Transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs), such as MoS2 and WSe2, provide two-dimensional atomic crystals with semiconductor band gap. In this work, we present a design of new mechano-electric generators and sensors based on transition metal dichalcogenide nanoribbon PN junctions and heterojunctions. The mechano-electric conversion was simulated by using a first-principle calculation. The output voltage of MoS2 nanoribbon PN junction increases with strain, reaching 0.036 V at 1% strain and 0.31 V at 8% strain, much larger than the reported results. Our study indicates that the length, width and layer number of TMDC nanoribbon PN junctions have an interesting but different impact on the voltage output. Also, the results indicate that doping position and concentration only cause a small fluctuation in the output voltage. These results have been compared with the mechano-electric conversion of TMDC heterojunctions. Such novel mechano-electric generators and sensors are very attractive for applications in future self-powered, wearable electronics and systems.
Mechanical energy is one of the most ubiquitous energy sources in the environments and is readily accessible from the human activities. Therefore, the conversion of mechanical energy into electricity offers an immediate, stand-alone power support for remote control systems, wearable electronics, wireless sensing and remote battery charging1,2,3,4,5,6. Piezoelectric transducer is the most distinguished technique for harvesting vibration based energy by its high power output and relatively low-cost manufacturing7. Recently, the piezoelectric properties of nanowires have been widely studied for potential applications in sensors, transducers, energy conversion and electronics8,9. The power generators based on piezoelectric nanostructures were successfully designed and fabricated10,11,12. The coupling of semiconductor and piezoelectric properties in one-dimensional (1D) ZnO nanowires (NWs) in a nanogenerator was reported with excellent power conversion efficiency from 17% to 30%13. However, the difficulty in aligning 1D ZnO NWs may hinder high-performance applications in Nanoelectromechanical Systems (NEMS)13,14,15,16.
Two-dimensional (2D) layered materials, such as hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN) and transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs)16,17,18, have gained considerable attentions for electronic applications. Their mechanical properties, possible application in body movement, muscle stretching and blood vessel contraction19,20, have also been studied. The MoS2 monolayer, a typical member of 2D TMDCs, becomes piezoelectric after exfoliation from the bulk crystal whereas the inversion symmetry is broken21,22. The asymmetry leads to valley polarization caused by valley-selective circular dichroism. This attracts potential applications in valleytronic devices23,24. Therefore, MoS2 nanostructures have become promising in NEMS application25,26 in nanopiezotronics, a rapidly emerging field.
The piezoelectric properties and applications of MoS2 monolayers, such as mechanical energy harvesting and piezotronic sensing, have very recently been explored experimentally25,26. Angular dependence of inversion symmetry has been measured by optical second-harmonic generation (SHG)27, indicating that it is mostly broken along armchair direction while preserves along zigzag direction. The absence of centrosymmetry endows MoS2 monolayer with piezoelectricity along the armchair direction19. An open-circuit voltage of 18 mV has been demonstrated at 0.53% strain along the armchair direction26 in a MoS2 monolayer of a dimension of 10 μm in length and 5 μm in width. This output voltage is quite small. Enhancement of output performance is very important for further application of 2D materials in mechanical-to-electric generators.
In this work, we report a novel mechano-electric conversion device based on TMDC nanoribbon PN junctions and heterojunctions. As shown in Fig. 1(a), a TMDC nanoribbon mechano-electric generator can be used to convert human muscle stretching power to support wearable electronics. Our first-principle calculation has shown that high output voltages, 0.036 V and 0.31 V at 1% and 8% strain, respectively, can be achieved in a 1.5 nm × 5 nm MoS2 nanoribbon PN junction. In consideration of the small size of nanoribbon, this mechano-electric generator has a high conversion voltage and its performance can be improved significantly by a series of connection26. Our study indicates the mechano-electric conversion of 2D TMDC PN junction is better than that of the heterojunction. This work is the first study of designing 2D TMDC junctions for application in high-performance mechano-electric conversion, suggesting a new way of using 2D TMDCs for future nanogenerators and sensors.
