Among the incomparably diverse group of insects no cases of central nervous system (CNS) preservation have been so far described in compression fossils. A third of the fossil insects collected from a 240–239 million year old (Ma) level at Monte San Giorgio UNESCO World Heritage (Switzerland-Italy) underwent phosphatization, resulting in the extraordinary preservation of soft tissues. Here we describe Gigamachilis triassicus gen. et sp. nov. (Archaeognatha: Machiloidea: Machilidae) that, with an estimated total length of ~80 millimeters, represents the largest apterygote insect ever recorded. The holotype preserves: (i) components of the CNS represented by four abdominal ganglia, optic lobes with neuropils and compound retina; (ii) muscular bundles. Moreover, G. triassicus, possessing morphological features that prompt its assignment to the extant archaeognathan ingroup Machilidae, places the origin of modern lineages to Middle Triassic. Interestingly, at Monte San Giorgio, in the same stratigraphic unit the modern morphology of G. triassicus co-occurs with the ancient one represented by Dasyleptus triassicus (Archaeognatha: †Monura). Comparing these two types of body organization we provide a new reconstruction of the possible character evolution leading towards modern archaeognathan forms, suggesting the acquisition of novel features in a lineage of apterygote insects during the Permian or the Lower Triassic.
The exceptional preservation of soft tissues in compression fossils has been reported only in few occurrences within invertebrates, as in the case of Cambrian arthropods from Chengjiang (e.g., refs 1, 2, 3, 4, 5) and Burgess Shale (e.g., refs 6, 7, 8). Such soft tissue preservation has been only exceptionally achieved by tissue mineralization, usually involving pyritisation and phosphatization9,10 or, in the case of non-mineralized fossils, in the form of kerogenized carbon films11. Phosphatization of organic matter is a process occurring in anoxic conditions and it is usually mediated by bacteria9; the diffusion of phosphate released from the decaying animal’s tissues to the surrounding media is prevented by a microbial film acting as insulation10. Approximately one third of the fossil insects collected from the Kalkschieferzone (239.51 ± 0.15 Ma)12 of Monte San Giorgio (UNESCO World Heritage Site, Switzerland-Italy) are completely or partially phosphatized13. In this Lagerstätte, phosphatization has been observed also in crustaceans but, interestingly, never among vertebrates (A.T. pers. obs). Here we describe two completely phosphatized specimens we assign to an extant bristletail group (Insecta: Archaeognatha: Machiloidea: Machilidae). They exhibit giant size, compared to known extinct and extant species (overall organism length of ~80 mm, body plus filum terminale), and extraordinarily preserved internal soft tissues, notably components of the central nervous system (CNS) and muscular bundles.
The fossil record of Archaeognatha (Machiloidea plus †Monura) is sparse and is often represented by fragmentary material. Specimens attributed to archaeognathan lineages span from Late Devonian (~379 Ma)14 to Miocene (~13 Ma)15. So far, most of the Paleozoic and Mesozoic samples are representatives of Dasyleptus, the only ingroup of †Dasyleptidae and †Monura (hence equivalent to these), while most of Cenozoic species are representatives of Machilis (Machilidae). The oldest bristletail fossils are fragments that date back to the Devonian Period14,16. A specimen described from Gaspé Bay (390–392 Ma) is a head capsule plus a separate thoracic fragment from the same organism16. The presence of large but dorsally not converging eyes on the head capsule, a synapomorphic trait of all modern bristletails17, suggest the assignment of this specimen to the Paleozoic monuran rather than to modern lineages. Findings from the compressed shales of Gilboa (376–379 Ma) are represented by partial tergites plus an eye fragment. The tergites bear coffin-shaped sockets compatible with structures present in extant bristletails, while the eye fragment was “tentatively identified as belonging to machilid insect” by the authors14. So far, fossils of certain attribution to Machilidae are known only from the Eocene18,19,20. Complete or almost complete Palaeozoic specimens of clear systematic affiliation have been described only for the extinct genus Dasyleptus (†Monura)21,22,23,24,25,26,27. Three specimens of Dasyleptus triassicus (†Monura) have been recovered from the same stratigraphic unit of our findings28, and many specimens from the German Upper Buntsandstein deposits (Obere Röttonsteine, Early Anisian) in Lower Franconia and Thuringia29. These findings extend the presence of Dasyleptus well after the end-Permian mass extinction (252.3 Ma) and demonstrate that these organisms were still quite common in the Middle Triassic. Here we provide an updated reconstruction of character evolution leading towards the modern forms of bristletails based on the comparison between the ancient-type D. triassicus and the modern-type represented by the new species described. Furthermore, we provide evidence for the acquisition of a new body organization in a lineage of apterygote insects at the end of the Permian or during the Triassic Period, after the end-Permian mass extinction.
