True polar wander (TPW), or planetary reorientation, is well documented for other planets and moons and for Earth at present day with satellites, but testing its prevalence in Earth’s past is complicated by simultaneous motions due to plate tectonics. Debate has surrounded the existence of Late Cretaceous TPW ca. 84 million years ago (Ma). Classic palaeomagnetic data from the Scaglia Rossa limestone of Italy are the primary argument against the existence of ca. 84 Ma TPW. Here we present a new high-resolution palaeomagnetic record from two overlapping stratigraphic sections in Italy that provides evidence for a ~12° TPW oscillation from 86 to 78 Ma. This observation represents the most recent large-scale TPW documented and challenges the notion that the spin axis has been largely stable over the past 100 million years.
True polar wander (TPW) is the reorientation of a planet or moon in order to align the body’s greatest nonhydrostatic principal axis of inertia (Imax) with the spin axis1,2,3,4. On Earth, TPW is achieved by wholesale rotation of the solid, silicate Earth (mantle and crust) around the liquid outer core. As Earth’s magnetic pole is tied primarily to rotationally induced excitations of the outer core, the magnetic poles remain aligned with the rotation axis through a TPW event. Thus, palaeomagnetic data record TPW as the coherent, simultaneous motion of all coeval rocks about a single equatorial Euler pole defined by Earth’s minimum moment of inertia (Imin). Palaeomagnetic sampling of a continuous sedimentary succession is an effective single-locality test of TPW as it eliminates potential caveats such as differential remagnetization and tectonic structure5,6.
The possibility of Late Cretaceous TPW is hotly debated7,8,9,10. One TPW rotation has been proposed to occur between the emplacement of two seamounts with Ar-Ar ages overlapping at ca. 84 Ma and palaeomagnetic poles discordant by 16° ± 3° (refs. 9,10). It has been asserted, however, that classic palaeomagnetic data from the correlative Gubbio and Moria sections of Scaglia Rossa limestone do not permit ca. 84 Ma TPW7. Irrespective of the quality of the original data, an analysis that calculates only three average inclinations from 90 to 75 Ma7 does not constitute a robust test of a comparatively rapid11 process. But the reliability of those old (however seminal) data12,13 is questionable for directional studies8. In particular, the Gubbio and Moria data pre-date least-squares analysis of palaeomagnetic data14, the use of controlled-atmosphere thermal demagnetization, and the measurement by sensitive superconducting magnetometers.
In this work, we present >1000 palaeomagnetic data from the Scaglia Rossa limestone as a rigorous test of the ca. 84 Ma TPW event. Samples were collected from two parallel stratigraphic sections as a test of reproducibility. Modern demagnetization and analytical palaeomagnetic methods were employed, including state-of-the-art rock magnetic experiments that shine new light on the origin of the stable palaeomagnetic remanences of the Scaglia Rossa limestone. Both stratigraphic sections definitively confirm the existence of ca. 84 Ma TPW. Furthermore, our new high-resolution record suggests not only a single TPW shift at this time, but a “roundtrip” TPW oscillation where the pole excurses and then returns back to its original pole position.
Samples were collected from stratigraphically correlative sections at Apiro and Furlo in Italy (Supplementary Fig. 1) at typical stratigraphic intervals of 5, 10, 25, 50, or 100 cm (Supplementary Fig. 2). At Apiro, the R1 and R2 members of the Scaglia Rossa are devoid of slumps and are lithologically homogenous apart from radiolarian chert beds in the R1 member. Only the homogenous background lithology of pelagic limestone was sampled for palaeomagnetic analysis. At Furlo, sampling was limited to strata in between slumping events known to anomalously rotate declination due to rotation about a local vertical axis15. Furthermore, stylolitic “pseudo-bedding” that characterizes the bedding style of the Scaglia Rossa at Gubbio and elsewhere in the Umbria–Marche basin16 is absent at Apiro, and less pronounced at Furlo (Supplementary Fig. 2), suggesting the sedimentary rocks of our sections are less tectonically modified than others.
We used traditional palaeomagnetic methods for analysis on an automated system17 and employed a detailed thermal demagnetization scheme (conducted in a controlled nitrogen atmosphere) to facilitate separation of magnetic components (Methods). The reliability and quality of Scaglia Rossa palaeomagnetism is well known12,13,15,16. Previous studies on similar sedimentary rocks generally report stable behavior up to ~570 °C, indicative of magnetite being the predominant remanence carrier despite the red color of the Scaglia Rossa imparted by fine-grained authigenic hematite18. First-order reversal curve (FORC) distributions are dominated by the “central ridge” (Fig. 1c), which indicates negligible magnetostatic interaction among magnetic grains and is interpreted to result from a chain structure of bacterially formed magnetite19. Additional rock magnetic experiments indicating a similar magnetic mineralogy for all lithologies and magnetization directions are presented in Supplementary Figs. 3 and 4. The presence and dominance of magnetofossils in the Scaglia Rossa limestone can account for its exceptional palaeomagnetic stability (Fig. 1a, b), making it an ideal candidate for testing ca. 84 Ma TPW.
Virtually all Scaglia Rossa samples carry low-stability magnetic overprints coincident with the present local field, consistently removed after thermal demagnetization to 150 °C, matching remanence expectations for either secondary goethite or a viscous overprint carried by large magnetite grains (Supplementary Fig. 5 and Supplementary Data 2). After removal of the overprint, the characteristic magnetizations were then typically stable up to 500–580 °C indicative of magnetite. All characteristic remanent magnetizations were determined by linear decay to the origin or stable-end point behavior on orthogonal demagnetization diagrams and exhibit striking palaeomagnetic stability for sedimentary rocks (Fig. 1a, b). The isolation of primary Late Cretaceous remanences is collectively supported by the successful removal of present local field overprints up to 150–180 °C (Fig. 1a, b and Supplementary Fig. 5), magnetostratigraphy matching the geologic time scale (Fig. 2 and Supplementary Figs. 6 and 7), and the success of fold tests conducted in the area13.
