Weyl fermions are massless chiral fermions that play an important role in quantum field theory but have never been observed as fundamental particles. A Weyl semimetal is an unusual crystal that hosts Weyl fermions as quasiparticle excitations and features Fermi arcs on its surface. Such a semimetal not only provides a condensed matter realization of the anomalies in quantum field theories but also demonstrates the topological classification beyond the gapped topological insulators. Here, we identify a topological Weyl semimetal state in the transition metal monopnictide materials class. Our first-principles calculations on TaAs reveal its bulk Weyl fermion cones and surface Fermi arcs. Our results show that in the TaAs-type materials the Weyl semimetal state does not depend on fine-tuning of chemical composition or magnetic order, which opens the door for the experimental realization of Weyl semimetals and Fermi arc surface states in real materials.
The rich correspondence between high energy and condensed matter physics has led to a deeper understanding of spontaneous symmetry breaking, phase transitions, renormalization and many other fundamental phenomena in nature, with important consequences for practical applications using magnets, superconductors and topological materials1,2,3,4. Recently, there has been considerable progress in realizing particles previously considered in high energy physics as emergent low-energy excitations of crystalline solids4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13. Materials that host these exotic particles exhibit unique properties and hold promise for applications such as topological qubits, low-power electronics and spintronics. Weyl fermions were originally considered in massless quantum electrodynamics, but have not been observed as a fundamental particle in nature1. Recently, it was theoretically understood that Weyl fermions can arise in some novel semimetals with non-trivial topology5,6,7,12,13,14. A Weyl semimetal has an electron band structure with singly degenerate bands that have bulk band crossings, Weyl points, with a linear dispersion relation in all three momentum space directions moving away from the Weyl point. These materials can be viewed as an exotic spin-polarized, three-dimensional (3D) version of ‘graphene’ that host topological Fermi arcs. However, unlike the two-dimensional (2D) Dirac cones in graphene9, the 3D Dirac cones in spin–orbit materials15,16 or the 2D Dirac cone surface states of Bi2Se3(refs 10, 11), the degeneracy associated with a Weyl point depends only on the translation symmetry of the crystal lattice. This makes the unique properties associated with this electron band structure more robust. Moreover, due to its non-trivial topology, a Weyl semimetal can exhibit novel Fermi arc surface states. Both the Weyl fermions in the bulk and the Fermi arc states on the surface of a Weyl semimetal are predicted to show unusual transport phenomena. Weyl fermions in the bulk can give rise to negative magnetoresistance, the anomalous Hall effect, non-local transport and local non-conservation of ordinary current17,18,19,20. Fermi arc states on the surface are predicted to show novel quantum oscillations in magnetotransport and quantum interference effects in tunnelling spectroscopy21,22,23. Because of the fundamental and practical interest in Weyl semimetals, it is crucial that robust candidate materials be identified.
It is theoretically known that a Weyl semimetal can only arise in a crystal where time-reversal symmetry or inversion symmetry is broken. A number of magnetically ordered or inversion symmetry-breaking materials have been proposed as Weyl semimetal candidates6,24,25,26,27. However, despite extensive effort in experiments for many years, a Weyl semimetal has yet to be realized in any of the compounds predicted thus far. One major concern is that the existing proposals require either magnetic ordering in sufficiently large domains6,24,25,26 or fine-tuning of the chemical composition to within 5% in an alloy24,26,27, which are highly demanding in real experiments. We propose the first Weyl semimetal in a stoichiometric, inversion-breaking, single-crystal material, TaAs as a representative of the transition metal monopnictide or the TX family where T=Ta/Nb and X=As/P. Unlike previous predictions, our proposal does not depend on magnetic ordering over sufficiently large domains, because our material relies on inversion symmetry breaking rather than time-reversal symmetry breaking. The compound we propose is also stoichiometric and does not depend on fine-tuning chemical composition in an alloy as in our previous prediction12. We have grown single crystals of TaAs where the crystal structure is consistent with previous reports28. We believe that this material is the platform for the experimental realization of the long-sought-for Weyl fermion semimetal phase and Fermi arc surface states.
