Featured
-
-
Article
| Open AccessDonut-like organization of inhibition underlies categorical neural responses in the midbrain
Decision making is facilitated by categorical neuronal responses, which robustly signal a winner despite input noise. In this study, the authors demonstrate that a donut-like inhibition motif effectively generates such categorical responses.
- Nagaraj R. Mahajan
- & Shreesh P. Mysore
-
Article
| Open AccessPrimate anterior insular cortex represents economic decision variables proposed by prospect theory
Prospect theory predicts irrational effects in human decision-making, but relies on ad-hoc assumptions. Here, authors provide a neural basis for this by showing that anterior insular cortex encodes key economic variables proposed by prospect theory.
- You-Ping Yang
- , Xinjian Li
- & Veit Stuphorn
-
Article
| Open AccessPremature commitment to uncertain decisions during human NMDA receptor hypofunction
In uncertain conditions, people make accurate decisions by considering multiple pieces of information. Here, the authors show that pharmacological n-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) receptor hypofunction is associated with elevated uncertainty and premature decisions based on unreliable evidence.
- Alexandre Salvador
- , Luc H. Arnal
- & Valentin Wyart
-
Article
| Open AccessTransient neuronal suppression for exploitation of new sensory evidence
While evidence is constantly changing during real-world decisions, little is known about how the brain deals with such changes. Here, the authors show that the brain strategically suppresses motor output via the frontal eye fields in response to stimulus changes.
- Maxwell Shinn
- , Daeyeol Lee
- & Hyojung Seo
-
Article
| Open AccessSources of confidence in value-based choice
The authors show that metacognitive awareness of choice certainty is closely linked to endogenous attentional states that guide decision behaviour.
- Jeroen Brus
- , Helena Aebersold
- & Rafael Polania
-
Article
| Open AccessComputational mechanisms of distributed value representations and mixed learning strategies
Real-world learning is particularly challenging because reward can be associated to many features of choice options. Here, the authors show that humans can learn complex learning strategies and reveal their underlying computational and neural mechanisms.
- Shiva Farashahi
- & Alireza Soltani
-
Article
| Open AccessProactive and reactive accumulation-to-bound processes compete during perceptual decisions
Models of perceptual decision making typically take into account either reactive responses to external stimuli or proactive aspects to decision making. Here the authors found that rat perceptual responses are generated by a combination of the standard evidence accumulation process with a fixed decision boundary, and a separate stochastic boundary collapse triggered by a parallel proactive process.
- Lluís Hernández-Navarro
- , Ainhoa Hermoso-Mendizabal
- & Alexandre Hyafil
-
Article
| Open AccessIndividual differences in information-seeking
Information-seeking is important for learning, social behaviour and decision making. Here the authors investigate factors that associate with individual differences in information-seeking behaviour.
- Christopher. A. Kelly
- & Tali Sharot
-
Article
| Open AccessA model for learning based on the joint estimation of stochasticity and volatility
Human learning depends on opposing effects of two noise factors: volatility and stochasticity. Here the authors present a model of learning that shows how and why joint estimation of these factors is important for understanding healthy and pathological learning.
- Payam Piray
- & Nathaniel D. Daw
-
Article
| Open AccessPrecise visuomotor transformations underlying collective behavior in larval zebrafish
How visual social information informs movement is unclear. Here, the authors characterise the algorithm zebrafish use to transform visual inputs from neighbours into movement decisions during collective swimming behavior. The authors can also predict the neural circuits involved in transforming the visual input into movement decisions.
- Roy Harpaz
- , Minh Nguyet Nguyen
- & Florian Engert
-
Article
| Open AccessEntropy-based metrics for predicting choice behavior based on local response to reward
Animals distribute their choices between alternative options according to relative reinforcement they receive from those options (matching law). Here, the authors propose metrics based on information theory that can predict this global behavioral rule based on local response to reward feedback.
