Abstract
Replying to: H. F. Jørgensen & A. G. Fisher Nature 467, doi:10.1038/nature09305 (2010)
Jørgensen and Fisher1 suggest that the discrepancy with our results2 could be attributable to our use of E14Tg2a (or its derivatives, such as OS25) rather than E14Tg2a.4 as the parental control line for the REST+/− cells (YHC and RRC). We have now reconfirmed our use of E14Tg2a.4 clonal cells as the control cells. Also, we have found that the YHC and RRC cells used in our experiments2, originally purchased from Bay Genomics, differ from the YHC and RRC cells used by Jørgensen and Fisher1 with respect to pluripotency-based on alkaline phosphatase/self-renewal assays (N. Song and S.K.S., unpublished results). We are currently using other assays to confirm these observations.
Similar content being viewed by others
Main
We have discovered that the original YHC and RRC cells from Bay Genomics were expanded without drug selection at MMRRC before being made available for distribution; these were the cells used by Jørgensen and Fisher1. Such propagation of mutant cells under self-renewal culture conditions could create an adaptive response, in which mutant cells produce changes to dampen the REST-mediated pathway and activate counteracting mechanisms to increase the self-renewing cell population.
To eliminate the effect of adaptive response of mutant cells to growth conditions, we grew wild-type E14Tg2a.4 mouse ES cells2 and knocked-down Rest with small interfering RNA or short hairpin RNA. The results indicated a clear dependence of pluripotency of these cells on REST protein and that this pathway involved microRNA21, supporting our original observation2.
We therefore believe that growth conditions such as media, duration of growth and presence of fibroblasts can influence REST’s role in pluripotency. We would welcome exchange of cells and information on culture conditions to help clarify the situation.
References
Jørgensen, H. F. & Fisher, A. G. Can controversies be put to REST? Nature 467 10.1038/nature09305 (2010)
Singh, S. K., Kagalwala, M. N., Parker-Thornburg, J., Adams, H. & Majumder, S. REST maintains self-renewal and pluripotency of embryonic stem cells. Nature 453, 223–227 (2008)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Author contributions N.S., P.S. and S.K.S.: project planning, data collection, data analysis and review; M.N.K., J.P.T., H.A.: review; S.M.: project planning, writing and review.
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
declared none.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Singh, S., Kagalwala, M., Parker-Thornburg, J. et al. Singh et al. reply. Nature 467, E5 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature09306
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature09306
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.