The group A Streptococcus (GAS) M1T1 clone emerged in the 1980s as a leading cause of epidemic invasive infections worldwide, including necrotizing fasciitis and toxic shock syndrome1,2,3. Horizontal transfer of mobile genetic elements has played a central role in the evolution of the M1T1 clone4,5, with bacteriophage-encoded determinants DNase Sda16 and superantigen SpeA27 contributing to enhanced virulence and colonization respectively. Outbreaks of scarlet fever in Hong Kong and China in 2011, caused primarily by emm12 GAS8,9,10, led to our investigation of the next most common cause of scarlet fever, emm1 GAS8,9. Genomic analysis of 18 emm1 isolates from Hong Kong and 16 emm1 isolates from mainland China revealed the presence of mobile genetic elements associated with the expansion of emm12 scarlet fever clones10,11 in the M1T1 genomic background. These mobile genetic elements confer expression of superantigens SSA and SpeC, and resistance to tetracycline, erythromycin and clindamycin. Horizontal transfer of mobile DNA conferring multi-drug resistance and expression of a new superantigen repertoire in the M1T1 clone should trigger heightened public health awareness for the global dissemination of these genetic elements.
The bacterial pathogen group A Streptococcus (GAS; Streptococcus pyogenes) causes over 700 million cases of superficial infections such as pharyngitis and impetigo each year. GAS can also cause severe diseases such as invasive infections, toxic shock, rheumatic heart disease and streptococcal glomerulonephritis, resulting in >500,000 deaths per annum3,12. Scarlet fever is thought to occur following pharyngeal infection by GAS strains that secrete superantigens, and symptoms include a finely papular deep red rash, “strawberry tongue”, and exudative pharyngitis13. While a major cause of childhood morbidity and mortality in the 19th and early 20th centuries, scarlet fever has been in decline as a public health threat for over 100 years3,14. Beginning in 2011, outbreaks of scarlet fever occurred in mainland China8 and Hong Kong9,10, which are ongoing (Supplementary Fig. 1). Molecular emm-typing determined the most common cause of scarlet fever as emm12 (serotype M12) GAS8,9,10. Genomic analysis of 144 emm12 isolates revealed the multiclonality of outbreak strains, and the association of these strains with the acquisition of integrative and conjugative elements (ICE) encoding resistance to tetracycline, erythromycin and clindamycin, and bacteriophage encoding superantigens SSA and SpeC11. Molecular type emm1 GAS (serotype M1) was identified as the next most common cause of scarlet fever in mainland China and Hong Kong8,9. Worldwide, the most frequently isolated GAS strain from severe invasive infections is the M1T1 clone15. The M1T1 clone is molecularly typed as emm1 and has horizontally acquired a 36 kb emm12 chromosomal region encoding toxins NAD-glycohydrolase and streptolysin O, and bacteriophage encoding virulence determinants DNase (Sda1/SdaD2) and the SpeA2 superantigen1,2,5,15. The bacteriophage-encoded DNase Sda1 contributes to increased virulence6 and superantigen SpeA has been recently demonstrated to enhance colonization7. The association of emm1 GAS strains with scarlet fever in mainland China and Hong Kong led us to investigate the penetrance of horizontally acquired scarlet fever-associated bacteriophage and ICE elements into the emm1 genomic background.
We sequenced the genomes of 34 available Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 GAS isolates, including 25 confirmed scarlet fever isolates and 9 isolates from other clinical cases (Supplementary Table 1). Next, we performed phylogenetic analyses to investigate clonal relationships between Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 GAS isolates and a comprehensive collection of 3,185 emm1 strains4 representative of the known diversity of the emm1 clone. On the basis of 6,496 nucleotide substitutions identified by reference-free k-mer based approach within the core emm1 genome, all 34 Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 GAS isolates cluster with the M1T1 reference strain MGAS5005 (Fig. 1a). The emm1 strains from Hong Kong are distributed within 4 separate sub-clades while the emm1 strains from mainland China belong to a single clade (Fig. 1b). Temporal regression analysis of the 34 emm1 isolates from Hong Kong and mainland China estimated the origin of these clades during the early 1980s (Supplementary Fig. 2). These observations support previous findings suggesting a global expansion of the M1T1 lineage during the 1980s1,2,3,4. Of 417 mapping-based core substitutions identified in the 34 emm1 strains from Hong Kong and mainland China, there were no substitutions uniquely associated with clinical cases of scarlet fever (Supplementary Table 2).