Exploring the possibility of long-term variations in palaeomagnetic direction, we calculate the average inclination and declination of Italy in one-million-year intervals (Fig. 2) and its associated palaeopole path (Fig. 3). Palaeomagnetic data from Italy must be locally restored relative to the larger African plate, which also must be tectonically reconstructed in order to test the TPW hypothesis (Methods). Contrary to the claim that the Scaglia Rossa limestone does not show significant variations in inclination7, our new data show a ~12° oscillation (~24° total) between 86 and 79 Ma (~7 million years [Myr]; Fig. 3) that temporarily both rotated and translated Italy to lower latitudes during C33r, with coeval changes to both declination and inclination, respectively (Fig. 2). Although the excursion broadly overlaps with magnetochron C33r, we note that the peak offset occurs during C34n, arguing against the idea that magnetic polarity contaminates the signal. Furthermore, our demagnetization methods are detailed enough to resolve and remove overprints (Fig. 1a, b and Supplementary Fig. 5) and directional transitions observed across magnetic reversals are smooth instead of sudden (Fig. 2), as would be the case if directional shifts were artifacts of unresolved normal polarity overprints.
Inclination shallowing due to sediment compaction is a common problem in sedimentary palaeomagnetism that must be considered to explain the temporary lowering of inclination. Inclination shallowing usually stems from the electrostatic attraction of small magnetite lathes to clay flocs or hematite platelets having a preferred flow-regime or gravity-induced directionality20. But with the Scaglia Rossa, we are not relying on nanoscale magnetite laths or on hematite platelets for our magnetization, rather, single-domain biogenic magnetite grains (Fig. 1c). The Scaglia Rossa magnetofossils may well be independent of the clay associated or grain shape anisotropic effects that commonly cause inclination shallowing. Nonetheless, to test for burial compaction, we conducted anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility (AMS) experiments. Previous AMS data at Apiro and Furlo reveal a minor clustering of kmin axes and girdle of kmax and kint axes, implying a mildly oblate compaction fabric in the plane of bedding21. Our new data from the same sections confirm a minor oblate flattening in the plane of bedding generally for all samples. However, no correlation between AMS and inclination is found when the data are cross-plotted (Supplementary Fig. 8), suggesting inclination shallowing is unlikely to explain the inclination variation within a section. Finally, the distinct data groupings through time (Fig. 2) differ substantially in declination, not just inclination, so inclination shallowing cannot entirely account for the systematic dispersion of the Scaglia Rossa data.
As predicted by the ca. 84 Ma TPW hypothesis9, the largest polar excursion observed in Italy occurs between 84 and 82 Ma (Fig. 3). Our Italy data thus do not refute the ca. 84 Ma TPW hypothesis9. The amplitude of the ~12° ± 3° excursion of Italy palaeopoles (Fig. 3) furthermore overlaps within uncertainty the 16° ± 3° dispersion of Pacific Plate palaeopoles9,10. TPW is able to explain the coincident excursions in both inclination and declination observed in Italy (Fig. 2). Due to the palaeogeographic position of Italy relative to the TPW axis near Africa22, Italy should have experienced both latitude change (inclination) as well as rotation (declination) during the TPW excursion, as is observed. The TPW axis (Imin) is defined by the triaxial or nearly prolate shape of the nonhydrostatic Earth due to long-wavelength mantle convection23,24, which is thought to be stable over the past 300 Myr during the Pangaea supercontinent cycle22. The east-west longitudinal orientation of the polar motion observed in the Late Cretaceous in Italy is similar to that of earlier Mesozoic TPW22 as well as the present-day TPW axis4,25, as expected (Fig. 3). Also, as observed elsewhere5 and in high-resolution detail here (Figs. 2 and 3), TPW is typically modeled as a back-and-forth “roundtrip” oscillation where the pole shifts away, but then snaps backs to the original pole position23. Whether the “figure 8” path exhibited by both Mesozoic TPW oscillations (Fig. 3) is significant remains to be tested with modeling.
A cumulative “roundtrip” amplitude of ~24° for the TPW oscillation observed in Italy over ~8 Myr (86–78 Ma) implies a TPW rate of ~3.0° Myr−1. The present viscosity of the lower mantle sets a ~2.4° Myr−1 “speed limit” for TPW as the solid Earth must conform to the migrating hydrostatic bulge for reorientation to proceed11. Our data are thus broadly compatible with this theoretical speed limit, but may suggest that the Cretaceous mantle was different than today. As detectable secular mantle cooling has occurred since Late Cretaceous time26, the TPW speed limit could have been higher in the past with a hotter, less viscous mantle11. Despite consistency between the Late Cretaceous petrological26 and palaeomagnetic data, the large uncertainties in the parameters of the mantle properties from which the TPW speed limit is determined11 renders the implication for a hotter mantle at this time as constrained by TPW rate ambiguous at best. Instead, older, and potentially faster TPW events24, should be used to constrain such a problem. The slightly above average speed of ca. 84 Ma TPW could rather be explained by a larger mantle convective forcing than normal.
Our observed TPW oscillation of ~12° amplitude at this age can be used to parameterize models to better assess Earth’s nonhydrostatic figure and the relative effects of sinking slabs and rising mantle plumes on Earth’s rotational stability. Using the well-constrained history of recently subducted slabs, the modeled effect on Earth’s nonhydrostatic geoid that controls the location of the spin axis (and thus TPW) predicts a large and rapid TPW event between 80 and 90 Ma27, precisely when our observations indicate that TPW in fact occurred (Figs. 2 and 3). This general agreement thus begins to reconcile the apparent discrepancy between TPW observations and the model predictions at this age27. Nonetheless, despite the striking consistency in suggesting large-scale (>10°) TPW between 80 and 90 Ma, there is a notable contrast in the amplitudes and styles of the observed and predicted TPW events. Our data suggest a ~12° TPW oscillation, whereas the model27 predicts a ~90° TPW shift. Since the model considers only TPW excitation from subduction27, we speculate that plumes rising through the mantle at this time may have counteracted the effect of sinking slabs and thereby reduced the amplitude of TPW excited by subduction alone as plumes have the opposite effect of slabs on Earth’s geoid kernel27. Plumes leaving the core-mantle boundary (e.g., the Réunion hotspot later producing the ca. 66 Ma Deccan Traps) or those reaching the surface (e.g., the Marion hotspot producing the 84–91 Ma Morondova large igneous province) at this age, both of deep mantle origins and occurring in the Indian Ocean of the southern hemisphere28, would have been well positioned to have potentially counteracted the effect of subducting slabs largely in the North Pacific27. Such complications aside, on both a theoretical and empirical basis, Late Cretaceous TPW represents the youngest known large-scale TPW event in Earth history24.