Crystal and electronic structure
In order to find a Weyl semimetal that respects time-reversal symmetry, one needs to search for materials that break space inversion symmetry. In addition, since the Weyl nodes in a Weyl semimetal are usually not located along any high-symmetry direction, one has to calculate the band structure throughout the bulk Brillouin zone (BZ) in order to check whether there are Weyl nodes in a material or not. We have therefore searched through hundreds of inversion symmetry-breaking materials, identified the ones that are likely to be semimetal or narrow bandgap semiconductors, and then performed systematic calculations of the bulk band structures to theoretically understand the nature of their electronic and topological groundstate. Tantalum arsenide crystalizes in a body-centered tetragonal lattice system (Fig. 1a–c). The lattice constants are a=3.437 Å and c=11.656 Å, and the space group is I41md (#109, C4v). This crystal consists of interpenetrating Ta and As sub-lattices, where the two sub-lattices are shifted by , . There are two Ta atoms and two As atoms in each primitive unit cell. It is important to note that the system lacks a horizontal mirror plane and thus inversion symmetry. This makes it possible to realize an inversion breaking Weyl semimetal in TaAs. We also note that the C4 rotational symmetry is broken at the (001) surface because the system is only invariant under a four-fold rotation with a translation along the out-of-plane direction. The bulk and (001) surface BZs are shown in Fig. 1d, where high-symmetry points are also noted.
The ionic model would suggest that the Ta and As atoms are in the 3+ and 3− valence states, respectively. This indicates that the lowest valence band arises from 4p6 electrons in As and 5d2 electrons in Ta, whereas the lowest conduction band primarily consists of 5d electrons in Ta. However, we may expect Ta 5d electrons to have a broad bandwidth because of the wide extent of the atomic orbitals. This leads to strong hybridization with the As 4p states, which may suggest that the conduction and valence bands are not entirely separated in energy and have a small overlap, giving rise to a semimetal. In Fig. 2a, we present the bulk band structure in the absence of spin–orbit coupling. The conduction and valence bands cross each other along the Σ–N–Σ1 trajectory, which further indicates that TaAs is a semimetal. In the presence of spin–orbit coupling, the band structure is fully gapped along the high-symmetry directions considered in Fig. 2c. However, Weyl points which are shifted away from the high-symmetry lines arise after spin–orbit coupling is taken into account. Below, we consider the Weyl points in the bulk BZ. We also note that the double degeneracy of bands is lifted in the presence of spin–orbit coupling except at the Kramers’ points, which confirms that TaAs breaks inversion symmetry but respects time-reversal symmetry.
Weyl fermions form the bulk Weyl cones
In order to better understand the Weyl points in TaAs, we first examine the band crossings near the Fermi level in the absence of spin–orbit coupling. These band crossings take the form of a closed curve, or line node, on the Mx and My mirror planes of the BZ, shown in red and blue in Fig. 3a. We present the band structure near one of the red nodal lines, on the Mx mirror plane, in Fig. 3b. The conduction and valence bands dip into each other, giving rise to a line node crossing. Next, we include spin–orbit coupling. This causes each line node to vaporize into six Weyl points shifted slightly away from the mirror planes, shown as small circles in Fig. 3a. There are 24 Weyl points in total: 8 Weyl points on the kz=2π/c plane, which we call W1, and 16 Weyl points away from the kz=2π/c plane, which we call W2. We present the band structure near one of the Weyl points W1 in Fig. 3c, where a point band touching is clearly observed. We have calculated the momentum space locations of the Weyl nodes for the entire TaAs family. The k-space location for Weyl node W1 is (0.0072, 0.5173, 0), (0.0074, 0.5191, 0), (0.0025, 0.4884, 0) and (0.0028, 0.4901, 0) for TaAs, TaP, NbAs and NbP in the unit of (2π/a, 2π/a, 2π/c), respectively. The k-space location for Weyl node W2 is (0.0185, 0.2831, 0.6000), (0.0156, 0.2743, 0.5958), (0.0062, 0.2800, 0.5816) and (0.0049, 0.2703, 0.5750) for TaAs, TaP, NbAs and NbP in the same unit, respectively.
