Abstract
Plasmas have been recently studied as topological materials. However, a comprehensive picture of topological phases and topological phase transitions in cold magnetized plasmas is still missing. Here we systematically map out all the topological phases and establish the bulkedge correspondence in cold magnetized plasmas. We find that for the linear eigenmodes, there are 10 topological phases in the parameter space of density n, magnetic field B, and parallel wavenumber k_{z}, separated by the surfaces of Langmuir waveL wave resonance, Langmuir wavecyclotron wave resonance, and zero magnetic field. For fixed B and k_{z}, only the phase transition at the Langmuir wavecyclotron wave resonance corresponds to edge modes. A sufficient and necessary condition for the existence of this type of edge modes is given and verified by numerical solutions. We demonstrate that edge modes exist not only on a plasmavacuum interface but also on more general plasmaplasma interfaces. This finding broadens the possible applications of these exotic excitations in space and laboratory plasmas.
Introduction
Recently, the relation between the topological properties of the bulk modes and the chiral (unidirectional) edge modes has attracted growing interest in classical fluid^{1,2,3,4,5} and plasma physics^{6,7,8,9,10}. Originating in condensed matter physics, the bulkedge correspondence^{11,12,13} predicts that at the interfaces between two topologically different materials, there exist gapless edge modes across the common band gap. For condensed matter systems, the gap Chern number is a topological invariant for bulk modes to give a \({\mathbb{Z}}\) classification^{12}. On the other hand, continuum media, including plasmas, do not have well defined Brillouin zones, and compactification techniques in the wavenumber space^{4,5,10,14} have been adopted to generate integer Chern numbers. It has also been argued that proper Brillouin zones are not essential for using Chern numbers to predicting boundary states^{15}. Landau levels in the continuum and Weyl semimetals are good examples.
In plasma physics, the wellknown ClemmowMullalyAllis (CMA) diagram^{16,17,18,19} provides a crude topological classification of wave normal surfaces in the parameter space of magnetic field and density. The classification of the waves using the topological index of the Chern type provides a different theoretical understanding that can be used as predictive tool, e.g., in the study of edge modes. For cold magnetized plasmas, topological phases and topological phase transitions have not been systematically mapped out because of the complicated parameter dependency. The bulkedge correspondence has not been well established due to the noncompactness of the wavenumber space. For cases with wave vectors perpendicular to the magnetic field, the bulk topology and corresponding edge states of the X waves (transversemagnetic waves) have been extensively studied^{13,14,20,21,22,23,24} when the O waves (transverseelectric waves) are ignored. It is reported that under certain conditions, the bulkedge correspondence between the gap of X waves can be physically violated^{25}. Another type of edge mode has been derived using a simplified analytical model^{6} and linked to the Weyl degeneracies^{7}. This edge mode was also numerically demonstrated^{10} for a plasmavacuum interface with continuous density falloff. However, the corresponding bulk topological phases and phase transition have not yet been identified.
In the present study, we attempt at a comprehensive picture of the topological phases, topological phase transitions, and the bulkedge correspondence of magnetized cold plasmas in the absence of a solid boundary. We extend the study by Parker et al.^{10} of the linear eigenmodes in a cold plasma with stationary ions in a uniform magnetic field, and carefully draw the topological phase diagram in the parameter space, and clarify the condition for the existence of the topological edge modes. Specifically, we report the following findings. (i) In the parameter space of magnetic field \({\bf{B}}={B}_{0}\hat{z}\), density n, and wavenumber k_{z}, there are 10 topological phases, separated by the Langmuir waveL wave (LL) resonance, the Langmuir waveCyclotron wave (LC) resonance, and the B = 0 surface. (ii) Their topological properties are classified by the integer Chern numbers of the spectrum. For fixed nonvanishing B and k_{z}, there are two possible topological phase transitions due to the two resonances, while only the transition at the LC resonance produces edge modes. (iii) There exists a critical density n_{c} such that plasmas below and above n_{c} are in different topological phases across the LC resonance. We find that edge modes exist not only at the plasmavacuum boundary^{10}, but also at more general plasmaplasma interfaces when a necessary and sufficient condition, Eq. (7), is satisfied, and the edge modes can be categorized by different behaviors of the Fermi arcs or Fermiarcslike curves. This finding broadens the possible applications of these exotic edge modes in space and laboratory plasmas.
Results
Bulk dispersion relation and eigenmodes
Following ref. ^{10}, we use the linearized fluid equations for a magnetized cold plasma with stationary ion and uniform density n_{e} to study the eigenmodes of the system. The constant background magnetic field is in the zdirection, i.e., \({{\bf{B}}}_{0}={B}_{0}\hat{{\bf{z}}}\), and there is no equilibrium flow. After spacetime Fourier transform, ∂_{t} → − iω, ∇ → ik, and the governing equations can be written as \(H({\bf{k}})\left\psi \right\rangle =\omega \left\psi \right\rangle \), where H(k) is a 9 × 9 Hermitian matrix, and \(\left\psi \right\rangle ={({\bf{v}},{\bf{E}},{\bf{B}})}^{{\rm{T}}}\) is a ninedimensional vector consisting of the perturbed velocity and electromagnetic fields. A detailed derivation of H(k) is provided in the “Methods” section.
