Abstract
Traversal of a symmetrybreaking phase transition at finite rates can lead to causally separated regions with incompatible symmetries and the formation of defects at their boundaries, which has a crucial role in quantum and statistical mechanics, cosmology and condensed matter physics. This mechanism is conjectured to follow universal scaling laws prescribed by the Kibble–Zurek mechanism. Here we determine the scaling law for defect formation in a crystal of 16 lasercooled trapped ions, which are conducive to the precise control of structural phases and the detection of defects. The experiment reveals an exponential scaling of defect formation γ^{β}, where γ is the rate of traversal of the critical point and β=2.68±0.06. This supports the prediction of β=8/3≈2.67 for finite inhomogeneous systems. Our result demonstrates that the scaling laws also apply in the mesoscopic regime and emphasizes the potential for further tests of nonequilibrium thermodynamics with ion crystals.
Introduction
The Kibble–Zurek mechanism (KZM) applies to nonequilibrium systems traversing a secondorder phase transition. Before the phase transition, fluctuations relax into the lowest energy equilibrium state under the dissipative influence of a cooling mechanism. The characteristic time of this relaxation increases near a structural phase transition and diverges at the critical point. Therefore, there is no finite rate at which the critical point can be traversed adiabatically and the structure of the system is effectively frozen before it reaches the critical point. Furthermore, different regions of the system can be causally disconnected owing to a finite propagation speed of perturbations, allowing for multiple nucleation sites of the symmetrybroken ground states. If the choice of symmetries of neighbouring sections is incompatible, defects form where the phase boundaries meet and the system is thus prevented from reaching a global ground state.
The KZM was first proposed by Kibble^{1,2} to describe the occurrence of topological defects in the early universe. Later, Zurek^{3} generalized this theory to condensed matter physics, making this mechanism accessible in laboratories. Experimental work on liquid crystals^{4} and liquid ^{4}He (refs 5, 6, 7) has provided confirmation of the KZM in a homogeneous setting. Recent theoretical studies^{8,9,10,11,12} have triggered further interest in these scaling laws in other settings, such as inhomogeneous ion crystals confined in a linear Paul trap.
For such an inhomogeneous system, different regions reach the critical point at different moments and lead to timedependent phase boundaries. This gives rise to an adiabatic transition if the propagation speed of perturbations v_{s} exceeds the propagation speed of the phase boundary v_{p}, thus allowing for the causal connection of different domains and preventing the formation of defects. Hence, defects may only be created in a region of the system where v_{p}>v_{s}.
Lasercooled Coulomb crystals in ion traps feature the possibility of tunable spatial inhomogeneities. In addition, this finitesized mesoscopic system is accessible under highly controlled experimental conditions, which permits the observation of the KZM without initial defects^{13} or impurities. Moreover, our setup features relevant control parameters that can be tuned over a wide range, ideal for the study of nonequilibrium statistical mechanics.
In this work, we investigate the KZM in the structural phase transition of an ion crystal from the linear to the zigzag configuration^{14,15}. The structure of localized ions in a linear Paul trap is controlled by the confining electrostatic potentials along the length of the crystal (axial) and the dynamic radiofrequency potential in the perpendicular (radial) directions, which gives rise to an effective harmonic potential in all three dimensions. The combination of the Coulomb repulsion between ions and the dissipative forces of laser cooling yields a crystalline structure with minimum potential energy. For lowaxialtrapping frequencies, this structure is a linear chain. When the strength of the axial confinement is increased beyond a critical value, the structure is squeezed into the radial dimensions and undergoes a structural phase transition. In the case of a radially anisotropic trap potential, the linear crystal transforms into a planar zigzag configuration, which can be described by a secondorder phase transition^{8}. The latter phase can take the form of two symmetrybroken ground states, referred to as ‘zigzag’ and ‘zagzig’ configurations. Here we generate a harmonic axial potential such that the phase transition initiates at the centre where the ion density is the highest. The phase boundary then propagates outwards towards the ends with a finite propagation speed v_{p}. If the curvature of the trapping potential is rapidly increased, v_{p} can exceed the speed of sound v_{s} and defects may be created^{16,17}. Defects manifest themselves as kinks in the zigzag structure of the crystal. The positions of the individual ions are determined by fluorescence imaging, revealing the final configuration of the crystal. This allows for the determination of the defectformation rate d as a function of the rate at which the critical point is traversed. By solving the timedependent Ginzburg–Landau equation in the underdamped regime^{18}, a universal power law for the density of defects with respect to the rate of change of the control parameter, which is realized by the derivative of the trap frequency at the critical point γ=dω/dt_{CP}, can be derived. If the lengths of causally connected regions are small compared with those of system size, a scaling of the defectformation rate dγ^{β} with β=4/3 is predicted^{10,11}. Previous work has asserted that a further doubling of the exponent occurs^{19} when the system size is comparable to the size of these causally connected regions, which leads to β=8/3≈2.67. Our experiment with 16 lasercooled ions is performed in this regime showing a scaling exponent of β=2.68±0.06 and β=2.62±0.15 for two different radial anisotropies, confirming the theoretical prediction. Our findings are reproduced by numerical simulations.
