Quantitative modeling predicts mechanistic links between pre-treatment microbiome composition and metronidazole efficacy in bacterial vaginosis

Lee, Christina Y.; Cheu, Ryan K.; Lemke, Melissa M.; Gustin, Andrew T.; France, Michael T.; Hampel, Benjamin; Thurman, Andrea R.; Doncel, Gustavo F.; Ravel, Jacques; Klatt, Nichole R.; Arnold, Kelly B.

doi:10.1038/s41467-020-19880-w

Download PDF

Article
Open access
Published: 01 December 2020

Quantitative modeling predicts mechanistic links between pre-treatment microbiome composition and metronidazole efficacy in bacterial vaginosis

Nature Communications volume 11, Article number: 6147 (2020) Cite this article

4910 Accesses
23 Citations
10 Altmetric
Metrics details

Subjects

Abstract

Bacterial vaginosis is a condition associated with adverse reproductive outcomes and characterized by a shift from a Lactobacillus-dominant vaginal microbiota to a polymicrobial microbiota, consistently colonized by strains of Gardnerella vaginalis. Metronidazole is the first-line treatment; however, treatment failure and recurrence rates remain high. To understand complex interactions between Gardnerella vaginalis and Lactobacillus involved in efficacy, here we develop an ordinary differential equation model that predicts bacterial growth as a function of metronidazole uptake, sensitivity, and metabolism. The model shows that a critical factor in efficacy is Lactobacillus sequestration of metronidazole, and efficacy decreases when the relative abundance of Lactobacillus is higher pre-treatment. We validate results in Gardnerella and Lactobacillus co-cultures, and in two clinical cohorts, finding women with recurrence have significantly higher pre-treatment levels of Lactobacillus relative to bacterial vaginosis–associated bacteria. Overall results provide mechanistic insight into how personalized differences in microbial communities influence vaginal antibiotic efficacy.

VagiBIOM Lactobacillus suppository improves vaginal health index in perimenopausal women with bacterial vaginosis: a randomized control trial

Article Open access 09 February 2024

Cysteine dependence of Lactobacillus iners is a potential therapeutic target for vaginal microbiota modulation

Article 03 March 2022

Towards a deeper understanding of the vaginal microbiota

Article 04 March 2022

Introduction

Bacterial vaginosis (BV) is a condition that affects 30–60% of women worldwide^1,2, with negative outcomes including increased susceptibility to sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and greater likelihood for adverse reproductive outcomes^3,4,5,6,7. BV is characterized by a shift from Lactobacillus species (spp.)-dominated vaginal microbiota to a diverse array of anaerobic bacteria including Gardnerella vaginalis (Gv) and Atopobium vaginae^8,9,10. Treatment of symptomatic BV with metronidazole (MNZ) aims to restore Lactobacillus-dominated microbiota; however, recurrence rates remain high, occurring in 57–90% of women who receive treatment^11,12,13,14. Recurrence is associated with several host factors including previous episodes of BV, douching, and sexual activity, but no one factor emerges as a single driver of treatment failure^{11,15,16,17,18}. In addition, associations between vaginal microbiota composition and BV recurrence have been reported but remain poorly understood, with several studies citing conflicting results^15,17,19.

Recent improvements in 16S rRNA sequencing have enhanced the ability to identify and more accurately quantify the composition of the vaginal microbiota in BV^20,21, finding that the transition is frequently associated with an abundance of Lactobacillus iners (Li)^22,23. Despite the association between Li and incidence of BV, identifying how Li dictates communities of optimal and non-optimal microbiota remains elusive, as the vaginal microbiota can change significantly over time and vary between women^24,25,26, especially in the presence of MNZ. The recommended treatment regimen for BV consists of oral or vaginal MNZ oriented toward selectively targeting anaerobic bacteria with little effect on Lactobacillus spp.^27,28, but high variability in efficacy indicates that further study is required to understand the reestablishment of optimal vaginal microbiota ecosystems.

Recent research in the HIV microbicide field has highlighted the importance of vaginal microbiome composition in drug treatment efficacy. In a landmark study, variability in tenofovir (TFV) microbicide efficacy was accounted for by differences in the vaginal microbiome, specifically the presence of the non-target species Gv, which were shown to metabolize TFV²⁹. Likewise for MNZ treatment of Trichomonas vaginalis, a proposed mechanism of treatment failure was decreased bioavailability of MNZ due to the absorbance of the antibiotic by other microorganisms in the vagina^30,31,32. In the context of BV, it is difficult to discern the role of multiple possible interactions that have the potential to influence MNZ efficacy, including MNZ metabolism, resistance, and sequestration across multiple bacterial species that vary considerably among women. We propose that variability in MNZ efficacy may result from underlying differences in MNZ uptake and susceptibility in target and non-target species, and therefore would be highly dependent on individual differences in pre-treatment vaginal microbiota composition.

In this work, we use an ordinary differential equation-based (ODE) model and experimentally measure parameters (MNZ internalization by bacteria, metabolism, and bacterial antibiotic susceptibility) to predict Li and Gv growth dynamics with MNZ treatment. The model demonstrates that a critical factor in MNZ efficacy may be Li sequestration of MNZ, and predicts that MNZ efficacy decreases in individuals with higher pre-treatment amounts of the non-target species, Li, relative to the target species, Gv. We validate this finding with in vitro co-cultures, and extend our analysis to more representative models which illustrate that this behavior is also expected in microbial environments with additional species, interspecies interactions, and strain variability. Finally, by analyzing cervicovaginal samples from BV-infected women treated with MNZ in two distinct cohorts we demonstrate that our initial findings have clinical relevance in characterizing BV treatment outcomes^33,34. Overall, our findings highlight the importance of leveraging quantitative models that evaluate interactions of target bacteria and non-target Lactobacillus spp. with MNZ in improving insight into personalized differences in BV recurrence and treatment failure.

Results

Model predicts Lactobacillus MNZ sequestration influences efficacy

To determine how MNZ treatment efficacy can be altered by bacterial-mediated interactions in vitro, we created an ODE model to predict growth of Gv and Li upon co-culture and treatment with MNZ (Fig. 1a). Parameters for each bacterial species were obtained by least-squares fitting of in vitro kinetic data and dose–response curves for MNZ exposure with each species in monoculture (Supplementary Figs. 1, 2, Supplementary Table 1), before the ODE model was used to predict co-culture conditions with Gv and Li both interacting with extracellular MNZ. The model assumes that Gv and Li internalize or sequester MNZ at rates k_int-Gv and k_int-Li, respectively, and Gv can convert MNZ to the stable metabolite, acetamide, and unknown metabolites at rate k_met³⁵. The model additionally assumes logistic growth at rates k_grow-Gv and k_grow-Li, with carrying capacities of K_Gv and K_Li and growth inhibition by MNZ toxicity at rates k_kill-Gv and k_kill-Li in a dose-dependent manner based on 50% effective concentrations of MNZ on Gv and Li (EC50_Gv, EC50_Li)^36,37. Since MNZ is a pro-drug that is activated when internalized by anaerobic bacteria, the cytotoxicity of MNZ in the model is dependent on the intracellular concentration of MNZ rather than extracellular MNZ concentration; however, we used the external MNZ concentration as the basis for EC50 of internalized MNZ, as experimentally determining the intracellular level of MNZ per cell was challenging and the main goal was to capture the relative sensitivity between Gv and Li^27,28,30,38.

**Fig. 1: Model schematic for bacterial growth dynamics in BV with MNZ treatment.**

To identify model parameters that were most critical for decreasing Gv growth, we performed a 1-dimensional (1D) sensitivity analysis by altering each parameter three orders of magnitude above and below baseline and evaluated Gv growth (Fig. 1b, c). Growth was scaled relative to the predicted growth in an unperturbed (no MNZ) co-culture based on the time point and initial population sizes evaluated and is referred to as percent maximum growth. The sensitivity analysis identified Gv growth as highly dependent on the MNZ internalization/sequestration rate into Li (k_int-Li). A 50-fold increase in this rate increased the growth of Gv from 7.42 to 69.5% its maximal growth upon 48 h treatment with MNZ (Fig. 1c). Likewise, changing the MNZ internalization rate into Gv (k_int-Gv) has similar effects on Li where increasing this rate 50-fold resulted in 89.7% Li’s maximal growth (Supplementary Fig. 3a). Overall, these results illustrate how MNZ efficacy in inhibiting Gv growth is influenced by the competition between each bacterium to internalize the drug.