The dispersion relation is given by the vanishing determinant of H(k) − ωI_{9}, which can be simplified as
where N = ck/ω, and ϵ is the 3 × 3 cold plasma dielectric tensor. In terms of the standard notations in ref. ^{16},
where \({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}=\sqrt{{n}_{{\rm{e}}}{e}^{2}/{m}_{{\rm{e}}}{\epsilon }_{0}}\) is the plasma frequency, and Ω = −eB_{0}/m_{e} is the electron cyclotron frequency. The plasma is called underdense if \({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}<\left{{\Omega }}\right\), and overdense if \({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}> \left{{\Omega }}\right\). It can be shown that the dispersion relation surfaces in the (ω, k) space are symmetric with respect to all four coordinate hyperplanes. For each given k_{z}, the system has 9 eigenvalues ω_{n} and eigenvectors \(\left{\psi }_{n}\right\rangle \) as functions of k_{⊥}, where ω_{−n} = − ω_{n} and n = − 4, − 3, ..., 3, 4 is the index for the eigenmodes. See the “Methods” section for a detailed discussion of the symmetry properties of the spectrum. Note that ω_{0} = 0 is the zero frequency eigenmode of the system. The dispersion surfaces ω(k_{z}, k_{⊥}) of the four positivefrequency branches for both overdense and underdense plasmas are shown in Fig. 1a, b. To better illustrate the crossing between branches, the dispersion curves ω(k_{z}) at different values of k_{⊥} are shown in Fig. 1c, d. We can observe that branch crossing occurs only when k_{⊥} = 0, represented by the coldest blue lines. In this case, the horizontal lines ω = ω_{p} are the Langmuir waves given by P = 0. The other three branches are the R wave and the L wave given by N^{2} = R and N^{2} = L, respectively, where R = S + D and L = S − D. For convenience, we define functions
When k_{z} > 0, the Langmuir wave resonates with the L wave at k_{z} = k^{+}. In an underdense plasma, the Langmuir wave also resonates with the lower branch of the R wave, a.k.a electron cyclotron wave, at k_{z} = k^{−}. Notice that k^{−} → ∞ when ω_{p} → ∣Ω∣. These four resonant points at k_{z} = ± k^{±}, previously recognized as the Weyl points^{7}, play important roles in determining the topological properties of magnetized plasmas.
Topolgoical phase diagram
When fixing k_{z} as a parameter, we can calculate the Chern number for each band, i.e., branch of the dispersion relation, in the k_{⊥} = (k_{x}, k_{y}) space. If the k_{⊥} space can be properly compactified^{10,14}, Chern numbers in the system should be integers, which are invariant under continuous transforms. It means that each band’s Chern number is a topological invariant that can change only when different bands cross. As shown in Fig. 1, the band crossing in a cold plasma is only possible at the points (k_{x}, k_{y}, k_{z}) = (0, 0, ± k^{±}) when B ≠ 0 and k_{z} ≠ 0. Therefore, the locations of k_{z} = ± k^{±} defines the boundaries between topologically different regions if separated regions have different Chern numbers. In Fig. 2a, the surfaces of k_{z} = k^{±} and Ω = 0 in the (ω_{p}, Ω, k_{z}) space are shown, which separate the parameter space into 10 different regions, each represents a different phase characterized by a set of Chern numbers. Although the first band touches the zerofrequency mode at k_{z} = 0, we will show later that this band crossing does not affect the topology. The cross sections of the 3D surfaces at (ω_{p} = 1, Ω > 0, k_{z} > 0) and (ω_{p} > 0, Ω = 1, k_{z} > 0) are shown in Fig. 2b, c, each of which is separated into three phases. Notice that phase I in these cross sections only exists in underdense plasmas, i.e, when ω_{p} < ∣Ω∣.
We adopt the same formalism of Berry curvature and regularization strategy used in ref. ^{10} to calculate the Chern numbers numerically. The Chern number of the nth band is denoted by C_{n}. As functions of (ω_{p}, Ω, k_{z}), Chern numbers admit the following symmetries, C_{n}(Ω, k_{z}) = C_{n}(Ω, − k_{z}) = − C_{n}(−Ω, k_{z}) = − C_{−n}(Ω, k_{z}). See additional details about the symmetry properties of the Chern numbers for the system in the Methods section. Therefore, it suffices to calculate the Chern numbers for the three phases in the domain of k_{z} > 0 and Ω > 0, as shown in Fig. 2b, c.