Next, we consider how the Weyl points project on the (001) surface BZ. We show a small region in the surface BZ around the line, which includes the projections of six Weyl points, two from W1 and four from W2. A schematic of the projections of all 24 Weyl points on the surface BZ is shown in Fig. 3e. We find that for all points W2, two Weyl points project on the same point in the surface BZ. We indicate the number of Weyl points that project on a given point in the surface BZ in Fig. 3e. Lastly, we study the chirality of the Weyl points by calculating the Berry flux (gauge field) through a closed surface enclosing a Weyl point. We call positive the chiral charges that are a source of Berry flux and negative the chiral charges that are a sink of Berry flux. We colour the positive chiral charges black and the negative chiral charges white. In Fig. 3f, we show the spin texture of the band structure near two Weyl points W1. In this case, the spin texture presents a source–sink flow around Weyl points. Moreover, it turns out that the points W2 project on the surface BZ in pairs that carry the same chiral charge.
Topological Fermi arc surface states
Another key signature of a Weyl semimetal is the presence of Fermi arc surface states that connect the Weyl points in pairs in the surface BZ. We present calculations of the (001) surface states in Fig. 4. We show the surface states on the top surface in Fig. 4a and the bottom surface in Fig. 4b. The black and white circles denote the Weyl points, the shaded regions represent the spectral weight of some additional bulk bands near the surface region, whereas the sharp red or blue curves show the surface states. We find surface Fermi arcs that connect Weyl points of opposite chirality in pairs. To better understand the rich structure of the Fermi arcs, we show a schematic of the surface states on the top surface in Fig. 4c and the bottom surface in Fig. 4d. We note that Fig. 4c,d are only designed to show the connectivity of the Fermi arcs and the Weyl nodes. The detailed shape of the Fermi arcs does not necessarily match up with our calculation results in Fig. 4a,b. Note that one Fermi arc connects each pair of points W1. However, two Fermi arcs connect to each projection of points W2, because they project in pairs with the same chiral charge, as discussed above. This leads to Fermi arcs that connect the points W2 in a closed loop of surface states. The largest Fermi arc loop on the top surface threads through four projected Weyl points in the surface BZ. We also note that the Fermi surface of the surface states from the top is very different from that of the bottom (Fig. 4a,b), consistent with broken inversion symmetry in this system. In addition, because the presence of a surface breaks the C4 screw symmetry, the surface states are also very different along the kx and ky directions of the surface BZ. Finally, we observe closed Fermi surfaces that do not intersect Weyl points and do not form Fermi arcs. These extra Fermi surfaces reflect how different ways of annihilating the Weyl points would give rise to an insulator with a different topological invariant (see the Discussion below). We present a particularly simple set of Fermi arcs arising near the point in Fig. 4e, including surface states from both the top and bottom surfaces. To visualize the arc nature of the surface states, we present three energy dispersion cuts along the directions indicated in Fig. 4e. Along Cut 1, shown in Fig. 4f, we see a Dirac cone connecting the bulk valence and conduction bands across the bulk bandgap, exactly like a topological insulator. Along Cut 2, shown in Fig. 4g, we see the projected bulk Weyl cones, with surface states which pass through the Weyl points. Lastly, in Cut 3, shown in Fig. 4h, we observe a full bandgap. The surface states along this cut are trivial because they do not connect across the bulk bandgap.
A number of candidates for a Weyl semimetal have been previously proposed. However, existing proposals have proven difficult to carry out because they rely on magnetic ordering to break time-reversal symmetry or fine-tuning of the chemical composition of an alloy. Magnetic order can be difficult to predict from first-principles, may be difficult to measure experimentally, and most importantly, may not form large enough domains in a real sample for the properties of the Weyl semimetal to be preserved. Fine-tuning chemical composition is typically challenging to achieve and introduces disorder, limiting the quality of single crystals. For instance, a proposal for a Weyl semimetal in Y2Ir2O76 assumes an all-in, all-out magnetic order, which is challenging to verify in experiment29,30. Another proposed Weyl semimetal, HgCr2Se4 (ref. 25), has a clear ferromagnetic order, but because of the cubic structure there is no preferred magnetization axis, likely leading to the formation of many small ferromagnetic domains. Moreover, a proposal in Hg1−x−yCdxMnyTe26 requires straining the sample to break cubic symmetry, applying an external magnetic field and fine-tuning the chemical composition. Another proposal for the inversion breaking compounds LaBi1−xSbxTe3 and LaBi1−xSbxTe3 (ref. 27) requires fine-tuning the chemical composition to within 5%. Despite extensive experimental effort, a Weyl semimetal has not been realized in any of these compounds. We believe that in large part the difficulty stems from relying on magnetic order to break time-reversal symmetry and fine-tuning the chemical composition to achieve the desired band structure. We note that, in contrast to time-reversal symmetry-breaking systems, large single crystals of inversion symmetry-breaking compounds exist, such as the large bulk Rashba material BiTeI, where the crystal domains are sufficiently large so that the Rashba band structure is clearly observed in photoemission spectroscopy31. We propose that TaAs overcomes the difficulties of previous candidates because it realizes a Weyl semimetal in a stoichiometric, inversion-breaking, single-crystal material without compositional modulations.
