Abstract
As rodlike domains pinch off owing to Rayleigh instabilities, a finite-time singularity occurs as the interfacial curvature at the point of pinch-off becomes infinite. The dynamics controlling the interface become independent of initial conditions and, in some cases, the interface attains a universal shape1. Such behaviour occurs in the pinching of liquid jets and bridges2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9 and when pinching occurs by surface diffusion10,11,12. Here we examine an unexplored class of topological singularities where interface motion is controlled by the diffusion of mass through a bulk phase. We show theoretically that the dynamics are determined by a universal solution to the interface shape (which depends only on whether the high-diffusivity phase is the rod or the matrix) and materials parameters. We find good agreement between theory and experimental observations of pinching liquid rods in an Al–Cu alloy. The universal solution applies to any physical system in which interfacial motion is controlled by bulk diffusion, from the break-up of rodlike reinforcing phases in eutectic composites13,14,15,16 to topological singularities that occur during coarsening of interconnected bicontinuous structures17,18,19,20, thus enabling the rate of topological change to be determined in a broad variety of multiphase systems.
Similar content being viewed by others
Main
As pinch-off is approached, the length and timescales near the singularity become much smaller than the scale of the initial conditions that caused the singularity to form. In this regime the interfacial morphology can be written in scale-independent self-similar coordinates2. Experimental investigations of self-similar evolution that determine both the interfacial morphology and dynamics near topological singularities have largely been confined to multiphase fluids. In some cases, the interface asymptotically approaches a symmetric cone shape as the time of pinch-off is approached. For pinching by surface diffusion, a countable set of solutions can be identified, each with a different cone angle. A stable solution is found for only the largest cone angle, and thus the geometry of the system close to pinching is universal12. This universality has not been observed experimentally. There is no corresponding analysis for pinching through mass diffusion in the bulk phases.
We examine the evolution of interfacial morphology of liquid rods in a solid matrix. An Al–15 wt.% Cu alloy is employed along with 4D synchrotron radiation-based tomographic microscopy. The interfaces evolve by bulk diffusion of solute through the high-diffusivity liquid21. The rods were created by holding a 1-mm-diameter sample isothermally 5 °C above the eutectic temperature to form a solid–liquid mixture. The interfacial morphology of liquid rods was observed in situ using tomographic microscopy at the TOMCAT beamline of the Swiss Light Source over a 12 h period22,23 (see Methods for details). Hundreds of pinching events were observed during this time. Figure 1 shows one such pinching event.
To determine whether a self-similar solution exists near pinch-off, we define a set of self-similar variables in cylindrical coordinates:
where r is the radial coordinate of the interface position, t is time, z is the axial coordinate, ts is the time of the singularity, η and ξ are the radial and axial coordinates in the time-independent similarity variables, B is a scaling constant dependent on material properties and α is an exponent specific to the process. The system is assumed to be symmetric about the z and ξ axes.
We assume that the diffusion coefficient of solute in the solid, DS=0 in the surrounding solid, and that interface motion is slow compared with the time required for the diffusion field to relax. Thus the diffusion field in the liquid is given by a solution to Laplace’s equation:
where CL is the solute concentration in the liquid. We seek a solution to (2) consistent with the boundary conditions. The first is the Gibbs–Thomson equation
where CL is the solute concentration on the liquid side of the interface, CL0 and CS0 are the equilibrium solute concentrations at a flat interface, d0 is the capillary length and H is the mean interfacial curvature. The other boundary condition is the interfacial mass balance,
where v is the interfacial velocity in the direction normal to the interface, DL is the diffusion coefficient in liquid and ∂ CL/∂ n is the derivative of the concentration field in the normal direction.
We seek a similarity solution to (2) consistent with the boundary conditions by defining the difference between the solute concentration in the liquid and the equilibrium concentration in terms of a scaled concentration in similarity variables, K(ξ,η):
where A is a scaling constant dependent on materials properties. Substituting (5) into (3) and (4) and using (1), we find that α=−β=1/3 is required for a self-similar solution consistent with the boundary conditions and Laplace’s equation. From (3) and (4), a similarity solution also requires that B=(DLd0)−1/3 and A=(CL0−CS0)(d02/DL)1/3. The interfacial coordinates thus scale as r∼z∼[DLd0(ts−t)]1/3.