TPW predicts that all continents rotated at this age and about a common TPW axis consistent with palaeogeography. Although the Pacific Plate exhibits a polar shift of similar age and magnitude to Italy9,10, uncertainty of the palaeogeographic reconstruction of the Pacific Plate precludes testing the consistency of the palaeolongitude of the TPW axis. Palaeopoles of this age from Europe and North America, continents that are both well resolved palaeogeographically with restoration of Atlantic seafloor spreading, both circumscribe polar excursions of similar magnitude as well as similar coplanar orientation to Italy, preliminarily passing the global reproducibility test of the TPW hypothesis (Supplementary Fig. 9; ref. 9). Unlike earlier Mesozoic TPW events that are substantiated by the palaeomagnetic records of multiple or even most continents22,29,30,31,32, Late Cretaceous TPW is nonetheless only documented for Italy, the Pacific Plate, and, with less confidence, a few other regions. The relative paucity of sampling is not surprising, however, provided the rapidity of the proposed event. Future testing of coeval stratigraphies around the world should be conducted at commensurate resolution on palaeomagnetic targets of comparable quality. It should also be noted that the older portion of the TPW oscillation depicted here has only been documented in Italy and thus requires additional testing in particular.
Even though this time interval has been examined by other palaeomagnetic studies, their sampling resolutions were likely insufficient to identify the TPW oscillation and thus aliased it. Our study collected an order of magnitude more samples than is typically done in high-quality palaeomagnetic studies over a 10 Myr interval, i.e., ~1000 samples instead of ~100. Despite arguing for multiple TPW events between 300 and 100 Ma (Fig. 3), global appraisals of TPW have not identified any TPW events in the past 100 Myr22,33. However, such analyses employ both 10-Myr averaging of palaeomagnetic data and use data from multiple continents to generate global apparent polar wander (APW) paths. Indeed, TPW should be a global phenomenon, which is why such an approach is taken. Nonetheless, while this method may be adequate for identifying larger amplitude TPW shifts (20–30°) occurring over longer amounts of time (≥10 Myr), it would smooth out and/or obscure the signal of a smaller amplitude TPW shift (~10°) over a shorter amount of time (≤10 Myr). By contrast, as allowed by our increased sampling resolution, our study employs 1-Myr averaging of data from one continent. Although TPW for the past 100 Myr may be of smaller amplitude34,35 than earlier TPW shifts24, our high-resolution palaeomagnetic study would suggest that one cannot rule out the possibility of rapid TPW shifts of small amplitude (<20°) in the most recent past.
Geologic setting and sampling
The Umbria–Marche pelagic succession of central Italy is the classic locality for the Cretaceous-Palaeogene (K/Pg) extinction36 and several of the oceanic anoxic events, where they occur within rhythmically bedded limestones, marls, and cherts37,38. This study focuses on a ~15-Myr interval between these dramatic Late Cretaceous events. Much previous work has been done to date the Umbria–Marche succession. The Gubbio section (Supplementary Fig. 1) spans all of Late Cretaceous time and serves as a standard for magnetostratigraphic sampling12. Although relatively stratigraphically condensed, a subsequently sampled magnetostratigraphy at Moria (Supplementary Fig. 1) confirms the magnetic reversal pattern observed at Gubbio and on the seafloor, as well as serving as a positive palaeomagnetic fold test validating the Scaglia Rossa palaeopole13.
Both the classic Gubbio and Moria sections, unfortunately, are tectonically disturbed with faults and slumps, often causing cryptic block rotations vital to avoid15,39,40, at the base of the R2 Member of the Scaglia Rossa Formation, our target interval. We sampled two correlative stratigraphic sections in distinct thrust panels (Supplementary Figs. 1 and 2). The Apiro section (43.38°N, 13.155°E) spans the entire ~10-Myr-long magnetochron 33 and has been studied previously for rock magnetic fabrics41. The Furlo section (43.64°N, 12.71°E) is exposed on the western flank of a large anticline and was previously sampled for magnetostratigraphy15. By correlation, the Furlo record fills in a ~2-Myr gap in lower C33r at Apiro. Furlo also offers reproducibility tests with Apiro.
Throughout the Umbria–Marche basin, the Scaglia Rossa was deposited above the carbonate compensation depth, but below storm wave base; estimates of depth range from 1500 to 2000 m (refs. 42,43,). The basin formed on the thinned continental margin of Adria, which was tectonically active as evidenced by synsedimentary slumping, faulting, and turbidity currents39,44. The presence of active tectonics has complicated the retrieval of a continuous magnetostratigraphic record during Santonian–Campanian time in the basin: of measured sections of Scaglia Rossa, half exhibit soft sedimentary deformation accommodated by a marly layer occurring around the C33n-C33r reversal throughout the basin. U/Pb constraints from across the Umbria–Marche Apennines45 allows correlation from the basin (e.g., Gubbio) to the southern platform46.