The resulting Chern numbers for each positivefrequency band in all three phases are shown in Fig. 3a–c. We find that the Chern numbers in phases II and III are (C_{1}, C_{2}, C_{3}, C_{4}) = (−1, 1, 1, −1) and (−1, 2, 0, −1), respectively, as reported in ref. ^{10}. For the special case of k_{z} = 0, the Chern numbers for phase III are consistent with those calculated in refs. ^{14,22}. For phase I, we discover that its Chern numbers are (C_{1}, C_{2}, C_{3}, C_{4}) = (0, 0, 1, − 1), which was not reported previously. When the parameters cross the boundary of k_{z} = k^{−} and change from phase I to phase II, bands 1 and 2 cross at k_{⊥} = 0 and change their Chern numbers from (0, 0) to (−1, 1). This change agrees with the fact that the Weyl point at k_{z} = k^{−} has Chern number 1^{7}. Similar behavior is observed between bands 2 and 3 when parameters cross the boundary of k_{z} = k^{−} and change from phase II to phase III.
Of particular interest in the present study is the transition between phases I and II. The boundary between them, i.e., the LC resonance surface, defines a critical density n_{c}, which, expressed in terms of the corresponding plasma frequency \({\omega }_{{\rm{p,c}}}=\sqrt{{n}_{{\rm{c}}}{e}^{2}/{m}_{{\rm{e}}}{\epsilon }_{0}}\), is
For fixed k_{z} and Ω, transition between phases I and II occurs at n = n_{c}. Notice that when k_{z} → ∞, ω_{p,c} → ∣Ω∣, and n_{c} becomes \({{n}_{{\rm{c}}}}^{\infty }\equiv {{{\Omega }}}^{2}{m}_{{\rm{e}}}{\epsilon }_{0}/{e}^{2}\).
The surface of Ω = 0 is also a boundary between different topological phases because C_{n}( − Ω) = − C_{n}(Ω). For the special case of k_{z} = 0, the boundary between phases I and II and the boundary between phases II and III collapse to the lines defined by Ω = 0 and ω_{p} = 0. In this case, the only possible nontrivial phase transition happens at the Ω = 0 surface.
Band gaps
Bulkedge correspondence suggests that edge modes exist in the common band gaps at the interface between two topological materials with different gap Chern numbers. We now identify possible band gaps in a magnetized cold plasma. At fixed k_{z}, when k_{⊥} → ∞, (ω_{1}, ω_{2}, ω_{3}, ω_{4}) → (0, ω_{uh}, ck_{⊥}, ck_{⊥}), where \({\omega }_{\,\text{uh}\,}^{2}={\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}^{2}+{{{\Omega }}}^{2}\) is the upper hybrid frequency. Thus, when ∣k_{z}∣ ≠ k^{±}, it is possible to have gaps between bands 1 and 2 and between bands 2 and 3. However, the gap between bands 2 and 3 does not always exist. When k_{⊥} = 0, ω_{3}(k_{z}) is given by N^{2} = L. The nonoverlapping of bands 2 and 3 requires ω_{3}(k_{z}) > ω_{uh}, which leads to
The locations of ∣k_{z}∣ = k^{*} in the parameter space are shown in Fig. 2b, c. It is clear that the gap between bands 2 and 3 does not exist in phase III because condition (6) is not satisfied there.
The topology of a band gap is characterized by it gap Chern number, which is defined as \({C}_{i,i+1}=\mathop{\sum }\nolimits_{n = 4}^{i}{C}_{n}\) for the gap between the ith and (i + 1)th bands. In phase I, both C_{1,2} and C_{2,3} are trivially zero, as in the phase of vacuum^{11} that phase I neighbors at the boundary of ω_{p} = 0. Thus, as far as the gap topology is concerned, phase I plasmas are identical to the vacuum, which is interesting if not surprising. In phase II, the gap Chern numbers (C_{1,2}, C_{2,3}) become (−1, 0), indicating a topological phase transition at the boundary between phases I and II due to the crossing of the gap between bands 1 and 2. In phase III, the gap Chern numbers (C_{1,2}, C_{2,3}) are (−1, 1). Although C_{2,3} is different between phase II and III, there is no band gap between bands 2 and 3 in phase III as proved above. When ∣k_{z}∣ ≠ 0, there is another band gap between bands 0 and 1. However, the gap Chern number C_{0,1} for this gap is zero for all three phases, and it is a trivial band gap. Therefore, only the band gap between bands 1 and 2 shared by phases I and II is interesting in the context of bulkedge correspondence.
It is worth mentioning that when k_{z} = 0, band 3 becomes the O wave, and bands 2 and 4 are the X wave. If one chooses to ignore the O wave^{13,14,20,22}, then a band gap shows up between bands 2 and 4, as long as Ω ≠ 0. The physical properties of this gap has been extensively studied, including the violation of bulkedge correspondence under certain conditions^{25}. However, as an important eigenmode in magnetized cold plamsas, band 3 always exists. Especially when ∣k_{z}∣ > k^{+}, band 3 has a nonzero Chern number and should not be ignored. In the present study, we include all 9 bands in magnetized cold plasmas.
