We report on a functional human model to evaluate multi-organ toxicity in a 4-organ system under continuous flow conditions in a serum-free defined medium utilizing a pumpless platform for 14 days. Computer simulations of the platform established flow rates and resultant shear stress within accepted ranges. Viability of the system was demonstrated for 14 days as well as functional activity of cardiac, muscle, neuronal and liver modules. The pharmacological relevance of the integrated modules were evaluated for their response at 7 days to 5 drugs with known side effects after a 48 hour drug treatment regime. The results of all drug treatments were in general agreement with published toxicity results from human and animal data. The presented phenotypic culture model exhibits a multi-organ toxicity response, representing the next generation of in vitro systems and constitutes a step towards an in vitro “human-on-a-chip” assay for systemic toxicity screening.
According to the FDA’s Adverse Event Recording System, 2.3 million reports of adverse drug effects were submitted across 6000 registered compounds between 1969 and 20021. During this period, 75 drugs or drug products were removed from the market due to these unpredicted effects and a further 11 were given special requirements or restrictions1. In addition to withdrawn compounds, only 1 in 10 drugs entering clinical trials typically proves efficacious enough to become registered for human treatments2, indicating a significant proportion of compounds validated during preclinical screening have unpredicted problems when introduced into living human systems. The high failure rate of drugs at this late stage of development contributes significantly to this increase in cost as well as delays in the development of new and more effective clinical treatments.
The generation and characterization of in vitro systems capable of reproducing the functionality of specific human organs in a quantifiable manner is currently a focal point of intensive research and development given the long-standing inadequacies inherent to the use of conventional preclinical techniques for predicting human tissue behavior3,4,5. Such advanced in vitro systems are seen by many as the means to streamline current drug development protocols and thought to generate more informative platforms with which to investigate human tissue physiology and pathology in defined and controllable environments5. Current high-throughput systems for drug discovery and toxicology applications rely on indirect measurement of cell health and function, such as biomarkers and RNA expression analysis. The field would benefit from more advanced systems that are low cost and utilize defined media to support multiple cell types under continuous flow conditions with reproducible functional readouts.
Attempts to observe and characterize the interaction between multiple cell types in vitro have already been achieved to some degree. For example, co-culture of gut epithelial Caco-2 cells with hepatocytes has been performed using trans-well membranes6 and multiple cell types have been successfully maintained by simply establishing all cultures in confined spaces within a single culture well7,8. However, these examples lack the dynamic flow of nutrients and toxins generated in living systems for extended time periods (>7 days). Microfluidic techniques enable the culturing of cells in compartmentalized chambers with controlled interactions between each chamber to better mimic blood flow5. This technology facilitates the metabolism of the drug in one compartment and subsequent convective transfer of the resulting metabolite into other compartments where its effect on different cell types can be evaluated, but generally these systems are utilized for acute toxicity evaluations. In addition, most systems have employed peristaltic or other pump types as well as bulky valves and tubing that increases cost and introduce bubbles and other factors detrimental to system function. These proof-of-concept studies successfully demonstrate the potential, but also some of the drawbacks, for using such microsystems technology to study simple interactions between organs.
Research focused on extending the lifespan of these microfluidic devices has been the main focus of many laboratories to validate body-on-a-chip systems as models for repeated dose or chronic exposure of compounds for efficacy, toxicity and pharmacokinetic studies. Currently, the toxicology models used to study chronic exposures are still animals and a focus of this research is to switch to the utilization of in vitro models. More recently, a two organ model, incorporating liver and skin micro-tissue mimics, has been developed and data presented which validates its ability to maintain these cultures out to 28 days in vitro9. Although microfluidic systems have also been developed to investigate three10 and four11 organ interconnectivity and functionality in vitro, these studies focused on metabolic function over an acute, 48 hour time period. Data supporting the use of these models for measuring the effects of long-term drug treatment, repeat dose studies or to represent chronic pathological conditions have yet to be presented. It is also noteworthy that the majority of these studies9,10,12 have relied on serum-containing medium as well as biomarker readouts as measurements of cell health and function and the use of perfused systems to feed the culture in the device with an external pump. Given that animal sera contain undefined and variable constituents, their inclusion in multi-organ models for drug screening applications limits the predictive capacity of the developed assay since interaction of the compound with unknown components in the medium cannot be effectively controlled13. In addition, biomarker assays only approximates cell or tissue function and are costly to measure and external pumps increase the footprint of the device and the ultimate price for any marketed system or services.
This study details the development and characterization of a low-cost gravity driven flow system14 for maintaining viable and functional human cardiac, liver, skeletal muscle and neuronal cultures within a common defined medium for two weeks. These cell types were chosen to provide insight into important metabolic and functional changes in human tissues in response to challenge with compounds with well-defined toxicological properties. The presented data demonstrates the survival and continued functionality of all 4 human cell types over a 14 day culture period under flow in this microfluidic system to demonstrate the ability to reach chronic timeframe, as well as their response to therapeutic challenge from five compounds at 7 days for acute responses. The cultures were evaluated in situ and ex situ to show both the ability to carry out non-invasive analysis or the capability to perform more extensive testing after disassembly. This low cost platform was self-contained and allowed for continuous circulation of the blood surrogate with periodic medium supplementation and analyte analysis and represents the next generation of organ-on-a-chip or body-on-a-chip systems for both acute and chronic studies.
Device design and gravitational flow simulations
A schematic overview of the system, indicating the location of each cell compartment within the fluidic platform, is shown in Fig. 1a. Although we show specific tissues in these chambers the system is modular and reconfigurable in that other organ modules can be substituted in the device. A gravity-induced flow was enabled by utilizing a rocker platform to generate shear stress on the cellular monolayers within accepted ranges14,15. Flow rate and shear stress on the cells were determined by the choice of tilt angle, periodicity of the tilting action and the cross sectional area of the channels and chambers. Air bubble formation within the device was greatly reduced as they were prevented from entering the system due to buoyancy and communication between chambers ensured equal oxygen and nutrient distribution throughout the platform. Figure 1b indicates the shear stress distribution in each chamber of the system when the gravity-induced flow was applied, calculated utilizing the computational fluid dynamics program CFD-ACE+. The results from the simulations were used to determine the effects of tilt angle and time period of oscillation of the rocker platform to program the flow rate in the system and to keep shear rates within physiological ranges (more detail in supplement files). For example, a tilt angle of 8° with two oscillations per minute gives a maximum shear stress of 0.25 dynes/cm2, which is within the physiological values seen for internal organs such as the liver15.
Cell survival and functional evaluation in flow conditions
Each cell type is cultured on a “module,” which is inserted into the system. These modules allow measurement of not only metabolic but electrical and mechanical function. Data obtained from cell viability and functionality assessment after 14 days of co-culture under flow in the system are shown in Fig. 2. Human serum albumin (HSA) production and urea production by human liver cells were assessed throughout the culture period by analyzing samples of conditioned serum-free medium removed from the platform reservoirs each day (30% of the total volume). Figure 2a indicates stable levels of albumin (p = 0.17) and urea (p = 0.88) for liver function that indicate no significant changes during the experiments when no drugs are added. The same volume of fresh medium replaced the conditioned medium removed to replenish nutrients. Cardiomyocyte in situ measurement function was evaluated by measuring the amount of deflection of microfabricated cantilevers from contracting cell monolayers grown on these BioMEMs devices16. Figure 2b shows cardiomyocyte spontaneous contractile activity after 14 days in the system (top) as well as controlled cardiomyocyte contractility in response to broad-field electrical stimulation pulses at 2 Hz (bottom). Skeletal muscle cultures were assessed using video analysis and found to contract in culture after 14 days under broad-field electrical stimulation (Fig. 2c, video in Supplementary Material). Neurons were analyzed at day 14 using whole cell patch clamp electrophysiology and were found to possess strong inward sodium and outward rectifying potassium currents. All cells investigated were found to be capable of generating action potentials when stimulated after 14 days (Fig. 2d) and no decrease in cell number of more than 29 ± 17% was observed after 2 weeks in co-culture. The 4-organ co-culture under flow did not appear to affect the cell viability significantly of any organ mimic during the experiment. These observations together demonstrate that the base system (no drugs added) operates stably for at least two weeks in a common serum-free medium. Functional measurements of electrical and mechanical (force) as well as video analysis, both in situ and ex situ, are clearly possible for chronic experiments.
