Earth’s modern climate is defined by the presence of ice at both poles, but that ice is now disappearing. Therefore understanding the origin and causes of polar ice stability is more critical than ever. Here we provide novel geochemical data that constrain past dynamics of glacial ice on Greenland and Arctic sea ice. Based on accurate source determinations of individual ice-rafted Fe-oxide grains, we find evidence for episodic glaciation of distinct source regions on Greenland as far-ranging as ~68°N and ~80°N synchronous with ice-rafting from circum-Arctic sources, beginning in the middle Eocene. Glacial intervals broadly coincide with reduced CO2, with a potential threshold for glacial ice stability near ~500 p.p.m.v. The middle Eocene represents the Cenozoic onset of a dynamic cryosphere, with ice in both hemispheres during transient glacials and substantial regional climate heterogeneity. A more stable cryosphere developed at the Eocene-Oligocene transition, and is now threatened by anthropogenic emissions.
One of the most prominent climate changes in our planet’s history involved the transition from early Cenozoic global warmth to the present glaciated state with ice in both hemispheres1,2,3. The timing and cause of this transition is intensely debated3,4,5, largely because of the paucity of sedimentary data from polar regions. Challenging conditions for sample recovery and glacial erosion mean there are few archives of past climate variability available. Studies of the Arctic have focused on a small number of sites and relied upon direct paleoclimate indicators to estimate the onset of ice, including the distribution and chemistry of ice-rafted debris (IRD)6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16, and the occurrence of microfossils that live in or near sea ice15,17. In addition, oxygen isotope (δ18O) records for different oceans provide an indirect proxy of ice volume and have been used to determine the timing of ice sheet appearance3,5,18,19,20,21,22. Other constraints come from proxy reconstructions of high-latitude temperatures23,24,25,26.
Based on these techniques, for decades geoscientists have suggested that activity of the cryosphere during the Cenozoic was initiated with the growth of an Antarctic ice sheet ~34 million years ago (Ma), while glacial ice in the Northern Hemisphere formed ~14–6 Ma1,2,4,6,14,18,19,20,27,28,29,30,31,32. This paradigm argues for two major pulses of Antarctic ice growth, followed by two episodes of Northern Hemisphere ice growth ~20 million years later. The first major glaciation on Antarctica was believed to have occurred near the Eocene-Oligocene boundary, followed by deglaciation, and another major episode of widespread Antarctic ice sheet growth occurred nearly 10 million years later at the Oligocene-Miocene boundary1,2. Based on findings of glacially derived sediments on Iceland and in the North Atlantic and Pacific Oceans6,14,27,33,34,35,36, the onset of ice in the Northern Hemisphere was dated to the late Miocene, with local-scale glaciers developing between 14 and 6 Ma, and an expansion of ice growth to continental-scale glaciation at ~3 Ma.
However, recently some investigations reported evidence for an earlier and more synchronous hemispheric onset of glaciation during the Cenozoic, with the episodic presence of glacial ice3,5,8,12,13 in the Northern Hemisphere and Arctic sea ice13,15,16,17,37 as early as the middle Eocene to Oligocene (~47–34 Ma), possibly linked to declining CO23,13. Sediments recovered from the tropical Pacific Ocean provided detailed records that support simultaneous, but short-lived, glaciation at both poles during the middle Eocene to early Oligocene3,5,21. Specifically, the records show changes in the δ18O of marine carbonates, including benthic foraminifera and the bulk carbonate fraction of sediments largely comprised of coccoliths. Because carbonate δ18O is a marker for changes in temperature and water δ18O, these records reveal synchronous shifts in surface and bottom water hydrography in the tropical Pacific at the same time as changes in the carbonate compensation depth as early as ~44–435 or ~41.53 Ma. Benthic foraminiferal δ18O records were compared with coeval water-temperature estimates that were derived using Mg/Ca thermometry, a technique standard in Cenozoic studies22,38,39,40,41, in order to isolate the temperature and seawater δ18O components of the carbonate δ18O data3,5. Since the growth of ice sequesters 16O and leaves seawater more enriched in 18O, these results revealed evidence for transient episodes of ice growth beginning in the middle Eocene. Furthermore, using a global isotopic mass balance to calculate 18O partitioning between the oceans and ice sheets, these studies inferred the simultaneous presence of ice at both poles, with a minor but significant component of ice storage in parts of the Northern Hemisphere episodically from ~44 Ma3,5. However, one study argued the isotopic variations reported in Pacific sediments were not indicative of global ice volume, because such shifts were not observed in Atlantic sediments4. Yet it is more likely that δ18O records differ between the Pacific and Atlantic because of regional water mass effects and/or other localized artifacts (e.g., hiatuses, carbonate diagenesis).
The middle Eocene timing of the initiation of ephemeral Cenozoic bipolar glaciations inferred from Pacific δ18O records has been supported by more direct evidence, such as the discovery in the Arctic of sea-ice associated diatoms15,17 and iceberg-rafted sediment8,12,13,15,16. Another piece of evidence has been the study of surface textures of quartz grains recovered from the central Arctic Ocean13,15,16, which include dissolution and conchoidal fractures, as both are consistent with transport by sea ice and/or glacial ice. The timing of Arctic IRD and sea ice development was also shown to be broadly consistent with a major decline in atmospheric CO213 inferred from one proxy reconstruction derived from boron isotope-based estimates of seawater pH42.
More recently, Eocene and Oligocene sediment from the Greenland Sea were shown to have IRD, including quartz grains with various surface textures indicative of ice transport8,12. Interpretations of provenance have been limited because surface textures can only provide constraints on transport mechanism(s) and not source regions. Although whole rock element chemistry was used to argue for a possible East Greenland source of IRD between 38 and 30 Ma8, this technique is not considered conclusive at establishing provenance in the Arctic and elsewhere due to the impact of variable mineralogy on the elemental chemistry of bulk rock, and the complex and highly variable mineralogy and petrology of Greenland and circum-Arctic rocks and sediments. These previous interpretations are limited by the fact that the method used cannot prove that Greenland was the only possible source for these grains, which is why this method is generally not used in studies of Quaternary ice rafting. Therefore the provenance of IRD to the Greenland Sea and the extent of glacial ice on Greenland remains unknown.