Euarthropoda sensu Walossek, 199930; Insecta Linnaeus, 1758; Archaeognatha Börner, 1904; Machiloidea Handlirsch, 1904; Machilidae Grassi, 1888; Gigamachilis gen. nov. http://zoobank.org/urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:58CF94C0-30E8-4102-B4CD-918FDE929C02
Gigamachilis triassicus new species here designated. http://zoobank.org/urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:760D7E33-357C-430E-BB93-F71EF36B32DA
Giga- (from Greek gígas) means giant, referring to the very large size; -machilis from Machilidae to which Gigamachilis is ascribed; triassicus (Latin) refers to the Triassic Period.
The two G. triassicus types were recovered at the UNESCO World Heritage Middle Triassic site of Monte San Giorgio (Switzerland) in locality D (Val Mara, Meride) on the uppermost part of the Lower Kalkschieferzone. Detailed information regarding geology, dating of the collecting site and on the fossil assemblage is reported in Supplementary Note 1.
Specimen will be deposited at Museo Cantonale di Storia Naturale di Lugano (MCSN) – Switzerland. MCSN8463 (holotype) is an almost complete specimen (Figs 1, 2 and 3) while MCSN8466 (paratype) preserves only the abdomen and the metathorax (Supplementary Fig. S1).
Taphonomy and preservation
Holotype and paratype are fully phosphatized. The holotype preserves the entire body, including soft tissues, with the exception of the distal part of the body appendages as the maxillary palps, the antennae, the walking legs and the filum terminale. This preservation, including the loss of the delicate appendages, suggests that G. triassicus was rapidly transported from its original habitat to the depositional basin by a high-energy event, such as floods caused by heavy rains. The rapid transportation of the specimens to the anoxic condition of the depositional basin represents a requirement to obtain soft tissue preservation through the bacteria-mediated process of phosphatization. Since the body outline of both specimens is preserved, we can infer that underwater currents and bioturbation were absent in the depositional environment.
Huge machilids, almost twice the size of the largest species of Machilidae known so far. The pattern of coxal vesicles distribution is not congruent with any previously described form, both extinct and extant.
G. triassicus is ascribed to Archaeognatha based upon the following characters: large maxillary palps with several elements, abdominal coxopodites with coxopodal vesicles and styli, paired annulated cerci and filum terminale (basal parts preserved). The presence of styli-like structures on the second thoracic leg and of scales on appendages prompts its attribution to the extant group Machilidae.
Here we describe the new taxon based on the almost complete holotype (MCSN8463; Figs 1, 2 and 3); the description of the partially preserved paratype (Supplementary Fig. S1) is provided in the Supplementary Note 1.
General habitus: specimen with head and thorax slightly rotated in the sagittal plane, only visible in ventral view; body length from the apex of the head to the apex of the last abdominal segment, thus excluding filum terminale, of 40 mm; body maximum width of 12.5 mm (second thoracic segment) (Fig. 1). On the base of the ratio between the length of the filum terminale and that of the whole organism in extant taxa, the length of G. triassicus was estimated in approximately 80 mm.
