Article | Open | Published:

Opposite macroevolutionary responses to environmental changes in grasses and insects during the Neogene grassland expansion

Nature Communicationsvolume 9, Article number: 5089 (2018) | Download Citation

Abstract

The rise of Neogene C4 grasslands is one of the most drastic changes recently experienced by the biosphere. A central - and widely debated - hypothesis posits that Neogene grasslands acted as a major adaptive zone for herbivore lineages. We test this hypothesis with a novel model system, the Sesamiina stemborer moths and their associated host-grasses. Using a comparative phylogenetic framework integrating paleoenvironmental proxies we recover a negative correlation between the evolutionary trajectories of insects and plants. Our results show that paleoenvironmental changes generated opposing macroevolutionary dynamics in this insect-plant system and call into question the role of grasslands as a universal adaptive cradle. This study illustrates the importance of implementing environmental proxies in diversification analyses to disentangle the relative impacts of biotic and abiotic drivers of macroevolutionary dynamics.

Introduction

The emergence and spread of grasslands during the Miocene and Pliocene is one of the most drastic changes recently experienced by the biosphere1. Low latitudes and altitudes grassland ecosystems are dominated by grasses (Poaceae) that employ C4 photosynthetic pathways1,2, and are thereby better adapted to low CO2 conditions than plants using a C3 pathway, especially under warm and dry conditions3. The multiple independent evolutionary origins of C4 pathways has led to suggestions that the major drop in atmospheric CO2 beginning roughly 30 million years ago (Ma) provided conditions conducive to the diversification of C4 grasses and their rise to dominance in many areas at the expense of C3 lineages1,2,4. Fossil phytoliths and paleosols support this hypothesis, indicating that C4 grasses appeared about 20–25 Ma in the geological record5. This pattern is also confirmed by recent molecular phylogenetic studies, which indicate that distinct C4 grass lineages appeared multiple times between the late Oligocene and the late Miocene1, and that the shift from C3 to C4 pathways constituted an important precursor to speciation in the evolutionary history of grasses6. However, it was not until the late Miocene and Pliocene (ca. 3–9 Ma) that C4 grasslands became a major component of Earth’s terrestrial ecosystems across all continents5,7,8. The drop in atmospheric CO2 was likely instrumental in this transition, but other environmental factors, such as the increased intensity of fire regimes, herbivory, and changes in climatic seasonality are likely causal factors8,9,10.

This major biome shift is thought to have had a pivotal role in the evolution of herbivore communities by promoting the diversification of herbivorous lineages associated with C4 grasses11,12,13. Feeding on C4 grasses requires-specific adaptations for the feeders, as tissues from these plants are usually more fibrous than those of C3 plants, due to the higher density of bundles of fibers, veins, and silica phytoliths (reviewed in ref. 14). They also have lower nutritional values than C3 plants because of lower nitrogen and higher carbon contents15,16,17. In mammals, a commonly accepted theory posits that the Neogene grasslands enabled the development of adaptive radiations, favouring lineages of grass eaters following key innovations in dental morphology (hypsodonty), and plant assimilation18. However, this view was recently challenged by studies revealing that hypsodonty originated well before the appearance and spread of Neogene grasslands (e.g. ref. 19). Toljagic et al.20 also demonstrated that the evolution of hypsodonty in ruminants was slower than previously thought, excluding the possibility of its representing an immediate adaptive response. Another study revealed that the hypothesized adaptive radiation of horses coinciding with the spread of grasslands was not correlated to phenotypic evolution and, if anything, impeded by ecological limits21. In herbivorous insects, the role of C4 grasslands as a potential adaptive zone has never been properly investigated even though several independent species-rich lineages are intimately associated with C4 grasses, exhibiting-specific morphological adaptations, such as more heavily chitinized mandibles (e.g., in acridid grasshoppers22), or enlargement of mandibular muscles to cope with silica-rich stems (e.g., in stemborer moths23). Dated phylogenies also provide conflicting evidence, suggesting that diversification of specialized insect lineages either predated (e.g., for satyrine butterflies24), or coincided with (e.g., in anisopliine beetles25) the spread of C4 grasslands. No study to date has quantified whether reciprocal macroevolutionary dynamics occurred between C4 grasses and specialized lineages of herbivores. Under the theory of ecological opportunity26, we can hypothesize that C4 grasslands provided a template for the radiation of specialist herbivores able to colonize this new niche. Alternatively, we could also postulate that the diversification of specialized herbivores may also be unaffected by host diversification, if they remain able to utilize all the descendant hosts of their ancestral host-plants.

To investigate the diversification dynamics of both herbivorous insects and grassland plants in the context of the C3/C4 transition, we study a clade of stemborer moths (Noctuidae: Apameini: Sesamiina) representing a radiation of ca. 200 species, most of which are distributed in their Afrotropical centre of origin27. Sesamiina are mostly associated with C4 grasses28,29,30 and are well-adapted to Afrotropical grasslands, where they constitute one of the most abundant and conspicuous moth group28. Similar to other groups of internal feeders31,32,33,34,35, Sesamiina species are highly specialized; most species only feed on one or a few plant species. In any given locality diverse sesamiine species are also usually associated with distinct sets of host-plants. They constitute a particularly tractable system for studying co-diversification given the expanding body of accurate life history data surrounding host-plant associations.

We explore the macroevolution of Sesamiina stemborers in the light of comprehensive phylogenetic, ecological, and geographic data for both the herbivorous insect group and their host-plants (Supplementary Data 13). To determine whether the origin of Sesamiina and their C4 grass hosts coincided, we conduct phylogenetic and dating analyses on a novel molecular dataset of six loci, comprising 1393 specimens from 245 noctuid species, and historical biogeographic analyses based on a timeframe established for Poaceae6. We also carry out several estimations of ancestral character states to investigate the evolution of host associations, and ecological attributes. To complement these approaches, we use an array of diversification analyses, including a recently developed analytical method36 to test the potential role of several paleoenvironmental proxies within a temporal framework for both insects and plants. As we describe, the double-dating of plant and insect clades shows synchronous origins and radiations, suggesting that they interacted and diversified in parallel. We find strong evidence that, following the origin of both clades, speciation rates of insects decreased, whereas those of grasses increased through time. Our results also reveal opposite macroevolutionary responses to environmental changes with temperature as a primary evolutionary driver. This study confirms that the drop of atmospheric carbon is a key driver for the diversification of C4 grasses. Analyses using organic carbon concentration as a proxy for the proportion of C4 grasses also indicate that the expansion of C4 grasslands did not act as a primary environmental driver for the insects. This study therefore suggests that the rise of C4 grasslands did not necessarily favor the diversification of herbivores that feed on them.