From this result, we hypothesized that the relative quantity of cells internalizing MNZ (ratio of Gv and Li) could significantly influence growth of both strains. We tested this hypothesis in our computational framework by predicting Gv survival after varying the starting ratio of Gv to Li (Gv:Li ratio) from 1000× fold to 0.001×. Results indicated that altering the initial Gv:Li ratio influences the growth of both Gv and Li. Counterintuitively, Gv survival was high when Li initially outnumbers Gv 1000× and Li growth is optimal when Gv initially exceeds Li 1000× (Fig. 1d). Stated differently, the model suggested that more Gv present at MNZ treatment initiation resulted in a better treatment outcome. The importance of MNZ internalization rate into Li became more apparent as Li became the predominating species, leading to increased growth of Gv (Fig. 1e). This result additionally supports the concept that Li competes with Gv to internalize or sequester extracellular MNZ, as when one bacterial strain is in excess, it likely depletes available extracellular MNZ and decreases the amount of drug internalized by the non-dominating bacterial strain.

We used our model to explore this ratio-dependent behavior over a range of relevant MNZ concentrations extending from 100 to 1600 μg/ml, as estimates for vaginal accumulation range from 20 to >1000 μg/ml (Fig. 2a, b)^39,40. Doses below 100 μg/ml had no effect on Gv or Li growth and doses above 1600 μg/ml exhibited near-complete cell killing for both bacterial strains (Fig. 2a, b); these data are in agreement with experimentally determined effective concentrations of MNZ on Gv and Li cultured individually (Supplementary Fig. 2c, d). However, for doses between 100 and 1600 μg/ml there were significant differences depending on the initial Gv:Li ratio, where MNZ was most efficacious in eliminating Gv when more Gv than Li was present initially.

**Fig. 2: A higher initial Gv:Li ratio improves MNZ treatment efficacy.**

Model validation in Gv and Li co-cultures

We validated these counterintuitive model predictions experimentally in vitro by varying the initial Gv:Li ratios in the presence of 500 μg/ml MNZ and tracking growth for 48 h (Fig. 2c, d). Experimental measurements confirmed model predictions that MNZ efficacy for inhibiting Gv growth decreased when Li was initially dominant (p = 4.67 × 10⁻⁸), and were not significantly different than model predictions (0.001× Gv:Li, p = 0.430; 1000× Gv:Li ratio, p = 0.689, Fig. 3c), with Gv exhibiting a predicted 30.3% and experimental 41.4% ± 13.3% maximal growth after treatment when Li was initially dominant compared to a predicted 2.1% and experimental 9.4% ± 13.8% maximal growth when Gv initially was dominant. Li growth in the presence of 500 μg/ml MNZ was also dependent on the initial Gv:Li ratio, where MNZ inhibited Li growth the most when Li was initially dominant, 7.2% ± 3.9% maximal growth compared to when Gv was initially dominant, 70.5% ± 33.8% (p = 3.29 × 10⁻⁹, Fig. 2d). Notably, the model over-predicted the growth of the Li population when Li was initially dominant (0.001× Gv:Li), where the model prediction of 23.9% maximal growth was over threefold higher than experimentally observed, 7.19% ± 3.91% growth (0.001× Gv:Li experiment vs simulation, p = 1.43 × 10⁻⁵), suggesting efficacy dependence on a high pre-treatment Gv:Li ratio may be even greater than that predicted by the model. Experimental and model predictions of Li growth were not significantly different when Gv was initially dominant (1000× Gv:Li, p = 0.726). Likewise, model predictions of MNZ and MNZ metabolite concentrations were not significantly different from experimental results in cultures starting with a 0.001× Gv:Li ratio (extracellular MNZ: p = 0.255, intracellular MNZ: p = 0.336, acetamide: p = 0.877), but predictions for extracellular MNZ, intracellular MNZ, and acetamide concentrations in cultures with a 1000× Gv:Li ratio did vary significantly from experimental data (Supplementary Fig. 4). The deviation of model predictions when Gv is initially dominant suggests that experimental investigation of detailed mechanisms of Gv interactions with MNZ is warranted (for example, the potential ability of Gv to externally degrade MNZ). Despite some deviation of peripheral model predictions from experimental measurements, the Gv:Li ratio-dependent trends were reproduced by the model. The dependency on initial culture ratios of Gv to Li on growth suggests that non-target bacteria that sequester MNZ could significantly alter drug efficacy.

**Fig. 3: Initial Gv:Li ratios dictate final microbial populations.**

We observed some variation in the sensitivity (EC50) of Li to MNZ. Variability in minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC) estimations have been reported, as changes in culture conditions including incubation length and the inoculum effect can influence the apparent sensitivity of bacteria to antibiotic^37,41. In addition, the sensitivity of Lactobacillus spp. and Gv to MNZ and their MICs are reported to range from 500 to 4000 µg/ml and 0.75 to >256 µg/ml, respectively^42,43,44. To ascertain whether our results would be influenced by variation in Li sensitivity to MNZ, we repeated the simulations over a range of EC50 values. To represent reported resistance of Lactobacillus spp. in vitro, we increased the EC50 value of Li to be 10-fold higher than Gv (EC50_Li = 4200 µg/ml). MNZ efficacy in inhibiting Gv growth was similarly decreased at low Gv:Li ratios (36.5% max growth at 0.001× Gv:Li) compared to high Gv:Li ratios (3.96% max growth at 1000× Gv:Li, Supplementary Fig. 5a). Li had little to no susceptibility over the range of MNZ concentrations tested (Supplementary Fig. 5b). In addition, these EC50 values replicated trends in experimental data for growth kinetics (Supplementary Fig. 2d, h versus Supplementary Fig. 5c, d). These results support that the initial Gv:Li ratio-dependent trends in MNZ efficacy for inhibiting Gv growth are independent of Li’s sensitivity to MNZ.

Optimal MNZ doses are dependent on pre-treatment microbiome

We next used the model to determine specific combinations of MNZ concentrations and initial Gv:Li ratios that resulted in optimal final Li proportion after 48 MNZ exposure. The initial Gv:Li ratio was highly associated with the final Gv:Li ratio for doses of MNZ >250 µg/ml (Fig. 3a). Interestingly, cultures that were initially Li dominant (0.001× Gv:Li), were nearly insensitive to any dose of MNZ, resulting consistently with >50% Gv (Fig. 3a). This result carries the surprising implication that women with Li-dominant vaginal microbiomes at treatment initiation are likely to undergo recurrence, regardless of MNZ dose. Of note, cultures that were originally Gv dominant (Gv:Li >1) were the most likely to be Li dominated after 48 h exposure to MNZ. Experimental data supported these trends, as the simulation predictions were not significantly different for the final proportion of Li at 500 µg/ml for 1000× (p = 0.680, t = 0.420, df = 17). The model did overestimate the final proportion of Li at the 0.001× Gv:Li ratio (predicting a 44.1% proportion of Li compared to 14.2% ± 7.16% obtained experimentally); however, this result suggests an even more significant reduction in Li proportion when Gv is initially dominant (p = 0.008, t = 4.06, df = 17).

A phase diagram of MNZ therapy outcomes at 48 h was created to characterize both Li and Gv endpoint growth dynamics, which depict either an increase/expansion or decrease in population size relative to the initial population. The optimal growth dynamics would depict the expansion of only the Li population and the least optimal growth dynamics would be the expansion of only Gv. A decrease in both populations is additionally not optimal, as lower levels of beneficial microbiota are often associated with opportunistic infections or overgrowth of non-optimal species^45,46. We observed that higher initial Gv:Li ratios in conjunction with MNZ concentrations over 250 µg/mL were more likely to result in optimal final growth dynamics where the Li bacterial population was the only population expanding (Fig. 3b). Likewise, it was possible for only the Gv population to grow and the Li population to decrease when the initial Gv:Li ratio was <1×. Interestingly, the diagram predicts that it is possible that both Gv and Li populations would decrease for intermediate ratios of Gv:Li, which expand to include a wider range of ratios as the dose of MNZ is increased. Overall, in vitro co-culture experimental data supported the model predictions for endpoint growth dynamics, with 15 of 18 samples agreeing with the dynamics predicted by the phase diagram for the 1000× Gv:Li, 500 µg/ml group and for all 18 samples agreeing with the predictions for the 0.001× Gv:Li ratio, 500 µg/ml group (Fig. 3b, right). This result reinforces the importance of pre-treatment Gv:Li ratio on post-treatment bacterial community composition.

