Breast cancer, one of the most common and deadly malignancies, has undoubtedly plagued humans since the dawn of our species. The history of the fight against the disease is one of lurching progress against a backdrop of misery. But recent decades have seen greatly improved treatments and increased survival. By Will Tauxe.
200 million years ago
Milk-producing skin glands evolve during the Late Triassic period in a group of egg-laying proto-dinosaurs called cynodonts. Instead of sweat or scent, these early mammaries produce a simple milk to supplement the diet of hatchlings. Over time, these glands grouped together under nipples and began responding to sex hormones such as oestrogen.
∼ 2500 BC
A medical text from ancient Egypt contains the first known reference to breast cancer. It describes 48 surgical problems, including “bulging tumours on the breast”. The unknown author describes “swellings on [the] breast, large, spreading and hard: touching them is like touching a ball of bandages”. It would be some time before surgeons could offer anything beyond a diagnosis. The author's take on treatment: “there is nothing”.
Box of bones: ∼2200 BC
During a 2015 excavation of the Egyptian necropolis Qubbet el-Hawa near Aswan, a team led by Egyptologists and anthropologists from the University of Jaén in Spain discovered a coffin with remarkable contents: bones of a woman, showing the tell-tale deformations of metastatic breast cancer (pictured). She died some 4,200 years ago, making her the first known victim of the disease.
Doctors begin to embrace the possibilities — and limitations — of surgery for breast cancer. In eleventh-century Moorish Spain, the noted surgeon Abu al-Qasim al-Zahrawi writes that breast cancer could be cured when “complete removal [of the tumour] is possible, and especially when in the early stage and small. But when it is of long standing and large, you should leave it alone. I myself have never been able to cure such, nor have I seen anyone else succeed before me”.
Deep cut: 1590
French surgeon Barthélémy Cabrol suggests that advanced breast cancer could be cured by removing the underlying chest muscles along with the breast. Others will attempt variations on this idea for centuries, with often dismal results.
Emil Grubbe, an electronics enthusiast and medical student at the Hahnemann Medical College in Chicago, Illinois, assembles one of the earliest X-ray devices. A colleague remarks on the radiation burns on Grubbe's hands and suggests that X-rays might be used against unhealthy tissue. The first recorded instance of radiation oncology occurs later that year when Grubbe's machine is used to irradiate a breast carcinoma in a woman named Rose Lee. She reportedly received several hour-long treatments and died shortly thereafter.
X-ray vision: 1956
Robert Egan starts to develop effective mammography, an X-ray examination that can detect breast tumours that are too small to be felt. By the 1970s, mammography has become a popular screening test for women.
Double standard: 1975
The National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project shows that surgery combined with chemotherapy works better against breast cancer than surgery alone. Combined treatments become the standard of care.
Drug stop: 1977
The oestrogen-blocking drug tamoxifen (pictured) is approved in the United States as a treatment for advanced metastatic breast cancer. Today, tamoxifen is one of many hormone-blocking drugs used worldwide to treat — and in some cases prevent — certain types of breast cancer.
Mary-Claire King and colleagues (J. M. Hall et al. Science 250, 1684–1689; 1990) use samples of DNA from families with a history of breast cancer to establish a link between mutations in a tumour-suppressing gene she names BRCA1 and an elevated risk of breast and ovarian cancer. The discovery changed thinking about genetic influences on cancer. Further research showed that mutations in another gene, BRCA2, could also increase cancer risk. Today, some women who test positive for these mutations — including actress Angelina Jolie (pictured) — choose to have their breasts removed to reduce their cancer risk.
Busted flush: 1995
The US Nurses' Health Study reveals that hormone replacement therapy (HRT) increases the risk of developing breast cancer. At the time, HRT was popular both to treat and prevent menopausal symptoms among post-menopausal women. Today, HRT is no longer routinely recommended for long-term use in post-menopausal women.
Charles Perou and colleagues (C. M. Perou et al. Nature 406, 747–752; 2000) show that breast cancers can be grouped into clinical subtypes on the basis of mutations in their DNA. Analysis of tumour-cell DNA enables doctors to choose treatments that are more likely to be effective. The subtype of 'triple-receptor-negative' breast cancer is particularly difficult to treat because these cancers do not respond to signals from any of the breast growth hormones: oestrogen, progesterone and human epidermal growth factor 2.
Less is more: 2002
Two large studies show that people with breast cancer live just as long after small lumpectomy surgery combined with radiation as they do after radical mastectomy. Further studies show that only a narrow 2-millimetre 'clean margin' of healthy tissue needs to be removed along with the cancer in a lumpectomy.
Times change: 2009
The US Preventive Services Task Force recommends that women should be offered a mammogram first at age 50, and then every other year after — a departure from previous advice to start annual screening at age 40. The change sparks debate about the balance between the harm of unnecessary treatment and the risk of undiagnosed cancers.
In the case Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, the US Supreme Court overturns molecular-diagnostics company Myriad's patents on the genetic codes of BRCA1 and BRCA2. The court's decision states that “a naturally occurring DNA segment is a product of nature and not patent eligible”, although tests to find specific harmful mutations are still considered patentable.
In 2015, breast-cancer survival rates are at their highest ever. More than 6 million people worldwide are still alive 5 years after being diagnosed with breast cancer, although survival rates continue to lag in areas without reliable access to advanced medicine. Breast cancers are now treated with tailored combinations of surgery, chemotherapy and radiation, and continued research is making treatments more precise and minimizing side effects.
About this article
Scientific Reports (2017)