Multi-organ toxicological studies
The compounds chosen for the study were Doxorubicin (DOX) 5 μM, Atorvastatin (ATR) 100 μM, Valproic acid (VPA) 2 mM, Acetaminophen (APAP) 5 mM and the control compound, N-Acetyl-m-aminophenol (AMAP) 5 mM. A compilation of the results obtained from the systemic toxicity study of each drug in the 4 organ system are compared to literature reports in Table 1. The toxicity trials were initiated after 5 days under flow in the pumpless system and lasted for 48 hours. Drugs were administered through the reservoir closest to the liver. The cultures were compared to untreated controls at 7 days in the flow system for both function and viability. In the control 7 day cultures, bright field microscopy images indicated normal morphology of the different cell types in the microfluidic platform under flow are shown in Fig. 3a–d. Examples of cell survival and expected phenotype after 7 days in co-culture were also confirmed by immunocytochemical staining, as shown in Fig. 3e–h.
Cardiac cell viability is compromised in vitro when incubating with DOX due to induction of apoptotic pathways and increased reactive oxygen species (ROS) production17. The dose used in this report (5 μM) is higher than what is typically detected in patient plasma concentrations (0.5–1 μM) but consistent with what it is found in mitochondria (typically 100 times more concentrated than plasma levels)17. As the metabolism of DOX in the body is predominantly executed by the liver, high amounts of oxidative stress are generated in this organ, leading to hepatotoxicity as another side-effect of DOX treatment. 40% of patients undergoing DOX treatment show hepatotoxicity due to reduced cellular regeneration, an increase in lipid peroxidation, a decrease in glutathione (GSH) levels to counteract oxidation, DNA damage and apoptosis induction through the release of cytochrome c from the mitochondria17.
The overall cytotoxic effects of DOX are summarized in Table 1, where cell viability and cell functionality data obtained with the microfluidic system are compared to general toxic effects reported in the literature. MTT assays of the DOX treated system indicated a decrease in viability of both hepatocytes and cardiomyocytes of 49 ± 10% (p = 0.012) (Fig. 4a) and 65 ± 6% (p = 0.0004)(Fig. 4b) respectively. The toxic effect on cardiomyocytes was also shown functionally by a 47 ± 9% decrease in beat frequency (p = 0.049) (Fig. 4c). No effects on albumin (p = 0.48) and urea (p = 0.48) production were observed (Fig. 4d–e). Whereas muscle morphology was not affected, the contractile activity was shown to cease in 60% of the cultures. Neuronal electrophysiology showed no changes in ion currents or firing of stimulated action potentials, which corresponds to healthy, functional neurons (Fig. 4f). In addition, action potential peak voltage (p = 0.24), resting membrane potential (p = 0.37) and peak ionic currents (Na+ p = 0.34, K+ p = 0.32) were not significantly different between treated and untreated control. However, there was a loss of repetitive (p = 0.008) and spontaneous (p = 0.082) firing ability. The neuronal morphology study also indicated a 33 ± 18% cell loss compared to the control condition (p = 0.088). These data show multiple effects of doxorubicin on various organs in the system.
Statins are reported to induce different grades of myotoxic effects in a significant number of patients18,19. The ATR concentration used in this study (100 μM) is within the range for human plasma levels (13–125 μM)20,21 and the overall cytotoxic effects found are reported in Table 1.
ATR treatment in the system resulted in a 50 ± 16% decrease of hepatocyte viability (p = 0.017) (Fig. 5a) and a 30 ± 15% decrease in skeletal muscle viability (p = 0.068) (Fig. 5b), compared to the vehicle control (DMSO) and muscle cellular contractility was shown to cease in 50% of the cultures. ATR increased hepatocyte urea production by 24 ± 4% (p = 0.095) (Fig. 5d), while no change in albumin production was observed (p = 0.39) (Fig. 5e). A significant increase in cardiac beat frequency (43 ± 16% from 0.9 ± 0.2 Hz) (p = 0.035) after 7 days in co-culture was observed compared to the vehicle (Fig. 5f). Along with functionality, cardiac viability also increased (24 ± 8%) (p = 0.015) compared to the control (Fig. 5c). The neuronal electrophysiology analysis, although showing typical ion currents and stimulated firing APs, indicated altered ability to fire APs repetitively (p = 0.001) and spontaneously (p = 0.082) as well as changes in it’s peak voltage (p = 0.071) and resting membrane potential (p = 0.030) (Fig. 5g). The neuronal morphological analysis revealed a 47 ± 14% cell loss compared to the control condition after a 48 h treatment (p = 0.030).
Valproic Acid (VPA)
At therapeutic dosages, VPA is detected in the range of 300–700 μM in patient plasma22, while concentrations around 2 mM are known to be cytotoxic in vitro23. Clinical data correlates VPA with idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity; liver failure has been reported previously, but at a very low rate of approximately 1 in 15,000. However, children under 2 years old undergoing polytherapies do suffer from a higher rate of fatal hepatotoxicity in response to VPA treatment22,23,24. VPA is rapidly metabolized to various pharmacologically active metabolites, trans-2-en-valproate being one of the most active products22. A concentration of 2 mM was tested in the 4-organ platform. The overall results of the cytotoxicity study for VPA are reported in Table 1.
A decrease of 56 ± 16% (p = 0.020) for hepatocyte viability following drug treatment in the system was observed (Fig. 6a), while hepatic metabolic functionality was slightly affected (Fig. 6d,e) with a 13 ± 2% (p = 0.015) decrease in urea production but no changes in HSA levels (p = 0.15). Treatment with VPA resulted in a cardio-protective effect, with an increase of both cardiomyocyte viability (36 ± 18%) (p = 0.051) and beat frequency (38 ± 18% from 0.9 ± 0.2 Hz) (p = 0.039) after 7 days in co-culture (Fig. 6b,f). No significant effect on skeletal muscle viability was observed (Fig. 6c)) but there was a loss of contractile activity in 76% of the cultures. The neuronal electrophysiology analysis indicated no changes compared to the control (Fig. 6g) (p = 0.76).
The therapeutic and safe, plasma concentration for APAP is in the low micromolar range. This is reached when taking 500–1000 mg orally three times a day, with a maximum daily dose of 4 g25,26,27. Toxic APAP plasma concentrations depend on the half-life of the compound in humans, being around 2 mM the first two hours after ingestion and falling to less than 50 μM after 24 hours26,28. A dosage of 5 mM over 48 hours in the 4-organ model indicated a decrease in liver cell viability under flow conditions. The overall cytotoxic effects of APAP are summarized in Table 1.
APAP treatment resulted in a 37 ± 9% decrease in hepatocyte viability (p = 0.012) (Fig. 7a) and while albumin production was not affected (p = 0.25) (Fig. 7e), urea production increased by 52 ± 13% (p = 0.095) (Fig. 7d). Viability of cardiomyocytes (Fig. 7b) and skeletal muscle (p = 0.17) (Fig. 7c) were not significantly affected by treatment with APAP. However, there was a 33% decrease in the number of skeletal muscle cultures that contracted and an increase in the beating frequency of the cardiomyocytes by 27 ± 9% (p = 0.017) (Fig. 7f). The electrophysiology of the neurons indicates the loss of repetitive (p = 0.0004) and spontaneous (p = 0.082) firing ability, but no changes in ion currents or the firing of stimulated action potentials, indicating healthy neurons (Fig. 7g). A reduction of neuronal cell numbers after the 48 h APAP treatment was 50 ± 18% (p = 0.036) and was contrary to expectations.
