Abstract
Respiratory viruses are an extremely common cause of childhood morbidity. However, the current seroprevalence of viruses in infant populations is difficult to establish because invasive venipuncture may be technically and ethically unacceptable. This prospective study aimed to establish the seroprevalence of respiratory viruses in an infant population by use of a novel multiantigen fluorescence immunoassay against common respiratory viruses, using heel-prick blood samples collected on filter paper. Mothers and babies were recruited in the immediate peripartum period in the Royal Maternity Hospital, Belfast. Cord blood samples at birth and heel-prick filter paper blood samples at 7 mo were collected for measurement of virus-specific IgG to respiratory syncytial virus, influenza A virus, adenovirus, and parainfluenza virus type 1, type 2, and type 3 by indirect immunofluorescence using a multiviral assay developed for this purpose. Of 386 mothers approaches, 325 (84%) permitted follow-up at 7 mo, and of these, 256 (79%) agreed to the heel prick. From 234 paired samples, 125 infections were documented. Adenovirus infections were commonest, 53 (22.6%), followed by respiratory syncytial virus, 32 (13.7%); influenza A virus, 22 (9.4%); parainfluenza virus type 3, 14 (6%); parainfluenza virus type 1, 2 (0.85%); and parainfluenza virus type 2, 2 (0.85%). These results demonstrate the seroprevalence of a range of respiratory viruses in an infant population, using a novel multiviral immunoassay. The filter paper collection of blood samples and multiantigen assay format has implications for easy, widespread viral serodiagnosis in both seroepidemiology studies and in the diagnosis of pediatric viral illnesses. Filter paper permits recovery of respiratory virus-specific IgG and can be used as a simple and acceptable epidemiologic and diagnostic tool.
Similar content being viewed by others
Main
Respiratory viruses are an extremely common cause of childhood morbidity-it is estimated that an average child will experience four to five respiratory illnesses in each of the first 2 y of life(1). Thirty percent of healthy infants acquire lower respiratory tract illnesses severe enough to merit medical attention in the first year of life, of which 60% are bronchiolitis(2). Nasopharyngeal and throat swabs have often been used to establish epidemiologic patterns of respiratory infection(2,3) because collecting blood samples in infancy, whether for purposes of diagnosis or for epidemiologic data collection, is both technically and ethically difficult. As a result the true seroprevalence of viruses in infant populations may be unknown or based on outdated data. In 1939 the use of filter paper was suggested for collection, storage, and transport of blood(4), and since 1963, dried blood on filter paper has been in use for widespread neonatal screening programs to detect phenylketonuria(5). In Northern Ireland it is also used to screen for neonatal hypothyroidism, homocystinuria, and cystic fibrosis. Filter paper minimizes the need for invasive tests, enhances acceptability, and reduces the cumbersome transport difficulties associated with whole-blood samples. Its use has been extended to encompass a wide range of purposes(6–19), including the identification of a variety of viruses(20–24).
This study set out to explore a new multiantigen viral immunofluorescence assay as a potential epidemiologic and diagnostic tool to establish the seroprevalence of respiratory viruses in a pediatric population in Northern Ireland and to evaluate the use of filter paper for blood sample collection.
METHODS
Subjects. The study population consisted of a subsample of mothers from a larger study (n = 386) looking at factors influencing the prevalence and severity of RSV infection in infancy. The subsample included 256 mothers delivering babies in the Royal Maternity Hospital, Belfast (January 9, 1995 to June 12, 1995) who completed an initial and follow-up questionnaire as part of the larger study and permitted collection of both cord blood at birth and a follow-up heel-prick blood sample taken from their infant at 7 mo. A pediatrician (J.K.N.) prospectively enrolled mothers in the immediate perinatal period. Ethical approval was granted by the hospital ethical committee, and written informed consent was obtained before completion of the maternal questionnaire and cord blood analysis. Seven months was chosen for follow-up because the majority were seen by health visitors and follow-up coincided with the 7-mo child surveillance check. Mothers missed by health visitor follow-up were seen at one of three follow-up clinics or at a home visit.
Collection of cord blood samples. Two to three milliliters of cord blood was collected at birth, stored at 4°C until centrifugation and the sera were stored frozen at -70°C until analysis.
