Abstract
Many patients experience recurrent ischemic events despite optimal antiplatelet therapy. This has generated much interest in finding a laboratory test of platelet function to identify such patients, who have been termed 'nonresponders' or antiplatelet 'resistant'. Laboratory tests of platelet function have identified 'resistance' in 5–60% of patients taking aspirin and 4–30% of those taking clopidogrel. However, these tests of 'resistance' have not correlated closely with subsequent recurrent events, and have not reliably identified nonresponders to antiplatelet therapy. Here, we identify and discuss three major limitations common to all these tests. Firstly, they are performed on citrate-anticoagulated blood, secondly, blood is stored for a variable period of time, and thirdly, the assessment of thrombotic status on the basis of platelet response to only one or two agonists ignores the complexity of the mechanism of platelet thrombus formation in vivo. In this Review we discuss the significance of these important limitations, and the applicability of such in vitro platelet function tests to the prediction of in vivo events. We conclude that such tests are so unphysiological that they cannot reliably predict the true thrombotic status of patients. Identification of 'resistance' on the basis of these tests lacks sensitivity and specificity for identifying thrombotic risk, and is likely to be artifactual.
Key Points
-
We believe that the true thrombotic status of patients cannot be assessed using currently available in vitro tests and, therefore, the existence of 'resistance' to antiplatelet therapy is questionable
-
Most data on 'resistance' to antiplatelet drugs are provided by platelet aggregometry, modified thromboelastography, the platelet function analyzer 100 (PFA-100)®a and VerifyNow®b assays
-
With the exception of thrombin, physiological platelet stimuli do not cause secondary aggregation, granule release and thromboxane A2 generation in native blood
-
The use of citrated blood with critically low Ca2+ distorts the in vivo effect of platelet agonists and antagonists
-
None of the currently available in vitro tests of platelet function allow the assessment of thrombin generation by activated platelets
aDade international, Inc., Deerfield, IL.
bAccumetrics, Inc., San Diego, CA.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 12 print issues and online access
$209.00 per year
only $17.42 per issue
Buy this article
- Purchase on Springer Link
- Instant access to full article PDF
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Gurbel, P. A. et al. Evaluation of dose-related effects of aspirin on platelet function: results from the Aspirin-Induced Platelet Effect (ASPECT) study. Circulation 115, 3156–3164 (2007).
Gum, P. A. et al. Profile and prevalence of aspirin resistance in patients with cardiovascular disease. Am. J. Cardiol. 88, 230–235 (2001).
Gum, P. A., Kottke-Marchant, K., Welsh, P. A., White, J. & Topol, E. J. A prospective, blinded determination of the natural history of aspirin resistance among stable patients with cardiovascular disease. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 41, 961–965 (2003).
Mueller, M. R. et al. Variable platelet response to low-dose ASA and the risk of limb deterioration in patients submitted to peripheral arterial angioplasty. Thromb. Haemost. 78, 1003–1007 (1997).
Grotemeyer, K. H., Scharafinski, H. W. & Husstedt, I. W. Two-year follow-up of aspirin responder and aspirin non responder. A pilot-study including 180 post-stroke patients. Thromb. Res. 71, 397–403 (1993).
Mani, H., Linnemann, B., Luxembourg, B., Kirchmayr, K. & Lindhoff-Last, E. Response to aspirin and clopidogrel monitored with different platelet function methods. Platelets 17, 303–310 (2006).
Nguyen, T. A., Diodati, J. G. & Pharand, C. Resistance to clopidogrel: a review of the evidence. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 45, 1157–1164 (2005).
Gurbel, P. A. et al. The relation of dosing to clopidogrel responsiveness and the incidence of high post-treatment platelet aggregation in patients undergoing coronary stenting. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 45, 1392–1396 (2005).
Gurbel, P. A. & Tantry, U. S. Drug insight: clopidogrel nonresponsiveness. Nat. Clin. Pract. Cardiovasc. Med. 3, 387–395 (2006).
Gurbel, P. A. & Tantry, U. S. Aspirin and clopidogrel resistance: consideration and management. J. Interv. Cardiol. 19, 439–448 (2006).