Head: eyes very large, developed laterally. Antennae partially preserved, only proximal parts visible: antennal socket, scapus, pedicellus and a portion of the annulated flagella (length 2.9 mm). Mouthparts partially preserved. The terminal element of the right labial palp and the first three elements of the large leg-like maxillary palps are visible; labium prementum, maxillary palpifers and glossae are partially visible.
Thorax: total length 9.8 mm, maximum width at mesothorax 12.5 mm. Impression of lateral rims of pronotum and mesonotum preserved on the right side (respectively 1.8 and of 3.6 mm long; mesonotum thickness 0.6 mm), rim of mesonotum partially preserved on the left side. Procoxae (length: right 3.9 mm, left 3.3 mm), proximal part of protrochanters, mesocoxae (length: right 4.2 mm, left 2.8 mm) and mesotrochanters (length: right 3.5 mm, left 4.3 mm) preserved. Left mesocoxa bearing the proximal part of the coxal stylet (length 0.9 mm). Trochanter distally lobe-shaped. Right metacoxa (length 4.7 mm) and metatrochanter preserved (length 9.2 mm), the first bearing coxal stylet (length 4.3 mm), setae (length 0.35 mm) and scales (Figs 1 and 2). Left metatrochanter only partially visible.
Abdomen: composed of 10 visible segments, the first only partially visible on the right side, the last segment bearing the proximal part of the two cerci and of the filum terminale. Total length 26.3 mm, maximum width at abdominal metamere I 10.1 mm. Inferior rim of the tergite and right coxopodite preserved on abdominal metameres I to VIII, whereas in metamere IX these structures are visible but poorly preserved (Fig. 1). Coxopodal vesicles present on abdominal segments I to VII (Figs 1 and 2E–H). Abdominal styli are clearly visible on abdominal appendages II (left) and IV (right). Cerci and filum terminale on segment X partially preserved.
Soft tissue preservation
Notably, in the holotype of Gigamachilis triassicus soft tissues are preserved, namely parts of the central nervous system and muscular bundles within legs, abdominal appendages and in the head. The following structures of the central nervous system, are preserved: (i) optic lobes and, possibly, components of the lateral protocerebrum (right side) (Figs 1, 2A,B and 3D–G); (ii) partial ventral nerve cord composed of four pairs of abdominal ganglia with their connectives (Figs 1 and 3A,B). Symmetrically to the postmentum, two semispherical structures are preserved (Figs 1, 2A,B and 3D–G). Due to their position and to the striated structures they are interpreted as compound retinae (Fig. 3D–G). Posteriorly to the retina the optic lobes are visible (Figs 1, 2A,B, 3D–G). On the right side the outline of the three nested retinotopic neuropils characteristic of the optic lobes of extant archaeognathans (Fig. 3E–G) can be distinguished, namely, from outside to inside: the lamina, the medulla on which it is possible to recognize the Cuccati’s bundle (indicated by the arrow in Fig. 3F) and the protolobula. In addition, three other areas, possibly belonging to the lateral protocerebrum are preserved (Fig. 3D–G). A bundle-like feature is visible below the optic lobes; considering its position and its fibrous nature, it might represent segmental cephalic muscular bundles such as those present below the posterior tentorium or as the superimposed muscles of the labial palp (distal part of the labial right palp visible in Fig. 2A,B).
More clearly than in the head region, in four abdominal segments of G. triassicus ganglia joined by their paired connectives are visible (Figs 1 and 3A,B). The exceptional preservation of these structures allows the identification of two hemiganglia in three out of the four preserved ones and, possibly, the commissure in ganglion VIIa and VIIIa. They are compatible with neuropils within the ganglia (length and width of the ganglia: VIa ~440 μm, ~320 μm; VIIa ~580 μm, ~310 μm; VIIIa ~370, ~260 μm).
Muscular bundles, hypothesized as femur-trochanter and adductor muscles are preserved respectively in the mesotrochanter and within the right hind leg in coxa and trochanter (Figs 1B,C and 2C,D). In addition, within abdominal plates I to IV muscles of stylets and of coxal vesicles are visible.