Initial composition influences efficacy in more complex models

While our model results emphasize the importance of pre-treatment Gv:Li ratios in MNZ efficacy in co-cultures, BV in women is more complex, and involves interspecies interactions and strain variability across many different bacterial species. To evaluate the above results in more complex settings that include multiple species, interspecies interactions, and strain variability, we created three additional model structures (Fig. 4a–d). In Model B and Model D, we account for potential interspecies interactions, such as amensalism between Lactobacillus spp. and BV-associated bacteria and commensal or mutualistic behavior within BV-associated bacteria subpopulations and Lactobacillus spp. (Fig. 4a, d)^{47,48,49,50,51}. In Models C and D we add additional representative species; a second BV-associated species and second Lactobacillus spp. (Fig. 4c, d). To address potential variability in associated parameters, we randomly selected parameter values from physiologically relevant ranges determined from previously published studies (Supplementary Tables 2 and 3). Notably, across all four model structures we found that higher initial relative amounts of BV-associated bacteria to Lactobacillus spp. had higher relative post-antibiotic levels of Lactobacillus spp. (BV:LB ratio, Fig. 4e, f, Supplementary Fig. 6, p < 1E–6, p < 1E–6, p < 1E–6, p < 1E–6). This result held for a range of ratios (0.6× BV:LB and 100× BV:LB) chosen to reflect the observed relative abundance of Lactobacillus spp. in BV positive women (60–1.0%)⁵². Moreover, for each of these model structures, the global sensitivity analyses consistently selected the MNZ internalization/sequestration parameter (k_int) and the initial relative abundance of BV-associated bacteria to Lactobacillus spp. (BV:LB ratio) as significantly sensitive parameters in post-antibiotic treatment Lactobacillus spp. relative abundance. Variability in Gv sensitivity to MNZ (EC50) and growth rate were also selected as critical parameters in dictating response to MNZ treatment, which are of interest as there is significant variability across Gv subclasses in terms of resistance to MNZ, and metabolism⁵³. Furthermore, when models were modified such that Lactobacillus spp. could not internalize/sequester MNZ, the ratio-dependent effect was abrogated, and was independent of sensitivity of Lactobacillus spp. to MNZ (Supplementary Fig. 7a, b). Altogether, this provides additional quantitative evidence that Lactobacillus spp. sequestration of MNZ may contribute to BV recurrence in more complex microbial environments.

**Fig. 4: High pre-treatment BV:LB ratio is predicted to reduce MNZ efficacy in more complex microbial environments regardless of strain variability.**

Pre-treatment composition is associated with clinical outcome

We next evaluated whether the influence of initial BV:LB ratio on MNZ efficacy is observed clinically. We compared the pre-treatment ratio of BV-associated bacteria to Lactobacillus spp. (BV:LB ratio) in vaginal samples collected from women who underwent MNZ treatment for BV and were cured or experienced recurrence, in two clinical studies; the UMB-HMP study³³ (n = 11) and CONRAD BV study³⁴ (n = 33). We chose to evaluate each study separately to minimize the effects of differences in sample collection and in methods of microbial species measurements. In the UMB-HMP cohort, 11 women were observed over the course of 10 weeks and provided cervicovaginal lavage (CVLs) samples each day for quantification of relative microbial abundances by sequencing of the V3 and V4 regions of 16S rRNA. Patients underwent treatment for BV that consisted of 1 week of 500-mg oral MNZ, taken twice daily. Of the 11 women, 8 met inclusion criteria and were classified as recurrent or cured dependent on Nugent scoring, where recurrent patients were described as women who responded to treatment but exhibited a second episode of BV during the 10-week period (Supplementary Table 4). Results resonated with model predictions where individuals who experienced recurrence had higher amounts of Lactobacillus spp. relative to BV-associated bacteria (lower BV:LB ratios, p = 0.0366) at treatment initiation and tended to have higher abundances of Lactobacillus spp., particularly Li, but abundance of individual species were not statistically significant after adjustment for multiple comparisons (p = 0.201, Fig. 5a, Supplementary Fig. 8a). In addition, Gv relative abundance was not significantly different between groups (p = 0.984, Supplementary Fig. 8b). Furthermore, when we analyzed the specific species in the original two-species model, we also observed similar results where cured women had significantly higher ratios of Gv to Li (p = 0.0497, Fig. 5b). It is important to note that since the Gv:Li ratio comparison was a selective analysis, we did not correct for multiple comparisons based on individual species in the original data set (over 190 species measured). These results support both the in vitro experimental data and model results that predicted a lower efficacy of MNZ treatment when a lower ratio of Gv to Li was present pre-treatment.

**Fig. 5: Increased initial BV:LB ratios associated with successful treatment of BV.**

We also evaluated model findings in a second clinical cohort, the CONRAD BV study, which consisted of 33 women whose vaginal microbiome was sampled at enrollment in the study, 1 week after MNZ treatment and 1 month after MNZ treatment. Relative abundances were determined by sequencing of the V4 region of the 16S rRNA. Women were excluded from this subset analysis if they failed to finish the antibiotic regimen, contracted a secondary vaginal infection, did not respond or had delayed response of treatment. Of the 33 women, 21 met inclusion criteria and were evaluated by molecular-BV criteria (dominance of Lactobacillus spp.) at 1 week and 1 month, with women exhibiting a vaginal microbiota composition of <50% Lactobacillus spp. classified as BV positive. The group analyzed consisted of women who were cured (n = 10) and or were determined to have recurrent BV (n = 11; Lactobacillus was dominant at 1 week, but molecular-BV returned after 1 month, Supplementary Table 5). Like the previous study, we found that women who experienced recurrence had higher levels of Lactobacillus spp. relative to BV-associated bacteria (lower BV:LB ratio, p = 0.0242, Fig. 5c). Comparison of CLR-transformed relative abundance did not result in statistically significant differences for Li or Gv, but tended to support the trend of recurrent women having higher Li and lower Gv (Supplementary Fig. 8c, d, p = 0.521, p = 0.694). Similarly, analysis of the Gv:Li ratio supported higher pre-treatment Gv relative to Li was associated with better treatment outcomes (Fig. 5d; p = 0.0338). Though preliminary and limited by low sample numbers, these results support the model predictions and suggest that successful BV treatment could be driven by competition for MNZ, where non-target bacterial populations, Lactobacillus spp., like Li sequester MNZ away from target bacterial populations like Gv, A. vaginae, Sneathia, etc., ultimately decreasing MNZ efficacy.

Discussion

Here we show a personalized tolerance mechanism that may contribute to BV recurrence and treatment failure. Our model illustrates how non-target bacteria, such as Li or other Lactobacillus spp., may sequester antibiotic and lower the amount of MNZ available to target bacteria like Gv. This model result implies that MNZ efficacy may be dependent on highly variable pre-treatment relative abundances of Lactobacillus spp. such as Li to BV-associated bacteria populations (BV:LB ratios) and raises the question of whether patients with higher levels of Lactobacillus spp. are more susceptible to recurrent BV than those with higher degrees of dysbiosis. Importantly, results from the model, in vitro experiments, and clinical data all point to a higher pre-treatment BV-associated bacteria population relative to Lactobacillus spp. as a driver of MNZ efficacy in inhibiting Gv growth and facilitating post-treatment Lactobacillus dominance. This study complements ongoing work in the search for drivers of BV treatment efficacy, in which experimental studies are often limited to delineating the role of individual bacteria, and it is challenging to assess the importance of numerous clinical and microbial variables that are associated with treatment outcome¹⁵.

The potential for non-antibiotic-target bacterial populations to act as a sink for MNZ and alter efficacy is similar to a concept that has been previously explored in bacterial ecology, termed the inoculum effect (IE), which describes an increase in antibiotic MICs due to increased bacterial load and decreased per cell antibiotic concentration⁵⁴. While the IE and the ability of bacterial species to influence MNZ bioavailability has been previously reported, to our knowledge its role in BV recurrence has not yet been considered. Furthermore, the ODE model used here was essential for determining the critical importance of MNZ sequestration by Lactobacillus spp. across multiple interactions that have the potential to influence efficacy and recurrence, including metabolism, proliferation, and susceptibility to MNZ of both target and non-target species. The model was also necessary for translating the importance of this parameter to microbial communities with varying compositions and with different MNZ dosing regimens. Though the proposed MNZ sequestration mechanisms were not experimentally validated in this study, the model predictions for associated relationships between pre-treatment microbial composition and BV recurrence were recapitulated in both co-cultures and in cervicovaginal samples, providing an additional mechanism for recurrence that has not previously been considered.