For this study, we apply a well-established chemical fingerprinting technique9,10,11,37,43 to identify specific regions of origin for individual IRD grains. We constrain Greenland glacial ice and Arctic sea ice dynamics during the middle Eocene through early Oligocene. The occurrence of glacial ice on Greenland was synchronous with episodes of circum-Arctic ice-rafting and, in some cases, with proxies for ice volume and carbon cycle changes. Ephemeral glaciations occurred until the earliest Oligocene, marking the end of the transition from early Cenozoic hothouse conditions to a stable icehouse state.
IRD source fingerprinting
We examined 2029 detrital anhydrous Fe oxide grains from the sand fraction of middle Eocene to early Oligocene sediments recovered at Ocean Drilling Program (ODP) Site 913 (Fig. 1), located 360 km east of Greenland. IRD from these sediments have previously been the subject of study8,12. In total, we examined 100 sediment samples from Site 913 using the chemical fingerprinting method. Sediment sources were determined for ice-rafted grains that were present in 51 core samples. The remaining 49 samples did not contain Fe oxide grains.
Sources of oldest IRD
We find that beginning in the late middle Eocene, IRD originated from multiple sources on Greenland and the circum-Arctic region (Fig. 2), with the oldest sample (~47.1 Ma) containing grains that can be matched to sources in both of these regions (Fig. 3). No samples examined from below this initial IRD peak contained sand-sized or coarser detrital material and no Fe oxide grains were found. The first highly significant influx of ice-rafted Fe oxide grains (≥5 grains from 1 source) from Greenland indicates the presence of glacial ice at 43.6 Ma, followed by several notable peaks in fluxes through 26 Ma (Fig. 3, Supplementary Data 2).
Fingerprinting results for Eocene and Oligocene samples
From 47 to 26 Ma, there are some intervals when there are large numbers of Fe oxide grains (up to 75 Fe oxide grains, where 2 grains would be statistically significant) matched to two specific source areas on Greenland (Figs. 2, 3). In addition, although some Eocene samples do not contain any IRD from Greenland, all of the Oligocene samples we examined do (Table 1), a pattern that is consistent with ephemeral glacial ice on Greenland during the middle and late Eocene.
Specific Greenland source areas
Sources include three regions on East and Southeast Greenland (marked as source areas #42, #43, and #46 in Fig. 1). East Greenland (source area #42 on Fig. 1) is represented by the largest number of ice-rafted Fe oxide grains. The largest contributions from this region are from fjords that contain notable layered intrusives with unique Fe oxide grain compositions. These fjords are known to be sources of large icebergs in recent years44,45. Many of the core samples contain an abundance of Fe oxide grains that can be traced to this small source region (Fig. 2). Southeast Greenland (source area #43) is the source of a significant quantity of Fe oxide grains during major episodes of ice-rafting (Fig. 4; Supplementary Fig. 1–5). The fluxes from this region mimic those from East Greenland sources (#42 and #46), although the Southeast Greenland values are slightly lower than the two combined East Greenland sources.
Comparison with published proxy data
Our results were compared with published proxy data, including indicators of global ice volume. We find that several peaks in IRD sourced from Greenland broadly coincide with times of increasing values of benthic foraminiferal δ18O and/or Pacific water δ18O (Fig. 4). Some, though not all, of these IRD peaks are also synchronous with changes in carbon cycle indices, including increases in the carbonate compensation depth, and low pCO2 (<500 p.p.m.v.) (Fig. 4; Supplementary Fig. 1–5).
Our chemical fingerprinting approach quantitatively measured 14 elements43 in each of 2029 sand-sized detrital Fe oxide grains in sediment samples from the Greenland Sea. The technique enabled us to determine the precise sources of the Fe oxide grains from in the circum-Arctic region and within Greenland. We found that Fe oxide grains could be traced to widespread source areas including the Laptev and Chukchi Seas, the Canadian Arctic Archipelago, and to multiple regions in East and Southeast Greenland (source areas #42, #43, and #46). Sea ice is the likely transport mechanism for grains from many of the circum-Arctic source regions.
However, the probable source of the Fe oxide grains derived from Greenland are icebergs rafted from glacial ice. Glacial transport from Greenland source areas is consistent with the coarse nature of the sediment, the large percentage of quartz grains with evidence of glacial abrasion, and other textural indices8,12. Although sea ice may have been important locally along the Greenland coast for entraining sediments, we note the extent of sea ice in the Greenland Sea today is limited to the shelf along most of East Greenland46. During the middle Eocene through early Oligocene, when global climate was warmer than today, we assume the extent and thickness of sea ice in this region would have likely been substantially reduced. Modeling studies indicate a cyclonic circulation in the Greenland Sea region for the Eocene47, that sea ice was thinner or less extensive than today under these substantially warmer climatic conditions, and that sea-ice drift may have also been significantly faster48. The circuitous route required to reach Site 913 from source areas #42, #43, and #46 makes it likely that grains from these Greenland source areas were dominantly transported by icebergs the >400 km distance from the coast to Site 913 (Fig. 1), and not solely by sea ice, given that only icebergs can survive drifting in open water for tens to hundreds of kilometers.