Results
Scaling law
To determine the scaling law of the defectformation rate, we loaded 16 ^{40}Ca ions into a linear segmented Paul trap (see Fig. 1) realizing a linear ion crystal (Fig. 2a). Doppler cooling close to saturation was applied during the whole experimental cycle. We ramped the axial trap frequency from 167 to 344 kHz (see Fig. 3 and Methods) across the critical point at 201.7 kHz, which led to a change of the crystal structure into a ‘zigzag’ (Fig. 2b) or ‘zagzig’ (Fig. 2c) configuration. The voltage ramp was driven with an arbitrary function generator (AFG), which we used to generate an output with the functional form V(t)[1+exp(−(t−t_{0})/τ))]^{−1}. This voltage was created at different rates with time constants τ ranging from 0.5 to 4.0 μs. An image of the crystal configuration was captured 100 μs after the ramp with a 10msexposure time and the number of kinks (Fig. 2d–f) was counted via image analysis (see Methods). The measured defectformation rate as a function of the rate of change of the axial trapping frequency γ=(dω_{ax}/dt)_{CP} is presented in Fig. 4 (dots). The predicted scaling law for the inhomogeneous finitesized system was confirmed by the observation of a scaling exponent of β=2.68±0.06, matching the prediction of β=8/3≈2.67.
Effect of radial anisotropy
Owing to the anisotropy of the radial potential, the zigzag phase is a planar crystal oriented in the plane of the weaker radial confinement. As shown in Fig. 4, we have measured the defect density for two different radial anisotropies. With an anisotropy of ω_{x}/ω_{y}=1.03, the observed defect densities are depicted as circles in Fig. 4. For a small increase in anisotropy to ω_{x}/ω_{y}=1.05, the measured defect density is decreased by ~50% (see squares in Fig. 4), but the scaling observed, β=2.62±0.15 (Fig. 4), remains in agreement with the predicted value.
Discussion
The influence of the crystalline structure on the dynamics and stability of defects can be described by the Peierls–Nabarro potential^{20}. In our case, we have an attractive Peierls–Nabarro potential, with the defects trapped at the axial potential minimum, which is at the point of the highest charge density. This is based on the fact that we choose a low radial anisotropy such that, if defects form, they extend into the third dimension^{21} and are likely to be axially confined. For a small increase in anisotropy, this confinement is significantly reduced and thus the defect density is also diminished. With a shallower Peierls–Nabarro potential, the thermal excitation of the ion crystal results in a higher loss rate of defects, because they migrate to the end of the crystal and vanish. This does not change the scaling behaviour because this loss channel acts as a multiplicative factor, and thus shifts the curve in the vertical direction but does not influence the scaling exponent.
