Neutron energy is directly correlated with the energy of the incident ions in experiments involving laser-driven nuclear reactions. Using high-energy incident ions reduces the energy concentration of the generated neutrons. A novel “laser-collider” method was used at the Shenguang II laser facility to produce monoenergetic neutrons via 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions. The specially designed K-shaped target significantly increased the numbers of incident d and Li ions at the keV level. Ultimately, 13.3 MeV neutrons were obtained. Considering the time resolution of the neutron detector, we demonstrated that the produced neutrons were monoenergetic. Interferometry and a Multi hydro-dynamics simulation confirmed the monoenergetic nature of these neutrons.
Fast neutrons, because of their unique characteristics of electrical neutrality and strong penetration capability in high-Z materials compared with charged particles and X-rays, possess tremendous appliciation value in the fields of materials testing for fusion power plant1, neutron radiography2, neutron therapy3, and others4,5. Intense neutron pulses can be obtained from spallation sources, nuclear reactors, and high-energy particle accelerators. Unfortunately, the enormous size and cost of these devices are preventing their widespread use. The rapid development of high-intensity laser technology offers an alternative approach at relatively low cost, and the ultra-fast nature of laser-driven neutron sources could allow this technology to find further applications in the ultrafast sciences. Because of their cross-sections and Q-values, three nuclear reactions are primarily used for neutron production:
Because tritium is radioactive and not readily available, the (d, t) reaction, which is typically applied in inertial confinement fusion experiments, was excluded in the current study. Based on the remaining reactions, there are two main paths for ultra-fast laser-driven-neutron production. One possibility is to use the Coulomb explosion mechanism with a deuterium cluster target6,7. In this regime, the atoms of the clusters are entirely ionized by the laser-cluster interaction, which results in prompt explosion due to Coulomb repulsion and the production of the multi-keV ions required to initiate the fusion reactions. Extensive studies have indicated that 2.45 MeV quasi-monoenergetic neutrons can be produced using deuterium cluster targets through reaction (1)8,9,10,11,12. The measured energy spread, determined primarily based on the thermal velocity of the colliding ions, may be 10% or less13. However, when a cluster medium is used, the kinds of nuclear reactions available are restricted because it is impossible to transform all of the reaction materials (such as lithium or beryllium) into the cluster phase. Therefore, an alternative known as the “pitcher-catcher” approach has emerged14,15. In this method, the laser drives an ion beam (typically of deuterium ions) from a primary pitcher target, usually through target normal sheath acceleration (TNSA)16,17. Then, the ions collide with a secondary catcher target, where the nuclear reactions occur. In this way, high-energy neutrons can be obtained through the 7Li (d, n) and 9Be (d, n) nuclear reactions, as in (2)18,19. The laboratory energy E3 of a neutron produced in this way can be expressed as a function of the incident ion energy E1 and the angle θ of the emitted neutron relative to the incident ion,
where m1, m2, m3, and m4 are the masses of the incident ion, the target particle, the neutron, and any other associated particles, respectively20,21. Equation (4) indicates that the energy E3 of neutrons produced in the pitcher-catcher regime strongly depends on the incident ion energy E1 and the Q-value of the nuclear reaction. Because the E1 values that can be achieved through the TNSA mechanism (usually tens of MeV) are on the same order as the Q-value, the neutron beams thus produced are not monoenergetic and therefore are not suitable for detector calibration, neutron-induced cross-section studies, or various other specialized applications22,23,24.
A novel method termed the “plasma-collider” technique was first applied by our group to enhance the neutron yields via the collision of high density deuterated plasma generated directly from the laser-plasma interaction25,26. This method has ability to produce numerous multi-keV ions participating in the nuclear reactions, although at a very low cross-section. Therefore, this method has enormous potential to be used to precisely calculate the cross-sections of 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions because the incident ions are at the multi-keV level. It also has great potential to increase the probabilities of nuclear reactions induced in head-to-head collisions of plasma streams. In addition to these advantages, because E1 is several keV and this is negligible compared with the Q-value (on the order of MeV), equation (4) can be simplied as follows:
In this regime, the energy of the neutrons is determined simply by the Q-value of the nuclear reaction, and 13.3 MeV monoenergetic neutrons can be generated via 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions. These 13.3 MeV neutrons can serve as a new type of laser-driven monoenergetic neutron source, in addition to 2.45 MeV and 14.1 MeV neutrons that can be produced through d (d, n) and d (t, n) nuclear reactions, respectively.