Like APAP, AMAP exerts analgesic and antipyretic properties, but contrary to APAP, AMAP does not induce hepatotoxicity. AMAP was used as a negative control for APAP in this study and was applied at the same concentration and conditions. The cytotoxic effects of AMAP are summarized in Table 1. No significant effects were observed in the system with AMAP treatment in viability data for hepatocytes (p = 0.15) and neurons (p = 0.19) (Fig. 8a,c). While it did not affect hepatic viability, as seen with APAP, there was a net increase in urea production (p = 0.02) (Fig. 8d) and albumin (p = 0.032) (Fig. 8e). The neuronal electrophysiology showed no significant changes compared to the control (p = 0.19) (Fig. 8g) and while there was some increase in cell numbers, this was not a significant change after the 48 hour treatment (p = 0.19). Muscle viability and contractile ability were not affected (p = 0.46). However, cardiomyocyte viability was reduced by 28 ± 6% (p = 0.005) and beat frequency dropped by 25 ± 4% (p = 0.012) (Fig. 8b,f). These results support the conclusion that AMAP is mildly cardiotoxic in this four organ system. It is unclear whether AMAP induced cardiac toxicity exists in vivo as it is most commonly used as a liver toxicity control in studies where no cardiac data is collected.
This is the first multi-organ human system to use a pumpless platform with electrical and mechanical readouts to assess organ component health. The use of functional readouts beyond metabolic biomarkers opens new opportunities for these microphysiological systems to give deeper insight into physiological responses as well as lower cost and allow for chronic non-invasive monitoring of these systems. The other key developments with this platforms being the integration of the four organ systems together under continuous recirculating flow in a serum-free medium, which has also not previously been demonstrated. Given that animal sera contain undefined and variable constituents, their inclusion in models for drug screening applications limits the predictive capacity of the assay since interaction of the compound with unknown components in the medium cannot be effectively controlled13 and has been advocated for in multiple studies10,14,29,30. Serum-free media also promotes the maintenance of differentiated cellular function31 which is important for these in vitro models, but is often difficult to attain with multiple cell types for long periods in a common medium. The platform utilized a pumpless system where circulation was achieved through gravity driven flow14. This unique pumping method avoids the need for external pumps, tubing and valves resulting in a system of decreased complexity, which should decrease cost and improve operability (e.g. reduce problems due to gas bubble entrapment). The system was shown to be viable and functional for up to 14 days under continuous flow. Single organ systems have been reported over the last 15 years which mimic the functionality of a wide variety of tissues and while they are important (see Esch3 and references contained therein), their in vivo counterparts rarely act in isolation. Here, we demonstrate a system that allows one to determine if a single drug affects multiple organs simultaneously.
The organ chips were distributed in separate compartmentalized chambers, each interconnected to one or two other chambers though microfluidic channels. Human cell types of the four organs were represented with cell lines, primary cells and cells derived from iPSc allowing the exchange of metabolites and signal molecules. Functional evaluation of the organs after pharmacological exposure for 48 hours was achieved by measuring cardiac beat frequency, muscle contractibility, neuronal electrophysiology as well as liver albumin and urea production. The results were compared to human clinical data or other data from the literature to provide initial validation of the presented system as a model for accurately predicting multi-organ toxicity in humans. The utilization of functional measures of organ status allows for a decreased reliance on biomarkers as indicators of cell health, but also enables noninvasive monitoring of organ health and function for both acute and, more importantly, chronic experiments in the future.
The four human organs or tissues represented in this platform are common targets in drug development and toxicity but have only indicated multi-organ toxicity in in vivo results previously. The liver is a key processor of drug metabolites and regulator of drug half-life. It is a common target of unpredicted harmful side-effects caused by drug or metabolite exposure32,33. The second most important tissue is the ventricular myocardium as effective cardiac modeling is the subject of intense research since 40–70% of all drug attritions during development are due to arrhythmogenic properties34,35. Adequate modeling of cardiac rhythm generation is essential for any multi-organ drug screening platform. The third and fourth organs represented in the platform are muscle and the nervous system. Skeletal muscle is responsible for significant levels of glucose storage in the body and accounts for a substantial proportion of overall energy expenditure. It is a common target for unpredicted compound side effects, which can have a significant impact on patient quality of life (through induction of tremors, spasms, atrophy and muscular pain). The neuronal compartment represents a particularly sensitive cellular system and a means to introduce the ability to monitor non-fatal central nervous system effects into this multi-organ platform by measuring electrophysiological function.
Immunocytochemical staining of specific markers for each tissue highlight the successful maintenance of all cell types in this dynamic long-term culture system. The functional readouts collected following 7 or 14 days in culture include albumin and urea production levels from the liver fraction, observation of cardiac electrical properties, measurement of contractile activity in the cardiac and the skeletal muscle fractions and recordings of action potential firing activity in the cultured neurons. The correlation of observed results from this system with human in vivo data as shown in Table 1 validates the platform as a novel tool for studying and eventually predicting drug efficacy and toxicity. The concentration analyzed for each compound was selected to produce modest toxic effects within 48 hours in the specific organs and the dosages were based on the available literature. Doxorubicin (DOX) is a widely used chemotherapeutic that impairs replication and transcription, but has a strict dose limit due to its established cardiotoxic side effects36. The cardiotoxicity experienced by patients treated with DOX can be due to acute or chronic (cumulative) dosages17,36. A 48 hour treatment with 5 μM DOX in the 4-organ system, representing an acute dosage, generated a 65 ± 6% loss in the cardiac cell population compared to untreated controls. Among the viable cells, the system indicated a 47 ± 9% decrease in the spontaneous beat frequency, which is in line with previously reported data using other in vitro cardiac culture systems37. The mechanism of this toxicity appears to be multifactorial17,36,38,39. The generation of ROS and the degradation of DOX to its toxic metabolite, doxorubicinol, are the principal causes of the apoptotic side effects17. Doxorubicinol is a potent cardiotoxic agent that inhibits cardiac function and the ATPase activity of the sarcolemma, mitochondria and sarcoplasmic reticulum38,39.
Another known side effect of DOX treatment involves hepatotoxicity, which was observed in our system by a decrease in viability (49 ± 10%), but not in hepatic metabolism in the first 48 hours after drug exposure. The depletion of glutathione levels and thus antioxidant levels, is one of several mechanisms involved in DOX induced hepatotoxicity40. The neuronal fraction of the 4-organ platform was significantly affected by the DOX treatment (33 ± 13% cell loss), however neurons continued to fire action potentials, although the repetitive and spontaneous APs were not observed after treatment. This is consistent with a report by Aquilano and coworkers where neuron viability dropped 25% when exposed to 1uM DOX for 24 hours41. With respect to the skeletal muscle fraction, DOX is known to induce a toxic effect at physiological concentrations through a Ca2+ handling impairment and an increase in oxidative stress, leading to muscle weakness and fatigue, but not atrophy42,43. The DOX concentration assessed in this report slightly affected muscle viability and reduced contractile activity in 60% of the cultures, supporting the literature reports of force reduction.
Atorvastatin (ATR) is a commonly prescribed statin used for cholesterol homeostasis. A 48 hour treatment with ATR (100 μM) in the 4-organ system induced myotoxicity, reducing cell viability by 30 ± 15% and reduced myotube contraction events (50%). Statin induced myotoxicity is reported to induce different grades of myopathy in a significant part of the population, ranging from mild myalgia to fatal rhabdomyolysis19. ATR is metabolized by the liver (CYP3A4 is the main enzyme participating) and the reduction of its metabolism by inhibiting CYP3A4 activity triggers this toxicity18. A 48 hour incubation of ATR (100 μM) in the liver mono-culture condition induced CYP3A4 activity by 12-fold (data not shown). Interestingly, ATR myotoxicity in the co-culture is not decreased by the presence of the liver. Statins rarely cause clinically significant liver injury, although asymptomatic elevation in aminotransferase levels is observed in 1–3% of patients44,45,46. ATR-related hepatotoxicity has been associated with a mixed pattern of liver injury, typically occurring several months after the initiation of the medication. Hepatotoxicity was detected in the 4-organ platform and characterized as a reduction in liver cell viability by 50 ± 16%.