The Scaglia Rossa is composed of three principal lithologies (light pink pelagic limestone, nodular or tabular chert of assorted colors, and dark pink marl), sometimes deposited in cycles that are striking at the outcrop scale. Only the homogenous background lithology of pelagic limestone was sampled for palaeomagnetic analysis (Supplementary Fig. 2). The dominant lithology, a white to light pink pelagic biomicrite, is made up of abundant foraminifera tests suspended in a nannofossil (largely coccolith) matrix, with minor calcified, sub-spherical radiolarian skeletons. The partially silicified nodular and tabular chert layers of various colors are instead made of an abundant assemblage of radiolarians suspended in a microcrystalline quartz matrix and few silicified, planktonic foraminifera tests that are often pyritized.
Apiro has never been studied within a stratigraphic context. Red chert layers near the base of the exposure can be lithologically identifiable as the top of the R2 Member of the Scaglia Rossa. Apiro contains all of the Scaglia Rossa Formation, with exception of a ~30-m-thick covered interval near the base of C33r. Apiro is stratigraphically expanded and devoid of stylolitic “pseudo-bedding,” which characterizes the bedding style of the Scaglia Rossa elsewhere in the Umbria–Marche basin47. Correlation to the relatively constant thin beds of Furlo reveals much thicker beds and faster sediment accumulation at Apiro. Turbidites and evidence for resedimenation are not found at Apiro as in Furlo. Data from Furlo can be imported into the Apiro record in order to fill in the missing C34n-C33r reversal interval (Supplementary Fig. 2 and Fig. 3). Combined, our composite Italy section spans 4 geomagnetic reversals, 7 biozones, and ~15 Myr (88–73 Ma; see section below for details of age modeling).
Oriented palaeomagnetic cores 2.54 cm in diameter were drilled on site using a portable, gasoline-powered, diamond-tipped coring drill with both air- and water-cooled functionality. All 1090 samples were hand-drilled cores except for 24 block samples. Sun-compass observations were made whenever possible to check the magnetic compass, and to independently measure the local magnetic deviation, which, at ~1°E, is indistinguishable from the International Geomagnetic Reference Field model for the sites. Remanent magnetization measurements were made with a 2G EnterprisesTM DC-SQuID magnetometer with background noise sensitivity of 5 × 10−12 Am2 per axis at both the California Institute of Technology and Yale University. The magnetometers are equipped with computer-controlled, online alternating-field (AF) demagnetization coils and an automated vacuum pick-and-put sample-changing array17. Samples and instruments are housed in a magnetically shielded room with residual fields <100 nT throughout the demagnetization procedure and <5 nT in the sense region.
After measurement of natural remanent magnetization (NRM), all samples were demagnetized cryogenically in a low magnetic field-shielded liquid nitrogen bath in an attempt to help unblock larger multi-domain magnetite grains by “zero-field” cycling through the Verwey transition near 77 °K (ref. 48), and typically this step was repeated a second time. Next, all samples were thermally demagnetized in steps of 4–25 °C, starting at 50 °C and going up to 590 °C (or until thoroughly demagnetized or unstable, usually 20–30 thermal steps per specimen) in a magnetically shielded furnace (±2 °C relative error) in a flowing nitrogen atmosphere. After each demagnetization step, automated three-axis measurements were made in both sample-up and sample-down orientations, and samples with circular standard deviation >10° were rerun manually.
Magnetic components were computed for each sample using principal component analysis14 as implemented in PaleoMag OS X49 (Fig. 1a, b). See main text for discussion of results. Palaeomagnetic poles from various previous works are compiled and compared using the software programs GPlates (www.gplates.org) (Fig. 3) and Paleomac50 (Supplementary Fig. 9). To first order, the records between Apiro and Furlo are consistent with each other as demonstrated in Fig. 2. Nonetheless, due to appreciable uncertainties in the different local tectonic restorations and degrees of inclination shallowing in the two sections (see below), we do not combine the data from the two sections when calculating palaeopoles. Instead, we use exclusively poles from Apiro with the exception of the 85 and 84 Ma poles from Furlo that fill the temporal gap at Apiro (Supplementary Fig. 2 and Supplementary Data 1).
Non-destructive rock magnetic experiments were performed on seven samples of the Scaglia Rossa limestone (six samples from Apiro and one sample from Furlo) using a 2G Enterprises SQuID magnetometer following the RAPID protocols, and analyzed using the RAPID Matlab scripts17 (https://sourceforge.net/projects/paleomag/). Our protocol includes measurements of AF demagnetization of the NRM, acquisition and demagnetization, anhysteretic remanent magnetization (ARM) acquisition and demagnetization, isothermal remanent magnetization (IRM) acquisition and demagnetization, and backfield IRM acquisition. These analyses can be used to observe fundamental properties that can be used to distinguish different ferromagnetic minerals. The destructive rock magnetic technique of KappaBridge thermal susceptibility was measured on a neighboring specimen using an AGICO MFK1-FA KappaBridge and reduced in Matlab. AMS measurements were conducted using an AGICO MFK1-FA KappaBridge.
FORC diagrams provide information on the distribution of coercivities (Hc) and local interaction fields (Hu) for a magnetic grain assemblage in a sample51,52. In particular, they are used for detecting biogenic magnetite in sediments53,54; the occurrence of a sharp ridge along the Hc axis with little vertical spread, called “the central ridge,” is diagnostic, which indicates negligible magnetostatic interaction among magnetic grains and is interpreted to result from a chain structure of bacterial magnetite grains19,55. FORC measurements were made on limestone samples from a section at San Severino near Apiro (C33r/C33n reversal age) using an alternating gradient magnetometer (MicroMag 2900, Princeton Measurements Corporation) at the Geological Survey of Japan, National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology. Field spacing was 0.5 mT, and 191 FORCs were measured, with interaction field (Hu) between −15 and 15 mT and coercivity (Hc) from 0 to 60 mT. The maximum applied field was 1.4 T. The averaging time for each data point was 200 ms. The FORCinel software56 was used for data processing and the VARIFORC algorithm57 was used for smoothing (Sc0 = 4, Sb0 = 3, Sc1 = Sb1 = 7).
