Predictive value of patient history and correlation of nocturnal penile tumescence, colour duplex Doppler ultrasonography and dynamic cavernosometry and cavernosography in the evaluation of erectile dysfunction

Abstract

Aims: The results of history and physical examination, nocturnal penile tumescence testing (NPT), colour flow duplex Doppler ultrasonography and dynamic infusion cavernosometry and cavernosography (DICC) were retrospectively correlated in 207 patients with erectile dysfunction.

Methods and materials: The predictive value of the patient’s own subjective assessment of early morning and nocturnal erections, history of cigarette smoking, the presence of vascular risk factors was correlated to the outcome of investigations. The result of Rigiscan NPT was correlated to the peak systolic velocity (PSV) and the resistance index (RI) determined at colour flow duplex Doppler ultrasonography, and the maintenance flow rate (Q^m) determined at DICC.

Results: Eighty-five out of two hundred and seven patients (41%) had normal NPT comprising 48 out of 85 patients (56%) who described rigid early morning and nocturnal erections, 15 out of 85 patients (18%) who smoked cigarettes and 9 out of 85 patients (11%) with other positive vascular risk factors. 72 out of 85 patients (85%) had a normal PSV (>30 cm/s), 80 out of 85 patients (94%) had a normal RI (>0.85) and 82 out of 85 patients (96%) had a normal Q^m), (<10 ml/min). Vascular investigations in this group identified 71 out of 85 patients (84%) with no penile vascular disease, 11 out of 85 patients (13%) with arteriogenic impotence, 2 out of 85 patients (2%) with mixed vasculogenic impotence and 1 out of 85 patients (1%) with cavernosal venous leakage (CVL).

One hundred and twenty-two out of two hundred and seven patients (59%) had an abnormal NPT comprising 18 out of 122 patients (15%) who continued to experience rigid early morning erections, 65 out of 122 patients (53%) who smoked cigarettes, 59 out of 112 patients (48%) with other positive vascular risk factors, 36 out of 112 patients (29%) had an abnormal PSV (<30 cm/s), 49 out of 122 patients (40%) had an abnormal RI (<0.85) and 55 out of 122 patients (45%) had an abnormal Q^m (>10 ml/min). Vascular investigations in this group identified five patients with no penile vascular disease, 51 out of 122 patients (41%) with arteriogenic impotence, 31 out of 122 patients (25%) with cavernosal venous leakage (CVL) and 35 out of 122 patients (29%) with mixed vasculogenic impotence.

Conclusions: (1) a history of cigarette smoking and positive vascular risk factors are good predictors of organic impotence whereas the patient’s subjective assessment of his own early morning erections is unreliable; (2) normal NPT correlates well with normal PSV, RI and Q^m but does not exclude organic impotence; (3) abnormal NPT correlates well with abnormal PSV, RI and Q^m.