At times in the Eocene and during the Oligocene, numerous large icebergs would have needed to calve from the East and Southeast Greenland source areas simultaneously, given that only a small percentage of icebergs would reach the core site. For the modern surface circulation, ice-drift models suggest that only a small amount of ice would drift east toward Iceland and then north into the Greenland Sea44,45,49. This drift track covers more than 1000 km and IRD deposition from icebergs decreases dramatically from calving sites to the last melt-out, similar to the thickness decreases seen at different core sites in Heinrich layers50. In order to reach Site 913, most of the icebergs from the Greenland source areas would have drifted south through Denmark Strait44,45,49,51,52. Even in the highly unlikely event the East Greenland Current flowed north instead of south in the past, the straight-line drift distance from source area #43 to Site 913 would be over 1000 km. Therefore only a small fraction of icebergs originating in a given source area on Greenland or elsewhere would have survived to deposit IRD at Site 913. It is likely that some of the observed intervals of IRD in cores from Site 913, which can be up to 2–4 cm in thickness, would likely correspond to time intervals of intense glaciation.
During some glacial maxima, regions as far south as 68o latitude, and at least as far north as source area #46 (~73o latitude), were glaciated. The presence of IRD at Site 913 that was simultaneously delivered from source areas #42, #43, and #46 indicates that glacial ice came from widespread areas across East and Southeast Greenland. Fe oxide grains measured in this study matched to every sample cataloged in the database from these three source areas (Fig. 1) and therefore can be attributed to specific locations. Given that other core samples contain no IRD, these results can be best explained if there were some times that were ice free, and during other time intervals there were ephemeral glaciations that were intense enough to cover these areas simultaneously with glacial ice that produced calving icebergs. Although Greenland was not likely to have been completely ice-covered as it is now, our data identify regions of Greenland that were covered with glaciers during parts of the middle Eocene through early Oligocene.
We note the actual distribution of glacial ice at a given time would reflect a combination of summertime temperatures that would largely be controlled by insolation, topography, and greenhouse gas content, as well as moisture availability. Eocene and Oligocene glacial conditions in the Northern Hemisphere would have been affected by the same factors that influence Miocene–Holocene (~24 Ma-present) climate. In addition to temporal variability, there would also have been significant spatial heterogeneity in conditions due to dynamical processes (e.g., factors such as atmospheric and oceanic circulation and heat transport) that today exert a dominant control over regional differences in climate. During transient glacial maxima, if the calving glaciers that supplied icebergs extended inland to the divide, then glacial ice covering these three areas would encompass about 4.3 × 105 km2 or ~20% of Greenland (black dashed line–Fig. 1). A caveat that limits a more complete assessment of the full extent of ice coverage is that representation in the database for Greenland is limited, with no samples available from the northeastern regions of Greenland to compare to Site 913 (between source areas #1/35 and #46 on Fig. 1). The abundance of Fe oxide grains in many samples from Site 913 indicates that at times, large numbers of icebergs were produced, consistent with the intermittent occurrence of glaciations, with ephemeral glacial maxima that at times spread far inland and supported calving at the coast (Figs. 1, 2).
Fluctuations in numbers of Fe oxide grains from various source regions in samples from Site 913 indicate that when parts of Greenland experienced ephemeral glaciations, sea ice from multiple regions of the Northern, Western, and Southern Arctic also drifted to the core site. The same sediments containing grains derived from Greenland sources also contain IRD from several circum-Arctic regions, including the Canadian Arctic Archipelago, Western and Northwestern Arctic, and the Northeastern and Eastern Arctic (Figs. 1, 2). These findings are indicative of synchronous ice-rafting in from multiple shelf regions around the Arctic. Several of these sources are represented by significant numbers of Fe oxide grains in Site 913 samples. Sources include Banks and Ellef Ringnes Islands in North America, and Franz Josef Land in Russia (source areas #8, #4, and #32, respectively, in Fig. 1). Many other Arctic source areas are represented by the presence of more than two Fe oxide grains in any one sample (e.g., source areas #2, #5, #18, #19, #33, and #39 in Fig. 1). Some of these areas were probably never glaciated given the lack of glacial deposits, their locations and elevations and thus it is likely that at least some of these Arctic Fe oxide grains were transported by sea ice.
We note that alkenone-based sea surface temperatures derived for the ACEX core from the central Arctic Ocean have been interpreted to reflect summer temperatures of between 6–20 °C during the middle Eocene (~47–38 Ma)23. One way to reconcile these two types of data sets, assuming the temperature estimates are robust for this region and time interval, is through geographic and/or temporal variability in conditions. This would require ACEX alkenone data and Site 913 IRD peaks to truly be coeval, and for sea ice to have drifted at a much faster rate, given warmer ocean temperatures and thinner ice48. Average drift rates would need to be as high as 25 cm/s for some sources near Banks Island if the drift were along similar trajectories as today; such rates are more than twice what models predict for near ice-free conditions48. Alternatively, it is also feasible that individual data points in different proxy records from both sites capture different times within orbital cycles or higher-frequency fluctuations, and together, the data sets provide a glimpse into climate variability during the middle Eocene (i.e., with times of glacial ice on Greenland, sea ice in the circum-Arctic, and ice-free conditions represented in the different data sets), our slightly favored explanation, given that the ocean-climate-cryosphere system would have exhibited variability over a range of timescales including millennial and orbital-scale during the Eocene and Oligocene, just as it has throughout Earth’s history. Another possibility is that directly correlating our data from Site 913 to the published records from ACEX is hampered by limitations on age control. These issues can only be addressed through the recovery and study of more complete sedimentary successions from different regions during future research expeditions.
The provenance data for Site 913 pinpoints the origins of IRD in the Greenland Sea to source regions in East Greenland, Southeast Greenland, and the entire circum-Arctic Ocean, which episodically contributed IRD in the middle Eocene and became more stable by the early Oligocene (~34 Ma, Fig. 2). The coincident peaks in our records from these various source regions indicate that episodic glaciation in Greenland was synchronous with periods of ice-rafting from multiple regions around the Arctic Ocean. Therefore the cold conditions necessary for glaciers to develop on Greenland during these intervals also extended to some, if not all, of the terrestrial areas around the Arctic Ocean. A possible analog for the warm glacial regime on Greenland may include present-day British Columbia and Southeastern Alaska, where there are glacial accumulation areas at high elevation with glaciers extending to and calving at sea level, neither of which has perennial sea ice today.