In the cardiac compartment, no reduction was observed in cell viability following ATR treatment and a 43 ± 16% increase in beat frequency was recorded. ATR is known to play a protective role in induced cardiotoxicity47 and has been used as a negative control in cardiotoxicity studies37; the results obtained in this study are consistent with the previously published data. A significant reduction of 47 ± 16% in cell viability was observed in the neuronal fraction upon ATR incubation, but regular AP activity was recorded with good sodium and potassium currents, although no repetitively firing cells were observed. Studies using animal models and various cell types indicate some inconsistencies regarding ATR toxicity in the nervous system. Previous studies have suggested a neuroprotective effect at low concentrations (100 nM to 1 μM), but neurotoxic events in the micromolar range48,49. ATR is able to cross the blood brain barrier due to its lipophilic character50 and inhibit brain cholesterol biosynthesis with possible consequences for synaptic cholesterol homeostasis51. Results obtained in this study using a relatively high ATR concentration of 100 μM could correlate with the observed toxicity in previous in vitro and in vivo studies49.
Valproic acid (VPA) is a first-line anticonvulsive agent and is also used as a mood stabilizer and other indications are currently being studied through clinical trials24. VPA potentiates the GABA inhibitory effect by blocking its degradation and also by the blocking of ion channels. The incubation with 2 mM VPA in the 4-organ system affected the liver fraction by reducing viability by 56 ± 16% and decreasing urea production by 13 ± 2%. Other in vitro23,52,53 and in vivo54 studies using hepatoma cell lines have reported cytotoxicity with VPA (in the millimolar range) in a dose-dependent manner. Hepatocellular damage after VPA treatment has also previously been reported in mice54.
VPA incubation in this system exhibited a protective effect on neurons and maintained the electrophysiological parameters of the cells (in terms of spontaneous firing behavior) throughout the experiment compared to untreated controls. This finding corresponds with previous references that report a general neuroprotective effect of VPA22,24. VPA has been identified as a drug candidate for spinal muscular atrophy or being motoneuron protective55. VPA exerted a protective effect in the cultured cardiac cells, with a 36 ± 18% increase in viability and a 38 ± 18% increase in beat frequency. This result is consistent with previous data on the induction of VPA mediated cardioprotection during cardiac remodeling and myocardial function after infarction in rats56.
Acetaminophen is a derivative of acetanilide and widely used as an over-the-counter analgesic and antipyretic25,57. However, overdoses with APAP cause acute liver failure in humans58. It’s metabolism by the liver leads to the oxidized N-acetyl-p-benzoquinone imide (NAPQI) metabolite through a secondary pathway that involves the cytochrome p450 system. NAPQI is conjugated with glutathione (GSH) and finalizes its cycle with kidney elimination. In a GSH depletion scenario (APAP overdose or specific p450 enzyme induction), non-conjugated NAPQI disrupts cellular homeostasis, leading to hepatotoxicity25,27,57. Interestingly, APAPs toxicity is species specific; hamsters, mice and humans are sensitive to acetaminophen overdoses, whereas rat, rabbit and guinea pig are not57, highlighting the importance of using human cell types for effective preclinical drug toxicity screening. The dose of 5 mM, chosen to mimic an overdose serum level, compromised liver function by reducing HepG2/C3A viability by 37 ± 9% and increasing urea production by 52 ± 13%. Ma and coworkers showed previously a 60% reduction in HepG2 viability inside a microfluidic system with double the concentration of APAP described in this manuscript59.
Recent laboratory and pre-clinical studies correlate beneficial effects of APAP on skeletal muscle, cardiac and neuronal function25. With this regard, cardiac viability and functionality was preserved (even improved) upon APAP treatment. Concentrations in the millimolar range have been used previously in other cardiac in vitro assays as negative controls for cardiotoxicity37. This general protective characteristic of APAP could be due to the antioxidant property that APAP exerts in the therapeutic range as suggested by Blough and Wu25. However, contrary to results by Blough and coworkers, neurons lost some viability as well as the ability to spontaneously and repetitively fire and muscle exhibited a reduction in contraction for 37% of the cultures. Since our exploratory studies focused on device development rather than specific toxicological questions, this result will need to be verified through many more repeats.
Finally, AMAP, which is a regioisomer of APAP, with the hydroxyl group located at the meta-, instead of in the para- position was treated as a non-toxic control. AMAP metabolites lead to reduced glutathione depletion in comparison with APAP60. The lack of liver toxicity induced by AMAP however, has generated some controversy in the literature61,62. The results obtained from the 4 human organ system support the innocuous characteristics of AMAP for the liver, when compared to hepatotoxic APAP. Interestingly, some liver functionality appeared to be affected as a significant increase in urea production was observed (138 ± 19%) upon drug incubation. Urea production was also up-regulated by its regioisomer APAP, although in a less acerbated manner (52 ± 13%). An increase in albumin production was also observed (23 ± 4%). Of particular note, AMAP was the only drug that modified albumin secretion in the first 48 h. Evidence for neuroprotective activity in this compound was supplemented by analysis of the neuron fraction, which indicate no change in viability and conserved the repetitive and spontaneous AP firing.
Unlike APAP, AMAP was found to exert a moderate damaging effect on cardiac cells (30% reduction in viability and beating frequency). However, no published data regarding AMAP and cardiomyocytes was found to compare with this observation. This finding suggests studies on AMAP induced cardiotoxicity may be fruitful and provides an example of how this 4-organ in vitro system represents a valuable tool for identifying potential toxic interactions in off-target tissues. Interestingly, different toxicities are sometimes observed with regioisomer molecules and in this case the hydroxyl located in the para- position induces hepatotoxicity and exerts cardioprotective benefits, while the meta regioisomer gives the opposite effect and benefits the hepatic fraction and induces some toxicity in cardiac cells.
It should be noted that the neuronal results for the tested compounds were obtained with a mixed population of neurons with some glia and in cases where the overall number of neurons decreased, but the functional electrophysiological properties were stable, it could be that non-neuronal cells were targeted. More interesting is the loss of repetitive firing with some drugs as it’s a subtle change and could be linked to impairment of neuronal communication as opposed to loss of cellular function that is normally measured. In addition, the functional data roughly tracked with the viability data for all cells in the system, but the functional measurement appeared to be more sensitive to toxic evaluation than the assay for cell death. The system described here is clearly a prototype and many improvements are possible. These include the addition of other biological components such as barrier tissues (e.g., skin, GI tract, blood brain barrier) and other organ systems (e.g. kidney, lung, pancreas). The basic format and pumpless system can be expanded to accommodate the inclusion of such systems given its modular and reconfigurable nature. The creation of a common serum free medium that preserves essential functionality is a challenge, but we have preliminary experiments demonstrating that we can maintain at least seven different organs in a common serum free medium. We believe that this prototype system forms a solid basis for more complex and realistic human models for both chronic and acute drug testing.
We demonstrate here, for the first time, a four organ system with continuous recirculation of a serum free medium that mimics human response to five different drugs for at least 14 days. This system measures electrical and mechanical response to various drugs as well as metabolic response. The design uses a pumpless system which is simple, mechanically reliable and low cost. The system is modular, reconfigurable and the organ systems tested (liver, cardiac, neuronal and muscle) represent the most important organs in terms side effects leading to drug candidate failure. The results obtained from this work indicate that this human 4-organ in vitro system is a viable tool to study: (i) organ to organ communication, (ii) drug toxicity and (iii) novel drug compound effects in humans for predictive purposes, for either short or longer term studies. The generation of a novel tool that improves the predictive power of preclinical efficacy/toxicity studies is of substantial benefit to the health industry as a whole and will aid in the generation of human-specific target compounds with a significantly higher safety profile.