Next, we provide some general comments on the nature of the phase transition between a trivial insulator, a Weyl semimetal and a topological insulator, illustrated in Fig. 5a. When a system with inversion symmetry undergoes a topological phase transition between a trivial insulator and a topological insulator, the bandgap necessarily closes at a Kramers’ point. If we imagine moving the system through the phase transition by tuning a parameter m, then there will be a critical point where the system is gapless. In a system which breaks inversion symmetry, there will instead be a finite range of m where the system remains gapless, giving rise to a Weyl semimetal phase. In this way, the Weyl semimetal phase can be viewed as an intermediate phase between a trivial insulator and a topological insulator, where the bulk bandgap of a trivial insulator closes and Weyl points of opposite chiral charge nucleate from the bulk band touchings. As m is varied, the Weyl points thread surface states through the surface BZ and eventually annihilate each other, allowing the bulk bandgap to reopen with a complete set of surface states, giving rise to a topological insulator. This understanding of a Weyl semimetal as an intermediate phase between a trivial insulator and a topological insulator offers some insight into the closed Fermi surfaces we find in TaAs around the point of the top surface and the point of the bottom surface. We propose that these surface states reflect the topological invariant we would find if we annihilated the Weyl points to produce a bulk insulator. We consider the bottom surface, and annihilate the Weyl points in pairs in the obvious way to remove all surface states along . Then, we can annihilate the remaining Weyl points to produce two concentric Fermi surfaces around the point. Since this is an even number of surface states, we find that this way of annihilating the Weyl points gives rise to a trivial insulator. If, instead, we annihilate the remaining Weyl points to remove the Fermi arc connecting them, only the closed Fermi surface would be left around , giving rise to a topological insulator. A similar analysis applies to the top surface.
Finally, we highlight an interesting phenomenon regarding how an electron travels along a constant energy contour in our predicted Weyl semimetal, TaAs, under an external magnetic field perpendicular to the surface. Figure 5b shows the calculated Fermi surface contours on both the top and the bottom surfaces near the point. We consider an electron initially occupying a state in one of the red Fermi arcs, whose wavefunction is therefore localized on the top surface in real space. We ask how the wavefunction evolves as the electron traces out the constant energy contour. As the electron moves along the Fermi arc (the red arc on the left-hand side of Fig. 5c), it will eventually reach a Weyl point, where its wavefunction will unravel into the bulk. The electron will then move in real space to the bottom surface of the sample. Then it will follow a Fermi arc on that surface (the blue arc on the left-hand side of Fig. 5b), and reach another Weyl point. The electron will next travel through the bulk again and reach the top surface, returning to the same Fermi arc where it began. This novel trajectory is predicted to show exotic surface transport behaviour as proposed in ref. 23. This is just one example of the unique transport phenomena expected in Weyl semimetals. We hope (Fig. 4e) that our theoretical prediction will soon lead to the experimental discovery of the first Weyl semimetal in nature. In fact, during the review of this article, evidence for the experimental discovery of Weyl semimetal states in TaAs and NbAs have emerged 32,33,34,35, as we have predicted here.