The large variations in IRD accumulation rate and the contribution of IRD from different sources imply that despite it being reduced in volume compared to the Southern Hemisphere cryosphere, the Northern Hemisphere cryosphere was highly dynamic. The large variability in fluxes from Greenland and circum-Arctic sources, with anywhere from 75 to 0 grains matched in a sample, imply a substantially earlier occurrence of ice accumulation on Greenland than the widely accepted timing of 14 to 6 Ma. Because the oldest samples of Greenland-derived IRD from Site 913 date to ~47 Ma, it is likely glacial ice occurred ephemerally on Greenland beginning as early as the middle Eocene. Not all of the middle and late Eocene (~47–34 Ma) samples we examined contain IRD, indicating that at times ice may have disappeared completely (Fig. 4). In some regions, it is possible that a large ice cap or a small ice sheet was only present during cold summer orbits and was initiated in areas of high elevation, with conditions therefore also being conducive to the development of Arctic sea ice. These results are consistent with the presence of an ephemeral, highly dynamic cryosphere in the Northern Hemisphere beginning in the middle Eocene. On Greenland, episodic glaciations in multiple regions provided adequate ice in the form of icebergs to reach Site 913 during intervals of the Eocene and stabilized by the Oligocene. Specifically, every sample we examined from the early Oligocene contains IRD sourced from Greenland, implying that during and after the Oi-1 glaciation (~33.8–33.6 Ma), glacial ice on Greenland was likely more stable and less ephemeral (Fig. 4).
Some of the peaks in the Fe oxide grain data from Site 913 are contemporaneous with known major isotopic excursions in the marine sedimentary record3,22,53,54,55 (Fig. 4). For example, several of the maxima in grains from Greenland and circum-Arctic sources delivered to this site (indicated by blue lines in Fig. 4) are contemporaneous with changes in published records including positive excursions in the Pacific δ18O record3,5,21 which largely reflects temperature and Antarctic ice volume, pCO256,57, and variations in carbonate sedimentation that reflect changes in sea level and carbon cycling3,58 (Fig. 4; Supplementary Fig. 1–5). These times are also periods when some records show notable changes in Southern Ocean surface water hydrography and there are reports of IRD derived from Antarctica59,60,61 (Fig. 5). Several of the maxima at Site 913 also broadly line up with changes in published IRD records from the central Arctic13,15,16,37, although there are differences in sampling resolution, coring gaps, and age model uncertainties (Fig. 3).
Ultimately, our results are consistent with episodic bipolar glaciation and circum-Arctic ice-rafting beginning in the middle Eocene and throughout the early Oligocene. Significantly, results suggest a broadly concurrent Cenozoic onset and history of Arctic sea ice, glacial ice on Greenland, and glacial ice on Antarctica (Fig. 5). Determining the timing and extent of glaciations in the Northern Hemisphere can help to constrain the tectonic and environmental drivers of climate change2. Some have argued that tectonically forced changes in ocean currents circumscribing Antarctica triggered glaciation during the Eocene and Oligocene62,63, while a later onset of Northern Hemisphere glaciation occurred largely because of current-driven heat transport changes resulting from the emergence of the isthmus of Panama64. An earlier timing for the onset of ice in the Northern Hemisphere indicates ocean heat transport was not likely the sole or direct trigger for the Cenozoic initiation of the first glaciations on Greenland, although the oceanic meridional overturning circulation may have served as a feedback mechanism for ice growth and/or a driver of carbon cycle changes.
Others have argued that greenhouse gas levels may have had a role in driving these transitions2,3,13,65, in part based on the timing of ice growth relative to reconstructions of CO2 fluctuations. During the Cenozoic, falling pCO2 may have resulted in temperatures at both poles dropping below critical thresholds for the formation of sea ice and glacial ice3,13. Some studies have hypothesized the polar regions in both hemispheres had relatively similar CO2 thresholds for the onset of glaciation3,13. Alternatively, substantially different CO2 and temperature thresholds may exist for glaciation on Greenland and Antarctica due to differences in land mass, latitude, and solar insolation66. Our data allow us not only to test whether there is evidence for CO2 serving as a critical component of the climate system governing cryospheric evolution during the Cenozoic, but also to evaluate these differing views of thresholds for glaciations.
The IRD source fingerprinting results coincide at times with fluctuations reported in reconstructions of pCO2 derived from multiple marine and terrestrial proxies (Fig. 4; Supplementary Fig. 1–5). Both types of pCO2 reconstructions show changes during the middle Eocene through early Oligocene. Some of the changes observed suggest that at times, maxima in IRD sourced from Greenland coincided with CO2 minima. Comparison with records constraining Northern and Southern Hemisphere polar glacial onset indicates that during multiple intervals, when reconstructed pCO2 values dropped below ~500 p.p.m.v., there is evidence for glacial ice in both hemispheres (Figs. 4, 5). Thus, our results may support an occurrence of glaciations with broadly similar CO2-equivalent and temperature thresholds in both hemispheres3,13.
Other factors that link glaciation to CO2 include insolation and lapse rates. For example, during intervals with relatively low CO2 values and orbital parameters favoring cold polar summers, given thermodynamically constrained values for lapse rates, these times would have been associated with precipitation falling as snow at elevation in the surrounding region, including Greenland, leading to the presence of glacial ice. Figure 5 shows proxy CO2 values that provide a dynamically plausible mechanism for Northern Hemisphere ice during the hothouse-icehouse climate transition of the early Cenozoic.
Significantly, the source fingerprinting method provides evidence that the initiation of glacial ice on Greenland, with a possible large ice cap or even small ice sheet, occurred earlier than previously suggested, and that the occurrence of glacial ice in the middle Eocene to early Oligocene was synchronous with pan-Arctic sea ice. These new observations allow us to critically reevaluate our prior understanding, suggesting that previous theories were only working hypotheses and allowing us to work towards a more complete interpretation. In fact, the Cenozoic initiation of glacial ice on Greenland, and sea ice in the Arctic, was close in timing to the development of Antarctic ice. We find evidence for ephemeral glacial ice and sea ice in the Northern Hemisphere, and times of ice-free conditions, until the Oi-1 glaciation, and for more stable glacial conditions in the early Oligocene. Future studies will provide insights into the history of Northern Hemisphere ice and bipolar glaciations during the Eocene and Oligocene.
