This Article is retracted by the authors. Nature Communications previously issued an Editorial Expression of Concern ( related to this Article, following the publication of a report commissioned by The Karolinska Institute and prepared by the Expert Group for Misconduct in Research at the Swedish Central Ethical Review Board. Owing to the technical issues raised by this investigation, we, the authors, are now retracting the Article.

P.M., S.S., Y.G., S.B., M.A.B., C.D.G., A.S., K.K., H.K., P.D., A.B., R.H., D.R., C.I., B.J. and D.A.T. agree with this retraction. P.J., M.L.L., J.H., G.L., A.B.R., H.U. and Y.Z. could not be reached for comment.

About this article

Publication history




  1. Search for Sebastian Sjöqvist in:

  2. Search for Philipp Jungebluth in:

  3. Search for Mei Ling Lim in:

  4. Search for Johannes C. Haag in:

  5. Search for Ylva Gustafsson in:

  6. Search for Greg Lemon in:

  7. Search for Silvia Baiguera in:

  8. Search for Miguel Angel Burguillos in:

  9. Search for Costantino Del Gaudio in:

  10. Search for Antonio Beltrán Rodríguez in:

  11. Search for Alexander Sotnichenko in:

  12. Search for Karolina Kublickiene in:

  13. Search for Henrik Ullman in:

  14. Search for Heike Kielstein in:

  15. Search for Peter Damberg in:

  16. Search for Alessandra Bianco in:

  17. Search for Rainer Heuchel in:

  18. Search for Ying Zhao in:

  19. Search for Domenico Ribatti in:

  20. Search for Cristián Ibarra in:

  21. Search for Bertrand Joseph in:

  22. Search for Doris A. Taylor in:

  23. Search for Paolo Macchiarini in:

Further reading


By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.