The experimentally determined scaling of defect formation is supported by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of ion trajectories during a ramp (see Methods). A realistic model of the trap is employed and the equations of motion are solved with a partitioned Runge–Kutta integrator^{22,23}. Laser cooling is modelled by a Langevin force and a constant dissipation. The simulations reveal the dynamics of the ions on a fast timescale that is not accessible in the experiment and thus assist the experimental design and the interpretation of results. By monitoring the trajectory of each individual ion, we verified that no swapping of ions, and therefore no melting of the crystal, occurs during the ramping procedure. We also ensured that the excitation of axial oscillations is minimized (see Fig. 3) by choosing an optimized voltage ramp for squeezing the linear ion crystal over the phase transition. The simulation of the scaling behaviour is performed over the same range of critical parameters used in the experiment. The blue stars in Fig. 4 show the simulation results with a scaling exponent of β=2.53±0.23, confirming the theoretical expectation. It is noteworthy that the simulation result is shifted below the experimental data by around 5%, which corresponds to the defect generation rate due to background gas collisions.
In conclusion, we have observed the KZM in a model system with closeto ideal preparation, control and readout capabilities. The observed scaling of the defectformation rate for two different experimental conditions is in excellent agreement with the theoretical prediction. Realistic simulations show detailed agreement to experimental data also confirming the theoretical scaling exponent. In future experiments, we might utilize the trap control voltages to modify the local charge density and explore the role spatial inhomogeneities have in defect formation, thus investigating the crossover between the inhomogeneous and homogeneous KZM. Increasing the number of ions may allow access to the inhomogeneous KZM for large system sizes^{10}. Instead of external trap potential ramps, spindependent forces could be used to initiate structural phase transitions and quantum quenches^{24}. Ultimately, it might be possible to cool the system deeper into the quantum regime to explore quantum statistical mechanics where phase transitions are driven by quantum rather than thermal fluctuations^{25,26,27,28,29}. This would require all relevant vibrational modes of the linear ion crystal to be cooled near to the ground state, for example, by employing electromagnetically induced transparency cooling^{30}. In addition, by the use of sideband spectroscopy, defects in the zigzag crystal could be detected directly after the phase transition by their specific eigenmode, which is separated in the frequency domain from the modes of the regular crystal^{21}.
During the preparation of this manuscript, we became aware of similar results presented in another paper^{31}.
Methods
Segmented linear Paul trap
The experiments are performed in an Xshaped microfabricated segmented Paul trap based on four goldcoated lasercut alumina chips, each with 11 electrodes (see Figs. 1 and 5) with a thickness of 125 μm. The segment width is 200 μm with isolating gaps of 30 μm. The radial distance of the segmented electrodes to the center of the trap measures 960 μm, whereas the length of the whole trap is 2.9 mm. The radial confinement is generated by applying a radiofrequency voltage of ~450V_{pp} at a drive frequency of Ω/(2π)=22 MHz, resulting in a relevant radial trap frequency of ω_{rad}/(2π)= 1.4 MHz. The axial potential is generated by a superposition of static potentials applied to these segmented electrodes and variable voltages applied to the conical endcap electrodes allowing for axial frequencies (ω_{ax}/(2π)) within a range of 167–344 kHz. The base pressure in the vacuum chamber is 1 × 10^{−9} mbar. Optical detection is achieved using an electronmultiplying chargecoupled device camera with a 10msexposure time, oriented at 45° to the planar structure of the crystal. The camera has an optical chip with 128 × 128 pixels and a pixel size of 24 × 24 μm^{2}. An objective lens leads to an effective pixel size in the acquired images of 1.7 μm.
Experimental sequence and setup
To allow for high statistics and a large number of data points in maintainable time, a high repetition rate of the whole experimental sequence was ensured by implementing a fully automated realtime experimental control system. A fieldprogrammablegatearray controls the timing of the lasers, the electronmultiplying chargecoupled device camera and the AFG (see Fig. 6), which has 16bit amplitude resolution at a sample rate of 200 Msamples per second for fast and glitchfree voltage ramps with variable time constants^{32,33}. The experimental sequence (Fig. 6) starts with the loading of ions. For this purpose, Ca atoms in a thermal atom beam cross the centre of the trap and are ionized with resonantly enhanced twophoton ionization at wavelengths of 423 and 375 nm.
The cloud of trapped ions is Dopplercooled by laser radiation red detuned to the cycling dipole transition ^{2}S_{1/2}↔^{2}P_{1/2}, leading to a condensation of the ions into a linear crystal. To drive the cooling transition, we use a diode laser near 397 nm with a power of 0.15 mW and a beam direction that has a projection on all three trap axes. The cooling laser is switched on during the whole sequence of the experiment, and the resonance fluorescence is used for the image acquisition.