To more fully resolve glacial and sea ice dynamics, given coring gaps in current sedimentary archives and limitations with existing age models, it is critical to recover new and complete Cenozoic sedimentary successions from the Arctic and Southern Ocean. Continuous successions will also enable the development of high-resolution records that could provide constraints on the role of orbital forcing in governing cryospheric stability. The ability to generate paired records of IRD and carbonate stable isotope ratios in a single core, which is not possible at Site 913 due to the lack of preserved carbonate, may shed light on past changes in the extent of Greenland ice and on the relative timing of glaciation in the Northern Hemisphere compared to fluctuations in global ice budgets during the Cenozoic. An extension of the Arctic source database to include presently undocumented regions, including in Northeastern Greenland, would place more complete constraints on the spatial extent of ice on Greenland in the past, although some sources may have been eroded away. Such research would shed light on the behavior of an ancient Greenland ice cap or ice sheet under warm and polythermal glacial regimes that presumably existed during the middle Eocene through Oligocene. In addition, the application of the IRD source fingerprinting method and other techniques including weathering proxies, to new and existing sediment core sites, will allow us to gain a more complete picture of Greenland glacial ice and Arctic sea ice dynamics under higher CO2 regimes.
To critically test the hypothesis that glacial ice occurred ephemerally on Greenland beginning in the middle Eocene and became more stable after the Eocene–Oligocene transition, we applied an accurate, precise, and well-established geochemical fingerprinting technique that allows us to identify the specific regions of origin for IRD9,10,11,37,43. By characterizing multi-element signatures of detrital iron oxide minerals that occur in core samples, we are able to isolate sources of IRD over time, determine the sources and shed light on the relative extent of glacial ice on Greenland, and decipher contributions of sea ice from specific circum-Arctic sources during a given interval. We constrain Greenland glacial ice and Arctic sea ice dynamics using data from Site 913 during the middle Eocene through early Oligocene interval (47–26 Ma). We also compare our results with published data, including other proxies for sea ice, glacial ice, and ice volume. Our results are compared to extensive carbon cycle proxy data sets that enable us to study the relationship between Northern Hemisphere cryosphere dynamics and atmospheric pCO2, and to investigate causal mechanisms, such as whether fluctuations in CO2 may have driven the transition to a Cenozoic climate characterized by glacial maxima in both hemispheres, i.e., episodic bipolar glaciations.
Results were compared with published data on IRD, including mass accumulation rates, dropstone occurrence, and Arctic sea ice diatom occurrence12,13,15,37. These records are also compared to a global benthic δ18O and δ13C synthesis, a seawater δ18O synthesis, estimates of the carbonate compensation depth, and reconstructed atmospheric pCO2 from multiple proxies1,3,22,56,57,58. A full list of publications that are the sources of data used for comparison to our results, are listed in the Supplementary Methods.
Fe grain matching
Iron oxides are dominant accessory minerals in most sediments and rocks and are highly durable. Their diverse geochemistry (e.g., with potential substitutions of several elements for Fe in mineral lattices) gives rise to unique regional chemo-geographic patterns. Therefore the chemistry of individual mineral grains can be used to pinpoint each grain’s region of provenance9,43.
Samples were measured and data analyzed blindly at Old Dominion University. The method for precise source determination uses the chemical signature of 14 elements in nine types of iron oxide minerals37,43. The anhydrous detrital Fe oxide grains (Fe grains) were separated magnetically using a hand magnet and the Frantz magnetic separator on the sieved 45–250 μm size fractions. These grains were then mounted in epoxy plugs, polished, and photographed so that each Fe grain could be identified as to location on the photo and mineral type for later analysis on the Cameca SX100 electron probe microanalyzer (EPMA). The mineral identifications were checked after EPMA analysis to insure that the microscopic identification done with a reflected light microscope (1000×) were correct. Each grain was analyzed for 14 elements (Fe, Ti, O, Mn, Mg, Si, Al, Ca, Zn, V, Ni, Cr, Nb, and Ta). Each grain was then matched to grains of the same mineral type from the entire Arctic database of over 39,000 Fe grain analyses for all 14 elements for nearshore and onshore samples taken from 284 sample sites43. These Fe oxides formed in igneous and metamorphic rocks that almost always predated the Eocene (most are much older) and have been eroded and deposited in Pleistocene and younger deposits where they were sampled for the database. Each element has to be within 2 standard deviations of multiple analyses of hundreds of selected grains with high values of each element.
This technique enables us to trace each grain to a specific source region (Fig. 1). The uncertainty of this method has been quantified, with an error rate of incorrect matches of only 1.5%37,43. By characterizing all of the grains in a sediment sample, and by knowing the exact source for each grain, we can determine the multiple regions that contributed IRD present in a sediment sample. When more than one source Fe grain matched to an Fe grain from a sample, the sources were pro-rationed according to how close the analyses were to all 14 elements. This provenance tool has also been compared to the use of lithic grains for source determination in several studies with compatible but far more precise results that are cited in the Supplementary Methods.
Thus, we can ascertain the geographic distribution of glacial ice and sea ice that rafted grains to Site 913. We note that while it is possible that matched Fe oxide grains are from unsampled source areas, the probability of Fe oxide grains having the same chemical fingerprint as grains represented in the source database is low (<0.01)43. Sample coverage for Northeastern Greenland between source areas #35 and #46 is limited, although this region is not known to have recently produced many icebergs. Source area #46 consists of an inner shelf core (PS2641) with 147 samples from every few centimeters down to 266 cm. All Fe oxide grains matched to sources north of Fram Strait were removed from this database in order to ensure that only Fe oxide grains from East Greenland are represented.
