Hundreds of specimens of the beaked bird Confuciusornis sanctus have been recovered from Early Cretaceous lake deposits of northeastern China. These birds show remarkable variation in size and plumage, with some displaying two long, central ornamental rectrices (tail feathers) and others lacking them altogether. Although, traditionally specimens with ornamental rectrices were interpreted as males and those without them as females, this supposed sexual dimorphism has remained unconfirmed. Here we report on the discovery of medullary bone, a tissue unique to reproductively active female birds, in a specimen of C. sanctus (DNHM-D1874) lacking these feathers. Our discovery constitutes the first case of gender identification in a Mesozoic bird, and it provides undisputed evidence that individuals of C. sanctus without ornamental rectrices are females. By permitting gender identification in C. sanctus, our results provide insight into the onset of sexual maturity and attainment of adult body size of this and other early birds.
Confuciusornis sanctus1 is the most abundant species of the diverse fossil avifauna from the Early Cretaceous Jehol Group of northeastern China. A complete, articulated specimen of this early bird, DNHM-D1874 (Dalian Natural History Museum, China), preserves distinctive feathers around the body, but does not display any central ornamental rectrices associated with its well-preserved caudal region (Fig. 1a). The femoral dimensions (52 mm) suggest that DNHM-D1874 falls within the high end of the size range known for C. sanctus2.
Studies of bone histology are known to provide valuable insight pertaining to growth dynamics and biology of extinct animals3,4,5,6,7,8. The left humerus, tibia and ulna of DNHM-D1874 were therefore sampled for histological analyses. Our histological study detected the presence of medullary bone, thus indentifying DNHM-D1874 as a reproductively active female. Such discovery indicates that individuals of C. sanctus lacking ornamental rectrices are females. Framed within the context of the size distribution characteristic of this species, the discovery of medullary bone in DNHM-D1874 also indicates that C. sanctus, and other early birds, matured sexually well before reaching skeletal maturation.
Examination of thin sections of the humerus reveals three distinct layers in the compacta: Outermost is the more slowly formed lamellar bone of the outer circumferential layer, wherein at least two lines of arrested growth are visible; internal to this is the reticular fibro-lamellar bone tissue formed during early ontogeny; and below this is a thick inner circumferential layer (Fig. 2a). Internal to the inner circumferential layer and extending from the endosteal margin into the medullary cavity is a layer of medullary bone (Mb) (Fig. 2). This well vascularized, endosteally formed tissue characteristically has a cancellous or spongy texture and consists of woven bone9,10,11,12,13. Endosteal deposits are sometimes caused by disease (for example, avian osteopetrosis) and in such cases they are usually accompanied by bony periosteal outgrowths13. In DNHM-D1874, the periosteal surface of the humerus (and other bones in the skeleton) does not have any reactive deposits, which supports our conclusion that the endosteally derived tissue is not pathologic in origin. Furthermore, although the partial bone wall of DNHM-D1874 might suggest that the bone within the medullary cavity corresponds to displaced pieces of the compact bone wall, differences in the texture (spongy versus compact) and location (medullary bone spicules are outgrowths of the endosteal surface) (Fig. 2b) precludes them from being mistaken for one another.
Several studies have shown that the deposition of avian medullary bone is directly linked to the maturation of the ovarian follicles before egg laying, and that it acts as a calcium reservoir for the production of the calcareous eggshell9,10,11,12,13,14,15. The deposition of medullary bone is considered to be an adaptation to compensate for the thin-walled bones of birds, from which extensive bone resorption leads to brittleness and susceptibility to fractures11,14,15. Thus, our discovery of medullary bone directly indicates that DNHM-D1874, a specimen lacking ornamental rectrices, is a reproductive female. The fact that the medullary bone of DNHM-D1874 appears to be in a resorptive state in the humerus and only traces remain in the ulna, suggests that eggshell calcification had occurred and that an indeterminate number of eggs had been laid before death.
The discovery of medullary bone in DNHM-D1874 sheds light on the biological significance of the variation in the tail plumage of C. sanctus. Although most researchers considered such variation as expressions of sexual dimorphism16,17,18,19, whether it was instead the result of moulting or some other biological manifestations could not be ruled out1. In addition, previous large-sample morphometric studies failed to provide definitive support for the presence of rectricial sexual dimorphism2. The current unequivocal identification of DNHM-D1874 as a female supports the hypothesis that individuals of C. sanctus without central ornamental rectrices are females and those displaying them are males. This interpretation is congruent with absence of medullary bone in three sampled specimens that distinctly present a pair of central ornamental rectrices (Methods).