Results

Synchronous temporal and spatial diversification

We assembled a dataset for a group of C4 grass specialist moths with information on geographic distribution, host- and habitat-associations (see Methods). A total of 1393 specimens representing 245 noctuid species (including 181 species of Sesamiina) were sampled for six loci (Supplementary Data 1); this sampling encompasses all described Sesamiina genera and ca. 90% of the described Sesamiina species. Phylogenetic analyses were carried out in maximum likelihood and Bayesian frameworks, using all individuals (specimen-level dataset) and using only one representative per species (species-level dataset). The resulting trees (Supplementary Figures 12) provide a comprehensive and robust picture of Sesamiina relationships (within Sesamiina ca. 80% of nodes are well supported for the species-level dataset). Molecular dating analyses performed on the species-level dataset with Bayesian relaxed clocks using uniform priors and either birth-death (BD) or pure birth tree priors yielded consistent divergence time estimates for the insect clade (Supplementary Figures 34), with the BD model being recovered as the best tree prior (MLEYule = −84,860.12 vs. MLEBD = −84,002.91, Bayes factor » 10). For all downstream analyses, we thus relied on the chronogram obtained with the BD tree prior. Based on this dating analysis, Sesamiina originated ca. 20.7 Ma (95% credibility interval = 17.8–23.2 Ma), and ancestral state estimation (ASE) revealed a high level of phylogenetic niche conservatism (PNC) on C4 lineages of the grass subfamily Panicoideae (Supplementary Figures 5a–b, 6a–b), a diverse group of plants (about 3500 known species) with a worldwide distribution37,38. Sesamiina are mostly associated with the C4 tribe Andropogoneae (1132 species worldwide6) and a large C4 clade (732 species worldwide6) of the tribe Paniceae. These two panicoid clades represent almost two-thirds of the diversity of the subfamily (Sesamiina are rarely associated with the tribe Paspaleae, which is mostly distributed in the Western Hemisphere; Supplementary Data 3). Although the inferred pattern of PNC is conserved (few host-shifts are inferred), ASE analyses indicate that at least 19 nodes represent a generalist state to at least one descendant specialist (Supplementary Figure 5a). These results are particularly relevant in the context of the current debate on the evolution of host-range of phytophagous insects39,40,41, surrounding two hypotheses with different points of emphasis: the oscillation hypothesis (OH), in which speciation is driven by expansions and contractions of host-ranges (usually considered at the plant family level39,40,41), and the musical chairs hypothesis (MCH), where speciation is driven by host-plant shifts, without concomitant changes in host-ranges or diet breadth. Both hypotheses are similar in that they predict more species in clades with more ‘lability’ in host use (Nylin pers. com.). The elevated occurrence of transitions between generalist to specialist states is more consistent with the OH, which predicts that ‘host expansions do not happen with regular frequency and amplitude’41 relative to host breadth contractions, and that clades with such oscillation patterns should be more diverse39,41 than their counterparts. Also consistent with the OH is the observation that: (i) generalist Sesamiina species (such as Sesamia calamistis or S. nonagrioides) tend to be widespread, and (ii) recolonizations of ancestral hosts that have been lost (such as Panicoideae) are common (Supplementary Figure 5a). An increase in speciation rates following inferred shifts in diet breadth was not observed within the Sesamiina clade (see Supplementary Table 1). However, this does not necessarily represent an invalidation of the OH, as the increase of speciation rates linked to host-range oscillations may not be detectable at this macroevolutionary scale; its assessment likely requires denser sampling throughout the stemborer subtribes (especially within the diverse Apameina, which are primarily associated with C3 plants in the Northern hemisphere23) and their relatives.

To get a better understanding of the spatial patterns of the primary sesamiine host-plant group, the Panicoideae, we reconstructed its biogeographic history and infer that the first colonization of the Afrotropics by a panicoid lineage (tribe Paniceae) occurred ca. 21 Ma, slightly before the start of the Sesamiina diversification on the same continent ca. 20.7 Ma (Fig. 1 and Supplementary Figure 7). The early diversification of panicoid lineages in the Afrotropics is mostly attributable to the Paniceae, as Andropogoneae only colonized the Afrotropics in the late Miocene (Supplementary Figure 7). We acknowledge that the origins of Poaceae and internal clades are debated due to a lack of consensus on the use of fossil calibrations. Two main strategies are used here to estimate divergence times of grasses: the first relies on macrofossils that are reliably assigned to a given clade, whereas the second also includes microfossils (phytoliths) whose use in molecular dating is controversial because phytolith characters are usually phylogenetically unreliable42,43. Accordingly, the grass divergence times can vary depending on the calibration strategy. Here we rely on the results of the calibration strategy with macrofossils of the comprehensive study of Spriggs et al.6, which recovered an origin for Paniceae at ca. 21 Ma. Though older age estimates were sometimes inferred from the use of phytoliths6,43, these are questionable because age estimates for C4 grass lineages then significantly predate the fossil record of open grasslands. The ca. 21 Ma age estimate for the Paniceae is also consistent with the results of the macrofossil calibration of Christin et al.43 (median age of 25.4 Ma with a 95% credibility interval = 20.6–31.7 Ma) and with the results of the microfossil calibration of Prasad et al.42 (median age of 20.1 Ma with a 95% credibility interval = 11.5–29.6 Ma). Importantly, it is also in accordance with our inferred origin of stemborer moths (95% credibility interval = 17.8–23.2 Ma). Overall, these results thus support the nearly simultaneous and sympatric origin of both Sesamiina and panicoid grasses, and their co-diversification in the Afrotropics during the early Miocene.