Comparison with published records of Arctic sea ice from ACEX
There are data sets for two different sites used to place constraints on Arctic sea ice as shown in Figs. 3–5, and as discussed in the text: (1) Site 913 (IRD provenance data generated in this study shown on the Site 913 age model) and (2) the ACEX site (full list of citations in Supplementary Methods). For ACEX, we note there are two different age models proposed68,69 that yield different ages and place the first appearance of IRD in ACEX a few million years apart, and produce different ice-rafting histories for that site. Therefore we show the results of using each of these age models in Fig. 3, with the different color lines in the bottom panel, as described in the figure caption.
Comparison with ACEX IRD source matching
Estimates for number of ACEX IRD grains that can be matched to a source region comes from a publication37.
Comparison with records of Arctic sea ice
Estimates for Arctic sea ice onset come from multiple publications. Full list of citations in Supplementary Methods.
Site 913 IRD MAR
Estimates of IRD mass accumulation rates at Site 913 come from a publication12.
Comparison with records of Antarctic ice
Estimates for Antarctic ice storage come from multiple publications. Full list of citations in Supplementary Methods.
Composite deep-sea benthic foraminiferal δ 18O and δ 13C
Benthic foraminiferal δ18O and δ13C are a compilation from multiple publications. Full list of citations in Supplementary Methods.
Seawater δ 18O
Reconstructed seawater δ18O from multiple publications. Full list of citations in Supplementary Methods.
Carbonate compensation depth
Reconstructed tropical Pacific and equatorial Pacific CCD from multiple publications. Full list of citations in Supplementary Methods.
Proxy atmospheric CO2 synthesis contains data from multiple publications. Full list of citations in Supplementary Methods.
Zachos, J., Dickens, G. R. & Zeebe, R. E. An early Cenozoic perspective on greenhouse warming and carbon cycle dynamics. Nature 451, 279–283 (2008).
Zachos, J. C., Pagani, M., Sloan, L. C., Thomas, E. & Billups, K. Trends, rhythms, and aberrations in global climate 65 Ma to present. Science 292, 686–693 (2001).
Tripati, A., Backman, J., Elderfield, H. & Ferretti, P. Eocene bipolar glaciation associated with global carbon cycle changes. Nature 436, 341–346 (2005).
Edgar, K. M., Wilson, P. A., Sexton, P. F. & Suganuma, Y. No extreme bipolar glaciation during the main Eocene calcite compensation shift. Nature 448, 908–911 (2007).
Dawber, C. F. & Tripati, A. K. Constraints on glaciation in the middle Eocene (46–37 Ma) from Ocean Drilling Program (ODP) site 1209 in the tropical Pacific Ocean. Paleoceanography 26, PA2208 (2011).
Larsen, H. C. et al. Seven million years of glaciation in Greenland. Science 264, 952–956 (1994).
Wolf-Welling, T. C. W., Cremer, M., O’Connell, S., Winkler, A. & Thiede, J. Cenozoic arctic gateway paleoclimate variability: indications from changes in coarse-fraction composition. In Proceedings of Ocean Drilling Program, Scientific Results Vol. 151 (eds. Thiede, J., Myhre, A. M., Firth, J. V., Johnson, G. L. & Ruddiman, W. F.) 515–568 (Ocean Drilling Program, College Station, TX, 1996).
Eldrett, J. S., Harding, I. C., Wilson, P. A., Butler, E. & Roberts, A. P. Continental ice in Greenland during the Eocene and Oligocene. Nature. 446, 176–179 (2007)
Darby, D. A. & Bischof, J. F. A statistical approach to source determination of Lithic and Fe oxide grains: an example from the Alpha Ridge, Arctic Ocean. J. Sediment. Res. 66, 599–607 (1996).
Bischof, J. F. & Darby, D. A. Quaternary ice transport in the Canadian Arctic and extent of Late Wisconsinan Glaciation in the Queen Elizabeth Islands. Can. J. Earth. Sci. 36, 2007–2022 (1999).
Darby, D. A. The Arctic perennial ice cover over the last 14 million years. Paleoceanography 23, PA1S07 (2008).
Tripati, A. K. et al. Evidence for Northern Hemisphere glaciation back to 44 Ma from ice-rafted debris in the Greenland Sea. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 265, 112–122 (2008)
St. John, K. Cenozoic ice-rafting history of the central Arctic Ocean: Terrigenous sands on the Lomonosov Ridge. Paleoceanography 23, PA1S05 (2008).
St. John, K. E. K. Site 918 IRD mass accumulation rate record, late Miocene-Pleistocene. In Proceedings of the Ocean Drilling Program, Scientific Results Vol 163 (eds. Larsen, H.C., Duncan, R.A., Allan, J.F. & Brooks, K.) 163–166 (Ocean Drilling Program, College Station, TX, 1999)
Stickley, C. E. et al. Evidence for middle Eocene Arctic sea ice from diatoms and ice-rafted debris. Nature 460, 376–379 (2009).
Moran, K. et al. The Cenozoic palaeoenvironment of the Arctic Ocean. Nature 441, 601–605 (2006).
Stickley, C. E. et al. Variability in the length of the sea ice season in the Middle Eocene Arctic. Geology 40, 727–730 (2012).
Miller, K. G., Fairbanks, R. G. & Mountain, G. S. Tertiary oxygen isotope synthesis, sea level history, and continental margin erosion. Paleoceanography 2, 1–19 (1987).
Shackleton, N. J. & Kennett, J. P. Paleotemperature history of the Cenozoic and the initiation of Antarctic glaciation: Oxygen and carbon isotope analyses in DSDP sites 277, 279, and 281. In Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Project 29, 743–755 (1975).
Zachos, J. C., Quinn, T. M. & Salamy, K. A. High-resolution(104 years) deep-sea foraminiferal stable isotope records of the Eocene-Oligocene climate transition. Paleoceanography 11, 251–266 (1996).