Barnes, G. D. et al. Dual antiplatelet agent failure: a new syndrome or clinical nonentity? Am. Heart J. 154, 732–735 (2007).
Christiaens, L., Ragot, S., Mergy, J., Allal, J. & Macchi, L. Major clinical vascular events and aspirin-resistance status as determined by the PFA-100 method among patients with stable coronary artery disease: a prospective study. Blood Coagul. Fibrinolysis 19, 235–239 (2008).
Sweeny, J. M., Gorog, D. A. & Fuster, V. Antiplatelet drug 'resistance'. Part 1: mechanisms and clinical measurements. Nat. Rev. Cardiol. 6, 273–282 (2009).
Zucker, M. B. & Grant, R. A. Nonreversible loss of platelet aggregability induced by calcium deprivation. Blood 52, 505–513 (1978).
Shattil, S. J. & Brass, L. F. The interaction of extracellular calcium with the platelet membrane glycoprotein IIb-IIIa complex. Nouv. Rev. Fr. Hematol. 27, 211–217 (1985).
Moore, E. W. Ionized calcium in normal serum, ultrafiltrates, and whole blood determined by ion-exchange electrodes. J. Clin. Invest. 49, 318–334 (1970).
Scarborough, R. M. Development of eptifibatide. Am. Heart J. 138, 1093–1104 (1999).
Ts'ao, C. H., Lo, R. & Raymond, J. Critical importance of citrate–blood ratio in platelet aggregation studies. Am. J. Clin. Pathol. 65, 518–522 (1976).
Legrand, D. A. & Scheen, A. J. [Aspirin resistance in diabetic patients: laboratory entity or clinical reality?]. Rev. Med. Liege 62, 610–615 (2007) (in French).
Scheen, A. J. & Legrand, D. Aspirin and clopidogrel resistance in patients with diabetes mellitus. Eur. Heart J. 27, 2900–2901 (2006).
Fogh-Andersen, N., McNair, P., Moller-Petersen, J. & Madsbad, S. Lowered serum ionized calcium in insulin treated diabetic subjects. Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. Suppl. 165, 93–97 (1983).
Viigimaa, M., Tsikas, D. & Frolich, J. C. Platelet aggregation, sensitivity to prostaglandin E1 and thromboxane A2 release in recombinant hirudin- and heparin-anticoagulated blood. Blood Coagul. Fibrinolysis 7, 259–261 (1996).
Weiss, H. J., Turitto, V. T., Vicic, W. J. & Baumgartner, H. R. Effect of aspirin and dipyridamole on the interaction of human platelets with sub-endothelium: studies using citrated and native blood. Thromb. Haemost. 45, 136–141 (1981).
Lalau, K. C., Kinlough-Rathbone, R. L., Packham, M. A., Suzuki, H. & Mustard, J. F. Conditions affecting the responses of human platelets to epinephrine. Thromb. Haemost. 60, 209–216 (1988).
Mann, K. G., Whelihan, M. F., Butenas, S. & Orfeo, T. Citrate anticoagulation and the dynamics of thrombin generation. J. Thromb. Haemost. 5, 2055–2061 (2007).
Mills, D. C., Robb, I. A. & Roberts, G. C. The release of nucleotides, 5-hydroxytryptamine and enzymes from human blood platelets during aggregation. J. Physiol. 195, 715–729 (1968).
Hevelow, M. E., McKenzie, S. M. & Siegel, J. E. Reproducibility of platelet function testing. Lab. Hematol. 13, 59–62 (2007).
Vilen, L. et al. ADP-induced platelet aggregation in young female survivors of acute myocardial infarction and their female controls. Acta Med. Scand. 217, 9–13 (1985).
Michno, A. et al. Alterations of adenine nucleotide metabolism and function of blood platelets in patients with diabetes. Diabetes 56, 462–467 (2007).
Vilen, L., Jacobsson, S., Wadenvik, H. & Kutti, J. ADP-induced platelet aggregation as a function of age in healthy humans. Thromb. Haemost. 61, 490–492 (1989).
Mustard, J. F., Perry, D. W., Kinlough-Rathbone, R. L. & Packham, M. A. Factors responsible for ADP-induced release reaction of human platelets. Am. J. Physiol. 228, 1757–1765 (1975).