Recent studies evaluating pre-treatment vaginal microbiota composition on MNZ efficacy have reported inconsistent results, likely due to differences in patient exclusion criteria, time point of treatment outcome assessment, drug regimen, and methods to collect and quantify the vaginal microbiota. One study that employed a similar drug regimen (oral MNZ) and sample collection methods to the clinical cohorts evaluated here supported our results, finding higher pre-treatment loads of antibiotic-target species, Gv and A. vaginae, associated with BV treatment efficacy¹⁹. Other studies that used different sample collection methods and antibiotic regimens did not explicitly evaluate the pre-treatment ratio of BV-associated bacteria to Lactobacillus spp.; generally suggested there was an association between total Lactobacillus relative abundance and successful treatment^15,55,56. Notably, some of these studies focused on analyzing treatment outcome immediately after antibiotic therapy was completed, and in some cases treatment failure was due to no response to therapy. We propose that recurrence and failure to respond to therapy likely arise from different factors, where recurrence is due to a collective bacterial population’s resilience to antibiotic therapy and failure to respond is due to inherent resistance of BV-associated bacteria. Studies that have associated higher Gv loads with treatment failure correspond with the latter and could be due to the formation of biofilms or other resistance mechanisms⁵⁶. As our model predicts immediate post-therapy Lactobacillus spp. relative abundance, no response to treatment would be equivalent to predicting no change or low Lactobacillus spp. relative abundance at 48 h. An additional limitation of our model is that it does not appear to be applicable to cases of MNZ treatment failure in women who initially had very low levels of Lactobacillus spp. (<1%), which our model would predict should promote MNZ efficacy³⁴. However, we propose that treatment failure in this case may be a result of the Allee effect^57,58, which can be caused by a variety of mechanisms that lead to decreased fitness at low population densities, suggesting these women have Lactobacillus abundances that are too low to recolonize the vagina and may be associated with more precisely modeling interspecies interactions. Moreover, since Li is the only Lactobacillus spp. observed to date to significantly sequester MNZ, it will be important to characterize how other vaginal bacterial species interact with MNZ to further explore the role of non-target bacterial species on MNZ efficacy. Altogether, conflicting results in clinical studies of pre-treatment vaginal microbiota composition support the need for the development of quantitative platforms to evaluate the interplay between multiple microbial species, clinical variables, and dosing regimens that contribute to personalized differences in treatment failure.

Models presented here are only simple reconstructions of the minimal possible interactions between bacterial species and an antibiotic that have been established as key species by the existing literature^10,15,17, with a time-scale that was limited by in vitro co-culture conditions. While the model provided useful insight into how non-target bacterial species may influence BV recurrence after MNZ treatment, predicting regrowth of Lactobacillus spp., and the full quantitative mechanisms underlying responses to treatment are likely more nuanced. More complex model frameworks did suggest key results would hold true in microbial communities with additional microbial species, interspecies interactions, and strain variability, though we were not able to validate this experimentally. Interspecies interactions in our models were incorporated with generalized Lotka–Volterra equations which simplifies relationships to a single term, but represent a good starting point for recapitulating ecosystem-level complexities^{59,60,61,62,63}. Specific metabolic interactions that dictate survival and elimination of bacterial species in the vagina could be included with greater mechanistic detail in the future. In instances where parameters are unknown or difficult to measure experimentally, this work demonstrates the value of a global computational sensitivity analysis for understanding the relative importance of strain-level differences in antibiotic uptake, metabolism, or sensitivity. Predictive simulations can be run across multiple possible parameter ranges to determine the effects of variation prior to costly experimental measurements. This tool will be valuable in isolating the role of individual parameters in making a bacterial population or community more tolerant to antibiotic therapy.

In this study, we demonstrated that ODE models can provide insights into antibiotic–microbe interactions pertinent to understanding BV treatment efficacy. Our work highlights that it is possible for BV treatment to fail, even if target bacteria are not resistant to MNZ as vaginal bacterial populations as a whole can be resilient to antibiotic, resulting in recurrent BV. While our clinical analysis is limited in sample size and therefore should be considered preliminary, future extensions of this work could be used to inform clinical decision-making regarding personalized therapy options. More generally, we envision that the use of quantitative models such as this will provide a framework for integrating knowledge of interactions between multiple bacterial species and drug treatments in mucosal tissues to give insight into the diverse responses observed in infectious disease and other syndromes of the female reproductive tract.

Methods

Bacterial strains and culture conditions

Lactobacillus iners ATCC 55195 and Gardnerella vaginalis ATCC 14018 (group C) were obtained from the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) and maintained on Human Bilayer Tween Agar (BD) plates and New York City III (NYCIII) medium according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Agar plates and liquid cultures were incubated at 37 °C with anaerobic gas mixture, 80% N₂, 10% CO₂, and 10% H₂. Frozen stocks of strains were stored at −80 °C in 40% (v/v) glycerol.

Metronidazole quantification by tandem mass spectrometry

MNZ concentrations were determined by validated LC-MS/MS assays. Sample aliquots were centrifuged at 3000 × g and divided between supernatant and cell pellet. Extracellular MNZ was extracted from supernatant via protein precipitation using acetonitrile. For intracellular concentration measurements, cell pellets were lysed using sonication and re-suspended in 100 μL of sterile water. Samples were subjected to positive electrospray ionization (ESI) and detected via multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) using a LC-MS/MS system (Agilent Technologies 6460 QQQ/MassHunter). Calibration standards were prepared with an inter- and intra-day precision and accuracy of ≤5% with an r² value of 0.9988 ± 0.0009. Quantification was performed using MRM of the transitions of m/z 172.2 → 128.2 and 176.2 → 128.2 for MNZ and MNZ-d4 respectively. Each transition was monitored with a 100-ms dwell time. Stock solutions of MNZ and MNZ-d4 were prepared at 1 mg/mL in acetonitrile-water and stored at −20 °C. Mobile phase A is 0.1% acetic acid in H₂O and mobile phase B is 0.1% acetic acid in ACN, and chromatographic separation was achieved using a gradient elution with a Chromolith Performance RP-C18 column maintained at 25 °C from 0 to 4.6 min, B% 0–100, with 0.5 μL/min flow. During pre-study validation, calibration curves were defined in multiple runs on the basis of triplicate assays of spiked media samples as well as QC samples. This method was validated for its sensitivity, selectivity, accuracy, precision, matrix effects, recovery, and stability. Replicates of reference samples were included every six samples and evenly distributed throughout the MS analysis to monitor consistency and performance and to utilize for downstream normalization.

Bacterial quantification

Bacterial quantification determined via turbidimetry was completed by measuring the optical density at each time point, 100 μL of sample inoculum was read at O.D. 600 nm using a SpectraMax Plus 384 UV spectrophotometer. Time points were recorded within 5 min of sampling and stored at 4 °C.

Bacterial quantification using plate counting was done by doing a 10-fold dilution using sterile water and aliquoting 100 μL spread evenly onto BD agar plates. Cultures were incubated at 37 °C. Plating was done in triplicates and was counted manually. Prior optimization ensured the dilution would result in no more than 300 colonies making quantification as accurate as possible.

For co-culture validation experiments, 100 μL of sample was aliquoted on Rogosa agar and Gardnerella selective agar. Experiments were conducted to verify the absence of Lactobacillus growth on Gardnerella selective media and absence of G. vaginalis growth on Rogosar agar, to confirm that colony formation specific to respective taxa. Cultures were incubated at 37 °C, with a total of 36 biological replicates for the 1000× and 0.001 Gv:Li ratio cultures (n = 18 cultures for each ratio). Plating was done in triplicates and was counted manually. Prior optimization ensured the dilution would result in no more than 300 colonies making quantification as accurate as possible.

Bacteria–MNZ experiments

For the MNZ experiments, 50 μL MNZ was added at appropriate concentrations to 5 mL of NYCII media. Samples equilibrated at 37 °C for 1 h prior to the addition of 50 μL of bacterial inoculum (2 × 10⁶). One hundred and fifty microliters of aliquot was taken for time-point readings for MNZ and bacterial quantification (as described above). Samples were incubated at 37 °C under constant mixing and only removed for time-point measurements.

For the co-culture experiments, Gv:Li ratios were added at appropriate experimental conditions in a likewise manner. For each varying ratio sample within each experiment, a side-by-side duplicate was performed without MNZ as a negative control. The negative control was assessed only for bacterial quantification to ensure that no growth condition or external stimuli promoted the growth of one over another. Negative control experiments demonstrated bacterial proliferation that modeled growth curves of each individual bacterium cultured alone thus confirming any changes in growth seen in our bacteria–MNZ experiments were the result of the addition of MNZ.

ODE models

The model equations were constructed assuming both Li and Gv internalize MNZ at rates k_int-Li and k_int-Gv, MNZ toxicity to Li and Gv occurred at rates dependent on the maximum rates k_kill-Li and k_kill-Gv and the concentration of internalized MNZ where growth inhibition increased as internalized MNZ exceeded a threshold as described by 50% effective concentrations, EC50_Li and EC50_Gv. The growth of Li and Gv was assumed to be logistic in behavior at rates k_grow-Li and k_grow-Gv with distinct carrying capacities for each bacterium, K_Li and K_Gv. The parameters for k_grow-Li, k_grow-Gv, K_Li, and K_Gv were determined by nonlinear least-squares fitting of the logistic function to growth curves for Li and Gv grown in separate cultures (Supplementary Fig. 2a, b)⁶⁴. The k_kill-Li, k_kill-Gv, EC50_Li, and EC50_Gv were determined by fitting the Hill equation to kill curves for Li and Gv cultured in isolation (Supplementary Fig. 2c, d). Internalization rates, k_int-Li and k_int-Gv and metabolism rates, k_acet and k_met were determined from fitting the ODE model to time course mass spectrometry data for external MNZ, internal MNZ and acetamide and cell densities (optical density) using a multistart local optimization strategy (Multistart) with the local solver lsqcurvefit.