Previous rock magnetic data12 are consistent with a fine-grained source of remanent magnetization, either biogenic or detrital single-domain magnetite. The AMS in a rock can be geometrically depicted as a triaxial ellipsoid minimum (kmin), intermediate (kint), and maximum (kmax) principal axes. Subsequent deformation associated with compaction after deposition modifies an original rock fabric. Previous AMS data at Apiro and Furlo reveal a minor clustering of kmin axes and girdle of kmax and kint axes, implying a mildly oblate compaction fabric in the plane of bedding21. Compared with previous AMS results for the Scaglia Rossa limestone21, our new data from these same sections (Apiro and Furlo) confirm a minor oblate flattening in the plane of bedding generally for all samples. However, no correlation between AMS and inclination is found when the data are cross-plotted (Supplementary Fig. 6), suggesting that differential inclination shallowing cannot account for the systematic stratigraphic variation in inclination (Fig. 2).
Rock magnetic experiments highlight the presence of a non-interacting mid-coercivity phase interpreted to be magnetite, mixed with a higher coercivity phase in differing proportions interpreted as hematite (Supplementary Figs. 3 and 4). Six samples through the Apiro section (across the proposed TPW event) are very similar, dominantly magnetite with a small amount of hematite, while the one sample studied from Furlo has a higher proportion of hematite. Overall, our results agree with previous rock magnetic data12 suggesting magnetite mixed with varying amounts of hematite. The Lowrie–Fuller test suggests that these phases are single domain or pseudo single domain, although results may be skewed by hematite for the sample from Furlo (Supplementary Fig. 3). ARM acquisition highlights the samples contain non-interacting particles close to the magnetotactic bacteria endmember suggesting the possibility of magnetofossils (Supplementary Fig. 3). The Fuller test suggests that the magnetization carried by the magnetite is detrital in origin, highlighting that any hematization did not also precipitate magnetite (Supplementary Fig. 3).
KappaBridge thermal susceptibility experiments on a sample from Apiro (Supplementary Fig. 4) show a minor drop in coercivity at 580 °C, the Curie temperature of magnetite, and an irreversible cooling curve with strong increase in susceptibility and a slight shift in Curie temperature. No Verwey transition is seen in the sample, but even a few weight percent titanium can cause the transition to be shifted to lower temperatures beyond the range of the Kappabridge58, although the substitution of titanium would be surprising in biogenic magnetite.
The FORC distributions are dominated by the “central ridge” (Fig. 1c), which indicates that magnetofossils are the main constituent of the magnetic mineral assemblage. Biogenic magnetite, then, may be the answer to age-old mystery of what accounts for the remarkable stability of Scaglia Rossa remanent magnetization.
Aliquots of palaeomagnetic samples from both Apiro and Furlo sections were prepared for biostratigraphic foraminifera identification. First occurrences and last occurrences were identified following a new age-calibrated biostratigraphic zonation59. Planktonic foraminifera were studied in washed residues. Preparation included gentle crushing, cold acetolysis with acetic acid (80%) following the method of Lirer60, sieving through a 63 μm mesh, 1–2 h cleaning in an ultrasonic cleaner, and drying at 60 °C. The cold acetolysis method enables extraction of generally well-identifiable foraminifera even from indurated limestone. This offers the possibility of accurate taxonomic determination and detailed analysis of foraminiferal assemblages.
Age modeling of the sampled sections using dated magnetic reversal boundaries provides both time scales for each section and new biostratigraphic ages for global chronostratigraphic correlation (Supplementary Fig. 6). The Apiro and Furlo sections both span the C34n-C33r-C33n interval, where C34n-C33r is preserved at Furlo, C33r-C33n is present at both sections, and the top of C33n is identified at Apiro. At Apiro, we identify the C33r-C33n reversal within less than a half of a meter (Supplementary Fig. 7), but a substantial covered interval (from 50 to 83 m) masks the C34n-C33r reversal (Supplementary Figs. 2 and 7). At Furlo, the C34n-C33r reversal is documented within less than a meter (Supplementary Fig. 7). Following convention, ages for stratigraphic heights occurring between two dated levels are determined by linear interpolation, whereas ages of strata above and below dated levels are determined by linear extrapolation. The assumption of constant sediment accumulation rates is applied for each bracketed time segment.
Updated ages are used for the top and bottom of C33r, requiring recalculation of foraminiferal zonal boundary ages within chron 33. A refined age of 80.32 Ma for the C33r-C33n reversal boundary from U/Pb ages on zircon in bentonites in the Pierre Shale is used61. The base of C33r, the end of the Cretaceous long normal superchron, is radiometrically unconstrained62, but cyclostratigraphy provides an astronomical calibration37. Ages of biostratigraphic boundaries are updated in Petrizzo et al.59; ages of those zonal boundaries that are calibrated by our work are provided in Supplementary Fig. 6.
Age models for each section are shown in Supplementary Fig. 6. A rather uniform sediment accumulation rate of ~10 m Myr−1 is thought to characterize much of the pelagic Umbria–Marche basin63. Dating of our sections generally supports this classic interpretation. Compared with Gubbio, or any other section for that matter, Apiro is stratigraphically expanded. Increased sediment accumulation rates may indicate that the eastern thrust in which Apiro is exposed (Supplementary Fig. 1) represented an intrabasinal depocenter that sourced turbidite events recorded elsewhere (e.g., Furlo39,64).
