Collection 

The future of research assessment

Submission status
Closed
Submission deadline

It is now thirty years since the UK’s first research assessment exercise took place in 1986. To mark this anniversary, Humanities & Social Sciences Communications will publish a thematic Collection on the future of research assessment. A strong cast of contributors, drawn from academia, management, policy and practice, will explore recent developments and debates in the UK and internationally.

Across research systems worldwide, policymakers, universities, funders and publishers are grappling with how to measure and assess the qualities and impacts of research. Since the mid-1980s, there has been a steady escalation in the quantity, reach and sophistication of research assessment. 

Several triggers lie behind this: pressure from governments for tighter audit and evaluation of public investment in research; demand by policymakers for more strategic intelligence on impacts and future priorities; the need for universities and other institutions to mange and develop their research portfolios; competition within and between institutions for prestige, students, staff and resources; increases in the availability of real-time ‘big data’ on research uptake; and the capacity of indicators, metrics and other tools for data analysis. 

Architects and advocates of assessment point to accompanying increases in research productivity and quality. But the relationship to outcomes is intensely debated, and critics argue that the burdens of audit and assessment systems, and the pressures and incentives they create, are having corrosive effects on research cultures, qualities and values.

We invite contributions from academics, policymakers and practitioners on the following themes:

  • The development, use and effectiveness of different policies, frameworks and tools for research assessment; 
  • The relationship between research assessment and outcomes, qualities and impacts;
  • Uses, merits and limitations of quantitative indicators and peer review in research assessment;
  • The politics and ethics of research assessment;
  • The effects of assessment on research cultures, careers, equality and diversity;
  • Responses to the growing influence of university rankings and league tables;
  • Altmetrics and indicators for assessing research qualities and/or wider impacts;
  • Gaming, unintended consequences and strategic responses to assessment;
  • The history, development and comparative analysis of national assessment systems;
  • Strategies for evaluating inter, multi and transdisciplinary research.

This is an open Collection and as such submissions/proposals will be welcomed at any point up until December 2022.

Close-up of a stack of paper files

Editors

The road to REF 2021: is the UK leading or lagging in its approach to research assessment?

Wednesday 7 December, 2016

In the UK, a national research assessment exercise has taken place every few years since 1986, and is the basis on which nearly £2 billion of annual funding is parcelled out. As a result, it has huge reach across the university system. In July 2016, Lord Stern published his review of the Research Excellence Framework. To reduce the burden of the assessment process, this review recommends the inclusion of all research active staff, and an end to the portability of research outputs between institutions. He also proposes to broaden the way research impacts are defined.

What will these proposals mean for the design and operation of the next REF? Will the aspiration to reduce burden be realised? How will the prospects of early career researchers be affected? And what ambiguities still need to be resolved? This panel brings together leading thinkers and practitioners to debate the direction of the REF, discuss the key questions in HEFCE’s post-Stern technical consultation, and consider lessons from other assessment systems.

Chair: James Wilsdon (Professor of Research Policy at the University of Sheffield, UK)

Panellists:

 

 

 

 

Videos:

Watch all the presentations from the event by clicking on the links below.

The event can be viewed in full below or via this link.