Abstract
The aim of this trial was to study the value of adding post-operative radiotherapy to lumpectomy in a subgroup of breast cancer patients with favourable patient-, tumour-, and treatment-related prognostic features. 152 women aged over 40 with unifocal breast cancer seen in preoperative mammography were randomly assigned to lumpectomy alone (no-XRT group) or to lumpectomy followed by radiotherapy to the ipsilateral breast (50 Gy given within 5 weeks, XRT group). All cancers were required to be invasive node-negative, smaller than 2 cm in diameter and well or moderately differentiated, to contain no extensive intraductal component, to be progesterone receptor-positive, DNA diploid, have S-phase fraction ≤7 and be excised with at least 1 cm margin. During a mean follow-up time of 6.7 years, 13 (18.1%) cancers recurred locally in the no-XRT and 6 (7.5%) in the XRT group (P=0.03). There was no difference between the groups in the ultimate breast preservation rate (95.0% vs. 94.4% in XRT and no-XRT, respectively, P=0.88), distant metastasis-free survival (P=0.36), or 5-year cancer-specific survival (97.1% in XRT and 98.6 in no-XRT). Radiation therapy given after lumpectomy reduces the frequency of ipsilateral breast recurrences even in women with small breast cancer with several favourable clinical and biological features. However, the breast preservation rate may not increase due to more frequent use of salvage mastectomies in patients treated with postoperative radiotherapy. © 2001 Cancer Research Campaign http://www.bjcancer.com
Similar content being viewed by others
Article PDF
Change history
16 November 2011
This paper was modified 12 months after initial publication to switch to Creative Commons licence terms, as noted at publication
References
Bloom HJG and Richardson WW (1957) Histological grading and prognosis in breast cancer. Br J Cancer 11: 359–377
Clark RM, McCullogh PB, Levine MN, Lipa M, Wilkinson RH, Mahoney LJ, Basrur VR, Nair BD, McDermot RS, Wong CS and Corbett PJ1 (1992) Randomized clinical trial to assess the effectiveness of breast irriditation following lumpectomy and axillary dissection for node-negative breast cancer. J Natl Cancer Inst 84: 683–689
Clarke DH and Martinez AA (1992) Identification of patients who are at high risk for locoregional breast cancer recurrence after conservative surgery and radiotherapy: A review article for surgeons, pathologists and radiation and medical oncologists. J Clin Oncol 10: 474–483
Dalberg K, Eriksson E, Kanter L, Sandelin K, Liedberg A, Auer G, Thorstensson S, Fredriksson I, Johansson U and Rutqvist LE (1999) Biomarkers for local breast recurrence after breast-conservation – a nested case-control study. Breast Cancer Res and Treat 57: 245–259
de la Rochefordiere A, Abner A, Silver B, Vicini F, Recht A and Harris JR (1992) Are cosmetic results following conservative surgery and radiation therapy for early breast cancer dependent on technique?. Int J radiat Oncol Biol Phys 23: 925–931
de la Rochefordiere A, Asselain B, Campana F, Scholl SM, Fenton J, Vilcoq JR, Durand JC, Pouillart P, Magdalenat H and Fourquet A (1993) Age as a prognostic factor in premenopausal breast carcinoma. Lancet 341: 1039–1043
Early Breast Cancer Trialists Collaborative Group (1995) Effects of radiotherapy and surgery in early breast cancer. N Engl J Med 333: 1444–1455
Fisher B, Anderson S, Fisher ER, Redmond C, Wickerham DL, Wolmark N, Mamounas EP, Deutsch M and Margolese R (1991) The significance of ipsilateral breast tumour recurrence after lumpectomy. Lancet 338: 327–331
Fisher B, Andersson S, Redmond CK, Wolmark N, Wickerham DL and Cronin WM (1995) Reanalysis and results after 12 years of follow-up in a randomized clinical trial comparing total mastectomy with lumpectomy with or without irradiation in the treatment of breast cancer. N Engl J Med 333: 1456–1461
Fisher B, Dignam J, Wolmark N, Mamounas E, Costantino J, Poller W, Fisher ER, Wickerham DL, Deutsch M, Margolese R, Dimitrov N and Kavanah M (1998) Lumpectomy and radiation therapy for the treatment of intraductal breast cancer: findings from National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project B-17. J Clin Oncol 16: 441–452
Forrest AP, Stewart HJ, Everington D, Prescott RJ, McArdle CS, Harnett AN, Smith DC and George WD (1996) Randomized controlled trial of conservation therapy for breast cancer: 6-year analysis of the Scottish trial. Lancet 348: 708–713
Fourquet A, Campana F, Zafrani B, Mosseri V, Vielh P, Durand JC and Vilcoq JR (1989) Prognostic factors of breast recurrence in conservative management of early breast cancer: A 25-year follow-up. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 17: 719–725
Fowble BL, Schultz DJ, Overmoyer B, Solin LJ, Fox K, Jardines L, Orel S and Glick JH (1994) The influence of young age on outcome in early stage breast cancer. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 30: 23–33
Gage I, Schnitt SJ, Nixon AJ, Silver B, Recht A, Troyan SL, Eberlein T, Love SM, Gelman R, Harris JR and Connolly JL (1996) Pathological margin involvement and the risk of recurrence in patients treated with breast conserving therapy. Cancer 78: 1921–1928
