Strategies to harness photosynthesis from living organisms to generate electrical power have long been considered, yet efficiency remains low. Here, we aimed to reroute photosynthetic electron flow in photosynthetic organisms without compromising their phototrophic properties. We show that 2,6-dimethyl-p-benzoquinone (DMBQ) can be used as an electron mediator to assess the efficiency of mutations designed to engineer a novel electron donation pathway downstream of the primary electron acceptor QA of Photosystem (PS) II in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Through the use of structural prediction studies and a screen of site-directed PSII mutants we show that modifying the environment of the QA site increases the reduction rate of DMBQ. Truncating the C-terminus of the PsbT subunit protruding in the stroma provides evidence that shortening the distance between QA and DMBQ leads to sustained electron transfer to DMBQ, as confirmed by chronoamperometry, consistent with a bypass of the natural QA°− to QB pathway.
The prospect of biophotovoltaics whereby organisms performing oxygenic photosynthesis are exploited to generate electric power emerged over the last decade1,2,3. It consists in utilizing the remarkable characteristics of photosynthetic reaction centres to generate electrical power. The potentialities of natural photosystems rely on their very high maximum quantum efficiency4,5. Yet, extracting electrons from these photosystems to generate a photocurrent requires the establishment of sustained flux that will be determined by the intrinsic rate constant of light-independent reactions. Currently, these kinetic limitations are such that the yield of biophotovoltaics is still far lower than the theoretical limit of conversion efficiency2.
To circumvent these limitations, attempts were made to optimize the electrical connectivity between isolated photosystems and the electrode that eventually collects the reducing equivalents they produce under illumination. For instance, the ZnO-binding peptide was used to facilitate electron transfer from PSI to ZnO anodes when this peptide was linked to the PsaE subunit, which allows tight docking of PSI to the anode6. Alternatively, single amino acid substitutions were made within photosystems to change their surface charge density and favour electron transfer to the electrode. As an example, the D1-K238 mutation on the stromal surface of PSII led to higher photocurrent in Synechocystis7,8.
Other approaches consisted in using native photosynthetic membranes in order to alleviate the negative impact of biochemical purification of photosystems on the cost/efficiency ratio of the final biophotovoltaic device. The most common redox mediators used to extract electrons are quinones, which have been successfully employed with PSII-enriched membranes9, thylakoid membranes10,11 or intact cells of cyanobacteria12,13,14. Chloro-substituted benzoquinones were initially taken as effective electron acceptors of PSII15,16,17. Later, it was postulated that several derivatives of benzoquinone undergo reduction by displacement of plastoquinone from their binding site in the QB binding pocket of PSII, and/or by direct oxidation of the plastoquinone pool in the thylakoid membranes18,19,20. The direct electron transfer from immobile semiquinone QA°− to exogenous quinones was also reported21, suggesting that further modification of the structure of the QA binding pocket may increase the reduction rate of exogenous quinones.
Irrespective of the velocity with which quinones, native or exogenous, accept electrons from PSII, the kinetic limiting step of photosynthesis is located downstream of PSII. Therefore, PSII does not turnover at its maximal rate under saturating illumination conditions. Yet, under such conditions, the PSII primary electron acceptor accumulates in its reduced state, which promotes charge recombination. This decreases the overall conversion efficiency of charge separation but also provides a potent source of reactive oxygen species that damages the photosynthetic machinery. The cost of the ensuing damage/repair cycles actually is a main source of energetic loss in photosynthesis and accounts for its relatively poor yield22.
We explored the possibility of designing an additional electron transfer pathway branched in parallel with the endogenous pathway, which would drive electrons out of PSII, when the semiquinone QA°− accumulates. By decreasing the concentration of QA°−, such design would decrease the probability of photodamage and thus increase both the overall energetic yield of the biophotovoltaic device and its lifespan. If engineered to preserve phototrophy via regular electron transfer downstream of PSII, the design would allow using viable microalgae, exposed to saturating light intensity, to collect, with an electrode, electrons from a long-lived semi-quinone at the QA site. Here we modify the environment of the QA site in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and screen site-directed PSII mutants for their ability to enhance electron transfer to exogenous quinones. Our results demonstrate that shortening the distance between QA and exogenous quinones increases the reduction rate of exogenous quinones and thus decreases electron accumulation at the QA site, consistent with our design aimed at rerouting electrons from QA to exogenous quinone.
Contrasting efficiency of quinones as PSII electron acceptors
To assess the relative efficiency of various quinones to accept electrons from PSII, we used a mutant strain of C. reinhardtii lacking cytochrome b6f (ΔpetA), a protein complex which acts as a quinol:plastocyanin oxidoreductase. In this strain, illumination progressively reduces the plastoquinone pool and consequently QA°−, leading to an increase of the fluorescence yield. Thus, the ability of exogenous quinones to accept electron from PSII, that is, to restore the electron flow downstream of PSII, is witnessed by a decrease in the steady-state fluorescence level reached under continuous illumination with sub-saturating light. This can be quantitatively assessed by the ratio (FM−FS)/FM, where FM is the maximum fluorescence yield probed by a saturating multi-turnover light pulse and FS is the fluorescence yield under continuous illumination probed before the pulse. Figure 1 demonstrates that addition of any of the three quinone derivatives induced an increase of the (FM−FS)/FM value, although 2,6-dimethyl-p-benzoquinone (DMBQ) was markedly less efficient than 2,6-dichloro-p-benzoquinone (DCBQ) and phenyl-p-benzoquinone (PPBQ).
