The three-dimensional topological insulator is a quantum state of matter characterized by an insulating bulk state and gapless Dirac cone surface states. Device applications of topological insulators require a highly insulating bulk and tunable Dirac carriers, which has so far been difficult to achieve. Here we demonstrate that Bi2-xSbxTe3-ySey is a system that simultaneously satisfies both of these requirements. For a series of compositions presenting bulk-insulating transport behaviour, angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy reveals that the chemical potential is always located in the bulk band gap, whereas the Dirac cone dispersion changes systematically so that the Dirac point moves up in energy with increasing x, leading to a sign change of the Dirac carriers at x~0.9. Such a tunable Dirac cone opens a promising pathway to the development of novel devices based on topological insulators.
The surface state of a three-dimensional topological insulator (TI) is characterized by a Dirac cone dispersion showing a helical spin structure1,2,3,4, which makes the Dirac fermions immune to backward scattering and robust to non-magnetic impurities and disorder5,6. Experimental realizations of novel topological phenomena expected for such helical Dirac fermions hinge on the dominance of surface transport, but a highly insulating bulk has rarely been achieved in prototypical TIs such as Bi2Se3 and Bi2Te3 because of naturally occurring defects and the resulting carrier doping3,7,8,9,10. Furthermore, applications of TIs to a wide range of devices would require a means to intentionally manipulate the properties of the Dirac carriers (sign, density, velocity and so on.) while keeping the bulk sufficiently insulating. However, such a Dirac cone engineering has been difficult to achieve because of the lack of suitable materials.
Recently, it has been shown that the ternary tetradymite TI material Bi2Te2Se, which forms the ordered Te–Bi–Se–Bi–Te quintuple layers, has a large bulk resistivity11,12 because of its chemical characteristics suitable for reducing defect formations. In this regard, the tetradymite Bi2-xSbxTe3-ySey (BSTS) solid solution, which has the same crystal structure as Bi2Te2Se (Fig. 1a), is of interest because a series of special combinations of x and y have been known to yield a high resistivity13,14,15. Thus, in the insulating compositions reported here ((x, y)=(0, 1), (0.25, 1.1), (0.5, 1.3), (1, 2)), the y value is unique when x is specified (details are described in Methods (in the subsection Transport properties of BSTS)). Such a control of the material properties is an advantage of the solid–solution systems16,17,18 and makes the BSTS system an interesting platform for investigating the Dirac band structure while keeping the insulating nature of the bulk.
Here we report our angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) experiments on BSTS, which elucidated the surface and bulk electronic states in the vicinity of the Fermi level (EF) responsible for the peculiar physical properties. We show that simultaneous tuning of the Sb and Se contents in the BSTS crystal makes it possible to control the energy location of the Dirac cone in the bulk band gap (and the sign of Dirac carriers) while keeping the bulk insulating character. This result demonstrates that what BSTS offers is, at present, the closest to the ultimate goal of the Dirac cone engineering, that is, being able to tune the Dirac band structure to have desired surface carrier properties without having to tune the chemical potential in bulk crystals.
T.A, T.S., S.S., K.K., K.N., M.K. and T.T. performed ARPES measurements. Z.R., K.S. and Y.A. carried out the growth of the single crystals and their characterizations. T.A., T.S., Z. R. and Y.A. conceived the experiments and wrote the manuscript.
Electronic states of Bi2Te2Se
We first demonstrate the ARPES data of an end member Bi2Te2Se (x=0; y=1). The photon-energy dependence of the band structure near EF is displayed in Figure 1b, where one can see several common features such as a prominent electron-like band centred at the point (ky=0) in the binding energy EB range of 0.0–0.3 eV and rather complicated band dispersions at EB>0.3 eV. These features correspond to the surface state (SS) and the bulk valence bands (VB), respectively, judged from the analysis shown in Figure 1c, where the energy position of the SS is stationary with the variation in hν unlike that of the VB. A closer look at Figure 1c also reveals that the SS has an 'x'-shaped dispersion with its Dirac point at ~0.3 eV, indicative of an electron-doped character of the surface. The highest lying VB at ~0.4 eV exhibits an 'm'-shaped dispersion and is located closest to EF at hν=58 eV. We use this photon energy for comparing the electronic states at different compositions of BSTS and also for quantitatively estimating characteristic energies, as will be described later. One can see in Figure 1b that the signature of the bulk conduction band (CB) is completely absent in the ARPES intensity, confirming the insulating nature of the bulk. The two-dimensional contour plots of the ARPES intensity at various EB shown in Figure 1d signify the hexagonal warping of the SS band structure that gradually weakens on approaching the Dirac point, as commonly observed in other TIs4,8,19. Outside the SS, the VB feature is visible as a six-fold petal-like intensity pattern at EB=0.25–0.3 eV.