Fig. 1
Fig. 1

Double-dating of associated stemborer moths and grass lineages. Dating analyses of panicoid grasses and stemborer moths reveal synchronous origins and radiations between Afrotropical C4 lineages and their herbivorous moths. Ancestral state estimations show the evolution of photosynthetic pathway for grasses and the evolution of host-type preferences for moths (C3 in green C4 in brown). For illustrative purpose, a picture of Setaria megaphylla (Steud.) T.Durand & Schinz is presented on the left, and a picture of Acrapex subalbissima Berio is figured on the bottom right. Copyright notes: the picture of grass was cropped from “Leaves of Setaria megaphylla at Umdoni Bird Sanctuary, Amanzimtoti, South Africa” by M. Purves, licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0. The picture of the moth was taken by B. Le Ru (last author of the paper)

Diversification rates of moths and grasses are uncorrelated

Having established that Sesamiina and panicoid grasses colonized the Afrotropics roughly at the same time, we investigated whether the diversification dynamic of moths paralleled that of the panicoid grasses. We hypothesized that the spread of C4 grasslands in the Neogene promoted the diversification of moths by providing a newly available resource and ecological opportunity for these insects already associated with Poaceae. To test this hypothesis, we used three independent approaches to estimate the diversification dynamics in each clade. First, we used Bayesian analysis of macroevolutionary mixtures (BAMM44), which found strong support for a single diversification regime showing elevated speciation rates in the early stages of the insect lineage evolution, followed by a progressive slowdown but no drastic downward or upward shift in speciation (Supplementary Table 1 and Supplementary Figure 8a). In contrast, we found evidence for the opposite pattern in panicoid grasses, with lower rates close to the origin of the group and increasing rates of speciation over time, accompanied by two significantly supported upshifts in speciation with the crown tribes Andropogoneae and Paspaleae (Supplementary Table 1 and Supplementary Figure 8b). Because of the potential sensitivity of BAMM45,46, we used two other approaches to test the pattern of inverted diversification rates. Analyses inferring speciation rates as a function of time (RPANDA47) recovered distinct diversification patterns, with decelerating speciation rates for the moths and accelerating speciation rates for the grasses (Fig. 2a). Using episodic BD models (TreePar48), we also recovered two significant shifts in diversification at 13.0 and 1.3 Ma for the moths, both consistent with progressively decelerating diversification (Fig. 2b and Supplementary Table 2). For the panicoid grasses, episodic BD models inferred three shifts of diversification at 20.3, 9.6, and 1.5 Ma but, again contrary to the insect clade, these shifts represented increased diversification (Fig. 2b and Supplementary Table 2b). The congruence of these results suggests that the diversification rates of both groups are inversely correlated. Analyses relying on the binary-state speciation and extinction (BiSSE) model49 recovered very similar net diversification rates for both Afrotropical and non-Afrotropical panicoid lineages (comprised between 0.24 and 0.28 events per Myr per lineage, respectively). Lineages-through-time (LTT) plots show patterns of increasing species accumulation for both Afrotropical and non-Afrotropical panicoid lineages, with no distinct up-shifts and no plateau of diversity (Supplementary Figure 9a–b). By contrast the stemborer LTT plot exhibits a plateau of diversity toward the present (Supplementary Figure 9c). Overall, the extent of the analyses performed suggests that diversification is similar between Afrotropical and non-Afrotropical panicoid lineages; however, we acknowledge the uncertainty underlying this finding because of the incompleteness of the sampling for the panicoid grasses (805 species out of ca. 3500 known species6).

Fig. 2
Fig. 2

Diversification dynamics through time and potential environmental factors. a Diversification dynamics through time for the stemborer moths (blue curve) and the panicoid grasses (green curve) inferred with a time-continuous BD model. b Diversification dynamics through time with an episodic BD model. Both analyses show an opposite trend of speciation rate evolution for moths and grasses. c Analyses of temperature-dependent diversification indicate that past warm climate fostered moth speciation, whereas cooling events boosted grass speciation. d Global temperature inferred from δ18O isotopes in benthic foraminifer shells recovered in marine sediments41. e Analyses linking speciation and past variations in atmospheric CO2 for grasses, suggest higher speciation when CO2 concentration decreases, although the analyses linking for moths show a negative association between speciation and the rise of grasslands. f Potential environmental factors driving the diversification of stemborer moths and panicoid grasses such as the increase of C4 grasses (dark blue curve) reconstructed from δ13C of tooth enamel of mammalian herbivores52, 53, the atmospheric concentration of CO2 (red curve) compiled from multiple sources (notably inferred from δ13C measurements52). Copyright notes: the grass and plant symbols rely on pictures taken by G.J. Kergoat and B. Le Ru (first and last authors of the study, respectively)

Differential responses to environmental changes

We used a maximum-likelihood framework to test competing hypotheses of rate variation based on BD models. Out of 14 diversification models, a model with temperature-dependent speciation best fit the data for both groups (Supplementary Table 3). Best-fit models further indicate a positive correlation (α > 0) between temperature and speciation for the Sesamiina while they show a negative correlation (α < 0) for the panicoid grasses, indicating that the groups had opposite responses to changes of temperature over time. For Sesamiina, speciation rates appear to have been higher under warmer climates while the opposite holds for panicoid grasses (Fig. 2c, d). In Sesamiina, diversification models relying on δ13Corganic (as estimated from stable carbon isotopes; see Methods) as a proxy for the proportion of C4 grasses show a negative correlation (Fig. 2e, f), and are consistently outperformed by diversification models incorporating temperature or time dependence (Supplementary Table 3). The latter and the fact that no upshift in diversification rates was inferred for the Sesamiina during the spread of C4 grasslands suggest that the expansion of C4 grasslands did not act as a primary environmental driver of sesamiine diversification. To confirm this pattern, we performed additional diversification analyses using the recently estimated proportion of C4 plants in Eastern Africa through time50 instead of the global δ13Corganic. We still found that a positive temperature-dependent model best explains the stemborer diversification, and we found a negative C4 grasses-dependent model suggesting a macroevolutionary decorrelation between Afrotropical C4 plants and their herbivores (Supplementary Table 4). In panicoid grasses as a whole (i.e., both C3 and C4 lineages), models accounting for changes in atmospheric CO2 also ranked behind models incorporating temperature or time dependence. However, when independently analyzing the two primary panicoid C4 host-plant lineages (i.e., Andropogoneae and the large clade of Paniceae using a C4 pathway), models accounting for changes in atmospheric CO2 is recovered as best-fit models (Supplementary Table 3). This is consistent with the predictions made by Pagani et al.51 and Edwards et al.1, who postulated that the diversification of C4 grass lineages is correlated positively with the drop in atmospheric CO2 (Fig. 2e, f). It is important to note that the pattern of increasing speciation rates is always recovered for the primary host-plant groups, independently of the clade being considered (panicoid grasses as a whole, Andropogoneae or the major clade of Paniceae).