Cattaneo, M., Gachet, C., Cazenave, J. P. & Packham, M. A. Adenosine diphosphate (ADP) does not induce thromboxane A2 generation in human platelets. Blood 99, 3868–3869 (2002).
Rossi, E. C. & Lousi, G. A time-dependent increase in the responsiveness of platelet-rich plasma to epinephrine. J. Lab. Clin. Med. 85, 300–306 (1975).
Madsen, N. J., Holmes, C. E., Serrano, F. A., Sobel, B. E. & Schneider, D. J. Influence of preparative procedures on assay of platelet function and apparent effects of antiplatelet agents. Am. J. Cardiol. 100, 722–727 (2007).
LaRosa, C. A. et al. Human neutrophil cathepsin G is a potent platelet activator. J. Vasc. Surg. 19, 306–318 (1994).
Selak, M. A. Neutrophil elastase potentiates cathepsin G-induced platelet activation. Thromb. Haemost. 68, 570–576 (1992).
Renesto, P. & Chignard, M. Enhancement of cathepsin G-induced platelet activation by leukocyte elastase: consequence for the neutrophil-mediated platelet activation. Blood 82, 139–144 (1993).
Amaro, A. et al. Plasma leukocyte elastase concentration in angiographically diagnosed coronary artery disease. Eur. Heart J. 16, 615–622 (1995).
Collier, A. et al. Neutrophil activation detected by increased neutrophil elastase activity in type 1 (insulin-dependent) diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Res. 10, 135–138 (1989).
Piwowar, A., Knapik-Kordecka, M. & Warwas, M. Concentration of leukocyte elastase in plasma and polymorphonuclear neutrophil extracts in type 2 diabetes. Clin. Chem. Lab. Med. 38, 1257–1261 (2000).
Kinlough-Rathbone, R. L., Perry, D. W., Rand, M. L. & Packham, M. A. Effects of cathepsin G pretreatment of platelets on their subsequent responses to aggregating agents. Thromb. Res. 95, 315–323 (1999).
Egger, G., Kukovetz, E. M., Hayn, M. & Fabjan, J. S. Changes in the polymorphonuclear leukocyte function of blood samples induced by storage time, temperature and agitation. J. Immunol. Methods 206, 61–71 (1997).
Camenzind, V. et al. Citrate storage affects thrombelastograph analysis. Anesthesiology 92, 1242–1249 (2000).
Heptinstall, S. & Fox, S. C. Human blood platelet behaviour after inhibition of thromboxane synthetase. Br. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 15 (Suppl. 1), 31S–37S (1983).
Bartele, V., Cerletti, C., Schiepatti, A., di Minno, G. & de Gaetano, G. Inhibition of thromboxane synthetase does not necessarily prevent platelet aggregation. Lancet 1, 1057–1058 (1981).
Perneby, C., Wallen, N. H., Rooney, C., Fitzgerald, D. & Hjemdahl, P. Dose- and time-dependent antiplatelet effects of aspirin. Thromb. Haemost. 95, 652–658 (2006).
Meen, O. et al. No case of COX-1-related aspirin resistance found in 289 patients with symptoms of stable CHD remitted for coronary angiography. Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. 68, 185–191 (2008).
Freund, M. et al. Experimental thrombosis on a collagen coated arterioarterial shunt in rats: a pharmacological model to study antithrombotic agents inhibiting thrombin formation and platelet deposition. Thromb. Haemost. 69, 515–521 (1993).
Lepantalo, A., Beer, J. H., Siljander, P., Syrjala, M. & Lassila, R. Variability in platelet responses to collagen—comparison between whole blood perfusions, traditional platelet function tests and PFA-100. Thromb. Res. 103, 123–133 (2001).
Ardlie, N. G., McGuiness, J. A. & Garrett, J. J. Effect on human platelets of catecholamines at levels achieved in the circulation. Atherosclerosis 58, 251–259 (1985).
Soloviev, M. V., Okazaki, Y. & Harasaki, H. Whole blood platelet aggregation in humans and animals: a comparative study. J. Surg. Res. 82, 180–187 (1999).