If the pinching process is self-similar, the diameter of the rod should decrease as (t−ts)1/3. Using data such as those shown in Fig. 1, we can determine whether this is the case in the experiment. As the data are obtained in three dimensions, it is possible to view the rod along its axis to measure accurately its smallest cross-section or diameter. Figure 2 shows that the diameter decreases linearly as (t−ts)1/3 for a single pinching rod. This behaviour was also observed in the 19 other pinching events investigated. These data suggest the presence of self-similar interfacial evolution, and we thus proceed to examine theoretically the interfacial morphology near the topological singularity.
Using the similarity variables of (1), the interfacial morphology, both before and after pinching, was determined numerically using a boundary-integral method (see Methods for details). The solid–liquid interface position is given by the function η=f(ξ), along which K(ξ,η) is equal to the interfacial curvature. After pinch-off, solutions were found for the shape of the two receding tips at any cone angle, consistent with previous findings for the pinch-off of rods by surface diffusion10. Before pinch-off, we find a discrete set of solutions for various cone angles, where the cone angle is defined as twice the angle of the interface from the ξ axis as . For diffusion inside the rod, we find solutions for cone angles of 30° and 76°; see Fig. 3. Further solutions are expected at cone angles smaller than 30°. However, as in the surface-diffusion-limited case12, we expect that only the solution with the largest cone angle is stable and thus observable experimentally.
Additionally, we find that, for pinching by bulk diffusion outside the rod, the stable solution has a cone angle of 80° (with unstable solutions also expected but not identified). Examples where this shape would be found include the pinch-off of solid rods surrounded by liquid in Al–Cu at lower volume fractions of solid24 and the pinching of atomically ordered eutectic intermetallic rods embedded in an atomically disordered intermetallic matrix25.
The similarity solution for the interface shape η=f(ξ) determines the prefactor of the temporal power law of the pinching event. Using (1), the radius at the centre (ξ=0) of a pinching liquid rod, R(t), evolves as
where f(0)=0.60 and 0.37 for the solutions with cone angles of 76°, and 30°, respectively; see Fig. 3. Thus, sufficiently close to the singularity, the time dependence of the radius is independent of initial conditions and is a function of only f(0) and materials parameters.
Theory thus suggests that, as the topological singularity is approached, the interfacial shape may be universal; it does not depend on the initial conditions of the rod and materials system, and the kinetics of the pinching process are described by a simple temporal power law. This unique solution will also determine the shape before and after the pinching event. However, two issues remain to be addressed before we can conclude that the pinching process is universal: most importantly, whether the quasistationary approximation will hold sufficiently close to the pinch-off for universality to be observed, and second, whether there is evidence for similarity shapes with cone angles other than 76°.
To assess the validity of the quasistationary approximation, we define the characteristic length scale l as the diameter of the pinching rod, and the characteristic timescale τ as
Writing the diffusion equation in dimensionless form after scaling by these characteristic length and timescales, we obtain
where is the dimensionless time, c is concentration, is the dimensionless Laplacian and ε=[2f(0)]3d0/l. The quasistationary approximation is valid as long as ε≪1. Using f(0)=0.60 and the capillary length for the solid–liquid interface in Al–Cu, d0=2.27 nm (ref. 27), the quasistationary approximation holds as long as the rod diameter is much greater than 3.9 nm, well below the 1.48 μm resolution of the tomography.
We test the theory by comparing the kinetics predicted by the similarity solution with experimental data on the evolution of rod diameter. From (6), the slope of the line shown in Fig. 2 is related to the materials parameters and f(0), the interface location in similarity variables at ξ=0. Linear slopes were determined for 19 pinching events on the basis of diameters measured for at least three time steps before ts. The average slope was 1.35 μm s−1/3 with a standard deviation of 0.211 μm s−1/3. From (6), the predicted slope, or prefactor, is given by 2f(0)(DLd0)1/3 (the factor of two converts radius to diameter). Using DL=8.3×10−10 m2 s−1 (ref. 26), d0=2.27 nm (ref. 27) and f(0)=0.60, the theoretically predicted prefactor is 1.47 μm s−1/3. This is within 0.57σ of the experimentally measured prefactor, indicating an excellent agreement between theory and experiment, given the uncertainties in the materials parameters. If we had used, instead, f(0) for the solution with a cone angle of 30°, the predicted prefactor would be 0.91 μm s−1/3, or 2.1σ below the value measured experimentally. Any other possible solutions will have cone angle smaller than 30° and a smaller f(0) (ref. 12), so the predicted prefactor would be even smaller. This suggests that only the solution with a cone angle of 76° is observable experimentally. Moreover, the agreement between theory and experiment is excellent from very early in the pinching process.