Gigamachilis triassicus, with an estimated total length of ~80 millimeters, is known from two phosphatized specimens preserved in ventral view. The exceptional preservation of soft tissues at ultrastructural level observed in G. triassicus includes abdominal ganglia, compound retina, optic lobes with the possible presence of the three nested neuropils found in modern archaeognathans, components of the lateral protocerebrum and muscular bundles. This preservation occurred through the microbially mediated taphonomic process of phosphatization9 and it has never been reported so far among compression fossils of terrestrial arthropods. A remarkable case of such exceptional preservation was previously observed in a specimen of Mesolimulus walchi from the Upper Jurassic, where spiral and coccoid bacteria forming a biofilm were preserved in addition to the horseshoe crab musculature31. In the Kalkschieferzone of Monte San Giorgio approximately one third of the insects recovered are completely or partially phosphatized13. Noteworthy, the phosphatized specimens belong to insect groups such as bristletails and stoneflies (larvae), in which the cross-link between proteins of the exocuticle and quinone occurs only in limited parts of the exoskeleton. In the Kalkschieferzone, phosphatization occurred also in other arthropods (i.e., crustaceans) but not in vertebrates (A.T. pers. obs.). The depositional environment of the Kalkschieferzone, a shallow lagoon adjacent to a carbonate platform32,33, has likely facilitated a rapid process of fossilization, which prevented the consumption of organic matter and allowed the preservation of soft tissues together with their fine structural features. The presence of clay-chips beds, rich in algal film fragments32,33, may be considered as a clue that in the depositional environment of the Kalkschieferzone the conditions for the microbially mediated phosphatization of organic matter were established.
Here, for the first time in compression fossils of terrestrial arthropods, components of the CNS are preserved. The ventral nerve cord exhibits a homonomous metameric pattern, as to be expected. Notably, the ganglia of ventral nerve cord observable in G. triassicus highly resemble those of extant Machilidae (Fig. 3C). In the optic lobes, the number and the relative position of the three nested retinotopic neuropils correspond to those of extant bristletails, indicating a phenotypic stability of these structure lasting at least ~240 My (extant archaeognathan optic lobes reported in Sinakevitch et al.34 Figure 9D); for an exemplary review on the organization of the optic lobes across crustaceans and insects see Strausfeld35.
The discovery of G. triassicus, a representative of Machilidae, besides tracing the origin of this lineage back to the Middle Triassic and extending the range of this group by approximately 200 My, sheds light also on the evolution of archaeognathan body organization. Archaeognatha with a different body organization co-occur in the same stratigraphic unit at Monte San Giorgio: (i) G. triassicus representing the new lineage with the presence of well developed cerci and with filum terminale and a large, possibly arched, metathorax supporting jumping capabilities; and (ii) D. triassicus, the more ancestral-type, surviving the end-Permian mass extinction (Fig. 4). The latter, according to the fossil record28,29, was near to its extinction while the former was just blooming.
It has been observed that representatives of Dasyleptus markedly resemble juveniles of extant species of Machiloidea25,36. Therefore, two hypotheses could be formulated as possible explanations concerning of the co-occurrence of these two forms: (i) representatives of Dasyleptus, including D. triassicus, recovered from Upper Carboniferous to Middle Triassic, represent immature stages of Machiloidea; or, (ii) fossils described as Dasyleptus are representatives of separate species. Even if the first hypothesis is still debated25,36,37,38, Rinehart and colleagues39, identified six instars in Dasyleptus brongniarti from Kuznetsk Formation (Middle Permian) and estimated an adult length of 15–20 mm (including the filum terminale). The authors establish that most specimens of Dasyleptus should represent adults and their morphology would therefore be an ancestral adult condition for archaeognathans. The morphology of modern archaeognathans, including G. triassicus, would then be a derived condition (Fig. 4) representing an example in which ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny (seen in juvenile machilids, hence a case of peramorphosis).