The M1T1 clone is a leading cause of GAS infections worldwide1,2,3. GAS emm1 is a significant cause of morbidity in Hong Kong, with emm1 GAS replacing emm12 GAS as the dominant clinical strain at a major teaching hospital (Queen Mary Hospital) over the 2011-2014 period (Supplementary Table 3). The acquisition of mobile genetic elements such as bacteriophage and integrative conjugative elements can rapidly alter pathogen epidemiology and evolution, and the role of toxin-harboring prophage in the evolution and emergence of GAS is well recognized16. The M1T1 clone displays stability in prophage content, with the vast majority (2,903 of 3,443 MGAS5005-like isolates) containing an identical profile consisting of three phage encoding SpeA2, Sda1/SdaD2 and DNase Spd3 respectively4. Examination of the prophage content of emm1 GAS revealed that 25 of the 34 Hong Kong and mainland China strains harbored prophage ΦHKU488.vir, including 20 of 25 scarlet fever isolates (Fig. 1c). ΦHKU488.vir is a homolog of ΦHKU.vir, a prophage associated with the emergence of scarlet fever emm12 GAS clones11. Comparison of the sequences of ΦHKU.vir (emm12 reference strain HKU16)10,11 and ΦHKU488.vir (HKU488) revealed that these share 99.9% nucleotide sequence identity, with the key virulence determinant genes ssa, speC and spd1 sharing 100% identity (Fig. 2a). ΦHKU488.vir expresses both the superantigens SSA and SpeC (Fig. 2b). The prophage integration site near the promoter of uvrA is identical in HKU16, HKU488 and the other emm1 GAS encoding ΦHKU488.vir (Supplementary Fig. 3). These findings strongly suggest horizontal transmission of SSA, SpeC and Spd1 encoding phage between emm12 and emm1, or from an independent donor. While directionality cannot be inferred with any accuracy, these findings highlight the promiscuity of GAS bacteriophage16. Other bacteriophage encoding Spd1 and SpeC (Fig. 1c and Supplementary Fig. 4) and DNases Spd3 and Spd4 (Fig. 1c and Supplementary Fig. 5) are also variably distributed. Scarlet fever is a toxin-mediated disease3,13 and superantigens SSA, SpeA and SpeC are over-represented in scarlet fever GAS isolates elsewhere17. It is striking that 20 of 25 Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 scarlet fever isolates contain ΦHKU488.vir integrated into the M1T1 genome, whereas our bioinformatic screening detected ssa in less than 0.5% of MGAS5005-like contemporary GAS emm1 isolates sequenced in a recent study4.
An alarming feature of GAS epidemiology in Hong Kong and mainland China has been the high levels of resistance to macrolides (erythromycin, azithromycin, and clarithromycin), the lincosamide antibiotic clindamycin, and tetracycline10,11,18. This multidrug resistance is mediated by integrative and conjugative elements (ICE) encoding both macrolide (ermB) and tetracycline (tetM) resistance10,11. Less than 0.5% of 3,443 previously examined MGAS5005-like strains encode ermB4. In contrast, 23 of the 34 Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 isolates harbored an ICE element encoding ermB and tetM, herein defined as ICE-HKU488, which shared 99.9% and 99.5% nucleotide sequence identity with the emm12 ICE-HKU397 and ICE-HKU16 respectively (Fig. 3). The ICE integration site is identical in HKU16, HKU397, HKU488 and the other emm1 GAS, and is located at the 3′ end of a tRNA uracil methyltransferase gene (Supplementary Fig. 3). An additional 5 strains from mainland China harbor a 64 Kb ICE-HKU30-like11 element designated ICE-HLJGAS2022. This element also encodes ermB and tetM, and, similar to ICE-HKU30, appears to be located in a distinct genomic location from ICE-HKU488 (Fig. 3 and Supplementary Fig. 3). The acquisition of both ermB and tetM encoding ICE and the ΦHKU488.vir phage occurs in a single emm1 sub-clade and is retained by all strains once acquired (Fig. 1c).