Coxall, H. K., Wilson, P. A., Palike, H., Lear, C. H. & Backman, J. Rapid stepwise onset of Antarctic glaciation and deeper calcite compensation in the Pacific Ocean. Nature 433, 53–57 (2005).
Cramer, B. S., Miller, K. G., Barrett, P. J. & Wright, J. D. Late Cretaceous–Neogene trends in deep ocean temperature and continental ice volume: Reconciling records of benthic foraminiferal geochemistry (δ18O and Mg/Ca) with sea level history. J. Geophys. Res. Oceans 116, C12023 (2011).
Stein, R. et al. Cenozoic Arctic ocean climate history: some highlights from the integrated ocean drilling program Arctic coring expedition. In Earth Life Processes Discovered from Subseafloor Environments: A Decade of Science Achieved by the Integrated Ocean Drilling Program (IODP) (eds. Stein, R., Blackman, D. K., Inagaki F. & Larsen, H), 259–293 (2014).
Stein, R. et al. Evidence for ice-free summers in the late Miocene central Arctic ocean. Nat. Commun. 7, 11148 (2016).
Weller, P. & Stein, R. Paleogene biomarker records from the central Arctic Ocean (Integrated Ocean Drilling Program Expedition 302): Organic carbon sources, anoxia, and sea surface temperature. Paleoceanography 23, PA1S17 (2008).
Levy, R. et al. Antarctic ice sheet sensitivity to atmospheric CO2 variations in the early to mid-Miocene. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. 113, 3453–3458 (2016).
Helland, P. E. & Holmes, M. A. Surface textural analysis of quartz sand grains from ODP Site 918 off the southeast coast of Greenland suggests glaciation of southern Greenland at 11 Ma. Palaeogeog. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 135, 109–121 (1997).
Miller, K. G. et al. The Phanerozoic record of global sea-level change. Science 310, 1293–1298 (2005).
Winkler, A., Wolf-Welling, T., Stattegger, K. & Thiede, J. Clay mineral sedimentation in high northern latitude deep-sea basins since the Middle Miocene (ODP Leg 151, NAAG). Int. J. Earth Sci. 91, 133–148 (2002).
Wise Jr, S. W., Breza, J. R., Harwood, D. M., Wei, W., & Zachos, J. Paleogene glacial history of Antarctica in light of leg 120 drilling results. In Proceedings of the Ocean Drilling Program, Scientific Results Vol. 120 (eds. Wise, S. W. et al.) 1001–1030 (Ocean Drilling Program, College Station, TX, 1992)
Barrett, P. J. Antarctic Cenozoic History from CIROS-1 Drill Hole, McMurdo Sound, DSIR Bulletin No. 245 (1989).
Barron, E. J. Explanations of the tertiary global cooling trend. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol. 50, 45–61 (1985).
McDougall, I. & Wensink, H. Paleomagnetism and geochronology of the Pliocene-Pleistocene lavas in Iceland. Earth Planet Sci. Lett. 1, 232–236 (1966).
Shackleton, N. J. et al. Oxygen isotope calibration of the onset of ice-rafting and history of glaciation in the North Atlantic region. Nature 307, 620–623 (1984).
Ruddiman, W. F. & Raymo, M. E. Northern Hemisphere climate regimes during the past 3 Ma: possible tectonic connections. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B 318, 411–430 (1988).
Krissek, L. A. Late Cenozoic ice-rafting records from Leg 145 sites in the North Pacific: late Miocene onset, late Pliocene intensification, and Pliocene–Pleistocene events. in Proceedings of the Ocean Drilling Program, Science Results Vol. 145 (eds. Rea, D. K., Basov, I. A., Scholl, D. W. & Allan, J. F.) 179–194 (Ocean Drilling Program, College Station, TX, 1995).
Darby, D. A. Ephemeral formation of perennial sea ice in the Arctic Ocean during the middle Eocene. Nat. Geosci. 7, 210–213 (2014).
Lear, C., Elderfield, H. & Wilson, P. Cenozoic deep-sea temperatures and global ice volumes from Mg/Ca in benthic foraminferal calcite. Science 287, 269–272 (2000).
Elderfield, H. et al. A record of bottom water temperature and seawater δ18O for the Southern Ocean over the past 440 kyr based on Mg/Ca of benthic foraminiferal Uvigerina spp. Quat. Sci. Rev. 29, 160–169 (2010).
Tripati, A. K. et al. Tropical sea-surface temperature reconstruction for the early Paleogene using Mg/Ca ratios of planktonic foraminifera. Paleoceanography 18, https://doi.org/10.1029/2003PA000937 (2003).
Tripati, A. K. & Elderfield, H. Deep-sea temperature and circulation changes at the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum. Science 308, 1894–1898 (2005).
Pearson, P. & Palmer, M. Atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations over the past 60 million years. Nature 406, 695–699 (2000).
Darby, D. A., Myers, W., Herman, S. & Nicholson, B. Chemical Fingerprinting, A Precise and Efficient Method To Determine Sediment Sources. J. Sediment. Res. 85, 247–253 (2015).
Andrews, J. T., Bigg, G. R. & Wilton, D. Holocene ice-rafting and sediment transport from the glaciated margin of East Greenland (67-70°N) to the N Iceland shelves: Detecting and modelling changing sediment sources. Quat. Sci. Rev. 91, 204–217 (2014).
Wilton, D., Bigg, G. R. & Hanna, E. Modelling twentieth century global ocean circulation and iceberg flux at 48°N: implications for west Greenland iceberg discharge. Prog. Oceanogr. 138, 194–1210 (2015).
Martin, T. & Wadhams, P. Sea-ice flux in the East Greenland Current. Deep Sea Res. Part II Top. Stud. Oceanogr. 46, 1063–1082 (1999).
Handoh, I. C., Bigg, G. R. & Jones, E. J. W. Evolution of upwelling in the Atlantic Ocean basin. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol. 202, 31–58 (2003).