Holland R, Connolly J, Gelman R, Mravunac M, Hendriks JH, Verbeek AL, Schnitt SJ, Silver B, Boyages J and Harris JR (1990) The presence of an extensive intraductal component (EIC) following a limited excision correlates with prominent residual disease in the remainder of the breast. J Clin Oncol 8: 113–118
Julien J-P, Bijker N, Fentiman I, Peterse JL, Delledonne V, Rouanet P, Avril A, Sylvester R, Mignolet F, Bartelink H and Van Dongen JA (2000) Radiotherapy in breast-conserving treatment for ductal carcinoma in situ: first results of the EORTC randomised phase III trial 10853. Lancet 355: 528–533
Kearney TJ and Morrow M (1995) Effect of re-excision on the success of breast-conserving surgery. Ann Surg Oncol 2: 303–307
Kurtz J (1992) Factors influencing the risks of local recurrence in the breast. Eur J Cancer 28: 660–666
Kurtz JM, Almaric R, Brandone H, Ayme Y, Jacquemier J, Pietra JC, Hans D, Pollet JF, Bressac C and Spitalier JM (1989) Local recurrence after breast-conserving surgery and radiotherapy. Cancer 63: 1912–1917
Kurtz JM, Amalric R and Brandone H (1990) Risk factors for breast recurrence in premenopausal and postmenopausal patients with ductal cancers treated by conservation therapy. Cancer 65: 1867–1878
Liljegren G, Holmberg L and Adami HO (1994) Sector resection with or without postoperative radiotherapy for stage I breast cancer: five-year results of a randomized trial. J Natl Cancer Inst 86: 717–722
Liljegren G, Holmberg L, Bergh J, Lindgren A, Tabar L, Nordgren H and Adami HO (1999) 10-year results after sector resection with or without postoperative radiotherapy for stage I breast cancer: A randomized trial. J Clin Oncol 17: 2326–2333
Locker AP, Ellis IO and Morgan DAL (1989) Factors influencing local recurrence after excision and radiotherapy for primary breast cancer. Br J Surg 76: 890–894
Renton SC, Gazet JC, Ford HT, Corbishley C and Sutcliffe R (1996) The importance of resection margin in conservative surgery for breast cancer. Eur J Surg Oncol 22: 17–22
Sinn HP, Anton HW, Magener A, von Fournier D, Bastert G and Otto HF (1998) Extensive and predominant in situ components in breast carcinoma: their influence on treatment results after breast-conserving therapy. Eur J Cancer 34: 646–653
van Dongen JA, Bartelink H, Fentiman IS, Lerut T, Mignolet F, Olthuis G, van der Schueren E, Sylvester R, Tong D, Winter J and van Zijl K (1992) Factors influencing local relapse and survival and results of salvage treatment after breast-conserving therapy in operable breast cancer: EORTC trial 10801, breast conservation compared with mastectomy in TNM stage I and II breast cancer. Eur J Cancer 28A ( 4/5): 801–805
Veronesi U, Zucali R and Del Vecchio M (1985) Conservative treatment of breast cancer with the QU.A.RT. technique. World J Surg 9: 676–681
Veronesi U, Luini A, Del Vecchio M, Greco M, Galimberti V, Merson M, Rilke F, Sacchini V, Saccozzi R, Savio T, Zucali R, Zurrida S and Sarvadori B (1993) Radiotherapy after breast-preserving surgery in women with localised cancer of the breast. New Engl J Med 328 (22): 1587–1591
Veronesi U, Salvadori B, Luini A, Greco M, Saccozzi R, del Vecchio M, Mariani L, Zurrida S and Rilke F (1995) Breast conservation is a safe method in patients with small cancer of the breast: Long-term results of three randomized trials on 1,973 patients. Eur J Cancer 31A: 1574–1579
Voogd AC, Peterse JL, Crommelin MA, Rutgers EJ, Botke G, Elkhuizen PH, van Geel AN, Hoekstra CJ, van Pel R, van de Vijver MJ and Coebergh JW (1999) Histological determinants for different types of local recurrence after breast-conserving therapy in invasive breast cancer. Eur J Cancer 35: 1828–1837
Whelan T, Clark R, Roberts R, Levine M and Foster G (1994) Ipsilateral breast tumor recurrence post-lumpectomy is predictive of subsequent mortality: results from a randomized trial. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 30: 11–16
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
From twelve months after its original publication, this work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Holli, K., Saaristo, R., Isola, J. et al. Lumpectomy with or without postoperative radiotherapy for breast cancer with favourable prognostic features: results of a randomized study. Br J Cancer 84, 164–169 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1054/bjoc.2000.1571
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1054/bjoc.2000.1571
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Study on the dose modification factor of strut adjusted volume implant (SAVI) with a 169Yb source using MCNP4C
Australasian Physical & Engineering Sciences in Medicine (2018)
-
Revisiting the impact of age and molecular subtype on overall survival after radiotherapy in breast cancer patients
Scientific Reports (2017)
-
Patients with bilateral breast ductal carcinoma in situ treated with accelerated partial breast irradiation—initial experience
Journal of Radiation Oncology (2014)
-
Cost effectiveness of new breast cancer radiotherapy technologies in diverse populations
Breast Cancer Research and Treatment (2012)
-
Radiation Therapy in Early-Stage Invasive Breast Cancer
Indian Journal of Surgical Oncology (2011)