Bulkedge correspondence
Having established the topological phase diagram and possible band gaps in a magnetized cold plasma, we now investigate the edge modes at the interface between two different magnetized cold plasmas. As discussed above, at a fixed B, the only possible nontrivial gap that admits two different gap Chern numbers is the gap between bands 1 and 2 shared by phases I and II. The bulkedge correspondence then predicts that edge modes exist in the common band gap at the interface between a phase I plasma and a phase II plasma. We now solve for these edge modes numerically in an 1D inhomogeneous plasma. The background magnetic field is constant, i.e., \({{\bf{B}}}_{0}={B}_{0}\hat{z}\), and the plasma density is nonuniform only in the xdirection, as shown in Fig. 4a. The density profile is given by \(n(x)=\frac{1}{2}({n}_{1}{n}_{2})\{\tanh [(xl)/\delta ]+\tanh [(x+l)/\delta ]\}+{n}_{2}\), where n_{1} and n_{2} are the densities of the inner and outer plasmas, and l and δ are the location and width of the interface. For realistic plasmas, the width of the interface is finite, i.e., δ > 0.
Because the system is uniform in the zdirection, the parallel wavenumber k_{z} enters as a parameter. The inner and outer plasmas can be represented by two points, (ω_{p,1}, Ω, k_{z}) and (ω_{p,2}, Ω, k_{z}), in the phase diagram shown in Fig. 2. Here, ω_{p,1} and ω_{p,2} are the inner and outer plasma frequencies. As discussed above, when there is a common band gap shared by the inner and outer plasmas, chiral edge modes exist in the gap if and only if the inner plasma is in phase I and outer plasma is in phase II such that they have different gap Chern numbers. Furthermore, the number of chiral edge modes at the interface should be equal to the difference of the gap Chern numbers, which is 1 in the present case. Since n_{c} is the critical density at the boundary between phases I and II, for given k_{z} and Ω, the chiral edge mode exists if and only if
which, expressed in terms of plasma frequencies, is
Here, we observe that underdense and overdense plasmas behave differently. When both the inner and outer plasmas are overdense, edge mode cannot exist regardless of k_{z}. If the inner plasma is overdense while the outer plasma is underdense, edge modes can be found when k_{z} > k^{−}(ω_{p,2}). If both the inner and outer plasma are underdense, the edge mode can only be found when k^{−}(ω_{p,1}) > ∣k_{z}∣ > k^{−}(ω_{p,2}). Notice that when the outer side is a vacuum, the criteria given by Eq. (8) can be satisfied in two scenarios, either \({k}_{z}^{2}\) is small enough or the inner plasma is overdense. Incidentally, all the parameters chosen in ref. ^{10} belong to the first scenario.
To numerically verify the criteria in Eqs. (7) or (8), we Fouriertransform in y, z and t, then spatially discretize the Hamiltonian H in the xdirection using a finite difference method. A periodic boundary condition at x = ± 2l is adopted, as in ref. ^{1}. To ensure the numerically calculated spectrum admits the same symmetries as the analytical spectrum, we adopt a discretization scheme that preserves the Hermiticity and the particlehole symmetry of the system. See the “Methods” section for details. The structures of the positivefrequency bands for different (n_{1}, n_{2}) at ck_{z}/∣Ω∣ = 0.7 are shown in Fig. 4d–f. For the cases of n_{c} > n_{1} > n_{2} = 0 and n_{1} > n_{2} > n_{c}, there is no edge mode in the gap between the first and second bands. In particular, Fig. 4f shows that the edge modes can be absent at a plasmavacuum interface. In Fig. 4e, n_{1} > n_{c} > n_{2} and there are two gapless edge modes in the band gap. Due to the symmetry of ω(k_{y}) = ω( − k_{y}), the two edge modes cross at k_{y} = 0. The electric field structure of the two gapless modes localized at different edges is shown in Fig. 4b, c. The number of edge modes at each edge is the same as the difference of the gap Chern number, consistent with the prediction of bulkedge correspondence.
To further understand the edge modes, band structures at k_{y} = 0 with various densities are plotted in Fig. 5, which shows that edge modes can be classified by behaviors of the Fermi arc or Fermiarclike curves. The inner plasma is underdense in Fig. 5a, c and overdense in Fig. 5b, d. The outer is underdense in Fig. 5c, d and vacuum in Fig. 5a, b. The bulk dispersions are shown by orange and blue lines for inner and outer plasmas in each case. The topological edge modes are shown in red lines representing the crossing points between the left and right edge modes at each given k_{z}. We can see that the range where edge modes exist coincides with Eq. (8) exactly. Noticeably, in Fig. 5a, edge modes exist when ∣k_{z}∣ < k^{−}(ω_{p,1}) between a underdense plasma and a vacuum. The dispersion surface ω = ω(k_{z}, k_{y}) of the edge modes connects the two Weyl points of the inner plasma at k_{z} = ± k^{−}(ω_{p,1}). The intersection of this dispersion surface and ω = ω_{p,1} is known as the Fermi arc connecting two Weyl points^{26,27}. When the inner plasma is overdense in Fig. 5b, the Weyl points ± k^{−}(ω_{p,1}) disappear, but the edge modes still exist and the dispersion surface connects to k_{z} = ± ∞. When the inner and outer plasmas are all underdense in Fig. 5c, edge modes are prohibited if − k^{−}(ω_{p,2}) < k_{z} < k^{−}(ω_{p,2}), then the dispersion surface no longer connects the Weyl points of the inner plasma at positive and negative k_{z}. Instead, a Fermiarclike curve connects k_{z} = k^{−}(ω_{p,1}) and k_{z} = k^{−}(ω_{p,2}), the Weyl points of the inner and outer plasmas. In Fig. 5d, the inner is overdense and the outer underdense, a Fermiarclike curve connects the Weyl point of the outer plasma to infinity. These numerical results also confirm the condition given by Eqs. (7) or (8) for the existence of the edge modes.