Model simulations and validation

Unless otherwise noted, all simulations were completed at MNZ concentration of 500 μg/ml over the course of 48 h. Growth outputs were normalized to the maximal growth density (K_Li and K_Gv) for comparison across simulations and to experimental data. External MNZ, internal MNZ, and acetamide concentrations were relative to the total volume of cellular pellets. Sensitivity analyses were completed by perturbing a single model parameter while keeping the rest of the parameters constant over 1000×–0.001× the original value. Surfaces were generated over three orders of magnitude for MNZ concentration (10–1500 μg/ml) and eight orders of magnitude for ratio of Gv:Li (1.6 × 10⁻⁴–1.6 × 10⁴) at 1225 combinations of MNZ concentration and Gv:Li ratio. Model validation was completed by comparing the experimental co-culture data to model predictions using unpaired t-tests.

Generalized models and global sensitivity analysis

To incorporate intraspecies and interspecies variation we developed three additional model structures and ran simulations with randomized parameter sets to determine if the influence of initial Gv:Li ratio, or the more generalized BV:LB ratio, on endpoint Lactobacillus spp. composition is consistently observed across these model structures.

For capturing intraspecies variation, we used Latin Hypercube Sampling of parameter ranges for each parameter to create 100 parameter sets. We derived these parameter ranges from the literature and a summary of these ranges can be found in Supplementary Tables 2 and 3. These same parameter ranges and sampling methods were used for the global sensitivity and uncertainty analysis, which analyzed the partial rank correlation coefficient with 2000 randomly generated parameter sets with endpoint (48 h, 500 μg/ml MNZ) Lactobacillus spp. relative abundance⁶⁵. For capturing interspecies variation, and microbe–microbe interactions like cross-feeding, we developed a four species model that includes two representative BV-associated bacteria, and two Lactobacillus species, L. iners and a second species representing L. crispatus, L. jensenii, or L. gasseri.

Internalization/uptake rates (k_int)

To our knowledge, this is the first publication that demonstrates that G. vaginalis and L. iners uptake or sequester MNZ. Previous literature describing uptake of MNZ in other bacterial species, including both obligate and facultative anaerobes has been published by Ralph and Clarke³¹, Tally et al.²⁷, and Narikawa⁶⁶. These publications demonstrate that even bacteria that are resistant to MNZ can still uptake MNZ, and at similar rates. Despite the fact that facultative anaerobes are believed to be largely insensitive to MNZ, Narikawa specifically demonstrates that nitroreductase activity is associated with the ability to uptake MNZ, and that pyruvate:ferrodoxin activity is associated with sensitivity to MNZ as an explanation for why the facultative anaerobes Escherichia coli, K. pneumoniae, M. morganii, and S. faecalis exhibited high MICs, but reduced supernatant MNZ. We calculated the rates of MNZ uptake for five species, one obligate anaerobe, B. fragilis, and four facultative anaerobes (E. coli, S. aureus, P. morganii, and S. faecalis) by digitizing the kinetic data for cell counts and extracellular MNZ concentrations in Ralph and Clarke³¹ and fitting second-order reaction kinetics by ordinary least-squares regression. The rates ranged from 2 × 10⁻¹⁷ to 0.15 cell density⁻¹ h⁻¹. To determine the likelihood that these parameters could be a basis for Lactobacillus spp. uptake of MNZ, we assessed the similarity between E. coli’s oxygen-independent NADPH-nitroreductase, nsfA, with nitroreductase protein sequences of G. vaginalis (34.7%), L. crispatus (31.0%), L. iners (29.4%), L. jensenii (19.4%), and L. gasseri (18.52%). In addition, Guillen et al.⁶⁷ reported that L. plantarum had selective nitroreductase activity, that shared 32–43% sequence similarity with several Lactobacillus species, and in comparison had similarity with G. vaginalis (24.0%), L. crispatus (38.5%), L. iners (25.5%), L. jensenii (52.8%), and L. gasseri (30.0%). Sequence similarity was assessed by NCBI’s protein BLAST⁶⁸. As obligate anaerobes were observed to uptake MNZ at higher rates, we assumed that the other BV-associated bacteria, which could be an obligate anaerobe could potentially have higher capacity to internalize MNZ.

Growth rates (k_grow) and carrying capacities (K)

To account for potential variability in growth rates, we surveyed previously published to determine ranges in growth. For Lactobacillus species, we calculated growth rates by digitizing growth curves from Chetwin et al.⁶⁹ and analyzed growth rates reported in Juárez–Tomás⁷⁰, Anukam and Reid⁴⁵. G. vaginalis and other bacterial strains growth curves were less abundant in the literature, but we did calculate growth rates from Atassi et al.⁴⁹ and Anukam and Ried⁴⁵. Generally, G. vaginalis and other BV-associated bacteria seemed to have slower growth rates than Lactobacillus species, and in the same culture conditions this was observed in Anukam and Ried⁴⁵. For carrying capacity we assumed that there were similar carrying capacities for all species, except the BV-associated bacteria based on data from Castro et al.⁷¹, that reported A. vaginae at lower levels that G. vaginalis at steady state⁷¹.

Sensitivity to MNZ (EC50 and k_kill)

MNZ is highly variable, and typically obligate anaerobes are considered the most sensitive to MNZ. The strain of G. vaginalis used in the basis of this model is relatively resistant to MNZ, with growth barely inhibited at 256 μg/ml (9% inhibition compared to 0 μg/ml control, Supplementary Fig. 2d). For A. vaginae, the MIC can range 2–256 μg/ml and G. vaginalis can range from 0.75 to >500 μg/ml^43,44. Generally, it is assumed that Lactobacillus spp. are insensitive to MNZ; however, this also appears to be highly strain and species-dependent with some Lactobacillus isolates in similar ranges of sensitivity as G. vaginalis^42,45. The rate at which MNZ inhibits growth is more difficult to find, as the experiments to determine this rate are more laborious than the standard kill curve to calculate EC50 so we assumed all kill rates to be equal across all species.

Metabolism of MNZ

To our knowledge, this is the first manuscript to describe the metabolism of MNZ by vaginal microbiota. We solely based the parameter value on the rate observed for the G. vaginalis strain from the model. In addition, we assumed that only BV-associated bacteria metabolism MNZ based on the observation that only BV-associated bacteria metabolize HIV microbicide drugs²⁹.

Interspecies interaction terms

Gause⁷² noted the calculation for interaction terms for a generalized Lotka–Volterra model describing competitive exclusion (Eqs. (1) and (2)). In our model, we generalized the interaction terms further to be able to capture many different interactions, specifically amensal behavior where Lactobacillus spp. can inhibit BV-associated bacterial growth with no effect of BV-associated bacteria on Lactobacillus species growth (−/0) as well as mutualistic (both species benefit from the other +/+) and commensal behaviors (one species benefits 0/+) between BV-associated bacteria or within the Lactobacillus population. The amensal behavior between Lactobacillus species has been documented experimentally in co-culture⁷³ and we calculated the interaction term for many different species and strains of Lactobacillus on G. vaginalis and Prevotella bivia from Atassi et al.⁵⁰. It is largely believed that D-lactic acid produced by many Lactobacillus species inhibits the growth of BV-associated bacteria; however, L. iners does not produce this isomer of lactic acid and is the reasoning behind not including an interaction term between L. iners and the BV-associated bacteria^48,74. It is believed that commensal behavior exists between G. vaginalis and P. bivia in the form of cross-feeding, so we allowed the model to simulate this behavior⁵¹. In addition, G. vaginalis is associated with promoting the growth of other BV-associated bacteria like A. vaginae⁷¹. Calculations were completed assuming the reported mono and co-cultures were at steady state to derive Eqs. (3) and (4). Equations (3) and (4) relate to the parameters in Supplementary Table 3 by Eqs. (5) and (6), which generalizes the reported interaction strength from the literature to be able to be adjusted for varying carrying capacities simulated in the model that do not equal the carrying capacities from the literature.

$$\frac{{dN}}{{dt}} = r_NN\left[ {1 - \frac{{N + {\mathrm{s}}_{{\mathrm{P}} \to {\mathrm{N}}}P}}{{K_N}}} \right]$$

(1)

$$\frac{{dP}}{{dt}} = r_PP\left[ {1 - \frac{{P + {\mathrm{s}}_{{\mathrm{N}} \to {\mathrm{P}}}N}}{{K_P}}} \right]$$

(2)

$${\mathrm{s}}_{{\mathrm{P}} \to {\mathrm{N}}} = \left[ {\frac{{K_N - N}}{P}} \right]$$

(3)

$${\mathrm{s}}_{{\mathrm{N}} \to {\mathrm{P}}} = \left[ {\frac{{K_P - P}}{N}} \right]$$

(4)

$$s_{{\mathrm{P}} \to {\mathrm{N}}} = \left[ {\frac{{K_N - {\mathrm{f}}_{{\mathrm{P}} \to {\mathrm{N}}}K_N}}{{f_{{\it{N}} \to {\it{P}}}K_P}}} \right]$$

(5)

$${\mathrm{s}}_{{\mathrm{N}} \to {\mathrm{P}}} = \left[ {\frac{{K_P - f_{{\it{N}} \to {\it{P}}}K_P}}{{f_{{\it{P}} \to {\it{N}}}K_N}}} \right]$$

(6)

Software

Parameterization, ODE modeling, and sensitivity analyses were completed using Matlab® 2018b (Matlab, Natick, MA). Statistical analyses were performed using PRISM 8, exact p-values <1E–6 were calculated in Matlab.