The contrasting patterns recovered for Sesamiina and panicoid grasses may best be explained by their long-term responses to environmental changes, and in particular to temperature. Grass diversification (C3 and C4 lineages) correlated positively with climatic cooling and, in the main C4 lineages, with the drop in atmospheric CO2. By contrast, lower temperatures appear to have slowed diversification of the insects. Interestingly, changes in temperature over time (Fig. 2d) are also associated with changes in climatic conditions: during the Cenozoic, warmer periods have tended to be associated with wetter conditions, and colder periods are associated with drier conditions, with a shift from moist woodlands/wetlands and predominantly summer rainfall to a range of more arid to semi-arid open habitats and increasingly seasonal rainfall regimes52,53,54. From a biological point of view C4 grasses are less drought sensitive than C3 grasses55, and generally benefit from drier conditions associated with high-light habitats1. In Sesamiina, numerous species are hygrophilous and are distributed in grasslands in contact with wet habitats (e.g., see refs. 29,30 Supplementary Data 2). To investigate whether Sesamiina exhibit a pattern of phylogenetic niche conservatism for a given climatic condition, ASE of moths’ ecological preferences were performed. Results (Supplementary Figure 10) suggest that wet habitat-association is conserved phylogenetically. This leads to the hypothesis that the decrease of wet habitats and the increase of periodically dry conditions associated with progressive temperature drops impeded the diversification of Sesamiina over time.

Role of C4 grasslands in herbivore speciation

Our results also challenge the role of C4 grasslands as a potential adaptive zone, and as a driver for herbivorous insect speciation. The spread of C4 grasslands is usually seen as an ecological opportunity, providing a fertile ground for speciation through adaptation and diversifying selection. Ecological opportunities depend on the availability of novel ecological resources coupled with ease of colonization and/or adaptation or key innovation. Here we argue that the radiation of Sesamiina was likely influenced by two-related ecological opportunities: (i) access to a novel resource—the C4 grasses—in the Afrotropics in the early Miocene, and (ii) a major biome shift that enabled the spread of such C4 grasslands and reflected in the rapid radiation of C4 grasses themselves in the late Miocene. We found that these parallel and extended events impacted insect diversification in different and far less straightforward ways than previously believed.

Our results indicate that the diversification of sesamiine stemborers is tightly linked to the emergence and diversification of C4 grasses at the time when both interacting partners colonized the Afrotropics in the early Miocene. This new ecological resource provided some of the requisite conditions for the radiation of specialist insects. As diversification proceeded, we infer that the magnitude of this novel resource diminished as the window of ecological opportunity closed with the saturation of niche space by new species. Therefore, a core prediction of this scenario is that speciating lineages would undergo early bursts of rapid diversification followed by asymptotic decreases in diversification rates over time56. Here all diversification analyses recover a signal consistent with an early burst pattern of diversification among ancestral Sesamiina, which is thus consistent with a hypothesis of an adaptive radiation in the broad sense. Eventually speciation rates are expected to slow towards an equilibrium as species saturate available niches (in this case, C4 grass species). To test this notion, a diversity-dependent model of diversification57 was used to assess whether the entire Sesamiina clade approached stasis, interpreted as an equilibrium or evolutionary carrying capacity of sorts. In this case, stemborer radiation conforms to a diversity-dependent speciation model (Supplementary Table 5) that predicts a carrying capacity of 240 species (ca. 200 species are known today). This suggests the existence of ecological, and in this case spatio-temporal, limits to moth diversification. Such a scenario is traditionally interpreted as adaptive radiation through the occupation of extrinsic niches or niche filling56.

Yet, niche space of sesamiine stemborers presumably expanded over time both in terms of diversity and abundance due to increased diversification rates of C4 grasses over time, and their rise to dominance starting in the late Miocene (green curve in Fig. 2a–d, see also Supplementary Figure 9a–b  and Supplementary Methods for evidence showing similar C4 species accumulation in Afrotropics and outside)1,6. This increase in niche space therefore constituted a major ecological opportunity for C4-specialist insects. However, instead of the expected upshift of speciation/diversification rates, a decline in the diversification of moths was inferred (blue curves in Fig. 2). The pattern of diversification between moths and C4 grass lineages appears decoupled, as indicated by the fact that models with δ13Corganic dependence (our proxy for the proportion of C4 grasses) are negatively correlated. To explain this counter-intuitive pattern, we postulate that inverse responses to abiotic factors account for differences in the pace of diversification. When the climate changed drastically in the late Miocene, becoming cooler and drier, C4 grasses began an unprecedented radiation that did not confer higher speciation rates to their moth herbivores. In fact, as the climate cooled, sesamiine moths diversified less rapidly despite the fact that their host-plants were thriving.

The marked preference of Sesamiina for wet habitats may have limited the dimensions of their available niche space in an increasingly dry environment. Dry environments also directly influence plant form and phytolith formation in C4 grasses. As underlined by a recent large-scale study on West African grasses58, drier environments are characterized by smaller, more therophytic grass species, which are too small to accommodate all stemborer larval stages. Sesamiina larvae are also sensitive to the high levels of silicon content59. One of the factors promoting phytolith formation (accumulation of silicon) in grasses is evapotranspiration60, which is more important in drier environments61. All of these observations are consistent with a reduction of the availability of suitable niches in dry environments and may reflect or even explain the preference of Sesamiina for wet habitats. An interesting parallel may be drawn here between stemborers and another group of C4-specialists, the grass-feeding Bicyclus butterflies (Nymphalidae, Satyrini), which represent a radiation of ca. 103 species in the Afrotropics62. Nokelainen et al.14 discovered that, when laying eggs, females of Bicyclus safitza (Westwood) preferred shaded habitats characterized by high concentrations of tender grass foliage to open habitats dominated by less readily consumable leaves. We surmise that the advent of drier and more open environments in the late Miocene may have limited the diversification of Sesamiina. Despite representing a highly apparent and diverse food source, the confinement of these grasslands to open and comparatively dry habitats translated to a reduction of potential niche space for these grass-specialist insects.