Methods in Simulation
In this work, the energy diagrams of 2D TMDC nanoribbon PN junctions and heterojunctions have been calculated by first principle calculations carried out by the density functional theory (DFT) in Virtual Nanolab ATK package28. The n-type and p-type TMDCs are achieved by substitutional doping. The Localized Density Approximation (LDA) exchange correlation with a Double Zeta Polarized (DZP) basis was used with a mesh cut-off energy of 150 Ry29. We used 1 × 1 × 50 Monkhorst-Pack k-grid mesh in this simulation with more k-points in transport direction30. All atomic positions and lattice constants were optimized by using the Generalized Gradient Approximations (GGA)31 with the maximum Hellmann-Feynman forces of 0.05 eV/Å. Pulay-mixer algorithm was employed as iteration control parameter with a strict tolerance value of 10−5 32. The maximum number of fully self-consistent field (SCF) iteration steps was set to 100029. The electronic temperature was set to 300 K for all the simulations. The self-consistent field calculations were checked strictly to guarantee fully converging within the iteration steps.
In order to clearly illustrate the design and characteristics of TMDC junction mechano-electric converters, the results are reported as follows: (1) The intrinsic piezoelectricity of 2D infinite MoS2 monolayer was studied. (2) The PN junction-based device electric output performance was evaluated. (3) Effects of sizes (width, length and layer number) on output voltages were investigated. (4) The fluctuation in output voltage induced by various doping positions and concentrations was studied. (5) The mechano-electric conversion of TMDC nanoribbon heterojunctions were studied and compared with that of PN junctions. Finally, the mechano-electric conversion of various designs based on 2D TMDCs was analyzed and compared.
Results and Discussion
The basic MoS2 monolayer PN junction was configured as Fig. 2(a). The model is divided into three regions: left electrode, right electrode, and central region. The central scattering region consists of 5 × 9 unit cells: the width is composed of 5 periodic unit cells in zigzag direction and 9 basic lattice lengths are included in armchair direction, which is designed as transport direction in this study. In the transport direction Dirichlet boundary condition was applied on the two opposite electrodes, in which the electric potential was held homogeneously across the boundary. Neumann condition was employed on the other two directions, in which the electric field was held homogeneously at the boundary. MoS2 nanoribbon exhibits intrinsic semiconducting property and strongest piezoelectricity along the armchair direction while metallicity and highly crystal inversion symmetry are demonstrated in zigzag direction33,34. The coupled semiconducting and piezoelectric properties are responsible for the mechanism of power generator35. Substituting sulfur (S) by chlorine (Cl) shifts the Fermi level towards conduction bands, resulting in n-type doping while the inverse p-type doping is realized by the replacement of phosphorus (P). The impurity density on both sides is chosen to be 1013 cm−2 within reasonable computational burden36. Fig. 2(b) displays the electrostatic potential as a function of position in the unstrained central region. As shown it is decreasing monotonically along the transport direction and the electrostatic potential dropping (EPD) is 1.174 eV at right edge with respect to the left counterpart. This is consistent with our design that p-type is realized at the left side while the right side is n-type.
Intrinsic piezoelectricity of 2D MoS2 monolayer
Firstly, the intrinsic piezoelectricity of MoS2 monolayer is investigated. Noncentrosymmetric lattice structure is necessary for a material to be piezoelectric37,38. The three-dimensional (3D) bulk stacked-layer h-BN and 2H-TMDC crystals are centrosymmetric due to their experimentally observed antiparallel stacking sequence39. However, the two dimensional (2D) monolayer of TMDCs, such as MoS2, WSe2, WS2, MoSe2 etc., which have been successfully fabricated by exfoliation from their 3D bulk materials40,41,42,43, exhibits noncentrosymmetric crystal structure22. This noncentrosymmetry stems from the particular dislocated stacks of the different layers composed by chalcogen atoms and transition elements and accordingly results in the absence of inversion center. As a typical member of TMDCs, 2D MoS2 monolayer is naturally piezoelectric. Figure 2(c) shows its polarization charge as the function of strain applied along in-plane armchair direction. In this work, the strain is evaluated as the lattice changing percentage. We defined εx ≡ Δa0/a0, where Δa0 is the increase of lattice constant a0 due to the strain. a0 = 5.47 Å, signifying the lattice constant along the transport direction (armchair direction). The coefficient e11, defined as the slope of linear fit line for charge vs. strain curve, reveals the change in polarization along armchair direction per area by strain19. Our estimation of e11 is 2.98 × 10−10 C/m, which is very close to the experimentally reported 2.90 × 10−10 C/m25.