- Ethan Trepka
- , Mehran Spitmaan
- & Alireza Soltani
-
Article
| Open AccessA habenula-insular circuit encodes the willingness to act
A crucial component of voluntary behaviour is deciding that it is worth doing something rather than nothing. Here the authors show the brain network that encodes this decision, which includes the habenula and anterior insula.
- Nima Khalighinejad
- , Neil Garrett
- & Matthew F. S. Rushworth
-
Article
| Open AccessConcept neurons in the human medial temporal lobe flexibly represent abstract relations between concepts
It is unclear how distinct concepts are processed in the brain. Here, the authors recorded from concept cells in human subjects with epilepsy and found that a subset of concept cells responded to non-preferred concepts if those non-preferred concepts required comparison to a preferred concept.
- Marcel Bausch
- , Johannes Niediek
- & Florian Mormann
-
Article
| Open AccessLearning non-stationary Langevin dynamics from stochastic observations of latent trajectories
Langevin dynamics describe transient behavior of many complex systems, however, inferring Langevin equations from noisy data is challenging. The authors present an inference framework for non-stationary latent Langevin dynamics and test it on models of spiking neural activity during decision making.
- Mikhail Genkin
- , Owen Hughes
- & Tatiana A. Engel
-
Article
| Open AccessZebrafish capable of generating future state prediction error show improved active avoidance behavior in virtual reality
Using a closed-loop virtual reality system for fish, the authors show that zebrafish are capable of assigning rules to the scenery they see, and of generating a state prediction error by comparing reality with a prediction derived from an internal model.
- Makio Torigoe
- , Tanvir Islam
- & Hitoshi Okamoto
-
Article
| Open AccessBayesian inference with incomplete knowledge explains perceptual confidence and its deviations from accuracy
A Bayesian framework based on partially observable Markov decision processes (POMDPs) not only predicts subjects’ confidence in a perceptual decision making task but also explains well-known discrepancies between confidence and choice accuracy as arising from incomplete knowledge of the environment.
- Koosha Khalvati
- , Roozbeh Kiani
- & Rajesh P. N. Rao
-
Article
| Open AccessLinear reinforcement learning in planning, grid fields, and cognitive control
Models of decision making have so far been unable to account for how humans’ choices can be flexible yet efficient. Here the authors present a linear reinforcement learning model which explains both flexibility, and rare limitations such as habits, as arising from efficient approximate computation
- Payam Piray
- & Nathaniel D. Daw
-
Article
| Open AccessA common limiter circuit for opioid choice and relapse identified in a rodent addiction model
The neural circuits underlying rewarding effects of drugs of abuse and natural rewards are not fully understood. Here the authors investigate the role of the infralimbic cortex to nucleus accumbens shell pathway during heroin or food choice in rats.
- Jasper A. Heinsbroek
- , Giuseppe Giannotti
- & Jamie Peters
-
Article
| Open AccessMemory and decision making interact to shape the value of unchosen options
Making a decision requires one to differentiate between choice options, committing to one and leaving the other behind. Here, the authors show that decision-making paradoxically binds options together, such that the outcome of the choice ends up changing the value of both the chosen and the unchosen options, in opposite directions.
- Natalie Biderman
- & Daphna Shohamy
-
Article
| Open AccessDecision-related feedback in visual cortex lacks spatial selectivity
Feedback modulates visual neurons, thought to help achieve flexible task performance. Here, the authors show decision-related feedback is not only relayed to task-relevant neurons, suggesting a broader mechanism and supporting a previously hypothesized link to feature-based attention.
- Katrina R. Quinn
- , Lenka Seillier
- & Hendrikje Nienborg
-
Article
| Open AccessChildren’s exploratory play tracks the discriminability of hypotheses
People can infer unobserved causes of perceptual data (e.g. the contents of a box from the sound made by shaking it). Here the authors show that children compare what they hear with what they would have heard given other causes, and explore longer when the heard and imagined sounds are hard to discriminate.