The evolutionary scenario we propose differs from that so far accepted (Fig. 4) since it postpones the divergence between Machiloidea and Dasyleptus. The time and the drivers for the evolution of the new body organization in this lineage of apterous insects are currently unknown. Possible causes could include peculiar paleoenvironmental conditions at the end of the Permian and in the Early Triassic. The high temperatures at the P/T boundary and during the Smithian40 may have favored the small size of Dasyleptus. Conversely, the switch to a cooler climate during the Spathian40 in association with the adaptive advantage provided by body size diversification during the biotic recovery following the end-Permian mass extinction41 could be considered the propulsive forces that led to the evolution of giant bristletails with new body organization and jumping capability. An alternative hypothesis relies on a possible, not yet identified abiotic event or on a series of events having occurred during the Middle Triassic that significantly contributed to the renewal of insect lineages. The last hypothesis is supported also by the high rates of insect lineage turnover, origination and extinction in the Middle Triassic42,43, where some Paleozoic insect lineages become extinct and others have their first occurrence in the same periods. Our findings, associated with the presence of D. triassicus on the same stratigraphic unit, support this interpretation of insect evolution. However, the evolution of G. triassicus during the Permian, or in earlier period, cannot be ruled out on the basis of currently available data. Studies integrating further fossil evidences and molecular data are required to shed light in the evolution of extant representatives of Machilidae.
Materials and Methods
The two specimens used in this study were collected during the fieldwork activities carried out between 1997 and 2003 in the Lower Kalkschieferzone (KSZ), the uppermost part of the Meride Limestone, at the Val Mara site D near Meride, on the Swiss side of UNESCO World Heritage site of Monte San Giorgio (Italy-Switzerland). Specimens belonging to Machilis sp. were collected in Baggero (CO – Italy) in order to isolate the ventral nerve chord and perform the comparison with that of the fossil G. triassicus.
Direct observations and measurements were performed using a stereomicroscope Leica MS5 with an ocular micrometer. The specimens were photographed under two different settings. First, macrophotography was performed under cross-polarized light with a Canon Rebel T3i with a MP-E 65 mm lens and a Canon Macro Twin Flash MT 24EX, taking several image stacks of adjacent areas to achieve an entirely sharp high-resolution image. The stacks were subsequently fused and stitched with Combine ZM/ZP or Image Analyzer and Adobe Photoshop CS3. Additionally, microphotography using autofluorescence was taken out with a Keyence BZ-9000, again recording image stacks processed in the same way. The autofluorescence of the specimens enhances the contrast against the matrix44,45.
To isolate the ventral nerve chord, dissections of Machilis sp were performed under the stereomicroscope Zeiss Axio Zoom V16 and images of ganglia were acquired with the digital camera Zeiss Axiocam 506.
How to cite this article: Montagna, M. et al. Central nervous system and muscular bundles preserved in a 240 million year old giant bristletail (Archaeognatha, Machilidae). Sci. Rep. 7, 46016; doi: 10.1038/srep46016 (2017).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We thank C. Lombardo for the hard work during long years of fieldwork and for her contribution to the knowledge of fossils from the Kalkschieferzone; C. Bandi and D. Fontaneto for their suggestions on the manuscript; Steffen Harzsch for discussing the preserved CNS features. We sincerely thank the anonymous reviewers for their suggestions and comments, in particular those related to the optic lobes interpretation. Holotype MCSN8463 and paratype MCSN8466 will be deposited at Museo Cantonale di Storia Naturale di Lugano (MCSN) – Switzerland. The field work was supported by grants from the Land Department of the Canton Ticino and the Federal Office for Environment, Forests and Landscape in Berna to the Museo Cantonale di Storia Naturale in Lugano. A.T. is partially founded by the Italian Ministry of Education, University and Research MIUR-PRIN 2010-11 (E. Erba). M.M. received the Systematics Research Fund 2016, funded by the Linnean Society of London and the Systematics Association, to study the phosphatized fossil insects of Monte San Giorgio. J.T.H. was kindly funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG Ha 6300/3-1). C.H. was supported with an Equal Opportunities Sponsorship (BGF) of the LMU.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/