Clinical data and study population

The UMB-HMP cohort

The study results and associated clinical data were previously published³³ and all data provided were de-identified to this study. The UMB-HMP study was not an interventional study, but an observational prospective study, where treatment information was recorded during a clinical exam at week 5 and week 10 for 135 nonpregnant women of reproductive age. Within this study, MNZ treatment was provided as standard of care, as recommended by the CDC (metronidazole 500 mg orally twice a day for 7 days)⁷⁵. The original study protocol was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the University of Alabama at Birmingham and the University of Maryland School of Medicine. Written informed consent was appropriately obtained from all participants, who also provided consent for storage and use in future research studies related to women’s health.

Women self-collected cervicovaginal swabs for 10 weeks. Vaginal microbiota data were generated by sequencing the V3–V4 regions of the 16S rRNA gene and is available in dbGAP BioProject PRJNA208535. In this study, the vaginal microbiota composition data from 11 women who experienced BV and were treated with MNZ during the UMB-HMP study were analyzed. Any participants who failed to complete the MNZ regimen, who did not have BV according to Nugent scoring at the time of MNZ treatment, or who did not have follow-up data available were excluded from the analysis. The initial relative abundances were averaged across the week before starting MNZ treatment. Patients were classified to have recurrent BV if they exhibited a second episode of BV based on Nugent scoring (7–10) during remaining of the 10-week observation period.

The CONRAD BV cohort

The study results and associated clinical data were previously published³⁴ and all data provided were de-identified to this study. The original clinical study protocol was approved by the Chesapeake Institutional Review Board (IRB) (Pro #00006122) with a waiver of oversight from the Eastern Virginia Medical School (EVMS) and registered in ClinicalTrials.gov (#NCT01347632). A total of 69 women were screened from symptomatic discharge and 35 women were enrolled in the study. Vaginal microbiota data were generated by sequencing the V4 region of the 16S rRNA gene, providing taxonomic resolution at the general level.

Thirty-three women completed all three visits. BV was evaluated by vaginal microbiota compositional data (molecular-BV)⁷⁶. After biological samples were obtained at visit 1 (V1), women with BV were prescribed twice daily, 500-mg MNZ for 7 days. Participants returned for visit 2 (V2) 7–10 days after completing the course of MNZ therapy and visit 3 (V3) 28–32 days after completing treatment. At all three visits, samples were obtained to evaluate vaginal semen (ABAcard, West Hills, CA), vaginal pH, gram stain for Nugent score and semiquantitative vaginal flora culture. CVLs were collected, followed by vaginal swabs and three full-thickness biopsies.

Analysis of clinical outcomes

In the Human Microbiome Project cohort, patients were defined as cured or recurrent based on whether after initial MNZ treatment the patient suffered an additional episode of BV (Nugent 7–10) during the 10-week course of data collection. For analysis, initial flora relative abundances were averaged across the 7 days prior to reported treatment start date. To analyze the relative ratio between BV-associated bacteria and Lactobacillus spp., we combined the relative abundances for the top 20 BV-associated bacteria and all Lactobacillus spp. The genera BV-associated bacteria included were Gardnerella, Atopobium, Megasphaera, BVAB1-3, Streptococcus, Prevotella, Leptotrichia, Anaerococcus, Peptoniphilus, Eggerthella, Veillonella, Sneathia, Mobiluncus, Corynebacterium, Ureaplasma, Eubacterium, Porphyromonas, Dialister, Peptostreptococcus, Bacteroides, Fusobacterium, Actinomyces, and Bifidobacterium. Before statistical analysis, the BV:LB ratio was log-transformed, and the relative abundances of L. iners, G. vaginalis were center-log ratio (CLR) transformed, with pseudocounts added to taxonomic units with relative abundances equal to zero. Statistical analysis of the BV:LB ratio and Gv:Li ratio was completed using two-sided unpaired Student’s t-tests and analysis of the CLR-transformed single species abundances was completed using two-sided unpaired Student’s t-tests and were corrected using the FDR method of Benjamini and Hochberg (PRISM 8).

For the CONRAD BV cohort, treatment outcome was defined based on Lactobacillus dominance evaluated at enrollment, 7 days after treatment and 28–32 days after treatment. Patients that exhibited Lactobacillus dominance at both 1 week and 1 month after treatment were considered cured, and patients that exhibited Lactobacillus dominance only at week 1 and not at 1 month were considered recurrent. The statistical analysis followed the same methodology as the HMP cohort.

Reporting summary

Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article.

Data availability

The source data are provided with this paper for Figs. 2–5, Supplementary Figs. 1, 2, 4 and 8, which includes the in vitro validation, model parameterization, and clinical validation. For the clinical studies, the UMB-HMP cohort study sequence data and metadata were deposited in the Sequence Read Archive (SRA; http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Traces/sra/) under BioProject PRJNA208535 (The daily dynamics of the vaginal microbiota before and after bacterial vaginosis) ([SRP026107] and [SRA091234])³³. An abbreviated data set necessary for the reproduction of Fig. 5a, b and Supplementary Fig. 8a, b are in Supplementary Table 4 and the Source data file. The sequence data and metadata for the CONRAD BV study are not in a formal repository, but are fully available upon request; however, we have included an abbreviated version of this data set that includes all the data necessary for reproduction of Fig. 5c, d and Supplementary Fig. 8c, d are in Supplementary Table 5 and can be found in the Source data file. Source data are provided with this paper.

Code availability

The code used to generate the model simulations is published (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4121904)⁷⁷.