Discussion

Our study shows that differential responses to environmental changes may yield counter-intuitive patterns of diversification in plants and insects. Although the initial radiation of C4 grasses in the Afrotropics likely met criteria for an adaptive zone in a group of grass-specialist insects, subsequent climatic changes may have driven diversification in a direction opposite that predicted by the inferred spread of C4 grasslands ca. 3–9 Ma. Environment-dependent diversification analyses demonstrate that the diversification of at least two major C4 panicoid grass lineages comprising the primary hosts of Sesamiina was likewise correlated with a drop in atmospheric CO2. The negative correlation between the spread of grasslands calibrated via δ13Corganic proxy and the diversification of Sesamiina further calls into question the role of C4 grasslands as simple drivers of graminivorous herbivores. This study suggests a potentially far more complex picture regarding the role of grasslands as herbivore adaptive zones analogous to the results of recent studies on mammals (e.g. ref. 21). We also illustrate the potential of implementing multiple environmental proxies in diversification analyses that serve to disentangle the relative impacts of biotic and abiotic drivers of macroevolutionary dynamics.

Methods

Moth taxon sampling and molecular dataset

Extensive field surveys conducted since 200428 in 17 sub-Saharan countries and in the Palearctic region (in France and Portugal), targeting wild habitats rich in Poales combining infested host-plant collections and light traps, allowed us to obtain about 80,000 specimens, of which more than 52,000+ larvae were reared (Supplementary Figure 11) from 220 identified species of grasses and sedges. A total of 1389 specimens from 241 noctuid species were sequenced; we also used sequences from GenBank for four additional species (Supplementary Data 1). This sampling encompasses all described Sesamiina genera and ca. 90% of the described species. We sequenced 2.6 kilobases of the mitochondrial genes cytochrome c oxidase I, cytochrome b, ribosomal 12S, and ribosomal 16S, and 2.1 kilobases of the nuclear protein-coding gene elongation factor-1α and the ribosomal 28S. The individual gene fragments were aligned and the reading frames of protein-coding genes checked.

Moth phylogenetics and dating

Partitioning schemes and models of nucleotide substitution were estimated. Phylogenetic relationships for the specimen-level dataset were inferred with maximum likelihood using RAxML63. For the species-level dataset (245 species), we reconstructed phylogenetic relationships with Bayesian inference using MrBayes64, but also with RAxML and IQ-TREE65 for maximum likelihood to estimate branch support in all analyses. Resulting phylogenetic trees were used to estimate divergence times with a Bayesian relaxed-clock approach in BEAST66, with one clock model for the mitochondrial genes and one clock model for the nuclear genes (see Supplementary Methods). Given the scarcity and questionable status of noctuid fossils, we relied on three secondary calibrations (see Supplementary Methods). We used uniform priors to model conservative node calibrations.

Ancestral host-plant associations and ecological preferences

Host-plant associations and ecological preferences (Supplementary Data 2) were determined by field surveys and rearing of larvae from plants collected in the field (see Supplementary Note 1). Host associations were either categorized at the family level (for plants belonging to Cyperaceae and Typhaceae) or at the subfamily level (for plants belonging to Poaceae). We were unable to assign a host-plant state for seven of the 181 species, because only adults were collected; therefore, we coded them as ambiguous. We used multistate ASE to account for the few species that develop on distinct families/subfamilies (10 species associated with distinct plant families; eight species associated with distinct grass subfamilies). Ancestral character states were reconstructed with a maximum likelihood approach as implemented in the DEC model67. We also carried out an analysis of a truncated dataset by pruning all Sesamiina species without genus- or species-specific host-plant data. To avoid favoring the OH over the MCH in the ASE analyses, we used an unconstrained transition matrix allowing any host shift to be equally probable. We also conducted two supplementary analyses with binary traits (see Supplementary Data 2 for the coding). First, we explored the evolution of host-plant preference in relation to photosynthetic pathways (C3 or C4). Second, we inferred the evolution of ecological preferences in relation to dry or wet environments.

Plant phylogeny and biogeography

We studied the origin and diversification of the main host-plant group. As we inferred that Panicoideae was the ancestral state of host-plant preference for the stemborers, we obtained a dated phylogeny for 805 species of Panicoideae by pruning the dated Poaceae tree of Spriggs et al.6. We tested the hypothesis of a synchronous temporal and geographic origin between the Panicoideae and their insect predators (knowing that the radiation of stemborers originated in the Afrotropics27). Ancestral area estimations for Panicoideae were inferred with the DEC model. Species ranges were coded by presence–absence (excluding marginal distribution or anthropic introduction) for seven areas (Afrotropics, Australasia, Eastern Palearctic, Nearctic, Neotropics, Oriental, and Western Palearctic; Supplementary Data 3). The historical biogeography of Panicoideae was estimated with an unconstrained DEC model with only one time slice (see Supplementary Methods for details).

Diversification of insects and plants

We investigated whether the modes of species diversification were similar between the Panicoideae and the insects feeding on them, following a step-by-step procedure that took time-calibrated phylogenies as the basis for the analyses. When possible we took into account age uncertainties (100 randomly selected trees from the posterior distribution of dating analyses). We first estimated whether the clades’ diversification deviates from a constant BD model and if shifts in speciation and extinction rates occurred using three complementary approaches (BAMM44; RPANDA47; and TreePar48). The best-fit model was selected using Bayes factors (BAMM), corrected Akaike information criteria (RPANDA) and likelihood ratio tests (TreePar). We further tested the impact of past environmental changes on the diversification of both clades to assess whether they responded similarly to changing abiotic conditions. An environmental-dependent model was used in which speciation and/or extinction can vary as a function of temporal variation of the environment36. We compiled paleodata (Fig. 2e, f) for variables that have been associated with macroevolutionary hypotheses of diversification and that represent best paleoclimatic changes: temperature data (inferred from δ18O measurements54) and atmospheric CO268. Temperature is the canonical indicator of climate change. Levels of atmospheric CO2 are thought to impact photosynthetic organisms2,3,8. We also obtained δ13Corganic reflecting global changes in organic carbon sequestration69,70. In the Cenozoic, δ13C is the best proxy for reconstructing ancient C4 grasslands as it represents the proportion of C3 and C4 grasses1,2,50,70, and is therefore relevant to test the role of grasslands on the evolution of herbivores that feed on grasses. Recently, a compilation of δ13C for eastern Africa has allowed quantification of the percentage of C4 plants through time50. The percentage of C4 through time provides a more direct test of the role of grasslands. For stemborers we fitted diversification models in which speciation and/or extinction may vary according to dependence with temperature and δ13Corganic/percentage of C4 in eastern Africa. For Panicoideae grasses we fitted models with temperature- and CO2-dependence. These models were compared to constant-rate and time-variable models. Finally, we also used the BiSSE model49 to estimate whether the respective diversification rates of Afrotropical and non-Afrotropical panicoid species are comparable. To do so, first we estimated the number of native Afrotropical panicoid species to be comprised between 900 and (conservative estimate) and 1034 species (see Supplementary Methods for details). We then carried out eight BiSSE models, from the null model (no variation of rates) to the most complex model in which all parameters of speciation, extinction and transition are estimated (see Supplementary Methods for details). We also generated LTT plots for the panicoid grasses, based on a 805 species timetree; distinct plots for both Afrotropical and non-Afrotropical lineages relied on distinct BiSSE analyses, with an estimated diversity of 900 and 1034 species for the Afrotropical lineages. A LTT plot was also generated for the Sesamiina, based on a 181 species timetree.

