The Moon's current orbit is at odds with theories predicting that its early orbit was in Earth's equatorial plane. Simulations now suggest that its orbit was tilted by gravitational interactions with a few large bodies. See Letter p.492
Four and a half billion years ago, a giant impact with Earth is thought to have created an Earth-orbiting disk of debris that coalesced to form the Moon. 'Inelastic' collisions between such debris would dissipate energy and remove relative up-and-down motions, so that the Moon that assembled from these collisions would orbit approximately in Earth's equatorial plane. Yet the Moon's current orbit implies that its initial orbit was substantially inclined relative to Earth's Equator1, a troubling contradiction.
On page 492 of this issue, Pahlevan and Morbidelli2 identify a compelling and simple solution to this problem — that the Moon's early orbit was gravitationally jostled into a tilted state by close passes of large objects left over from the formation of the inner planets. The existence of a population of these objects could also explain how elements such as iridium, platinum and gold were delivered to Earth's outer layers after the Moon formed3.
The Earth–Moon pair is a dynamically coupled system. The Moon's gravity raises tides on Earth, most notably in the oceans, and gravitational interactions between these tides and the Moon is causing Earth's rotation to slow as the Moon's orbit expands. Tidal interactions also reduce the tilt of the Moon's orbit relative to a preferred plane. This would have coincided with Earth's equatorial plane when the early Moon was orbiting close to Earth and transitioned to the plane of Earth's orbit around the Sun as the Moon's orbit expanded. In the absence of other effects, the current 5° inclination of the Moon's orbit relative to Earth's orbital plane implies an initial 10° inclination relative to Earth's equatorial plane when the Moon formed1, 10 times larger than expected according to theory4.
A seemingly unrelated — until now — set of clues about the conditions soon after the Moon formed emerge from the abundance of precious metals in the Earth. Elements such as platinum and gold are highly siderophile, which means that they have strong chemical affinities for iron. Because Earth formed in a largely molten state, high-density iron would have readily sunk to the planet's centre to form a core, taking highly siderophile elements with it and efficiently removing these from Earth's upper layers. The fact that we find such elements in relatively high abundance in rocks at Earth's surface suggests that they were delivered to the planet after the end of core formation, through a 'late veneer' of material that added about the last 1% of Earth's mass5.
If Earth's late veneer was delivered by a large number of small impactors, the Moon would have received about 1/20th as many impactors on the basis of its smaller cross section3. But lunar siderophile abundances imply that the Moon received much less than that amount. It thus seems probable that Earth's late veneer was delivered by only a few large impactors, each roughly comparable in size to the Moon, because the Moon would have received less than its proportionate share under these circumstances.
Pahlevan and Morbidelli use computational methods (Monte Carlo simulations) to consider the effects of such a population of large, late-accreting background objects on the Moon's early orbit. Their simulations begin with a Moon orbiting in Earth's equatorial plane close to our planet (Fig. 1). With time, the Moon's orbit expands because of tidal interaction with Earth, and is gravitationally perturbed by the background objects until this population is depleted over typically a few tens of millions of years.
Central to the new work is the recognition that each object that ultimately collides with Earth first undergoes many thousands of non-collisional close passes, a portion of which strongly perturb the Moon's orbit. An object approaching the Moon from a random direction may increase or decrease the Moon's orbital tilt. But just as a series of steps, each equally likely to be forward or backward, causes the standard deviation in the net distance travelled to increase with time, so too does a series of randomly oriented kicks to the lunar orbit lead to a general increase with time in the probability of exciting a minimum tilt.
Pahlevan and Morbidelli's results show a high likelihood that such random scattering events can cumulatively produce the necessary early tilt in the Moon's orbit, as long as the number of objects that deliver the final approximately 1% of Earth's mass is small (fewer than 5) and the rate of early tidal expansion of the Moon's orbit is sufficiently rapid. The rate of early tidal expansion needed is broadly consistent with the average tidal properties inferred for Earth on the basis of the expansion of the Moon's orbit to its current orbital distance. However, the specific values that would have applied to the earliest Earth remain uncertain.
The magnitude of the excited tilt scales roughly linearly with the late mass delivered to Earth. It is not known what fraction of the siderophiles that were concentrated in the cores of such large impactors would have been retained in Earth's upper layers. Improved models of late-veneer impacts should therefore be used to better constrain the late-accreted mass; this would in turn allow a closer approximation of the inclination expected from scattering. Moreover, the new scattering model is most effective if the Moon's inclination has been damped only by tides. If other forms of inclination damping have occurred, then — depending on the timing of this damping — the required initial inclination might increase, and with it the required mass of background objects, perhaps to unrealistically high values.
Previously reported models for the origin of the Moon's inclination rely on more-complex processes involving either a periodic gravitational interaction (gravitational resonance) with the Sun6 or a resonant interaction between the Moon and its precursor disk7. Both require rather narrow sets of conditions for success. The new mechanism is simpler than these models, and the population of late lunar-sized objects that it requires is compellingly consistent with that needed to account for the delivery of Earth's precious metals, a completely independent constraint. Had such a population of objects not existed, the Moon might be orbiting in Earth's orbital plane, with total solar eclipses occurring as a spectacular monthly event. But our jewellery would be much less impressive — made from tin and copper, rather than from platinum and gold. Footnote 1
Goldreich, P. Rev. Geophys. 4, 411–439 (1966).
Pahlevan, K. & Morbidelli, A. Nature 527, 492–494 (2015).
Bottke, W. F., Walker, R. J., Day, J. M. D., Nesvorny, D. & Elkins-Tanton, L. Science 330, 1527–1530 (2010).
Ida, S., Canup, R. M. & Stewart, G. R. Nature 389, 353–357 (1997).
Walker, R. J. Chem. Erde 69, 101–125 (2009).
Touma, J. & Wisdom, J. Astron. J. 115, 1653–1663 (1998).
Ward, W. R. & Canup, R. M. Nature 403, 741–743 (2000).