Local tectonic restoration of northern Umbria
The Umbrian path of palaeopoles has traditionally been regarded to have an “African” character: once relative rotation during Neogene time is restored, the two APW paths are nearly identical65,66. Northern Umbria is thought to have rotated counterclockwise relative to southern Umbria (and stable Africa) since Mesozoic time. Umbrian tectonic deformation is attributable to oroclinal bending and/or local or regional tectonic rotation about a sub-vertical axis in the Apennines67,68. van der Voo66 follows Vandenburg et al.69 who propose a 25° clockwise restoration of Northern Umbria into an African reference frame. Independently, Channell et al.70 proposed a slightly smaller restoration of 22° clockwise, and subsequently rounded that estimate to 20° (ref. 65). Most recently, van Hinsbergen et al.71 developed a kinematic model for Mediterranean tectonic evolution using Euler rotations guided by palaeomagnetic and other datasets. For 80 Ma, northern Umbria (their plate #3980) restores to Africa with these Euler parameters: 64.75°N, 9.89°E, 4.01°CW. Within the northern Umbrian plate, local rotations are additionally possible. By comparing our declination means to the predicted values from van Hinsbergen et al.71 and the global APW path of Torsvik et al.72, we find minimal offset when Apiro is restored an additional +5°CW about a local axis, and Furlo +12°CW (Fig. 2). Our results add to abundant palaeomagnetic evidence for the orocline hypothesis of a near-linear belt that has been secondarily bent73. After we restore the palaeopoles from the Apennines to Africa with these rotations, we then apply the South Africa plate reconstruction to the palaeomagnetic reference frame for 80 Ma72 to test the TPW hypothesis (Fig. 3). Also in the comparison of the Apiro and Furlo records (Fig. 2), Furlo inclinations are uniformly lower than those of Apiro, implying more inclination shallowing at Furlo than Apiro, and consistent with the occurrence of stylolitic pseudo-bedding at the former but not the latter (Supplementary Fig. 2). A flattening factor of 0.85 was applied to Furlo inclinations, a value that optimally matches inclinations from the two sections where they overlap in time (Supplementary Data 1). This flattening factor is similar to elongation/inclination analysis74 applied to the Furlo dataset (Supplementary Fig. 10).
The palaeomagnetic data from this study are available in the online content of this paper and from the Open Science Framework (https://osf.io/hqzdy/?view_only=2c5ab4f569d842b8a7678b8bfd1a27dd). Magnetometer measurements are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Gold, T. Instability of the Earth’s axis of rotation. Nature 175, 526–529 (1955).
Perron, J. T., Mitrovica, J. X., Manga, M., Matsuyama, I. & RIchards, M. A. Evidence for an anceint martian ocean in the topography of deformed shorelines. Nature 447, 840–843 (2007).
Schenk, P., Matsuyama, I. & Nimmo, F. True polar wander on Europa from global-scale small-circle depressions. Nature 453, 368–371 (2008).
Schuh, H., Nagel, S. & Seitz, T. Linear drift and periodic variations observed in long time series of polar motion. J. Geod. 74, 701–710 (2001).
Maloof, A. C. et al. Combined paleomagnetic, isotopic, and stratigraphic evidence for true polar wander from the Neoproterozoic Akademikerbreen Group, Svalbard, Norway. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 118, 1099–1124 (2006).
Mitchell, R. N., Evans, D. A. D. & Kilian, T. M. Rapid Early Cambrian rotation of Gondwana. Geology 38, 755–758 (2010).
Cottrell, R. D. & Tarduno, J. A. Late Cretaceous true polar wander: not so fast (comment). Science 288, 2283a (2000).
Sager, W. W. & Koppers, A. A. P. Late Cretaceous true polar wander: not so fast (response). Science 288, 2283a (2000).
Sager, W. W. & Koppers, A. A. P. Late Cretaceous polar wander of the Pacific plate: evidence of a rapid true polar wander event. Science 287, 455–459 (2000).
Gordon, R. G. Late Cretaceous apparent polar wander of the Pacific Plate; evidence for a rapid shift of the Pacific hotspots with respect to the spin axis. Geophys. Res. Lett. 10, 709–712 (1983).
Tsai, V. C. & Stevenson, D. J. Theoretical constraints on true polar wander. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 112, B05415 (2007).
Lowrie, W. & Alvarez, W. Late Cretaceous geomagnetic polarity sequence: detailed rock and palaeomagnetic studies of the Scaglia Rossa limestone at Gubbio. Italy Geophys. J. R. Astronomical Soc. 51, 561–581 (1977).
Alvarez, W. & Lowrie, W. Upper Cretaceous palaeomagnetic stratigraphy at Moria (Umbrian Apennines, Italy); verification of the Gubbio section. Geophys. J. R. Astronomical Soc. 55, 1–17 (1978).
Kirschvink, J. L. The least-squares line and plane and the analysis of palaeomagnetic data. Geophys. J. R. Astronomical Soc. 62, 699–718 (1980).
Alvarez, W. & Lowrie, W. Magnetic stratigraphy applied to synsedimentary slumps, turbidites, and basin analysis; the Scaglia Limestone at Furlo (Italy). Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 95, 324–336 (1984).
Alvarez, W., Colacicchi, R. & Montanari, A. Synsedimentary slides and bedding formation in Apennine Pelagic limestones. J. Sediment. Petrol. 55, 720–734 (1985).
Kirschvink, J. L., Kopp, R. E., Raub, T. D., Baumgartner, C. T. & Holt, J. W. Rapid, precise, and high-sensitivity acquisition of paleomagnetic and rock-magnetic data: Development of a low-noise automatic sample changing system for superconducting rock magnetometers. Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst. 9, Q05Y01 (2008).
Channell, J. E. T., Freeman, R., Heller, F. & Lowrie, W. Timing of diagenetic haematite growth in red pelagic limestones from Gubbio (Italy). Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 58, 189–201 (1981).
Li, J., Wu, W., Liu, Q. & Pan, Y. Magnetic anisotropy, magnetostatic interactions and identification of magnetofossils. Geochem. Geophysics Geosystems 13, Q10Z51 (2012).
Kodama, K. P. A successful rock magnetic technique for correcting paleomagnetic inclination shallowing: case study of the Nacimiento Formation, New Mexico, USA. J. Geophys. Res. 102, 5193–5205 (1997).
Lowrie, W. & Hirt, A. M. Anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility in the Scaglia Rossa pelagic limestone. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 82, 349–356 (1987).
Steinberger, B. & Torsvik, T. H. Absolute plate motions and true polar wander in the absence of hotspot tracks. Nature 452, 620–623 (2008).