The microfabrication of the silicon cantilever for this study was performed at the Cornell NanoScale Science and Technology Facility. All mask designs were created in L-Edit layout editor. The cantilevers were fabricated with a 4 in double sided polished Silicon on insulator (SOI) wafer, with a device thickness of 4 μm, buried oxide thickness of 1 μm and a handle thickness of 500 μm. The device layer of the SOI wafer was spin coated with photoresist and the cantilever front side pattern was defined using standard photolithography techniques. A deep reactive ion etching (DRIE) process was performed on the photoresist patterned device layer to etch through the silicon until the buried oxide layer was visible. The handle layer (backside) of the SOI wafer was spin coated with photoresist and the backside window/cleave lines pattern was defined. A DRIE of the patterned handle layer was performed in multiple runs to achieve a through etch of the handle layer until the buried oxide layer was visible. Following the DRIE step, wet etching of the SOI wafer with 25% dilute HF was performed to strip the buried oxide layer below the cantilevers to release the Si cantilevers and also open a window underneath to provide laser access to probe the cantilevers. The SOI wafer was then rinsed in a DI water bath and oven dried. The fully processed SOI wafer was manually cleaved along etched cleave lines to obtain the individual cantilever chips.
All human cells types were cultivated at 37 °C with a 5/95% CO2/Air mixture in a humidified atmosphere in their own specific medium before being transferred to the co-culture. The different cultures were started at different times in advance of the co-culture integration (liver; 4, cardiac; 7, muscle; 22 and neurons; 35 days). Culture origin, growth, maintenance, differentiation and plating, for the different cell types, is detailed below.
Human hepatocellular carcinoma HepG2/C3A (ATCC® CRL-10741™) were routinely grown, up to fifteen passages, in HepG2/C3A medium (Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM) (from Life technologies) supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS), 1 mM Sodium Pyruvate (all from Life Technologies) and 5 mM Hepes (Sigma)). Four days (approximately) before transferring to the in vitro system, 6 × 104 cells (0.34 cells/mm2) were plated in collagen type-I coated 15 mm diameter round glass coverslips. Medium was replaced with HepG2/C3A medium the following day and every 2 days afterwards until co-culture.
Human induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSc) differentiated Cardiomyocytes (Cellular Dynamics International, CDI) were plated according to user instructions and one cryovial was used for each experiment. Cardiomyocytes were plated with CDI cardiac plating medium, 7 days before transferring to the in vitro system, on control SiO2 surfaces (500 cells/mm2), or cantilevers (2,500 cells/mm2) previously coated with fibronectin (50 μg/mL in 1X PBS (phosphate buffer solution)). Forty-eight hours later, the medium was replaced with cardiac serum-free maintenance medium63 and followed by half medium changes every 48 hours before co-culture.
Human Skeletal Myofibers were obtained as a gift from H. Vandenburg, Brown University without identifiers and prepared by isolation and differentiation steps previously described by this group, with small modifications64. Biopsies were performed according to procedures approved by the Institutional Clinical Review Board of the Miriam Hospital65. For each culture, human skeletal muscle (hSKM) SCs/progenitors were plated 22 days (approximately) before the co-culture on N-1(3-(trimethoxysilyl) propyl) diethylenetriamine (DETA) modified 15 mm diameter coverslips (30 cells/mm2) in hSKM Growth Medium (Lonza) and fed afterwards every 2 days by replacing the medium. On day 7, myoblast fusion into postmitotic myofibers was induced by incubation with differentiation medium 164. The cells were fed every 2 days by changing half of the medium. Four days later, the cells were fed with NBActive4 (Brain Bits) every 2 days by changing half of the medium, for a minimum of 11 days.
Human Motoneurons, obtained from NeuralStem, were differentiated as described66 from human spinal cord stem cell line (hSCSC) previously isolated, with slight modifications. Briefly, approximately 35 days before the co-culture, 0.5 × 106 hSCSCs were plated in a T25 flask in Growth medium for 7 days until they were close to confluence. They were then harvested by trypsinization and plated into a PDL/fibronectin-coated 60 mm paranox cell culture dish (Nunc, Cat #174888) at a density of 2.5 million cells/dish and differentiated 4 days in the priming medium followed by 6 days in differentiation medium67. Then the cells were replated onto DETA-coated 15 mm diameter round glass coverslips at a density of 250 cells/mm2 and cultured in the defined serum-free medium for another 16–18 days before being transferred into the in vitro system.
Human iPSc differentiated cortical-like neurons (Cellular Dynamics International, CDI) were plated according to user instructions and one cryovial was used for each experiment. Neurons were plated with CDI neuronal plating medium, 2–4 days before transferring to the in vitro system, cells were plated onto DETA modified 15 mm diameter round glass coverslips and then coated with laminin (3.3 μg/mL) at a density of 700 cells/mm2. Forty-eight hours later, the medium was replaced with cortical serum-free maintenance medium68, followed by half medium changes every 48 hours before the co-culture.
The defined serum-free medium base composition used to maintain the functionality of the 4 organ culture system for up to 14 days was previously published62 and was modified by the addition of an antibiotic/antimycotic cocktail at 1X (Life Technologies, 15240-062) and the elimination of the G5 supplement. The base medium was composed of 1X Neurobasal (Life Technologies, 21103-049), 1X B27 (Life Technologies, 17504-044), 1X Antibiotic and antimycotic (Life Technologies, 15240-062) and 1X Glutamax (Life Technologies, 35050-061). It was supplemented with 10 ng/mL Glial-derived Neurotrophic Factor (GDNF) (Cell Sciences, CRG400B), 20 ng/mL Brain-derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF) (Cell Sciences, CRB600B), 5 ng/mL Ciliary-derived Neurotrophic Factor (CNTF) (Cell Sciences, CRC400A), 20 ng/mL Neurotrophin-3 and 4 (NT3 and NT4) (Cell Sciences, CRN500B and CRN501B), 100 ng/mL Vitronectin (Sigma, V8379-50UG), 10 ng/mL Insulin-like Growth Factor-I (IGF-1) (PeproTech, 100-11), 100 ng/mL Agrin (R&D, 550-AG-100), 1 μM Adenosine 3′, 5′-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) (Sigma, A9501), 4 μg/mL laminin (Life Technologies 23017-015), 50 ng/mL Sonic Hedgehog, N-terminal peptide (Shh) (R&D, 1845-SH-025) and 0.1 μM Retinoic acid (Sigma, R2625). All the compounds purchased as a powder were dissolved in water, except for retinoic acid which was dissolved in DMEM 1X.
All experiments utilized cells that were commercially available or derived from commercially available cells. Additional IRB protocols or informed consent at UCF was not necessary as no cell lines contained identifiable information.
The four organ in vitro systems were assembled, on day 0, by placing the corresponding surfaces cell side up in a specific chamber of the housing (liver coverslip into chamber 1, cardiac coverslips and cantilevers into chambers 2 and 4, muscle coverslips into chamber 5 and neuron coverslips into chamber 3 and they were then topped with the serum-free co-culture medium (1X Neurobasal Medium, 1X B27, 1X AB/AM, 1X Glutamax (all from Life Technologies)) before locking the system. Right after assembling, the medium was completely replaced with 4 mL of the co-culture defined serum-free medium and the systems placed on a rocking platform inside an incubator. Platforms were checked every day by inspecting for expected cell morphology inside the system and by replacing medium (1.2 mL total volume) from the two reservoirs (30% of the total volume was replaced) with fresh medium. Drug incubation was initiated on day 5 of the co-culture by addition of the drug through the reservoir closer to the liver chamber (no. 1), allowing a first contact of the drug with the liver. 20 μL of the drug stock solution (or vehicle) to achieve a working concentration in 4 mL of total volume in the platform was utilized. On day 6, after 24 hours of drug incubation, 6 μL of the drug stock solution (or vehicle) was added to the fresh medium exchange volume (1.2 mL). After 48 hour of drug incubation, on day 7, systems were disassembled to test organ functionality that same day. For mono-culture conditions, surfaces remained in a 12-well plated with 1 mL of the co-culture defined serum-free medium maintained by daily replacement of half volume.
Bright-Field Cell Imaging
Cell morphology and function were studied each day with an inverted bright-field microscope (Carl Zeiss) using a 10X objective. This working distance allowed the imaging of the cells in the specific surfaces inside the housing. Images of each fraction and systems were collected with an Axio Cam and AxioVision AC software to study morphological or functional changes in the co-culture chamber for each organ.