Electron-acceptor sites of exogenous quinones
The following question was at which location in the electron transport chain the exogenous quinones could accept electrons downstream of QA°−. In the absence of exogenous quinones, addition of 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea (DCMU) induces a rise of the initial fluorescence yield (from F0 in its absence to Fi in its presence) due to the inability of DCMU to enter the QB binding pocket when it is occupied by QB°−, as happens in about 50% of the PSII centres in algae kept in darkness23. Owing to the equilibrium between the QAQB°− and QA°−QB states, PSII centres in the former state transiently reverse to the QA°−QB state, allowing DCMU to compete with QB for occupying the ‘QB pocket’, thus closing all centres originally in the QB°− state in darkness24. The rise of the initial fluorescence yield observed upon addition of DCMU is thus a measure of the fraction of PSII centres having QB in its semiquinone state. We measured the DCMU-induced rise from F0 to Fi upon addition of exogenous quinones as a marker of their ability to oxidize QB. Whereas DCBQ and PPBQ almost completely cancelled the fluorescence rise observed upon addition of DCMU, the Fi/F0 ratio was only marginally affected by the addition of up to 100 μM DMBQ (Fig. 2a). Thus, DMBQ poorly interacts with the QB binding site and the downstream plastoquinone pool with which QB is at equilibrium. Since the three quinones are benzoquinones that do not differ greatly in terms of reduction potential of their relevant redox couples, all the three quinones can readily accept electrons based on the midpoint potential data25. We therefore interpret this poor interaction, as being due to the mediocre partitioning of DMBQ into the thylakoid membranes. This conclusion was further substantiated by the Stern–Volmer plot of FM for the three quinone derivatives that showed that DCBQ and PPBQ—but not DMBQ—are efficient fluorescence quenchers (Fig. 2b). To interact directly with the excited states of protein-bound chlorophylls and decrease their lifetime by a mechanism that would involve the transient formation of a charge-transfer state26, these quinones must be embedded within thylakoid membranes. Altogether with the results in Fig. 1, we conclude that DMBQ has little interaction with the plastoquinone pool or the QB binding site of PSII. We thus selected this quinone to assess our engineering strategy aimed at designing an additional electron transfer pathway from QA°− to the stroma.
Extraction efficiency using absorbance changes of P700
To assess the effect of exogenous quinones in the WT strain, which was further used as a recipient strain for site-directed mutagenesis, we used the reduction rate of P700, the primary chlorophyll donor of PSI, as a measure of the ability of exogenous quinones to divert electrons from the regular photosynthetic electron flux towards P700, and hence to decrease its relative reduction state under steady-state illumination of non-saturating light. Such decrease became significant when using DCBQ and PPBQ at concentrations of about 20 μM, while, in agreement with the results above, the effect of DMBQ on the reduction state of P700 was far more limited (Fig. 3a; see Methods and Supplementary Fig. 1a for the estimation of the P700 reduction ratio). The same experiments were also conducted in the presence of the PSII inhibitor DCMU (10 μM), to assess whether the addition of exogenous quinones impacts cyclic electron flow (Fig. 3b). Addition of exogenous quinones also led to a decrease of the P700 reduction ratio. It is of note that, in contrast with its limited effect on linear electron flow, DMBQ significantly interfered with the reduction of P700 in the cyclic pathway, suggesting that it can interact with stroma-soluble electron carriers involved in cyclic electron flow.
Since we aimed at screening different PSII site-directed mutants for their respective ability to divert electrons from PSII to DMBQ, we had to take into account that differences in efficiency of linear electron flow would necessarily arise between strains after mutagenesis. At steady state, the reduction state of P700 is equal to kred/(koxi+kred), where kred is the light-induced P700 reduction rate and koxi the oxidation rate. Assuming that koxi is fully determined by the light intensity and marginally affected by the addition of quinones (see Supplementary Fig. 1b for the absence of PSI acceptor side limitation above 5 μM of exogenous quinones), kred can be computed, as a function of the concentration of quinones and normalized to the reduction rate in the absence of quinones, kred(0). Figure 3c,d show the kred/kred(0) ratio computed from the data shown in Fig. 3a,b. In the absence of DCMU, both DCBQ and PPBQ almost completely abolished the electron flux towards P700 in the 30–40 μM range, which, by contrast, remained rather insensitive to the addition of DMBQ. In the presence of DCMU (Fig. 3d), we note that, at low-concentration of quinones, DMBQ impacted more efficiently the reduction state of P700 than the two other quinones. As expected from its mediocre partitioning within the thylakoid membranes, DMBQ would then readily interact in the stroma with a soluble electron carrier such as, for example, ferredoxin or ferredoxin-NADP+ reductase, whereas the action of DCBQ and PPBQ would still be at the level of the intramembrane plastoquinone pool.
Redesigning PSII to increase reactivity of QA°− with DMBQ
To increase the access of stromal exogenous electron acceptors to QA°−, we selected several sites of the D2, CP43 and PsbT subunits (encoded by the psbD, psbC and psbT genes, respectively) for mutagenesis, based on the PSII structure modelled after that from Thermosynechococcus vulcanus27. The environment of the QA site is well conserved with only one amino acid difference between the two organisms in a 10-Å sphere around QA (Fig. 4a). We targeted two glutamates of the D2 protein, E241 and E242, exposed to the stromal surface and presumably negatively charged at physiological pH. Another target was the D2-W253 residue, whose mutation may affect the lifetime of QA°− because it is adjacent to PheoA and QA. Besides these single amino-acid substitutions, we truncated several peptides covering the stromal side of the QA binding pocket. Increased accessibility was accessed by the shortest distance between the QA conjugated ring and the water-excluded surface. This distance is decreased by a maximum 2.9 Å in the Δ24–31 truncation of the PsbT subunit, promoting a potential increased rate by a factor of ∼55 (ref. 28). Docking of DMBQ into those newly accessible surfaces corroborates this potential rate acceleration (Supplementary Table 2).