First-principles calculations were performed by OpenMX code based on norm-conserving pseudopotentials generated with multi-reference energies and optimized pseudoatomic basis functions within the framework of the generalized gradient approximation of density functional theory (DFT)36,37,38. Spin–orbit coupling was incorporated through j-dependent pseudo-potentials39. For each Ta atom, three, two, two and one optimized radial functions were allocated for the s, p, d and f orbitals (s3p2d2f2), respectively, with a cutoff radius of 7 Bohr. For each As atom, s3p3d3f2 was adopted with a cutoff radius of 9 Bohr. A regular mesh of 1,000 Ry in real space was used for the numerical integrations and for the solution of the Poisson equation. A k point mesh of (17 × 17 × 5) for the conventional unit cell was used and experimental lattice parameters were adopted in the calculations. Symmetry-respecting Wannier functions for the As p and Ta d orbitals were constructed without performing the procedure for maximizing localization and a real-space tight-binding Hamiltonian was obtained40. This Wannier function-based tight-binding model was used to obtain the surface states by constructing a slab with 80-atomic-layer thickness with Ta on the top and As on the bottom.
How to cite this article: Huang, S.-M. et al. A Weyl semimetal with surface Fermi arcs in the transition metal monopnictide TaAs class. Nat. Commun. 6:7373 doi: 10.1038/ncomms8373 (2015).
Weyl, H. Elektron und gravitation I. Zeitschrift Physik 56, 330–352 (1929).
Volovik, G. E. The Universe in a Helium Droplet Oxford University Press (2003).
Wilczek, F. Why are there analogies between condensed matter and particle theory? Phys. Today 51, 11–13 (1998).
Hasan, M. Z., Xu, S.-Y. & Neupane, M. in Topological Insulators: Fundamentals and Perspectives (eds Ortmann, F., Roche, S. & Valenzuela, S. O.) (John Wiley & Sons, (2015).
Balents, L. Weyl electrons kiss. Physics 4, 36 (2011).
Wan, X., Turner, A. M., Vishwanath, A. & Savrasov, S. Y. Topological semimetal and Fermi-arc surface states in the electronic structure of pyrochlore iridates. Phys. Rev. B 83, 205101 (2011).
Haldane, F. D. M. Attachment of surface ‘Fermi Arc’ to the bulk Fermi surface: “Fermi-Level Plumbing” in topological metals. Preprint at http://arxiv.org/abs/1401.0529 (2014).
Alicea, J. New directions in the pursuit of Majorana fermions in solid state systems. Rep. Prog. Phys. 75, 076501 (2012).
Geim, A. K. & Novoselov, K. S. The rise of graphene. Nat. Mater. 6, 183–191 (2007).
Hasan, M. & Kane, C. L. Topological insulators. Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 3045–3067 (2010).
Qi, X. L. & Zhang, S. C. Topological insulators and superconductors. Rev. Mod. Phys. 83, 1057–1110 (2011).
Singh, B. et al. Topological electronic structure and Weyl semimetal in the TlBiSe2 class of semiconductors. Phys. Rev. B 86, 115208 (2012).
Murakami, S. Phase transition between the quantum spin Hall and insulator phases in 3D: emergence of a topological gapless phase. New. J. Phys. 9, 356 (2007).
Turner, A. M. & Vishwanath, A. Beyond band insulators: topology of semi-metals and interacting phases. Preprint at http://arxiv.org/abs/1301.0330 (2013).
Wang, Z. et al. Dirac semimetal and topological phase transitions in A3Bi (A=Na, K, Rb). Phys. Rev. B 85, 195320 (2012).
Wang, Z. et al. Three dimensional Dirac semimetal and quantum spin Hall effect in Cd3As2 . Phys. Rev. B 88, 125427 (2013).
Zyuzin, A. A. & Burkov, A. A. Topological response in Weyl semimetals and the chiral anomaly. Phys. Rev. B 86, 115133 (2012).
Liu, C.-X., Ye, P. & Qi, X.-L. Chiral gauge field and axial anomaly in a Weyl semi-metal. Phys. Rev. B 87, 235306 (2013).
Hosur, P. & Qi, X.-L. Recent developments in transport phenomena in Weyl semimetals. C. R. Phys. 14, 857–870 (2013).
Parameswaran, S. A., Grover, T., Abanin, D. A., Pesin, D. A. & Vishwanath, A. Probing the chiral anomaly with nonlocal transport in three-dimensional topological semimetals. Phys. Rev. X 4, 031035 (2014).
Hosur, P. Friedel oscillations due to Fermi arcs in Weyl semimetals. Phys. Rev. B 86, 195102 (2012).