References

Koumans, E. et al. The prevalence of bacterial vaginosis in the United States, 2001–2004; associations with symptoms, sexual behaviors, and reproductive health. Sex. Transm. Dis. 34, 864–869 (2007).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Peebles, K., Velloza, J., Balkus, J. E., McClelland, R. S. & Barnabas, R. V. High global burden and costs of bacterial vaginosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sex. Transm. Dis. 46, 304–311 (2019).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Taha, T. et al. Bacterial vaginosis and disturbances of vaginal flora: association with increased acquisition of HIV. Aids 12, 1699–1706 (1998).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Haggerty, C. L., Hillier, S. L., Bass, D. C. & Ness, R. B. Bacterial vaginosis and anaerobic bacteria are associated with endometritis. Clin. Infect. Dis. 39, 990–995 (2004).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Hillier, S. L. et al. Association between bacterial vaginosis and preterm delivery of a low-birth-weight infant. The Vaginal Infections and Prematurity Study Group. N. Engl. J. Med. 333, 1737–1742 (1995).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Bradshaw, C. S. & Brotman, R. M. Making inroads into improving treatment of bacterial vaginosis—striving for long-term cure. BMC Infect. Dis. 15, 292 (2015).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Ness, R. B. et al. A cluster analysis of bacterial vaginosis-associated microflora and pelvic inflammatory disease. Am. J. Epidemiol. 162, 585–590 (2005).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Nunn, K. L. & Forney, L. J. Unraveling the dynamics of the human vaginal microbiome. Yale J. Biol. Med. 89, 331–337 (2016).
PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Fredricks, D. N., Fiedler, T. L., Thomas, K. K., Mitchell, C. M. & Marrazzo, J. M. Changes in vaginal bacterial concentrations with intravaginal metronidazole therapy for bacterial vaginosis as assessed by quantitative PCR. J. Clin. Microbiol. 47, 721–726 (2009).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Srinivasan, S. et al. Temporal variability of human vaginal bacteria and relationship with bacterial vaginosis. PLoS ONE 5, e10197 (2010).
Article ADS PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar
Bradshaw, C. S. et al. High recurrence rates of bacterial vaginosis over the course of 12 months after oral metronidazole therapy and factors associated with recurrence. J. Infect. Dis. 193, 1478–1486 (2006).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Bradshaw, C. S. & Sobel, J. D. Current treatment of bacterial vaginosis-limitations and need for innovation. J. Infect. Dis. 214, S14–S20 (2016).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Ma, L., Su, J., Su, Y., Sun, W. & Zeng, Z. Probiotics administered intravaginally as a complementary therapy combined with antibiotics for the treatment of bacterial vaginosis: a systematic review protocol. BMJ Open 7, e019301 (2017).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Ferris, D. G., Litaker, M. S., Woodward, L., Mathis, D. & Hendrich, J. Treatment of bacterial vaginosis: a comparison of oral metronidazole, metronidazole vaginal gel, and clindamycin vaginal cream. J. Fam. Pract. 41, 443–449 (1995).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Xiao, B. et al. Association analysis on recurrence of bacterial vaginosis revealed microbes and clinical variables important for treatment outcome. Front. Cell. Infect. Microbiol. 9, 189 (2019).
Brotman, R. M. et al. A longitudinal study of vaginal douching and bacterial vaginosis—a marginal structural modeling analysis. Am. J. Epidemiol. 168, 188–196 (2008).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Wang, B. et al. Molecular analysis of the relationship between specific vaginal bacteria and bacterial vaginosis metronidazole therapy failure. Eur. J. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 33, 1749–1756 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Zhou, X. et al. Recent advances in understanding the microbiology of the female reproductive tract and the causes of premature birth. Infect. Dis. Obstet. Gynecol. https://www.hindawi.com/journals/idog/2010/737425/abs/ (2010).
Ferreira, C. S. T. et al. Treatment failure of bacterial vaginosis is not associated with higher loads of Atopobium vaginae and Gardnerella vaginalis. J. Med. Microbiol. 66, 1217–1224 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Coleman, J. S. & Gaydos, C. A. Molecular diagnosis of bacterial vaginosis: an update. J. Clin. Microbiol. 56, e00342-18 (2018).
Gajer, P. et al. Temporal dynamics of the human vaginal microbiota. Sci. Transl. Med. 4, 132ra52 (2012).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Tamarelle, J. et al. Non-optimal vaginal microbiota after azithromycin treatment for Chlamydia trachomatis infection. J. Infect. Dis. https://doi.org/10.1093/infdis/jiz499 (2019).
Vaneechoutte, M. Lactobacillus iners, the unusual suspect. Res. Microbiol. 168, 826–836 (2017).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Faust, K., Lahti, L., Gonze, D., de Vos, W. M. & Raes, J. Metagenomics meets time series analysis: unraveling microbial community dynamics. Curr. Opin. Microbiol. 25, 56–66 (2015).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Lugo-Martinez, J., Ruiz-Perez, D., Narasimhan, G. & Bar-Joseph, Z. Dynamic interaction network inference from longitudinal microbiome data. Microbiome 7, 54 (2019).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Brotman, R. M., Ravel, J., Cone, R. A. & Zenilman, J. M. Rapid fluctuation of the vaginal microbiota measured by Gram stain analysis. Sex. Transm. Infect. 86, 297–302 (2010).
Article PubMed Google Scholar
Tally, F. P., Goldin, B. R., Sullivan, N., Johnston, J. & Gorbach, S. L. Antimicrobial activity of metronidazole in anaerobic bacteria. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 13, 460–465 (1978).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Church, D. L., Rabin, H. R. & Lalshley, E. J. Role of hydrogenase 1 of clostridium pasteurianum in the reduction of metronidazole. Biochem. Pharmacol. 37, 1525–1534 (1988).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Klatt, N. R. et al. Vaginal bacteria modify HIV tenofovir microbicide efficacy in African women. Science 356, 938–945 (2017).
Article ADS CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Edwards, D. I. Mechanisms of selective toxicity of metronidazole and other nitroimidazole drugs. Br. J. Vener. Dis. 56, 285–290 (1980).
CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Ralph, E. D. & Clarke, D. A. Inactivation of metronidazole by anaerobic and aerobic bacteria. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 14, 377–383 (1978).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Edwards, D. I., Thompson, E. J., Tomusange, J. & Shanson, D. Inactivation of metronidazole by aerobic organisms. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 5, 315–316 (1979).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Ravel, J. et al. Daily temporal dynamics of vaginal microbiota before, during and after episodes of bacterial vaginosis. Microbiome 1, 29 (2013).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Thurman, A. R. et al. Bacterial vaginosis and subclinical markers of genital tract inflammation and mucosal immunity. AIDS Res. Hum. Retroviruses 31, 1139–1152 (2015).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Koch, R. L., Chrystal, E. J., Beaulieu, B. B. & Goldman, P. Acetamide—a metabolite of metronidazole formed by the intestinal flora. Biochem. Pharmacol. 28, 3611–3615 (1979).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Regoes, R. R. et al. Pharmacodynamic functions: a multiparameter approach to the design of antibiotic treatment regimens. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 48, 3670–3676 (2004).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Meredith, H. R. et al. Applying ecological resistance and resilience to dissect bacterial antibiotic responses. Sci. Adv. 4, eaau1873 (2018).
Article ADS CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Ings, R. M., McFadzean, J. A. & Ormerod, W. E. The mode of action of metronidazole in Trichomonas vaginalis and other micro-organisms. Biochem. Pharmacol. 23, 1421–1429 (1974).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Davis, B., Glover, D. D. & Larsen, B. Analysis of metronidazole penetration into vaginal fluid by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 149, 802–803 (1984).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Simoes, J. A. et al. Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 stimulatory activity by Gardnerella vaginalis: relationship to biotypes and other pathogenic characteristics. J. Infect. Dis. 184, 22–27 (2001).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Brooks, J. P. et al. Changes in vaginal community state types reflect major shifts in the microbiome. Microb. Ecol. Health Dis. 28, 1303265 (2017).
Simoes, J. A., Aroutcheva, A. A., Shott, S. & Faro, S. Effect of metronidazole on the growth of vaginal lactobacilli in vitro. Infect. Dis. Obstet. Gynecol. 9, 41–45 (2001).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
De Backer, E. et al. Antibiotic susceptibility of Atopobium vaginae. BMC Infect. Dis. 6, 51 (2006).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar
Petrina, M. A. B., Cosentino, L. A., Rabe, L. K. & Hillier, S. L. Susceptibility of bacterial vaginosis (BV)-associated bacteria to secnidazole compared to metronidazole, tinidazole and clindamycin. Anaerobe 47, 115–119 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Anukam, K. C. & Reid, G. Effects of metronidazole on growth of Gardnerella vaginalis ATCC 14018, probiotic Lactobacillus rhamnosus GR-1 and vaginal isolate Lactobacillus plantarum KCA. Microb. Ecol. Health Dis. 20, 48–52 (2008).
CAS Google Scholar
Buffie, C. G. et al. Profound alterations of intestinal microbiota following a single dose of clindamycin results in sustained susceptibility to clostridium difficile-induced colitis. Infect. Immun. 80, 62–73 (2012).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
France, M. T., Mendes-Soares, H. & Forney, L. J. Genomic comparisons of Lactobacillus crispatus and Lactobacillus iners reveal potential ecological drivers of community composition in the vagina. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 82, 7063–7073 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
O’Hanlon, D. E., Moench, T. R. & Cone, R. A. Vaginal pH and microbicidal lactic acid when lactobacilli dominate the microbiota. PLoS ONE 8, e80074 (2013).
Article ADS PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar
Atassi, F., Pho Viet Ahn, D. L. & Lievin-Le Moal, V. Diverse expression of antimicrobial activities against bacterial vaginosis and urinary tract infection pathogens by cervicovaginal microbiota strains of Lactobacillus gasseri and Lactobacillus crispatus. Front. Microbiol. 10, 2900 (2019).
Atassi, F., Brassart, D., Grob, P., Graf, F. & Servin, A. L. Lactobacillus strains isolated from the vaginal microbiota of healthy women inhibit Prevotella bivia and Gardnerella vaginalis in coculture and cell culture. FEMS Immunol. Med. Microbiol. 48, 424–432 (2006).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Pybus, V. & Onderdonk, A. B. Evidence for a commensal, symbiotic relationship between Gardnerella vaginalis and Prevotella bivia involving ammonia: potential significance for bacterial vaginosis. J. Infect. Dis. 175, 406–413 (1997).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Ravel, J. et al. Vaginal microbiome of reproductive-age women. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 4680–4687 (2011).
Article ADS CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Deng, Z.-L. et al. Metatranscriptome analysis of the vaginal microbiota reveals potential mechanisms for protection against metronidazole in bacterial vaginosis. mSphere 3, https://doi.org/10.1128/mSphereDirect.00262-18 (2018).
Brook, I. Inoculum effect. Rev. Infect. Dis. 11, 361–368 (1989).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Xiao, B. et al. Predictive value of the composition of the vaginal microbiota in bacterial vaginosis, a dynamic study to identify recurrence-related flora. Sci. Rep. 6, 26674 (2016).
Verwijs, M. C., Agaba, S. K., Darby, A. C. & Wijgert, J. H. H. Mvande Impact of oral metronidazole treatment on the vaginal microbiota and correlates of treatment failure. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 222, 157.e1–157.e13 (2020).
Article CAS Google Scholar
Allee, W. C. Principles of Animal Ecology (Saunders Co., 1949).
Goswami, M., Bhattacharyya, P. & Tribedi, P. Allee effect: the story behind the stabilization or extinction of microbial ecosystem. Arch. Microbiol. 199, 185–190 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Stein, R. R. et al. Ecological modeling from time-series inference: insight into dynamics and stability of intestinal microbiota. PLoS Comput. Biol. 9, e1003388 (2013).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar
May, R. Stability and Complexity in Model Ecosystems (2001).
Medlock, G. L. et al. Inferring metabolic mechanisms of interaction within a defined gut microbiota. Cell Syst. 7, 245–257 (2018).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Momeni, B., Xie, L. & Shou, W. Lotka-Volterra pairwise modeling fails to capture diverse pairwise microbial interactions. eLife 6, e25051 (2017).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Goldford, J. E. et al. Emergent simplicity in microbial community assembly. Science 361, 469–474 (2018).
Article ADS CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
McKendrick, A. G. & Pai, M. K. XLV.—The rate of multiplication of micro-organisms: a mathematical study. Proc. R. Soc. Edinb. 31, 649–653 (1912).
Article CAS MATH Google Scholar
Marino, S., Hogue, I. B., Ray, C. J. & Kirschner, D. E. A methodology for performing global uncertainty and sensitivity analysis in systems biology. J. Theor. Biol. 254, 178–196 (2008).
Article MathSciNet PubMed PubMed Central MATH Google Scholar
Narikawa, S. Distribution of metronidazole susceptibility factors in obligate anaerobes. J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 18, 565–574 (1986).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Guillén, H., Curiel, J. A., Landete, J. M., Muñoz, R. & Herraiz, T. Characterization of a nitroreductase with selective nitroreduction properties in the food and intestinal lactic acid bacterium Lactobacillus plantarum WCFS1. J. Agric. Food Chem. 57, 10457–10465 (2009).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar
Altschul, S. F. & Koonin, E. V. Iterated profile searches with PSI-BLAST—a tool for discovery in protein databases. Trends Biochem. Sci. 23, 444–447 (1998).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar
Chetwin, E. et al. Antimicrobial and inflammatory properties of South African clinical Lactobacillus isolates and vaginal probiotics. Sci. Rep. 9, 1917 (2019).
Article ADS PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar
Juárez Tomás, M. S., Ocaña, V. S., Wiese, B. & Nader-Macías, M. E. Growth and lactic acid production by vaginal Lactobacillus acidophilus CRL 1259, and inhibition of uropathogenic Escherichia coli. J. Med. Microbiol. 52, 1117–1124 (2003).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar
Castro, J., Rosca, A. S., Cools, P., Vaneechoutte, M. & Cerca, N. Gardnerella vaginalis enhances Atopobium vaginae viability in an in vitro model. Front. Cell. Infect. Microbiol. 10, 83 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Gause, G. F. Experimental demonstration of Volterra’s periodic oscillations in the numbers of animals. J. Exp. Biol. 12, 44–48 (1935).
Google Scholar
Jackman, C. M., Deans, K. W., Forney, L. J. & Lin, X. N. Microdroplet co-cultivation and interaction characterization of human vaginal bacteria. Integr. Biol. 11, 69–78 (2019).
Article Google Scholar
France, M. T., Mendes-Soares, H. & Forney, L. J. Genomic comparisons of Lactobacillus crispatus and Lactobacillus iners reveal potential ecological drivers of community composition in the vagina. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 82, 7063–7073 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
CDC - STD Treatment. https://www.cdc.gov/std/treatment/default.htm (2020).
McKinnon, L. R. et al. The evolving facets of bacterial vaginosis: implications for HIV transmission. AIDS Res. Hum. Retroviruses 35, 219–228 (2019).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Lee, C. Y. et al. Quantitative modeling predicts mechanistic links between pre-treatment microbiome composition and metronidazole efficacy in bacterial vaginosis, chyylee/BV, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4121904 (2020).