PN junction MoS2 nanoribbon based device
Secondly, the electronic property of our model under lateral strain has been simulated. The strain given by ε = (L–L0)L0 is initially applied along transport direction, where L0 and L is the equilibrium length along the transport direction of the unstrained and strained device, respectively. Fig. 3(a) reveals the electrostatic potential distribution along the transport direction in the central region for the device applied by 0%, 4% and 8% tensile strain, respectively. The central region was extended from 49.2 Å to 53.2 Å in length by 8% strain. As shown the structure under 8% strain has the smallest EPD. EPD reduces from 1.174 V for unstrained structure to 0.878 V for the structure under 8% strain. Fig. 3(b) demonstrates the output voltage as a function of strain applied along the transport direction. The absolute value of output voltage is linearly increasing by larger strain. The maximum output voltage is 0.310 V in the case of 8% strain. The negative value denotes that the electrical potential at left electrode is higher than that of right electrode and therefore the left side serves as the anode while the right counterpart is the cathode in our device. Our study suggests a nano-generator with excellent performance, which has output of ~20 mV in small size (5 nm × 1.5 nm) under 0.5% strain. This indicates significantly enhanced performance by doping and PN junction based device over undoped MoS2 nanosheet in large area26. This tremendous improvement in output is attributed to the strongly enhanced polarization between bipolar atoms induced by the coupled built-in electric field and external strain.
Next, we investigate the mechanical property of our device based on PN junction. Fig. 3(c) demonstrates the variation of total energy with uniaxial strain applied along transport direction. The total energy (Etotal) is increasing monotonically as the increasing strain (ε). The slope of this curved line given by ε is also rising by the increasing strain. The evolution of the stress with strain is estimated by the mathematic expression: ε, where V is the volume of our sampled system44. The orthorhombic cube with the total volume of 9.6 nm3 was sampled in our study. The stress required for deformation intensity denoted by strain ε is increasing monotonically with the larger strain. The stress vs. strain relation keeps good linearity within the small strain range 0 ≤ ε ≤ 3% and the elastic modulus C is keeping constant by the expression: C = dб/dε. Previous report indicated that this parameter can remain constant within small strain (−2% ≤ ε ≤ 2%) for MoS2 monolayer45,46. For the larger strain from 4% up to 8%, this relation slightly deviates from linearity and accordingly the elastic modulus C reduces. Fig. 3(d) shows the output voltage response for our device under laterally applied stress in Sine waveform-time domain. The periodic time of our dynamic stress is 1ms. Therefore a proper assumption can be suggested that there is negligible delay between input force and output voltage phase47. Experimentally, the stress can be realized by bending the substrate periodically26. For the mathematic expression of time dependent stress, we deduce it as following:where A is the maximum stress with the value of 0.051 eV/ Å3, which induces 8% strain. As shown the maximum output voltage ~0.310 V is reached at the maximum stress.