Evolution of electronic states in Bi2-xSbxTe3-ySey
Figure 2a–c show a comparison of the Fermi surface and the near-EF band structure at different compositions, all of which belong to the bulk insulating phase as confirmed by the resistivity data shown in Figure 2d. Indeed, only the SS is present at EF in all the samples. Interestingly, the SS Fermi surface systematically shrinks on increasing x (Fig. 2a) accompanied by an overall upward shift of the SS (Fig. 2b,c). This demonstrates that increasing x (and the simultaneous increase in y) provides more acceptors, which is likely due to a slight change in the carrier compensation condition, while the bulk remains highly insulating as confirmed by the electrical resistivity data in Figure 2d; in particular, the resistivity for Bi1.5Sb0.5Te1.7Se1.3 (x=0.5; y=1.3) is very high for TIs, reaching 10 Ωcm at low temperatures, and previous magnetotransport studies elucidated the surface mobility to exceed 1,000 cm2 Vs−1 for this composition14. An important indication of our data is a systematic compensation of Dirac carriers that can be seen in Figure 2a–c; this trend can also be confirmed in the momentum distribution curves (MDCs) at EF shown in Figure 2e, where the momentum separation of two peaks in the MDC, corresponding to the 2kF (Fermi vector) value, gradually decreases with increasing x. To quantitatively evaluate the evolution of the SS, we plot in Figure 2f the Dirac band dispersion determined from the peak positions of the energy distribution curves (EDCs) in Figure 2c. One can see that the energy shift of the Dirac band proceeds in a rigid-band manner, the bands for different x values essentially overlap with each other when we plot its energy position with respect to the Dirac-point energy (EDP), despite the total chemical potential (μ) shift of as large as 0.3 eV as seen in Figure 2g. Intriguingly, the SS band dispersion below EF for x=1.0 suggests that the Dirac point is located slightly above EF, which can also be confirmed in the plot of the 2kF values in Figure 2h, pointing to a sign change of Dirac carriers from n- to p-type at some x value between 0.5 and 1.0. Another important indication in Figure 2 is that the bulk VB does not show a rigid-band shift relative to the SS, as inferred from the data in Figure 2b, where the lower hole-like branch of the Dirac cone for x=1.0 is more clearly visible than in x=0.
Band diagram of Bi2-xSbxTe3-ySey
Looking at Figure 2a, one notices that the Dirac point is buried in the bulk VB at x=0, which means that the putative transport properties near the Dirac point would be strongly affected by the bulk-surface interband scattering. In contrast, one can see in Figure 2b that the Dirac point for x=1.0 is well isolated from the bulk, indicating a more ideal situation for applications. To depict a comprehensive picture of the evolution of the energy bands, it is necessary to determine the energy locations of the bulk-band edges. This requires the observation of the CB which becomes possible by ageing the sample surface20,21,22. The details of this ageing experiments are described in Methods (Surface ageing to observe the bulk CB). We have estimated ECB and EVB as well as the Dirac-point energy (EDP) by using the ageing technique for all compositions, and the obtained characteristic energies are shown in Figure 3a. While the magnitude of the band gap is almost independent of x, the Dirac-point energy relative to the VB top, EDP–EVB, is negative at x=0 and turns to positive around the critical x of ~0.25. As illustrated in the schematic band diagram (Fig. 3b), the intrinsic transport properties near the Dirac point can be achieved in samples with x>0.25, and, therefore, this composition range is particularly suited for realizing the topological phenomena to require the tuning of μ to the Dirac point, such as the topological magnetoelectric effect23. Another important aspect is that μ at the native surface of our BSTS samples is located above the Dirac point in 0 ≤ x ≤ 0.5 and below it in x=1.0. This suggests that a sign change in surface Dirac carriers takes place at x~0.9 (estimated from a linear interpolation in Fig. 2h), and, therefore, a p–n junction fabricated by a composition gradient in BSTS may be conceivable. In this regard, the Hall coefficient at low temperature is negative for x=0.0–0.5, whereas it is positive for x=1.0 as described in Methods (in the subsection Transport properties of BSTS), in good agreement with the ARPES data.
The observed isolated nature of the Dirac cone at x=1 as opposed to its buried character at x=0 may be understood in terms of the difference in the Se/Te content: according to the previous ARPES studies, the Dirac point in Bi2Se3 (ref. 3) is well isolated from the bulk bands while that in Bi2Te3 is situated inside the bulk VB8. In BSTS, the Dirac cone is gradually isolated from the bulk band as the Se/Te ratio is increased from 0.5 to 2.0 (on which x changes from 0.0 to 1.0), in accordance with the natural expectation from the difference in the electronic states in Bi2Se3 and Bi2Te3. This suggests the importance of controlling the orbital character of chalcogen-derived bands for the Dirac cone engineering.