- Max H. Siegel
- , Rachel W. Magid
- & Laura E. Schulz
-
Article
| Open AccessTransforming absolute value to categorical choice in primate superior colliculus during value-based decision making
Value-based decision making involves choosing from multiple options with different values. The authors identify a neural mechanism that directly transforms absolute values to categorical choices within the superior colliculus and which supports value-based decision making critical for real-world economic behaviours.
- Beizhen Zhang
- , Janis Ying Ying Kan
- & Michael Christopher Dorris
-
Article
| Open AccessA cortico-collicular pathway for motor planning in a memory-dependent perceptual decision task
Duan, Pan et al. find that the premotor cortex cooperates with the midbrain superior colliculus via direct projections to implement decision maintenance. These results reveal mechanisms of cortico-collicular interaction during cognition and action in a pathway- and cell-type-specific manner.
- Chunyu A. Duan
- , Yuxin Pan
- & Ning-long Xu
-
Article
| Open AccessThalamocortical excitability modulation guides human perception under uncertainty
How is neural processing adjusted when people experience uncertainty about the relevance of a stimulus feature? Here, the authors provide evidence suggesting that heightened uncertainty shifts cortical networks from a rhythmic to an asynchronous (“excited”) state and that the thalamus is central for such uncertainty-related shifts.
- Julian Q. Kosciessa
- , Ulman Lindenberger
- & Douglas D. Garrett
-
Article
| Open AccessInteracting with volatile environments stabilizes hidden-state inference and its brain signatures
Here, the authors show that humans perceive uncertain environments as more stable when actively interacting with them than when observing them. Magnetoencephalographic signals in the temporal lobe were associated with the increased stability of beliefs during active sampling.
- Aurélien Weiss
- , Valérian Chambon
- & Valentin Wyart
-
Article
| Open AccessPrimate ventral striatum maintains neural representations of the value of previously rewarded objects for habitual seeking
Ventral striatum is known to be involved in the value update for habit learning. Here, the authors report neural and behavioural correlates for the long-term maintenance of value memory for previously rewarded objects in the ventral striatum of humans and monkeys.
- Joonyoung Kang
- , Hyeji Kim
- & Hyoung F. Kim
-
Article
| Open AccessA Hierarchical Attractor Network Model of perceptual versus intentional decision updates
In this study, the authors distinguish between changes of mind about perceptual vs. intentional decisions. A Hierarchical Attractor Network Model is proposed in which human voluntary actions emerge from continuous and dynamic integration of higher-order intentions with sensory evidence and motor costs.
- Anne Löffler
- , Anastasia Sylaidi
- & Patrick Haggard
-
Article
| Open AccessMulticentric tracking of multiple agents by anterior cingulate cortex during pursuit and evasion
Pursuit or evasion requires world-centric and agent-centric representation to coordinate navigation and motor control. The dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, which communicates bi-directionally with both the hippocampal complex and premotor areas serve a mapping role in this process.
- Seng Bum Michael Yoo
- , Jiaxin Cindy Tu
- & Benjamin Yost Hayden
-
Article
| Open AccessDifferential reinforcement encoding along the hippocampal long axis helps resolve the explore–exploit dilemma
Decisions under uncertainty involve a balance between exploiting familiar valuable options and exploring unfamiliar ones. Here, the authors study hippocampal responses using fMRI during a reinforcement learning task, and show the differential involvement of the anterior-posterior regions in the explore-exploit aspects of the task.
- Alexandre Y. Dombrovski
- , Beatriz Luna
- & Michael N. Hallquist
-
Article
| Open AccessLarge-scale dynamics of perceptual decision information across human cortex
Even decisions based on simple sensory stimuli result from an interplay between many brain regions. Here, the authors track the dynamics of information about sensory input and behavioral choice across the human cerebral cortex, uncovering feedback of decision signals to early sensory cortex.