The detailed bone microstructure of both the humerus and the ulna indicates that DNHM-D1874 had passed its most rapid (juvenile) phase of growth20 and that its growth rate had dramatically slowed down. Size comparisons with other specimens in our sample indicate that DNHM-D1874 was substantially smaller than the largest known specimens of C. sanctus (Fig. 3). The presence of multiple lines of arrested growth—structures consistently interpreted as annual pauses in growth21,22,23,24—directly indicates that skeletal maturity occurred over several years, and that DNHM-D1874 was in its third year of growth. Ornamental rectrices in specimens with femora that are 69% the size of DNHM-D1874 (and 60% the largest specimen recorded by Marugán-Lobon et al.2) (Fig. 3) indicate that such dimorphism in C. sanctus developed well before skeletal maturity—our mass estimates (see Methods) indicate that the smallest, sexually mature specimens had ∼23% the mass of the largest specimens in our sample (Fig. 3). This further implies that unlike modern birds and similar to their nonavian ancestors24,25 sexual maturity occurred well before skeletal maturation. Histological studies of other premodern birds have suggested that the extant condition of generally attaining adult body size within the first year of life, evolved late in the history of birds6,21,22. Our findings suggest that in addition, early birds also attained sexual maturity much earlier in ontogeny than their modern relatives.
Sampling and thin section preparation
This study is part of a multi-year project aimed at understanding the life history of C. sanctus. In the course of this research, hundreds of specimens were photographed and measured for the purpose of morphological and morphometric analyses1,2. Plumage variation (that is, presence or absence of long ornamental rectrices) was determined upon close examination of the caudal region of each specimen: long ornamental rectrices were considered absent only on specimens in which the outline of the plumage around the pygostyle was well preserved, offering strong evidence that the absence of these feathers was not the result of taphonomy.
Multiple bones (humerus, radius, ulna, tibia and femur) of 11 individuals were sampled for histological analyses. In three specimens, ornamental rectrices were clearly visible, whereas in six others they were not present, and in two specimens the caudal regions were not well preserved. Of the six specimens without ornamental rectrices, only DNHM-D1874 appeared to be reproductively active (that is, breeding) at the time of death, and thus preserved medullary bone tissue. It should be noted that our histological analyses of the three specimens with ornamental rectrices did not find evidence of medullary bone.
The sampled bone pieces of the left humerus, tibia and ulna of DNHM-D1874 were embedded in Struers epoxy, and thin sectioned using standard histological methods10. Four thin sections of the humerus, and two thin sections of the ulna and tibia were prepared at the University of Cape Town in South Africa. The sections were studied under a biological petrographic microscope (Nikon Eclipse E200). The bone histology of the humerus and ulna were well preserved, but the tibial sample was incomplete and unsuitable for histological analyses. Both the humerus and the ulna preserved medullary bone around the edges of the medullary cavity, although the humeral sample was better preserved. Photomicrographs were taken using a Nikon DS-Fi1 digital camera and the imaging program NIS Elements version 3.2.
Body mass calculation
Body mass estimates (in g) in Fig. 3 correspond to allometric mean values calculated on the basis of the length of the femur (in mm). These mean values were calculated from the body mass estimates derived from the equations of Maloiy et al.26 and Alexander27, as listed by Hone et al.,28 and the equation of Peters and Peters29, which was modified from that of Prange et al.30 (Table 1).
How to cite this article: Chinsamy, A. et al. Gender identification of the mesozoic bird Confuciusornis sanctus. Nat. Commun. 4:1381 doi: 10.1038/ncomms2377 (2013).
Chiappe, L. M., Ji, S., Ji, Q. & Norell, M. A. . Anatomy and systematics of the Confuciusornithidae (Theropoda: Aves) from the Late Mesozoic of northeastern China. Bull. Am. Mus. Nat. Hist. 242, 1–89 (1999) .
Marugán-Lobón, J. et al. Quantitative patterns of morphological variation in the appendicular skeleton of the Early Cretaceous bird. Confuciusornis. J. Syst. Pal. 9, 91–101 (2011) .
Sander, P. M. . Long bone histology of the Tendaguru sauropods: implications for growth and biology. Paleobiology 26, 466–488 (2000) .
Chinsamy, A. . In Mesozoic Birds: Above the Heads of Dinosaurs eds Chiappe L. M., Witmer L. M. 421–431University of California (2002) .
Erickson, G. M. . Assessing dinosaur growth patterns: a microscopic revolution. Trends Ecol. Evol. 20, 677–684 (2005) .
Erickson, G. M. et al. Was dinosaurian physiology inherited by birds? Reconciling slow growth in Archaeopteryx. PLoS ONE 4, e7390 (2009) .
Horner, J. R., De Ricqlès, A., Padian, K. & Scheetz, R. D. . Comparative long bone histology and growth of the ‘hypsilophodontid’ dinosaurs Orodromeus makelai, Dryosaurus altus, and Tenontosaurus tilletii (Ornithischia: Euornithopoda). J. Vert. Paleontol. 29, 734–747 (2009) .
Chinsamy-Turan, A. . The Forerunners of Mammals: Radiation, Histology, Biology Indiana University (2012) .
Dacke, C. G. et al. Medullary bone and avian calcium regulation. J. Exp. Biol. 184, 63–88 (1993) .