Collection of 7-mo heel-prick blood samples. Health visitors performed the majority of heel-prick blood tests at 7 months. Drops of blood fully saturated up to three circles (15-mm diameter) on a filter paper card in routine use for neonatal screening (Summit Printing Systems, Lisburn, Northern Ireland). Blood was allowed to dry at room temperature, packaged in a polythene resealable bag, and posted to the Regional Virology Laboratory where it was frozen at -20°C.
Elution of blood from filter paper. Filter paper cards were defrosted. Three-millimeter-diameter discs were punched from the center of the blood-soaked circles, using a ticket punch (Maun Industries, Mansefield, England). Twenty discs were added to 200 µL of PBS with 0.05% Tween and 1% skimmed milk in a Sarstedt tube (Sarstedt Ltd, Leicester, England). This gave a previously determined serum dilution of 1/10. Each tube was agitated for 30 min at room temperature before centrifugation at 1300 rpm for 5 min. This method has been described previously(22). The eluate was withdrawn and frozen at -70°C.
Immunofluorescence. All cord sera and heel-prick sera were assayed for measles, RSV, IFA, ADV, PF1, PF2, and PF3 specific IgG by a standard indirect immunofluorescence technique. These viruses were chosen because all (except measles) were demonstrated in or grown from other inpatient clinical specimens, reflecting the circulating respiratory viruses in Northern Ireland during the winter period under study; influenza B virus was not included as it was not recovered during the study. The analysis of measles IgG was included as a comparative control to demonstrate diminution of maternally derived antibody between cord sera at birth and heel-prick sera at 7 months.
Infected Cell Preparation. Laboratory isolates of measles and ADV were grown in Vero E6 cells, RSV and PF3 were grown in HEp-2 cells, and IFA, PF1, and PF2 were grown in primary rhesus monkey kidney cells. The cell monolayers were grown in 75-cm2 tissue culture flasks (Bibby Sterilin Ltd, Stone, England). They were infected with stock virus preparations and harvested when approximately 80% of the cells showed a cytopathic effect. The cells were removed with glass beads and centrifuged in a plastic universal bottle (Bibby Sterilin Ltd) at 1500 rpm in a Mistral bench-top centrifuge. They were resuspended in 500 µL of PBS, aliquoted in 100 µL amounts, and stored at -20°C.
Slide preparation. An aliquot of each antigen was thawed. Indirect immunofluorescence with in-house MAb on doubling dilutions of the cell suspensions was used to find the working concentration of the respective antigens; this was chosen as the dilution preceding the one with a noticeable fall-off in fluorescence staining. A 1-µL volume of each antigen at its working dilution was added to each well of a 10-well, multiwell slide, in a predetermined pattern. IFA, measles, and ADV were added at 1, 3, and 5 o'clock positions. PF1, PF2, and PF3 were added at 11, 9, and 7 o'clock, and RSV was added to the center of the well. Each antigen was air-dried before the next was applied, and the completed slide then fixed in acetone for 10 min at 4°C.
Virus IgG assay. Four microliters of cord sera was diluted 1/50 in PBS and 8 µL of heel-prick sera was diluted 1/5 in PBS (final dilution 1/50). Each pair was added to adjacent multiantigen wells, incubated at 37°C for 30 min, washed in PBS for 30 min, and counterstained with goat anti-human IgG FITC conjugate (Sigma Chemical Co, Poole, England). They were washed for 30 min in PBS, mounted with glass cover slips using glycerol saline, and read using a Zeiss IV epifluorescence microscope. Positive and negative control sera and conjugate controls were included in each run. All sera were ranked for strength of antibody reactivity in ascending order of reactivity as -, ±, +, ++, and +++. The presence of virus-specific IgG in heel-prick sera of either equal or greater strength to that seen in the corresponding cord sera was taken to indicate de novo antibody synthesis and childhood infection with that virus.
RESULTS
The larger study population comprised 386 mother and baby pairs of whom 357 (92.5%) were contacted at follow-up. Of 325 (84%) who agreed to continue to participate in the study, 69 (21%) refused the heel prick. Thirty-two (8.3%) refused any follow-up, and 29 (7.5%) could not be traced. Of the 256 mother and baby pairs who permitted both heel prick and questionnaire follow-up, 234 paired cord sera and heel-prick sera were successfully tested. Eleven (4%) of the heel-prick sera had insufficient blood for analysis, and 11 (4%) of the samples were not analyzed either because there was insufficient eluate or because of investigator error or spillage during analysis.