Data availability

All newly generated sequencing data that support the findings of this study have been deposited in GenBank (accession numbers MH847792-MH853351). All other relevant data are available as Supplementary Data.

Additional information

Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

References

  1. 1.

    Edwards, E. J., Osborne, C. O., Stromberg, C. A. E. & Smith, S. A. C4 Grasses Consortium The origins of C4 grasslands: integrating evolutionary and ecosystem science. Science 328, 587–591 (2010).

  2. 2.

    Tipple, B. J. & Pagani, M. The early origins of terrestrial C4 photosynthesis. Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 35, 435–461 (2007).

  3. 3.

    Keeley, J. E. & Rundel, P. W. Fire and the Miocene expansion of C4 grasslands. Ecol. Lett. 8, 683–690 (2005).

  4. 4.

    Estep, M. C. et al. Allopolyploidy, diversification, and the Miocene grassland expansion. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 111, 15149–15154 (2014).

  5. 5.

    Strömberg, C. A. E. Evolution of grasses and grassland ecosystems. Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 39, 517–544 (2011).

  6. 6.

    Spriggs, E. L., Christin, P. A. & Edwards, E. J. C4 photosynthesis promoted species diversification during the Miocene grassland expansion. PLoS ONE 9, e97722 (2014).

  7. 7.

    Cerling, T. E., Wang, Y. & Quade, J. Expansion of C4 ecosystems as an indicator of global ecological change in the late Miocene. Nature 361, 344–345 (1993).

  8. 8.

    Hoetzel, S., Dupont, L., Schefuß, E., Rommerskirchen, F. & Wefer, G. The role of fire in Miocene to Pliocene C4 grassland and ecosystem evolution. Nat. Geosci. 6, 1027–1030 (2013).

  9. 9.

    Osborne, C. P. Atmosphere, ecology and evolution: what drove the Miocene expansion of C4 grasslands? J. Ecol. 96, 35–45 (2008).

  10. 10.

    Charles-Dominique, T. et al. Spiny plants, mammal browsers, and the origin of African savannas. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 113, E5572–E5579 (2016).

  11. 11.

    Webb, S. D. A history of savanna vertebrates in the New world. Part I: North America. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 8, 355–380 (1977).

  12. 12.

    Clayton, W. D. Evolution and distribution of grasses. Ann. Mo. Bot. Gard. 68, 5–14 (1981).

  13. 13.

    Stebbins, G. L. Coevolution of grasses and herbivores. Ann. Mo. Bot. Gard. 68, 75–86 (1981).

  14. 14.

    Nokelainen, O., Ripley, B. S., van Bergen, E., Osborne, C. P. & Brakefield, P. M. Preference for C4 shade grasses increases hatchling performance in the butterfly, Bicyclus safitza. Ecol. Evol. 6, 5246–5255 (2016).

  15. 15.

    Caswell, H., Reed, F., Stephenson, S. N. & Werner, P. A. Photosynthetic pathways and selective herbivory: a hypothesis. Am. Nat. 107, 465–480 (1973).

  16. 16.

    Barbehenn, R. V., Chen, Z., Karowe, D. N. & Spickard, A. C3 grasses have higher nutritional quality than C4 grasses under ambient and elevated atmospheric CO2. Glob. Change Biol. 10, 1565–1575 (2004a).

  17. 17.

    Barbehenn, R. V., Karowe, D. N. & Spickard, A. Effects of elevated atmospheric CO2 on the nutritional ecology of C3 and C4 grass-feeding caterpillars. Oecologia 140, 86–95 (2004b).

  18. 18.

    MacFadden, B. J. Fossil horses-evidence for evolution. Science 307, 1728–1730 (2005).

  19. 19.

    Jardine, P. E., Janis, C. M., Sahney, S. & Benton, M. J. Grit not grass: concordant patterns of early origin of hypsodonty in Great Plains ungulates and Glires. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 365–366, 1–10 (2012).

  20. 20.

    Toljagic, O. et al. Millions of years behind: slow adaptation of ruminants to grasslands. Syst. Biol. 67, 145–157 (2018).

  21. 21.

    Cantalapiedra, J. L., Prado, J. L., Fernández, M. H. & Alberdi, M. T. Decoupled ecomorphological evolution and diversification in Neogene-Quaternary horses. Science 355, 627–630 (2017).

  22. 22.

    Patterson, B. D. Correlation between mandibular morphology and specific diet of some desert grassland Acrididae (Orthoptera). Am. Midl. Nat. 111, 296–303 (1984).

  23. 23.

    Goldstein, P. Z. & Fibiger, M. F. Biosystematics and evolution of the Apameini: a global synopsis. In Noctuidae Europeae, Vol. 8 Apameini (eds Zilli, A., Ronkay, L. & Fibiger, M.) (Entomological Press, Sorø, Denmark, 2005).

  24. 24.

    Peña, C. & Wahlberg, N. Prehistorical climate change increased diversification of a group of butterflies. Biol. Lett. 4, 274–278 (2008).

  25. 25.

    Micó, E., Sanmartín, I. & Galante, E. Mediterranean diversification of the grass-feeding Anisopliina beetles (Scarabaeidae, Rutelinae, Anomalini) as inferred by bootstrap-averaged dispersal-vicariance analysis. J. Biogeogr. 36, 546–560 (2009).