As a side note, the gap between bands 1 and 2 of the inner plasma may overlap with the gap between bands 2 and 3 of the outer plasma. It is reasonable to suggest that if C_{in,1,2} ≠ C_{out,2,3}, edge modes might exist within this gap. However, this common gap is filled with other eigenmodes in reality. The upper hybrid frequency ω_{uh}, which depends on plasma density, sets the upper range for band 2. Since the density profile is continuous, the local upper hybrid frequency ω_{uh}(x) will always fill in the gap between the second bands of the inner and outer plasmas. An example is illustrated in Fig. 6, where the inner and outer plasmas belong to phases II and I, respectively.
Varying density is a convenient but not the only way to create interfaces between topologically different plasmas. Since plasma topology varies with the strength and direction of the magnetic field, one can create topologically nontrivial interfaces by assembling two plasmas with different background magnetic field. In particular, when k_{z} = 0, the only possible topological phase transition in a cold plasma occurs at the Ω = 0 surface, as discussed above. In this case, the edge modes at the interface between two plasmas with opposite magnetic fields has been studied for the X wave^{13,23}. However, as a whole system, such a setup is inhomogeneous, and the O wave cannot be decoupled. More thorough analysis is need.
Discussion
The linear and nonlinear properties of edge modes, or surface waves, in plasmas have been studied for decades^{28,29,30}. However, the relation between surface modes and the topology of bulk plasma was only pointed out recently. In the present research, we studied the linear eigenmodes of a cold plasma in a uniform magnetic field, and found that the system has 10 different topological phases in the (ω_{p}, Ω, k_{z}) space. The different phases are separated by the surfaces of Langmuir waveL wave resonance, Langmuir wavecyclotron wave resonance, and Ω = 0. We found that at fixed Ω and k_{z}, only the band gap between bands 1 and 2 shared by phases I and II is interesting in the context of bulkedge correspondence, and that the necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of edge modes is n_{1} > n_{c} > n_{2}. These findings were verified by numerical studies of the corresponding chiral edge modes in 1D inhomogeneous plasmas. The edge modes exist not only on the plasmavacuum interface, but also on more general plasmaplasma interfaces. The validity of the bulkedge correspondence is confirmed for the cold magnetized plasma as a nondriven Hermitian system. These results improved our understanding of the elementary properties of the magnetized plasma as a topological material.
It is worth mentioning that in the plasma physics community, the term “edge” usually refers to the physical boundary of plasmas adjacent to the first wall of vacuum chambers^{31,32}. In the context of topological matters, the term ‘edge’ refers to the boundary of two topologically different regions, although a plasmavacuum edge can also be a topological edge when the plasma and the vacuum have different Chern numbers. As discussed above, the topological edges include not only the plasmavacuum boundary, but also more general gaseous plasmaplasma interfaces, which are the focus of the present study We did not consider gaseous plasmasolid interfaces, which, unlike the interfaces between solid state materials^{27}, involve more complex physical processes, such as the plasma sheath and plasmawall interactions^{31,33}. It is not appropriate to model gaseous plasmasolid interfaces only as simple interfaces between two different topological materials.
The present classification of the topological phases in the parameter space is carried out for the linearized system of a homogeneous, magnetized, cold plasma with stationary ions. Such a classification in this simplified system provides an elementary tool and serves as a reference model for studying the topologicalmatter properties of more realistic plasmas. For example, in an inhomogeneous plasma, edge modes may be excited at the interface between two plasmas in different topological phases. When other physical effects, such finite temperature, plasma collisions, and kinetic interactions, are important, the band structures^{16} and topological properties of the system can change significantly, including the number of topological phases and possible phase transitions. One systematic approach for understanding these changes is to analyze the variations of the symmetry properties of the system^{34}. For instance, the magnetized cold plasma model studied here has a broken timereversal symmetry, but the linearized ideal magnetohydrodynamics system is invariant under the (modified) timereversal transformation^{8}, despite the existence of an external magnetic field. Furthermore, the linear dynamics in many plasma models is expected be to nonHermitian^{35,36}, permitting unstable and damped eigenmodes. Applying the methods of topological phases for nonHermitian systems^{37,38} will bring more insights and discoveries in the study of plasma instabilities for laboratory and astrophysical plasmas.