Creveling, J. R., Mitrovica, J. X., Chan, N. H., Latychev, K. & Matsuyama, I. Mechanisms for oscillatory true polar wander. Nature 491, 244–248 (2012).
Mitchell, R. N. True polar wander and supercontinent cycles: implications for lithospheric elasticity and the triaxial Earth. Am. J. Sci. 314, 966–979 (2014).
Pavoni, N. Present true polar wander in the frame of the Geotectonic reference system. Swiss J. Geosci. 101, 629–636 (2008).
Herzberg, C. & Gazel, E. Petrological evidence for secular cooling in mantle plumes. Nature 458, 619–622 (2009).
Steinberger, B., Seidel, M.-L. & Torsvik, T. H. Limited true polar wander as evidence that Earth’s nonhydrostatic shape is persistently triaxial. Geophys. Res. Lett. 44, 2016GL071937 (2017).
Glisovic, P. & Forte, A. M. On the deep-mantle origin of the Deccan Traps. Science 355, 613–616 (2017).
Muttoni, G. & Kent, D. V. Jurassic monster polar shift confirmed by sequential paleopoles from Adria, promontory of Africa. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 124, 3288–3306 (2019).
Fu, R. R., Kent, D. V., Hemming, S. R., Gutierrez, P. & Creveling, J. R. Testing the occurence of Late Jurassic true polar wander using the La Negra volcanics of northern Chile. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 529, 115835 (2020).
Kent, D. V., Kjarsgaard, B. A., Gee, J. S., Muttoni, G. & Heaman, L. M. Tracking the Late Jurassic apparent (or true) polar shift in U-Pb-dated kimberlites from cratonic North America (Superior Province of Canada). Geochem. Geophysics Geosystems 16, 983–994 (2015).
Fu, R. R. & Kent, D. V. Anomalous Late Jurassic motion of the Pacific Plate with implications for true polar wander. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 490, 20–30 (2018).
Torsvik, T. H. et al. Deep mantle structures as a reference from for movements in and on the Earth. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA. 111, 8735–8740 (2014).
Woodworth, D. & Gordon, R. G. Paleolatitude of the Hawaiian hot spot since 48 Ma: evidence for a mid-Cenozoic true polar stillstand followed by late Cenozoic true polar wander coincident with Northern Hemisphere glaciation. Geophys. Res. Lett. 45, 632–611,640 (2018).
Petronotis, K. E., Gordon, R. G. & Acton, G. D. A 57 Ma Pacific plate palaeomagnetic pole determined from a skewness analysis of crossings of marine magnetic anomaly 25r. Geophys. J. Int. 118, 529–554 (1994).
Alvarez, L. W., Alvarez, W., Asaro, F. & Michel, H. V. Extraterrestrial cause for the Cretaceous Tertiary extinction. Science 208, 1095–1108 (1980).
Huang, C., Hinnov, L., Fischer, A. G., Grippo, A. & Herbert, T. Astronomical tuning of the Aptian Stage from Italian reference sections. Geology 38, 899–902 (2010).
Mitchell, R. N. et al. Oceanic anoxic cycles? Orbital prelude to the Bonarelli Level (OAE 2). Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 267, 1–16 (2008).
Montanari, A., Chan, L. S. & Alvarez, W. In SEPM Special Publication No 44 (eds Crevello, P., Wilson, J. L., Sarg, R., & Reed, F.) 379–399 (Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, 1989).
Chan, L. S., Montanari, A. & Alvarez, W. Magnetic stratigraphy of the Scaglia Rossa: implications for syndepositional tectonics of the Umbria-Marche Basin. Riv. Ital. Di Paleontologia E Stratigrafia 91, 219–258 (1985).
Hirt, A. M. & Lowrie, W. Paleomagnetism of the Umbrian Marches Orogenic Belt. Tectonophysics 146, 91–103 (1988).
Arthur, M. A., & Premoli Silva, I. Development of widespread organic carbon-rich strata in the Mediterranean Tethys. In Nature and Origin of Cretaceous Carbon-rich Facies (eds Schlanger, S. O. & Cita, M. B.) 7–54 (Academic Press, 1982).
Kuhnt, W. Agglutinated foraminifera of western Mediterranean Upper Cretaceous pelagic limestones (Umbrian Apennines, Italy, and Betic Cordillera, southern Spain). Micropaleontology 36, 297–330 (1990).
Montanari, A. & Koeberl, C. Impact Stratigraphy: The Italian Record. Lecture Notes in Earth Sciences. Vol. 93 (Springer, 2000).
Bernoulli, D. et al. Volcanic ash layers in the Upper Cretaceous of the Central Apennines and a numerical age for the early Campanian. Int. J. Earth Sci. 93, 384–399 (2004).
Lampert, S. A., Lowrie, W., Hirt, A. M., Bernoulli, D. & Mutti, M. Magnetic and sequence stratigraphy of redeposited upper Cretaceous limestones in the Montagna della Maiella, Abruzzi, Italy. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 150, 79–93 (1997).
Alvarez, W., Colacicchi, R. & Montanari, A. Synsedimentary slides and bedding formation in Apennice Pelagic Limestones. J. Sediment. Petrol. 55, 720–734 (1985).
Muxworthy, A. R. & Williams, W. Low-temperature cooling behavior of single-domain magnetite: forcing of the crystallographic axes and interactions. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 111 (2006).
Jones, C. H. User-driven integrated software lives: “Paleomag” paleomagnetics analysis on the Macintosh. Comput. Geosci. 28, 1145–1151 (2002).
Cogne, J. P. PaleoMac; a MacintoshTM application for treating paleomagnetic data and making plate reconstructions. Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst. 4, 8 (2003).
Roberts, A. P., Heslop, D., Zhao, X. & Pike, C. R. Understanding fine magnetic particle systems through use of first-order reversal curve diagrams. Rev. Geophys. 52, 557–602 (2014).