The experimental realization of both Dirac holes and electrons in the BSTS system demonstrated here points to the high potential of this material for studying the various topological phenomena requiring the access to the Dirac point. Moreover, it would provide an excellent platform for the development of novel topological devices to utilize a dual-gate configuration for the electric control of spins24 or p—n-junction configurations that are essential for various applications, as in semiconductor technology. Another important feature of this system is that the energy location of the Dirac point in the band gap can be tuned while keeping the bulk-insulating nature and a high surface mobility, allowing one to study the effect of the bulk-surface scattering channel on the surface carriers near the Dirac point. Furthermore, the availability of the Dirac cone engineering in bulk crystals is important for the topological magnetoelectric effect, because it has been proposed that the energy gain in the bulk owing to the axion term can be crucial for realizing such an effect25. The present result provides an important step toward establishing the means to fully control of surface Dirac fermions in TIs to explore a variety of exotic physical properties proposed for this exciting class of materials.
High-quality single crystals of BSTS were grown by sealing stoichiometric amounts of high-purity elements in evacuated quartz tubes and melting them at 850 °C for 48 h with intermittent shaking to ensure a homogeneity of the melt, followed by cooling slowly to 550 °C and annealing at that temperature for 4 days. X-ray diffraction analyses confirmed that all the samples have the same crystal structure (R m) with the desired chalcogen ordering as shown in Figure 1a. Transport properties were measured with Quantum Design PPMS using the standard AC four-probe method.
ARPES measurements were performed with a VG Scienta SES2002 electron analyser with a tunable synchrotron light at the beamline BL28A at Photon Factory (KEK). We used circularly polarized lights of 36–116 eV. The energy and angular resolutions were set at 15–30 meV and 0.2°, respectively. ARPES measurements were also performed with a MBS A1 electron analyzer with a high-flux Xe discharge lamp and a spherical grating monochromator (hν=8.437 eV)26 at Tohoku University. Samples were cleaved in-situ along the (111) crystal plane in an ultrahigh vacuum of 1×10−10 Torr. The Fermi level of the samples was referenced to that of a gold film evaporated onto the sample holder. A shiny mirror-like surface was obtained after cleaving the samples, confirming its high quality.
Transport properties of BSTS
As was reported in ref. 15, the 'intrinsic' compositions in the solid–solution system BSTS were recently elucidated. At such compositions, acceptors and donors maximally compensate each other, and bulk-insulating behaviour is observed. In the present ARPES experiment, we studied four combinations of (x, y) [=(0, 1), (0.25, 1.1), (0.5, 1.3), and (1, 2)] that all belong to such intrinsic compositions. The crystals used in the present work are obtained after careful optimization of the growth conditions for insulating behaviour, as evidenced by the resistivity data (Fig. 2d) that present even higher values for all compositions compared with those reported in ref. 15.
To corroborate our claim that all the compositions studied here possess highly bulk-insulating nature, and to elucidate the sign of the surface charge carriers, the temperature dependences of the Hall coefficient RH for the four compositions were measured (Supplementary Fig. S1). The Hall measurements were done on the same samples as those used for the resistivity measurements. One can see that the absolute values of RH at the lowest temperature are 400 cm3 per °C or larger, which indicates that the present samples are even better insulators than the Bi2Te2Se sample originally reported in ref. 13 (where |RH| at the lowest temperature was 200 cm3 per °C).
Surface ageing to observe the bulk conduction band
To determine the energy location of the bulk CB that is located above EF in our insulating samples, we intentionally aged the sample surface in our vacuum chamber and doped electrons into the SS to enhance the surface band-bending effect, by following the ARPES studies of Bi2Se3 and Bi2Te3 (refs 20, 21, 22) and also a recent transport study of BSTS14. A representative result for x=0 shown in Supplementary Figure S2 demonstrates that the ageing leads to an overall downward shift of the spectral feature and, simultaneously, the appearance of the CB at EF. As shown in the right panel of Supplementary Figure S2, it is thus possible to estimate the actual locations of the bottom of the CB (ECB) and the top of the VB (EVB) by tracing the trailing/leading edges of the EDCs27.
How to cite this article: Arakane, T. et al. Tunable Dirac cone in the topological insulator Bi2-xSbxTe3-ySey. Nat. Commun. 3:636 doi: 10.1038/ncomms1639 (2012).
We thank Y. Tanaka, K. Yoshimatsu, H. Kumigashira and K. Ono for their assistance in ARPES measurements. This work was supported by JSPS (NEXT Program and KAKENHI 23224010), JST-CREST, MEXT of Japan (Innovative Area 'Topological Quantum Phenomena'), AFOSR (AOARD 10-4103), and KEK-PF (Proposal number: 2010G507).
Supplementary Figures S1-S2