Clash of cultures means early return for physics prizewinner.
Perhaps the relationship never had a chance. Robert Laughlin, who shared the 1998 Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on quantum fluids, was hired in July 2004 to reform the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST) in Daejeon. Last week, the institute's board of trustees decided not to renew his two-year contract.
Laughlin, formerly of Stanford University in California, was recruited by the office of South Korea's president, Moo Hyun Roh, to help shake up the country's university system. The reforms he proposed were fairly standard from a US perspective: he advocated competitive hiring of faculty at market rates; expanding the undergraduate student body; and running preparatory undergraduate degrees in medicine, law and business.
Many of KAIST's 400 or so professors did not agree with Laughlin's approach. Of 278 that took part in a vote, 89% said they did not want him to continue. Choon Sup Yoon, a condensed-matter physicist who heads the faculty association, says that Laughlin's plans to expand the university's professional schools and humanities departments would have undermined KAIST's traditional status as a science and technology powerhouse. “His philosophy is totally different from what KAIST is about,” says Yoon.
Another KAIST researcher, who did not want to be named, says the problem was more to do with Laughlin's attitude. “The content was not that bad. But he made enemies, probably because of a lack of experience in running an organization,” he says.
Laughlin admits that he lacked experience, but says that was not the real problem. The point of his dismissal, he says, “was to discredit the policy of hiring outsiders”.
It was a stormy end to a bitter affair in which Laughlin was even at times accused of abusing his vacation privileges. Some say it was inevitable. Chan-Mo Park, head of Pohang University of Science and Technology where Laughlin still holds a post as distinguished professor, says that philosophies simply clashed. “Everything resulted from a cultural difference between the two countries,” says Park. “It's a very sad story.”
Laughlin finishes at KAIST in mid-July and will return to Stanford to resume teaching in the autumn.