Tremblay, L. B., Schmidt, G. A., Pfirman, S., Newton, R. & Derepentigny, P. Is ice-rafted sediment in a North Pole marine record evidence for perennial sea-ice cover? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. A 373, 20140168 (2015).
Poulain, P.-M., Warn-Varnas, A. & Niiler, P. P. Near-surface circulation of the Nordic seas as measured by Lagrangian drifters. J. Geophy Res 101, 237–258 (1996).
Hemming, S. R. Heinrich events: massive late Pleistocene detritus layers of the North Atlantic and their global climate imprint. Rev. Geophys. 42, 1–43 (2004).
Heburn, G. W. & Johnson, C. D. Simulations of the mesoscale circulation of the Greenland-Iceland-Norwegian Seas. J. Geophys. Res. 100, 4921–4941 (1995).
Aukrust, T. & Oberhuber, J. M. Modeling of the Greenland, Iceland, and Norwegian Seas with a coupled sea ice—mixed layer—isopycnal ocean model. J. Geophys. Res. 100, 4771–4789 (1995).
Peters, S. E., Carlson, A. E., Kelly, D. C. & Gingerich, P. D. Large-scale glaciation and deglaciation of Antarctica during the Late Eocene. Geology 38, 723–726 (2010).
Pekar, S. F., Hucks, A., Fuller, M. & Li, S. Glacioeustatic changes in the early and middle Eocene (51-42 Ma): Shallow-water stratigraphy from ODP Leg 189 1171 (South Tasman Rise) and deep-sea d18O records. GSA Bull. 117, 1081–1093 (2005).
Browning, J., Miller, K. & Pak, D. Global implications of Eocene Greenhouse and Doubthouse sequences on the New Jersey coastal plain; the Icehouse cometh. Geology 24, 639–642 (1996).
Beerling, D. J. & Royer, D. L. Convergent Cenozoic CO2 history. Nat. Geosci. 4, 418–420 (2011).
Franks, P. J. et al. New constraints on atmospheric CO2 concentration for the Phanerozoic. Geophys. Res. Lett. 41, 4685–4694 (2014).
Pälike, H. et al. A Cenozoic record of the equatorial Pacific carbonate compensation depth. Nature 488, 609–614 (2012).
Ehrmann, W. U. et al. History of Antarctic glaciation: An Indian Ocean Perspective. In Synthesis of results from scientific Drilling in the Indian Ocean (eds. Duncan, R. A. & Rea, D.) 423–446 (American Geophysical Union, Washington, D.C., 1992).
Ehrmann, W. U. & Mackensen, A. Sedimentologic evidence for the formation of an East Antarctic ice sheet in Eocene/Oligocene time. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclim. Palaeoecol. 93, 85–112 (1992).
Bohaty, S. & Zachos, J. Significant southern ocean warming event in the late middle Eocene. Geology 31, 1017–1020 (2003).
Kennett, J. P. Cenozoic evolution of antartic glaciation, the circum-Antartic Ocean, and their impact on global paleoceanography. J. Geophys. Res. 82, 3843–3860 (1977).
Lawver, L. A. & Gahagan, L. M. Opening of the Drake Passage and its impact on Cenozoic ocean circulation. In Tectonic Boundary Conditions for Climate Reconstructions (eds. Crowley, T. J. & Burke, K. C.) 212–223 (Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 1998).
Haug, G. H. & Tiedemann, R. Effect of the formation of the Isthmus of Panama on Atlantic Ocean thermohaline circulation. Nature 393, 673–676 (1998).
Lunt, D. J. Late Pliocene Greenland glaciation controlled by a decline in atmospheric CO2 levels. Nature 454, 1102–1105 (2008).
DeConto, R. et al. Thresholds for Cenozoic bipolar glaciation. Nature 455, 652–656 (2008).
Eldrett, J. S., Harding, I. C., Firth, J. V. & Roberts, A. P. Magnetostratigraphic calibration of Eocene-Oligocene dinoflagellate cyst biostratigraphy from the Norwegian-Greenland Sea. Mar. Geol. 204, 91–127 (2004).
Backman, J. et al. Age model and core-seismic integration for the Cenozoic Arctic Coring Expedition sediments from the Lomonosov Ridge. Paleoceanography. 23, PA1S03 (2008).
Poirier, A. & Hillaire-Marcel, C. Improved Os-isotope stratigraphy of the Arctic Ocean. Geophys. Res. Lett. 38, L14607 (2011).
Valdimarsson, H. & Malmberg, S.-A. Near-surface circulation in Icelandic waters derived from satellite tracked drifters. Rit Fisk. 16, 23–40 (1999).
This manuscript is dedicated to the memory of Michele Darby. We thank Robert Eagle for initiating this study, Ruediger Stein, Kate Ledger, Franek Hasiuk, Beth Caissie, and Al Wanamaker, Jr. for their comments on earlier drafts of this manuscript. This project uses samples from the Integrated Ocean Drilling Program. The Fe grain analyses were supported by NSF grant NSF-ARC 1107942. A.T. acknowledges support from the Department of Energy through BES grant DE-FG02-13ER16402 and NSF through CAREER award EAR-1325054. This work was also supported by the “Laboratoire d’Excellence” LabexMER (ANR-10-LABX-19) and co-funded by a grant from the French government under the program “Investissements d’Avenir”.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Edited by B. Joseph
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Tripati, A., Darby, D. Evidence for ephemeral middle Eocene to early Oligocene Greenland glacial ice and pan-Arctic sea ice. Nat Commun 9, 1038 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-03180-5
This article is cited by
Communications Earth & Environment (2022)
Scientific Reports (2022)
Nature Reviews Materials (2021)
Paleocene-Eocene volcanic segmentation of the Norwegian-Greenland seaway reorganized high-latitude ocean circulation
Communications Earth & Environment (2021)
Scientific Reports (2020)