Sixteen of the cord sera were strongly reactive for one of the viral antibodies under assay and were ranked +++; this included nine sera for RSV, two for measles, and one each for the remaining viruses. In the corresponding heel-prick sera the respective antibody became undetectable for 14 of the 16 with the remaining two having a low level of antibody still detectable (rank ±). These were against RSV and PF3.
A total of 100 (43%) children had evidence of respiratory virus infection during the study (Table 1). Seventy-five children had IgG specific for one respiratory virus only. A further 25 had IgG specific for two respiratory viruses (Table 2). The staining pattern of fluorescence was almost always solely against the single virus. Occasional minimal reactivity against a second virus in the panel was also present.
ADV was the most frequently recorded infection (53/234) whereas PF1 and PF2 were the least common (2/234 for each virus). All but one of the cord sera were positive for measles IgG. None of the heel-prick sera had detectable measles IgG.
DISCUSSION
This study introduced a multiantigen fluorescence immunoassay format with paired heel-prick and cord sera to examine exposure to common respiratory viruses in infancy. The filter paper collection of blood samples and multiantigen assay format have implications for easy, widespread viral serodiagnosis in both seroepidemiology studies and the diagnosis of pediatric viral illnesses. A filter paper method of blood collection is a safe and more acceptable option than venipuncture for follow-up serology(22). Of the parents in our study agreeing to questionnaire follow-up, only 21% refused the heel prick.
The format of the immunoassay is designed to maximize the number of tests available from the infected cell preparations by using a minimal number of cells per well. Storage at -20°C with a subsequent single thawing is minimally damaging to the cells and allows the various antigens to be prepared in advance of making the slides without having to synchronize the respective cell cultures. Having multiple antigens (in this case, seven) on each well minimizes the volume of serum and reagents used and the manual labor of the test. It also controls for anticellular staining of each serum by having multiple cell lines assayed concurrently, eliminating a problem encountered with immunofluorescence assays and increasing specificity.
Fall-off in maternally transmitted IgG antibody was controlled for by two qualitative approaches. First, measles was included in the panel of viruses tested because antibody would be expected to be present in the entire cohort of cord sera and would be unlikely to be stimulated by natural infection during the study. All except one of the cord sera, but none of the heel-prick sera, were positive for measles IgG, indicating the likelihood that the latter did not contain residual maternal IgG.
Second, by ranking the cord sera for all viruses, we were able to confirm that only two of the 16 cord sera antibodies ranked +++ had detectable heel-prick sera antibody and that was of the lowest rank (±). From these two parameters we are confident that we were not detecting maternal antibody in the heel-prick sera. It is likely that our criteria for accepting that a childhood infection had occurred, with the viruses under investigation, actually underestimates the true number of infections that have taken place.
In our region we detect ADV in approximately 10% of all feces from children younger than the age of 5, and it is likely that the ADV infections in this study are inclusive of more than the respiratory types. Also detection of group-specific antibody reactivity by parainfluenza-infected cells could have resulted in inaccurate conclusions. However, in practice this did not happen, and we recorded no instance in which there was evidence of infection by more than a single parainfluenza virus type.
The strength of immunofluorescence in the heel-prick sera was noticeably stronger for ADV and, as we suggest, probably indicates infection by more than one serotype. This would result in our detection of a secondary rather than a primary immune response and higher antibody levels. The opposite is true for the respiratory pathogens, especially those with an epidemic transmission pattern, such as RSV. These viruses would be expected to result in a primary infection with the generation of a low level of antibody, which would quickly fall to low or undetectable levels. It is recognized that in a pediatric population (1 mo to 14 y), antibody assay alone may detect only 29% of respiratory viral infections and in infants antigen detection has been shown to be the most accurate method of microbial diagnosis(25). Understandably we recorded a different pattern of reactivity in the cord sera, in which RSV was the strongest antibody detected, indicating repeated maternal exposure to this virus.
