Elucidation of the pathogenesis and effective treatment of autism spectrum disorders is one of the challenges today. In this study, we examine hair zinc concentrations for 1,967 children with autistic disorders (1,553 males and 414 females), and show considerable association with zinc deficiency. Histogram of hair zinc concentration was non-symmetric with tailing in lower range, and 584 subjects were found to have lower zinc concentrations than −2 standard deviation level of its reference range (86.3–193ppm). The incidence rate of zinc deficiency in infant group aged 0–3 year-old was estimated 43.5 % in male and 52.5 % in female. The lowest zinc concentration of 10.7 ppm was detected in a 2-year-old boy, corresponding to about 1/12 of the control mean level. These findings suggest that infantile zinc deficiency may epigenetically contribute to the pathogenesis of autism and nutritional approach may yield a novel hope for its treatment and prevention.
Autism spectrum disorders are a group of neural development disorders characterized by impairments in reciprocal social interaction and communication, and by the presence of restricted and repetitive behaviors1, affecting 1 in 150 children in developed countries2. Therefore, the elucidation of the pathogenesis and effective treatment of autistic disorders is one of the challenges today. Autism spectrum disorders is thought to be heritable and some related genes have been reported3,4. However, the underlying genetic determinants are still unclarified1 and the interaction of heritable factors with uncertified lifestyle and environmental factors seem play a significant role in the pathogenesis. For example, ethyl-mercury, a component in vaccines has been claimed to be one of the environmental candidates causing autistic disorders5, but its relationship with autism remains to be proved scientifically. Recently, epigenetic alteration of gene expression by environmental influences is considered one of key events in the pathogenesis of genetic diseases6. And some toxic elements such as cadmium, arsenic and mercury, and also essential mineral deficiencies have been reported to be candidate factors that induce epigenetic disorders7,8,9.
Recent great advances in high-sensitive and reliable trace element analysis method using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) have enabled it to be applied for estimating chronic toxic metal burden and essential mineral deficiency in human body, showing that human blood mineral concentrations reflect to their levels in hair or nail specimen10,11. Thus, clinical metallomics studies with reliable ICP-MS method have been tried for investigating some association of several diseases and symptoms with the dynamics of trace bio-elements such as toxic metals and essential minerals12,13,14,15,16,17,18.
The importance of zinc in human nutrition and health has been recognized since the early 1960s. For assessment of zinc nutritional status, the use of serum zinc alone is subject to limitations because its level seems be influenced by factors other than dietary zinc intake; for example, hypoalbuminemia, infection, acute stress, pregnancy and use of oral contraceptive agents can lower serum zinc values19. In addition, serum zinc levels are subject to diurnal variation and influenced by the fasting status of the subjects.
For the last five years, we have examined on the association of toxic metal burden with autistic disorders, and reported that some parts of the children with autism have suffered from high accumulation of toxic metals such as cadmium, lead or aluminium more than mercury20,21,22.
In this preliminary study, we have determined human scalp hair zinc concentrations for 1,967 children diagnosed with autistic spectrum disorders by their physicians, and showed that many of them, especially in the infant group aged 0–3 year-old, are suffering from zinc deficiency.
The histogram of logarithmic hair zinc concentrations for 1,967 children diagnosed with autism by their physicians is shown in Figure 1. The distribution of the logarithmic zinc concentration was non-symmetric with tailing in lower range, and 584 in 1,967 subjects (29.7 %) were found to have low zinc concentration less than −2 S.D. (standard deviation) level of the control reference range (86.3–193 micro g/g hair (ppm); geometric mean = 129 ppm), estimated as zinc deficiency. The logarithmic zinc concentrations in the autistic subjects showed a significant correlation with age (r = 0.367, p < 0.0001), with a plateau at over 10 year-old (Fig. 2). The only one 0 year-old case in 1,967 subjects was 11 month-old female with no zinc deficiency (Fig. 2) and may be a suspect, because she was found to suffer from high burdens with aluminium, lead, iron and copper (data not shown). The minimum zinc concentration of 10.7 ppm was observed in a 2-year-old boy, corresponding to about 1/12 of the control mean level. The geometric mean zinc concentration was lowest in the age group of 0–3 year-old in both sexes (Table 1). The incidence rate of zinc deficiency in the age group of 0–3 and 4–9 year-old was estimated 43.5 and 28.1 % in male, and 52.5 and 28.7 % in female, respectively (Table 2). In the group aged 10–15 year-old, the zinc deficiency rate in male and female was calculated 3.3 and 3.5 %, respectively. There was little marked gender difference observed in scalp hair zinc concentration and incidence rate of zinc deficiency in the subjects with autism.
Zinc is an essential trace element that plays important roles in nucleic acid/protein synthesis, cell replication, tissue growth and repair, especially in pregnant women and infants. Therefore, zinc deficiency is known associated with various pathological conditions, including impaired immunity, delayed wound healing, retarded growth, neural development disorders and degenerative diseases23,24.