As a further test of the theory, a three-dimensional representation of the theoretically predicted interface shape was created. We aligned the experimental data to the theoretically predicted shape for the solution with a cone angle of 76°, and linearly scaled the predicted shape such that the diameter at the centre of the pinching rod was the same as that measured experimentally (see Methods for details). The distance from the theoretically predicted shape to the closest point on the experimentally measured shape was calculated; see Fig. 4. As expected, the agreement between theory and experiment improved as the singularity is approached, because initial conditions have less influence and the shape becomes locally determined. Just before pinch-off, the mean deviation between shapes is less than the 1.48 μm resolution of the X-ray tomographic microscopy scan, indicating excellent agreement between theory and experiment. Even in the region where the experimentally measured shape differs most from the theory (lower right of Fig. 4d), the measured cone angle is 66°–71° (using the experimental error of 0.74 μm). Very similar diagrams result if we plot the distance between the experimentally measured and theoretically predicted shapes in similarity variables, confirming that the improved agreement as ts is approached is not just a result of the changing length scale. In some cases, the initial shapes of the rods were asymmetric about the pinching axis, but still decayed at the rate predicted by the symmetric solution. In all 19 cases examined the agreement between theory and experiment improved as the singularity was approached. Thus, to the resolution of the tomography, the experiments confirm that, some distance from the pinching point, the shape approaches a cone with the predicted cone angle of 76°.
Both the interfacial morphology and dynamics of the pinching process measured experimentally agree with the predictions of theory for the solution with a cone angle of 76°, implying that the shape with the highest cone angle is the only stable shape. We therefore conclude that the pinching process under interfacial-energy-driven bulk diffusion is governed by a unique self-similar solution.
We find that topological singularities in a system evolving by a previously unexplored class of dynamics exhibit universal behaviour. Furthermore, the dynamics of the pinching process by capillarity-induced bulk diffusion agree very well with those predicted theoretically, even early in the pinching process, when the interfacial morphology is not precisely that given by theory. The theory also shows that self-similar shapes exist when pinching occurs by diffusion outside the rod, and we conjecture that the shape with the largest cone angle is also universal. As the prefactor of the temporal power law is in agreement with theory from very early in the evolution of the morphological instability, the universal behaviour caused by the approaching singularity exhibits itself far before the singularity occurs. These results are applicable to a variety of systems that exhibit topological singularities, such as eutectic and bicontinuous two-phase mixtures, and could be used, for example, to calculate the time required for a non-symmetric bicontinuous mixture to lose continuity in one phase, which results in a dramatic change in properties of the material.
Methods
Numerical solution for shape.
We seek a solution for the shape of the solid–liquid interface in similarity variables, η=f(ξ), or defined parametrically F=η−f(ξ)=0, assuming axial symmetry about ξ. Laplace’s equation and the boundary conditions (3), (4) were transformed into the self-similar coordinate system. Green’s third identity was used along with the free-space Green’s function for Laplace’s equation to yield an integrodifferential equation for the scaled concentration K(ξ,η) on the interface:
where g is the free-space Green’s function for Laplace’s equation, g=1/|r(ξ0,η0)−ri(ξ,η)|, n is the unit normal vector to the interface and r(ξ0,η0) and ri(ξ,η) are the field and source points, respectively. On the boundary, the concentration difference from equilibrium can be written in terms of the Gibbs–Thomson condition in similarity variables
because . The solute-conservation boundary condition can used in combination with the material derivative for the interface to find ∂ K/∂ n on the boundary
where the subscripts denote partial differentation. Substituting (8) and (9) into (7) gives a set of integrodifferential equations for f(ξ). Boundary conditions on f(ξ) are that f(ξ) approaches a straight line with angle θc/2 (where θc is the cone angle) from the ξ axis as and f′(0)=0, which ensures finite curvature at the origin.