Effects of Sizes
The evolution of the output voltage with the nanoribbon width (Na) was also investigated. The nanoribbon width is denoted by periodical number of unit cells in zigzag direction vertical to the transport direction. For each structure with incremental width, one doping atom was kept at the center of lateral edge. The length of nanoribbon was kept 9 periodic unit cells in the transport direction. As displayed in Fig. 4(a), the output voltage oscillations are observed for the narrow ribbons, and those nanoribbons of Na = 3p + 1 (where p is an integer) have larger output than the neighboring two nanoribbons. With increasing width, the output voltage finally converges to a constant value ~0.355 V. The enlarged size will attenuate the doping concentration, and might lead to unexpected impact on the performance of our device. To clarify this issue, two pairs of phosphorus and chlorine doping atoms are introduced in 8-width structure (Fig. 4(b)), and also, three pairs of doping atoms are introduced in 12-width nanoribbon (Fig. 4(c)). The doping concentration of these structures are keeping the same as 4-width structure with one pair of doping atoms. The output voltage for these two structures are 0.328 V and 0.346 V, indicating slight difference with one doping structure of 8-width (0.328 V) and 12-width (0.352 V), respectively. It should be noted that the output of the structure with low doping concentration is slightly higher than that of the highly doping structure. This issue will be discussed in part doping effect.
In addition to the width effect, we also investigate the influence of nanoribbon length on the output performance. As displayed by Fig. 5(a) the length of nanoribbon is defined by the periodic lattice number (Nb) of the central region in the transport direction (armchair direction). The width number (Na) is kept constant value of 5 for all the investigations on length effect. The output voltage for the device under 8% strain as a function of Nb is shown in Fig. 5(b). The output voltage of the nanoribbon with Nb = 6 is 0.3103446 V, setting as the reference value. The output voltage is slightly increasing by the order of magnitude of 10−6 V with increasing Nb. The rising rate (∆Output/∆Nb) reduces as larger Nb, indicating that the output will saturate to a constant value under sufficiently large Nb. Our study indicates that the structure length has negligible effect on the output voltage.
We also investigated the output voltage as a function of layer number of MoS2 stacked structure. Fig. 6(a) shows the configuration of 3 layers MoS2 mechano-electric converter. Each layer is doping by a pair of P and Cl, respectively. P replaces S at left side while Cl is doping at right side. As demonstrated by Fig. 6(b), the output voltage exhibits a fluctuant behavior as increasing layers. It reaches maximum of 0.310 V by single layer, while is reducing significantly to 0.16 V by 2 layers stacked structure. As limited by the simulation complexity and its converging difficulty, we only put forward our investigation to 5 layers. However, a reasonable speculation can be made that the output voltage finally converges to a constant value as increasing layer number, which is trended similarly as that tuned by increasing width. In experiments the output voltage of undoped MoS2 in large area shows a proportional relation with the second-harmonic generation (SHG) intensity for stacked structures: MoS2 flakes stacked by odd number of layers exhibited strong piezoelectricity along armchair direction, while the output voltage disappeared for even number of layers26. Our study shows that the structures with even number of layers still have strong output, indicating a distinct underlying physical principle with the device by undoped nanosheet. It should be noted that as the larger size (Larger width, length and layer number), the output voltage of our device tends to converge to a constant value. Our study suggests a mechano-electric generator with weak dependence on dimension and size, which is exceedingly favourable for industrial application.
Precisely control the dopant position and number is the main challenge for the application of low-dimensional nanomaterials. This inaccuracy in fabrication induces variations in mechanic and electronic properties of 2D materials and devices48,49. Therefore we investigate the variation of output voltage upon the various doping positions in MoS2 nanoribbon mechano-electric converter. As displayed by Fig. 7(a), the various combinational doping positions of P and Cl are denoted by P(m, n), where m, n are the atomic ordinal number of doping atoms P and Cl. P replaces S at left side while Cl is doping at right side. The variation of output voltage upon the doping combinations is exhibited in Fig. 7(b). The combination P(4,4) has the nearest distance between P and Cl while they reaches farthest away from each other in P(1,1). Generally the output voltage randomly fluctuates within small range from 0.301 V to 0.312 V. This limited variation modulated by various doping positions is favourable for future industrial applications. The doping concentration effect are also revealed in our study. 2 pairs of doping atoms are introduced in our device, as shown in Fig. 7(c). The dependence of output voltage on strain is demonstrated in Fig. 7(d). It increases linearly as larger strain. However, the output is lowered by higher doping concentration compared to that of the device based on one pair of doping atoms. The output is 0.028 V and 0.256 V for the device applied by 1% and 8% strain, respectively.