Human Serum Albumin quantification
Human Serum Albumin (HSA) production from the liver fraction was tracked throughout the co-culture, by measuring the HSA concentration in the supernatant of the culture as it represents liver protein anabolism. Samples were collected from the exchanged medium (1.2 mL) and stored at −20 °C until analysis. One freeze-thaw cycle occurred before samples were analyzed following manufacturers’ instructions provided in the ELISA Starter Accessory Kit (Bethyl Laboratories Inc, Cat #: E101). Samples were diluted as necessary in sample conjugate/diluent buffer to ensure readings measured within the range of the standard curve. The standard curve was prepared by serial dilutions of human reference serum in sample conjugate/diluent buffer (0–1600 ng/ml). After the reaction was stopped optical densities (OD) were immediately measured at 450 nm using a Synergy HT plate reader and KC4 software.
Final HSA concentrations were calculated in an excel file by first removing the average OD reading measured for blanks from average sample and standard OD readings. Concentrations of standard dilutions were plotted against average OD values measured in XY scatter plots. A standard curve was created by adding an order of 2 polynomial trendline to XY scatter plots and selecting the option to display the equation of the trendline, as well as the R2 value, on each scatter plot (for ease of analysis HSA sigmoidal curves were split into 3 standard curves with HSA concentration ranges of 0–200 ng/ml, 200–800 ng/ml and 400–1600 ng/ml). Quadratic equations were rearranged to make X (sample HSA concentration) the unknown variant. Y values (OD values) and a/b/c constants generated from trendline equations were inputted into rearranged quadratic equations per assay. HSA concentrations calculated were corrected accordingly for any differences in culture final volumes, sample dilutions during assays and cells number.
Urea production, corresponding to liver protein catabolism, was analyzed from the same samples as for HSA, thus tracking daily concentration changes. For this colorimetric assay, manufacturers’ instructions provided for the QuantiChromTM Urea Assay Kit (BioAssay Systems, Cat #: DIUR-500) were followed. Plates were incubated in the dark for 50 minutes at room temperature, then OD was measured at 520 nm, using a Synergy HT plate reader and KC4 software. Final urea concentrations were calculated in the same way as for HSA and plotted as urea produce per day.
Cytochrome p450 1A1 and 3A4 enzymatic activity
Enzymatic activities for 1A1 and 3A3 isoforms were assessed in the liver fraction (in mono-culture ± drugs) individually, as an end point evaluation according to the manufacturer’s instructions (p450-610TM assay from Promega) and Li, 200964. Enzymatic products from 1A1 were run with LDR and separately, 3A4 were run with LDR containing esterases. Enzymatic activities were finally represented as D-Luciferin picomoles produce in 1 hour by 1 × 106 cells.
Force measurements were quantified from the cardiac organ chamber after 14 days in co-culture. Individual surfaces were evaluated for spontaneous contraction, or contraction induced by a broad field electrical stimulation on microscale silicon cantilevers as previously reported from this group4. Cardiomyocytes were interrogated for spontaneous and stimulated contraction. The resulting force calculations were performed using a modified version of Stoney’s equation5.
Cardiac beating frequency
Seven or fourteen days after the co-culture, cardiac beating frequency was quantified from video recordings of three different areas of each of the cMEA surfaces, where the cardiomyocytes culture where located. Surfaces were located in a 37 °C bath platform containing co-culture medium with 50 mM HEPES on the stage of a Zeiss Axioscope 2FS upright microscope. Beats were counted in a period of 10 s and the average number of 3 values was obtained. Drug effect was plotted as percentage of change compared to the control conditions.
Myotube stimulated contraction
Myotube contraction in coverslips was evaluated after the co-culture was finalized. Individual surfaces were evaluated as previously reported in the group6. Drugs effects were quantify in a binary code mode, cells were or were not contracting. Representing videos demonstrating contraction synchronously with the stimulation pulse are available as supplementary files.
Neuron electrophysiology recording
Electrophysiological properties of neuron cultures where recorded on the last day of co-culture following a previously described method2. Values of firing, repetitive firing, spontaneous firing, inward sodium current, outward potassium current, action potential peak voltage and the resting membrane potential, characterized the mature functionality of neurons in the in vitro system. Drug alterations of the neuronal electrophysiology are discussed in this manuscript.
Surfaces were fixed in freshly prepared 4% PFA (paraformaldehyde) for 15 minutes after co-culture. Cells were rinsed afterwards, with 1X PBS, 3 times with longer incubations, 5, 10 and 15 minutes at RT. To permeabilize the cells a 0.2% triton X-100 in 1X PBS was incubated for 15 minutes. Non-specific binding sites were blocked with 5% DS and 0.5% BSA in 1X PBS for 1 hour at RT. Primary antibodies were incubated on the cells OVN at 4 °C. The following day, primary antibodies were removed and surfaces were rinsed, with 1X PBS, 3 times. Then, the cells were incubated with secondary antibodies, in the dark, for 2 hours at RT. Surfaces were newly rinsed and incubated with 3 mM 4′-6-Diamidino-2-Phenylindole (DAPI) in 1X PBS for 10 min, in the dark and at RT for nuclei staining. Finally, two more 1X PBS rinses were done before imaging. DAPI incubation was replaced by a Hard Set Mounting with DAPI (Vector laboratories, Inc.) when the cells were on coverslips. Images were collected with Axioskop 2 mot plus upright spinning disk confocal microscope (Carl Zeiss) with a XCite 120 Fluorescence Illumination system (EXFO) beam and a multi-spectral laser scanning, coupled to Volocity software (Perkin Elmer).
The following primary antibodies were used for this study: mouse anti-Troponin (MAB1693, 1:200) and rabbit anti-neurofilament (AB1981, 1:2000) (from Millipore); mouse anti-Myosin Heavy Chain (A4.1025-5 5ea, 1:10) and sheep anti-Human Serum Albumin (ab8940, 1:100) (from ABcam). Secondary antibodies and actin stain used in the secondary antibody cocktail dilutions: donkey anti-mouse 488 (A-21202, 1:200), donkey anti-rabbit 488 (A21206, 1:200), donkey anti-sheep 568 (A21099, 1:200) and Phalloidin 594 (A12380, 1:40) (from Life Technologies).
Seven days after the initiation of the co-culture, viability of each organ chamber, except for neurons, was evaluated through an MTT assay. After functional assays were performed, 1.2 mM 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)- 2,5- diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) (Sigma-Aldrich) diluted in culture medium was incubated for 2 hours at 37 °C. Supernatant removal was followed by the addition of the solubilization reagent (0.57% acetic acid and 1% SDS in DMSO). Cell viability was measured at 570 nm in a Synergy HT plate reader and KC4 software. The results were expressed as the percentage of cell survival relative to the control (untreated or incubated with vehicle). The neuronal fraction viability was evaluated through morphological analysis throughout the co-culture experiment as the final coverslips were used for patch-clamp electrophysiology. Phase images (10X) where obtained every day of the co-culture. Neuronal viability was evaluated by cell morphology integrity and by cell count from day 1 to day 14.
Values are expressed as the mean ± SE of a minimum of three independent experiments. Data were evaluated by unpaired Student’s t-test when analyzing the trend of change between two conditions, control and drug-treated. Student’s t-test analysis was run with a one tail distribution and a two sample unequal variance. Cardiac beating frequency data was transformed (applying a logarithm base 10) to reduce the variance between treatments and then analyzed with the t-test. One-way ANOVA test was used for different conditions that differ in one parameter (i.e. time). Both analysis were ran with Microsoft Excel Statistical tool. Differences with p-values <0.1 were taken as statistically significant.
Doxorubicin (DOX), Valproic Acid (VPA), Acetaminophen (APAP), 3-Acetamidophenol (AMAP) and Atorvastatin calcium (ATR), Dimethyl Sulfoxide (DMSO), Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA) (all purchased from Sigma). PDMS, Paraformaldehyde (PFA) (Electron Microscope Sciences), Donkey Serum (DS) (S30, Millipore), Collagen type-I from Rat tail (A10483-01, Gibco) was diluted to 60 μL/mL with 0.02 M Acetic acid (Sigma) in 1X PBS and Fibronectin (FC010, Millipore) was diluted to 50 μg/mL in 1X PBS. Laminin was diluted to 3.3–4 μg/mL in mQ water.