The integrodifferential equations were discretized, and the angular integral was rewritten as a complete elliptic integral of the first kind and approximated using the polynomial approximation of ref. 28. The integration was carried out numerically using the trapezoidal rule on a truncated domain along ξ. A Taylor expansion was used to approximate integrable singularities when ξ=ξ0. Newton’s method was then used to iteratively solve for f(ξ). A coarse grid spacing along ξ was used to search for solutions as θc was varied. The grid spacing was refined using solutions from the coarse mesh as an initial guess to narrow down the exact cone half-angle to ±1°. Convergence was tested by varying the grid spacing and by varying truncation length in the ξ-direction; second-order convergence was obtained.
Experiment.
Al–15 wt% Cu was directionally solidified to form Al-rich dendrites. In preparation for X-ray tomographic microscopy, 1-mm-diameter samples were cut from the original ingot and mounted in a custom-made sample furnace. The samples were coarsened in situ at 565 °C, and data were collected in real time using X-ray tomographic microscopy at the TOMCAT beamline located at the X02DA port of the Swiss Light Source at the Paul Scherrer Institut (Villigen, Switzerland). An energy of 20 keV was used with 80 ms exposure time, and 721 projections were captured over the 180° of rotation. A total of 1,024 slices, with a spatial resolution of 1.48 μm3 per voxel, were collected at 150 s intervals for the first 4.5 h and at 450 s for the remaining 7.5 h. The tomograms were then converted to binary using sample-specific algorithms created in the IDL software package. Further information about the TOMCAT beamline and the details of the experiment can be found in refs 22 and 23, respectively.
Data analysis.
In preparation for analysis, three-dimensional arrays from the experiment were smoothed to remove alignment and reconstruction artefacts from the interface. The arrays were then imported into the visualization program Amira, and the arrays were cropped to an individual pinching event. The pinch-off diameters (that is, the minimum diameters at the centre) were measured using Amira. The theoretically predicted shape was also imported into Amira and the principal (or longitudinal) axes of the experimental shapes were then aligned with the theoretically predicted shape by aligning the two shapes to the axes with the lowest moment of inertia.
The pinch-offs at each time-step were scaled such that the cone diameter matched that of the theoretical shape. Scaling the pinch-offs to the theoretical shape provided a way to quantitatively observe the self-similarity and interface agreement with the theory over time. By plotting the diameter cubed versus time, the critical pinching time, ts, was measured on the basis of a linear fit. The deviation between theory and experiment at a given vertex was determined as the distance to the closest point on the other surface.
References
Eggers, J. Nonlinear dynamics and breakup of free-surface flows. Rev. Mod. Phys. 69, 865–929 (1997).
Keller, J. B. & Miksis, M. J. Surface-tension driven flows. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 43, 268–277 (1983).
Eggers, J. Universal pinching of 3D axisymmetrical free-surface flow. Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3458–3460 (1993).
Chen, Y. J. & Steen, P. H. Dynamics of inviscid capillary breakup: Collapse and pinchoff of a film bridge. J. Fluid Mech. 341, 245–267 (1997).
Day, R. F., Hinch, E. J. & Lister, J. R. Self-similar capillary pinchoff of an inviscid fluid. Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 704–707 (1998).
Zhang, W. W. & Lister, J. R. Similarity solutions for capillary pinch-off in fluids of differing viscosity. Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1151–1154 (1999).
Cohen, I., Brenner, M. P., Eggers, J. & Nagel, S. R. Two fluid drop snap-off problem: Experiments and theory. Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1147–1150 (1999).
Leppinen, D. & Lister, J. R. Capillary pinch-off in inviscid fluids. Phys. Fluids 15, 568–578 (2003).
Sierou, A. & Lister, J. R. Self-similar recoil of inviscid drops. Phys. Fluids 16, 1379–1394 (2004).
Wong, H., Miksis, M. J., Voorhees, P. W. & Davis, S. H. Capillarity driven motion of solid film wedges. Acta Mater. 45, 2477–2484 (1997).
Wong, H., Miksis, M. J., Voorhees, P. W. & Davis, S. H. Universal pinch off of rods by capillarity-driven surface diffusion. Scr. Mater. 39, 55–60 (1998).
Bernoff, A. J., Bertozzi, A. L. & Witelski, T. P. Axisymmetric surface diffusion: Dynamics and stability of self-similar pinchoff. J. Stat. Phys. 93, 725–776 (1998).
Cline, H. E. Shape instabilities of eutectic composites at elevated temperatures. Acta Metall. 19, 481–490 (1971).
Nakagawa, Y. G. & Weatherly, G. C. Thermal-stability of rod Al3Ni–Al eutectic. Acta Metall. 20, 345–350 (1972).