TMDCs heterojunction based device
We also investigate the mechano-electric converter based on TMDCs heterojunctions. Fig. 8(a). displayed the WSe2-MoS2 heterojunction based mechano-electric generator. The left part is WSe2 nanoribbon and the right counterpart is MoS2 nanoribbon. Fig. 8(b) reveals the electrostatic potential distribution along transport direction in the central region for the device under 0%, 4% and 8% tensile strain, respectively. The EPD mainly occurs at the narrow connection region between WSe2 and MoS2 nanoribbon. This radical change in electrostatic potential arises from the great difference between the work functions of WSe2 and MoS2 monolayer. As opposite to the regulatory change of EPD by strain in MoS2 PN junction, increasing strain causes larger EPD in heterojunctions. Fig. 8(c) reveals the output performance as a function of strain. The output voltage increases with larger strain and 0.185 V can be achieved by 8% strain. Our observation suggests that MoS2 PN junction based device has better output performance than TMDCs based heterojunctions.
Fig. 9 shows the output voltage as a function of strain for 4 different heterojunctions: a) WSe2-MoS2 (b) WSe2-MoSe2 (c) WS2-MoS2 (d) WS2-MoSe2. As shown in Fig. 9(c), WS2-MoS2 heterojunction reaches maximum output of 7.21 × 10−3 V under 5% strain, then reduces significantly by larger strain. For the other 3 structures, the output voltage is generally increasing by larger strain. Among these structures, WSe2-MoS2 heterojunction achieves the largest output of 0.185 V under 8% strain. However, this is still inferior to the performance of MoS2 PN junction, which possesses the output of 0.310 V under the equal strain. WSe2-MoS2 and WS2-MoSe2 can obtain the output voltage with a value of one order of magnitude larger than those of the other two structures, indicating that the enhanced output can be achieved by the TMDCs heterojunction based on different chalcogen materials. Table 1 summarizes the output voltage and EPD for 8 different TMDCs PN junctions and heterojunctions, all of which are in the same size of 5 × 9 (Na = 5, Nb = 9). The heterojunction structures with higher EPD can achieve higher output voltage. Larger EPD is attributed to larger difference in work functions of distinct nanoribbons at opposite sides. This rule is also applied appropriately to the TMDCs PN junctions, among which the output voltage and EPD both reach largest value in WS2 PN junction.
In summary, enlightened by the intrinsic piezoelectricity of TMDCs based two dimensional monolayer, we have designed and simulated a novel piezoelectric device realized by MoS2 monolayer based PN junction. Its electromechanical property was simulated by first-principle calculations. 0.31 V of output voltage can be achieved by 0.051 eV/ Å 3 of the laterally tensile stress, which leads to 8% strain in transport direction. We have also demonstrated the time domain-output voltage in the case of the applied stress in Sine waveform. The investigation on size-dependent performance demonstrates that by increasing width, length and layer number the output will finally converge to constant output. Our investigation on the doping effect shows that various doping positions affect slightly on the output voltage and the low concentration gives rise to higher output performance. The piezoelectric performance based on 4 different TMDCs-heterojunction were also simulated. We conclude that the structure with higher EPD can obtain higher output voltage. Our study suggests a novel TMDCs PN junction and heterojunction based mechano-electric generator with high output voltage. This may open up a suite of applications in 2D-TMDCs based piezoelectric transistor.
How to cite this article: Yu, S. et al. Novel Two-Dimensional Mechano-Electric Generators and Sensors Based on Transition Metal Dichalcogenides. Sci. Rep. 5, 12854; doi: 10.1038/srep12854 (2015).
This work was supported in part by the U.S. NSF Grant ECCS-1407807 and in part by Virginia Microelectronics Consortium research grant.
About this article
Monolayer MoS2 Nanoribbons as a Promising Material for Both n-type and p-type Legs in Thermoelectric Generators
Journal of Electronic Materials (2016)