Roberts, A. P., Pike, C. R. & Verosub, K. L. First-order reversal curve diagrams: a new tool for characterizing the magnetic properties of natural samples. J. Geophys. Res. 105, 28461–28475 (2001).
Roberts, A. P., Chang, L., Heslop, D., Florindo, F. & Larrasoana, J. C. Searching for single domain magnetite in the “pseudo-single-domain” sedimentary haystack: Implications of biogenic magnetite preservation for sediment magnetism and relative paleointensity determinations. J. Geophys. Res. 117, B08104 (2012).
Yamazaki, T. & Ikehara, M. Origin of magnetic mineral concentration variation in the Southern Ocean. Paleoceanography 27, PA2206 (2012).
Egli, R., Chen, A. P., Winklhofer, M., Kodama, K. & Horng, C.-S. Detection of non-interacting single domain particles using first-order reversal curve diagrams. Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst. 11, Q01Z11 (2010).
Harrison, R. J. & Feinberg, J. M. An improved algorithm for calculating first-order reversal curve distributions using locally weighted regression smoothing. Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst. 9, Q05016 (2008).
Egli, R. VARIFORC: an optimized protocol for calculating non-regular first-order reversal curve (FORC) diagrams. Glob. Planet. Change 110, 302–320 (2013).
Moskowitz, B. M., Jackson, M. & Kissel, C. Low-temperature magnetic behavior of titanomagnetites. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 157, 141–149 (1998).
Petrizzo, M. R., Falzoni, F. & Premoli Silva, I. Identification of the base of the lower-to-middle Campanian Globotruncana ventricosa Zone: comments on reliability and global correlations. Cretac. Res. 32, 387–405 (2011).
Lirer, F. A new technique for retrieving calcareous microfossils from lithified lime deposits. Micropaleontology 46, 365–369 (2000).
Mitchell, R. N. Late Cretaceous Paleomagnetic Pole for North America from the Pierre Shale: Implications for Baja-British Columbia and True Polar Wander. BA thesis, Carleton College (2007).
Gale, A. S. et al. Definition and global correlation of the Santonian-Campanian boundary. Terra Nova 7, 611–622 (1995).
Arthur, M. A. & Fischer, A. G. Upper Cretaceous-Paleocene magnetic stratigraphy at Gubbio, Italy I. Lithostratgraphy and sedimentology. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 88, 367–371 (1977).
Bice, D. M., Montanari, A. & Rusciadelli, G. Earthquake-induced turbidites triggered by sea level oscillations in the Upper Cretaceous and Paleocene of Italy. Terra Nova 19, 387–392 (2007).
Channell, J. E. T. Paleomagnetic data from Umbria (Italy): implications for the rotation of Adria and Mesozoic apparent polar wander paths. Tectonophysics 216, 365–378 (1992).
van der Voo, R. Paleomagnetism of the Atlantic, Tethys, and Iapetus Oceans. (Cambridge University Press, 1993).
Muttoni, G., Argnani, A., Kent, D. V., Abrahamsen, N. & Cibin, U. Paleomagnetic evidence for Neogene tectonic rotations in the northern Apennines, Italy. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 154, 25–40 (1998).
Muttoni, G. et al. Paleomagnetic evidence for a Neogene two-phase counterclockwise tectonic rotation in the Northern Apennines (Italy). Tectonophysics 326, 241–253 (2000).
Vandenberg, J., Klootwijk, C. T. & Wonders, A. A. H. Late Mesozoic and Cenozoic movements of the Italian Peninsula: further paleomagnetic data from the Umbrian sequence. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 89, 133–150 (1978).
Channell, J. E. T., Lowrie, W., Medizza, F. & Alvarez, W. Paleomagnetism and tectonics In Umbria, Italy. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 39, 199–210 (1978).
van Hinsbergen, D. J. J. et al. Orogenic architecture of the Mediterranean region and kinematic reconstruction of its tectonic evolution since the Triassic. Gondwana Res. 81, 79–229 (2020).
Torsvik, T. H. et al. Phanerozoic polar wander, palaeogeography and dynamics. Earth Sci. Rev. 114, 325–368 (2012).
Carey, S. W. The orocline concept in geotectonics. Pap. Proc. R. Soc. Tasmania 89, 255–288 (1955).
Tauxe, L. & Kent, D. In Timescales of the Paleomagnetic Field Vol. 145 (ed Channell, J. E. T.) 101–116 (American Geophysical Union, 2004).
King, R. F. Remanent magnetism of artifically deposited sediments. Geophys. Suppl. Monthly Not. R. Astronomical Soc. 7.3, 115–134 (1955).
Gradstein, F. M., Ogg, J. G., Schmitz, M. D. & Ogg, G. The Geologic Time Scale 2012. (Elsevier, 2012).
Alessandro Montanari of the Osservatorio Geologico di Coldigioco provided invaluable field support and local geological knowledge. David Bice helped identify the critical outcrop at Apiro Dam. Assistance in the field was provided by Alec Brenner, Emily Carter, Stefan Farsang, Harry Golash, Hima Gudipati, Jessica Heringer, Harrison Miller, Alessandro Montanari, Karen Paczkowski, and Brian Penserini. Laboratory measurements were conducted by Jacob Abrahams, Michael Grappone, Garima Gupta, Marco Cruz-Heredia, Valerie Pietrasz, Kirby Sikes, and Lewis Ward. R.N.M. and J.L.K. were supported by NSF Geophysics grant EAR-1114432. R.N.M. was also supported by the the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 41890833 and 41772192) and the Institute of Geology & Geophysics, CAS, grant no. IGGCAS-201905. This is a contribution to the International Geoscience Programme 648.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Peer review information Nature Communications thanks William Sager and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Mitchell, R.N., Thissen, C.J., Evans, D.A.D. et al. A Late Cretaceous true polar wander oscillation. Nat Commun 12, 3629 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-23803-8
Enigmatic well-characterized remanent magnetization of silicified Lower Devonian rocks from the Tadrart area (Murzuq basin, SE Algeria)
International Journal of Earth Sciences (2022)