Ion losses can occur because of background gas collisions and possible losses during the relaxation ramp. With the fully automated sequence, we reach a repetition rate of one experiment per second. To achieve automated control, a first image is taken and the number of ions in the chain is evaluated. If the count is lower than 16, another pulse of the ionization lasers increases the number of ions. In the case where the number of ions is higher than 16, the axial trapping potential is temporarily lowered to reduce the ion number. Only if the number of ions in the chain is exactly 16, does the sequence continue with the ramp of the axial confining potential. The fieldprogrammablegatearray then triggers the AFG, which controls the ramp of the voltage at the endcaps and thus increases the axial trap frequency.
Because of noise on external signal filters, we observe a temporal jitter of the start of the voltage ramp of about 80 μs. To guarantee that the images are taken after the ramp, the image acquisition exposure of 10 ms starts with a delay of 100 μs. Subsequent to the ramp and the image acquisition, the axial potential is ramped back slowly to the initial value, such that the crystal relaxes again into a linear configuration. Another image is taken to verify the number of ions. If the number still equals 16, the ramping sequence is started again. Otherwise, the sequence continues with reloading.
Evaluation of the defect density
To guarantee an efficient detection of defects and reliable categorization of the images into different classes of possible crystal structures, their normalized twodimensional discrete Fourier transforms were calculated and compared with 14 reference images (Fig. 7). Such reference images were generated by averaging the manually selected samples for a total of 14 relevant configurations. The coefficient of determination R^{2} (ref. 34) was then used to classify the images into 15 classes corresponding to the 14 template images and 1 class for images that did not fulfil a matching threshold, containing blurred images and images where the amount of ions did not match 16. This recognition threshold was applied to the coefficients of determination to reject the lowquality images (<5%). The density of defects was calculated as d=(n_{1}+2n_{2})/N, where n_{1} is the number of singlekink images, n_{2} is the number of doublekink images and N is the total number of images, not including those rejected.
Longterm defect stability
To estimate the stability of the crystal structure during the fluorescence detection, we repeatedly imaged the ions in the final potential. A blurred image indicated that the configuration changed during the exposure because of the loss of a defect or some other event, such as a background gas collision. For each of a range of exposure times from 10 to 1800, ms, >500 images were captured. The proportion of nonblurred images decreased exponentially with the exposure time, revealing a time constant of τ=(800±140) ms, the uncertainty being calculated assuming a binomial distribution for the two possible outcomes (blurred or nonblurred), combined with an error due to the sorting algorithm. This indicates that, in the 10ms time required for imaging, the probability of a change to the crystal structure, including the loss of a defect, is less than a few percent.
MD simulations
To exclude the possibility of the crystal melting and vibrational excitation, which would lead to a modified scaling behaviour, we simulated the dynamics of the ions during the experiment using MD Monte–Carlo simulations with a fourthorder Runge–Kutta integrator performed on the bwGRiD computer cluster ( http://www.bwgrid.de). In the simulations, the system of ions was first initialized in a linear configuration at a specific temperature T, followed by the evaluation of the dynamics during the potential ramp.
To generate an ion chain at a specific temperature T, we used a Langevin thermostat MD calculation. The ions were assumed to obey the Langevin equation of motion.
where r_{j}=(x_{j},y_{j},z_{j}) is the coordinate of the jth ion, m is the mass of each ion, V is the energy potential of the ion chain, η is the friction force and ξ_{j} is the stochastic force satisfying the following ensemble average relations
The ponderomotive approximation for the potential energy is used:
Initializing the system of 16 Ca^{+} ions with the starting conditions of the experiment results in a linear chain of ions at rest. Evolving the system using equation (1) then leads to a chain of ions at a specific temperature T, corresponding to the Dopplercooled ion chain in the experiment. Numerical evaluation was carried out using the Langevin impulse method^{35}. We have verified the thermalization of the system by checking that the equipartition theorem is satisfied, that is, , where v_{j} is the speed of the jth ion.