By truncating PsbT, we also aimed at an increased peptide flexibility either by breaking electrostatic interactions between C-terminal sequences of the CP43 and PsbT subunits, or by eliminating two prolines that rigidify the protein backbone. We therefore considered three options: (1) the complete deletion of the C-terminal part from position R24 to K31 (the C-terminus), (2) a shorter deletion from P27 to K31, which preserves the 24-RDP-26 sequence and thus the interactions between PsbT-R24 and CP43-D461 on the one hand, and between PsbT-D25 and PsbL-R15 on the other hand, both of which may stabilize the structure, (3) the substitution of the 24-RDPP-27 tetrapeptide by glycine–glycine–alanine–glycine (GGAG). This would suppress the above-mentioned interactions and may loosen the structure in the vicinity of QA, while preserving the C-terminus sequence of PsbT and, in particular, PsbT-R28 which interacts with CP43-D461 and may thus stabilize this side of the putative entry pathway to QA (Fig. 4c,d). According to our models in Fig. 4, the most favourable case regarding the accessibility to QA is the Δ24–31 truncation, followed by the Δ27–31 truncation and the GGAG substitution (Fig. 4b,d). All these mutations, associated with an antibiotic resistance cassette for the selection of transformed cells, were introduced in the chloroplast genome of the WT strain by biolistic transformation. Transformants were all, except that carrying the psbD(W253A) mutation, capable of phototrophic growth, although the phototrophic growth capability of the psbC(Δ454–461), psbD(W253H) and psbD(W253Y) mutant strains was significantly reduced (Supplementary Fig. 2).
Characterization of the mutated strains
The relative abundance of PSII in the above mutants was analysed by immunoblotting their content in D2, one of the two major reaction centre II subunits (Fig. 5). None of the psbT-C-terminus mutants showed significant changes in their PSII content, but deletion of the CP43 C-terminus resulted in a two-fold decrease in the relative abundance of PSII. Surprisingly, the PSI content was somehow affected in these strains. Polar effects due to aadA insertion downstream of the psbC gene upon gene transformation might be responsible for these changes. In the psbD mutant strains, the E241Q, E242Q and W253H substitutions hardly affected the PSII content whereas it was drastically diminished in the W253Y and W253F mutants and remained below detection in strain W253A. We noted some variation in the accumulation of the b6f complex, probed via its PetA product that did not correlate with the changes in abundance of PSII.
We also measured the PSII/(PSI+PSII) ratio using the light-induced absorbance change at 520 nm, which is proportional to the number of light-induced charge separation29,30. Overall, the results were consistent with the immunoblot analysis, with the exception of the psbD(W253H) mutant that showed only 50–60% PSII activity despite a wild-type content in PSII proteins (Table 1).
We then characterized the various strains using chlorophyll fluorescence analysis (Table 1). The FV/FM value, which is a measure of the maximum quantum efficiency of PSII, expectedly decreased according to the decrease in PSII/(PSI+PSII) ratio. The (FM−FS)/FV value, which equals the PSII operating efficiency over the PSII maximal efficiency31, did not decrease as much as the FV/FM value, thus indicating that the decrease of the PSII to PSI ratio to about 50% in the case of the psbC mutant strains did not affect the overall light-induced flux, at the light intensity used for this experiment (26 μmol photons m−2 s−1).
The mutations introduced in the QA binding pocket and its surroundings may also affect the midpoint potential of QA/QA°−. Changes in this parameter may be assessed by measuring the lifetime of QA°− in the presence of DCMU, although it does not provide an absolute measure of the midpoint potential32. Indeed, QA°− lifetime depending on the free energy gap between the P680°+QA°− and P680°+Pheo°− radical pairs should be affected by variations in the midpoint potential of the QA/QA°− couple, assuming that the midpoint potentials of the other redox couples involved are not affected in a compensatory manner32,33. We thus measured the lifetime of QA°− after a single-turnover light flash in the presence of DCMU. The intensity of the laser flash was kept low enough to induce ≤15% of the maximum fluorescence changes. Under such conditions, fluorescence changes are linearly correlated to changes in the fraction of QA°− (refs 34, 35), whose lifetime can be reliably assessed from the decay of fluorescence yield. Table 1 shows that QA°− lifetime was similar in the ΔpsbT strain and in the WT and only marginally affected in the three psbT-C-terminus mutants. C-terminal truncation of the CP43 protein and substitution of E242 by glutamine in the D2 protein somewhat slowed down the re-oxidation of QA°−. The D2-W253 site turned out to be an important determinant of the midpoint potential of QA/QA°−, as its mutation severely affected the lifetime of QA°− from about two times shorter (W253F) to 5 and 30 times longer (W253Y and W253H) than in the control strain psbD(aadA) (see Methods for details regarding the construction of the control strain). We note here that, owing to the impressive stability of QA°− in the psbD(W253H) mutant strain, a significant fraction of QA may be in the reduced state in the dark. This precludes a reliable assessment of PSII/(PSI+PSII) by the measure of the light-induced absorbance changes at 520 nm, thus explaining the above-described apparent discrepancy between the functional and biochemical determination of the PSII content in that strain.
Efficiency of electron transfer to DMBQ in mutated strains
As discussed above, we used the normalized kred/kred(0) ratio to estimate the relative efficiency of light-induced electron flux toward DMBQ in the various mutants. The rationale for this approach is saliently illustrated by the contrasting features of Supplementary Fig. 3a and Fig. 6a, which respectively show the raw P700 reduction ratio and the kred/kred(0) ratio as a function of [DMBQ]. Albeit the overall lower electron fluxes from PSII to PSI (Supplementary Fig. 3a), the relative efficiency in the D2-W253 mutants was not higher than that in the control strain (Fig. 6a). We also note that the normalized reduction rate of P700 was higher in WT than in the psbD(aadA) and most of the psbD mutant strains. This may stem from genetic drift upon several rounds of subcloning of the transformants on spectinomycin-containing growth medium (see ref. 36 for discussion of the wild type concept in Chlamydomonas), as well as from limited changes in chloroplast gene expression, when introducing the aadA gene downstream of the psbD gene.