Between 2011 and 2012, >100,000 scarlet fever cases in mainland China were reported by the Chinese Ministry of Health. Since September 2013, Public Health England have reported a scarlet fever outbreak of >15,000 cases. The evolutionary forces driving these outbreaks are currently unknown, but bacterial determinants (strain replacement, virulence gene acquisition), host immune status and environmental factors (such as temperature and rainfall) may all play a significant role19. The results of this current study are deeply concerning for a number of reasons. Firstly, the M1T1 clone emerged in the 1980s and disseminated as a global health threat1,2,3,4,5,15. Acquisition of new superantigens by the M1T1 clone, including the scarlet fever-associated superantigen SSA11,17, has the potential to change the pathogenesis and disease association of these strains, and underlines the fundamentally important role bacteriophage play in GAS evolution16. Only heightened surveillance and epidemiological analyses will determine the full impact these gene acquisitions will have on global GAS disease burden, though it is notable in this study that multiple emm1 scarlet fever isolates encode SSA. Secondly, prescription of macrolides and clindamycin is common in primary health care as a broad spectrum treatment for respiratory tract infections19. Acquisition of macrolide resistance into the M1T1 genomic background will likely present a further challenge at the primary health care level for the treatment of such infections. The use of penicillin in non-allergic patients remains an excellent treatment alternative for GAS infections, as all strains remain penicillin sensitive3.
GAS emm1 strain collection
Clinical GAS isolates were typed as emm1 according to standard procedures described by the Centre for Disease Control and Prevention ( http://www.cdc.gov/streplab/M-ProteinGene-typing.html). A total of 34 emm1 isolates from Hong Kong and mainland China, including 25 from scarlet fever diagnosed patients, were characterized. Antibiotic sensitivity was determined as previously defined10,11. Clinical and molecular characteristics of the isolates are listed in Supplementary Table 1. Genomic DNA was extracted from 37 °C overnight 1.8 ml brain heart infusion broth cultures using the DNeasy Tissue Kit (Qiagen). To place the Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 GAS examined in this study within the global evolutionary context of the emm1 GAS clone, the sequencing data of the most temporally and geographically comprehensive collection of 3,615 emm1 strains previously published4 was retrieved for these analyses.
Genome sequencing and comparative genomics analysis
Paired-end multiplex libraries were created as described previously20 followed by sequencing on the Illumina Hi-seq 2000 platform, with a read length set at 100 bp. Illumina sequence reads for the Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 collections were deposited in the European Nucleotide Archive under the accession codes listed in Supplementary Table 1. Prior to use, quality control (QC) checks were performed to ensure a mean base-pair quality score of Q> = 20 and a read length > = 85 bp, for a post-QC average coverage ranging from 97–140×. HKU488 was selected as a representative strain and subjected to PacBio (Pacific Biosciences) sequencing to confirm the sequence of complex elements such as prophage and ICE identified in emm1 scarlet fever isolates. PacBio sequencing was generated on the Pacific Biosciences RS II platform from a single molecule real-time (SMRT) cell as previously described11. De novo assembly of HKU488 was performed using PacBio’s SMRT Portal (v2.2.0) and the hierarchical genome assembly process HGAP21. The final assembly obtained reached an estimated average coverage of 114×. De novo assembly of Illumina sequencing data for the 34 emm1 strains was performed using Velvet 1.2.0722. All assemblies were then annotated using Prokka 1.1023. Comparative genomic analyses between individual strains were performed using a combination of tools, namely BLASTn, tBLASTx24, Artemis25 and Easyfig26.