In this letter, we present new studies of the production of monoenergetic neutrons from laser-driven K-shaped D-Li target. The “plasma-collider” method was used to significantly increase the numbers of incident d and Li ions at the keV level. Experimental and theoretical methods were used to verify the production of 13.3 MeV monoenergetic neutrons via 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions.
The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1. Eight arms of main laser pulses delivered a total energy of nearly 2 kJ to the K-shaped D-Li or D-D target. The laser beams were divided into two groups of four laser beams each, which were simultaneously focused onto the facing surfaces of the target with a focal spot diameter of 150 μm. Another laser pulse with a wavelength of 526 nm and a 70 ps duration was used as a probe beam. By changing the delay time between the main laser pulses and the probe beam, the process of plasma expansion and interaction was recorded at different delay times using a Nomarski interferometer and shadowgraph instruments. Four neutron detectors were employed to measure the neutron spectrum via the time-of-flight (TOF) method. The detectors were numbered from 1 to 4 and located at 5.1 m, 4.4 m, 5.5 m, 5.8 m, respectively, from the fusion plasma. All of the TOF signals were recorded by oscilloscopes with a bandwidth of 1 GHz.
A high density plasma with numerous energetic deuterium ions and lithium ions was generated by the laser beams focused on the two-sided target. The plasma streams from both sides expanded toward the opposite target face and collided with each other. During this process, the deuterium ions completely blended together with the lithium ions and collision events occurred, resulting in great potential for the occurrence of 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions. Figure 2 shows sample TOF signals obtained from detector No. 4. The neutron detection threshold was calculated to be 3 × 104 by considering the detection length, active detection area, and detection efficiency of the detector. Figure 2(a) shows the typical neutron results from the D-Li target. The initial X-ray peak shows a falling edge at 98.8 ns. Considering the distance between detector No. 4 and the fusion plasma as well as the speed of X-rays in the atmosphere, the initial instant of laser-plasma interaction was accurately calculated to be 79.7 ns. The narrow neutron peak not far behind the large X-ray peak has a falling edge at 194.4 ns which corresponds to the energy of 13.32 MeV. There is a tiny deviation between the measured energy and the intrinsic energy (13.36 MeV), which may originate from the measurement error in the neutron flight distance. When the resulting 8Be nuclei were in their first or second excited states, a small amount of 10.7 MeV or 3.27 MeV neutrons could have been generated in the experiment. However, no such neutrons were detected in this shot because of the low yield. The pulse duration of the neutron peak in Fig.2(a) is 9.6 ns (full width half maximum, or FWHM). Figure 2(b) presents the TOF signal from D-D target as a reference. The falling edge that neutron peak starts at a time point which is corrosponding to the energy of 2.44 MeV. This is a direct proof that d (d, n) nuclear reactions happened. There is also a tiny energy deviation read from the intrinsic energy (2.45 MeV) which is coming from the measurement error as mentioned above. By calculating the area of the neutron signals and considering the same detector parameters used in ref. 25, we estimated the neutron yields from the d (d, n) nuclear reactions to be ~106. Again considering the neutron signal from the 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions, the calculated area of the D-Li neutron signal is nearly 6 times lower than in the D-D case. Thus, the neutron yields from the 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions were greater than 105. Figure 2(c) shows a typical cosmic ray signal recorded by liquid scintillator detector No. 4 under natural conditions. An individual cosmic ray particle was collected and left a sharp peak on the oscilloscope. The acquired pulse duration of the cosmic ray particle was 9.4 ns (FWHM), which indicates the inherent time resolution of the detector. In other words, the neutrons produced in the 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions and the cosmic ray particle elicited detector responses of nearly the same time duration. This is strong evidence that the neutrons we obtained were quasi-monoenergetic.
To further illustrate the neutron energy acquired in the experiments, the neutron signals from several laser shots and different detectors were analyzed. The black curve in Fig. 3 gives a plot of calculated flight time versus flight distance in relation to the 13.36 MeV monoenergetic neutrons corresponding to Fig. 2(a). Similarly, the red curve shows the case of 2.45 MeV neutrons. From the absolute zero time, the 13.36 MeV neutrons started from the plasma interaction region with speed of 5.06 cm/ns (2.17 cm/ns for 2.45 MeV neutrons). At a special time, the neutrons arrived at the detector positions. The circles in Fig. 3 represent the mean value of flight time acquired from the detectors in several laser shots, and the error bar gives the variation range of these TOF data. The results implied that the experimental flight time points were highly matched with the calculated flight time curves and the measured neutron energy was confirmed by the nearly consistent flight times of different neutron detectors. The No. 1 and No. 2 detectors were not available during the D-Li experiments.