Although we observed no significant differences in the kred/kred(0) ratio between the ΔpsbT and WT strains (Fig. 6b and Supplementary Fig. 3b), the three psbT-C-terminus mutant strains displayed a lower normalized reduction rate than the control strain in the presence of DMBQ (Fig. 6c). This suggests that modifying the C-terminal part of PsbT increased the accessibility of QA°− to DMBQ, thereby generating a man-made electron transfer pathway competing with the natural flow between PSII and PSI. In addition, the data obtained in the absence of exogenous quinones (Supplementary Fig. 3c) showed that, in the conditions tested so far, the photosynthetic capacities of these strains are not compromised by the mutations. The psbC mutants looked less promising since, despite their higher sensitivity to the addition of quinones in terms of electron flow from PSII to PSI (Fig. 6d), they had a somewhat reduced PSII content (Table 1) that suggests a compromised stability of the protein that may become critical in other experimental conditions. We note that, when assessed in the presence of DCMU, we found no further effect of DMBQ on the electron transport around PSI, as indicated by the kred/kred(0) ratio (Supplementary Fig. 4), which excluded that there were additional electron sources for DMBQ reduction within cyclic electron flow in these mutants. We thus chose to further characterize the various psbT mutants since they turned out to be most promising regarding the design of a novel electron transfer from QA°− to exogenous and stromal electron carrier.
Extraction of electrons from QA°− in the presence of DCMU
To further determine whether DMBQ genuinely harvests electrons from QA°− by approaching the stromal side of the QA binding pocket in the psbT mutants, we designed the following experiment. Algae, first incubated in darkness with DCMU to inhibit electron transfer between QA and QB, were subjected to dim light (0.6 μmol photons m−2 s−1) to generate a steady-state situation in which QA°− should accumulate only in a fraction of PSII. This steady-state concentration of QA°− in the presence of DCMU results from the balance between its rate of light-induced formation and its rate of charge recombination with the oxidizing equivalent stored in the oxygen evolving complex. Provided the light intensity, which determines the rate of QA°− formation, is kept commensurate with the charge recombination rate, QA°− will accumulate only in a fraction of PSII and the steady-state fluorescence level, FS, will be lower than FM. Under such conditions, the exogenous electron acceptor capable to oxidize QA°− via our engineered pathways should decrease the steady-state concentration of QA°− and, from an experimental stand-point, FS. Figure 7a shows the dependence on (DMBQ) of the (FM−FS)/FM ratio normalized to its value in the absence of quinones. Besides a transient decrease at low concentration of DMBQ, the increase in (FM−FS)/FM with increasing (DMBQ) was clearly more pronounced in the ΔpsbT and psbT(Δ24–31) than in the control strain, reaching values close to 1.4 at the maximum concentration tested. The psbT(GGAG) mutant also displayed a significant increase in (FM−FS)/FM ratio up to about 1.2, as did the psbT(Δ27–31) strain, albeit to a much lesser extent.
We then used chronoamperometry (see Methods for details) to assess the ability of DMBQ to divert electrochemical current from the light-induced electron transfer. Representative curves are displayed in Supplementary Fig. 5. We determined the reaction of the light-induced current to the addition of DCMU, the rationale being that only those mutants allowing access of exogenous DMBQ to QA will generate a light-induced current, when electron transfer from QA to QB was inhibited. Figure 7b shows the variations of the slope of the amperometric signal versus time after addition of DCMU. To take into account the differences between strains, the slopes were normalized to their values before DCMU addition. In the control strain psbT(aadA), the normalized slope of the amperometric signal expectedly declined after addition of DCMU. We note that this decline developed in the range of 10–20 min, which reflects the time necessary for the electrode to fully electrolyse the sample volume of the set-up (see Methods and Discussion). The reaction of the amperometric signal of the psbT mutants to the addition of DCMU was similar to that of the psbT(aadA) control, with the remarkable exception of the psbT(Δ24–31) strain: the light-induced exogenous current proved remarkably resilient to the addition of DCMU. We then performed another type of experiment in which the strains were incubated with DCMU well before the onset of illumination (Fig. 8). In this case, the set-up was adapted to analyse the current production at more short times (a few minutes instead of a few hours). Here again the psbT(Δ24–31) strain remained capable of producing a photocurrent in presence of DCMU albeit of lower intensity then in the absence of the inhibitor, while the photocurrent in the control strain was fully suppressed by a preincubation with DCMU. Importantly, the psbT(Δ24–31) mutant was also short-listed after the two previous screens we implemented, either when assessing the electron transfer from QA°− to DMBQ in presence of DCMU or electrons diverted to DMBQ upstream of P700. Thus the chronoamperometric measurements provided further support to the conclusion that Δ24–31 truncation of the PsbT subunit allows electron flow to DMBQ that by-passes the natural QA°− to QB pathway.
We aimed at establishing a proof-of-principle device that would use intact engineered unicellular algae—in the present case Chlamydomonas reinhardtii—to produce a photocurrent without compromising their ability to perform photosynthesis. Producing a photocurrent out of a living cell may of course be the result of many processes, which may be difficult to properly identify, in such a complex multimolecular and multicompartment context. In this respect, the 12 PSII mutant strains in this study provided very contrasting results, once screened for a preserved intrinsic photosynthetic activity and for their ability to transfer electron to DMBQ that would sustain a usable photocurrent. These successive screens lead us to retain one mutant that satisfied the two criteria above therefore standing as the corner stone of future development and improvement of photovoltaic devices along the above described strategy. This study also raises a number of issues worth further investigation, as discussed below.