Thus, a limitation of this study is the overestimation of the prevalence of ADV as a respiratory pathogen and the likely underestimation of other viruses. However, the profile of exposure to the different respiratory viruses (Table 1), excluding ADV for the reasons mentioned, reflects that seen in our laboratory for confirmed infection using culture and direct antigen detection methods and is comparable with other studies, especially with regard to the relative frequency of RSV infection in the first year(1,2,25–28). We believe this supports the view that our findings are a valid determination of exposure to respiratory viruses in a newborn population during the winter months in Northern Ireland. However, accurate direct comparison with other studies is limited by differing study design, inclusion criteria (different age groups and restriction to analysis of lower respiratory tract infections), and the spectrum of viruses analyzed.
Identifying the exact virus for each illness will permit a more accurate understanding of virus-specific signs and symptoms, prognosis, and complication rates, and would be helpful for infection control purposes. As respiratory viral vaccines become feasible(29,30) it is only by establishing the prevalence and severity of specific viruses in our community that we can progress to consider the risks and benefits of prevention strategies.
This study has combined the advantages of filter paper blood collection with a multiantigen screening approach and has introduced a method that could facilitate future seroepidemiology studies of infectious diseases.
Abbreviations
- RSV:
-
respiratory syncytial virus
- IFA:
-
influenza A virus
- ADV:
-
adenovirus
- PF1:
-
parainfluenza virus type 1
- PF2:
-
parainfluenza virus type 2
- PF3:
-
parainfluenza virus type 3
References
Monto AS, Sullivan KM 1993 Acute respiratory illness in the community. Frequency of illness and the agents involved. Epidemiol Infect 110: 145–160.
Wright AL, Taussig LM, Ray CG, Harrison HR, Holberg CJ 1989 The Tucson Children's Respiratory Study. II. Lower respiratory tract illness in the first year of life. Am J Epidemiol 129: 1232–1246.
Glezen WP, Loda FA, Clyde WA Jr, Senior RJ, Sheaffer CI, Conley WG, Denny FW 1971 Epidemiologic patterns of acute lower respiratory disease of children in a pediatric group practice. J Pediatr 78: 397–406.
Zimmerman E 1939 Die Trockenblutprobe auf Syphilis. Ein Beitrag zu ihrer Vereinfachung. Muench Med Wochenschr 49: 1732–1733.
Guthrie R, Susi A 1963 A simple phenylalanine method for detecting phenylketonuria in large populations of newborn infants. Pediatrics 32: 338–343.
Nikoletti S 1994 Measurement of diptheria and tetanus antitoxin in blood samples collected on filter paper disks. Epidemiol Infect 112: 161–170.
Patel B, Holliman RE 1994 Antibodies to toxoplasma gondii in eluates from filter paper blood specimens. Br J Biomed Sci 51: 104–108.
Coltorti E, Guarnera E, Larrieu E, Santillan G, Aqiuno A 1988 Seroepidemiology of human hydatidosis; use of dried blood samples on filter paper. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 82: 607–610.
Sharma M, Ghosh S, Singal AK, Anand BS, Talwar GP 1994 Use of micro samples of finger prick blood dried on filter paper for a quick and simple dipstick dot-EIA for diagnosis of amebic liver abscess. J Clin Lab Anal 8: 96–98.
Thomas V, Chan W-C 1982 Evaluation of filter paper eluates for sero epidemiological studies on malaria in peninsular Malaysia. Trop Geogr Med 34: 145–149.
Papadea C, Eckman JR, Kuehnert RS, Platt AF 1994 Comparison of liquid and dried blood for neonatal hemoglobinopathy screening: laboratory and programmatic issues. Pediatrics 93: 427–432.
Chace DH, Hillman SL, Millington DS, Kahler SG, Adam BW, Levy HL 1996 Rapid diagnosis of homocystinuria and other hypermethioninemias from newborn blood spots by tandem mass spectrometry. Clin Chem 42: 349–355.
McCann MT, Thompson MM, Gueron IC, Lemieux B, Giguere R, Tuchman M 1996 Methylmalonic acid quantification by stable isotope dilution gas chromatographymass spectrometry from filter paper urine samples. Clin Chem 42: 910–914.
Srivuthana K, Yee HY, Bhambhani K, Elton RM, Simpson PM, Kauffman RE 1996 A new filter paper method to measure capillary blood lead level in children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 150: 498–502.