Lanza, F. et al. Epinephrine potentiates human platelet activation but is not an aggregating agent. Am. J. Physiol. 255, H1276–H1288 (1988).
Williams, M. S., Kickler, T. S., Vaidya, D., Ng'alla, L. S. & Bush, D. E. Evaluation of platelet function in aspirin treated patients with CAD. J. Thromb. Thrombolysis. 21, 241–247 (2006).
Kambayashi, J. et al. Prevalence of impaired responsiveness to epinephrine in platelets among Japanese. Thromb. Res. 81, 85–90 (1996).
Scrutton, M. C., Clare, K. A., Hutton, R. A. & Bruckdorfer, K. R. Depressed responsiveness to adrenaline in platelets from apparently normal human donors: a familial trait. Br. J. Haematol. 49, 303–314 (1981).
Kattlove, H. & Gomez, M. H. Collagen-induced platelet aggregation: the role of adenine nucleotides and the release reaction. Thromb. Diath. Haemorrh. 34, 795–805 (1975).
Moritz, M. W., Reimers, R. C., Baker, R. K., Sutera, S. P. & Joist, J. H. Role of cytoplasmic and releasable ADP in platelet aggregation induced by laminar shear stress. J. Lab. Clin. Med. 101, 537–544 (1983).
Agarwal, S., Coakley, M., Reddy, K., Riddell, A. & Mallett, S. Quantifying the effect of antiplatelet therapy: a comparison of the platelet function analyzer (PFA-100) and modified thromboelastography (mTEG) with light transmission platelet aggregometry. Anesthesiology 105, 676–683 (2006).
Alstrom, U., Tyden, H., Oldgren, J., Siegbahn, A. & Stahle, E. The platelet inhibiting effect of a clopidogrel bolus dose in patients on long-term acetylsalicylic acid treatment. Thromb. Res. 120, 353–359 (2007).
Dyszkiewicz-Korpanty, A., Olteanu, H., Frenkel, E. P. & Sarode, R. M. Clopidogrel anti-platelet effect: an evaluation by optical aggregometry, impedance aggregometry, and the Platelet Function Analyzer (PFA-100). Platelets. 18, 491–496 (2007).
Geiger, J. et al. Monitoring of clopidogrel action: comparison of methods. Clin. Chem. 51, 957–965 (2005).
Kotzailias, N. et al. Clopidogrel-induced platelet inhibition cannot be detected by the platelet function analyzer-100 system in stroke patients. J. Stroke Cerebrovasc. Dis. 16, 199–202 (2007).
Paniccia, R. et al. Different methodologies for evaluating the effect of clopidogrel on platelet function in high-risk coronary artery disease patients. J. Thromb. Haemost. 5, 1839–1847 (2007).
Holmes, M. B., Sobel, B. E. & Schneider, D. J. Variable responses to inhibition of fibrinogen binding induced by tirofiban and eptifibatide in blood from healthy subjects. Am. J. Cardiol. 84, 203–207 (1999).
Jaremo, P., Lindahl, T. L., Fransson, S. G. & Richter, A. Individual variations of platelet inhibition after loading doses of clopidogrel. J. Intern. Med. 252, 233–238 (2002).
Patel, P., Gonzalez, R., Dokainish, H. & Lakkis, N. Impact of adenosine diphosphate and calcium chelation on platelet aggregation testing in patients receiving clopidogrel therapy. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 47, 464–465 (2006).
Michelson, A. D. et al. Evidence that pre-existent variability in platelet response to ADP accounts for 'clopidogrel resistance'. J. Thromb. Haemost. 5, 75–81 (2007).
Ataullakhanov, F. I., Pohilko, A. V., Sinauridze, E. I. & Volkova, R. I. Calcium threshold in human plasma clotting kinetics. Thromb. Res. 75, 383–394 (1994).
Kirchhofer, D., Tschopp, T. B., Steiner, B. & Baumgartner, H. R. Role of collagen-adherent platelets in mediating fibrin formation in flowing whole blood. Blood 86, 3815–3822 (1995).
Panes, O. et al. Human platelets synthesize and express functional tissue factor. Blood 109, 5242–5250 (2007).