- Niklas Wilming
- , Peter R. Murphy
- & Tobias H. Donner
-
Article
| Open AccessGABAergic motor neurons bias locomotor decision-making in C. elegans
Motor neurons are generally considered to be passive receivers of commands from other neurons. However, this study shows that motor neurons may shape locomotor behaviour by regulating premotor neurons, and that premotor neurons serve to integrate information from sensory neurons and motor neurons.
- Ping Liu
- , Bojun Chen
- & Zhao-Wen Wang
-
Article
| Open AccessTransferring structural knowledge across cognitive maps in humans and models
Humans are able to exploit patterns or schemas when performing new tasks, but the mechanism for this ability is still unknown. Using graph-learning tasks, we show that humans are able to transfer abstract structural knowledge and suggest a computational mechanism by which such transfer can occur.
- Shirley Mark
- , Rani Moran
- & Timothy E. J. Behrens
-
Article
| Open AccessUnconscious reinforcement learning of hidden brain states supported by confidence
Humans can unconsciously learn to gamble on rewarding options, but can they do so when it comes to their own mental states? Here, the authors show that participants can learn to use unconscious representations in their own brains to earn rewards, and that metacognition correlates with their learning processes.
- Aurelio Cortese
- , Hakwan Lau
- & Mitsuo Kawato
-
Article
| Open AccessMolecular layer interneurons in the cerebellum encode for valence in associative learning
This study shows that cerebellar molecular layer interneurons (MLIs) develop responses encoding for identity of the stimulus in an associative learning task. Chemogenetic inhibition of MLIs decreased the ability of mice to discriminate stimuli suggesting that MLIs encode for stimulus valence.
- Ming Ma
- , Gregory L. Futia
- & Diego Restrepo
-
Article
| Open AccessNeural mechanisms underlying the effects of physical fatigue on effort-based choice
Fatigue influences our choices to engage in physical activity. Here, the authors investigate the underlying cognitive and neuronal mechanisms by which fatigue influences decisions to exert, and show that information about motor cortical state modulates decisions to engage in physical activity.
- Patrick S. Hogan
- , Steven X. Chen
- & Vikram S. Chib
-
Article
| Open AccessThe suboptimality of perceptual decision making with multiple alternatives
What sensory information is available for decision making? Here, using multi-alternative decisions, the authors show that a substantial amount of information from sensory representations is lost during the transformation to a decision-level representation.
- Jiwon Yeon
- & Dobromir Rahnev
-
Article
| Open AccessGlobal reward state affects learning and activity in raphe nucleus and anterior insula in monkeys
Wittmann and colleagues show that not only single outcome events but also the global reward state (GRS) impact learning in macaques; low GRS drives explorative choices. Analyses of macaque BOLD signal reveals that GRS impacts activity in the anterior insula as well as the dorsal raphe nucleus.
- Marco K. Wittmann
- , Elsa Fouragnan
- & Matthew F. S. Rushworth
-
Article
| Open AccessValue and choice as separable and stable representations in orbitofrontal cortex
In value-based decision-making, single prefrontal neurons represent multiple variables at different times in the decision process. Here, the authors show these representations to be separable and stable at the population level, allowing read out of specific variables at behaviorally relevant times.
- Daniel L. Kimmel
- , Gamaleldin F. Elsayed
- & William T. Newsome
-
Article
| Open AccessBiased belief updating and suboptimal choice in foraging decisions
In some types of decision-making, people must accept or forego an option without knowing what prospects might later be available. Here, the authors reveal how a key bias– asymmetric learning from negative versus positive outcomes – emerges in this type of decision.
- Neil Garrett
- & Nathaniel D. Daw
-
Article
| Open AccessDecisions bias future choices by modifying hippocampal associative memories
Decision-making is traditionally thought to be guided by memories of option values. Here, the authors challenge this view by showing that merely making a choice – even without experiencing any outcomes – alters neural representations of stimulus-reward associations and biases future decisions.