Several studies have suggested that methyl-substituted benzoquinones, compared with chloro-substituted benzoquinones, have generally less efficient support for light-induced oxygen evolution17,18. The present fluorescence analysis shows that DMBQ is a far less efficient PSII electron acceptor than DCBQ. Its lower reactivity with the plastoquinone pool may be partly due to its relatively negative midpoint potential compared with that of the two other quinones we studied25, but it is also consistent with a lower partitioning in the thylakoid membranes as suggested by the remarkably low quenching capacity of DMBQ (Fig. 2b and ref. 25). In contrast, DMBQ proved as efficient an electron acceptor as DCBQ and PPBQ when interfering with cyclic electron flow, as measured by the P700 re-reduction in the presence of DCMU (Fig. 3d), indicating that it reaches the stromal compartment where it may act as an electron acceptor. Therefore, we selected DMBQ as the proper redox mediator to implement our strategy.
The next step was to design a mutant in which exogenous DMBQ would approach QA°− from the stroma and divert a fraction of the photo-induced electron flow, without impacting the photosynthetic activity in its absence. Substitution of D1-K238 by glutamate in Synechocystis was shown to promote the reduction of cytochrome c by QA°−8. Thylakoids of this mutant strain generated a greater photo-induced current with respect to WT in the presence of exogenous cytochrome c, but its addition as a redox mediator between PSII and the electrode surprisingly turned out to be dispensable7,8. Here, our engineering specifications excluded any purification step thereby imposing the use of an amphiphilic redox mediator able to cross the cell membranes. Thus, the parameters that we had to tune were either the lifetime of QA°− or the accessibility of QA°− to a stromal and amphiphilic electron carrier, which is represented by the distance between the two since distance largely determines electron tunnelling rates28,37.
Owing to the short distance between the tryptophan in position 253 of the D2 protein and the QA site, we had anticipated that its substitution may affect the semiquinone lifetime. Indeed, we observed a surprisingly long-lived semiquinone radical at the QA site when tryptophan was changed to histidine or tyrosine but not to phenylalanine. This suggests that changing a non-polar aromatic residue to a polar one at position 253 considerably stabilizes the semiquinone radical, an effect that would indicate a significant shift in the midpoint potential of the QA/QA°− to more positive values38. We had hypothesized two possible contributions to a better extraction of electrons at the QA site: (1) a longer-lived QA°− species and (2) a shorter electron transfer distance. Hypothesis (1) found no further support since the psbD(W253H) mutant did not sustain a higher extraction efficiency of electrons by DMBQ despite its very long-lived QA°− species, thirty times longer than in the control strain (Table 1 and Fig. 6). By contrast, the promising results with psbT-C-terminus mutants suggest that the main contribution to a better electron extraction at the QA site would rather come from an increased access to exogenous quinones. In other words, peptides covering the QA molecule on the stroma surface prevent redox mediators from harvesting electrons on the stromal side unless they are truncated or modified. We targeted the PsbT subunit because previous studies of the ΔpsbT strain of C. reinhardtii had shown it was still able to grow phototrophically, although cell growth was severely impaired in high-light conditions39,40. The present psbT-C-terminus mutant strains also grew phototrophically, and had a similar amount and activity of PSII as the wild type. Accordingly the longest truncation we used—8 amino acids at the C-terminus of PsbT protein (Δ24–31)—did not compromised PSII activity, in stark contrast with the truncation of 8 amino acids at the C-terminus of CP43 protein (Δ454–461) that significantly compromised PSII accumulation.
When using the available X-ray structural data of PSII from T. vulcanus27, amended for a few amino acid substitutions present in C. reinhardtii, we obtained distances between QA and the modified molecular surface of the various mutants that correlated nicely with electron withdrawal by DMBQ. Docking simulation yielded several docking sites based on the estimation of binding free energy that corroborate the reduction of accessible distances, suggesting that the new formed crevices may be accessible and used by quinones. Nevertheless, the Δ24–31 truncation of the PsbT subunit was the most promising candidate using either of the two approaches, and, from all PSII mutants we examined, the psbT(Δ24–31) mutant showed the most efficient extraction of electrons as proved by (1) the highest re-reduction efficiency of P700 in the absence of DCMU, (2) the highest oxidation efficiency of QA°−, and (3) the highest electrochemical current that could be generated in the presence of DCMU.
The screen for high-extraction efficiency of electrons and for strong interaction with QA°− were respectively conducted by measuring the redox absorbance change of P700 in the absence of photosynthesis inhibitor and chlorophyll fluorescence in the presence of DCMU. While the latter experiment assays the accessibility of QA°− to DMBQ, the former assays the ability of DMBQ to compete with QB in the oxidation of QA°−. Thus, even though a mutation may provide an improved accessibility to the QA site, the electron donation rate to DMBQ may remain too low to compete with the transfer to QB. That was clearly observed when comparing the psbT mutants. The assay conducted in the presence of DCMU would appoint the ΔpsbT, psbT(Δ24–31) and psbT(GGAG), as the three mutants providing the best access to exogenous DMBQ. According to the P700 data, however, only the latter two displayed significant diversion of electrons from P700 reduction in the presence of DMBQ. Since the PsbT subunit has a transmembrane orientation in the vicinity of a cluster of carotenoids at the PSII dimer interface, its absence may impact neighbouring protein subunits and cofactors and result in a lower stability of PSII lacking PsbT in adverse conditions, as was shown earlier by its increased photosensitivity39,40. Further in vitro experiments using the engineered PSII reaction centres harbouring modified PsbT sequences should allow one to fully characterize their redox and kinetic properties, when assessed in the presence of DMBQ.