Viisoreanu, D. & Gear, A. Effect of physiologic shear stresses and calcium on agonist-induced platelet aggregation, secretion, and thromboxane A2 formation. Thromb. Res. 120, 885–892 (2007).
Leon, C. et al. Platelet ADP receptors contribute to the initiation of intravascular coagulation. Blood 103, 594–600 (2004).
Wagner, W. R. & Hubbell, J. A. Evidence for a role in thrombus stabilization for thromboxane A2 in human platelet deposition on collagen. J. Lab. Clin. Med. 119, 690–697 (1992).
Ratnatunga, C. P., Edmondson, S. F., Rees, G. M. & Kovacs, I. B. High-dose aspirin inhibits shear-induced platelet reaction involving thrombin generation. Circulation 85, 1077–1082 (1992).
Undas, A., Brummel-Ziedins, K. E. & Mann, K. G. Antithrombotic properties of aspirin and resistance to aspirin: beyond strictly antiplatelet actions. Blood 109, 2285–2292 (2007).
Wallen, N. H. & Ladjevardi, M. Influence of low- and high-dose aspirin treatment on thrombin generation in whole blood. Thromb. Res. 92, 189–194 (1998).
Dorsam, R. T., Tuluc, M. & Kunapuli, S. P. Role of protease-activated and ADP receptor subtypes in thrombin generation on human platelets. J. Thromb. Haemost. 2, 804–812 (2004).
van der Meijden, P. E. et al. Platelet P2Y12 receptors enhance signalling towards procoagulant activity and thrombin generation. A study with healthy subjects and patients at thrombotic risk. Thromb. Haemost. 93, 1128–1136 (2005).
Frelinger, A. L. III. et al. The active metabolite of prasugrel inhibits adenosine diphosphate- and collagen-stimulated platelet procoagulant activities. J. Thromb. Haemost. 6, 359–365 (2008).
Roald, H. E. et al. Clopidogrel—a platelet inhibitor which inhibits thrombogenesis in non-anticoagulated human blood independently of the blood flow conditions. Thromb. Haemost. 71, 655–662 (1994).
Zimmermann, N. & Hohlfeld, T. Clinical implications of aspirin resistance. Thromb. Haemost. 100, 379–390 (2008).
Gori, A. M. et al. Incidence and clinical impact of dual nonresponsiveness to aspirin and clopidogrel in patients with drug-eluting stents. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 52, 734–739 (2008).
Mega, J. L. et al. Cytochrome P450 polymorphisms and response to clopidogrel. N. Engl. J. Med. 360, 354–362 (2009).
Simon, T. et al. Genetic determinants of response to clopidogrel and cardiovascular events, N. Engl. J. Med. 360, 363–375 (2009).
Collett, J. P. et al. Cytochrome P450 2C19 polymorphism in young patients treated with clopidogrel after myocardial infarction: a cohort study. Lancet 373, 309–317 (2009).
Trenk, D. et al. Cytochrome P450 2C19 681G>A polymorphism and high on-clopidogrel platelet reactivity associated with adverse 1-year clinical outcome of elective percutaneous coronary intervention with drug-eluting or bare-metal stents. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 51, 1925–1934 (2008).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gorog, D., Sweeny, J. & Fuster, V. Antiplatelet drug 'resistance'. Part 2: laboratory resistance to antiplatelet drugs—fact or artifact?. Nat Rev Cardiol 6, 365–373 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1038/nrcardio.2009.13
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nrcardio.2009.13
This article is cited by
-
Insights into platelet pharmacology from a cryo-EM structure of the ABCC4 transporter
Nature Cardiovascular Research (2023)
-
Point-of-care platelet function tests: relevance to arterial thrombosis and opportunities for improvement
Journal of Thrombosis and Thrombolysis (2021)
-
PEAR1 is not a major susceptibility gene for cardiovascular disease in a Flemish population
BMC Medical Genetics (2017)
-
Enhanced pre-operative thrombolytic status is associated with the incidence of deep venous thrombosis in patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty
Thrombosis Journal (2014)
-
De invloed van aspirinedosis en glycemische controle op plaatjesremming bij patiënten met diabetes mellitus type 2
Nederlands Tijdschrift voor Diabetologie (2012)