Once the system is thermalized, we evaluated the dynamics of the squeezed system by numerically solving the equations of motion with a timedependent trapping potential that matches the experiment. The electric potential, which depends on the electrode geometry, was modelled with a fast multipole boundary element electric field solver. Care was taken that experimental trap frequencies are reproduced. The measured voltage ramps were fitted and the obtained values of the parameters were fed to the simulation programme such that the simulated conditions are as close as possible to the experimental realization. The motion of the system can be described by either Langevin equations or Newton’s equations. We have checked that both Newton’s equations and Langevin equations lead to the same statistics of created defects. This is because of the fact that during the quench, the stochastic thermal fluctuations are much smaller than the energy change due to the potential ramp. The simulations were carried out using a friction coefficient of η=4.0 × 10^{−21} kg s^{−1} and a Doppler temperature of T=25 mK, corresponding to the experimental conditions. The integration step size was 2^{−20}/ω_{zi}=0.895ps with ω_{zi} the initial axial trap frequency. Around 3,000 simulated experiments were used for each data point (Fig. 4, blue stars).
Additional information
How to cite this article: Ulm, S. et al. Observation of the Kibble–Zurek scaling law for defect formation in ion crystals. Nat. Commun. 4:2290 doi: 10.1038/ncomms3290 (2013).
References
Kibble, T. W. B Topology of cosmic domains and strings. J. Phys. A 9, 1387–1398 (1976).
Kibble, T. W. B. Some implications of a cosmological phase transition. Phys. Rep. 67, 183–199 (1980).
Zurek, W. H. Cosmological experiments in superfluid helium? Nature 317, 505–508 (1985).
Chuang, I., Yurke, B., Durrer, R. & Turok, N. Cosmology in the laboratory: defect dynamics in liquid crystals. Science 251, 1336–1342 (1991).
Hendry, P., Lawson, N., Lee, R., McClintock, P. & Williams, C. Generation of defects in superfluid ^{4}He as an analogue of the formation of cosmic strings. Nature 368, 315–317 (1994).
Ruutu, V. et al. Vortex formation in neutronirradiated superfluid ^{3}He as an analogue of cosmological defect formation. Nature 382, 334–336 (1996).
Bäuerle, C., Bunkov, Y., Fisher, S., Godfrin, H. & Pickett, G. Laboratory simulation of cosmic string formation in the early Universe using superfluid ^{3}He. Nature 382, 332–334 (1996).
Fishman, S., De Chiara, G., Calarco, T. & Morigi, G. Structural phase transitions in lowdimensional ion crystals. Phys. Rev. B 7, 064111 (2008).
Retzker, A., Thompson, R. C., Segal, D. M. & Plenio, M. B. Double well potentials and quantum phase transitions in ion traps. Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 260504 (2008).
Del Campo, A., De Chiara, G., Morigi, G., Plenio, M. B. & Retzker, A. Structural defects in ion chains by quenching the external potential: the inhomogeneous KibbleZurek mechanism. Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 075701 (2010).
De Chiara, G., del Campo, A., Morigi, G., Plenio, M. B. & Retzker, A. Spontaneous nucleation of structural defects in inhomogeneous ion chains. New J. Phys. 12, 115003 (2010).
Zurek, W. H. Causality in condensates: gray solitons as relics of BEC formation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 105702 (2009).
Griffin, S. M. et al. Scaling behavior and beyond equilibrium in the hexagonal manganites. Phys. Rev. X 2, 041022 (2012).
Enzer, D. G. et al. Observation of powerlaw scaling for phase transitions in linear trapped ion crystals. Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 2466–2469 (2000).
Kaufmann, H. et al. Precise experimental investigation of eigenmodes in a planar ion crystal. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 263003 (2012).
Landa, H., Marcovitch, S., Retzker, A., Plenio, M. B. & Reznik, B. Quantum coherence of discrete kink solitons in ion traps. Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 043004 (2010).
Schneider, C., Porras, D. & Schaetz, T. Experimental quantum simulations of manybody physics with trapped ions. Rep. Prog. Phys. 75, 024401 (2012).
Laguna, P. & Zurek, W. H. Critical dynamics of symmetry breaking: quenches, dissipation, and cosmology. Phys. Rev. D 58, 085021 (1998).