Download references

Acknowledgements

This work was in part funded by startup funds from the University of Miami to N.R.K., funds from NIH/NIDDK grant RO1DK112254 to N.R.K., and NIH/NIAID grant R01AI138718 subcontract to N.R.K., and startup funds from the University of Michigan to K.B.A. The UMB-HMP study, J.R. and M.F. were supported by the National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases of the National Institutes of Health under award numbers UH2AI083264 and R01NR015495. The CONRAD BV Study was funded by an intra-agency agreement between the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), United States Aid and International Development (USAID) and CONRAD (GPO-A-00-08-00005-00). The views expressed by the authors do not necessarily reflect those of the funding agency or CONRAD.

Author information

These authors contributed equally: Christina Y. Lee, Ryan K. Cheu.
These authors jointly supervised this work: Nichole R. Klatt, Kelly B. Arnold.

Authors and Affiliations

Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
Christina Y. Lee, Melissa M. Lemke & Kelly B. Arnold
University of Miami Department of Pediatrics, University of Miami, Miami, FL, USA
Ryan K. Cheu, Andrew T. Gustin & Nichole R. Klatt
Department of Pharmaceutics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA
Ryan K. Cheu, Andrew T. Gustin & Nichole R. Klatt
Institute for Genome Sciences and Department of Microbiology and Immunology, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA
Michael T. France & Jacques Ravel
Division of Infectious Diseases and Hospital Epidemiology, University of Zurich, Zürich, Switzerland
Benjamin Hampel
CONRAD, Eastern Virginia Medical School, Norfolk, VA, USA
Andrea R. Thurman & Gustavo F. Doncel
Department of Surgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA
Nichole R. Klatt

Authors

Christina Y. Lee
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Ryan K. Cheu
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Melissa M. Lemke
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Andrew T. Gustin
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Michael T. France
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Benjamin Hampel
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Andrea R. Thurman
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Gustavo F. Doncel
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Jacques Ravel
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Nichole R. Klatt
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Kelly B. Arnold
View author publications
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Contributions

C.Y.L., R.K.C., M.M.L., N.R.K., and K.B.A. conceived and designed the study. C.Y.L. completed the computational analysis and analyzed the clinical data. R.K.C., N.R.K., and B.H. designed and conducted monoculture and co-culture kinetic experiments. A.G., M.F., and J.R. curated data from the UMB-HMP cohort. J.R. led the UMB-HMP study and data collection. A.T. and G.D. provided CONRAD BV protocol development, patient care, and data analysis. C.Y.L., R.K.C., K.B.A., and N.R.K. wrote the manuscript and all authors read and revised the manuscript.

Corresponding authors

Correspondence to Nichole R. Klatt or Kelly B. Arnold.

Ethics declarations

Competing interests

J.R. is co-founder of LUCA Biologics, a biotechnology company focusing on translating microbiome research into live biotherapeutic drugs for women’s health. All other authors declare no competing interests.

Additional information

Peer review information Nature Communications thanks the anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.

Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Supplementary information

Supplementary Information

Peer Review File

Reporting Summary

Source data

Source Data

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Lee, C.Y., Cheu, R.K., Lemke, M.M. et al. Quantitative modeling predicts mechanistic links between pre-treatment microbiome composition and metronidazole efficacy in bacterial vaginosis. Nat Commun 11, 6147 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-19880-w

Download citation

Received: 26 August 2020
Accepted: 28 October 2020
Published: 01 December 2020
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-19880-w

This article is cited by

Lactobacillus iners and Genital Health: Molecular Clues to an Enigmatic Vaginal Species
- Johanna B. Holm
- Kayla A. Carter
- Rebecca M. Brotman
Current Infectious Disease Reports (2023)
Astodrimer sodium and bacterial vaginosis: a mini review
- Werner Mendling
- Wolfgang Holzgreve
Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics (2022)
Vaginom- und „Endometriom“-Diagnostik bei Kinderwunsch
- Wolfgang R. Heizmann
- Christoph Keck
Gynäkologische Endokrinologie (2022)
Bacterial vaginosis: drivers of recurrence and challenges and opportunities in partner treatment
- Lenka A. Vodstrcil
- Christina A. Muzny
- Catriona S. Bradshaw
BMC Medicine (2021)

Comments

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.