- Lennart Luettgau
- , Claus Tempelmann
- & Gerhard Jocham
-
Article
| Open AccessAnatomically and functionally distinct thalamocortical inputs to primary and secondary mouse whisker somatosensory cortices
The thalamus provides sensory input to the cortex, but many aspects of thalamocortical signaling remain unknown. Here, the authors reveal parallel non-overlapping thalamic pathways with distinct representations of tactile and decision-related information during a goal-directed sensorimotor task.
- Sami El-Boustani
- , B. Semihcan Sermet
- & Carl C. H. Petersen
-
Article
| Open AccessHuman stereoEEG recordings reveal network dynamics of decision-making in a rule-switching task
How sensory evidence is transformed into motor output is not fully understood. Here, the authors use stereoEEG recordings during a rule-switching task to reveal network dynamics of decision-making.
- Marije ter Wal
- , Artem Platonov
- & Paul H. E. Tiesinga
-
Article
| Open AccessSpatial planning with long visual range benefits escape from visual predators in complex naturalistic environments
Habitat complexity influences the sensory ecology of predator-prey interactions. Here, the authors show that habitat complexity also affects the use of different decision-making paradigms, namely habit- and plan-based action selection. Simulations across habitat types show that only savanna-like terrestrial habitats favor planning during visually-guided predator evasion, while aquatic and simple terrestrial habitats do not.
- Ugurcan Mugan
- & Malcolm A. MacIver
-
Article
| Open AccessConfidence drives a neural confirmation bias
People often ignore evidence that disconfirms their prior beliefs. Here, the authors investigate the underlying cognitive, computational and neuronal mechanisms of such confirmation bias, and show that high confidence induces a selective neural processing of choice-consistent information.
- Max Rollwage
- , Alisa Loosen
- & Stephen M. Fleming
-
Article
| Open AccessRepresentation of probabilistic outcomes during risky decision-making
Goal directed behavior requires the sequential retrieval and evaluation of the multiple choices for action and their deterministic outcomes. Here, the authors report sequential, decodable probabilistic outcome representations in magnetoencephalography (MEG) signals during a risky foraging task.
- Giuseppe Castegnetti
- , Athina Tzovara
- & Dominik R. Bach
-
Article
| Open AccessA mechanistic account of serotonin’s impact on mood
The cognitive computational mechanisms underlying the antidepressant treatment response of SSRIs is not well understood. Here the authors show that SSRI treatment in healthy subjects for a week manifests as an amplification of the perception of positive outcomes when learning occurs in a positive mood setting.
- Jochen Michely
- , Eran Eldar
- & Raymond J. Dolan
-
Article
| Open AccessConfidence reports in decision-making with multiple alternatives violate the Bayesian confidence hypothesis
Conventional theory suggests that people’s confidence about a decision reflects their subjective probability that the decision was correct. By studying decisions with multiple alternatives, the authors show that confidence reports instead reflect the difference in probabilities between the chosen and the next-best alternative.
- Hsin-Hung Li
- & Wei Ji Ma
-
Article
| Open AccessOptogenetic manipulation of a value-coding pathway from the primate caudate tail facilitates saccadic gaze shift
The caudate tail encodes the stable value associated with visual objects and modulates gaze accordingly. Here, the authors use pathway-specific optogenetic manipulation of the caudate terminals in the substantia nigra pars reticulata on oculomotor behaviour.
- Hidetoshi Amita
- , Hyoung F. Kim
- & Okihide Hikosaka
-
Article
| Open AccessResponse outcomes gate the impact of expectations on perceptual decisions
The authors use a combination of perceptual decision making in rats and computational modeling to explore the interplay of priors and sensory cues. They find that rats can learn to either alternate or repeat their actions based on reward likelihood and the influence of bias on their actions disappears after making an error.
- Ainhoa Hermoso-Mendizabal
- , Alexandre Hyafil
- & Jaime de la Rocha