Monaco, R., Mygind, J., Rivers, R. & Koshelets, V. Spontaneous fluxoid formation in superconducting loops. Phys. Rev. B 80, 180501 (2009).
Braun, O. M. & Kivshar, Y. S. The FrenkelKontorova Model, Concepts, Methods, and Applications Springer (2004).
Mielenz, M. et al. Trapping of topologicalstructural defects in Coulomb crystals. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 133004 (2013).
Singer, K. et al. Colloquium: trapped ions as quantum bits: essential numerical tools. Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 2609–2632 (2010).
Abah, O. et al. Singleion heat engine at maximum power. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 203006 (2012).
Baltrusch, J. D., Cormick, C. & Morigi, G. Quantum quenches of ion Coulomb crystals across structural instabilities. Phys. Rev. A 86, 032104 (2012).
Damski, B. The simplest quantum model supporting the KibbleZurek mechanism of topological defect production: LandauZener transitions from a new perspective. Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 035701 (2005).
Zurek, W. H., Dorner, U. & Zoller, P. Dynamics of a quantum phase transition. Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 105701 (2005).
Meyer, J. S., Matveev, K. A. & Larkin, A. I. Transition from a onedimensional to a quasionedimensional state in interacting quantum wires. Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 126404 (2007).
Shimshoni, E., Morigi, G. & Fishman, S. Quantum zigzag transitions in ion chains. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 010401 (2011).
Shimshoni, E., Morigi, G. & Fishman, S. Quantum structural phase transition in chains of interacting atoms. Phys. Rev. A 83, 032308 (2011).
Roos, C. F. et al. Experimental demonstration of ground state laser cooling with electromagnetically induced transparency. Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 5547–5550 (2000).
Pyka, K. et al. Symmetry Breaking and Topological Defect Formation in Ion Coulomb Crystals. Nat. Commun. 4, 2291 (2013).
Huber, G. et al. Transport of ions in a segmented linear Paul trap in printedcircuitboard technology. New J. Phys. 10, 013004 (2008).
Walther, A. et al. Controlling fast transport of cold trapped ions. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 080501 (2012).
Stapleton, J. H. Linear Statistical Models John Wiley and Sons (1995).
Skeel, R. D. & Izaguirre, J. A. An impulse integrator for Langevin dynamics. Mol. Phys. 100, 3885–3891 (2002).
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge helpful discussions with John Goold. The Mainz team acknowledges support by the VolkswagenStiftung, the DFGForschergruppe (FOR 1493) and the EUproject DIAMANT (FP7ICT). M.B.P. acknowledges support provided by the EU STREP Project PICC (FP7ICT), the Alexander von Humboldt Professorship and the GIF project ‘Nonlinear dynamics in ultracold trapped ion crystals’. A.R. acknowledges the carrier integration grant (CIG) no. 321798. R.N. was supported by the EPSRC Doctoral Training Center for Controlled Quantum Dynamics.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
S.U., J.R., G.J., C.D. and K.S. performed measurements. S.U., G.J., S.T.D. and K.S. designed experiment. S.U., J.R., R.N. and K.S. performed simulations. Data evaluation was performed by S.U., J.R., C.D., S.T.D. and K.S. Theoretical studies were carried out by R.N., A.R. and M.B.P. All authors contributed to the writing of this letter, including discussions and ideas. The projects were funded and the students were supervised by A.R., M.B.P, F.S.K. and K.S.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ulm, S., Roßnagel, J., Jacob, G. et al. Observation of the Kibble–Zurek scaling law for defect formation in ion crystals. Nat Commun 4, 2290 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms3290
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms3290
This article is cited by

KibbleZurek mechanism for nonequilibrium phase transitions in driven systems with quenched disorder
Communications Physics (2022)

Twodimensional supersolidity in a dipolar quantum gas
Nature (2021)

Thermally active nanoparticle clusters enslaved by engineered domain wall traps
Nature Communications (2021)

Experimentally testing quantum critical dynamics beyond the Kibble–Zurek mechanism
Communications Physics (2020)

Kibble–Zurek universality in a strongly interacting Fermi superfluid
Nature Physics (2019)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.