De novo draft genome assemblies from a collection of 3,615 emm1 strains4 were generated with SPAdes 3.0.027 using raw reads. Due to the majority of this dataset consisting of 42 bp single-end Illumina reads, a total of 432 assemblies associated with either low sequence coverage <20×, highly fragmented assembly (>1000 contigs) or contaminated samples were discarded from the analysis. A final set of draft genomes comprising 3,185 emm1 strains (including SF370 and MGAS5005) as well as the 34 emm1 Hong Kong and mainland China strains was then used as an input to determine genome-wide core SNPs using the reference-free k-mer based approach implemented in kSNP 2.1.228, resulting in a 6,496 bp core-SNP matrix. To avoid the detrimental impact of sub-optimal assemblies on core SNPs estimation, we performed high-resolution phylogenetic inference using a mapping approach, where reads from each of the 34 Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 strains were mapped against the MGAS5005 reference genome using SHRIMP 2.029. Nesoni 0.108 ( www.vicbioinformatics.com/software.nesoni.shtml) was then used to perform SNP calling (set on default parameters) as well as predict coding-effect SNP annotation. A 417 core SNP matrix was identified by performing n-way pairwise comparison as implemented in Nesoni, and discarding SNPs associated with mobile genetic elements.
For the phylogeny reconstruction analysis, we estimated maximum likelihood trees using RAxML 7.2.830 under the GTR nucleotide substitution model with a gamma correction for ASRV, for both the 3,219 global emm1 strains 6,496 bp core SNP matrix and the 34 emm1 Hong Kong and mainland China only 417 core SNP matrix, assessing node support using 100 and 1000 random bootstrap replicates, respectively. To estimate the underlying temporal signal of the 34 Hong Kong and mainland China emm1 strains and MGAS5005, we used Path-O-Gen v1.4 ( http://www.tree.bio.ed.ac.uk/software/pathogen), which performs a regression analysis between the genetic distance calculated from the root to the tips of the previously estimated 417 SNP-based phylogeny and the year of isolation of each strain.
Bioinformatic screening for ssa
Screening for the presence of ssa was performed using SRST2 using both single-end and paired-end raw reads and default parameters31.
SSA and SpeC western blots
Primary antibodies used were rabbit anti-SpeC (ab16024; Abcam) and affinity-purified rabbit antisera (produced by Mimotopes, Clayton, Australia) raised against the peptide H-CGGSSQPDPTPEQLNKSSQFTG-OH coupled to Keyhole Limpet Hemocyanin (anti-SSA). Overnight cultures of GAS strains were grown in THY broth containing 28 uM of the cysteine proatease inhibitor E64, or modified chemically defined medium (Gibco RPMI 1640, no glucose (Life Technologies) supplemented with 1% D-Glucose, 3.2 mM L-cysteine, and components 2 (amino acids), 3 (vitamins) and 5 (nucleobases) of the GAS chemically defined medium, pH 7.5). GAS supernatants were precipitated with 10% TCA and each protein was detected by western immunoblot, as described previously11.
How to cite this article: Ben Zakour, N. L. et al. Transfer of scarlet fever-associated elements into the group A Streptococcus M1T1 clone. Sci. Rep. 5, 15877; doi: 10.1038/srep15877 (2015).
This work was supported by the Wellcome Trust, National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia, Australian Research Council and the Research Fund for the Control of Infectious Diseases Commissioned Grant of the Hong Kong Government. We acknowledge the assistance of the sequencing and pathogen informatics core teams at the Sanger Institute.