Drug Concentrations and stock solutions
Drug stock solutions were prepared taking into account drug solubility and final concentrations targeted. Doxorubicin (1 mM) and Valproic Acid (400 mM) were reconstituted in purified water. Acetaminophen (4 M), 3-Acetamidophenol (4 M) and Atorvastatin calcium (20 mM) were reconstituted in DMSO. Stock aliquots were stored at −20 °C until needed. Acetaminophen and 3-Acetamidophenol were further diluted with media, previous to cell treatment, to a 1 M solution (<0.13% DMSO). Vehicle control was used as a control for Atorvastatin treatment (0.5% DMSO).
How to cite this article: Oleaga, C. et al. Multi-Organ toxicity demonstration in a functional human in vitro system composed of four organs. Sci. Rep. 6, 20030; doi: 10.1038/srep20030 (2016).
Wysowski, D. K. & Swartz, L. Adverse drug event surveillance and drug withdrawals in the united states, 1969–2002: The importance of reporting suspected reactions. Arch. Intern. Med. 165, 1363–1369 (2005).
Hay, M., Thomas, D. W., Craighead, J. L., Economides, C. & Rosenthal, J. Clinical development success rates for investigational drugs. Nat Biotech. 32, 40–51 (2014).
Esch, M. B. et al. How multi-organ microdevices can help foster drug development. Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev. 69–70, 158–169 (2014).
Huh, D., Torisawa, Y. S., Hamilton, G. A., Kim, H. J. & Ingber, D. E. Microengineered physiological biomimicry: organs-on-chips. Lab Chip 12, 2156–2164 (2012).
Sung, J. H. et al. Microfabricated mammalian organ systems and their integration into models of whole animals and humans. Lab Chip 13, 1201–1212 (2013).
Lau, Y. Y. et al. Evaluation of a novel in vitro Caco-2 hepatocyte hybrid system for predicting in vivo oral bioavailability. Drug Metab. Dispos. 32, 937–942 (2004).
Lee, M. Y. et al. Three-dimensional cellular microarray for high-throughput toxicology assays. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 105, 59–63 (2008).
Li, A. P., Bode, C. & Sakai, Y. A novel in vitro system, the integrated discrete multiple organ cell culture (IdMOC) system, for the evaluation of human drug toxicity: comparative cytotoxicology of tamoxifen towards normal human cells from five major organs and MCF-7 adenocarcinoma breast cancer cells. Chem. Biol. Interact. 150, 129–136 (2004).
Wagner, I. et al. A dynamic multi-organ-chip for long-term cultivation and substance testing proven by 3D human liver and skin tissue co-culture. Lab Chip 13, 3538–3547 (2013).
Iori, E. et al. Glucose and fatty acid metabolism in a 3 tissue in-vitro model challenged with normo- and hyperglycaemia. PloS One 7, e34704 (2012).
Zhang, C., Zhao, A., Rahim, N. A. A., van Noort, D. & Yu, H. Towards a human-on-chip: culturing multiple cell types on a chip with compartmentalized microenvironments. Lab Chip 9, 3185–3192 (2009).
Vozzi, F., Heinrich, J. M., Bader, A. & Ahluwalia, A. D. Connected culture of murine hepatocytes and HUVEC in a multicompartmental bioreactor. Tissue Eng. Part A 15, 1291–1299 (2009).
van der Valk, J. et al. Optimization of chemically defined cell culture media—replacing fetal bovine serum in mammalian in vitro methods. Toxicol. In Vitro 24, 1053–1063 (2010).
Sung, J. H., Kam, C. & Shuler, M. L. A microfludic device for a pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) model on a chip. Lab Chip 10, 446–455 (2010).
Esch, M. B., Mahler, G. J., Stokol, T. & Shuler, M. L. Body-on-a-chip simulation with gastrointestinal tract and liver tissues suggests that ingested nanoparticles have the potential to cause liver injury. Lab Chip 14, 3081–3092 (2014).
Pirozzi, K., Long, C. J., McAleer, C. W., Smith, A. S. T. & Hickman, J. J. Correlation of embryonic skeletal muscle myotube physical characteristics with contractile force generation on an atomic force microscope-based biomicroelectromechanical systems device. Appl. Phys. Lett. 103, 083108 (2013).
Carvalho, C. et al. Doxorubicin: the good, the bad and the ugly effect. Curr. Med. Chem. 16, 3267–3285 (2009).
Ginanneschi, F. et al. Rhabdomyolysis in an elderly multitreated patient: multiple drug interactions after statin withdrawal. J. Neurol. Sci. 336, 284–287 (2014).
Skottheim, I. B., Gedde-Dahl, A., Hejazifar, S., Hoel, K. & Asberg, A. Statin induced myotoxicity: the lactone forms are more potent than the acid forms in human skeletal muscle cells in vitro. Eur. J. Pharm. Sci. 33, 317–325 (2008).
Lins, R. L. et al. Pharmacokinetics of atorvastatin and its metabolites after single and multiple dosing in hypercholesterolaemic haemodialysis patients. Nephrol. Dial. Transplant. 18, 967–976 (2003).
Valera, H. R. & Ganguly, B. Study of plasma level of atorvastatin and its effect on lipid profile. Indian J. Physiol. Pharmacol. 53, 73–82 (2009).
Loscher, W. Basic pharmacology of valproate: a review after 35 years of clinical use for the treatment of epilepsy. CNS Drugs 16, 669–694 (2002).
Duenas-Gonzalez, A. et al. Valproic acid as epigenetic cancer drug: preclinical, clinical and transcriptional effects on solid tumors. Cancer Treat. Rev. 34, 206–222 (2008).
Chateauvieux, S., Morceau, F., Dicato, M. & Diederich, M. Molecular and therapeutic potential and toxicity of valproic acid. J. Biomed. Biotechnol. 2010, 479364 (2010).
Blough, E. R. & Wu, M. Acetaminophen: beyond pain and Fever-relieving. Front. Pharmacol. 2, 72 (2011).
Hadzimichalis, N. M. et al. Acetaminophen-mediated cardioprotection via inhibition of the mitochondrial permeability transition pore-induced apoptotic pathway. Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol. 293, H3348–3355 (2007).
Montgomery, C. J., McCormack, J. P., Reichert, C. C. & Marsland, C. P. Plasma concentrations after high-dose (45 mg.kg−1) rectal acetaminophen in children. Can. J. Anaesth. 42, 982–986 (1995).
Rumack, B. H. & Matthew, H. Acetaminophen poisoning and toxicity. Pediatrics 55, 871–876 (1975).
Hannoun, Z. et al. The comparison between conditioned media and serum-free media in human embryonic stem cell culture and differentiation. Cell Reprogram. 12, 133–140 (2010).
Klein, S., Mueller, D., Schevchenko, V. & Naar, F. Long-term maintenance of HepaRG cells in serum-free conditions and application in a repeated dose study. J. Appl. Toxicol. 34, 1078–1086 (2014).
Roberts, S. M., James, R. C. & Williams, P. L. Principles of Toxicology: Environmental and Industrial Applications. 3 edn, (John Wiley & Sons, 2015).
Horner, S., Robinson, S., Lees, D., Callander, R. & Roberts, R. Target organ profiles in toxicity studies supporting human dosing: An assessment of recovery and chronic dosing. Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 70, 270–285 (2014).
Szkolnicka, D. et al. Accurate prediction of drug-induced liver injury using stem cell-derived populations. Stem Cells Transl. Med. 3, 141–148 (2014).
Clements, M., Millar, V., Williams, A. & Kalinka, S. Bridging functional and structural cardiotoxicity assays using human embryonic stem-cell derived cardiomyocytes for a more comprehensive risk assessment. Toxicol. Sci. 148, 241–260 (2015).
Raschi, E., Ceccarini, L., De Ponti, F. & Recanatini, M. hERG-related drug toxicity and models for predicting hERG liability and QT prolongation. Expert Opin. Drug Metab. Toxicol. 5, 1005–1021 (2009).