Hair zinc is commonly used in marginal zinc deficiency studies of children, and its usefulness has been documented in many industrialized countries including Canada and the USA25,26,27,28,29. In the present study, we determined zinc concentration in scalp hair samples from 1,967 subjects (1,553 males and 414 females) diagnosed with autism by physicians, and investigated any association of zinc deficiency with autistic spectrum disorders.
The control zinc reference range for healthy subjects published by ourselves17,18 was almost consistent with those reported by other research groups10,11,12 and those for nutritionally-controlled children reported by Munakata et al.13 and Vancouver preschoolers aged 2–5 year-old (N = 719) by Vaghri et al.28,29. Based on these findings, the normal human hair zinc level was estimated to be around 130 ppm independently age and sex, although it was relatively low during childhood19,28 (Fig. 2) and infants seem liable to fall into zinc deficiency because of their higher necessity of zinc for developing and growing. Thus, the lower zinc levels for control children reported by Adams et al.15, Munakata et al.13 and ourselves14 should be re-considered as non-normal control values including non-healthy, affected zinc levels, as Adams themselves recently reviewed that the 11% participants in the neurotypical control children group were medicated with drugs such as anti-asthma/allergies or anti-incontinence30.
The histogram of logarithmic hair zinc concentration in the 1,967 autistic children showed a non-symmetric profile with a marked tailing in lower range, indicating that about 30 % of the subjects with autism have low zinc concentrations less than −2 S.D. level (< 86.3 ppm) of the control reference range, being estimated as marginal zinc deficiency (Fig. 1). In particular, nearly one half (male: 43.5 %; female: 52.5 %) of the autistic infants aged 0–3 year-old were found to suffer from marginal to severe zinc deficiency (Table 2).
A significant correlation (r = 0.367, p < 0.0001) of the zinc concentration with age in the autistic subjects (Fig. 2) suggests that children, in particular infants, need larger amount of zinc (per kg body weight) for their development and growth and so they are liable to zinc deficiency. In fact, the minimum zinc concentration as low as 10.7 ppm corresponding to about 1/12 of the control level was observed in a 2-year-old boy (Fig. 2), and the lowest mean concentration level was observed in the infant group aged 0–3 year-old in both sexes (male: 87 ppm; female: 81 ppm) (Table 1). These findings indicate that a considerable number of autistic children, in particular infants, are suffered from marginal to severe zinc deficiency, suggesting that infantile zinc deficiency may play a role in the neural development disorders and pathogenesis of autism spectrum disorders, and zinc supplementation may be useful for treatment and prevention of some patients with autistic disorders and suspects.
The incidence rate of zinc deficiency in the age group of 4–9 and 10–15 year-old was estimated 28.1 and 3.3 % in male, and 28.7 and 3.5 % in female subjects, respectively, indicating that there is little gender difference in zinc deficiency rate in the autistic subjects. It remains to be explained why the elder subjects over 10-year-old have normal zinc concentration, although this is maybe explained by the possibility that the young adolescents have better metal-protein functioning and utilize dietary zinc more efficiently and effectively.
There were some studies reporting lower serum zinc levels in children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in developing countries24,31. Recently, zinc deficiency has been remarked in not only developing but also developed countries, due to imbalanced intake of trace nutrients and dieting32,33. Faber et al.34 reported that the mean plasma Zn/Cu ratio in children with autistic disorder was below the cut-off value of the lowest 2.5 % of healthy children, suggesting that plasma zinc/copper ratio may be a biomarker of heavy metal toxicity in children with autism spectrum disorders. Other clinical studies reported that mean serum zinc levels were significantly lower in both autism and ADHD groups, and that serum zinc level correlated inversely with parent- and teacher-rated inattention in ADHD children33. Furthermore, zinc treatment was reported significantly superior to placebo in reducing symptoms of hyperactivity, impulsivity and impaired socialization in ADHD patients35,36. The other human study showed that many children with ADHD have lower zinc concentration in comparison to healthy children, and zinc supplement as an adjunct to methylphenidate has favourable effects in the treatment of ADHD children, pointing to the possible association of zinc deficiency and ADHD pathophysiology37.
The cellular zinc homeostasis is mediated by two transporter families: the zinc-importer (Zip) family that transport zinc into the cytosol, and the zinc transporter (ZnT) family transporting zinc out of the cytosol38. The severe zinc deficiency in a rare inherited human disease “acrodermatitis enteropathica” is reported to result from defective intestinal absorption of zinc by mutations in the Zip4 transporter located on intestinal duct39,40. Autistic children have often been reported to have gastrointestinal problems of intestinal mal-absorption of nutrients41, named “leaky gut syndrome” which may lead to zinc deficiency, and zinc deficiency itself may further lead to gut syndrome resulting from over-consumption of fructose42. Furthermore, many of the autistic children are also suffered from allergic disorders that are known to relate to zinc deficiency. Thus, these findings suggest that infantile zinc deficiency may be also responsible for the pathogenesis of various symptoms observed in the children with autistic spectrum disorders.