For our chronoamperometric measurements, we used an adapted set-up to extract photosynthetic electrons from an algae population by means of exogenous DMBQ acting as an electron carrier to a large carbon electrode surface. The resulting photocurrent under illumination was in the range of 10–20 μA. Comparison of these results with those from studies using non-intact or immobilized cells on other types of electrodes should be taken with care. Still the performance is often in the same range. As an example, the current density reported by Sekar et al.12 using immobilized cyanobacteria is close to 2,000 mA m−2 with 2 mM quinones. This is of the same order of magnitude as the present work (10–100 mA m−2 with 30 μM quinones), given that changes in configuration (adsorbed organisms, specific surfaces and so on) prevent a more accurate comparison.
The specific resiliency of the DMBQ-mediated photocurrent upon addition of DCMU to the psbT(Δ24–31) mutant demonstrates the significance of the chronoamperometric measurement regarding extraction of electrons from the QA site. Such a resiliency was also observed when considering a preincubation with DCMU. However, we noted that our set-up delivered photocurrents in the same range of amplitudes regardless of the quinone added (see Supplementary Fig. 8 for examples) despite their different extraction sites of photosynthetic electrons. These observations suggest a current limited by the mass transfer (convection and diffusion) of DMBQ between the bulk solution and the anode, which leads to many energy losses. Still, our experimental values compare well with an estimation of the photocurrent magnitude resulting from a convection-diffusion limitation (see Methods), which gives values of a few tens μA depending on the thickness of the diffusion layer.
Strains and growth conditions
C. reinhardtii strain T222+ (hereafter referred as WT), derived from multiple backcrosses of the 137c strain41, and the ΔpetA strain lacking the cytochrome b6f complex42 were used in this study. The psbT deletion (ΔpsbT) strain39 is a kind gift from Yuichiro Takahashi (Okayama University, Japan). Cells were grown to mid-log phase (2–5 × 106 cells per ml) in Tris-acetate-phosphate (TAP) liquid medium43 at 25 °C under white LED light (8 μmol photons m−2 s−1) before further measurements.
Molecular modelling and visualization
Homology models of the C. reinhardtii PSII and of its mutated variants were based on the PSII crystal structure of T. vulcanus (PDB code: 3ARC)27 and built with the SWISS-MODEL workspace44,45. Docking simulation of DMBQ onto the stromal side of the PSII was performed with the AutoDockTools and Autodock Vina programs46,47. Accessibility distances were calculated with UCSF Chimera48. The protein structures were visualized with the VMD program49.
Site-directed mutagenesis of chloroplast-encoded genes
To construct chloroplast transformation vectors for site-directed mutagenesis of the CP43, PsbT, or D2 proteins in C. reinhardtii, plasmids encompassing the psbC, psbT or psbD genes were respectively obtained from the Chlamydomonas Resource Center (P-578: psbC and P-72: psbT) or the pH3P plasmid for psbD (ref. 50). To avoid any polar effects of the insertion of the antibiotic resistance cassette used for the selection of transformants, which could hamper the expression of the downstream located genes, we used an engineered aadA cassette. We cloned an extra copy of the psaA promoter and 5′UTR regions downstream of the strong processing site within the rbcL 3′UTR. This was done by megaprime PCR51 using plasmid paAKR52 as a template and oligonucleotides rbcLCod and psaARev as external primers (see Supplementary Table 1 for the list of the oligonucleotides used in this work), and rbcLRev and psaACod as internal primers. The 494 bp long resulting PCR product, comprising a shortened version of the 3′rbcL followed by the psaA promoter and 5′UTR regions, was digested with PstI and SphI and cloned into the paAKR plasmid digested with the same enzymes to yield plasmid paAKRaA.
For psbD site directed mutagenesis, the pH3P plasmid50 was first shortened by digestion with PstI and AvrII and religated on itself to create plasmid pH3PSh. The modified aAKRaA cassette, excised from plasmid paAKRaA with restriction enzymes SmaI and EcoRV was introduced into the AleI site of the pH3PSh plasmid, downstream of and in the same orientation as psbD to yield plasmid pH3aAKRaA, used to generate the psbD(aadA) control strain. Site-directed mutations were constructed by megaprime PCR using plasmid pH3PSh as a template, the external primers psbD-mut-EF/ aadA-ER and the mutagenic oligonucleotides psbD-XX-IF/psbD-XX-IR (where XX corresponds to the mutations listed in Supplementary Table 1b). The final PCR product (1,562 bp) was digested by BstEII and AarI and cloned into the pH3aAKRaA vector digested by the same enzymes to yield transformation vectors pH3aAKRaA(XX).
For psbT site directed mutagenesis, the P-72 plasmid contains a 4.4 kb EcoRI fragment of the C. reinhardtii chloroplast genome encompassing the psbT coding sequence cloned in pUC8 and was obtained from the Chlamydomonas Resource Center. ClaI and AgeI restriction sites were introduced downstream of the psbT 3′UTR by megaprime PCR using the external primers psbT-aadA-EF/psbT-aadA-ER and the mutagenic primers psbT-aadA-IF/psbT-aadA-IR. The resulting 1,228 bp amplicon was digested with BanII and PstI and cloned into the P-72 vector digested with the same enzymes to generate P-72_AC. The aAKRaA resistance cassette, excised from plasmid paAKRaA by digestion with ClaI and AvaI, was cloned into the ClaI- AgeI digested plasmid P-72_AC to yield the P-72aAKRaA plasmid, used to generate the psbT(aadA) control strain. Mutations in the C-terminal end of PsbT were introduced by megaprime PCR using the external primers psbT-aadA-EF and aadA-ER and the mutagenic primers psbT-YY-IF and psbT-YY-IR, where YY designates the mutations listed in Supplementary Table 1c. The resulting 1,047 bp amplicon, digested with BanII and BstEII, was cloned into the P-72aAKRaA plasmid digested with the same enzymes to generate the P-72aAKRaA(YY) chloroplast transformation vectors.