Methods
Basic equations
Here we outline the band structure of cold plasma waves. Assume the background plasma is uniform and stationary, the ions are motionless and the magnetic field is constant, i.e., \({{\bf{B}}}_{0}={B}_{0}\hat{z}\). The linearized fluid equations are^{16}
where v, B, E are perturbed velocity, magnetic field and electric field, e is the electron charge, m_{e} and n_{e} are electron mass and density, and c is light speed. Let plasma frequency \({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}^{2}={n}_{{\rm{e}}}{e}^{2}/{\epsilon }_{0}{m}_{{\rm{e}}}\) and cyclotron frequency Ω = − eB_{0}/m_{e}. Define renormalized velocity \(\tilde{{\bf{v}}}={\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}{\bf{v}}\), reference electric field \(\bar{E}\) and reference frequency \(\bar{\omega }\). We normalize time to \({\bar{\omega }}^{1}\), frequency to \(\bar{\omega }\), length to \(c/\bar{\omega }\), \(\tilde{{\bf{v}}}\) to \(e\bar{E}/{m}_{{\rm{e}}}\), electric field to \(\bar{E}\), and magnetic field to \(\bar{E}/c\). The equation system becomes
Notice that when the density is not uniform, it suffices to change ω_{p} to ω_{p}(r) in Eq. (10). From now on, we omit the tilde for convenience. After space Fourier transform, ∂_{t} → − iω, ∇ → ik, and the governing equations can be written as \(H\left\psi \right\rangle =\omega \left\psi \right\rangle \), where \(\left\psi \right\rangle ={({\bf{v}},{\bf{E}},{\bf{B}})}^{{\rm{T}}}\) and
Here, H is a 9 × 9 Hermitian matrix. The dispersion relation is given by \(\det (H\omega {{\bf{I}}}_{9})=0\), which simplifies to Eq. (1).
Symmetries of the system
As a real system, the equations of motion for plasmas admit an unbreakable particlehole symmetry^{9,39}. For our system, the symmetry states that H(−k)^{*} = − H(k), where ^{*} denotes complex conjugate. It ensures that the dispersion relation has the symmetry of ω( − k) = − ω(k). Notice that Eq. (1) remains invariant under k → − k, so the dispersion relation satisfy ω(k) = ω( − k) as well. In addition, since the system is isotropic in the direction perpendicular to the background magnetic field, ω only depends on k_{z} ≡ k_{z} and \({k}_{\perp }\equiv \sqrt{{k}_{x}^{2}+{k}_{y}^{2}}\). Therefore, the dispersion relation surfaces in the (ω, k_{x}, k_{y}, k_{z}) space are symmetric with respect to the reflections of all four coordinate hyperplanes.
The symmetries of eigenvalues can also be obtained, which will be useful during the calculation of the Chern numbers. H(ω_{p}, Ω, k) has 9 eigenvalues, one of which is identically zero. The eigenvalues and corresponding eigenvectors can be labeled as \({\omega }_{n},\left{\psi }_{n}\right\rangle \), where n = − 4, − 3, ⋯ , 3, 4, ω_{i} < ω_{j} if i < j. Assume that at some (ω_{p}, Ω, k), the nth eigenvalue and eigenvector are ω_{n} = ω and \(\left{\psi }_{n}\right\rangle ={({\bf{v}},{\bf{E}},{\bf{B}})}^{{\rm{T}}}\). We can verify the following symmetries of eigenvalues and eigenvectors:

1.
For the reflection of band number n → − n, ω_{−n} = − ω and \(\left{\psi }_{n}\right\rangle ={({{\bf{v}}}^{* },{{\bf{E}}}^{* },{{\bf{B}}}^{* })}^{{\rm{T}}}\).

2.
For the reflection of magnetic field Ω → − Ω, ω_{n} = ω and \(\left{\psi }_{n}\right\rangle ={({{\bf{v}}}^{* },{{\bf{E}}}^{* },{{\bf{B}}}^{* })}^{{\rm{T}}}\).

3.
For the reflection of wavenumber k → − k, ω_{n} = ω and \(\left{\psi }_{n}\right\rangle ={({\bf{v}},{\bf{E}},{\bf{B}})}^{{\rm{T}}}\).
The symmetries of Chern numbers
In this section, we briefly describe the calculation and symmetries of Chern numbers. For any given parallel wavenumber k_{z}, the Chern number can be calculated in the k_{⊥} space for each band by^{12}C_{n} = (2π)^{−1}∫dS ⋅ F_{n}(k), where F_{n} = ∇_{k} × A_{n} is the Berry curvature, and A_{n} = i〈ψ_{n}∣∇_{k}ψ_{n}〉 is the Berry connection. Let \(\left{\psi }_{n}({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}},{{\Omega }},{\bf{k}})\right\rangle ={({\bf{v}},{\bf{E}},{\bf{B}})}^{{\rm{T}}}\). The Berry connection is A_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k) = i(v^{†}∇_{k}v + E^{†}∇_{k}E + B^{†}∇_{k}B), where † denotes conjugate transpose. Based on the symmetries of eigenvectors, we obtain the following symmetries of Chern numbers:

1.