The Nomarski interferometer and shadowgraph instruments were used to obtain a visual representation of the plasma expansion and interaction at a specific point in time after the laser-plasma interaction. Figure 4(a) shows the interferogram for the original D-Li target, which provides a reference for density analysis. The black area without fringes corresponds to the target body. The deuterium target is on the left side, and the LiF target is on the right side. Figure 4(b) shows a shadowgraph of the D-Li target at 3 ns after irradiation. The extension of the black area is caused by the expansion of the high-density target plasma. When the plasma density is higher than a critical density of ~4 × 1021 cm−3, the probe beam cannot penetrate the plasma. Therefore, the color depth represents the plasma density. There is a distinct opaque area at the center of Fig. 4(b), where the plasma density is higher than the density of the surrounding area. In this region, the plasmas were strongly fused and 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions occurred. Figure 4(c) shows an interferogram of the D-Li target at 3 ns. The displacement of the interferometric fringes in Fig. 4(c) indicates density fluctuations in that area. The intense displacement of the fringes was analyzed via Abel inversion to determine the plasma density. Figure 4(d) shows the spatial distribution of the plasma density at 3 ns, corresponding to Fig. 4(c). The crimson area corresponds to the no-fringe area in Fig. 4(c), where the plasma density is higher than the critical density. This area was manually cropped, and was not considered in the Abel inversion. The figure shows two plasma streams with a plasma density higher than 1020 meeting at the center. In this region, the deuterium ions completely blended together with the lithium ions and collision events occurred, resulting in a great potential for the occurrence of 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions.
The velocity and density results calculated from a simulation were used to verify the production of monoenergetic neutrons using the laser-collider method. Figure 5 shows the results of a MULTI 2D hydro-dynamics simulation of the K-shaped LiF target. The two-dimensional process of plasma expansion after laser irradiation was simulated. The K-shaped target appears on the right-hand side of the plots, as marked by a black dashed line. Two laser beams were focused on the K-shaped target, one on the upper part and one on the lower part. The plasma streams thus were produced and moved in the negative direction on the X axis. In Fig. 5, the X and Y axes represent the two spatial dimensions. The coordinates (X,Y) represent the position of the plasma. Figure 5(a) shows the spatial distribution of the plasma velocity at 3 ns. The color scale represents the velocity of the plasma stream. The highest velocity is 6 × 107 cm/s, which corresponds to the lithium ion kinetic energy of 13 keV. According equation (5), the calculated energy spread is less than 0.1%. The head-to-head collision significantly enhanced the cross section for 7Li (d, n) nuclear reactions. This provided sufficient conditions for monoenergetic neutron production. Figure 5(b) shows the spatial distribution of the plasma mass density at 3 ns. The color scale in this figure represents the plasma density. High-density plasmas containing energetic lithium ions were produced in the simulation. The two figures together show that the K-shaped target generated an overdense region along the X axis in the middle of the figure because of the overlap of the two plasma streams from the upper and lower parts of the K-shaped target, which had an opening angle of 120°. With this mechanism, a K-shaped target is distinctly advantageous for promoting a high plasma density compared with other alternatives25. This enhancement of the plasma density significantly increases the collision strength of the plasma streams, thereby also providing increased opportunities for the collision of deuterium and lithium ions and giving rise to essential conditions for monoenergetic neutron production.
In conclusion, we have presented experimental results of the irradiation of a K-shaped D-Li target with 2 kJ laser pulses. Laser-driven 13.3 MeV monoenergetic neutrons were produced for the first time. The interferogram shows plasma expansion and a head-to-head collision state after laser irradiation, with a plasma density of up to 1020 cm−3 in the fusion region, guaranteeing a significant increase in the neutron yield. Theoretical simulation results strongly support the abundant production of monoenergetic neutrons. This study has demonstrated that the “laser-collider” method can be widely applied for monoenergetic neutron production. In the near future, this novel method will also be used to fill the gap of a 7Li (d, n) nuclear reaction cross section at the keV level, which is of great interest in the field of nuclear physics.