For psbC site directed mutagenesis, the P-578 plasmid, obtained from the Chlamydomonas Resource Center, harbours a 10 kb EcoRI fragment of the chloroplast genome encompassing the last 173 codons of psbC, cloned in pBR328. This plasmid was first shortened by digestion with SnaBI and Tth111I and religated on itself to yield plasmid P-578Sh. MfeI and XmaI restriction sites were then introduced downstream of the psbC 3′UTR by megaprime PCR using psbC-aadA-EF/psbC-aadA-ER as external primers, and the mutagenic oligonucleotides psbC-aadA-IF/psbC-aadA-IR (see Supplementary Table 1d). The resulting 1,448 bp amplicon was digested with PmlI and XcmI and cloned into the P-578Sh vector digested by the same enzymes to generate plasmid P-578Sh_MX. The aAKRaA resistance cassette, excised from plasmid paAKRaA by EcoRI and XmaI, was cloned between the MfeI and XmaI sites of P-578Sh_MX to yield the P-578aAKRaA plasmid, used to recover the psbC(aadA) control strain. Truncations of the PsbC C-terminal ends were generated by PCR using the psbC-stop-R oligonucleotide together with primers psbC-F450stop-F or psbC-V454stop-F. The resulting 794 bp PCR products were digested by PmlI and BlpI and cloned into the P-578aAKRaA plasmid digested by the same enzymes to create the psbC(F450st) and psbC(V454st) transformation vectors.
All constructs were sequenced before transformation into the Chlamydomonas chloroplast genome to assess the presence of the desired mutations in an otherwise wild-type sequence. Mutations were introduced in WT C. reinhardtii cells by biolistic transformation53 using a home-built helium-driven biolistic gun54. The aadA strains containing the 5′psaA-aadA-3′rbcL gene without site-specific mutations were used as a control which shares with the mutant strains the same aadA insertion. Transformants were selected on spectinomycin-containing TAP solid medium plates (100 μg ml−1) and further sub-cloned until they reached homoplasmy on TAP solid medium supplemented with 500 μg ml−1 spectinomycin. Homoplasmy was checked by RFLP analysis of specific PCR products. At least three independent transformants were analysed for each constructs; variations between independent clones proved negligible.
Cells grown in TAP liquid medium were centrifuged at 4,000g for 5 min at 20 °C and resuspended in 0.1 M DTT, 0.1 M Na2CO3, 15% (w/v) glycerol, 1 × proteinase inhibitor cocktails (Roche) and frozen in liquid nitrogen. After addition of SDS (2% final), samples were heated at 95 °C for 1 min. The insoluble material was removed by centrifugation at 12,800g for 20 min, and proteins were loaded on an equal chlorophyll basis on a Mini-PROTEAN electrophoresis system (Bio-Rad) and separated by SDS–polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS–PAGE). For immunoblot analysis, proteins were transferred onto nitrocellulose membranes, and the membranes were blocked with 5% (w/v) skim milk in a phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) solution plus 0.1% (v/v) Tween 20 (Sigma-Aldrich). The target proteins were probed with primary antibodies and then incubated with horseradish peroxidase-conjugated anti-rabbit IgG antibodies (Catalogue number: W4011, Promega) at a dilution ratio of 1:100,000. The primary antibodies against the PSII subunit D2 (Catalogue number: AS06 146; used at a dilution ratio of 1:50,000) and the PSI subunit PsaA (Catalogue number: AS06 172; used at a dilution ratio of 1:10,000) were purchased from Agrisera. Antibodies against cytochrome f (PetA; used at a dilution ratio of 1:5,000) were prepared using purified cytochrome f injected to rabbits54, and those against the ATP synthase subunit β (AtpB; used at a dilution ratio of 1:5,000) were kindly provided by C. Lemaire (Centre de Génétique Moléculaire, Gif-sur-Yvette, France)55. Immuno-reactive proteins were detected with an Amersham ECL Select detection reagent (GE Healthcare) and visualized using the ChemiDoc XRS+ System (Bio-Rad). The uncropped blot images of Fig. 5 are displayed in Supplementary Fig. 9.
Chlorophyll fluorescence and spectroscopic analyses
Cells grown in TAP liquid medium were centrifuged at 4,000g for 5 min at 20 °C and resuspended in 20 mM HEPES pH 7.2, 10% (w/v) Ficoll PM400 (Sigma-Aldrich). Cells were then vigorously shaken at 300 r.p.m. for 30 min in the dark before spectroscopic measurements. Light-induced changes of absorbance and of chlorophyll fluorescence were measured with a JTS-10 spectrophotometer (Bio-Logic). Detection and actinic lights were provided by LEDs, and a short (5 ns) saturating light flash was provided by a dye laser (640 nm) pumped by a second harmonic Nd-YAG laser (Minilite, Continuum). Interferential filters were used to transmit detection light at selected wavelengths. The 6-mm bandpass glass filters (BG-39, Schott) were placed in front of photodiodes to cut off most of the excitation light.