For the reflection of band number n → − n,
$${{\bf{A}}}_{n}({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}},{{\Omega }},{\bf{k}}) ={\rm{i}}\langle {\psi }_{n} {\nabla }_{{\bf{k}}}{\psi }_{n}\rangle \\ ={\rm{i}}({\bf{v}}{\nabla }_{{\bf{k}}}{{\bf{v}}}^{\dagger }+{\bf{E}}{\nabla }_{{\bf{k}}}{{\bf{E}}}^{\dagger }+{\bf{B}}{\nabla }_{{\bf{k}}}{{\bf{B}}}^{\dagger })\\ ={{\bf{A}}}_{n}({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}},{{\Omega }},{\bf{k}}).$$(12)Thus, C_{−n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k_{z}) = − C_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k_{z}).

2.
For the reflection of magnetic field Ω → − Ω, A_{n}(ω_{p}, − Ω, k) = − A_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k). Thus, C_{n}(ω_{p}, − Ω, k_{z}) = − C_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k_{z}).

3.
For the reflection of parallel wavenumber k_{z} → − k_{z}, since the system is isotropic in k_{⊥}plane, it is equivalent to the reflection of wavenumber k → −k. Due to the symmetries of the eigenvectors, we have A_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, − k) = − A_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k) and F_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, − k) = F_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k). Therefore, C_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, −k_{z}) = C_{n}(ω_{p}, Ω, k_{z}).
For numerical evaluation of the Chern numbers, the following alternative formula of Berry curvature is used,
To enforce integer Chern numbers, we adopt the same regularization strategy used in ref. ^{10}. At large k_{⊥}, we regularize the plasma frequency in Eq. (11) by replacing ω_{p} with \({\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}/(1+{k}_{\perp }^{2}/{{k}_{{\rm{c}}}}^{2})\), where k_{c} is a largeenough cutoff wavenumber.
Numerical scheme
Here we introduce the numerical methods for eigenmodes calculation. When density n(x) is nonuniform in the xdirection, we Fouriertransform Eq. (10) in y, z, t and but not in x. The simulation region in the xdirection is [ − 2l, 2l] and is discretized into N grids. The interval of grids is Δx = 4l/N and the grid points are x_{i} = iΔx − 2l, i = 0, ⋯ , N − 1. Similar to ref. ^{1}, a periodic boundary condition is applied at x = ± 2l. Next, we adopt the strategy of structurepreserving geometric algorithms in plasma physics to discretize v and E on integer grid points x_{i} and B on halfinteger grid points x_{i+1/2} ≡ (x_{i} + x_{i+1})/2, i.e., v_{i} ≡ v(x_{i}), E_{i} ≡ E(x_{i}), and B_{i+1/2} ≡ B(x_{i+1/2}). Such discretization ensures centered discretization of xderivatives and preserves the geometric relations between different components of the field. Periodic boundary condition enforces that v_{N} = v_{0}, E_{N} = E_{0}, B_{N+1/2} = B_{1/2}. Define \({\omega }_{{\rm{p,j}}}\equiv {\omega }_{{\rm{p}}}({x}_{j}) \sim \sqrt{n({x}_{j})}\). Then, Eq. (10) is discretized as
Equations (14)–(16) are now a standard matrix eigenvalue problem, which can be solved by various established algorithms. It is straightforward to confirm that the matrix specified by Eqs. (14)–(16) is Hermitian and admits the particlehole symmetry as Eq. (10) is and does. This structurepreserving discretization enables the reformulation of the eigenvalue problem of an inhomogeneous, magnetized, cold plasma as an eigenvalue problem for a Hermitian matrices with the particlehole symmetry.
Data availability
All relevant data supporting the findings of this study are available on DataSpace at Princeton University (http://arks.princeton.edu/ark:/88435/dsp01qj72pb21d) or from the authors on request.
Code availability
The computer code used to generate results that are reported in the paper is available from the authors on request.
References
Delplace, P., Marston, J. & Venaille, A. Topological origin of equatorial waves. Science 358, 1075 (2017).
Souslov, A., Van Zuiden, B. C., Bartolo, D. & Vitelli, V. Topological sound in activeliquid metamaterials. Nat. Phys. 13, 1091 (2017).
Perrot, M., Delplace, P. & Venaille, A. Topological transition in stratified fluids. Nat. Phys. 15, 781 (2019).
Souslov, A., Dasbiswas, K., Fruchart, M., Vaikuntanathan, S. & Vitelli, V. Topological waves in fluids with odd viscosity. Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 128001 (2019).
Tauber, C., Delplace, P. & Venaille, A. A bulkinterface correspondence for equatorial waves. J. Fluid Mech. 868, R2 (2019).
Yang, B., Lawrence, M., Gao, W., Guo, Q. & Zhang, S. Oneway helical electromagnetic wave propagation supported by magnetized plasma. Sci. Rep. 6, 21461 (2016).
Gao, W. et al. Photonic Weyl degeneracies in magnetized plasma. Nat. Commun. 7, 12435 (2016).
Parker, J. B., Burby, J., Marston, J. & Tobias, S. M. Nontrivial topology in the continuous spectrum of a magnetized plasma. Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033425 (2020).
Parker, J. B. Topological phase in plasma physics. J. Plasma Phys. 87, 835870202 (2021).
Parker, J. B., Marston, J., Tobias, S. M. & Zhu, Z. Topological gaseous plasmon polariton in realistic plasma. Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 195001 (2020).