Ojanen, T. Helical Fermi arcs and surface states in time-reversal invariant Weyl semimetals. Phys. Rev. B 87, 245112 (2013).
Potter, A. C., Kimchi, I. & Vishwanath, A. Quantum oscillations from surface Fermi-arcs in Weyl and Dirac semi-metals. Nat. Commun. 5, 5161 (2014).
Burkov, A. A. & Balents, L. Weyl semimetal in a topological insulator multilayer. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 127205 (2011).
Xu, G., Weng, H., Wang, Z. & Fang, Z. Chern semi-metal and quantized anomalous Hall effect in HgCr2Se4 . Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 186806 (2011).
Bulmash, D., Liu, C.-X. & Qi, X.-L. Prediction of a Weyl semimetal in Hg1−x−yCdxMnyTe. Phys. Rev. B 89, 081106(R) (2014).
Liu, J. & Vanderbilt, D. Weyl semimetals from noncentrosymmetric topological insulators. Phys. Rev. B 90, 155316 (2014).
Murray, J. J. et al. Phase relationships and thermodynamics of refractory metal pnictides: the metal-rich tantalum arsenides. J. Less Common Met. 46, 311–320 (1976).
Shapiro, M. C. et al. Structure and magnetic properties of the pyrochlore iridate Y2Ir2O7 . Phys. Rev. B 85, 214434 (2012).
Liu, H. et al. Magnetic order, spin dynamics and transport properties of the pyrochlore iridate Y2Ir2O7 . Solid State Commun. 179, 1–5 (2014).
Ishizaka, K. et al. Giant Rashba-type spin splitting in bulk BiTeI. Nat. Mater. 10, 521–526 (2011).
Xu, S.-Y. et al. Experimental realization of a topological Weyl semimetal phase with Fermi arc surface states in TaAs. Preprint at http://arxiv.org/abs/1502.03807 (2015).
Xu, S.-Y. et al. Discovery of Weyl semimetal NbAs. Preprint at http://arxiv.org/abs/1504.01350 (2015).
Zhang, C. et al. Tantalum monoarsenide: an exotic compensated Weyl semimetal. Preprint at http://arxiv.org/abs/1502.00251 (2015).
Lv, B. Q. et al. Observation of Weyl nodes in TaAs. Preprint at http://arxiv.org/abs/1503.09188 (2015).
Perdew, J. P., Burke, K. & Ernzerhof, M. Generalized gradient approximation made simple. Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865–3868 (1996).
Ozaki, T. Variationally optimized atomic orbitals for large-scale electronic structures. Phys. Rev. B 67, 155108 (2003).
Ozaki, T. et al. OpenMX V.3.7 (2013) ) http://www.openmx-square.org.
Theurich, G. & Hill, N. A. Self-consistent treatment of spin-orbit coupling in solids using relativistic fully separable ab initio pseudopotentials. Phys. Rev. B 64, 073106 (2001).
Weng, H., Ozaki, T. & Terakura, K. Revisiting magnetic coupling in transition-metal-benzene complexes with maximally localized Wannier functions. Phys. Rev. B 79, 235118 (2009).
Research work at Princeton University is funded by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundations EPiQS Initiative through Grant GBMF4547 (Hasan). Work at National University of Singapore is supported by the National Research Foundation, Prime Minister’s Office, Singapore under its NRF fellowship (NRF Award No. NRF-NRFF2013-03). Single-crystal work was supported by National Basic Research Program of China (Grant Nos. 2013CB921901 and 2014CB239302). Sample characterization at Princeton University was supported by US DOE DE-FG-02-05ER46200. The work at Northeastern University was supported by the US Department of Energy (DOE), Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences grant number DE-FG02-07ER46352, and benefited from Northeastern University's Advanced Scientific Computation Center (ASCC) and the NERSC supercomputing center through DOE grant number DE-AC02-05CH11231.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Huang, SM., Xu, SY., Belopolski, I. et al. A Weyl Fermion semimetal with surface Fermi arcs in the transition metal monopnictide TaAs class. Nat Commun 6, 7373 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms8373
This article is cited by
Science China Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy (2023)
npj Quantum Materials (2022)
npj Quantum Materials (2022)
npj Quantum Materials (2022)
npj Computational Materials (2022)