  26. 26.

    Yoder, J. B. et al. Ecological opportunity and the origin of adaptive radiations. J. Evol. Biol. 23, 1581–1596 (2010).

  27. 27.

    Toussaint, E. F. A. et al. Palaeoenvironmental shifts drove the adaptive radiation of a noctuid stemborer tribe (Lepidoptera, Noctuidae, Apameini) in the Miocene. PLoS ONE 7, e41377 (2012).

  28. 28.

    Le, Ru,B. P., Ong’amo, G. O., Moyal, P., Muchungu, E. & Ngala, L. Major ecological characteristics of East African noctuid stem borers. Ann. Soc. Entomol. Fr. 42, 353–362 (2006).

  29. 29.

    Le, Ru,B. et al. Integrative taxonomy of Acrapex stem borers (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae: Apameini): combining morphology and Poisson Tree Process analyses. Invertebr. Syst. 28, 451–475 (2014).

  30. 30.

    Kergoat, G. J. et al. Integrative taxonomy reveals six new species related to the Mediterranean corn stalk borer Sesamia nonagrioides (Lefèbvre) (Lepidoptera, Noctuidae, Sesamiina). Zool. J. Linn. Soc. 175, 244–270 (2015).

  31. 31.

    Anderson, R. S. An evolutionary perspective of diversity in Curculionoidea. Mem. Entomol. Soc. Wash. 14, 103–114 (1995).

  32. 32.

    Bernays, E. A. & Chapman, R. F. Host-plant Selection by Phytophagous Insects. (Chapman & Hall, London, 1994).

  33. 33.

    Gaston, K. J., Reavy, D. & Valladares, G. R. Intimacy and fidelity: internal and external feeding by the British Microlepidoptera. Ecol. Entomol. 17, 86–88 (1992).

  34. 34.

    Marvaldi, A. E., Sequeira, A. S., O’Brien, C. W. & Farrell, B. D. Molecular and morphological phylogenetics of weevils (Coleoptera, Curculionoidea): do niche shifts accompany diversification? Syst. Biol. 51, 761–785 (2002).

  35. 35.

    Kergoat, G. J., Delobel, A., Le Ru, B. & Silvain, J.-F. Seed-beetles in the age of the molecule: recent advances on systematics and host-plant association patterns. In Researches on Chrysomelidae, Vol. 1 (eds Jolivet, P., Santiago-Blay, J. & Schmitt, M.) (Brill, Leiden, 2008).

  36. 36.

    Condamine, F. L., Rolland, J. & Morlon, H. Macroevolutionary perspectives to environmental change. Ecol. Lett. 16, 72–85 (2013).

  37. 37.

    Zuloaga, F. O., Morrone, O., Davidse, G. & Pennington, S. J. Classification and biogeography of Panicoideae (Poaceae) in the New World. Aliso 23, 503–529 (2007).

  38. 38.

    Soreng, R. J. et al. A worldwide phylogenetic classification of the Poaceae (Gramineae). J. Syst. Evol. 53, 117–137 (2015).

  39. 39.

    Janz, N., Nylin, S. & Wahlberg, N. Diversity begets diversity: host expansions and the diversification of plant-feeding insects. BMC Evol. Biol. 6, 4 (2006).

  40. 40.

    Hardy, N. B. & Otto, S. P. Specialization and generalization in the diversification of phytophagous insects: tests of the musical chairs and oscillation hypotheses. Proc. Biol. Sci. B 281, 20132960 (2014).

  41. 41.

    Janz, N., Braga, M. P., Wahlberg, N. & Nylin, S. On oscillations and flutterings - a reply to Hamm and Fordyce. Evolution 70, 1150–1155 (2016).

  42. 42.

    Prasad, V. et al. Late Cretaceous origin of the rice tribe provides evidence for early diversification in Poaceae. Nat. Commun. 2, 480–480 (2010).

  43. 43.

    Christin, P. A. et al. Molecular dating, evolutionary rates, and the age of the grasses. Syst. Biol. 63, 153–165 (2014).

  44. 44.

    Rabosky, D. L. et al. Rates of speciation and morphological evolution are correlated across the largest vertebrate radiation. Nat. Commun. 4, 1958 (2013).

  45. 45.

    Moore, B. R., Höhna, S., May, M. R., Rannala, B. & Huelsenbeck, J. P. Critically evaluating the theory and performance of Bayesian analysis of macroevolutionary mixtures. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 113, 9569–9574 (2016).

  46. 46.

    Rabosky, D. L., Mitchell, J. S. & Chang, J. Is BAMM flawed? Theoretical and practical concerns in the analysis of multi-rate diversification models. Syst. Biol. 66, 477–498 (2017).

  47. 47.

    Morlon, H. et al. RPANDA: an R package for macroevolutionary analyses on phylogenetic trees. Methods Ecol. Evol. 7, 589–597 (2016).

  48. 48.

    Stadler, T. Mammalian phylogeny reveals recent diversification rate shifts. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 108, 6187–6192 (2011).

  49. 49.

    Maddison, W. P., Midford, P. E. & Otto, S. P. Estimating a binary character’s effect on Speciation and extinction. Syst. Biol. 56, 701–710 (2007).

  50. 50.

    Uno, K. T., Polissar, P. J. & Jackson, K. E. Neogene biomarker record of vegetation change in eastern Africa. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 113, 6355–6363 (2016).

  51. 51.

    Pagani, M., Zachos, J. C., Freeman, K. H., Tipple, B. & Bohaty, S. Marked decline in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations during the Paleogene. Science 309, 600–603 (2005).

  52. 52.

    deMenocal, P. B. African climate change and faunal evolution during the Pliocene-Pleistocene. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 220, 3–24 (2004).

  53. 53.

    Bobe, R. The evolution of arid ecosystems in eastern Africa. J. Arid. Env. 66, 564–584 (2006).

  54. 54.

    Zachos, J. C., Dickens, G. R. & Zeebe, R. E. An early Cenozoic perspective on greenhouse warming and carbon-cycle dynamics. Nature 451, 279–283 (2008).

  55. 55.

    Taylor, S. H. et al. Physiological advantages of C4 grasses in the field: a comparative experiment demonstrating the importance of drought. Glob. Change Biol. 20, 1992–2003 (2014).