Macri JN, Anderson RW, Krantz DA, Larsen JW, Buchanan PD 1996 Prenatal maternal dried blood screening with alpha-fetoprotein and free beta-human chorionic gonadotropin for open neural tube defect and Down syndrome. Am J Obstet Gynecol 174: 566–572.
Shi H, Ma Y, Humphrey JH, Craft NE 1995 Determination of vitamin A in dried human blood spots by high performance capillary electrophoresis with laser-excited fluorescence detection. J Chromatogr B Biomed Sci Appl 665: 89–96.
Micic S, Norgaard-Pedersen B 1995 Improved stability of apolipoproteins A-I and B in filter paper blood spots impregnated with ascorbic acid. Clin Chem 41: 1042–1043.
Duoll IJM, Donovan SJ, Wood PJ, Holgate ST 1995 Bloodspot cortisol in mild asthma: the effect of inhaled corticosteroids. Arch Dis Child 72: 321–324.
Furukawa S, Nakachi T, Matsubara T, Yabuta K, Takeuchi T, Baba M 1990 Neonate blood IgE levels on filter paper as indicators of atopic disease. Allergy 45: 375–381.
Faradegan H, Quinn T, Polk BF 1987 Measuring antibodies to human immunodeficiency virus type III on dried blood on filter papers. J Infect Dis 155: 1073–1074.
Shibata M, Takano H, Hironaka T, Hirai K 1994 Detection of human cytomegalovirus DNA in dried newborn blood filter paper. J Virol Methods 46: 279–285.
Condorelli F, Scalia G, Stivala A, Gallo R, Marino A, Battaglini CM, Castro A 1994 Detection of immunoglobulin G to measles virus, rubella virus and mumps virus in serum samples and in microquantities of whole blood dried on filter paper. J Virol Methods 49: 25–36.
Punnarugsa V, Mungmee V 1991 Detection of rubella virus immunoglobulin (IgG) and antibodies in whole blood on Whatman paper: Comparison with detection in sera. J Clin Microbiol 29: 2209–2212.
Farzadegan H, Noori KH, Ala F 1978 Detection of hepatitis-B surface antigen in blood and blood products on filter paper. Lancet 1: 362–363.
Korppi M, Heiskanen-Kosma T, Leininen M, Halonen P 1993 Antigen and antibody assays in the aetiological diagnosis of respiratory infection in children. Acta Paediatr 82: 137–141.
Lina B, Valette M, Foray S, Luciani J, Stagnara J, See DM, Aymard M 1996 Surveillance of community-acquired viral infections due to respiratory viruses in Rhone-Alpes (France) during winter 1994-1995. J Clin Microbiol 34: 3007–3011.
Taussig LM, Wright AL, Morgan WJ, Harrison JR, Ray CG 1989 The Tucson Children's Respiratory Study. I. Design and implementation of a prospective study of acute and chronic respiratory illness in children. Am J Epidemiol 129: 1219–1231.
Cogswell JJ, Halliday DF, Alexander JR 1982 Respiratory infections in the first year of life in children at risk of developing atopy. BMJ 284: 1011–1013.
Englund JA, Mbawuike IN, Hammill H, Holleman MC, Baxter BD, Glezen WP 1993 Maternal immunization with influenza or tetanus toxoid vaccine for passive antibody protection in young infants. J Infect Dis 168: 647–656.
Tristram DA, Welliver RC, Hogerman DA, Hildreth SW, Paradiso P 1994 Second year surveillance of recipients of a respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) F protein subunit vaccine, PFP-1: evaluation of antibody persistence and possible disease enhancement. Vaccine 12: 551–556.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank the midwives in the Royal Maternity Hospital, Belfast, for their assistance in procuring cord bloods, the health visitors throughout Northern Ireland for their help with follow-up, and the parents who gave permission for their infants to participate in the study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Supported by a Research Fellowship from the Department of Health and Social Services, the Northern Ireland Mother and Baby Appeal, and a Royal Group of Hospitals Research Grant.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nelson, J., Shields, M., Stewart, M. et al. Investigation of Seroprevalence of Respiratory Virus Infections in an Infant Population with a Multiantigen Fluorescence Immunoassay Using Heel-Prick Blood Samples Collected on Filter Paper. Pediatr Res 45, 799–802 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1203/00006450-199906000-00003
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1203/00006450-199906000-00003