Torres, V. M. & Simic, V. D. in Cardiotoxicity of oncologic treatments (ed M. Fiuza ) Ch. 5, (InTech, 2012).
Abassi, Y. A. et al. Dynamic monitoring of beating periodicity of stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes as a predictive tool for preclinical safety assessment. Br. J. Pharmacol. 165, 1424–1441 (2012).
Cusack, B. J., Young, S. P., Driskell, J. & Olson, R. D. Doxorubicin and doxorubicinol pharmacokinetics and tissue concentrations following bolus injection and continuous infusion of doxorubicin in the rabbit. Cancer Chemother. Pharmacol. 32, 53–58 (1993).
Olson, R. D. et al. Doxorubicin cardiotoxicity may be caused by its metabolite, doxorubicinol. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 85, 3585–3589 (1988).
Damodar, G., Smitha, T., Gopinath, S., Vijayakumar, S. & Rao, Y. An evaluation of hepatotoxicity in breast cancer patients receiving injection Doxorubicin. Ann. Med. Health Sci. Res. 4, 74–79 (2014).
Aquilano, K. et al. Neuronal nitric oxide synthase protects neuroblastoma cells from oxidative stress mediated by garlic derivatives. J. Neurochem. 101, 1327–1337 (2007).
Gilliam, L. A. et al. Doxorubicin acts through tumor necrosis factor receptor subtype 1 to cause dysfunction of murine skeletal muscle. J. Appl. Physiol. 107, 1935–1942 (2009).
van Norren, K. et al. Direct effects of doxorubicin on skeletal muscle contribute to fatigue. Br. J. Cancer 100, 311–314 (2009).
Clarke, A. T. & Mills, P. R. Atorvastatin associated liver disease. Dig. Liver Dis. 38, 772–777 (2006).
Gershovich, O. E. & Lyman, A. E. Jr. Liver function test abnormalities and pruritus in a patient treated with atorvastatin: case report and review of the literature. Pharmacotherapy 24, 150–154 (2004).
Liu, Y. et al. Atorvastatin-induced acute elevation of hepatic enzymes and the absence of cross-toxicity of pravastatin. Int. J. Clin. Pharmacol. Ther. 48, 798–802 (2010).
Ramanjaneyulu, S. V., Trivedi, P. P., Kushwaha, S., Vikram, A. & Jena, G. B. Protective role of atorvastatin against doxorubicin-induced cardiotoxicity and testicular toxicity in mice. J. Physiol. Biochem. 69, 513–525 (2013).
Bösel, J. et al. Neuroprotective effects of atorvastatin against glutamate-induced excitotoxicity in primary cortical neurones. J. Neurochem. 92, 1386–1398 (2005).
Wood, W. G., Eckert, G. P., Igbavboa, U. & Muller, W. E. Statins and neuroprotection: a prescription to move the field forward. Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 1199, 69–76 (2010).
Gazzerro, P. et al. Pharmacological actions of statins: a critical appraisal in the management of cancer. Pharmacol. Rev. 64, 102–146 (2012).
Mailman, T., Hariharan, M. & Karten, B. Inhibition of neuronal cholesterol biosynthesis with lovastatin leads to impaired synaptic vesicle release even in the presence of lipoproteins or geranylgeraniol. J. Neurochem. 119, 1002–1015 (2011).
Li, X. et al. Synergistically killing activity of aspirin and histone deacetylase inhibitor valproic acid (VPA) on hepatocellular cancer cells. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 436, 259–264 (2013).
Schuchmann, M. et al. Histone deacetylase inhibition by valproic acid down-regulates c-FLIP/CASH and sensitizes hepatoma cells towards CD95- and TRAIL receptor-mediated apoptosis and chemotherapy. Oncol. Rep. 15, 227–230 (2006).
Knapp, A. C. et al. Toxicity of valproic acid in mice with decreased plasma and tissue carnitine stores. J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. 324, 568–575 (2008).
Lee, J. Y. et al. Valproic acid protects motor neuron death by inhibiting oxidative stress and endoplasmic reticulum stress-mediated cytochrome C release after spinal cord injury. J. Neurotrauma 31, 582–594 (2014).
Lee, T. M., Lin, M. S. & Chang, N. C. Inhibition of histone deacetylase on ventricular remodeling in infarcted rats. American journal of physiology. Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol. 293, H968–977 (2007).
Bessems, J. G. & Vermeulen, N. P. Paracetamol (acetaminophen)-induced toxicity: molecular and biochemical mechanisms, analogues and protective approaches. Crit. Rev. Toxicol. 31, 55–138 (2001).
McGill, M. R. et al. The mechanism underlying acetaminophen-induced hepatotoxicity in humans and mice involves mitochondrial damage and nuclear DNA fragmentation. J. Clin. Invest. 122, 1574–1583 (2012).
Ma, B., Zhang, G., Qin, J. & Lin, B. Characterization of drug metabolites and cytotoxicity assay simultaneously using an integrated microfluidic device. Lab Chip 9, 232–238 (2009).
Holme, J. A., Hongslo, J. K., Bjorge, C. & Nelson, S. D. Comparative cytotoxic effects of acetaminophen (N-acetyl-p-aminophenol), a non-hepatotoxic regioisomer acetyl-m-aminophenol and their postulated reactive hydroquinone and quinone metabolites in monolayer cultures of mouse hepatocytes. Biochem. Pharmacol. 42, 1137–1142 (1991).
Kenna, J. G. A new twist to an old tale: novel insights into the differential toxicities of acetaminophen and its regioisomer N-acetyl-meta-aminophenol (AMAP). Arch. Toxicol. 87, 15–18 (2013).
Myers, T. G. et al. A comparative study of mouse liver proteins arylated by reactive metabolites of acetaminophen and its nonhepatotoxic regioisomer, 3′-hydroxyacetanilide. Chem. Res. Toxicol. 8, 403–413 (1995).
Natarajan, A. et al. Patterned cardiomyocytes on microelectrode arrays as a functional, high information content drug screening platform. Biomaterials 32, 4267–4274 (2011).
Guo, X. et al. In vitro differentiation of functional human skeletal myotubes in a defined system. Biomater. Sci. 2, 131–138 (2014).
Powell, C. et al. Tissue engineered human bioartificial muscles expressing a foreign recombinant protein for gene therapy. Hum. Gene Ther. 10, 565–577 (1999).
Guo, X. F., Johe, K., Molnar, P., Davis, H. & Hickman, J. J. Characterization of a human fetal spinal cord stem cell line NSI-566RSC and its induction to functional motoneurons. J. Tissue Eng. Regen. Med. 4, 181–193 (2010).
Guo, X., Gonzalez, M., Stancescu, M., Vandenburgh, H. & Hickman, J. J. Neuromuscular junction formation between human stem cell-derived motoneurons and human skeletal muscle in a defined system. Biomaterials 32, 9602–9611 (2011).
Edwards, D., Das, M., Molnar, P. & Hickman, J. J. Addition of glutamate to serum free culture improves the electrical properties of adult hippocampal neurons in vitro. J. Neurosci. Methods 190, 155–163 (2010).
We would like to acknowledge support from the National Institutes of Health grant number UH2TR000516 and research collaboration and grant from L’Oreal Corporation.
JJH and MLS have potential competing financial interests, in that a company has been formed to market services for the type of device described herein in which they have a financial interest.
Electronic supplementary material
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Oleaga, C., Bernabini, C., Smith, A. et al. Multi-Organ toxicity demonstration in a functional human in vitro system composed of four organs. Sci Rep 6, 20030 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep20030
This article is cited by
Effect of gut microbiome-derived metabolites and extracellular vesicles on hepatocyte functions in a gut-liver axis chip
Nano Convergence (2023)
Organ-On-A-Chip Technology: An In-depth Review of Recent Advancements and Future of Whole Body-on-chip
BioChip Journal (2023)
Human organs-on-chips for disease modelling, drug development and personalized medicine
Nature Reviews Genetics (2022)
A guide to the organ-on-a-chip
Nature Reviews Methods Primers (2022)
Polymeric nanoparticles as therapeutic agents against coronavirus disease
Journal of Nanoparticle Research (2022)
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.