  56. 56.

    Rabosky, D. L. Diversity-dependence, ecological speciation, and the role of competition in macroevolution. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 44, 481–502 (2013).

  57. 57.

    Etienne, R. S. et al. Diversity-dependence brings molecular phylogenies closer to agreement with the fossil record. Proc. Biol. Sci. B 279, 1300–1309 (2012).

  58. 58.

    Schmidt, M. et al. Patterns of plant functional traits in the biogeography of West African grasses (Poaceae). Afr. J. Ecol. 49, 490–500 (2011).

  59. 59.

    Calatayud, P.-A. et al. Can climate-driven change influence silicon assimilation by cereals and hence the distribution of lepidopteran stem borers in East Africa? Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 224, 95–103 (2016).

  60. 60.

    Takahashi, E., Ma, J. F. & Miyake, Y. The possibility of silicon as an essential element for higher plants. Comm. Agric. Food Chem. 2, 99–122 (1990).

  61. 61.

    Sage, R. F. The evolution of C4 photosynthesis. New Phytol. 161, 341–370 (2004).

  62. 62.

    Aduse-Poku, K., Brakefield, P. M., Wahlberg, N. & Brattström, O. Expanded molecular phylogeny of the genus Bicyclus (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae) shows the importance of increased sampling for detecting semi-cryptic species and highlights potentials for future studies. Syst. Biodiv. 15, 115–130 (2017).

  63. 63.

    Stamatakis, A. RAxML version 8: a tool for phylogenetic analysis and post-analysis of large phylogenies. Bioinformatics 30, 1312–1313 (2014).

  64. 64.

    Ronquist, F. et al. MrBayes 3.2: efficient Bayesian phylogenetic inference and model choice across a large model space. Syst. Biol. 61, 539–542 (2012).

  65. 65.

    Nguyen, L. T., Schmidt, H. A., von Haeseler, A. & Minh, B. Q. IQ-TREE: a fast and effective stochastic algorithm for estimating maximum-likelihood phylogenies. Mol. Biol. Evol. 32, 268–274 (2015).

  66. 66.

    Drummond, A. J., Suchard, M. A., Xie, D. & Rambaut, A. Bayesian phylogenetics with BEAUti and the BEAST 1.7. Mol. Biol. Evol. 29, 1969–1973 (2012).

  67. 67.

    Ree, R. H. & Smith, S. A. Maximum-likelihood inference of geographic range evolution by dispersal, local extinction, and cladogenesis. Syst. Biol. 57, 4–14 (2008).

  68. 68.

    Beerling, D. J. & Royer, D. L. Convergent Cenozoic CO2 history. Nat. Geosci. 4, 418–420 (2011).

  69. 69.

    Falkowski, P. G. et al. The rise of oxygen over the past 205 million years and the evolution of large placental mammals. Science 309, 2202–2204 (2005).

  70. 70.

    Katz, M. E. et al. Biological overprint of the geological carbon cycle. Mar. Geol. 217, 323–338 (2005).

Download references

Acknowledgements

We would to thank A. Kawahara and P. Arnal for many helpful comments. Financial support was provided by IRD and icipe, African Insect Science for Food and Health, and by the project IMPACT_PHYTO funded by the INRA. Part of the sequencing was also supported by the programme BdV (Project NSBB) supported by a joint CNRS, INRA, and MNHN consortium. Laboratory facilities were provided by CBGP and EGCE in France and icipe in Kenya. We want to thank the numerous people who helped with fieldwork, rearing of larvae, collection permits, or studies of museum material (see Supplementary Note 2 for a detailed list). All specimens were collected under appropriate collection permits and no conflicts of interest were discovered. Mention of trade names or commercial products in this publication is solely for the purpose of providing-specific information and does not imply recommendation or endorsement by the USDA; USDA is an equal opportunity provider and employer.

Author information

Author notes

  1. These authors contributed equally: Gael J. Kergoat, Fabien L. Condamine.

  2. These authors jointly supervised this work: Paul Z. Goldstein, Bruno Le Ru.

Affiliations

  1. CBGP, INRA, CIRAD, IRD, Montpellier SupAgro, University of Montpellier, 755 Avenue du campus Agropolis, 34988, Montferrier-sur-Lez, France

    • Gael J. Kergoat
    •  & Anne-Laure Clamens
  2. CNRS, UMR 5554 Institut des Sciences de l’Evolution de Montpellier, Place Eugène Bataillon, 34095, Montpellier, France

    • Fabien L. Condamine
  3. Florida Museum of Natural History, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, 32611, USA

    • Emmanuel F. A. Toussaint
  4. UMR EGCE (Evolution, Génome, Comportement, Ecologie), CNRS-IRD-Univ. Paris-Sud, IDEEV, Université Paris-Saclay, 1 Avenue de la Terrasse, 91198, Gif-sur-Yvette, France

    • Claire Capdevielle-Dulac
    •  & Bruno Le Ru
  5. MNHN, Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle (Entomologie), 57 rue Cuvier, 75005, Paris, France

    • Jérôme Barbut
  6. USDA, Systematic Entomology Laboratory, Smithsonian Institution, National Museum of Natural History, PO Box 37012, Washington DC, USA

    • Paul Z. Goldstein
  7. IRD c/o ICIPE, NSBB Project, PO Box 30772, Nairobi, Kenya

    • Bruno Le Ru

Authors

  1. Search for Gael J. Kergoat in:

  2. Search for Fabien L. Condamine in:

  3. Search for Emmanuel F. A. Toussaint in:

  4. Search for Claire Capdevielle-Dulac in:

  5. Search for Anne-Laure Clamens in:

  6. Search for Jérôme Barbut in:

  7. Search for Paul Z. Goldstein in:

  8. Search for Bruno Le Ru in:

Contributions

G.J.K., F.L.C., E.F.A.T., P.Z.G., and B.L.R. designed research; J.B. and B.L.R. sampled and identified the specimens; E.F.A.T., C.C.-D., and A.-L.C. generated the molecular data; G.J.K. and F.L.C. analysed the data; and G.J.K., F.L.C., E.F.A.T., P.Z.G., and B.L.R. wrote the paper.

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Gael J. Kergoat.

Electronic supplementary material

About this article

Publication history

Received

Accepted

Published

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-07537-8

Comments

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.