Recently, dietary restriction-induced zinc deficiency has been reported to up-regulate intestinal zinc-importer (Zip4) and induce the increase in Zip4 protein located to the plasma membrane of enterocytes43. This adoptive response to zinc deficiency is known to lead to increasing in the risk of high-uptake of toxic metals such as cadmium and lead. Thus, infants with zinc deficiency are liable to be exposed to increased risk of absorbing high amount of toxic metals and retaining them in their body. These findings suggest that the increased risk of toxic metal burdens attendant on the infantile zinc deficiency may also contribute to the pathogenesis of autistic spectrum disorders.
The mechanisms of zinc deficiency in autistic infants and ADHD children may be explained by their unbalanced nutritional intake and lower absorption ability in intestinal duct41,44. In addition, maternal cigarette smoking has been reported to be associated with lower zinc and higher cadmium and lead concentrations in their neonates45. Because of their high distribution property to bone tissue, during pregnancy and lactation, these toxic metals accumulated in the maternal bone matrix are co-transferred with calcium and magnesium to foetal and newborn bodies through increased bone-resorption45,46,47.
Kern et al. 48 reported that arsenic, cadmium and lead were significantly lower in the hair of children with autism than in matched controls, and the patients have trouble excreting these toxic elements. We also reported that not only toxic but also some essential metals are significantly lower in autistic children13, suggesting that the patients with zinc deficiency have a low excretion ability of toxic metals and result in a higher body burden with them. Eklund and Oskarsson49 reported that soy-based formulas contain approximately six times more cadmium than cow's milk formulas, and cereal-based formulas have 4–21 times higher levels. Thus, the dietary intake of cadmium may be higher in the children feeding on infant formulas and weaning foods, compared to breast milk-fed infants.
In conclusion, this preliminary study shows that many of infants with autistic spectrum disorders have been suffered from marginal to severe zinc deficiency. This finding suggests that infantile zinc deficiency and attendant toxic metal accumulation may play principal roles in the pathogenesis of autism, in particular, through their epigenetic modifications. Furthermore, these findings suggest the possibility that some of autistic children and suspects may be improved by nutritional approach supplementing deficient nutrients such as zinc, on the basis of evidence data, although zinc supplementation should be applied for infantile patients rather than elder group over 10-year-old. This evidence-based nutritional approach may yield a novel pathway into prevention and treatment of the children with autism spectrum disorders in near future. Controlled studies for this nutritional approach are desirable to establish the principal roles of infantile zinc deficiency and toxic metal burdens in the neural development disorders and pathogenesis of autism.
Sampling and zinc analysis
On the basis of informed consent, scalp hair samples from 1,967 (male: 1,553; female: 414) subjects aged 0–15 years were collected in the period from June 2005 to September 2007, although 0 year-old subject was only one (11 month-old female). These subjects were comprised of the children diagnosed with autistic spectrum disorders by their physicians. Hair sampling was recommended to cut as close to the scalp of the occipital area as possible.
Hair sample of 75 mg was weighed into 50ml plastic tube, and washed with acetone and then with 0.01% Triton solution, in accordance with the procedures recommended by the Hair Analysis Standardization Board. The washed hair sample was mixed with 10 ml 6.25% tetra methyl ammonium hydroxide (TMAH, Tama Chemical, Kawasaki, Japan) and 50 micro-L 0.1% gold solution (SPEX Certi Prep, Metuchen, NJ, USA), and then dissolved at 75 °C with shaking for 2 hours. After cooling the solution to room temperature, internal standard solution was added, and after adjusting its volume gravimetric, the obtained solution was used for zinc analysis. The zinc concentrations were determined with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS; 7500ce, Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) by the internal standard method and expressed as ng/g hair (ppb) or micro-g/g (ppm)17,18. The method detection limit for zinc determination was 12 ng/g hair (ppb), and human hair certified reference material (NIES CRM No. 13) was used to check for the accuracy of analysis. The inter-daily variation of zinc determination was calculated 2.2 %. The control zinc reference range of 86.3–193 ppm, its geometric mean ± 2 S.D. level, obtained from the data for healthy 436 male subjects aged 21–40 year-old was close to that for healthy female adults, as previously reported17,18,50, furthermore almost consisting with those reported by the other research groups10,11,12. This control zinc reference range was also almost consistent with those for nutritionally controlled children13 and for the Vancouver preschoolers aged 2–5 year-old (N = 719)28, but somewhat different from the age-matched reference data for neurotypical control children in which the 11 % participants had been medicated as reviewed by Adams30.
This study has been approved by review of the ethical committee of La Belle Vie research laboratory. All of the data obtained are held securely in such a form as to ensure anonymity.
Because scalp hair mineral concentration is log-normally distributed, the zinc concentration was converted to logarithm, and the geometric rather than arithmetic mean was used as representative of its hair concentration. The relation between age and zinc concentrations of the subjects was examined by Pearson’s correlation coefficient test.
The authors thank the subjects and their parents for collaboration to this study.
About this article
Analysis of Hair Trace Elements in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders and Communication Disorders
Biological Trace Element Research (2017)