Chinsamy-Turan, A. . The Microstructure of Dinosaur bones: Deciphering Biology through Fine Scale Techniques Johns Hopkins University (2005) .
Whitehead, C. C. & Fleming, R. H. . Osteoporosis in cage layers. Poult. Sci. 79, 1033–1041 (2000) .
Schweitzer, M. H., Wittmeyer, J. L. & Horner, J. . Gender-specific reproductive tissue in ratites and Tyrannosaurus rex. Science 308, 1456–1459 (2005) .
Chinsamy, A. & Tumarkin-Deratzian, A. . Pathologic bone tissues in a Turkey vulture and a nonavian dinosaur: implications for interpreting endosteal bone and radial fibrolamellar bone in fossil dinosaurs. Anat. Rec. 292, 1478–1484 (2009) .
Wilson, S. & Thorpe, B. H. . Estrogen and cancellous bone loss in the fowl. Cal. Tiss. Res. 62, 506–511 (1998) .
Miller, S. C. & Bowman, B. M. . Medullary bone osteogenesis following estrogen adminstration to mature male Japanese Quail. Dev. Biol. 87, 52–63 (1981) .
Feduccia, A. . The Origin and Evolution of Birds Yale University (1996) .
Hou, L., Martin, L. D., Zhou, Z. & Feduccia, A. . Early adaptive radiation of birds: evidence from fossils from northeastern China. Science 274, 1164–1167 (1996) .
Hou, L., Martin, L. D., Zhou, Z., Feduccia, A. & Zhang, F. . A diapsid skull in a new species of the primitive bird Confuciusornis. Nature 399, 679–682 (1999) .
Martin, L. D., Zhou, Z., Hou, L. & Feduccia, A. . Confuciusornis sanctus compared to Archaeopteryx lithographica. Naturwissenshaften 85, 286–289 (1998) .
Chinsamy, A. . Histological perspectives on growth in the birds Struthio camelius and Sagittarius serpentarius. Courier Forschungsinstitute Senckenberg 181, 317–323 (1995) .
Chinsamy, A., Chiappe, L. M. & Dodson, P. . Growth rings in Mesozoic avian bones: physiological implications for basal birds. Nature 368, 196–197 (1994) .
Chinsamy, A. & Elzanowski, A. . Evolution of growth pattern in birds. Nature 412, 402–403 (2001) .
Cambra-Moo, O. et al. Histological observations of enantiornithine bone [Saurischia, Aves] from the Lower Cretaceous of Las Hoyas [Spain]. Comptes. Rendus. Palevol. 5, 685–691 (2006) .
Erickson, G. M., Curry-Rogers, K., Varrichio, D. J., Norell, M. A. & Xu, X. . Growth patterns in brooding dinosaurs reveals the timing of sexual maturity in non-avian dinosaurs and genesis of the avian condition. Biol. Lett. 3, 558–561 (2007) .
Makovicky, P. J. & Zanno, L. E. . In Living Dinosaurs: The Evolutionary History of Modern Birds eds. Dyke G., Kaiser G. ) 9–29Wiley-Blackwell (2011) .
Maloiy, G. M. O., Alexander, R. M., Njau, R. & Jayes, A. S. . Allometry of the legs of running birds. J. Zool. 187, 161–167 (1979) .
Alexander, N. . Allometry of the leg bones of moas (Dinornithes) and other birds. J. Zool. 200, 215–231 (1983) .
Hone, D. W. D., Dyke, G. J., Haden, M. & Benton, M. J. . Body size evolution in Mesozoic birds. J. Evol. Biol. 21, 618–624 (2008) .
Peters, W. S. & Peters, D. S. . Life history, sexual dimorphism and ‘ornamental’ feathers in the Mesozoic bird Confuciusornis sanctus. Biol. Lett. 5, 817–882 (2009) .
Prange, H. D., Anderson, J. F. & Rahn, H. . Scaling of skeletal mass to body mass in birds and mammals. Am. Nat. 113, 103–122 (1979) .
We thank M. Walsh for specimen preparation and histological sampling, and S. Abramowicz for preparation of the figures. This study was supported by grant from the Eppley Foundation for Research to L.M.C., funding from the University of Cape Town’s Research and Innovation Department to A.C., a Franklin Research Grant from the American Philosophical Society to L.M.C., and by donations to the Dinosaur Institute from Doreen and Glenn Gee.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Chinsamy, A., Chiappe, L., Marugán-Lobón, J. et al. Gender identification of the Mesozoic bird Confuciusornis sanctus. Nat Commun 4, 1381 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms2377
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences (2020)
Nature Communications (2019)
Anatomy and Flight Performance of the Early Enantiornithine Bird Protopteryx fengningensis : Information from New Specimens of the Early Cretaceous Huajiying Formation of China
The Anatomical Record (2019)
Bone tissue histology of the Early Cretaceous birdYanornis: evidence for a diphyletic origin of modern avian growth strategies within Ornithuromorpha
Historical Biology (2019)