Hasan, M. Z. & Kane, C. L. Colloquium: topological insulators. Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 3045 (2010).
Bernevig, B. A. & Hughes, T. L. Topological Insulators and Topological Superconductors (Princeton University Press, 2013).
Silveirinha, M. G. Proof of the bulkedge correspondence through a link between topological photonics and fluctuationelectrodynamics. Phys. Rev. X 9, 011037 (2019).
Silveirinha, M. G. Chern invariants for continuous media. Phys. Rev. B 92, 125153 (2015).
Marciani, M. & Delplace, P. Chiral Maxwell waves in continuous media from Berry monopoles. Phys. Rev. A 101, 023827 (2020).
Stix, T. H. Waves in Plasmas (Springer Science, Business Media, 1992).
Clemmow, P. C. & Mullaly, R. F. The dependence of the refractive index in magnetoionic theory on the direction of the wave normal. In Physics of the Ionosphere: Rep. Phys. Soc. Conf. (London Physical Society, 1955) p. 340.
Allis, W. P. Waves in a plasma. In Sherwood Conf. Contr. Fusion, Gatlinburg, TN, Apr. 27–28, p. 32 (1959).
Allis, W. P., Buchsbaum, S. J. & Bers, A. Waves in anisotropic plasmas. (MIT Press, Cambridge, 1963).
Silveirinha, M. G. Bulkedge correspondence for topological photonic continua. Phys. Rev. B 94, 205105 (2016).
Gangaraj, S. A. H., Nemilentsau, A. & Hanson, G. W. The effects of threedimensional defects on oneway surface plasmon propagation for photonic topological insulators comprised of continuum media. Sci. Rep. 6, 30055 (2016).
Gangaraj, S. A. H., Silveirinha, M. G. & Hanson, G. W. Berry phase, Berry connection, and Chern number for a continuum bianisotropic material from a classical electromagnetics perspective. IEEE JMMCT 2, 3 (2017).
Gangaraj, S. A. H. & Monticone, F. Coupled topological surface modes in gyrotropic structures: Greena’s function analysis. IEEE AWPL 17, 1993 (2018).
Gangaraj, S. A. H. et al. Unidirectional and diffractionless surface plasmon polaritons on threedimensional nonreciprocal plasmonic platforms. Phys. Rev. B 99, 245414 (2019).
Gangaraj, S. A. H. & Monticone, F. Physical violations of the bulkedge correspondence in topological electromagnetics. Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 153901 (2020).
Armitage, N., Mele, E. & Vishwanath, A. Weyl and Dirac semimetals in threedimensional solids. Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 015001 (2018).
Ozawa, T. et al. Topological photonics. Rev. Mod. Phys. 91, 015006 (2019).
Gradov, O. & Stenflo, L. Linear theory of a cold bounded plasma. Phys. Rep. 94, 111 (1983).
D’yakonov, M. New type of electromagnetic wave propagating at an interface. Sov. Phys. JETP 67, 714 (1988).
Vladimirov, S. V., Yu, M. & Tsytovich, V. Recent advances in the theory of nonlinear surface waves. Phys. Rep. 241, 1 (1994).
Stangeby, P. C. et al. The Plasma Boundary of Magnetic Fusion Devices, Vol. 224 (Institute of Physics Pub. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 2000).
Krasheninnikov, S., Smolyakov, A. & Kukushkin, A. On the Edge of Magnetic Fusion Devices (Springer, 2020).
Wesson, J. & Campbell, D. J. Tokamaks, Vol. 149 (Oxford University Press, 2011).
Chiu, C.K., Teo, J. C., Schnyder, A. P. & Ryu, S. Classification of topological quantum matter with symmetries. Rev. Mod. Phys. 88, 035005 (2016).
Qin, H., Zhang, R., Glasser, A. S. & Xiao, J. KelvinHelmholtz instability is the result of paritytime symmetry breaking. Phys. Plasmas 26, 032102 (2019).
Fu, Y. & Qin, H. The physics of spontaneous paritytime symmetry breaking in the KelvinHelmholtz instability. New J. Phys. 22, 083040 (2020).
Shen, H., Zhen, B. & Fu, L. Topological band theory for nonHermitian Hamiltonians. Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 146402 (2018).
Gong, Z. et al. Topological phases of nonHermitian systems. Phys. Rev. X 8, 031079 (2018).
Jin, D. et al. Topological magnetoplasmon. Nat. Commun. 7, 13486 (2016).
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy (DEAC0209CH11466). We thank Jeff Parker and Fang Xie for fruitful discussions.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Peer review information Nature Communication thanks the anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Fu, Y., Qin, H. Topological phases and bulkedge correspondence of magnetized cold plasmas. Nat Commun 12, 3924 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467021241893
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467021241893
This article is cited by

Strongly nonlinear topological phases of cascaded topoelectrical circuits
Frontiers of Physics (2023)

Topological invariant and anomalous edge modes of strongly nonlinear systems
Nature Communications (2022)

Modulation instability—rogue wave correspondence hidden in integrable systems
Communications Physics (2022)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.