The experiments were conducted at the Shenguang II laser facility in the National Laboratory on High Power Lasers and Physics. Eight arms of main laser pulses with energies ranging from 200 to 260 J and a 1 ns pulse duration delivered a total energy of nearly 2 kJ to the target27. The laser beams, with a wavelength of 351 nm (3ω), passed through the focusing lens on the chamber wall to form a focal spot of 150 μm in diameter (FWHM) at the target point, resulting in an average laser intensity of 1015 W/cm2. Another laser pulse with a wavelength of 526 nm and a 70 ps duration was used as a probe beam. Vacuum was established inside the experimental chamber was at ~10−4 Torr. The main laser pulses were separated into two groups, each composed of four laser beams; the two groups were focused to the surfaces on opposite sides of the target, as shown in the inset. This shooting pattern is depicted with only two laser beams on each side in Fig. 1 (Interaction region-2D), because the other two laser beams are concealed from the perspective of the image. The insert labeled “Interaction region-3D” in Fig. 1 provides clearer visual display. The probe beam was split into probe 1 and probe 2 while passing through the beam splitter prism, and probe 2 had a greater optical path difference than probe 1 by 2 ns. By changing the delay time between the main laser pulses and the probe beams, the process of plasma expansion and interaction was recorded at different delay times using the Nomarski interferometer and shadowgraph instruments.
Two types of 2-sided K-shaped targets with an opening angle of 120° and a separation distance of 2.5 mm were employed. One consisted of a 20 μm thick layer of deuterated hydrocarbon (CDn, the ratio of carbon to deuterium in the CDn molecules was 1:1.3) and a 100 μm thick layer of lithium fluoride (LiF), and coated onto each facing surface of the K-shaped copper base (D-Li). The other was a 20 μm thick D-D target, which was used as a reference to gauge the TOF spectrum of the neutrons.
Neutron radiation diagnostics
Four neutron detectors including two plastic and two EJ-301 liquid scintillator detectors were employed to measure the neutron spectrum using the time-of-flight (TOF) method. The operational parameters of these detectors were similar to those used in ref. 25. The two plastic scintillators were designed to have a larger neutron receiving area (π × 16 × 16 cm2) than the two liquid scintillators. The plastic detectors, No. 1 and No. 2, were located at 5.1 m and 4.4 m, respectively, from the fusion plasma. The two liquid scintillator detectors, with dimensions of π × 6.3 × 6.3 cm2, were more sensitive to neutrons because of the application of a high-voltage of up to 2 kV to the photomultiplier tubes (PMTs). The liquid detectors, No. 3 and No. 4, were located at 5.5 m and 5.8 m, respectively, from the fusion plasma. A Faraday cup was placed 44 cm away from the fusion region inside the chamber to collect energetic deuterium and lithium ions. All of the TOF signals were recorded by oscilloscopes with a bandwidth of 1 GHz.
A two-dimensional hydrodynamics simulation was performed using the MULTI code28,29. The equation of states (EOS) data for the target materials (Li and Cu) were generated using MPQeos (a sub-program contained in the MULTI 2D code, developed by the Max Planck Institute for Quantum Optics) and the opacity data were obtained using the Steady-state Non-local thermal equilibrium OPacities (SNOP) code that is part of the MULTI code. The simulation geometry was a cone instead of the actual “>” shape because cylindrical symmetry is assumed in the 2D MULTI code. The simulation was performed only for the upper half of the cone and the remaining lower part was constructed through symmetry.
The beam profile was flat in time and Gaussian in space centered at 200 μm away the center of the K-shape. The simulation target was a concave copper cone coated with a Li layer of 100 um in thickness. The cone angle was 120° in total.
The horizontal resolution of the Li layer in the simulation was 5.8 μm (100 μm/20 cells/sin(π/3)), and the vertical resolution was 3.3 μm (400 μm/120 cells), whereas the resolution of the substrate Cu layer was 80 cells in the horizontal direction.
How to cite this article: Zhao, J. R. et al. A novel laser-collider used to produce monoenergetic 13.3 MeV 7Li (d, n) neutrons. Sci. Rep. 6, 27363; doi: 10.1038/srep27363 (2016).
Perkins, L. J. et al. The investigation of high intensity laser driven micro neutron sources for fusion materials research at high fluence. Nucl. Fusion 40 (1), 301 (2000).
Loveman, R., Bendahan, J., Gozani, T. & Stevenson, J. Time of flight fast neutron radiography. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 99, 765–768 (1995).
Gray, L. H. & Read, J. Treatment of cancer by fast neutrons. Nature (London) 3845, 53–54 (1943).
Buffler, A. Contraband detection with fast neutrons. Radiat. Phys. Chem. 71, 853–861 (2004).
Lancaster, K. L. et al. Characterization of 7Li(p,n)7Be neutron yields from laser produced ion beams for fast neutron radiography. Phys. Plasmas 11, 3404–3408 (2004).
Ditmire, T. et al. High-energy ions produced in explosions of superheated atomic clusters. Nature (London) 386, 54–56 (1997).