The ratio of PSII to (PSI+PSII) was computed from absorbance changes measured at 520 nm (10 nm width at half maximum) 100 μs after an actinic flash: we subtracted signals obtained after adding 10 μM DCMU plus 1 mM hydroxylamine to pre-illuminated algae, yielding only one electrogenic charge transfer event per PSI, from those obtained with untreated algae that correspond to one electrogenic charge transfer event per PSI+PSII29,30. The P700 redox levels were calculated from absorbance changes measured at 705 nm (6 nm width at half maximum) corrected by subtraction of absorbance changes measured at 730 nm; the P700 reduction ratio is 1 minus the light-induced oxidation ratio of P700 (see Supplementary Fig. 1a for the calculation of the oxidation ratio of P700). The latter ratio is defined as the light-induced oxidation level of P700 divided by the maximal amplitude of P700 oxidation, which corresponds to the complete oxidation of P700 after a 10-ms excitation light pulse minus its relaxation level in the dark56,57.
The chronoamperometric measurements were performed in an adapted three-compartment cell using a QuadStat potentiostat supplemented with an e-corder data recorder (eDAQ). Vitreous carbon foam (ref. 398–733–69, Goodfellow Cambridge, UK) was used as a working electrode (∼0.25 cm3) and soaked in PBS solution (ref. 18912, Life Technologies) overnight before measurements. A platinum wire and an Ag/AgCl wire were used as counter and reference electrodes, respectively, and both separated with fritted glass of medium porosity. All the measurements were carried out in PBS solution at 25 °C. Control experiments demonstrated that negligible current was generated upon illumination in our set-up when C. reinhardtii cells or quinones were not supplemented (Supplementary Fig. 6). The generated current would reach to a steady-state level after ∼1 h of illumination (Supplementary Fig. 7).
For kinetic study of DMBQ reduction, C. reinhardtii cells grown in TAP liquid medium were centrifuged at 4,000g for 5 min at 20 °C and resuspended in the electrolytic cell containing 8 ml of PBS solution with the chlorophyll concentration adjusted to 4 μg ml−1. The solution was stirred with a magnetic stirrer at 350 r.p.m. The biased potential was set at 0.65 V versus Ag/AgCl, and the current was recorded every 2 s. The solution was supplemented with 30 μM DMBQ 5 min before its subjection to the illumination of green LED light (peak emission at 530 nm, 50 nm width at half maximum, 30 μmol photons m−2 s−1). The rise of current reached a steady-state level after 5–10 min of illumination, and 10 μM DCMU was added 15 min after illumination. The slope of current rise was estimated using the least squares approach to fit the current data in the range of a certain time point±1.5 min to a linear model. Because of the different locations of the electrode and the illumination zone (due the spectro-electrochemical cell geometry), the photocurrent magnitude is expected to be limited by mass-transport-controlled electrochemical re-oxidation (nFACD/δ). Given n=2, F=96,500 C mol−1, D=10−6 cm2 s−1 and A=specific electrode surface area given by the supplier=20 cm2, typical current values for C=30 μmol l−1 may range from 10 to 90 μA depending on δ=diffusion layer estimated as being in the range of 12.5 (from Levich’s law) to 100 μm. The recorded photocurrent values (10–20 μA) are of the same order of magnitude knowing that the maximum current value (90 μA) is an overestimation. In particular, the lowest diffusion layer thickness is probably underestimated by the Levich’s approximation, whereas the active quinone concentration is overestimated. Indeed it depends on the actual concentration of oxidized quinones in solution and on the other hand, a significant portion should be sequestered in cellular compartments other than the thylakoid membranes25.
Chronoamperometric measurements involving a preincubation with DCMU were performed in an adapted electrochemical cell using a Princeton potentiostat Parstat 2273. An ITO/Au modified glass slide was used as the working electrode. This electrode was obtained by sputtering a thin indium tin oxide (ITO) film (thickness 10 nm) followed by another film of gold (20 nm) onto the glass slide using a sputtering system EMITECH K675X. A PDMS (polydimethyloxane RTV-615; Momentive Performance Materials) piece with a 9 mm diameter hole inside was attached on the ITO/Au modified glass slide by the mean of a treatment with oxygen plasma at 400 mtorr (100 W) for 3 min (Harrick Plasma, NY, USA). The final device thus corresponds to a PDMS well (volume ∼0.5 ml) possessing the ITO/Au working electrode in the bottom. A platinum wire and a Ag/AgCl wire were finally used as the counter and as the reference electrodes, respectively.
C. reinhardtii cells were grown in TAP liquid medium and resuspended in minimum medium (chlorophyll concentration adjusted to 4 μg ml−1). Solutions were incubated with DCMU (10 μM) and then DMBQ (30 μmol l−1; 20 min) or only with DMBQ (30 μmol l−1; 20 min) before the experiments were carried out. The working electrode potential was subsequently set at 0.38 V versus Ag/AgCl and the current was recorded every 2.7 s. The actinic light was triggered once a stable baseline is observed. The actinic white light was provided by a Scott KL1500 LCD halogen lamp (50 μmol photons m−2 s−1 spanning the 400–700 nm range). The lamp was switched on 30 min before shutter opening to allow temperature stabilization.
All the data generated during the study are available from the authors.
How to cite this article: Fu, H.-Y. et al. Redesigning the QA binding site of Photosystem II allows reduction of exogenous quinones. Nat. Commun. 8, 15274 doi: 10.1038/ncomms15274 (2017).
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We wish to acknowledge basic support from Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) and Université Pierre et Marie Curie (UPMC) to UMR7141 and UMR 8640, and competitive funding from Labex Dynamo (ANR-11-LABX-0011-01). H.-Y.F. benefited from a postdoctoral support from Fondation Pierre-Gilles de Gennes (FPGG0049) and from Fondation Edmond de Rothschild. Fabrice Rappaport deceased in January 2016 before completion of the final version of this manuscript. His co-authors dedicate this study in his memory.
Supplementary Figures and Supplementary Tables
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/