Majumdar, B. & Chattopadhyay, K. The Rayleigh instability and the origin of rows of droplets in the monotectic microstructure of zinc–bismuth alloys. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 27, 2053–2057 (1996).
Liu, H. Y., Li, Y. & Jones, H. Thermal stability of the α-Zn–Mg2Zn11 and α-Zn–β-Al eutectics obtained by Bridgman growth. J. Mater. Sci. 33, 1159–1164 (1998).
Kwon, Y., Thornton, K. & Voorhees, P. W. Coarsening of bicontinuous structures via nonconserved and conserved dynamics. Phys. Rev. E 75, 021120 (2007).
Kwon, Y., Thornton, K. & Voorhees, P. W. The topology and morphology of bicontinuous interfaces during coarsening. Europhys. Lett. 86, 46005 (2009).
Jain, S. & Bates, F. S. On the origins of morphological complexity in block copolymer surfactants. Science 300, 460–464 (2003).
Davidovitch, B., Ertas, D. & Halsey, T. C. Ripening of porous media. Phys. Rev. E 70, 031609 (2004).
Kurz, W. & Fisher, D. J. Fundamentals of Solidification 3rd edn (Trans Tech Publications, 1992).
Stampanoni, M. et al. Trends in synchrotron-based tomographic imaging: The SLS experience. Dev. X-ray Tomogr. V 6318, U199–U212 (2006).
Fife, J. L. Three-dimensional Characterization and Real-time Interface Dynamics in Aluminum–Copper Dendritic Microstructures. PhD thesis, Northwestern Univ. (2009).
Kammer, D., Mendoza, R. & Voorhees, P. W. Cylindrical domain formation in topologically complex structures. Scr. Mater. 55, 17–22 (2006).
Louzguine-Luzgin, D. V., Louzguina-Luzgina, L. V. & Inoue, A. Deformation behavior of high strength metastable hypereutectic Ti–Fe–Co alloys. Intermetallics 15, 181–186 (2007).
Aagesen, L. K. Phase-Field Simulation of Solidification and Coarsening in Dendritic Microstructures. PhD thesis, Northwestern Univ. (2010).
Gunduz, M. & Hunt, J. D. The measurement of solid–liquid surface energies in the Al–Cu, Al–Si and Pb–Sn systems. Acta Metall. 33, 1651–1672 (1985).
Abramowitz, M. & Stegun, I. A. Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables (National Bureau of Standards Applied Mathematics Series, 55, US Dept. of Commerce : US G.P.O., 1972).
Acknowledgements
This work was partially supported by NSF RTG grant DMS-0636574 (L.K.A.). M.J.M. acknowledges support from US National Science Foundation RTG grant DMS-0636574 and NSF grant DMS-0616468. A.E.J., J.L.F. and P.W.V. acknowledge the US Department of Energy, grant DE-FG02-99ER45782, for financial support. E.M.L. and S.O.P. acknowledge the Danish National Research Foundation for supporting the Center for Fundamental Research: Metal Structures in 4D, within which part of this work was carried out. The authors thank the Paul Scherrer Institut for beam time at the TOMCAT beamlines of the Swiss Light Source. We would also like to thank G. Mikuljan from the TOMCAT team for his support in setting up the experiment at the beamline.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
L.K.A. carried out the theoretical analysis and prepared the manuscript. M.J.M. and P.W.V. were involved with the theoretical calculations. P.W.V. and E.M.L. conceived the experiments. J.L.F., S.O.P. and E.M.L. conducted the experiments. A.E.J. and J.L.F. analysed the experimental data. F.M. and M.S. provided technical guidance for the experiments.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Aagesen, L., Johnson, A., Fife, J. et al. Universality and self-similarity in pinch-off of rods by bulk diffusion. Nature Phys 6, 796–800 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys1737
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys1737
This article is cited by
-
Melt Flow-Induced Mechanical Deformation and Fracture Behaviour of Dendrites in Alloy Solidification
Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A (2023)
-
Dissimilar Metal Solution from Solid Alloys as Observed for Steels and Nickel‐Based Alloys in the Presence of Lead‐Based Liquid Alloys or Liquid Tin
JOM (2021)
-
Topology-generating interfacial pattern formation during liquid metal dealloying
Nature Communications (2015)
-
The Morphological Evolution of Low Volume Fraction Tin Dendrites During Coarsening
Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A (2013)