Hohenberger, M. et al. Dynamic acceleration effects in explosions of laser-irradiated heteronuclear clusters. Phys. Rew. Lett. 95, 195003 (2005).
Zweiback, J. et al. Nuclear fusion driven by Coulomb explosions of large deuterium clusters. Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 2634–2637 (2000).
Madison, K. W. et al. Fusion neutron and ion emission from deuterium and deuterated methane cluster plasmas. Phys. Plasmas 11, 270–277 (2004).
Ditmire, T. et al. Nuclear fusion from explosions of femtosecond laser-heated deuterium clusters. Nature (London) 398, 489–492 (1999).
Bang, W. et al. Temperature measurements of fusion plasmas produced by petawatt-laser-irradiated D2-3He or CD4-3He clustering gases. Phys. Rev. lett. 111, 055002 (2013).
Bang, W. et al. Optimization of the neutron yield in fusion plasmas produced by Coulomb explosions of deuterium clusters irradiated by a petawatt laser. Phys. Rev. E 87, 023106 (2013).
Ledingham, K. W. D., McKenna, P. & Singha, R. P. Applications for nuclear phenomena generated by ultra-intense lasers. Science 300, 1107–1111 (2003).
Fritzler, S. et al. Ion heating and thermonuclear neutron production from high-intensity subpicosecond laser pulses interacting with underdense plasmas. Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 165004 (2002).
Krygier, A. G. et al. Selective deuterium ion acceleration using the Vulcan petawatt laser. Phys. Plasmas 22, 053102 (2015).
Willingale, L. et al. Comparison of bulk and pitcher-catcher targets for laser-driven neutron production. Phys. Plasmas 18, 083106 (2011).
Li, Y. T. et al. Demonstration of bulk acceleration of ions in ultraintense laser interactions with low-density foams. Phys. Rev. E 72, 066404 (2005).
Higginson, D. P. et al. Production of neutrons up to 18 MeV in high-intensity, short-pulse laser matter interactions. Phys. Plasmas 18, 100703 (2011).
Roth, M. et al. Bright laser-driven neutron source based on the relativistic transparency of solids. Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 044802 (2013).
Izumi, N. et al. Observation of neutron spectrum produced by fast deuterons via ultraintense laser plasma interactions. Phys. Rev. E 65, 036413 (2002).
Petrov, G. M. et al. Generation of high-energy (>15 MeV) neutrons using short pulse high intensity lasers. Phys. Plasmas 19, 093106 (2012).
Harano, H. & Nolte, R. Quasi-monoenergetic high-energy neutron standards above 20 MeV. Metrologia 48, 292–303 (2011).
Shikaze, Y., Tanimura, Y., Saegusa, J. & Tsutsumi, M. Development of highly efficient proton recoil counter telescope for absolute measurement of neutron fluences in quasi-monoenergetic neutron calibration fields of high energy. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 615, 211–219 (2010).
Pioch, C. et al. Calibration of a Bonner sphere spectrometer in quasi-monoenergetic neutron fields of 244 and 387MeV. J. Instrum. 6, P10015 (2011).
Zhao, J. R. et al. Neutron yield enhancement in laser-induced deuterium-deuterium fusion using a novel shaped target. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 86, 063505 (2015).
Fu, C. B. et al. Laser-driven plasma collider for nuclear studies. Sci. bull. 60(13), 1211–1213 (2015).
Liu, X. et al. Collisionless shockwaves formed by counter-streaming laser-produced plasmas. New J. Phys. 13, 093001 (2011).
Ramis, R., Schmalz, R. & Meyer-ter-Vehn, J. MULTI-A computer code for one dimensional multigroup radiation hydrodynamics. Computer Physics Comm. 49, 475–505 (1988).
Ramis, R., Ramirez, J. & Schurtz, G. Implosion symmetry of laser-irradiated cylindrical targets. Laser Part. Beams 26, 113–126 (2008).
We gratefully acknowledge the staff of the SG-II laser facility. This work was supported by the National Basic Research Program of China (2013CBA01500), the National Key Scientific Instrument and Equipment Development Project (2012YQ120047), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (11135012, 11334013, 11421064, 11374210, 11503041, 11305185, and NSAF U1530150), and the CAS key program (KGZD-EW-T05). This project was also funded by the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2015M571124).
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Zhao, J., Zhang, X., Yuan, D. et al. A novel laser-collider used to produce monoenergetic 13.3 MeV 7Li (d, n) neutrons. Sci Rep 6, 27363 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep27363
This article is cited by
Reviews of Modern Plasma Physics (2018)
Scientific Reports (2017)