01. STXM-based X-ray absorption spectroscopy data were acquired at beamline 10ID-1 at the CLS, which is supported by the NSERC, the CIHR, the NRC and the University of Saskatchewan.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.